Skip to content
The Commercialization of Content episode artwork

Mar 21, 2024 20 min

The Commercialization of Content

from Further Up Hosted by Timothy Willard

This post follows up on my previous post, “Confessions of a Ghostwriter: Thoughts on Quitting Publishing, Writing Books, and the Life of the Mind.” If you haven’t read it, you might consider doing so. After reading my post, a good friend emailed me and posed some tough questions about the publishing world. He asked if the reality of the publishing world we all live in, in which we must sift through commercialized content (fiction, television, film, Christian resources), has created audiences who no longer thirst for deep wells of thought. To explain this better, let me tell you another publishing story. When I Was Told No Audience Existed for Deep Books In 2022, I published The Beauty Chasers: Recapturing the Wonder of the Divine with Zondervan Reflective. My publishing experience with Zondervan Reflective was wonderful, and the editing process invigorated me as a writer. The Beauty Chasers took nearly five years to publish. And it went through at least four iterations. And by iterations, I don’t mean general edits. I mean, wholesale changes to the book itself. After receiving my Ph.D. (2017)—my research explored beauty in the works of C.S. Lewis, a subfield known as theological aesthetics—I prepared a book proposal titled Where Beauty Begins. This first iteration focused more on C.S. Lewis’s thought of beauty as apologetic. I spent months preparing the proposal. My agent shopped it to at least 16 publishers (give or take). All but one rejected it. Nothing new, there. The one publisher who did not reject it asked if I’d consider revising the proposal to remove the focus on Lewis. I agreed and resubmitted it. And they rejected it. It’s okay; you can laugh. I did what they wanted, and then they said, “No thanks.” Puzzling, right? The book was eventually signed by a well-known American academic press that was signing authors to straddle the fence of academic and general audiences—think Brazos Press and Zondervan Reflective. It was a long, drawn-out process of submitting and revising. But here’s the kicker. During this process, one publisher said they loved my work but lamented that there was no audience for a book like this. When I told my wife what the publisher said, she was stunned and saddened. I wasn’t stunned. I guess I knew the publisher had a good point; a book on beauty is not very “commercial.” But I knew it in my own head. I’d never had that thought confirmed by a publisher. My friend who emailed me knew of my challenge shopping The Beauty Chasers, which led him to ask me if the glut of publishing, meaning the over-publishing of Christian books, had led to the watering down of content. It’s a good question—and a hard one. I won't tackle all the nuances of this problem in this post. Indeed, it would take several months to unpack them all. Podcast series, anyone? However, I do want to share my unrefined thoughts on the commercialization of content. I do believe that in general we as a culture overpublish. We flood the digital universe with content, we consume it on our phones and televisions, and we consume content through books and magazines (they still exist, right?). The question is, does this glut of content produce the shallowing of content? If so, what are the ramifications of overpublishing shallow Christian content? First, let’s define commercial and literary writing. Then, let’s explore the concept of commercialization. Finally, allow me to digress into ranting thoughts about the cultural dance of the content creators and producers. The Beautiful Disruption is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. What is Commercial Fiction and Nonfiction? In last week’s article, I said that James Patterson writes commercial fiction. This is not a secret. You could Google “who writes commercial fiction” and find a long list of authors. But how is commercial fiction different from literary fiction? How is commercial nonfiction—is there such a thing?—different than literary nonfiction? Commercial fiction is fiction written for mass appeal. It focuses more on plot and character development than on the style of writing and the themes woven into the narrative. In literary fiction, the plot and writing style are on equal footing. Commercial fiction is less concerned with writing style. It’s about getting an entertaining story to the masses. Commercial fiction subgenres include romance, fantasy, thriller, mystery, suspense, etc. You can loosely apply those same parameters to commercial and literary nonfiction. Literary nonfiction emphasizes thematic nuance, a beautiful writing style, a connecting narrative, etc. Commercial nonfiction will focus on mass appeal, approachability of content, application-driven content, entertainment, and approachability of writing style—in fact, writing style in the creative sense will not be emphasized. Commercial nonfiction will give you James Clear, not the Ernest Hemingway of nonfiction, a writer like Marilyn Robinson. My friend argued that Christian publishing has lost its soul because it overproduces commercial nonfiction and neglects deeper, more thoughtful books, what we call “literary nonfiction.” The proliferation of Christian books driven by mass appeal, which are commercial books written by platformed authors and influencers with massive baked-in audiences, has made it all but impossible for writers who focus on craft and nuanced themes to land book deals. I’m sure we can discuss whether commercial nonfiction and fiction should even exist, making the case for art to win the day. But we’ll save that for another post. What is Commercialization? Commercialization is a term used in the world of tech and business. It entails bringing a new product to the market. When business enterprises want to introduce a new initiative into the market, they don’t just build and release whatever they want. They pilot the idea, program, new store layout, gadgets or menu items, etc. After the pilot, they release the new product in certain markets and study the consumer’s reaction. They scale it for mass production if it’s successful in the pilot and test markets. Does commercialization apply to publishing? Of course, it does. Publishers exist to publish works that appeal to a wide array of audiences. They use sales analytics and track market trends to see what resonates with people—you, the masses. It’s an economy of ideas. Well, it used to be, anyway. The book proposal works like a marketing document in the nonfiction book world. It makes the case for the book idea, showing its relevance, audience need, and market readiness. It’s an idea proposal. Not all good ideas win. Usually, the idea coupled with a platformed author and a savvy launch initiative wins the day. The market drives the commercialization of content. This is the reality of the world we live in. Publishers seek books that meet a cultural need—they want a book that taps into an existing audience. They want to partner with authors who have already disseminated their message to a public audience. That author has already performed the market test. If a large audience likes the author's work, that message or story is ready for mass production. Two good examples of authors proving market readiness come from the world of fiction self-publishing. Before The Martian became a blockbuster film, it was a self-published novel. The author, Andy Weir, sold a massive number of units through Amazon alone. In months, a movie production company and publisher picked up the book simultaneously. The Shack sold millions as a self-published book before a publisher picked it up. The publisher 10xed it—probably 20xed it. Eventually, it was made into a blockbuster film. In nonfiction, platforming is the market readiness test. A publisher seeks a content creator already cultivating a rapt audience with a vibrant message. This can be referred to as platforming. This means the author builds his or her audience with a specific… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit timothywillard.substack.com/subscribe

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Commercialization of Content

0:00 20:35

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Further Up?

This episode is 20 minutes long.

When was this Further Up episode published?

This episode was published on March 21, 2024.

Can I download this Further Up episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.