Skip to content
The Burger Chef Murders (re-release) episode artwork

Sep 26, 2025 1 hr 6 min

The Burger Chef Murders (re-release)

from True Crime Brewery Hosted by Jill

Please enjoy this re-release of a premium show from 2022! For more of these episodes and to get rid of ads, you can subscribe at tiegrabber.com/subscribe Late on the night of November 17, 1978, Speedway, Indiana teenager Brian Kring stopped by his workplace, the Burger Chef fast food restaurant, to visit with his friends and […] The post The Burger Chef Murders (re-release) appeared first on Tiegrabber.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Burger Chef Murders (re-release)

0:00 1:06:02
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

True Crime Brewery contains disturbing content related to real-life crimes. Medical information is opinion based on facts of a crime and should not be interpreted as medical advice or treatment. Listener discretion is advised. I just feel like, you know, here's this particular area. If it could happen to him, it could happen to anyone. And that makes people uneasy. Four young people murdered after they were kidnapped from work at the Burger Chef restaurant in Speedway.

The Speedway Police Department and Indiana State Police announced that the bodies of Jane Seyfried, age 20, Mark S. Flemons, age 17, Dango R. Davis, age 16, Ruthie Shelton, age 17, have been discovered late this afternoon in Johnson County, Indiana. It's been 35 years, but Teresa Jeffries can't forget losing her older sister and the chill in the air. When fall hits, when the weather starts getting cold again, the day after she was buried was Thanksgiving. I have two children alive and one in heaven.

Together, sister and mother share family memories. The dress Ruth wore in the family photo. The last dress that my grandmother had made for her. And a high school ring are keepsakes they'll cherish. She was my only sister. I idolized her.

I wanted to be just as happy and go lucky as she was. Jeffrey says she still has nightmares thinking about how her sister and the three other Burger Chef employees were brutally murdered. I honestly believe that it will never be solved. The scene was never really processed as a crime scene. But it was a crime scene. Assistant manager Jane Freight's car was found abandoned in the morning a few miles away near the police station. Then, two days later, a couple found the four young people murdered. Their bodies 20 miles away, scattered in a wooded area off State Road 37 in Johnson County. They were killed three different ways, shot, stabbed, and possibly beaten with a chain.

A wreath on the Burger Chef door marked the restaurant closed until all four were laid to rest. Welcome to True Crime Brewery, tie grabbers. I'm Jill. And I'm Dick. On Friday, November 17th, back in 1978, Speedway Indiana teenager Brian Kring stepped by his workplace, the Burger Chef fast food restaurant, to visit with his friends and offer them help closing up for the night. But when he arrived, he found the restaurant empty. The four employees working that night, 20-year-old Jane Fright, 16-year-old Daniel Davis, 16-year-old Mark Flemons, and 17-year-old Ruth Shelton were all gone, but the door was unlocked and all the lights were still on.

Unable to reach the assistant manager, Jane, by phone, Ryan finally called the police. But when the police arrived, they were surprisingly cavalier. In their opinion, a group of irresponsible teens had taken the cash from the till and gone off for a night of fun. Join us at the quiet end for our discussion of the 1978 Burger Chef murders. The next day, the police would realize that they had made a big mistake. None of the employees arrived home, and their parents became frantic. But the police had not bothered to treat the abandoned restaurant as a crime scene.

That Sunday, four dead bodies were discovered in a clearing in the woods about 20 miles south of the scene. The young Burger Chef employees had been stabbed, shot, and bludgeoned to death. Now it's 43 years later, and no one has ever been arrested for these murders. So let's talk about it, see if we can figure anything out. Well, we can certainly try. And I think people have...

Kind of thought they had it figured out, but the usual suspects are all dead. Right. So it's going to be difficult. Well, it's close to impossible that anything will happen at this point. Yeah. Somebody said the only way they probably would solve it now would be to get a deathbed confession. Right. Yes. But some of the people they suspected are already dead. Most all of them are dead. But we can certainly talk about it and give our opinions, which we are apt to do. We've got plenty of opinions, right? Yes. Okay. For a beer, Indiana beer, right? I decided to go with Alpha King from Three Floyds Brewing Company in Munster, Indiana.

This is an American Pale Ale. It's 6.66% alcohol by volume. This beer is a copper color, nice white head, plenty of lacing, aroma of pine and citrus, and the taste is grapefruit and pine. Very simple. It's a medium-bodied, fairly hoppy beer. Sounds really good. Let's open it up. You'll like this one.

All right, down here at the quiet end, thankfully, we do have a fireplace, which we need. It's very chilly. It's a cool day. It really is. I'll be happy when spring comes. You got a ways to go. Yes. Although it comes sooner down here than it does up in Maine. Okay, why don't you get us started? Okay. So the town of Speedway, Indiana, is the home of the famous Indianapolis 500 car race. It was built in the 1920s to support the automotive industry. It is located just west of downtown Indianapolis, and in 1978, the population was just over 11,000 people. Speedway was seen as a fairly safe place to live until 1978.

and that's when several violent crimes occurred. In July, a 65-year-old woman was shot to death in her own garage, a shocking and random killing. Then in September, there was a series of bombings, seven or eight of them, and one of them severely injured a Vietnam veteran and his wife. Then in November, with these crimes still as yet unsolved, the Burger Chef murders occurred. Yeah, so if you were a teenager in the 1960s or 1970s and you lived in a small town, you might have worked in a Burger Chef. Yeah, that was Burger Chef's model. Open stores in small towns, not big ones. And they were largely a Midwest restaurant chain. So it was founded in 1957 and grew quite rapidly. In 1972, their 1,200 locations were surpassed only by McDonald's 1,600 locations. And the next several years saw a decline in business. In 1982, the owners divested themselves of the chain, gradually selling to the owners of Hardee's. So the last Burger Chef restaurant closed down in 1996.

