Skip to content
The Daily Whatever, May 4: Demisexuality episode artwork

May 4, 2025 1 hr 7 min

The Daily Whatever, May 4: Demisexuality

from The Daily Whatever Show Hosted by Dana DuBois and Lawrence Winnerman

Happy Sunday, friends! Today Lawrence Winnerman and I had a great conversation about this story I wrote about demisexuality: But really, it was a conversation about much more, including... * When does something cross over from being a modifier to an identity? * Do neo-identities like demisexual belong on the LGBTQ+ continuum, or are they taking up space where they don’t belong? * Is identity immutable? * Does it harm tweens and teens to identify as asexual or demisexual, because they apply a label that might be hard to escape over time? * How can asexuality be a spectrum, when the “a” prefix means “not” or “without.” No means no, right? Then we ended the live with our weekly picks for Substacks to follow. I recommended Jacqueline Dooley, a memoirist who writes beautifully about living with grief, and Lawrence recommended Füsun Aydın, who he believes will be “capital f famous” as a memoirist and novelist one day for her lyrical prose. We’d welcome your thoughts. And we thank Polly Walker Blakemore, Peter William Murphy, Damon Kenner, and many others for tuning in. Join us all week long at 10am ET/7am PT for The Daily Whatever here on Substack. Love you mean it! Get full access to The Daily Whatever Show at www.thedailywhatevershow.com/subscribe

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Daily Whatever, May 4: Demisexuality

0:00 1:07:46
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

We were talking about the story that Dana wrote recently and shared on Gen XC. Although I stayed recently and I look at the like published eight and it was April 17th, which somehow feel, I mean, it was weeks ago at this point. It was, and full transparency was posted on Medium last year. So it is a timeless story though.

None of the nice things about coming from Medium to Substack is having a pile of Evergreen articles to share with the whole new audience. And this one is one of my favorites. I'll let you, you leave the way, Lawrence. I'm jumping in like, as I want to do.

Yes, well, both of us, we acknowledge everybody. Both of us have a tendency to sort of grab the mic from each other. And as previously noted, we both have opinions and are not shy about sharing them. 100%.

So yeah, but today we're talking about Dana's story article, kind of a memoirist life reflection. And then at the end, we're going to kind of wrap up with sharing some of our favorite sub-stackers, which is a thing that we've decided we'd like to do on Sundays. But Dana, let's get into it. Let's talk about this article.

So the title of the article is, why I don't identify as demisexual, even though I could. Gen X take on rock stars, identities, and proclivities. And I feel like the place to start is the place that you start in the article, which is you have had two opportunities in your life to do the proverbial hookup with a rock star that you have a giant crush on. But you didn't do it.

Spoiler alert, not have sex with the rock stars, even though they were both hot and willing. They were very hot and very willing. Yeah, the story, I'm trying to remember back to the genesis of the story. If it started with the rock stars, or if it started with me pondering the notion of demisexuality, and especially the idea of demisexuality being part of the kind of pride continuum of identities.

And knowing me, it probably started thinking about rock stars. It was probably all in there at the same time, and that's how it popped out. So the first story that I talk about is from when I was a we young adult Dana 1994. I think it was right after I came out to visit you in Denise in Seattle.

And I was looking in Atlanta at the time. So yeah, it was definitely 94. And I was obsessed with the band Live. Do you guys remember Live?

There was the worst band name ever, because you were just like, I'm going to see Live, and who Live? No, I'm going to see Live. Live Live. Live Live Live, really dumb.

But I loved the first two records, like embarrassingly so. And I mean, I'm not throwing out the second one. Yeah, the power of his voice and those lyrics and the, ah, these like, whoa. Are you cool?

That was weird, Lauren. Yeah, no, I'm not particularly good at karaoke as you know, and nor my vocalist. I'm sure, like, who doesn't love to sing along with those? Lightning, grass, hails.

I know everyone kind of compares them to a poor man's Eddie Vetter. But I don't think that's, I mean, there were obviously a lot of comparisons in the way they articulate and project their powerful voices. And it was the same era of grunge. But anyway, I won't go into how Live was not a grunge band, in part because they were from Pennsylvania.

But anyways, a huge crush on Ed Koalcik and on the band. And their second record throwing copper had just come out. And they had announced the Atlanta show. And it was like the day before I was supposed to return from Seattle.

And I was such a big fan. I left our trip early and flew back for the show. What's funny is, I mean, I was clearly there in Seattle. Yeah, I was one of the people you were visiting.

I remember you leaving early to go to that show. I mean, I believe that it happened that way. Yeah. I just, I don't remember that detail.

It wasn't, it wasn't an important detail to you. You may have not even known my flight dates, right? Probably. Yeah.

It was an important. Yeah. Yeah. So I flew back to show was awesome.

This was during the brief window when Ed had his really long, beautiful hair before shaved it and looked like Jeff Bezos, when he was no longer hot. But he, I'm trying to, I think he was like a year younger than me. So he would have been 23 to my 24. And I do remember his birthday because I'm like, we're about birthdays, July 16th, this is birthdays right before mine.

But I think a year earlier, it was the 16th, 18th, something like that. It's been a long time. Anyways, Ed, if you're listening, maybe we can have a joint birthday party this year in July. And so.

With his wife and children, yeah. Yes. After the show, my friend Kathy, who was my best friend from grad school, and we'd moved to Atlanta together, she was from Montgomery, Alabama. She had like the greatest ability to just say absolutely anything because of her charming Montgomery accent.

And, oh, I'm a Leo, Karen. He's a cancer, but I'm July 25th. I'm a Leo. I'm just over the cusp.

