The Fight for Speech: Democracy vs. the Algorithm

In this episode of inSUBSTANTIA, host Gabor Farkas speaks with Eric Heinze, Professor of Law and Humanities at Queen Mary University of London, about the complex and often contentious role of free speech in democratic societies. Their conversation explores the philosophical and historical roots of free expression, including Karl Popper’s famous paradox of tolerance. ex Heinze contrasts US and European approaches to free speech law, examines the disruptive influence of digital platforms, and considers the growing threat of misinformation. He argues for distinguishing between regulating individual users and overseeing powerful tech platforms, calling for more nuanced regulatory frameworks. The episode also reflects on polarising events, such as the January 6 Capitol riots, and the evolving role of social media in shaping public discourse. Throughout, Heinze champions counter-speech and the creation of alternative platforms as vital tools for improving the quality of democratic debate.