Yeah, this one, the Speedway one, I think was briefly a Hardee's, and then they sold it to, I think it's an automotive parts store or something right now. But the building still does exist. Okay. So it was 11 p.m. on November 17, 1978, and the Burger Chef on Crawfordsville Road in Speedway, Indiana, had just closed for the night. The four young employees were cleaning up in preparation for the next day, a Saturday. Daniel Davis had changed out of his uniform shirt, and he was in the process of backing up the garbage. Jane Fright, the assistant manager, took cash from the drawers and placed the money in a safe in the manager's office.

Now, Jane was one of those real go-getter types who did well in school while she held down this job. She also was participating in a lot of extracurricular activities, and she worked as a teacher's aide and a library assistant. So she just had a great work ethic and was promoted to an assistant manager position after working at the burger shaft for just three months. She worked upwards of 50 hours a week. And when she was in the store, she was basically in charge of everything. Jane wasn't aware that she was going to be promoted to store manager, but that was the plan. And that would have been quite an accomplishment because she was only 20 years old. I got a chuckle. I mean, her manager was praising her and talking about what a great worker she was and how they were all part-time workers. And I'm saying that she worked upwards of 50 hours a week, which seems to me more like full-time than part-time.

Well, sure. But they don't want to qualify her as a full-time. Well, no. We don't want to be getting into any benefits or anything. Of course not. Sure. But yeah, those are a lot of hours to work when you're doing all that other stuff. Yeah. I mean, I think she's finished high school and is in college at this point. Right. She's 20. But still, it's a lot of stuff. And then the other thing that struck me was that even though she'd only been working there a short time, she's in line for a managerial position. She must have been quite something. Sounds like it. Yes.

Ruth Ellen Shelton, 17, was another one of those driven students who was already planning her career in computer science. She had turned in her resignation, feeling overworked and underpaid, but at the request of the store manager, she had agreed to work through the holidays. So that had to kind of weigh on her family's hearts after everything that happened. Oh, I'm sure. In the back of the store, short order cook Mark Flemons, a 16-year-old, was cleaning up the grill. And he was supposed to be off for the night. But he had agreed to fill in for a friend who needed the night off. Yeah, and then he wanted to renege on that agreement because he got an offer for something going on that Friday night. But the manager said, you know, I'm sorry. You agreed to work for the grill. You got to work. So that's how he ended up being there. Well, yeah, that's generally how it works. Right. But anyway, the store manager, Robert Gilead.

considered them an exceptional crew who worked really hard, and they never gave him any trouble. So these were good kids. These were very good kids, according to Gilead. Just after midnight that Friday night, Brian Kring drove by the Burger Chef. He was also employed there, as you said earlier, Jill. And when he saw some lights on, he decided, I'm going to stop and visit with the people working. So he walked around the back of the building to knock on the door and found the door partially opened, which should not have been. And this is a door to be locked at all times. Of course, yeah. So he walked in. He called out a greeting. No response, no answer. And as he went towards the front of the store, Brian saw that the cash drawers were lying empty on the floor. And then when he went into the manager's office, it looked like it had been tossed. So Brian's thinking, wow, this place got robbed.

And then his second thought is, well, where's the rest of the people? Well, yeah, because even in a robbery, generally, the staff are left behind whether they're hurt or not. Right. So Brian called 911, and when the police arrived, they found two empty currency bags and a roll of adhesive tape next to an open safe. So when the store manager showed up, he said there was about $600 missing. The police initially hypothesized that the robbery could have been an inside job. Gilly, the store manager, said there was no way that the crew could have committed the robbery. There had to be another explanation.

Since the rear door was to be locked at all times, there was a good possibility that the robbers had gained entrance while the trash was being taken out. Yeah, and I think that's a pretty valid supposition, the way things turned out. Right. So for a small town, and the population back then was what, around 11,000, I think you said? Yeah, 11 or 12, I've heard. But Speedway had seen its share of recent mishaps.

On July 29, 1978, Julia Cyphers was shot to death in the garage at her home. And they're investigating her death, and the police came to feel that her murder had been a professional job. And it turned out there was a local businessman who employed Cyphers' daughter. And the feeling was that he'd become a little too friendly with the daughter of Cyphers' daughter. So Cyphers' granddaughter worked there. Or it didn't work there. Cyphers' granddaughter attracted the attention of this guy. So Cyphers moved this granddaughter into her home just to get her out of the line of fire of this guy, and was thinking about filing charges against the businessman. And the police is...

Theory was that this guy had hired a hitman to take out ciphers. So Julia was in her 60s. Her granddaughter was how old? She was late teens, early 20s. And this guy was a middle-aged man? Yeah. Oh, so creepy. A creepy middle-aged man. Before arrests could be made, there were three explosions on September 1st, followed by five more explosions over the next few days. Police felt that the same individual or individuals was responsible, and they quickly focused on one man who had purchased the detonators. It turned out to be the same man suspected of being involved in ciphers killing.

But it would take another three years before the businessman and his associate would be charged in the bombings and murder. Yeah. So obviously, in this small town, you'd like to try to connect all the cases and say that they're all related to each other. But in this situation, it looks like the killing of ciphers and the bombs that went off in dumpsters and so on, those were connected, but they were not connected to the Burger Chef robbery and killings. Right. But when the Burger Chef incident happened, those weren't solved yet. So we didn't know. No, they didn't. And it took a few more years. But eventually, they apparently got it right.