So Kathy and I walk up, you know, the band was small enough that they were still like meeting the fans after the show. And it was a gaggle of young women all like, he, he, he loves party. But we were the only two who were over 21 along with the band. And so we suggested a bar.

And that's where they went because everybody else couldn't go to the bar. And so we got there and Kathy being the little southern flirt that she is, went up to him and was like, my friend is such a big fan of yours. You should give her a little kiss. I get quite do the Montgomery accent all the way.

But I mean, you're making it sound very blank to you all from a street card named Tucker. She could have, she could do that. You know, she was way too young. But the always, I guess I'm doing my I've always depended on the kind of strange things that you get on with depend on the kind of strange things that is to keep you from trouble and should you from danger.

Thank you. Thank you. Marge Simpson. So, so he did and then he invited me back to this hotel room.

And I was like, nothing like that had ever happened to me before. And I was like, Oh, my God, oh, my God, oh, my God. And so I went and he did answer the door in his underwear. Gray, vase, or briefs.

But the band was there still and because I remember being in this hotel room with the band talking about how great the show was and I don't know, t-shirt sales, I don't remember. But I remember the very sort of the business of the show. And they were in the left and we started making out and blah, blah, blah, blah. And certainly the opportunity was there to totally, you know, have sex with it.

Cool check. And I was like, OK, hang on. It's like we're skipping an important detail. OK, lucky.

Oh, she is. I don't remember. Who do you? It was not police.

He's asking. I think you guys know he's asking. I mean, I don't know. So, I don't remember Lawrence.

Isn't that weird? I want to say average to maybe big, definitely not small. I would have remembered small. OK.

He has a big nose. Yeah. So for those who would like to know, OK, Lisa just joined Lisa, texted me yesterday and said that she loves joining and listening. Stuff back will not let her comment or heart as we're talking for some reason.

Yeah, which I was like, there's nothing weird in our settings. Like you should be everyone should be able to do that. So sorry. How do you hear even if you can't heart and comment and do that?

Didn't we set up a no college roommates commenting on anything we say? Oh, right. Yeah, there's that setting. Yeah, former college roommates.

You can do it today, everybody. Look at that. It's Lisa, everyone. Yay, are both of our college roommates at the per time.

So Lawrence and I never were roommates. Yeah. So that's the point. And then I'll let you get on with it.

So back to the code phrase, everybody. This is daily, whatever glossary time. OK. Maki means little bird in Greek, apparently.

And it also means tiny penis and polar means big bird, which, you know, and booty is just bird, apparently. So there you go. Welcome to our world. Now you can speak like us.

There we go. I really should remember that detail. But I think I was I was just to. Yeah, you know, I don't know.

That's not the part that my memory remembers. I think good size words. I don't know. But I I know you've really thought that we like had a real connection and that he was going to call me because that was the only way to get in touch in 1984.

And we were going to have like a thing and we were going to get to know each other. And, you know, he was going to be my boyfriend or something like that. Of course that didn't happen. He took my number.

But of course, I know I'm still waiting to hear from Ed. I've never heard from him. And so I didn't have I still feel like I had like an experience of a lifetime, but I didn't have the full experience of a lifetime that it could have been. So we're going to pause there just to know that there's a fascinating conversation going on in the chat.

Peter, Peter Murphy on dead. Says that he and his friend insulted the TV mix and an elevator in Boston, not insult, well, not insult, more constructive criticism. What did you say? Yeah, Peter, I'm dying to know what you said.

And then Karen said, TV next used to buy her hair accessories from Karen's online store, which clearly we're talking about tomorrow, Karen. So, OK, yeah, I need. Yeah. Let us know, Peter, what how did how or why did you insult or destructively criticize the TV mix?

Did she need hair oil? Was that it? Did you tell her her hair was a little fizzy like minus this morning because a lot of hair oil in this? Anyways, we'll wait to hear back.

So to bring this back to my story, this is something that's been with me my whole life. This like I've never just been, you know, someone to just be very casual about sex. I've always had to feel like there's like a sense of trust and connection. And then the second incident I detail in this story is someone closer to home.

This is me and my early thirties. Hey, oh, hey, yeah, I just this is bonking little stick on this table. Now my dog is like, there's an intruder. We're going to all die if I don't market the dog and defend ignore her.

Sorry, guys. Yeah, come here. I think it's OK. She'll be fine.

She'll come back in a minute. So I had a crush on a local rock star and who I will out in a minute, but he was nationally big, but not so big that when he released his for solar record, you couldn't just walk up to him after the show and to him. And I did. And he took my email address because it wasn't just phones then his email and he emailed me and we were in touch and I invited him.

I don't know how I heard that he also liked karaoke. I invited him to karaoke and we agreed we would meet at this place called the bar and off and anyone who's in Seattle might know, you know, where the bar and off is Lawrence. Eighty fifth and greenwood or eight seven. It would be well where the bar and off is.

Yes. It is. It is like dive. The diveiest dive bar that ever done.

It's been there since time to get it has had a revitalization. Like it's so divey. It's sort of hipster cool and a lot of people go. But back in the early 2000s when the story takes place like this was like hardcore career drunks and that's about it.

I think they had karaoke on like Sunday and Monday nights. That was like, they also I don't think they still do this, but they used to have like a crock pot of soup and you could just eat soup for free at the bar. I don't know why I thought that was sort of dimly charming. Like maybe they were maybe they were worried that their patrons weren't eating food.

I don't know. And there was some care. The drinks were so cheap and so strong. And that is important context because we agreed to meet there and we said let's each bring a friend.

