Skip to content
The Defense That Could Change Murder Trials episode artwork

Sep 2, 2026 29 min

The Defense That Could Change Murder Trials

from The Sean Hannity Show Hosted by Sean Hannity

With the Lindsay Clancy jury still unable to reach a unanimous verdict, Sean looks beyond this single case to what its outcome could mean for the criminal justice system. Nancy Grace and Tiffany Smiley debate intent, postpartum psychosis, personal responsibility, failures in mental-health care, and whether the defense strategy could become a model for future murder cases. The discussion centers on the difficult line between recognizing genuine mental illness and preserving accountability when innocent lives are lost.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Defense That Could Change Murder Trials

0:00 29:16
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Breaking story from Alpine News Network. Homeowners Tony and Janet needed to consolidate their debt. They called Alpine Credits. In a flash, an Alpine Credits superhero appeared in their kitchen. Using telekinesis, she consolidated their debt into one low monthly payment. She then used her powers to make the dirty dishes disappear forever. Own your home, need a loan. Alpine Credits can help. Alpine Credits, where homeowners get approved.

Hey, it's Drew Franklin from NFL Cover Zero. The 2026 season is underway and we are loving football on TV. Here's what you can expect from the podcast in our second season. I would suggest for these preseason games, I think they should do what they do on the NFL draft. You know, when coverage of the NFL draft is basically for moms and they're just like, hey, he has a dog named Spark. Listen to NFL Cover Zero on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.

All right, News Roundup and Information Overload Hour. Here's our toll-free telephone number. It's 800-941-SHAWN if you want to be a part of the program. All right, so all the developments now in the Lindsey Clancy case, you know, starting with the biggest sign and symptom of, you know, what's to be and what the judge said here. So the judge comes out early today, just to recap, tells the Lindsey Clancy juries that say that they cannot reach a unanimous verdict to go back in and start deliberating. And that was the beginning of our day.

I've got your question. And the question is, after many hours of deliberation, we are unable to come to a unanimous decision. I brought you back out because I know that this was a long trial. All right. I know there were over 80 witnesses. There were over 300 exhibits. And but because of that, I'm going to ask you to go back out, keeping in mind all the instructions I gave you to go out and to continue your deliberations at this time. All right. And so with that, I'm going to ask you to go back out. Like I said, keep in mind the instructions I gave you reviewing the evidence.

And I'd ask you to resume your deliberations at this time. OK, thank you. All right. Common occurrence, predictable result. And, you know, here we find ourselves. Where are we? I don't think this is going to be the end of cases like this. There was an article yesterday how I think this case was in North Carolina, how more and more attorneys are adopting, you know, this the same strategy defense that they watched in the case of our friend, Mr. Reddington, obviously is no fan of mine or of Nancy Grace's, which we went into great specificity and detail yesterday. And, you know, is that problematic?

Now, the reason that I think we need a recap of this and a reanalysis of this, because this is going to be something we're going to see and hear more and more of. I've never thought anybody that could admit to killing three people, let alone your own three children, is by definition sane. So not guilty by reason of insanity would be applicable in any case. Here to debate this, we have Nancy Grace, of course, with Crime Stories on Fox 1, and Tiffany Smiley, who is a Republican. A friend of the program, but took a very different position in terms of her analysis of this case. Thank you both for being here. But I think the overriding issues are going to be ones that we face for many, many decades to come, unfortunately, because I really have a problem with all of this. But Tiffany, I get it. You used to be a triage nurse. All my sisters were nurses. One worked extensively and for years in an emergency room situation. I get it. But at the end of the day, the question is about the law and the law was clear and the law was clear on if the prosecution, the burden was on them to prove intent, which I believe they meant that burden.

Yeah, well, look, Sean, I mean, she needs to be held accountable and justice absolutely needs to be served. And this case should not be taken as a free pass, right, for lawyers in the future in similar sort of cases. But there's a bigger overarching question that I've tried to ask is how do we make sure this does not happen again? I have worked in triage. I have worked in women's health emergency rooms. Our health care system is inundated with a mental health crisis. When I was working, it was nearly 15 years ago, and it was really bad then.

And it's worse now. And I have a lot of questions about this case. I have a lot of questions about women's health care and our assessment of it and our awareness of it and just the holistic approach of it. This woman clearly had postpartum depression, but I think the question needs to be asked, did she have it with her first child? And it got swept under the rug and she wasn't treated properly. And then it subsequently got worse. And then her home life was not a healthy situation. Maybe her caretakers didn't know how to address the issue. Maybe it's a health care breakdown, right, where she should have been institutionalized. This woman should not have been alone with her children.

