Skip to content
The Final Chapter: The Night Eric Richins Died episode artwork

Oct 12, 2026 1 hr 47 min

The Final Chapter: The Night Eric Richins Died

from True Crime Brewery Hosted by Jill

Eric Richins died on a cold March night in his Utah home. Hours earlier, according to his wife Kouri, he had been sleeping peacefully. By morning, Eric was gone. What first appeared to be a sudden, tragic death soon revealed deeper fractures—financial strain, quiet resentment, and a marriage carrying more weight than anyone on the […] The post The Final Chapter: The Night Eric Richins Died appeared first on Tiegrabber.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Final Chapter: The Night Eric Richins Died

0:00 1:47:10
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

True Crime Brewery contains disturbing content related to real-life crimes. Medical information is opinion based on facts of a crime and should not be interpreted as medical advice or treatment. Listener discretion is advised. Welcome to True Crime Brewery. I'm Jill. And I'm Dick. Eric Richens died on a cold March night in his Utah home. Just hours earlier, according to his wife, Corey, he'd been sleeping peacefully. By morning, Eric was gone. What first appeared to be a sudden, tragic death soon revealed deeper fractures, financial strain, quiet resentment, and a marriage carrying more weight than anyone on the outside had even realized.

In the aftermath, a family was left reeling, and a community began to confront the unsettling possibility that this wasn't a natural death at all, but the end of a far darker story. So this is the final chapter, the story about the night Eric Richens died. As investigators pressed forward, the secrets multiplied. Hidden life insurance policies, mounting financial battles, a children's book about grief, written by a woman now accused of causing the very loss she claimed to help others navigate. And then came the discovery of her lover.

a relationship that added another layer to a motive already steeped in money and betrayal. So this episode steps right into the shadows, this marriage under pressure, the double life unfolding behind the closed doors, and, of course, the devastating loss of a father, a son, a brother, and a friend. And Dick is with us today with beer, his favorite. One of them. I just meant beer in general is your favorite. Yes, I would say that. So what have we got in Utah? I didn't think of Utah as much of a drinking type of state. Oh, you would pretty much be right about that. But they do have some breweries. They're not dry.

So we're going to drink a beer called Slipstream from Salt Flats Brewing Company in Salt Lake City. It's an Imperial IPA, 9% alcohol by volume. So we're not going to be chugging these. Well, okay. Maybe later we will. I doubt it. You never know. You never know. So this is a pretty okay IPA. It's not great and it's certainly not terrible. So I'd give it like a B. B is pretty good. Yeah. It's amber, small off-white head, very little lace, if any. Pretty nice aroma, sweet malt, a little fruit, and pine. And the taste was caramel. Yum. Peach.

And pine. Wow, that's pretty nice. It's a malt-forward beer, but there is that hot bitterness that lingers for some time. It's a decent beer. Well, I think most people who like an IPA will enjoy this. Oh, I think so. Yeah, it sounds like a good IPA. All right, let's open some up. Okay, we'll take a couple of bottles down to the quiet end. Absolutely. All right, Dickie, so we watched this whole trial, but it's been a while since then, so I might have to refresh your memory on a few things. You might have to. But we've known from the beginning we would be covering it. We've had many people ask us to, so we're glad we can finally get around to it.

39-year-old Eric Richens died on March 4th in 2022, apparently after celebrating a major milestone with his wife, Corey, at least according to Corey. According to her, she prepared him a cocktail to mark the closing of a house deal that she just completed. Then what began as a seemingly ordinary celebration would become the center of a chilling murder investigation. So when the medical examiner discovered that Eric had five times the lethal amount of fentanyl in his system, law enforcement turned its attention to the person who was closest to him, the person who had last been with him, and that's his wife, Corey. And as investigators dug deeper, they would uncover a web of financial disputes, hidden motives, and some suspicious behavior that painted a far darker picture than any of them would have imagined. So Eric was not a drug addict? No, Eric was not a drug addict. There would be no particular reason for him to be using fentanyl. No, and we know that some people are drug addicts, and they're secret about it. People don't know. But this is a huge amount of fentanyl, and there are many things happening in this relationship and in his life.

that just make this very unusual, very shocking. Well, I would have to recognize that if they find the fentanyl at five times the lethal amount, it got there somehow. Is she going to say he committed suicide? You're kind of looking at things too sensibly. As we know, most murderers really don't do things in a sensible manner, and that's why they fuck up and get caught.

