Skip to content
The Cave episode artwork

Sep 25, 2024 14 min

The Cave

from The Daily Vedantic Hosted by James Beshara

In this episode of The Daily Vedantic, we dive into the profound metaphor of Socrates' Allegory of the Cave, exploring its deeper nuances that often go unnoticed. We examine how the cave represents our limited perception of reality, the transformative journey of enlightenment, and the resistance faced when challenging conventional beliefs. This reflection also connects the allegory to Vedantic teachings and ancient wisdom, revealing how Socrates' insights resonate with Eastern philosophies. Join us as we uncover the layers of meaning behind this classic allegory and its implications for understanding reality. The Daily Vedantic is a daily podcast and YouTube channel dedicated to the timeless wisdom of the Upanishads (https://thedailyvedantic.com/). Dating back to over 5,000 years ago, the source of nearly all Eastern Philosophy, and loved by Western giants from Emerson to Thoreau to Carl Jung and Alan Watts, studied daily by Joseph Campbell to Aldous Huxley to Arthur Schopenhauer and countless others, The Daily Vedantic aims to make this ancient philosophy as modern and accessible as it is simple, practical — and profound. James Beshara (https://www.twitter.com/jamesbeshara) is a renowned startup founder of multiple companies, a prolific startup investor in 200+ others including some of the biggest startup names on the planet, a husband and father of three little girls, and philosophy student and teacher in Los Angeles. James also co-hosts Yoga For Your Intellect (https://www.YFYI.co), a biweekly long-form conversational podcast with his teacher Joseph Emmett (https://www.instagram.com/yogaforyourintellect). James is a student of Swami Parthasarathy, the acclaimed author of Vedanta Treatise (Vedanta Treatise – The Eternities) and teacher at Vedanta Academy in Malavli, India. As James says often, when you’re ready for the real thing, Swami’s daily lectures are where the true wisdom and systematic discovery of the world’s oldest continually studied philosophy resides: https://www.vedantaworld.org

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Cave

0:00 14:50
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Socrates really nailed it on the head, making it explicit. And giving us a model for not just a fun story of what could be, but a description and his mind of what is. We are back with another daily reflection on that TVV, the day of a dawn. Today's reflection.

It's called the cave. And I can go in a few different directions with an episode on a cave. Caves come up quite often within the philosophy. Early philosophers who punish Ottoman means to sit close below.

A master, a teacher, a guru, a guru, a guru is Sanskrit for dis-speller of darkness. So teacher of all teachers. And the gurus, oftentimes, three, five, eight thousand years ago, they were up in the caves in the Himalayas, as they say in India, in the Himalayas. So the cave ends up being a metaphor used quite often within this philosophy.

There's also, I think I mentioned it yesterday, one of my favorite quotes from the noted Vedantan Joseph Campbell is the treasure you seek is in the cave you at least want to enter. So I can do a whole episode on that, the treasure we seek. But this episode actually is going to touch on one of the most profound and notable metaphors of a cave in the West. And that is Socrates, allegory the cave.

As recounted by Plato, so we don't know if it was so great. So we don't know how much it was old plato, just waxing and using Socrates as his mouthpiece. But nonetheless, the cave, allegory the cave is mind-blowing. And it's so sad, like so many great pieces of literature philosophical thought, religious tradition, that it's so sad that we get exposed to it when we're 10, 12, 15 have no idea way too young to comprehend the greatness of something.

And yet by the time we're 20, we've heard it a thousand times and it loses any novelty to us. But I'll try to, I'll try to polish off some of the well-worn cliche nature of this allegory the cave and bring back some of the brilliance that until I was 37 really didn't really totally forgot, totally looked over. So you've got the allegory the cave, you've got these captives chained, looking at staring at a wall and behind them is this fire with this light with shadows on the wall and these captives that are chained think that they're staring at reality. I think this is the world, these shadows.

It's two-dimensional figures that are moving and they're convinced that well, this is all they know, it's what they're conditioned to believe. It's all they've experienced. So they think well, this is the world. Obviously, this is the world.

I've known it for years. My whole life. This is the world. And what's unique and it was totally lost on me.

There's three unique aspects of the cave that were totally lost on me when I was young. Their nuance is that it's almost like the heart of allegory the cave is in these three nuances in my perspective. So as the story goes, the high level story that we all know goes you have the cave, the captives, the shadows, and someone goes out of the cave and sees reality, sees real life, sees beyond the two dimensions and sees a whole another dimension, three-dimensional life. And that alone is provocative, quite thoughtful and quite symbolic of what Socrates, who is probably a mind for all.