And the guy and his associate were charged and found guilty. So understandably, given these recent crimes, the police wanted to solve the disappearance of the four young people as quickly as possible. So the first thing to do was to notify the parents. But none of the parents had any pertinent information for the police, so they couldn't help. But of course, they were very worried. Yeah, I mean, the police are showing up at their homes in the middle of the night and telling them that it looks like there's been a robbery at the Burger Chef and your child is missing. Right. That's not a great way to start things. But the police didn't seem to take it seriously enough.

No, they didn't. I mean, their initial thought was that the teens had just decided to rob the store and go party. But even if you're thinking that, you don't disregard all the proper police work, which they apparently did. Yeah. They didn't fingerprint nothing. They actually allowed the next shift to come in and clean the place. So that's not very good. But then they finally did mount a large-scale manhunt, and Jane's car, a white 1974 Chevy Vega, was found around 4.30 a.m. But there were no substantial clues found in her vehicle. Police at this point were working on the idea that the suspects gained entry into the burger chef.

as someone was taking out the trash. Then after taking the money, they forced the kids into Jane's car and they drove off with them with the car they had come in following behind. So Jane's car was then abandoned. So did the suspects then drive off with the four young people in their car? Apparently they did. Well, it's a real mystery at this point. I'm trying to figure out what the heck's going on, how it could have happened. Well, yeah, if you're going in to rob a fast food joint, usually you get the money and you leave. Yeah, you're not going to take hostages or prisoners, right? Not normally, no. And even if you were going to hurt the crew, why would you take them away to do that? Right. So you have to think maybe when they left with the kids, they weren't planning on necessarily killing them all. Maybe they weren't sure. Yeah, I've had a difficult time trying to figure out why they took them with them. Well, not only you, everyone has. One of the thoughts was that a worker recognized one of the robbers.

But they still could have killed them there. Why would they take them with them? That's what I figured. I was looking at that and said, well, sure, if that's the case, why complicate things even further by taking them out? If you're planning, after finding out that you've been recognized, you say, well, we need to get rid of these kids, kill them in the store and take off. Yeah, but is it even worth killing someone because you're recognized doing a robbery? I don't know what the punishment is for robbing a store at gunpoint, but it can't be as bad as murdering four people. I wouldn't think it'd be anywhere near what it would cost to be convicted of murder. Right, exactly.

So that's very odd, too. That's an oddity, yes. I mean, there has been discussion that there was some kind of drug involvement, like maybe one of the kids owed money for some drugs they bought, but they didn't seem like the kind of kids who even did drugs. No, they weren't, although we'll find out some differences later. Yeah. So daylight arrived Saturday morning, and the next shift came into the restaurant, the burger chef, to start working. These kids were told that a robbery had taken place the night before. Okay. But then, for whatever reason, they were allowed to clean the place up and open for business. Now, at this point, nobody had gotten any evidence, no photographs.

No fingerprints, no dusting, nothing. They showed up. And like you said, the supposition was that it was an inside job and the kids were having a good time on Burger Chef's money. But they did nothing to start the investigation. And one of the people involved said, quote, we screwed it up from the beginning, end of quote. Yes. Well, certainly I see it that way. But even if they thought the kids took the money and left, you think they would do an investigation? Because it is a crime either way. Yeah. I mean, there's so many things that left me scratching my head in this. But that's another one. Even if that's what you think, you still investigate it, right? Exactly. Yeah.

Well, didn't. Especially since the kids hadn't been located, you might want to just shut the place off until you find them and at least speak to them. Yeah, you would. But they didn't, so it was just very poorly handled, to say the least. About an hour before Brian Kring had stopped by the burger chef and found the rear door ajar, another couple had walked past the restaurant. A 16-year-old boy was walking his girlfriend home, and they sat behind the restaurant to talk, or maybe they were kissing, who knows. I think the way this was written up, yeah, they decided, let's just stop here and make out for a little bit. Okay. But then they were approached by two men.

These were white guys who were poorly dressed. So I guess kind of homeless-y looking? I'm not sure what that meant exactly. I don't think it was quite to the level of homeless dress, but not well dressed. And one of them had a scruffy old beard. The other one was clean shaven.

So they were a little bit scary for these young kids at night, I would imagine. You know, it's what, 10 o'clock at night or so? And you're sitting there trying to get to first base on your date, and these guys come walking up. I'd be a little nervous. Yeah. So one of these men told the kids that it wasn't safe for them to be there, and they left. But you have to think, what did he mean by that? Wasn't safe for them to be there because they were planning to do a robbery? But then if they were planning to do a robbery, would they really approach and speak to someone? It's a little puzzling. Just more things that...

You're supposed to interpret here. I suppose. And then the next day, that 16-year-old boy did call the police. Both he and his girlfriend were questioned, but they really didn't provide anything else that was useful. Just that they'd seen those two guys, and one of them told him it wasn't safe to be there. Right. And they ended up being the sources of the composite sketches. Yes. And then they eventually made busts as well, I believe. Yeah. That was after some time investigating the case where things hadn't happened yet. Nothing was showing up that was important. So, of course, the search for the four missing employees continued.

and there was no success on Saturday. Then on Sunday afternoon, Fred Heger and his wife Rosemary were out for a walk on their heavily wooded property when they came across four dead bodies. Now, from the uniforms they were wearing, the couple saw that they were likely those Burger Chef employees. So, of course, they called for help, and the area was soon run over with police. But, you know, not a lot of evidence was found, although they did find out that these kids were brutally murdered. They were. I mean, two of them had been shot. One had been stabbed in the heart, and one had been beaten. I mean, his face and head were a mess.

And that's the one, you know, some people thought he'd run into a tree trying to escape. Some people have said that he was beaten with a chain, but he was beaten. So it looked like there were three different methods of killing these kids. Gunshot, stabbing, and bludgeoning. Well, I guess we're pretty sure it was more than one person. Had to be at least two people doing this, I would imagine. At least two. Yeah.