Yes, that's true. Right. They don't think these things through. Yeah, but I don't know. I would think she'd realize that she's going to be a suspect. You would think so. But nope, I don't think she did at all. And what makes the story even more startling is what happened afterwards. Because in the wake of Eric's death, Corrie authored and published a children's book about grief and loss. And she titled it, Are You With Me? So this was a story written from the perspective of a child coping with the death of his father. And the book was marketed as a heartfelt tribute to her late husband, Eric. Yet, as allegations against her mounted, many were left asking a very unsettling question.

How could someone suspected of orchestrating her husband's death have the gall to write a book about mourning him? Now, this book also was self-published and she hired someone. So she didn't really write it at all. Also, her whole story was that she was searching for literature, something to help her children cope and couldn't find one book on grief for children. And we know that's ridiculous. There's plenty of books. There's plenty. Yes. Many, many better ones, I would imagine.

But, you know, it didn't end there. At the time of her arrest, Corey was reportedly preparing to release a sequel. So she thought she was going to make oodles of money off of this book. And I think anyone who self-published a book will tell you, you're really not going to get rich off of it unless you're an exceptional writer. And most of us aren't. But if you were an exceptional writer, a major chain would have, or a major publishing house would have taken over. Yeah, you would at least have an agent. Yeah. Yeah. So the case drew inevitable comparisons to other high-profile spousal poisoning investigations.

And I'm going to add to that the case of Colorado dentist James Craig, a case we covered very recently. And he was convicted of fatally poisoning his wife. But while the methods may have seemed similar, investigators believe the motives in these two cases were very different, very different situations. So in many cases involving the murder of a spouse, prosecutors look closely at potential motives like financial gain. We've got that here. Marital conflict. Yep. Infidelity. Yep. Or the desire for a fresh start. Yeah. In the Richens case, money quickly emerged as the central focus of the investigation.

Detectives would later uncover evidence suggesting significant financial pressures, disputes, and really raising some questions about whether greed and control had become deadly motivations to kill Eric. At first glance, the circumstances seem almost unbelievable. We've got this grieving widow who writes a children's book about loss, a husband dead from a massive fentanyl overdose. But as investigators peeled back the layers, they began to uncover a story far more disturbing than anyone had expected. But you know what? To understand how such a shocking case unfolded, we're going to have to go back to where it all began. And that's the small mountain community of Kamas, Utah, where Eric Richens believed he had found the woman of his dreams. So before becoming the center of a high-profile murder case, Eric Richens was known as just this hardworking family man who'd built his life around faith, family, a very successful business, and he loved the outdoors. Raised in Utah as the oldest child in a close-knit ranching family, he had developed a strong work ethic early on. The whole family worked on the ranch.

Friends and family remembered him as energetic, adventurous, competitive, loyal, and deeply protective of the people he loved. He was very active in sports throughout his life, and later he coached his son's teams, becoming a hands-on father who was heavily involved in their daily lives. He had three sons with Corey. Now, back before that, Eric served a mission in Mexico City for the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. He did become fluent in Spanish and later earned a degree in international studies from the University of Utah. Then he went on to build a successful masonry business, which earned a reputation.

as being a very good business. And he earned a reputation as a hardworking businessman who valued relationships and helped out other people whenever he could. Outside of work, he loved hunting, ranching, traveling, and just pretty much anything outdoors. Those who were really close to him remembered him for his humor, for having a larger-than-life personality, and having an ability to bring energy into any room. But most would say most important to Eric was being a devoted husband, father, son, brother, and friend. Long before he became known as a victim, he was a man who had dreams, many responsibilities,

very strong family ties, and three young sons who knew him simply as debt. His death didn't just create a criminal case then. It really left a permanent void in the lives of many people. So Camas, Utah is a quiet mountain valley town, and it's known more for its natural beauty than tourism. It was settled by a small group of Mormon pioneers back in 1859. It sits between the Uinta and Wasatch Mountains and serves as a popular spot for outdoor recreation. Eric met Corey Richens through a co-worker and mutual acquaintance while she worked at Home Depot. Right, so she was a cashier. She had grown up not poor, but middle class, and had actually worked as a housekeeper for a while. So some people have said maybe that gave her the dream of having a big, beautiful house, because she seemed to really want a lot of money and a lot of things.

