Skip to content
The Facebook Files episode artwork

Nov 4, 2021 33 min

The Facebook Files

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

Over the past few weeks, a series of drip-fed leaks have further tarnished the Facebook brand in the US. Regulation seems unavoidable but is it too little too late to put the misinformation back in the bottle? This week, Prue Clarke is joined by Ben Smith from The New York Times and Sacha Molitorisz from the Centre for Media Transition to discuss Frances Haugen's rollout strategy and the international effort to regulate social media.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Facebook Files

0:00 33:16
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my car doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.

That's how we protect Ontario for all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario. Your summer travels deserve an upgrade.

With Select Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, and Cadillac vehicles connected by OnStar, you can stream, game, and more all the go. Whether you're headed to a music festival or a cottage getaway, you can access hundreds of apps on Google Play right from your center display. Explore OnStar Tech Today at OnStar.ca and discover how to take your summer to the next level. OnStar, Better Never Stops.

Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Prue Clark. October 2021 may go down as a turning point in Facebook's 18-year history.

It's myriad critics hope it will mark the beginning of the end of Facebook as we know it. Twenty media outlets in the US and Europe now have access to the leaked documents known as the Facebook Papers, yielding dozens of revelations a day about how leaders knew about disinformation, incitement, and illegal acts on its platforms and did nothing to stop them. At the same time, they cowed to the demands of repressive regimes. The leaks themselves have been a big part of the story, orchestrated by former Facebook employee Francis Hagen.

Just as Hagen hoped, the leaks have pushed the US Congress closer than ever to tough regulation of the industry. To discuss the repercussions of any regulation for Australian media, we'll be joined a little later by lecturer in law and media, Sasha Molotores. But first, a chronicler of the Facebook leaks in the US, New York Times media columnist Ben Smith. Welcome back to the show, Ben.

Thank you for having me. So for an audience that's not in the US and really steeped in what's going on there at the moment, can you give us a sense of just how big this Facebook story is there? Well, I mean, it depends how you measure it. It's a big story.

Lots of journalists have been writing many, many things about it. I wouldn't say that the public is paying a ton of attention. I think people have come to basically expect the worst of Facebook and whether they care or not has kind of been priced into the market. Yeah, well, that would explain the share price is still going up.

Yeah, and also the literal market seems not to care very much. What we're talking about here is the Wall Street Journal called the Facebook files instead of leaked documents that kind of give a lot of insight into how Facebook has handled on other things content moderation. There are not brand new revelations in these documents. There's more, just much more deeply textured sense of the kind of trade-offs Facebook is making.

Including these cowing to regimes, which I imagine that must be surprising to some of the audience. You know, I don't know. I mean, I don't think it was surprising to me. One of the real lessons of the last few years, I think, has been that the internet is, in fact, a bunch of data on a set of servers that are located somewhere that national governments have basically retaken power, increasingly over their internet for better and for worse.

You've written about this age of mega-liques starting with WikiLeaks and Edward Snowden's leaks and other Panama Papers and Pandora Papers, but this whistle of Blower, Francis Haugen, has played this a bit differently. Can you talk about that? Yeah, I think that if you are a whistleblower, if you're somebody inside a government institution or inside a company with a bunch of fairly complex secrets, there is this tough question of what do you do? You can dump it all online, but I think we've seen that just a bunch of undifferentiated data that can be spun, can be misinterpreted, can be taken to mean whatever people want it to mean.

I think that the first two whistleblowers, Edward Snowden, first among them, have sought to go to sophisticated, sympathetic journalists who can voucher and interpret the documents, but then you have a situation which only a few people have access to them. I think what Haugen has tried to do here is get the best of both worlds in terms of first giving these documents to the Wall Street Journal with a long lead time, and they're just sensing which they're sort of artisanal, boutique, roll out, including this very flattering podcast featuring her, and then essentially open an information outlet ball of the suburbs which lots and lots of journalists, again, pre-selected, but maybe 30 journalists for more than 15 outlets were able to root around among all the stuff that the journal had essentially either already written about or turned down, generate another wave of stories, I think her goal is to keep kind of running that circle. And she had these financial backers? Well, she initially did not.