And so I brought three and Liz was one of them. Liz my kind of another BFF who I founded three imaginary girls with. And this is part of the three imaginary girls origin story, my music website. This was right as I first met Liz a few months before the whole thing started.

Okay. Sorry, I'm talking too much. We went we say a bunch of karaoke. We proceeded to get extremely hammered because the drinks were so incredibly strong.

And at the end of the night, like 2am as we stumbled out of the bar, he planted one on me for anyone on Greenwood Avenue to see. And he was a great kisser and it was super exciting and fun. But I did not go home with him. I don't even remember how I got home.

I don't think I drove but got home and waited here for him again. And because again, I'm like, well, I'm gonna be he lives here. We're gonna be in a relationship. And then I realized that he was in a relationship with at least half the city.

And so that that never came to be. And so the idea of being demisexual has been a bit in forever and it leaves me with no regrets. I don't regret not sleeping with either of these men because the act of actually having sex it doesn't change your diminished experience. And I think at the time would have been very painful if I hadn't heard from them after being intimate with them.

But to knock you from now, let's break in here and find you define demisexuality in the article courtesy of Mary Webster. So feeling sexual attraction towards another person only after establishing an emotional bond with that person. So you say that resonates with you. Yes, yes, yes, it does.

Yes, and it doesn't necessarily take a ton of time to establish that kind of bond with people. It's not like I'm some like, I don't have sex, I don't have someone for months because I don't feel it. I've certainly slept with people pretty quickly. I've certainly formed bonds like that after the earliest a couple of dates.

I have never found anything rewarding to come out of an experience where I've slept with someone after just a couple of dates. It always ends poorly for me. At least I know that there are people who hook up in the back of a bar that they need someone and go on to form a lifelong relationship with them. That hasn't happened for me.

But until then, there's sort of like a beautiful museum exhibit in a way. There's this sense of like, that's a little bit too much, but like there's a part of me that's like way back here that if I try to force it forward is not a good thing that I'm just like, I'm observing this and I can see you're really sexy and I like where this is going but I'm just not there yet. There's, yeah, it's like I'm watching it in a movie almost and my body is not engaged in a way that it needs to be. And when I first wrote this article, I got a lot of comments and a lot of them were like, oh, yeah, that's just called dating.

You want to know someone before you have sex with them. That's normal. And other people were like, yes, this really resonates with me. I hear too.

And then there were people who were like, you're just not defining demisexuality, you're not demisexuality. You don't get it. I'm demisexual and I get it. So this is the thinking point for me, right?

Like I read that definition in Miriam Webster and I, you know, I'm queer, right? Like I want to believe in everybody's thing. And I think this is kind of the point you're getting to, like, what are the nuances that I'm missing of demisexuality that don't just make it like, Hey, this is how people date. Yes.

So this was like word nerd moment. There's something that really fascinates me with, I think typically how people younger than us millennials on down talk about how they use words, both in terms of I, I've heard this use for identity. I've also heard it used with mental health. And I remember a younger than me co-workers saying once this really triggers my anxiety, my anxiety is this.

And I was like, wow, you see, I would the freight refraces that sent us to like this makes me feel anxious. And there's a difference in usage there that saying feel anxious is a short term modifier. I am a person who is feeling a sense of anxiety. Sometimes I take medication because I feel a sense of anxiety that's quite strong.

It's not part of my identity. But when you say I, my anxiety does this, it's like a part of you. And Karen's putting in here, it's on the asexual spectrum, which we're going to get to that as a word nerd in a minute as well. So if I say like demisexual when that term came about, I was like, well, that's useful.

That is like a shorthand way for me to talk to a new potential partner of like, you know, I have a sense of demsexuality. Like there's a sense that I don't like to connect quickly, or I don't like to hook up quickly because of this. It's not part of my identity though. I don't walk around each day and be like, I am a demisexual, right?

It's a different word usage that denotes a very different self-perception of what that word does for you. Like your gay Lawrence and there's, I don't know if you know this, but when you say, you know, when a person says I'm gay, you're not just talking about a sexual preference and behavior at that point because it permeates your sexuality. Yes, but that becomes something that impacts areas of your life because it deals with your sense of partnership and relationship partnership. And those are details you tend to share with the people in your life, your coworkers, your friends, your family, they know who you're in relationship with, who you're dating.

And to not share those details is like a very hard omission from your life. Right. And it's why I was so depressed and suicidal for the early part of my life is because I couldn't share with you and my family and other people that I loved and trusted like this very fundamental thing about who I am. And I don't, I don't, I don't, I don't, I mean, I don't know, I guess I sometimes marsh around wearing t-shirts and waving flags, you know, proclaiming it, but I don't generally think that like that is a term that I have to, you know, hang above my head and use the only descriptor for who I am, you know?

It's not the only descriptor, but when you wrote your bio for sub-stack, it's in there. Yeah, for sure. Because it's like a huge part of who you are. And because it's part of who you are, it's a way in which you face potential discrimination.

It permeates every aspect of your life, right? Even if one is like, I am demisexual and I want to proclaim it, it's simply that this comes back to the whole question of pride and like what goes on a pride flag, you know, it's May now. So pride is like five seconds away, pride month, really curious to see under Trump what we're going to see happening for pride month. I hope we're not seeing violence for pride month.

That's my fear. But how free we will feel to celebrate and acknowledge it. To me, being demisexual or identity, you know, having a, having those proclivities, the only people who really need to know about it are your partners. And yes, it can be helpful to talk about.