So she's a cashier at the Home Depot. And I don't think that it was lost from her that Eric was a wealthy man, a successful man. She picked up on that. Picked up on that for sure. But the relationship quickly developed and they married in 2013. And then they had three sons. Friends often describe them as having an ideal relationship. Though, you know, appearances can mask some very private, very extreme struggles. We all see those Facebook pictures of smiling families. And they're usually not what life is really like.

even for the families that are happy. But for families having troubles like these, it can be very misleading. Well, it's difficult just going on outward appearances. Absolutely. But things did appear great. When Corey married Eric, they appeared to be building the kind of life that most young couples could only dream about. Living in Utah, they raised three sons and seemed to just thrive as a team together. Eric worked hard to provide for the family, while Corey developed ambitions in real estate. So friends and neighbors saw growing family, successful business ventures, and a very comfortable lifestyle.

To outsiders, they looked like a couple who was moving steadily toward greater financial success and personal achievement. And Eric was successful. But we're going to find out that Corey's real estate business wasn't what she made it out to be. So behind the scenes, investigators later alleged that the marriage was becoming increasingly strained. The couple disagreed over money, trust, and major financial decisions. One recurring source of tension involved real estate transactions. Eric was really becoming concerned about family finances and some of Corey's business activities.

So he was a husband who was beginning to kind of try and exercise tighter control over their assets. And Corey was a wife who was frustrated by the restrictions he was trying to put on the money. But this wasn't like restrictions about, you know, you can't spend more than $150 at the grocery store. Don't buy too many clothes. These were, you know, huge amounts of money that she wanted to invest in real estate and wasn't necessarily earning that money back. So was she flipping houses or? Flipping houses was what the business was, yes.

That's a tough business to do. Yes, but she made it look easy, made it look good, at least from the outside. Yeah. So he's just trying to be more aware of her financial doings. Yeah. I mean, she did things that weren't great. Yeah, but he wasn't putting her on an allowance. No, I don't think it was anything like that at all. I think she was living very well. She could have easily just done her own thing and taken care of her kids. There was plenty of money.

But she wanted to have a career, which is fine. She had these ambitions. But I think she really wasn't going about it with that much wisdom or preparedness or really any kind of education in it. That's going to be difficult, isn't it? It was difficult. What neighbors saw as a successful partnership was really evolving into a relationship marked by a lot of conflict and resentment. So in the months leading up to Eric's death, the cracks in the marriage were really widening. Financial pressures and disagreements intensified. And Eric started taking steps to protect some of the assets.

During the later investigation, authorities uncovered evidence that showed Corey stood to benefit financially if her husband died. So there was like a prenup. His family, quite well off, didn't really approve of her in the beginning, but then they accepted her. But there were certain limitations on the money. Like if he died, she would inherit things. But if there was a divorce, there would be limits on what she would get out of this. Yeah, so she'll maximize it by having him killed. Well, yes. But if you think about it, even if she divorced him, they've got three children she would have been taken care of. This is not someone who had to worry about being on the street.

Sure. At all. She would have possibly thought that she would do better financially if he was dead. Well, certainly she did. Yes, that seems to be absolutely true. So there allegedly had been an earlier unsuccessful poisoning attempt involving a fentanyl lace sandwich that Corey gave to Eric on Valentine's Day 2022. So just a little over two weeks before his death, he did survive that incident, unaware of exactly what had happened. But there were indications that he was starting to suspect her. Was he really sickened from it? Yes, yes. He pretty much was out of contact for a while and thought he was quite ill.