I mean, I think she did this, it seems very much on her own with the help of a nonprofit group called Whistleblore Aid. It's a pretty low profile and legally focused nonprofit. After the journal had begun publishing, obviously a lot of people who are sympathetic to her kind of rally to her side, including in particular some groups that are funded by Pierre O'Majar, who's a billionaire who was one of the founders of eBay, and they've been helping her on the margin, paying for her travel and stuff like that and for maybe her legal defense. One interesting thing that she told me was that she's not accepting any personal financial support or taking any money from anybody because she had invested in crypto at a good time and seems to be living in Puerto Rico on her crypto winnings.

Did you do, do you, diligence on her? Do you think the others did a good job of that? I think that the journal's conclusion, which I sort of think was the right call, was that she doesn't matter very much. And this is her own perspective too.

She delivered a huge cash of documents, most of which she doesn't really know much more about than that you were at. There were documents that she was able to copy from Facebook's very open internal systems, but almost entirely the projects that she did not work on. I think her point of view is her motives don't really matter. She doesn't really matter in the story.

She's an interesting head of side story, but they don't really need a lot of documents to take whatever they want from them. They're free to kind of disagree with her interpretation of the documents. So the journalist inside the consortium have complained about being managed by her. Do you think that's fair?

Nobody complained to me about that. If they have been complaining about it, I don't think she's particularly tried to control the story beyond her own story and beyond just putting the documents out in the first list. Just the fact that she first gave them to the journal and then obviously she didn't give them a heads up that she was going to a broader audience. You know, she's dictating it.

Yeah, the journal was a little bit unhappy that she did decide to kind of run that circle, but you know, she'd also given them a dozen really amazing stories. I don't think they have too many complaints. All right. Are they dangerous?

Do you think the journalist should be aware of in reporting these leaks? I do think that there's this situation in which the leaker sort of becomes your assignment editor and it is worth trying to understand their motives. I do think you have these anonymous leakers, notably WikiLeaks, but also something in actually called DC Leaks that the US government at least believes was basically Russian intelligence. And they were essentially studying the news agenda for American journalists.

And I do think that, I mean, if you think about the DNC hack and the WikiLeaks release with those in the end, the bigger story was that there was this incredible Russian intelligence operation. That was a bigger story than anything that's actually in the leaks, which weren't that interesting. Journalists need to be really careful about this stuff. It can't be the end of these leaks.

I mean, just there must be other whistleblowers out there watching and amazing what she was able to document. Yeah, it's gotten much easier. And actually, you know, working from home is a big part of this, but it's gotten much easier to digitally reproducing. I think you're just taking photographs of her screen, basically.

But I don't know how exactly she did it. You know, whether Facebook's security might have noticed that this employee was looking at a lot of pages or what I do think there's both an enormous amount of opportunity for people these days and also more and more surveillance of employees to try to deter them from doing this kind of thing. And then finally, I think the tech industry, particularly has very open culture where thousands of thousands of people can see internal documents that a lot of companies would consider very sensitive. And I think that that is starting to close down.

I think that these companies are starting to basically see the risk of this kind of leak as too great. We talked about it hasn't really impacted the share price, but it has, we've seen some Facebook self-regulation of abandoning this facial recognition technology that was causing so many problems. Is this approach that she's taken? What needs to happen to actually cause change now that we've become so desensitized to the idea of Facebook and the damage it does?

I'm not sure. I don't think these companies are going to be wished away. They have huge reach and traction on the advertising industry, among other things, and on people's attention. Facebook is a monopoly, is fading of it.

One of the interesting revelations for these leaks is how Panek Facebook is about TikTok. She doesn't feel like a monopoly on the inside. It feels like a company who's central product, this blue Facebook app is really threatened through their making fairly desperate decisions to try to keep it alive and keep it growing in an environment where the social networks can kind of go. But they also have an enormous amount of capital and incredible business.

I think they're not going anywhere. Congress looks like they're taking regulation much more seriously as a result of this, or at the same time as this. You're not just a media observer, you were actually on the call face with Buzzfeed as the founding editor in chief. Do you think regulation is likely now and what sort of regulation is most likely?

The main sort of form of regulation that's essentially already in place is a tightening of antitrust practices in the US. I think Facebook did a lot of key growth requisitions through seeing potential competitors like Instagram and what's that and buying them before they can threaten them. They're basically no longer able to do that. Regulators are not going to let them do that.