For all we know, we have a handful of them in the West and we do a pretty good job of mischaracterizing them or Socrates Christ case killing them, denigrating them during their existence. And yet they're the people we talk about, one, two, a couple thousand years, three thousand years later, you've got King Solomon in the Old Testament. And you have, and by the way, it's tied directly to King Solomon and Ecclesiastes late in his life, writing that vapor, vapor, all is vapor. Sometimes it's translated as vanity, vanity, all is vanity, but perhaps the more correct translation is the one where in English, he's saying vapor, vapor, all is vapor, all of this is vapor.

It's not real. It lacks the true dimensionality of reality. And that's what Socrates is saying about us being in the cave captive, chained, conditioned and so convinced that what we're seeing is reality. So that's the high level version of the cave, but the three nuances that is that were totally blossoming, that give a whole new dimensionality to the allegory.

This example of the cave are these. One, that person is set free. The one that sees the light, sees reality outside the cave, set free, unchained, not by their own doing. We don't act in order to see reality.

It's just an unchaining that happens, that we allow to happen and that we lean into, but we don't do the unchaining. That person then ascends. It's not a cave up at a mountaintop and they descend. It's an us engine and it's a trek after being unchained and voluntarily going away from the shadows and ascending.

It's another nuance that's clearly present in the allegory, but can be lost in the other more provocative visuals. And in this ascension, when the person leaves the cave, part of this nuance, the ascension and the exposure is that they're blinded by the light. They're not able to see what's in this blinding light, to be able to figure out what they're even looking at. This is reminiscent of likely another enlightened soul in the west of St.

Paul who never met the corporal Christ, never met physical Christ, Christ had already passed. And in the midst of persecuting Christians as a vision that blinds him. The scales, as is described by Paul, scales fall off his eyes and he actually goes to a cave to try to understand for some people think it's weak, some people think it's years, but he goes away from society to keep to try to understand what did he see for his eyes to adjust. There is this immense blinding aspect, adjustment period, to be able to figure out what is this light showing me.

The last nuance is that then when that person descends and goes back down to go tell all the captives what he's seen, they want to kill him. That point until I was 36, 37, I never groked that point. Never I completely breezed over that aspect of this story. But when someone comes down and tells you what you're looking at isn't real, what you're obsessed with, what you're conditioned by, what you're absolutely convinced is real isn't.

There is no celebration or rejoice. And that person comes down and tries to free the other captives. They are so captivated by what they're so certain is reality that any notions to the contrary are not just met with ignorant, ignoring that person or ignorance. They're met with violent calls for that person's death.

One hell of a foreshadowing by Socrates of what would happen to him. A hell of a cultural foreshadowing of what would happen to a whole lot of these people, especially here in the West, that trying to show us that I've seen whole another dimensionality. But look at this and say this is all vapor. This is what you are convinced is reality is not reality.

There's something so much greater waiting for us if we're able to listen to them. What they're met with is calls for their death. There is no rejoicing our celebration. And someone brings you to the news that reality is waiting on the other side of an ascension.

You could spend weeks, decades thinking about these nuances, seeing these nuances, seeing just the logistics of how you start to figure this stuff out and you try to share it with family members to expect celebration, a warm reception to a philosophy that to a worldview that tries to unsettle someone that's completely fixated on, no, if I just get my career on the right track, I'm gonna have it all. They ever start to really listen to what you're saying. You can almost expect a violent protest. And if you ever start to listen to what is being said, there will be a very big part of there is a very big part of us, the violent protest and a dragging of our feet for the trek that is required, the ascension that is required, or disorientation when the light starts to peek through and you see sunlight for the first time after exiting a cave your whole life.

These nuances are reasons to revisit this allegory of the cave, perhaps the most famous philosophical concept we have in the West. And it is no coincidence that Socrates, that contribution of the allegory of the cave from him or a mixture of him and Plato, there's no coincidence that it is so reminiscent of what the Vedas have been saying for thousands of years before Socrates came on the scene. It's no coincidence because Socrates's hero was Pythagoras, who died about 20 years before Socrates was born, but that was his intellectual hero. And there's no consensus on this, but many people believe that Pythagoras spent one or two decades in the Indus Valley, and he was extremely well-traveled.

So at that time, especially with the Silk Road, there was a whole lot of trade happening between East and West. And these concepts, they'd poke their heads up before Pythagoras, before Socrates, with these extremely wise Solomon's a good example. He was the wisest of all the kings in the Old Testament, talking about the world as vapor, vapor, all his vapor. His concepts would poke themselves out of literature and philosophy and tradition in the West, but man, Socrates really nailed it on the head, making it explicit.

And giving us a model for not just a fun story of what could be, but a description and his mind of what is, what we're looking at, what we're so certain of, and what we're missing. That is today's Reflection on the Daily Vedantic. We'll see you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Vedantic?

This episode is 14 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Vedantic episode published?

This episode was published on September 25, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Vedantic episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.