So complicating the investigation, though, were the inevitable turf battles over the jurisdiction, because the Speedway police were taking the lead at the restaurant. But the bodies had been discovered in Johnson County, so technically the sheriff's department had jurisdiction there. Yeah, except for one little problem, sort of. When Fred Hager called his discovery in, he ended up calling the Indiana State Police before he called the sheriff's department. And the state police were, let's just say they were reluctant to share the investigation. So you've got...

At least three departments investigating the robbery and murders of the kids. And maybe not communicating as well as they should have with each other. No. I mean, the excellent book I read didn't go into it too much except to kind of indicate that there was a lot of jealousy between the departments and everyone wanted their department to be the one that solved the case. Well, that's extremely unprofessional and immature. Well, it happens. And as it turns out, this crime scene also became compromised. They didn't handle that very well either. No. See, so it wasn't just the local police. It's the state police that fucked up also. Yeah.

cars drove over areas that should have been cordoned off and one of the bodies had been moved before the medical examiner even arrived the medical examiner found that ruth allen and daniel had been shot numerous times in the head neck and shoulders the assistant manager jane had been stabbed twice in her heart and it was done so vigorously that the blade actually broke off inside of her body Mark had died after being bludgeoned, so struck repeatedly in the head to the point where he was very disfigured and covered in blood. So, of course, investigators believed at that point that more than one person was involved. I mean, for one thing, how would you get the four people to go with you if you were one person? Right. And how are you going to follow Jane's car with another car? That's another big one. Sure. You're not going to trust one of the employees to drive one of the cars. That's for sure. So it's at least two. Well, I guess you could if you rode in the car with your gun on someone. Maybe you could get someone else.

to lead the way or follow you just based on the safety of the other person. Yeah. But it doesn't seem likely. It seems like there were at least two people, like we said. Oh, no, there has to be at least two. Yeah, there's definitely a consensus on that. But the motive for the crime was kind of confounding for investigators. They thought it unlikely that they had been killed for less than $600. No kidding, right? But people have been killed for less, though, really. Oh, they certainly have, but still. Let's suppose you're a professional robbing group and you go around robbing these fast food places. You're not going to kill them. No, not if that's all you're doing. Right. So there's probably more behind it. Exactly. Right.

Several investigators were thinking that the kids were killed because they recognized the robbers. That was a big theory. You know, Mark was not supposed to be working that night. So maybe he recognized one of the robbers and they didn't expect him to be there. Yeah. When I was looking into this, that sounded reasonable. If you're kind of casing the place out and deciding when it would be the best time to rob it and how to do it, you would see that there was the same crew that worked nights. And now all of a sudden you go in to rob the place and there's a new guy there who you wouldn't recognize, didn't recognize.

And he knows who you are and he's going to finger you. So, yeah. Well, yeah, that's for sure. But still, that doesn't explain why they took them away. Why wouldn't they have just shot them right there? I can't figure that out at all. No. So the media and the public were becoming pretty disgruntled over the perceived lack of transparency that the police were giving them. Well, they weren't giving them anything. That was the main problem. They had nothing to write up or to think about.

So the police decided, well, let's see if we can show the public and the media that we are working on this and really trying to solve it. So they released the composite drawings of the two men that had interacted with the teenagers that night, the ones who said, you know, it's dangerous to be out here at night. Yeah, so tell me a little bit about these guys. Were they... Were they young? Were they older? They were on the younger side. But not high school or college aged? No, they were in their 30s, maybe 40s. Oh, well, that's quite a bit older. And the police were careful to call them people of interest and not suspects. I didn't know they were doing that back in the 70s. I thought that was more of a new thing. That's what they did, huh? That's what I read about. Okay. So two men, 30s or 40s. That's pretty vague. Yeah. What else have we got? Well, we've got some .38 caliber slugs that had killed Ruth and Daniel, but they didn't have a gun that matched the bullets. So we've got spent shell casings and no gun. So just one gun was involved.

They're not sure. Well, there was only one type of slug. Yeah, but you can do different slugs and different guns. Well, sure. So they were thinking it might have been more than one .38, you're saying? They found some slugs that were .38 caliber, and they hadn't found any weapons that could have been used.

Right. I'm just wondering if they had more than one gun, why would they have bludgeoned and stabbed people? That's my only thought. Right. Is there was probably only one gun or everyone would have been shot. Yeah, I like that. Although one of the numerous theories was that when they got to where they killed the kids and they were in the process of shooting two of them, the other two tried to run away and they tackled Jane and stabbed her and the other kid ran into a tree and knocked himself out. That was one of the theories. That's a pretty wild theory. I don't know about that. Was there a tree with blood on it? Is there a reason why they thought that? Nope. That's a little bit weird of a thing to come up with in my mind. Yeah.

Yeah, apparently he had died by aspirating his blood. So they're trying to think of ways that you could do that. But I don't know. We've got different methods of execution. We've got the composites of the two guys. We've got slugs. Oh, and Burger Chef also decided that they would offer a $25,000 reward for any information leading to a conviction. And this wasn't very helpful because it got all sorts of people coming out of the woodwork. Yeah, did they set up one of those numbers to call with tips? Yeah, they had so many that they were trying to get people to write in their tips and put a code name at the bottom of the write-up.

What do you mean? I don't understand that. You write up your information for the police to investigate and put it on the bottom, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. That's your ID number. And you keep a copy of that number so that if the tip turns out to be relevant, we can call up the person who submitted that number and give the reward to that person. OK. I've never heard of a system like that. Me either. OK. So once the bodies were buried, people of Speedway tried to resume their daily lives. But it was difficult. And Speedway was and is a small town. So there's always reminders going on about what happened with these kids.