I think he may have even taken an EpiPen or something, if I can remember correctly. But he definitely texted a friend that he thought he had been poisoned. The other part of that would be that he would be suspicious of his wife. Yeah. And why would that be? That's weird, right? What, the poisoning? Well, being suspicious of your wife. Your wife gives you a sandwich, you get sick, you wouldn't necessarily jump to the conclusion. She's trying to poison me, would you? Well, if they're having domestic problems, sure. Yes, sure. But that's pretty extreme, even if you're having problems. Yeah, it is. I mean, I don't think I'd be expecting that.

But Corey had done other things. I mean, for example, she had taken out a home equity loan of, I think, about $250,000 without letting him know, forging his name, I believe. So that's pretty huge. How do you think you're going to take that much money? They were well off, but it's not like he's just not going to notice that. You would think he'd notice that. He did notice that. And so I think that's when he really started to worry about his assets, at least, if not his life. So then came March 3rd, 2022. And according to Corey's account, this was a night of celebration. She said she and Eric were recognizing.

the closing of a real estate deal, and spent the evening together at their home. She said at some point she prepared him a Moscow Mule cocktail. Now, to anyone looking from the outside, I guess that could seem like an ordinary evening between a married couple. It's kind of weird, though, to give your husband a drink in bed. Really? Right? And then once they look into it, they see, you know, the closing on this mansion. This was a huge mansion that she was trying to purchase and renovate. And there was really nothing good about this. This was a disaster. And we're pretty sure Eric would not be on board with this. But this was her initial story. They were celebrating this great success.

So there were no emergency calls, no visible signs of a tragedy about to unfold, and really no indication that within hours, this family would be at the center of one of the most followed true crime cases in the country. So by the early morning hours of March 4th, everything here had changed. A 911 call. Now some have called it frantic. I call it white suspicious. I'd call it more whiny and hesitant than frantic. So Corey called, saying that Eric was cold, unresponsive, and not breathing. And there's going to be a lot made of how she hesitated during this call. So we'll play some of that.

I'm not going to play the whole thing, but I really feel like the prosecutor in this case did a great job going step by step through the 911 call and showing how she really just postponed anything happening and probably did not perform CPR, which we've seen in other cases, pretending to do CPR. Yeah, I mean, they're on the telephone. They don't know what you're actually doing. Right, right, exactly. But there are a lot of indications when you hear these recordings that you can kind of tell what's really going on. So emergency responders did rush to the house while Corey cried to the dispatcher and supposedly attempted CPR after initially hesitating. Paramedics were unable to save Eric.

So what first appeared to be some kind of shocking unexplained death would later be transformed by toxicology results showing extremely high levels of fentanyl in his system. And the investigation that followed would lead the authorities to re-examine not only Eric's final night, but really the entire history of the Richens' marriage, as they searched for clues hidden beneath the image of a successful family that had once seemed to have it all. So that night, March 3rd, according to Corey, She and Eric had spent the evening celebrating the closing of a real estate deal. According to her, she prepared him a Moscow mule cocktail before they went to bed. A few hours later, at 321 a.m., she called 911, telling the dispatcher that her husband was unresponsive, cold to the touch, and not breathing. Now, during the call, she repeatedly cried and pleaded for help. When the dispatcher instructed her to begin CPR, Corey said she couldn't get him off the bed, and she initially said she couldn't feel a pulse either. So she was hesitant to perform chest compressions or do anything. So really, the first thing is...

She said she couldn't get him off the bed. So the dispatcher was telling her, you know, take the sheet, pull him off the bed. Don't worry about hurting him by getting him on the floor. He needs help. He needs to be on the floor. And she was just very terrible with this. And one thing that we're going to hear from the prosecutor and maybe have a little more discussion about is how she said, you know, I can't move it. It's just dead weight. It. So this doesn't sound like someone you love or care about that you're trying to save. Or really any human being you would not call it, you would think.

So when she says that, it makes me think this was a guy who was a corpse for a while and she's just kind of grossed out by it. Doesn't want to move him. Doesn't want to do anything. She's performing on this call, waiting for someone to come and just kind of get this over with so she can move forward. She's got things she wants to do with her life that do not involve this man.

I need you to confirm it for me. Is he not breathing? Can you do CPR? I'm going to tell you how to. Are you willing to do CPR? Yes. Okay.