So other people can be like, okay, I'm not weird. I do think, you know, I have an intermittently single on and off my whole life, I'm single now. As I read this, this is saying that the world of dating each time, the rule shift and for sure, it is an expectation now that as soon as you meet someone like sex is immediately on the table. That is a norm even.

I mean, it always was for including I know, like that. I mean, not always necessarily like I think even in the gay world, there's, there's a focal minority of gay dudes who are kind of like, can't we just meet and like know each other before we jump into bed? It is just that I don't know. I don't necessarily want to blame this on biological differences, but you know, two horny guys getting together, there's usually not somebody saying no.

And so yes, we tend to talk on the first date as Dan said. Yes. And yes, we can, we can use F bombs on this podcast. I realize I'm being very like, and have sex.

We can just say fuck. I don't know why I'm being so pure technical here. But the expectation is they're very, very quickly. And so I can understand why having a word and having their people who are like, it's completely fine to not want to do this right.

You know, like this is an identity. You have to understand that there are people who are wired this way. Sure. I'm happy to be part of that discourse.

But what really, this was one of the drivers, like the impetus behind this article was I was at work and I worked for big corporate entity that has an internal communications team and they're like TVs in the break rooms that are showing messaging. I'm getting a lot of feedback on my voice. Is anybody else hearing it? Never.

Okay. And so it was June, so it was Pride Month and there was, it was a really wonderfully produced video. It was airing while I was making my cup of tea and it was a whole bunch of LGBTQ folks talking and the first was there was a lesbian couple and they talked about how the company had helped them get IVF so that they could be parents and how much they appreciated it. It was all done through the lens of being in place at this company.

And there were two gay men talking about being discriminated against and how welcoming a place this had been. And there was the trans person who talked about having their medications paid for by the insurance. Like these were big things to be very proud of, right? And oh my God.

That's my dog. And then there was a woman who was, like my jaw dropped, who was like, I'm demisexual. And that means, and like got into the definition of what demisexualism is. And I was like, this doesn't make me feel more scene at work.

This is the cringiest thing I've ever seen at work. Like I get they were trying to be inclusive in making this video and they were taking on some of the newer terms that younger, especially younger employees might have been familiar with, but like there is no tie from being demisexual to the one. Right. And so I think the thing you said in your article was that to you, this was like presenting a kink, right?

It would have been like, if someone had gone and been like, I'm a rope bunny. And with that theme, I love bondage. I'm so good at tying knots. And I love when I'm restrained from even like, you know, yeah, employee benefits to any accounting.

How does that make you like, right? I have a foot fetish and that means, right. It's a thing here. The more I get off, right, we've transgressed from, I am a part of the group which has traditionally been discriminated against or not kind of fully enfranchised into like, I'm just a person who has sex in a way that is maybe slightly different from the way other people have sex.

Right. And so I think that's how, when this reminds me around the same time, I do listen to Dan Savage and Savage Love pretty religiously. And I remember he had a question because he gets a lot of like people keep keeping around pride questions, not a lot, but there have been a few. And there was a lot of Karen's laughing at rope buddy.

I'm really, I've not been keeping up with the chat. We have to come back and talk about what's in the chat. But a person called in talking about, trying to remember what the details were. I think they were talking about how they had identified as asexual.

And so they were part of the LGBTQIA and that they now are, they have, they had multiple partners, they were poly and that they were upset that poly wasn't in the spectrum of LGBTQIA and how they were like, when I wasn't having sex, I was part of it. And now I don't feel like this is part of it and shouldn't poly be part of the queer spectrum. And Dan is always very polite and he's older than we are. He's an early boomer, not even Gen X.

So I think he presents pretty Gen X. And I know he's always very careful about saying anything too bold because he has to be welcoming to all. But he was like, we're not going to gatekeep who comes to pride. Be proud.

But you can't compare, oh, this one was talking about how she could bring her husband to the work party, the Christmas party, but she couldn't bring her boyfriend. And so that was what made her be like, isn't this more a part of pride that people don't understand my family relationship setup versus being asexual? And he was like, you can't compare, you're not being able to bring your boyfriend to the Christmas party, to the levels of oppression that a gay man like me has been facing since time began. And he's like, I'm not going to gatekeep you from coming to pride, but like calm down.

It's kind of what I heard in his answer. And I certainly as a society white women do not have, I'm not here to gatekeep who and what queer people decide belongs on their flag. You get a lot of little more sailor and I think as a gay man. I mean, and even I'm not here to gatekeep anything, right?

Like everybody's welcome. Come on in. Coming to pride for sure. Just to me, pride is based on a history of violence, right?

Like it was, it was, it's a response to not being safe, which in our world right now, we're increasingly maybe losing ground on the, on the advocacy work that's been done for the past several decades that have opened us up to having these freedoms and the first four, right? The LGBT folks were the forefront of this. And the ones who are still, and I guess, you know, queer is a pretty kind of, I think it was like a blink of term. Sure.

I feel like we've reclaimed queer from being a pejorative to being a blimp for 100%. So sure. But once you get past that, it's like, you know, I think you were joking earlier when we were talking about this topic of like, they're not going to be rounding up the demisexuals to put them in a gulag. Right.

Right. You know, when they come around to people, like they're definitely coming for me, right? No, they're going to be like, well, you're the gayest gay whoever gave. So you're clearly going into the ovens, you know, but like when they come to the asexual or sorry, the demisexual person, you know, what, what are they going to say?

Like, oh, you didn't, you didn't sleep with them on the first date? Okay. Do you want to go to the ovens? Because.

Do you just joking about the ovens? I mean, yeah. We're here. You know, no, it's fine.