And then the parents of the victims were overrun with mail and phone calls, most of them crank calls. The manager, the burger chef, had made some changes to the store so everyone's more safe. They were closed for a short time, but eventually they did reopen with these changes. Hopefully we're going to prevent or at least make it tougher for this type of thing to happen again. So we're going along and we've got hours going into days, days going into weeks, weeks going into months. No progress. Trying to get something going, the authorities had commissioned busts to be made of the people of interest from the drawings. And that's kind of an unusual thing to do. I'm a little surprised by that. Me too. Because these weren't even really very good suspects. No. These were... These were just two guys. Just basically two random guys. And that was probably, what, a good hour before the actual robbery? I know we're not sure of the exact time, but... Yeah. Maybe they didn't kill them at the restaurant because of the noise it would have made. That's possible. Yeah.

but they uh they didn't get anywhere see that far so looking at a few of the results from the Drawings and bus. They had two men who had been arrested in Chicago for aggravated battery. And there were several people who thought that these two guys resembled the men in the description from the teens. But they turned out to have solid alibis and were eliminated as suspects. And just another couple things, one or two things. Investigators also traveled to Cincinnati so that they could interview a prisoner there who resembled the bearded guy in the composite sketch. Now, this guy had lived near the burger chef at the time and had people saying that he dyed his hair and beard right after the murders. Suspicious stuff.

So this man passed a polygraph, and he also had an alibi for the night of the murders. But he did tell police that there were two other men who were responsible. And he said the plan was simply to rob the restaurant, but the perpetrators decided to murder the four kids when one of them recognized one of the robbers. See, that's still a stretch to me. I don't know if I really believe that. No. That seems like a big jump in behavior. Doesn't it? And the police didn't look at it that way anyway. They thought he wasn't involved. And he was really just trying to find a way to reduce his sentence. Okay. So, because he didn't tell them anything that wasn't already known.

Well, yeah, he didn't have any information that only a participant would know. Obviously, that's what you'd like to get. Yes. If you're withholding information from the public and the media, you're hoping that someone comes forward with information that could only be gained from firsthand knowledge. So a letter was sent to the Indianapolis Star on November 29th.

And the writer alleged that what started out as a basic robbery, whatever a basic robbery is, somehow went wrong. The writer said there were three people involved, but the three had split up and were no longer in Indiana at all. Police thought this information was credible. So what they did is they just begged the individual to come forward. But why would the person come forward? Well, he didn't. But anyway. So this was an anonymous letter. Right. And they weren't able to trace it. Sometimes that's fairly easy to do. Well, they weren't.

And before this person came forward, another person came by the newspaper office who wanted to talk. And he was interviewed by police and gave them the names of two people who he said were involved. But the police were not real sure that this was credible information. Well, did they look into it? They did. And nothing was connected? Nothing was connected. But then another letter arrived. This was from the first letter, the one that they were trying to get the guy to come forward. So the way it turned out was they got this letter. They wanted this person to come forward and give more information. The first letter? The first letter. Okay.

He finally sent this second letter and he said he wasn't going to be able to help him anymore. So how did they know the letter was from the same person? He said he was the same person. I don't know. Well, there was no new information, you're saying, basically. That's what it boils down to. No. But the author of that letter said he couldn't help either. And while police were happy to get some leads, they were really disheartened because there was no progress and none of the leads were panning out. Yeah, nothing was working. I felt incredibly frustrated at this point because they're not getting anything that's going to help with the investigation. So we've gone another few weeks. There's still no progress. And the police are starting to scale back the investigation a bit.

Yeah, but they remained committed to solving the crime, they said. And at this point, they must have been, you know, really trying just about anything they could think of. Yeah, I think they're starting to grasp at straws, right? Well, I don't know about straws, but they're definitely grasping for things. They definitely are grasping. And they consulted with a psychoanalyst to get an opinion. And this specialist concluded that the murderers were likely unproductive men between the ages of 16 and 25, and that at least one of them could be considered a psychopath. No, I'm sorry, but I don't find that at all helpful. Anybody could say that. That's based on what? Exactly. It's based on, I think it's based on them trying, the authorities trying to do something that showed they were working the case.

Right. I suppose. But why that? That doesn't seem helpful. It isn't. I mean, if you want to get a psychological profile of these people, for one thing, I think it's pretty impossible because these are people that just walked in and robbed a restaurant. It's not like a serial killer where you're getting patterns, you're getting evidence. They really have nothing to go on other that someone came and robbed it and that these young people were killed in another area. They don't even really know for sure how they got there or if they were all alive when they went. I know. And even 40 some years later, that's where you're still at. Yeah. So there was some discussion that the Burger Chef murders were related to the killing of that woman in her garage, the grandmother.

and those seemingly random bombings. But then that was ruled out by the authorities. And police also questioned two other people who looked like the composite drawings and did know the area, but they never got enough evidence to charge them either. So it's very frustrating. Yeah, well, it boiled over. By the end of 1979, still with no charges or any real credible leads against any individuals for the murders, the Board of Police Commissioners voted to fire the Speedway Chief of Police, that's Robert Copeland, for lack of leadership. Okay, so now is that something that really was his fault? Because you told me earlier that the state police were also involved. Yeah, but he's going to bear the brunt of it because he's not solving it. Okay, and that's when they created the task force. Right, so this is like a year later. Yeah, the end of 79. Yeah.