And even though she was on copious amounts of drugs, only three in her system, Sean, we also know when you stop medications, they can have an adverse reaction. So where was the breakdown? And how do we make sure this never happens again? Because there are three innocent, beautiful souls that are now dead. And I think I told you last week that I anticipated it would be a hung jury. And we'll have to have a retry. And now how do we retry it with the public weighing in on this, the national attention that is now weighing in on this case? Will we get the real answers? And will we come to a place in this country where we either fix our medical system?

We understand postpartum depression and research and back women in it and make sure that this never, ever happens again. You know, Nancy, I think you and I are more on the same page in as much as, you know, we're supposed to believe after she plotted, schemed and planned this thing in its entirety and sent the husband out to go to the drugstore after calling the drugstore, which to me indicates premeditation, and then even called, you know, in the process or right after she's killing these three kids, that you cannot tell me that for that little window of time that this psychosis thing came into play. And then you add to that everything that she looked up in terms of the Internet.

in terms of her own illness, but, you know, how does one, with the carotid artery, and, you know, how do you slit somebody's throat, et cetera, et cetera. So I can understand. Also, you've got to look at the venue in any case, Nancy. You know this better than anybody as a victim's advocate, being a victim, and as a former prosecutor. The venue means everything. This happens in Massachusetts, in Plymouth. They don't have a single elected Republican in Washington from that entire state. That governor just signed into law an infanticide bill where a woman can have an abortion up to the moment of birth. I don't think you're getting, you know, many conservatives in that jury pool.

Well, I know one thing firsthand now. I know how Tiffany can give an amazing and mesmerizing speech. That was amazing, what you just said, and much of it. True. But that is not the issue that brings us here today. The issue today is...

Lindsay, Clancy, and what happened to her three children. Was she not guilty by reason of insanity at the time she murdered them? That she murdered them is not an issue. She and her lawyer say she did it. As much as internet conspiracy theorists would like to blame the husband, no, he had nothing to do with it.

She planned this starting early on. And when Tiffany asked, was she getting treatment? She was getting treatment. There were caregivers. There were babysitters. There were nannies. There were cleaners. Her own sister, a certified therapist that talked to her practically daily and did not think she should be hospitalized. The victim here is not Lindsay Clancy. The victims are Dawson, Callan, and Cora. Those are the victims. And we have lost sight of that in our big brouhaha about Lindsay Clancy.

We're forgetting the children. His necks were shrunken down to inches wide from the extreme ligature strangulation they endured face down in their basement at the hands of their mother. I hate to be harsh in this manner when I don't. If I don't have to be, this is something I would say to convince the jury. But the reality is they died a horrific and painful death. And she planned it. No one wants to accept that because we don't like to think of a mother killing her children. We deem, she must be crazy. Well, she wasn't. And it'll be a cold day in H-E-double-L from what I know about psychosis, which...

Medical experts have told me, it's like, when you have a stroke, you really don't know what happened. You've seen those anchors on TV and they don't make any sense. They're looking around. They're having a stroke. They don't know what they're doing. They have no memory. That's what psychosis is. It's not postpartum depression. It is a break from reality. And you cannot tell me that she hears a voice for the first and last time. The moment her husband slams the door, kill your children, she does it. And in less than an hour, he's back. They're dead. And the voice is never heard again. N-O. Tiffany?

Yeah, well, look, you know, the prosecution went for a first-degree murder, right? And they obviously had a very hard time trying to prove that, as evidenced by what we are seeing with a potential hung jury. How were they going to, I think it's like, how would they prove that a sane, rational mother would do the most unrational thing imaginable? But Tiffany, if I may just interject, and then I want you to pick up where you are. Okay. If anybody commits murder, by definition, aren't they kind of insane? Don't you have to be insane? There's something really wrong with a person in cold blood that can kill anybody? Yes. But this is a woman who was in so much pain and torment.

that her only option out in this life was to kill her children and kill herself. Slow down. Her only option. That in her mind. So human beings then, by definition, is what you're saying, have no control over their behavior at the end of the day because by definition, somebody that will murder another person is insane. By definition. In her mind, at that time, that was clearly her only option to end. But isn't that every killer? Couldn't it be used in every case? You're talking about...

a woman who documented that she was having postpartum issues, documenting that she had issues, going to the doctor, getting medication. So a premeditated murder, as long as you document that you're feeling A, B, C, D, E, and F, and look up the right things ahead of time, if you're that evil and sinister, you can use the same defense and you should get, you know, a result that would be favorable for you. Is that what you're saying? Evil, it's sick, and it should never happen again. But there is a reason that the prosecution, what I'm saying... But should there be consequences? In other words, or are we determining here that...