I think the United States Congress is not particularly functional. It's unclear what if any action they'll take Apple in a strange way has become the central internet regulator. Obviously, it's also a competitor. But Apple's cracked down on certain kinds of tracking of advertising data.

Is a real threat to Facebook and has really impacted their business. We saw in the links that they threatened to ban Instagram for it being involved in selling a domestic servants in the Middle East. Yeah, that's right. Apple, by the way, is also self-entertizing.

I think they're a competitive voters of later as well. But I think that they're a lot of different players in the ecosystem. I'm not sure the United States government is likely to be the first actor. I think you saw the Australian government really push Facebook on news in a way that essentially spread back to the United States.

I think the Europeans are also putting a lot of pressure on them. We've heard a lot of talk about repeal of section 230, which means the platforms would be responsible for what's published there. You don't think that's likely? It's not really clear to me why people want that.

But it does not accomplish the thing that I think some people want, which is to prevent content they don't like from going viral. And it also would essentially end the internet as we know. And I think that Twitter had to pre-review every one of your tweets to make sure that you weren't liable in somebody. They would not tweet, which wouldn't exist.

And I don't think that's even what the people who are calling for the repeal of it want. So I think when Frances Hogan, the late Facebook leader, wants, and she has her own peculiar set of politics basically. But her point of view is that the way things spread out, the rhythmically, is the problem. Not the question of what you post, but the question of how it spreads, which is totally independent.

There's nothing to do with section 230. But a lot of calls in the US to say that you should not be able to write on the internet if the word's Donald Trump really won the election. The question is, should companies then amplify that message? And what are the mechanisms through which it's amplified and how is that monitored?

I can imagine media houses would like to level a playing field on this one. I mean, in Australia, the courts have ruled that media houses are responsible for the comments posted on their Facebook pages. And the media would be an attractive outcome, I imagine. They are competitive industries.

And I think often, particularly the extent that Facebook's advertising business can be dented. The media industry hope is that money comes back to the media. How about algorithm transparency? I think that's really interesting.

I think that a lot of these conversations that sound like they're about speech and censorship, the more interesting conversation is what is spreading inside these platforms and why, particularly when it's not that they are showing you things that your friends shared, but that they're showing you things that they are just sort of guessing that you're going to like, that's really a black box. That's, you know, in some sense, their secret sauce is proprietary and it's something that they are very focused on keeping as is, for instance, TikTok. But also that, I think, is the place where regulators and citizens have a lot of interest. Absolutely.

And especially these issues of privacy and safety for children? Yeah. in every political fight when you can start saying, think about the children, it's a huge advantage. And there is this very disturbing internal research on the relationship with some young girls of Instagram to eating disorders.

But this was Facebook's not peer reviewed, not particularly deep internal research. And I do think that there are some real questions about it. In particular, at least in the United States, the issue of young women struggling with eating disorders around the images that were in magazines, for instance, is not a new issue. And I think this is sort of emblematic of a lot of the questions around Facebook, which is, would there be right-wing populism in the world without Facebook?

Would girls have eating disorders without Facebook? Obviously, yes. And the question is, what is the impact? Is it amplifying it?

Is it the impact that people wear? Is this stuff is playing out? Or is it something that the answer's got to be some of both? But I think just entangling those things is really hard and important.

Have you met Mark Zuckerberg? Yes. What's your take on what's motivating him, resisting making the changes, or some of the changes that are being demanded? I mean, I don't know him well, and don't have deep psychological insight.

I mean, I do think he's someone who has ignored the haters through the years and from his point of view, and ignored conventional wisdom, and become one of the richest, most powerful men in the world by doing that. And it's just personally, totally totally, totally identified with this company. He controls the voting shares. The information this publication asked recently, he would consider stepping down and he said no.

He controls the company. But this is the kind of situation in which, for instance, Microsoft, a new CEO came in. And I think the fact that the company is so deeply identified with Zuckerberg and that he's irreplaceable, sort of intensifies this criticism, I think means that it's unlikely to stop anytime soon. I've heard talk of him being punted upstairs to the president position.