So they put together a seven-man task force and their job was to look into the Burger Chef murders. And within a fairly short amount of time, they were reinvestigating a suspect. Besides this person, the task force was looking at two men who like to rob fast food restaurants and who used similar methods to the Burger Chef robbery slash murders. But none of these people could be the real perpetrators. So they either had alibis or they were ruled out for other reasons. Correct. In October of 1980, the task force said they had another suspect who looked really solid. They also announced they were looking into the murders, being a result of some kind of drug debt. So that's something that had been considered for a while. Yeah, it was one of the ideas, but it took more credence.

When they got some more information. Right. So apparently Mark Flemons was worried he might be beaten or even killed because he had a $7,000 drug debt. Now that's huge. That's huge. And this is a, what, 16, 17-year-old high school kid. So is that real? So. Is that proven to be a real thing? I don't. I'm just not sure how credible that is. It's hard to believe. It really is. Who's going to float that much money as a loan to a 16-year-old? Well, I wouldn't think it would be all in one shot, but who would let him build up that kind of a debt? Right. And why would he? Yeah. There was no history of him being a real druggie or anything. Now at autopsy, Jane Fright did have marijuana in her system.

Yeah, so that's what really gave this whole idea of drugs being involved some traction. So they had a person of interest with a history of selling narcotics. And this person was also familiar with the area. But the only problem was the police were unable to arrest this guy because he kept disappearing. Yeah, so that's suspicious right there. And I'd be thinking, maybe we got somebody because we can't find this guy. Well, yeah, but if he's a drug dealer, would he really want to hang around anyway? Well, no, you're right. He wouldn't. But he was eventually tracked down and eventually cleared of any involvement in the crime. Still, though, investigators did believe that drugs were probably involved based on...

What? We don't really know. Well, based on the supposition that the one kid was worried that he was going to be beaten up or killed for his drug debt and that Jane had some traces of marijuana. I would think half the kids that you would test in 1978 would have traces of marijuana. They probably could be. So they also got a little more interested in this with Jane's brother, James Fried, because he was arrested for dealing cocaine. Well, now that I could take a little more seriously. Right. And he also, at least sort of, resembled the bearded man in the composite picture.

Okay. Now they investigated, apparently thoroughly, and James was cleared of any involvement. But he was a cocaine dealer. He was. And then just another interesting fact, Mark Fleming's brother was arrested in 1981 and charged with robbery and murder. So tell me a little bit about that. Was that anything similar? No. What did he do? No, that was just, you know, by the way, we got a family member who's a criminal. Yeah, but what did he rob and who did he kill and when did that happen? It has nothing at all to do with the Burger Chef robbery and killings. It's just guilt by association.

Well, the next two or three years passed without any new developments in the case. Big surprise. Then in December of 1984, reporter Dan Luzziter of the Indianapolis Star met with an inmate at the Marion County Jail because this inmate was looking at some serious time for burglary and had some information he thought might be helpful. This inmate said he knew who had been involved in the Burger Chef murders, and he named two men who he said were responsible for the crime. One of these men...

The police had already eliminated as a suspect. But the other one was a man who investigators knew nothing about. Nothing at all. So that could be a good leap. Yeah. You would think, aha, we got some fresh stuff going here. So maybe. So the guy that the investigators had no information about was a guy named Donald Ray Forrester. And this is a guy who's a career criminal in and out of prison since he was an 18-year-old. Now, Forrester said the motive for the robbery was drugs and homosexuality. So they investigated, and they found that certain parts of Forrester's story did hold up.

And then all of a sudden Forrester said, oh, I changed my mind. I don't want to talk to you guys anymore. So they went back and forth and he did eventually agree to cooperate and he needed to get something in return. And we'll find out what that was. And he named someone he said was involved in the murders. So on August 7th, 1985, detectives picked up Forrester at the jail and the plan was to take him to Speedway in the hopes that he would remember some details of the crime. But this turned out to be a waste of time. The police were starting to think they were just on a wild goose chase. He didn't have any information. And the new direction with Forrester was just another lead that went nowhere.

It's certainly going nowhere. But Forrester is persistent. So we've got two new informants showing up in 1986. What are we, eight years into it now, right? And some of what they said agreed with Forrester's story, and other things contradicted his story. So they're looking at it, and the investigators are getting more convinced that Forrester somehow is involved in the murders. They just have to get him to admit it.

So he meets with the investigators in November of 1986 and Forrester says, okay, I'm ready to come clean. And he actually gave information about the murders that could only be known by one of the participants. So this is like the positioning of the bodies, how they were arranged at the murder scene. And he knew about the various wounds that each one had suffered. And that wasn't common knowledge. Forrester told the investigators that the gun that had been used in the crime had been thrown into the White River.

And then he confessed. He said, it's me. I shot Ruth Ellen Shelton and Daniel Davis. They looked in the river and they could not find a gun. Of course, again, this is eight years after the fact. And who knows with river currents and silt and stuff being deposited. But he's basically saying I was involved in the crime and I killed two people. OK, but he's not saying who was with him that killed the other two people, which I would see as a big hole in his story that makes it much less credible to me. Well, and that's how they ended up. And it turns out to be nothing. But he had him going for a while. So positioning of the bodies. I wonder how specific he got on that because.

I don't know. Plus, there's always the idea that when he was talking to the police, they may have kind of led him along. Oh, sure. Either on purpose or accidentally. Because it was only one week later when Forrester recanted his confession and said he'd been coerced. So that has to make you wonder. Yeah. Well, what we'll find out, and this took the author of the book a while to come up with it, was that Forrester had some serious mental health issues. Right. Yeah. So basically everything he told him was probably bullshit. Well, he maintained that he had spoken with the killers and had helped them. But now he was saying he didn't participate. Yeah. Right. So we've gone in a week from saying I was in on it and I killed two people.