That people have no control over their own behavior and there's no individual responsibility. He clearly had it. Sean, she will be held accountable and she will be. My whole point, and you know... Massachusetts. Okay. Good luck with that. We should start a pool when she'll be out. Or she'll be in an institution for the rest of her life outside of public and living... You mean like John Hinckley who attempted to kill Ronald Reagan?

It's torturous, and she has to face these consequences, and she will. I guess what I'm trying to say is the prosecution is trying to prove to these jurors first-degree murder, and it's clear that they had a hard time. You know, a couple weeks ago, I was speaking with a legal analyst, and there were five of us in the group. Each of us approached this case from a different perspective, and we said right then and there, I guarantee you, it will be a hung jury. Well, I mean, the reality is the judge threw them, as we discussed earlier, this lifeline again and again, which gave them the other options. Nancy, I'm worried that, you know, by definition, if somebody now is devious and evil enough, and I think you have to be evil to kill somebody,

that if they just chronicle it properly and look up the right terms on the internet, that this defense is going to be used over and over again. It will be. And the fact that we're hearing she will be held accountable because she will be held accountable. That's what we call the law, not a secretary. It doesn't follow. It doesn't make sense. Let me point out, we always hear about Andrea Yates, how she still wants to wait. Well, what about Deanna Laney? She bludgeoned her two boys dead, left the other, the baby, with permanent brain damage and vision problems. She was behind bars in a mental facility for a period of about five to seven years and is walking free amongst us right now. You pointed out Hinkley. So I don't call that accountable. There are three coffins, three dead people, sentenced.

to that coffin from now on. And she has the ability to walk free. Do I feel sorry for what Lindsey Clancy has endured? Yes, I do. Her children are gone. I don't think you can do anything worse to me than take away my children. They're gone and at her own hand. And she has to live with that forever in her own prison cell in her mind. But though I feel sorry for her, the law is clear. The law is clear. There was intent. She performed the act and she needs to go to jail for life. Period. The end.

No, that won't happen. 800-941-SHAWN, our number if you want to be a part of the program. This debate is too important. Moving forward, the impact of all of this, I think the consequences are going to be more severe than we're anticipating even today. And I think that we're going to see case after case after case emerge with a lot of similarities. I hope I'm wrong. All right, quick break. Right back. We'll continue straight ahead. 800-941-SHAWN is our number.

Breaking story from Alpine News Network. John had a brilliant idea for a startup to turn children's artwork into toys. He called Alpine Credits for a home equity loan. His loan was approved, and a superhero was sent over to assist John with his business needs. Her superpower isn't just home equity loans. It's helping people realize their dreams. She can also run so fast her shoes melt. Own your home. Need a loan? Alpine Credits can help. Alpine Credits, where homeowners get approved.

Football's back. Hey, it's Drew Franklin from NFL Cover Zero. Enjoy the NFL season while listening to NFL Cover Zero. We have storylines, predictions, and lots of silliness. Here's what you can expect from the podcast in our second season. When you meet people and you say your job's a sports announcer, it's always interesting to see what the first thing they say is. I did have one of the more difficult questions, though. He sits next to me and he sees I'm on my computer and he goes, big sports fan. And I was like, yeah, actually. And he goes, we think about my Jaguars this year. I realized like no one's ever asked me that question ever about anything. And I was like.

Listen to NFL Cover Zero on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. All right, so the jury, quickly to recap, couldn't reach a verdict, told the unanimous verdict, told the judge. The judge asked them to continue deliberations. They did so for many hours today, and they have now convened for the day. But we continue. This is going to have long-term ramifications. And here to discuss both sides of it, Nancy Grace, we continue with her and with Tiffany Smiley. By the way, I want to reiterate something I said yesterday on both radio and TV about Nancy Grace.