Do you think it's likely? Sure, it's his company, and they could reshuffle the deck, too, so I think there's no real question about his charge. All right, thank you so much for joining us, Ben. Thank you.

Joining me now is Sasha Molotaurus, a lecturer in law and media, and my colleague at the Center for Media Transition at the University of Technology. Welcome to the show, Sasha. Hi, bro. Thanks for having me.

So Ben Smith might be a bit skeptical about regulation happening in US Congress, but a lot of other people think this is the moment that it's going to happen. And it raises this puzzle of what happens with such an international organization. I mean, so much of what's come out of the Facebook papers has been, things that have been happening in places like the Philippines or Myanmar, the Middle East, Africa. How does regulation in a US context play out across the world?

Yeah, that's a great question. And let me start by saying that I don't think regulation is the answer to all the yields that affect us. Regulation has an important role to play, but it won't fix everything. But in this space, we certainly need more regulation because there's been so little, digital platforms are largely unregulated.

And if we're talking about digital platforms, these are the news media, you just got this complete contrast. When news media are very heavily regulated, particularly in Australia, and digital platforms are not. But to your question about the international context, that is a real difficulty when it comes to regulation. You're talking with Ben about Section 230, what impact does that have on Australia?

Or if we're talking about something like privacy, which is an area that I've researched, you've got in Australia a current law reform process going on into privacy law. Over in Europe, you've had a new privacy law since 2018, which is very effective to some extent, but to not enforce enough. In the US, you've got to talk about, let's bring in a federal law. You've got all these differences.

To that, I would say, yes, there are these differences from jurisdictions and jurisdiction, but that's okay. We can have that. We can have an internet that is bound by different privacy laws in different countries, by different arrangements between digital platforms and using a year in different countries. And it can work.

Over time, we're going to work out how it can work, but we can do it. So if there were a repeal of 230, which I think a lot of people think is highly unlikely. And Ben said would actually just break the business model of the digital platforms. If they found some way to make the digital platforms responsible for what's published on their platforms, how do you think that would play out in Australia?

Well, I agree with Ben. Section 230, very unlikely that it will be repealed. Section 230 of the communications decency act. I don't think there's that political will.

I disagree that it would break the internet. I think that's hyperbole. The repeal of section 230 would change things. Yes, it would make digital platforms like Twitter or Facebook have a degree of responsibility for what appears on their platforms.

But I don't think it would mean the internet suddenly cracks in half and we can't use it anymore. A workable solution would be found. And if I can go a bit further with that point, I think digital platforms need to have some responsibility. Regulators need to impose some sort of responsibility onto it on Facebook, on digital platforms, for the content that appears on them.

But I don't think that should be the same responsibilities that a publisher has. So this is the position that we've taken at the Center for Media Transition, which we're still refining. And it's not unique to us. A lot of researchers agree with this.

Let's think about digital platforms in some other categories, maybe as distributors of news, as intermediaries in some other category. And that category will recognise that they play a crucial role in the information space and the news media space. And it will give them certain responsibilities and certain benefits as well. But yet, I certainly can't and shouldn't go completely unregulated and unrecognised by the law in that important space.

So what areas would you see them needing to be regulated? I mean, you know, in the excitement of violence or hate speech, that you know, what sort of areas? Absolutely. Look, there's a lot.

There's a long list. I guess the starting point there is that all these fields are interconnected, you know, incitement to hate misinformation, abuse of privacy, there are two connections between all of these areas, which are not immediately obvious. So what would we regulate? I think there are a lot of things that need to be done.

You were talking about algorithmic transparency with Ben. I think that's a really important place to start. Digital platforms just don't want any sort of algorithmic transparency. They don't want any regulation of algorithms.

But I think that's where it gets really interesting and important. What sort of content is surfacing? Is brought to the surface on people's news feeds on Facebook? How does Google search work in a more transparent way?

Now, with that, I don't mean that Google or Facebook need to reveal exactly all the workings of their algorithms that would be going too far. And it would also be in some ways meaningless. You know, we'd be looking at all sorts of data that regulators wouldn't understand, users wouldn't understand. But I think there is some degree of algorithmic oversight that is necessary so that we can understand how misinformation is circulating, what sort of misinformation is circulating, what sort of data is being used as an input?