No, nothing there. Well, plus, if he's not able to name his accomplice, I don't give him a lot of credence. Yeah. But he still told them enough stuff that they thought he had to be involved in some way. I suppose I could see that, or at least had heard about it from someone. Yeah. But a review of an old case would lead investigators to the link that they were looking for. Well, a link they were looking for in terms of eliminating him as a suspect. Right, right. Because it turns out that in 1969, Forrester was out with a friend and a friend's girlfriend, and they stopped and picked up a 14-year-old girl who knew the couple but didn't know Forrester.

And after they dropped off the couple, Forrester raped the girl. He was a little lucky he was able to plead guilty to assault and battery. But what he was hoping was that what he talked to the authorities about with the Burger Chef murders was going to be enough information to be useful to the authorities and they would get rid of his record for rape. But no one had ever told them that they would. No, plus the other stretch is that nothing he's given the authorities was information that was useful. Exactly. So, so much for him. So despite that lack of evidence implicating people Forrester had named, investigators were convinced that he was involved in some way.

Despite all that. Yeah, that's exactly what I said. Despite all this, all the stuff they've been through with him, time and time again, they get their hopes up and then they get their hopes dashed. They're still thinking, well, he's got to know something about it. Now, despite the fact that people that Forrester had named his perpetrators, nothing had come of that.

Somehow the investigators were still convinced that he was involved. So they asked prosecutor Stephen Goldsmith to bring charges against Forrester, which he was reluctant to do. His way of thinking is it's going to be very difficult to find Forrester guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Well, no kidding. No kidding, because there's nothing here. This was also a problem for Forrester, because if he wasn't charged, he's going to get sent back to the prison where he was, and he didn't want to be there. He was afraid for his life. And the other thing was that if he wasn't charged, he's going to lose all chances to revisit his prior conviction for rape or assault and battery, whatever you want to call it.

If he wasn't charged, he was? Yeah. Why? If he wasn't charged, they're just not going to think about looking into that. I don't know that they made a deal, but the understanding was that if things came to fruition, that they would find a way to revisit the charges against him or his conviction. So he's not got much going for him. Yeah. So it's weird because even though he'd recanted his confession, he was hoping he'd be charged for the Burger Chef murders. Isn't that weird? It's very unusual. Yes. Ultimately, Goldsmith did bring charges against Forrester for the Burger Chef murders. Did not.

Ultimately, Goldsmith did not bring charges against Forrester for the Burger Chef murders. He didn't feel they had enough evidence to get a guilty verdict, and he was likely correct. No doubt that he was correct. This guy was all over the place. So now we get to November 17th, 1988, and the Burger Chef murders are reaching a 10th anniversary with really nothing in the way of solving it. Nope. Dan Luzader, the newspaper guy, interviewed Forrester in prison on this 10th anniversary. And over time, Forrester had continued to feed information to others. Again, nothing that came to anything of use. And Forrester's mental state...

was pretty precarious at this point. No one really knew what was believable and what was unbelievable. Forrester himself claimed he had been implanted with a device that controlled his thoughts. It's a warning sign, don't you think? Yes. And he was unable to stop this device. And over time, with all this, he was still receiving his weekly doses of Thorazine.

I think they need to up the dose. Well, 1993 marked the 15th anniversary of the case. Still nothing. Jim Cramer of the Indiana State Police gave his thoughts on the case at that point. Now, he was the only original detective still working the case. Cramer and others who worked the case feel that it started off as a robbery, but then things deteriorated when one of the crew recognized one of the robbers. The robbers then kidnapped the employees, and they drove away in Jane Fright's car. Then they transferred to another vehicle.

The robbers then drove the crew to an isolated wooded area where they killed them in three different ways. And the bodies were discovered the next day by the couple who were out walking. Now, this is pretty much things that they'd known since 1978. Nothing new there. Right. There's nothing new. And it's not all really definite either. A lot of it's theory. Right. Because Kramer himself is going to admit or has admitted there's never been a conclusive motive established. And they are not at all certain that one of the employees recognized one of the robbers. And so this is all kind of supposition. Exactly. They have no way of knowing that. Nope.

So there does seem to have been two camps among investigators, one believing that scenario, and the other camp thinking it was perpetrated by a group who had a history of robbing fast food restaurants. In fact, Kramer himself interviewed Forrester several times, and he didn't think that Forrester provided any useful information. There's no way to be certain that he did. And I kind of like the idea of a group who had a history of robbing fast food restaurants, but then why the murders? Because these robbers are just interested in hitting up restaurants and getting away. Well, they're saying that the murder is because someone was recognized.

Yeah, I just, I don't know. But there's no way of knowing that. That's really just a guess. Yeah, it is. Because they're guessing to fill in the deficiencies in the story. Which I understand. But maybe it's better to just say we really don't know. Because, you know, the problem with making up something or just deciding that it was probably something could make you go off in the wrong direction. Right. Because there's nothing to support it. Plus, it gives hope to people involved, like the parents, that maybe they're actually going to solve the case. Well, maybe that's what they were trying to do, though, is perpetuate hope. Yeah. How many times do you do that?