Because Nancy Grace was attacked by Lindsay Clancy's attorney, Kevin Reddington, as I was attacked. But she was attacked more viciously than me. and the queen of mean and you know for those that never got a chance to watch my podcast with nancy please watch it you know wherever you get your video podcast because we go into great detail and specificity how her entire life and her life's trajectory was altered uh because she was 19 years old and her fiance was murdered um i don't think she ever planned to be a victim's advocate the way she's become or as passionate about these issues as she is um but for this guy to make these attacks when she is not only a victim of a horrible crime herself but has spent decades of her life being a prosecutor and a victim's advocate, I just think is vile, uncalled for, and obviously he doesn't know or care about who Nancy Grace really is. And, you know, the more I thought about this, the more angry I get. I don't care when people attack me, but when they attack my friends, it really bothers me, Nancy. And let me play this for example. It's been obviously a long weekend, okay? You're all journalists, reporters, news media, and this weekend has been horrific with the coverage.

And by that, I mean Mr. Hannity with his men discussing every little inch of Lindsay's symptoms and criticizing Nancy Grace, the queen of phrase, the queen of mean. who misrepresents facts. I challenge Nancy Grace to show us where Lindsay Clancy ever said, ever Googled how to kill words that came out of her mouth. And these things hurt. We have had a total of seven women, many of them, including our two guests, Tiffany Smiley and Nancy Grace, on my TV show and on this radio show, talking about this case, me and my men. He obviously just is wrong. I don't know how you interpret this, how to slit your throat to die.

I don't know how you may interpret it, but I interpret that as somebody looking for weight. Can you turn airbags off on a Kia Sorento? Of course, planning out, mapping out, timing out. Visa searches on Apple Maps to allegedly calculate the driving times and the distance to the pharmacy that she purposely sent her husband on a trip to. CVS Pharmacy, kids, Miralax. That to me shows intent and shows premeditation. That's my humble opinion. I'm allowed to have an opinion. What is the carotid artery? Oh, why would somebody want to know what a carotid artery is?

You would think a nurse would know that, but that's separate and apart. But Nancy, I just wanted to say that I thought this was vile, unfair, untrue. And it bothers me, especially you described to me, you went down to 80 pounds when you were 19 years old after your fiance was murdered. And that you almost didn't survive this. And it altered your life in ways that you didn't date for decades until you met the love of your life, your current husband, and have these two beautiful children. And for him to say that is so over the top and beyond the pale to me. Yes, Sean, I try.

And it's hard not to think back on that time because I can slip back into a major depression. And I have children to think of now. And yes, they're growing up, but they still need their mother. And I cannot be part of a severe depression that I can't get out of. It's just very dangerous for me to even consider it. But what you said is true. I lost down to 89 pounds, relationships, other people. Nothing meant anything to me.

I hate to even remember it. I remember I had my mother turn off all the TVs and the stereo. I couldn't stand here. I couldn't even stand here. The clock ticking. You had to stop the clock. I couldn't take it. My plan to be an English Shakespearean literature professor ended. I didn't know what I was going to do until I decided to go to law school to help other crime victims. That was the first time I had ever been in a courthouse to be a witness at Keith's murder trial. And I will never forget it as long as I live.

And in this case, I am not made of stone. I believe that Lindsay Clancy had depression. I don't know what demon she was finding, but as an officer of the court for crime victims, I have to tell it like it is. Ann Redington, or anybody else can hate me. I've had a string of defense attorneys hate me. From what I understand, they were dancing in the halls at the public defender's office when I left to go to court TV. So, fine. Hate me. I can't say I don't care, but I can't afford to care. I can't let anything stop me from telling the truth, and the truth is she had intent.

Reddington attacked me saying she did not Google how to kill. Specifically, she Googled how to slit your throat to die. Can you turn off airbags in the key at Sorrento? Can you treat a sociopath? She, as you said, Apple mapped her husband's route that she sent him on to determine exactly how long she would have to kill the children. Can you treat a sociopath?

She looked up symptoms that she later had, hallucinations, bipolar, psychosis symptoms, intrusive thoughts, and so much more. It all equals intent. The children are dead. They suffered a horrific death. I can't bring myself to describe again what happened to their little necks once those exercise bands were removed. They were pulled so tightly. It's horrific. That's what's horrific. This is the problem I have with the whole system, Tiffany, at the end of the day.

And that is there's so much surrounding this. And, you know, there's a lot of people out there with a lot of problems in life. I'm not disputing, you know, your medical background. I'm not disputing we should look at broader issues. I don't think that the answer is ever going to be found in any government run health care system or any system. The system failed or the doctors failed or the drugs failed. And then the worst part to me was when this attorney, Mr. Reddington, came out and said, you know, in closing arguments that the soul of this woman, meaning his client, Lindsay Clancy.