I think we're fine here. But I think we as a people need to be careful about, this is a funny thing for me to be saying, maybe because I'm not part of the community. But I don't want it to take up any space at pride other than as an ally, right? That's my only spot where I belong there.

Yes, we can talk about things like asexuality or being aromantic or talking about being demisexual or the whole long list of new kind of, um, neo terms that have come up. But I do fear that they are taking air away from those who especially now need it. They need more. They need the focus to be the focus on the support because me trying to spread awareness about our people, uh, date and decide to, you know, fuck future partners just isn't in no way an equal to that.

And, um, I, the other thing we haven't talked about yet is that, um, demisexuality is considered part of what they call the asexual spectrum. And as a word nerd, I really hard. I'm in the, in the, in the chat. Yes, I have a really hard time with the word asexual having a spectrum.

A means no, not. There's no spectrum on no. It is simply a no. And as a person with demisexuality, like I'm not asexual at all.

At all. And I don't know if Dan Savage coined this or just used this term graysexual instead of asexual. I'm okay with that. I guess.

I still think it's a little bit loud actually. I don't know that someone who wants to, uh, you know, know their partners better is any less of a sexual person than someone who wants to, you know, fuck on the first date. It's, um, that to me isn't on the continuum of like a lack of sex. I'm reading my life right now, maybe it is.

You know, like it certainly hasn't, I feel like it my lifelong experience. Um, then in an indicator of that, I don't know, fight me Lawrence if you disagree with me, but I just, um, I know there is an asexuality spectrum. I'm not the person who gets to make the rules that there shouldn't be one, but there should be no spectrum of no. No means no.

Right. Poly is opposing a new sexual scale that goes from zero to 10. So Poly, I've been thinking about this a lot. I, I think like the rubric we use to talk about sex and gender and identity and the way those things combine and the nuance that we're now bringing to this conversation is, is, is bigger than just kind of like a spectrum.

I, so I have this in my head, probably maybe we can collaborate on this and get published and be revolutionary, but I'm almost, I, I need to be like, I don't know, like a three-dimensional grid or something, right? Where you, the way that you gender express in the world and the way that you internalize your gender, your biological gender, who you're attracted to, how much you're attracted to them, the ways in which you're attracted to them, all, like all of those that kind of combine in some kind of three-dimensional thing, right? And like we talked about before, there's somebody for everybody, you know, like whatever your three-dimensional shape is, there's someone who matches it, right? Venn diagrams or something.

But yeah, you know, I, Dana, I hear what you're saying, like, you know, if, if asexual means no sex, right? Or I don't experience feelings of sexual attraction. This is a thing that we've talked about. I think this is what you're leading up to, which is like, if you start labeling yourself that, are you painting yourselves into a corner then for the future?

Well, it's right, right. Do you have, all right, I'm a top. Anyone out there at bottom? Who's the bottom?

Here you go. Right. And 62. Yeah, that's a verse top.

Right. Right. I'm on the line for the third. Who liked to be vocal and yeah, I don't know.

We could go on forever. Yes, you were, you were saying though, and I agree with this. And I agree with this, especially because this is the province of young people mostly, right? And I have two teens and I said I wasn't going to get into this, but I might, a little bit Lawrence of like, you say, yes.

In the best way, you really thank my battleship. Oh my God. Oh. My lower death through flooding, baby.

Right, pulana. That is what I'm hearing here. So when one takes on an identity, yeah, it becomes a part of who you are, right? And it is very hard to change a part of one's identity.

It can happen. It certainly happens sexually or otherwise, just how you see who you are and how you work walk through the world. But those who change you. I don't mean to interrupt, but like you're triggering something and like, I feel like for me, the reason that I use gay, right?

The reason that I am happy and whatever, the reason that I identify with the tag gay and use it is because it's an immutable part of who I am. And trans, right, is an immutable part of who those people are. Like it can't be separated from how they exist in the world and how they interact in the world. Gay can't be separated from me of how I exist and interact in the world.

Whereas I feel like for something like asexuality or aromanticism or demisexuality, like maybe you're locking yourself into a thing that could potentially change over time. I mean, at 16, I might have destroyed myself as demisexual or, you know, not aromantic, but asexual. Certainly I wasn't having sex. You know, that provided over time.

I would have identified as asexual potentially. Like I was a, what I would now just call it, or we would have said that it was a late bloomer. And like it kind of freaked me out. The idea of it freaked me out a bit.

And the media portrays teenagers as these little horn monsters, right? Always wanting to have sex. And I certainly saw it around me. And I bless you.

I was not like that. I feel like if I had taken on an identity like asexual at 15, 16 years old, like a lot of kids are doing, it would have taken me a long time to come into the adult I am now. Because it would have been a betrayal of my identity to be like, oh, I think I want to have sex with this person, or I want to have sex at all. And I might have said, if I, when I started dating, especially these days when everything is written down and documented online and not written down, but exists on a profile versus something you have to tell someone, like when we were coming to age, oh, this person is asexual.

I don't want to date them. Like it would have, it's an isolating thing in a way, right? You are narrowing your pull down and when you're gay, you have to narrow your pull down because you're only going to date other gay men. But if you label yourself as ace and you're only going to date ace people because you want companionship, I'm not saying there are people who are ace who simply remain ace their whole lives, but with ace awareness coming out, like they're, do you know the show Big Mouth Lawrence?

Have you ever watched it? No. First of all, it's so funny and you should watch it. It's a cartoon.