Are there abuses of personal data happening? A lot of these goes back to questions of privacy and data, and the sort of inputs that digital platforms are using to feed their algorithms, to come up with the recommendations that they make and the content of services. So I really do think that some degree of algorithmic transparency and oversight is really important. But there's a whole lot of other things.

You know, I mentioned privacy and data law. I think that area of reform is really important and really tricky. You know, in a sense, that's the source of a lot of these issues, that we get some sort of checks on how data is being shared between companies, how it's being sold, how it's being used in backgrounds in ways that aren't obvious to users and ways that users haven't consented to. Right, so there's regulation of data and privacy is really important.

Ben mentioned antitrust. I think antitrust is a really important way to think about these issues as well. We need to think about whether any of these companies have too much power. You know, there's the core case that's been initiated in the US by a dozen US states in that direction.

And the ACCC also, in September, it released its report into AdTech. So antitrust is another regulatory mechanism that's really potentially powerful. And lastly, I've mentioned the news media bargaining code, which gets much more lines, but I think actually is a really important piece of law that tries to strike some sort of deal, recognizing that digital platforms get the benefits of news content and news media businesses are not getting what they deserve to get from digital platforms for the use of that content. So there are a number of ways of regulating a number of these in train at the moment.

They've been developed, as Ben said, you know, in some places with Australia leading the way because America might be wanting to wait and see what other jurisdictions do. This is all going on at the moment, and there's a lot that can be done. And quite frankly, we need to move in this way, it's high time that we had some good regulation passed to get a better public sphere. That's what we're talking about, you know, which ultimately then will give us a better democracy and a better society.

You've talked about the fact that these regulators are actually working together. Is that unusual? As far as I understand, you know, antitrust law is a sub-minor my expertise, but as the ACCC engaged in its digital platforms inquiry, it was very explicit that it was talking to regulators overseas and it was seeing what actions they were taking, what have they done that it worked, what hadn't worked, regulators in Europe, regulators in the US, they were all talking to each other. And I think that's a really good approach.

You know, we started talking by acknowledging the international nature of the internet. And I think the only way this regulation can be successful, all these various bits of regulation, to be honest, is by taking notice of what's happening in different countries. And then having something about maybe not a united front from governments around the world, but at least on a lined front, so that they can work alongside each other to give us the sort of internet that we want, that is a positive, the best internet we can have or at least a much better internet than we currently have. Bringing this back to the media, it's very clear that all of these issues are interconnected for the media, business for what media can publish, from competition with digital platforms.

I think the most visceral case for Australia media was the Volocase, which gave digital platforms immunity from defamation cases. Can you talk a bit about that and how it would appeal if 230 might impact that? Yeah, look, I think I touched a question earlier about what 230 would mean for Australia. So I'll answer both of these together.

If 230 does get abolished, so that's Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, it won't have any direct impact for Australia, but it would be a flow on impact. The digital platforms are all housed in the US, that's where they construct themselves and they abide by US law, and that would flow onto Australia. The sort of platforms that we get in Australia would definitely be impacted by that. Now in Australia, that Voloc, judgment that you mentioned, is a really significant judgment.

So it's a defamation judgment that says that a news company is liable for indefamation, for any debaumetry comments made underneath that news article. And Facebook has no liability, for instance. Intuitively, it does set the bar pretty high for news media businesses, and I would argue it's that's far too high. It makes news media businesses too open to defamation claims.

And just this week, I was reading about some lawyers contacting some Facebook page administrators to remove certain posts because they were vulnerable to defamation. Defamation laws are definitely such that news media businesses are in a risky situation. And we've seen CNN pull some of their news stories and I think they're news content from Australia. So they're responding in that way.

At the moment, there are forms underway, but at the moment news media businesses are in a bit of a tricky spot here. We hear this news that Facebook has abandoned plans to use its facial recognition and deleted imprints, facial imprints across the platform. Can you talk a bit more about that? Absolutely.

Look, obviously Facebook is on the back foot and they want to be seen to be acting in a whole bunch of these places to get ahead of regulation. And this to me is a part of that. They just want to be seen to be doing the right thing. I mean, this to me is the right thing to do.