The soul of this client was ripped from her by these prosecutors in this case. Prosecutors are trying to bring, what about the souls of the three children? I mean, I felt that on his end was completely heartless, distant, out of touch, out of step with the full actions of his client. Yeah, I mean, this case is horrific. I hate that we're even having to talk about it, that it even happened that these three beautiful babies are gone, souls gone from this earth. And quite frankly, their mother didn't even want to be alive either. She wished she was dead.

And I would hope that we could be better. I would hope that we could say that this would never happen again. I would hope that our medical system could improve in this country. We are one of the most medicated people on earth in this country. And we clearly are missing the mark. I think I mentioned to you that I was working in triage when Obamacare rolled down, and we were forced to see more patients with less time. When you're talking about women and women's health care, that is not a good thing. That doesn't equal good outcomes for anyone. And if now we're just a society where we push meds and say, go out the door, you'll be fine, that's not good either. And so I guess my overarching view of this case is I haven't just picked aside and argued that until the day is gone, but trying to have this conversation and saying, where did the breakdown happen?

Clearly, this woman has demons. And like I mentioned earlier, felt that the only option in her life was to kill her children and herself. Let's ask how we got there. Can I ask you this? Shouldn't that question be asked in every murder case? Yeah.

Okay, and if it is, can't you come to a conclusion or, you know, following that logic, can't you say this individual, he was crying out for help, this individual when the person in the murder was young, he used to kill cats and dogs and birds, and that was an indication and nobody intervened and the system failed this person, etc. I mean, there's no end to this. At what point does the concept and belief in individual personal responsibility come into play? Yes, that clearly exists, but she was having... issues and postpartum issues. And I think that's.

That's where the prosecution had a hard time presenting the first degree murder is that there's just not enough known about it. People are scared of it. People don't maybe our medical system. You're only applying it to this case. And I'm arguing that it's much broader than that. By definition, you kill somebody, you're off. You're not well. Agreed. Agreed. OK, so then it should be applicable on it. You know, we can go into the past of every single murderer and we're going to come up with stuff, warning signs, people that should have known the system that broke down. I mean, at the end of the day, there's still evil in the heart of that person.

Yes, but if she was in a mental psychosis place that just continued to get worse and didn't have the adequate treatment or should have been institutionalized, she was institutionalized and then she was released. Why was that issue there? Well, I mean, at the end of the day, this is also somebody that should have had knowledge. In other words, if you're a nurse and you're documenting with copious notes all the medications that you're taking when you're taking them, you know, there's a certain intellectual knowledge that you would expect any person that's in that position to apply. I mean, I'm sure as a nurse, you know, you know about medications.

So, I mean, it gets rather complicated. Look, I appreciate the thoughtful hour that we've spent on this because I think that this is not going away. I think that we are going to hear one Lindsey, we'll refer to it as the Lindsey Clancy defense moving forward, one after another. And as far as, you know, a system that is going to allow this person to ever walk the streets, that to me is a massive, massive flaw in the system of justice. Justice has to be served. There will be no long-term justice, in my view, for those three children that were strangled to death.

But I do appreciate the thoughtful debate. Tiffany, I prefer when we usually agree. Nancy Grace, our love and prayers to you. I know this actually probably, unfortunately, brings back very, very painful memories in your life. And for that, I apologize. And you did not deserve what this defense attorney said about you. And for that, I'm sorry, too.

All right, that's going to wrap things up for today. Great Hannity tonight, 9 Eastern on the Fox News Channel. First of all, the jury tells the judge they can't come to a unanimous verdict in the Lindsey Clancy trial. He says go back to deliberations. They did so for hours. They have convened for the day. How do you interpret that? We'll have full analysis. Nancy Grace and others. John Fetterman is on tonight. Scott Besson is on tonight. Tommy Lahren is on tonight. I mean, I promise you, news you'll never get from the state-run abusively corrupt legacy media mob. 9 Eastern on Hannity. Set your DVR. We'll see you tonight. Back here tomorrow. Thank you for making the show possible.

Hey, it's Drew Franklin from NFL Cover Zero. The 2026 season is underway and we are loving football on TV. Here's what you can expect from the podcast in our second season. I would suggest for these preseason games, I think they should do what they do on the NFL draft. You know, when coverage of the NFL draft is basically for moms and they're just like, hey, he has a dog named Spark. Listen to NFL Cover Zero on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Sean Hannity Show?

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this The Sean Hannity Show episode published?

This episode was published on September 2, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Sean Hannity Show episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.