It was like seven seasons of it and my eldest brought it to me and was like, well, I think you're going to think this is really funny and we should watch it together. But just so you know, I've already seen the whole thing so you can't tell me I'm not allowed to watch it because it's very body. It's like, it's to me, super subversive because they start in middle school, they're in high school now. They have hormone monsters and my Rudolph is one and is the girls and I think just want to fuck all the time, they're gross and they're like, you know, they're these horny tweens.

But they give a ton of really great information about body awareness, like the boys knowing about periods, the masturbating and consent. Like there's all kinds of great stuff coming through in this very body disgusting show. But there is a character on there who's ace. They're 13 years old, right?

And he's a boy and he's religious and Missy who was originally voiced by Jenny Slate. I can't remember who's doing her voice now, but she's she really wants him and he's her boyfriend, but he's asexual. And I'm like, maybe this is a person who's never going to want to have sex this whole life, but I just feel like a lot of kids at 13 are still kids. And through shows like this, kids are learning this vocabulary.

And there's an, I mean, as early as fifth grade when my youngest was going through her gender journey, all these kids were talking about their identities constantly. I'm pan and I'm a lesbian and nobody was cishette straight, of course, because that is boring. And so it may just be that it would it's not pigeonholing as much for these Gen Z borderline gen alpha kids because they're so used to identity being fluid and moving. But I think us with, I'd like to hope wisdom of age looking back, there's this sense of like, maybe you don't need to identify your sexuality before you've tried anything sexual.

And I certainly would have picked asexual as a teenager if I had felt pressured to pick and share publicly, share an identity. And I think that would have harmed me. Sure. I mean, I've told you this before.

If all of the terminology had existed in the way they'd exist now when we were young and at these ages, like there may have been a moment where I would have identified as trans. And I'm not, obviously, but I thought about it, right? Like I toyed with the idea, like trying to understand my sexuality. I thought a lot of thoughts and I wondered a lot of wonderings and tried on, you know, very different and complicated thoughts.

And you know, for like, I don't know, a week, I might have been like, maybe, maybe I am a woman trapped in a man's body. But I fully, more fully kind of recognized who I am and, you know, and kind of what works for me again on that, like, you know, three dimensional, I am a person in this kind of body, having this kind of gender identity experience attracted to these kinds of people. So Lisa, we're maybe, Lisa, yay, made a comment saying, I feel like terminology helps to understand your wiring helps you to not feel weird, like Dana mentioned earlier, but isn't necessarily an identity. And I get that, right?

Like, like, at least it's a language and a vocabulary. I think this is your point, Dana, that, you know, you can, you have words to talk about what you're feeling. Yes. Proclivity, not an identity is how I say it.

Like, I'm, like, these are great words. And sometimes yesterday are. So sorry, I got worked in and got the dog a dog tree because she was fussing. I'm still trying to shrink.

Should have some shoulder. I know. I thought, Oh, it's so cute. I'm showing my shoulder.

No, it's just that it's a big hitty Lauren. So I'm not trying. Well, yeah, I'm trying to go. Okay.

Who me? Right. Am I looking? He's the pluristrap everybody?

Oh my God. Really? This is what you call a pluristrap. There are like three people out there who really think I'm at their strap on sub stack.

My DM's blowing up with three or four messages. I'm teasing. I mean, I'm not. I have three or four messages.

I'm not responding to it is a common reference point care and that's a really good way to put it. And I compared it to mental health earlier of like, you can define your mental health issues in any way you wish. If it is actually feels so strong that it's a part of your identity, then yes. But the preferred nomenclature I have heard from people younger is to describe the example I use was anxiety as immutable characteristic.

My anxiety sits with me versus a temporary state. It's kind of like, Oh my gosh, you didn't take Spanish Lawrence, but there are two verbs for to be in Spanish. One is as far and one is there. And it's been a long time since I took Spanish, so I'm going to mess them up.

But as far as things that are changeable and there is things that are immutable. Oh, wow. That's a great concept. Yes.

The thing that it made me think of is the is inside out, right? The movie where your characteristics are actual entities that sort of have their own agendas or whatever inside your head. Did you see the second one? I haven't yet.

Because in the second one, more complex emotions within. Excellent. And my favorite one and she is completely my eldest child is named on we. I love on we.

On the end, on the end French, she's a French woman and she's constantly on her phone like, Oh, I have no board. Why does nothing entertain me? Yeah, that's that is on we and she is amazing. But about demisexuality.

So yeah, where have we come with this conversation? I think like meta points of it are it needn't always be identity. Sometimes it's just proclivity. That's and I think a lot of nuance gets missed when I wrote the story.

It was of course under the Biden administration and things felt safe and great. And now I hesitate to lean into heavily with any of my grumble grumbles. I would more lean into people feeling free to express who they are and having to be safe. I don't think I am at any risk of persecution for being demisexual, at worst.

I may lose dating prospects at which there's zero right now. So really a nice. But yeah, yes, Karen, a t-shirt. What would the t-shirt be?

I think inside out Karen, which would be not an identity. Proclivity not an identity. Yeah, there you go. That's t-shirt.

I think people would be like what? Kind of reminds me of my favorite punper sticker. Which one? Subduction leads to a Rajani.

It's continental plates being forced under each other leads to mountain building. Oh. But it just sounds so hot. Proclivity leads to a Rajani.

Right. I don't see. I didn't even get it. Yeah.

Well, there you go. So you could wear your perclivity as not an identity t-shirt and people wouldn't get it. Right. They would just be like, what are you trying to say, woman?

And I think, here's the thing. I have demisexual tonsies, but I'm not a demisexual. That might get you kicked out of a Pride celebration actually. That would.