Before the people wise up and say, you know, you've told me 10 different people that are suspects and nobody's been charged yet. Sure. Well, and it does happen that murders are unsolvable. It happens quite a bit. I think that the reason this is more difficult is because they didn't do anything right in the investigation. If they'd done everything right and still had no actual suspects or convictions, then, you know, unfortunate but understandable. Exactly. That's a wonderful point. Thank you. I wasn't trying to curry favor with you, Jill. Although you show me favor all the time. Anyway, but no, I think that's a very...

reasonable point to make. Well, yeah, you can guess at all kinds of different things, and I think it's worth considering it. But to put that out to the public, that's not wise. No. No. So today, we're 43 years after these murders, and not very likely they're going to be solved. No, I read somewhere, I forget exactly where, that the only way that they can see it being solved now is if somebody makes a deathbed confession. Right. It just seems to be this perfect combination of unfortunate events coming together to make the case unsolvable, including maybe a well-executed robbery. We don't know.

multiple investigative errors that we do know, and maybe just some bad luck. Yeah. So it does happen. That's why the murder clearance rates are not 100% across the country. Oh, it certainly can happen. That's right. Yeah, I think the worst part is just the way it was handled, because that way you think maybe it could have been solved. Yeah. Maybe people could have been saved. Who knows what happened? That'd be the tough thing to kind of swallow, that they hadn't screwed up the investigation from the beginning. Maybe we wouldn't be at this point. Yeah, I think something as simple as some fingerprints.

Might have been helpful, but no chance at that. Nope, it would be tough. Just in case you're thinking that this is just an isolated incident, that there are no unsolved murders in Indiana, I got a couple for you that I picked out. Some we're quite familiar with. We've done podcasts on both of them. So there are unsolved murders still in Indiana. And one is Lauren Spearer. We did a podcast on that. That was a 20-year-old sophomore.

college sophomore who disappeared from her campus in the small hours of June 2nd, 2011. Remember, Lauren had been out partying and was visibly intoxicated, and a friend of hers suggested that she stay at his place, but she wanted to go home, according to him. Yeah, well, and she could hardly walk. Yes. So this friend accompanied her to about three blocks from her apartment and then left her. Now, that's what he said, and she has not been seen since. With this case, a popular theory is that she overdosed and died and that her friends got rid of her body, possibly putting it in the river, although her remains have never been found. No.

And then, of course, the most famous case recently would be the disappearance of Abby Williams and Libby German on February 13th, 2017. Very different from Lauren's case, of course. These girls' bodies were found the next day. Kind of a ritualistic, possible serial killer situation. And what really sticks out about this is that one of the girls had recorded the murderer speaking and walking on her cell phone. Yeah, it's a chilling scene. Very chilling. And there have been many leads, but we don't have anyone for that yet either. No, there's a new maybe.

Right? Well, yeah, in the last several months. Yeah. This is a guy named James Bryan Chadwell. So he's a guy, he lured a nine-year-old girl into his home in April of 2021. He beat her and sexually assaulted her, planning to murder her. Police officers somehow got notified and found the girl locked into the guy's basement. And she did survive with a lot of bruising and strangulation marks on her neck and a dog bite. Well, yeah, I think the way he lured her in was to pet his dog or his dogs. Right. He did plead guilty to attempted murder and child molestation. He got 90 years in prison.

There was an additional 20 years because of the fact that he was a habitual offender. So he's locked up and he won't be eligible for parole until 2091. So at least if he is responsible, he's not out to do it anymore. Some observers had pointed out that Chadwell has some tattoos of two girls' faces on his arms that look like they're crying blood. And one of these faces does resemble Libby German, but investigators have not publicly connected Chadwell to these murders. But I'll bet they're trying like hell to be able to do that. Well, it would wrap it up neatly if it was, but life doesn't always work that way. Yeah, it would solve the case if that's who it was.

Yeah, but I think if it was him, they'd probably know because I thought they had some DNA. Well, we're supposing that. Is that true that there is some DNA? I think there is. Then if there is, it's either his or not his. And he's either the perpetrator or not. Well, that's what I'm saying. He's probably not the perpetrator. Because I think if it was him, they would have proven it by now. And he could have confessed and maybe gotten some benefits for that. Yeah, I think you're right. Which he didn't do. So I'm kind of leaning away from it being him. Yeah. Yeah, unfortunately. So that means there's probably that madman is still out there. But it's just amazing that one because the video.

Yeah. And again, this is like Speedway. It's a small town. Everybody knows everybody. Yes. So you would think if everybody's got access to the picture of the guy on the cell phone, that somebody would recognize him. Well, that's what leads me to think it wasn't a local. Yeah. But you know, that guy looks like your average Indiana rural guy, you know, the bridge guy. Yeah. And you can't really see his face. I don't know about rural Indiana, but just a regular guy. There's nothing real distinctive. No, no, there isn't. Although I would think if you knew him, you'd know, but that's a whole different topic. Oh, yeah. But that gets into a whole new bunch of topics. That's right. Yes.

So fascinating case, just too bad that it isn't solved. And there's probably, it won't be solved. Yeah, I wish we could report something differently, but it's not going to be. No. It might not be. No, if these guys were in their 30s. Well, I think I read that every parent of the kids who were killed, every parent has succumbed to various illnesses. Really? Yeah, so there's no parents left. Yeah, they would be quite elderly. So that's just really sad. They never found out what happened. Yeah, terrible. It really is terrible. All right, Dickie. Well, kind of a heartbreaking case, but fascinating, that's for sure. Well, fascinating and frustrating.

Absolutely. Yes. Very frustrating. You always want to get to a point where you figure it out. Yeah. Yeah. So you can imagine how frustrating it is for people working in law enforcement, these cases. Oh, absolutely. It's drive you mad. Yeah. Yes, absolutely. So thanks for discussing it with me today, Dickie. I appreciate it. Well, thanks for putting up with me. And we'll be back soon with another regular episode of True Crime Brewery. So we'll see you next time at the Quietette. We'll save you some seats. Hurry up. Yep. Thanks for your support, tie grabbers. Bye, guys. Bye-bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of True Crime Brewery?

This episode is 1 hour and 6 minutes long.

When was this True Crime Brewery episode published?

This episode was published on September 26, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this True Crime Brewery episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.