Whether Facebook will be doing it for good motives of helping the world or whether it's actually a business decision if you're in a simple, I'm not sure. Can you explain a bit about what it actually meant for a Facebook user? Well, facial recognition is used in simple terms of people to unlock their phone. It's been used in all sorts of other ways.

There was a really big case actually that didn't get much press. There was only finally decided earlier this year and it led to a payout of about $650 million from Facebook to people in the US and the state of Illinois in particular for the use of facial recognition and the way that facial recognition led to people being tagged in photographs without those people ever consenting. But this facial recognition technology has, it's incredibly powerful. Your face gets stored on a server and then can be linked to footage many years later, video footage or photos, take them many years later.

I think of how we can now go back using facial recognition technology and see where people were and use locations so retrospectively, to pinpoint where people were and what they were doing. Facial recognition is really powerful, potentially really dangerous, open to abuse. We can think of all sorts of human rights abuses identifying people that we're talking about countries that are not democratic and that oppress human rights activists. You can think of all sorts of unjust ways that facial recognition is used.

And we know also that facial recognition has some really inherent problems with bias. The data sets that it's been trained on don't recognize people of color as well as white people, don't recognize women as well as men and so on. So all these biases have a tendency to perpetuate or exacerbate these inequities that we have already. Okay, so back to the regulation point.

I think Facebook is doing the right thing, such responding by shutting down a facial recognition system and deleting a billion face prints. I think that is a good thing for Facebook to do the right thing for them to do. And I think ultimately it's them getting ahead of this regulatory wave that they see coming, trying to get out in front by doing the right thing. And crucially, it's in that data space that I mentioned, where data to me is really the source of a lot of these issues.

It's kind of the first issue because without the data, these companies can't operate. That's what they use to operate. There's been an argument that they've been avoiding self-regulation because they didn't know what was coming and they didn't want to do more than they had to obviously. But do you think this will work?

Will this actually nullify regulators? Possibly. We can't underestimate the power of these digital platforms. They're incredibly powerful.

Because they're so profitable. They're so vegan profitable. One of the fallacies that emerged through the news media bargaining process, and this line I've heard a few times, is that the Australian government bullied Facebook and Google. That's absurd.

The Australian government exists to pass laws that it thinks are good laws that adjust laws for your laws. And in this case, that was to fix an unfet value exchange. The bullies in that case were Google and Facebook. They behaved like classic bullies.

Facebook actually took news off its platform for a week, right at the crunch time in February 2021. So one thing we can't underestimate here is the political clout and the lobbying power of these digital platforms were very powerful. Apart from whether it's right or wrong, I think it's right. This spatial recognition decision is a very strategic decision in the context of everything that's going on with regulators around the world.

And yes, I think in some cases it probably will modify some regulators. But hopefully it doesn't. Because the regulators just need to look at the actual issues in front of them and address those by making some good, sensible, fair, powerful laws. The bottom line for me is that, at the moment, we just have an internet where there are things that could be so much better.

If we're talking about privacy abuses, if we're talking about misinformation, if we're talking about the types of news media that is shared and comes to the surface, if we don't have the polarization of audiences, there are a whole lot of issues where we could be seeing a better internet. And that's what I would want to say. I wouldn't want to see any freedoms get tailed. It's not about impinging on the freedom of speech.

It's about putting in place systems and mechanisms that we end up seeing an internet that doesn't damage democracy and damage society and brings proper content, such as good journalism to the surface. It very much feels as if it's happened so fast with regulators and lawmakers who potentially aren't really across all of the issues and maybe not even using the social media platforms. And now it's become just so complicated. It is.

It's really complicated. And that is a big part of the challenge here. But just because something is really complicated and really hard doesn't mean we should throw up our arms and give up. I think we can definitely take really concrete steps to make the internet better and by that make the public see better, make democracy better.

You know, we can do all these things. And some of the things that I've talked about, steps towards algorithmic transparency, get our personal data protections, these sorts of things will help. Fantastic. All right.

On that optimistic note, thanks again, Sasha. Thanks, Drew. And thanks for listening. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network.

All the state is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation. Thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app. We'll be back next week with more.

But in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. The handle is Fourth Estate AU. Thanks to my producer, Toby Hennings, and executive producer Anthony Dockrell. I'm Prue Clark.

Thanks for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 33 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on November 4, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.