And that, but the thing is I would happily go. I have been in love with Pride celebration. I would never talk about my own sexuality and Pride celebration. And there is an ally.

Right. You guys, we're here to talk about you. But let me make it about me for a minute. I don't even put it on my online dating profile.

Although on many of the apps, it is a choice now. You have like a thousand different identities, like, CBO sexual and, oh, these things that sound dirty, but you can be many, many things on them. But I just, I don't think I'm that abnormal. I might make you wait till the third or fourth date to fuck me.

It's not something I need to proclaim outwardly. I'm making you that t-shirt. What do you want me to call me? I'm going to make you a demisexuality flag and it's literally going to say in the flag, I might make you wait until the third or fourth date to fuck me.

Just make it third to shorten it. Yeah. Yeah. Perfect.

You actually probably should make that shirt because people might actually would probably make people who actually identify as demisexual angry that were belittling their identity. But yeah, I'm not trying to belittle it. I don't know. We're two Jews making Holocaust jokes.

Right. Sometimes the jokes that we make are gonna offend somebody. Right. It's nothing sacred.

It's our own form of religion. We can talk about what we want. It's our own podcast, Lawrence. Yeah.

At least we have our own podcast, Hat joined, which is amazing. Even genetics change, which is true. Like your epigenetics absolutely influence the rest of your life and the lives of your children. Which is the whole topic that we like to talk about.

But we said we were going to save a part of this episode for one of our new favorite Sunday traditions, which is Sunday, Share the Love Sub-Stacker something, right? Where we talk about our favorite sub-stackers that we've discovered. So do you feel like you're complete in talking about demisexuality? I think so.

I mean, I love for you all to read the story. I'll link it in the recap from this. I also just shared it in notes. said, we're going to be talking about this.

But we'd love to hear any thoughts people have. I'm always up for a good conversation and changing my mind. The one thing that I wish your Lawrence that's sort of coming to mind as I'm talking about this is we talked about immutable versus immutable. And sometimes those things are even those immutable things are on a spectrum.

And I'm thinking of things like sometimes people are like I know women who have married men and are now married to women who were sworn up and down that they were straight. I know, you know, a gay men and women and trans people who Ben, you know, there's someone who sort of changes their mind. And they're like, I guess I'm at least a little by now. Yeah, I mean, my experience, right?

Like I I'm very, very, very gay. Very, but the guy that I'm dating right now, like the nature of our sexual relationship is such that I would experiment with having sex with a woman with him. Like it like there's something that he brings out in me that I haven't necessarily ever felt before. And good God, we could probably have an entire episode about that.

But you know, it's yeah, like even the even the most immutable things may may not be fully and firmly immutable. Yes. And things that are immutable, though, are far slower moving and harder to change, I guess. Right.

And by heart, I just mean, like it comes after either a great time or great impact, like this, you know, your, your guy, who I agree with. Yeah, in a scenario that I just kind of named, right? Like that what it revealed to me is that is that, you know, yes, maybe I'm a teeny tiny little bit bisexual, but I need like 17 stars and planets to align, you know, in kind of the perfect scenario before, that would be exciting to me. So, you know, that's the thing I learned about myself that I didn't know before.

Yes. And I know a couple of people here in Seattle, you know, at least one of them who are like late coming non-binary trans people who, both of them, I have always known up until the last couple of years as men who now identify as non-binary. And both I've taken on some feminine attributes. One of them is like hormones taking on feminine attributes.

I'm not sure about the other one. I don't know them as well. So perhaps that was always in there and it was just free to come out now, or perhaps like, you know, we have all as people. So as I'm talking this through, I'm like, yeah, I guess the the line between immutable, like identity versus a proclivity is not that's not binary either.

I guess my advocacy there is like, go easy on what we pick as identity and don't lose sight of people who who need our advocacy work in the Pride space. Yeah. Don't don't take up space where where support is needed. It's got the what came to my mind was that like the circle of grief.

I'm sure you've heard about this of the like when when someone passes that like the people closest to them are in the inner circle and then their next like maybe their their partner or parents and then the siblings and cousins are next and then the friends or whatever it is and like recognize where you are in the circle and always support on the way in. Yeah. If you are like on the outer circle, don't go making it about you when you're with their bereaved spouse, support them and take your grief further out of the circle. I feel like for me that metaphor holds.

I like it. I think that makes sense. Okay. Now that I tell me about your substacture of the week who's who's someone you want to shine some love on?

Well, I haven't told her I'm going to talk about her and she's not here. But this is one of my favorite medium writers who is also one sub stack. Her name is Jacqueline Doolie. She is probably not a stranger to anybody on here.

Jackie is also a friend. She's a fellow boost nominator. She also writes for age of empathy and the memoirist on medium. And so that was how I met her and Jackie.

So Jackie had two daughters and her older daughter died of cancer when she was 15 after a multi-year battle. And that happened now eight years ago. So long before I met her and she Jackie is one of the most gifted writers I have read in terms of personal essay and memoir and obviously writes a lot about grief and the loss of her child. And she has been writing about it for many years.

And so she'll post a new story and I'm like, okay, I'm not going to cry this time. I've read about Emma so many times and I will open it and read it and I have never not cried at one of her essays. I've never not learned something about grief from one of her essays. And one thing I like to say is also a memoirist.

I aimed at one day being at Jackie's caliber in terms of skill is that sometimes it's not about writing a story once. It's not like you're like, okay, I'm going to write about the time this happened. You can write about the time that happened over and over from different points of view and from different things you learned about it and over time your perspective as the narrator will shift and you will learn new things. And just Jackie is masterful at this and I can only imagine the comfort she has brought to so many as she has gone through the process very publicly of how she has managed a grief that is fully unmanageable.

And despite all of this, Jackie is one of the funnier people I know like she is a very, she's very funny and a delightful human to know. I think you would really hit it off with her to Lawrence. We should see if she's going to come on a podcast. She's another gen X non-practicing I think you lives in New York.

She paints, she loves to paint nature and is very into gardening and birding and hiking around her upstate New York. I don't know where in the state she is. I just know she's not in Manhattan. She's in a more rural area.

So I just, if you were not already following Jackie, you should. She's also been published off of Medium and Substack. And she famously, at least in my mind, got a story in Huffington Post, which Huffington Post is hard to get in as a memoirist. She wrote a story about, it was about Anna and it was about this imaginary world that she created at called Arcano.

I think, I hope I remember that right. If that's not quite it, it's close. It was a big anniversary, like a sixth or seventh year anniversary. I don't want to write about the grief of cancer.

I want to show you something about my daughter who's now gone and how she's, oh, Arcamo. Shit, I can't believe I'm forgetting the word. I should have looked this up. But she walks the reader through this whole made-up world.

She had her head and how she would build these structures. Jackie still has. And she broke Huffington Post. She got millions and millions of breeds.

They didn't disclose the exact amount. And Jackie got hundreds of males in responses from other people and how much it was such an interesting way to show her love for her child. And instead of focusing on the grief itself, focusing on this beautiful part of a life that was cut short far too soon. And that let everyone in on her grief through that one narrative device.

It's a beautiful story. So Jackie is my recommendation of the week. Jacqueline Dilly, a user full name so you can find her on sub stack and on, she's mostly on sub stack now. Putting a link to her sub stack into the chat because a couple people have asked.

There she is. She is wonderful. And yeah, tell her Dana said, Joe. Lawrence, who was your sub stack?

And I do want to acknowledge Polly. I was Polly's hundred subscriber to put in the chat and she also messaged to tell me yesterday. I was running around with my daughter all day yesterday and then passed out at 10 o'clock. But I wanted to I'm so honored.

I'm not for 100. That's so cool. Yeah. So they probably know what I was doing when I did that.

But I'm very honored to have been the hundreds Lawrence. Who is your recommended sub stacker this week? I don't think this will be a surprise to you. I've mentioned her previously.

So my pick for the week is a woman named Fusan Aiden and I will put her link here into the chat. Fusan is spelled F, who allowed you as UN. So Fusan is a Turkish trans woman who's now living in Portugal. She just moved to Portugal.

And she just started dating a wonderful guy. And Fusan is openly trans, openly a sex worker and an absolutely magnificent writer. I, on honestly, as a writer, I'm not sure I can do justice with words to explain how compelling I find her writing. She's so visceral and honest and clear eyed and what like absolutely does not leave herself out of the sort of the blame or the like, you know, kind of look at what an idiot I was here.

But but in such a just real and charming way that she's an amazing memoirist, you know, somebody who has experienced so much and who, you know, has experienced things frankly that maybe some people would never talk about, right? That some people that might that might end some people. And you know, certainly things that, you know, that people might be reluctant to kind of share with other people. But she's very transparent and again, clear eyed is kind of the best sort of adjective I can come up with.

You know, but there's also lyricism in what she writes. And it really impresses me because, you know, Turkish and English is not her first language. I don't think, you know, and I lived in Amsterdam for a very long time. So I'm kind of assuming that you learn Dutch and, you know, just that somebody could be so beautifully skilled in writing in English when it is not their first language is really impressive to me.

So what's that for sure? Like, I'm always blown away when non-native English speakers are eloquent writers. English is hard. English is hard, right?

Like getting nuance right in English is hard. And to be a lyrical writer in English as a non-native speaker is a particular feat. And so I read her and there have been a number of moments where I've come away, you know, almost shaking a little thinking, she's going to be famous, like capital F famous. Like, this is an author.

This is a personality and a writer who will leave a mark. And in my mind, she kind of reminds me of Jean-Génet a little bit. I don't know if you've ever read any Jean-Génet, so Jean-Génet was a French writer who kind of born into poverty. And he was almost actual, he was gay, he kind of used prostitution as a way to survive.

He was a thief, he was a prostitute. And he wrote a kind of a novelized memoir called The Thief's Journal that is really compelling reading. And there's a lyricism to his writing and kind of that same sort of unvarnished, like I'm just going to tell the truth as it is. You know, which was, so he was a writer in the, you know, 40s and 50s.

And so it was scandalous because, you know, he was writing about being a gay man, being arrested for having gay sex and being thrown into prison and having sex with the prisoners, you know? And, and was shocking at the time. And, you know, and then he lived a very long life. He became a playwright.

He received a pardon that was kind of a big deal at the time because, you know, like Pablo Picasso advocated for him to be pardoned from serving time in prison. Like, you know, I don't remember, like famous Parisian, I don't know, luminaries from the time that he was in. And you know, and then he went on to be a playwright and then he went on to be, you know, like he was a social justice advocate and, you know, kind of spoke on behalf of the Black Panthers and the civil rights movement and a fascinating person. And for Stun, I feel like is the kind of big personality and the kind of insightful writer that, again, I feel like we're seeing somebody famous on her rise, right, as she was beginning to find her voice.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Whatever Show?

This episode is 1 hour and 7 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Whatever Show episode published?

This episode was published on May 4, 2025.

Can I download this The Daily Whatever Show episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.