So she did eventually agree to try to do CPR, and then emergency responders got to the house. When paramedics and sheriff's deputies got there, they found Eric lying unresponsive, and medical personnel immediately took over life-saving efforts. While Corey spoke with the officers about the evening before, she explained they'd shared drinks and gone to sleep separately. She said she'd been in bed with one of her kids who'd had a nightmare, and she offered possible explanations for this sudden collapse, including that he may have taken a THC gummy. There were some of those in the house. She said sometimes he took those for sleep.

Now, she did call her mom, and shortly afterward, her mom did arrive. And the mom was pretty suspicious to me. She mentioned an allergy shot that Eric had received the day before. She also mentioned that she thought he'd looked horrible the day before and asked him what was wrong with him. But of course, at that moment, no one at the scene, other than Corey, knew that fentanyl would later be identified as the cause of death. And responders reportedly were considering the possibility of some kind of sudden medical emergency, like an aneurysm, because he's only 39. Why is he suddenly dying? Yeah, and he's been in good health. Yes, pretty active, actually.

That's different. Yes. And one thing to point out about Corey's mom is she had not a husband, but a partner that she lived with who died of a drug overdose. So that's interesting. Did Corey's mom give her this idea and say, hey, it worked for me? Because the mom was totally on Corey's side. And it just makes me suspicious how the mom sat there with police and kind of made it seem like there was something wrong with him the day before when no one else really said that. So I do find her a bit suspicious. Yes.

So then as the investigation unfolded, prosecutors began scrutinizing Corey's actions in the house before the first responders arrived. Although she told the dispatcher she was performing CPR, investigators questioned whether any meaningful resuscitation efforts had even been attempted. They pointed out her reluctance during the 911 call and argued that physical evidence at the scene did not support that she had tried to save her husband. So they can tell if CPR has been started before or not. Why? Because some fluids come out of the mouth. Yeah, there can be some.

Drainage. There could be bone breakage, right? Or at least sternum. Bruising of the skin. Yeah, but there was nothing that really showed that CPR was done. Still, he couldn't be revived and was pronounced dead. And what initially appeared to be tragic and unexplained took a really dramatic turn when the autopsy determined he had died from the fentanyl. Investigators found fentanyl levels in his system far above the lethal range. So even if he was fooling around with drugs, it's unlikely he would have taken that much. Plus, there was no fentanyl found at the bedside or anywhere in the house.

So as you can imagine, this death sparked a lengthy investigation and they really started focusing on Corey. So you can see the video of when the police arrived and they're talking to Corey. And one thing about it for me is that she's covering her face the entire time. She's talking, but like her head's down and she's covering her face. And that to me is a telltale sign. She doesn't want to show her expression and she's probably not really crying. Yeah, it'd be easier to say crying if you're covering up your eyes. Right. Another thing is the policeman's like, where are your children? She says, well, one's asleep in this room and the other two are there with their ear to the door. I don't want them to come out.

Now, a normal woman would want to comfort her children, in my opinion, in this type of situation. It wouldn't leave them in the room. And really, they seemed like kind of an afterthought to her. And when you see Eric's sister, Katie, come to the house, she's devastated. She's just a fucking mess. Much more like what you would expect when your 39-year-old relative is just all of a sudden dead. And another thing about the sister was, she's like, where are the boys? Where are those babies? Immediately wants to comfort the children. But not Corey. Not Corey. She really didn't seem to have any interest in those kids either. What happened today? How did you see them?

What alerts do you have today, right now? You said he was on his back. Okay. Where are your children now? At room two, we're awake now. Where are the other two at? That's awake? No, awake at your... Where is that now? Is there any family members who can call them right now? Yeah, I need to call them. Thank you. I don't know. Okay. Is Ms. Vision's emotional reaction consistent with what you typically see? No. Please describe that. Well...

Well, I'm on scene at a death call. Normally, the victim, they have tears. They look at me when I ask them a question. They're pretty direct when I ask a direct question. It just, every time I spoke to Ms. Richens, it just seems like her face was in her hands, and I couldn't see her face. I think I went to even lean down and just try to look to see her emotions. But, you know, it was just a little abnormal.

So maybe each of these little things individually wouldn't mean she killed him, but it just starts adding up. It really starts piling on. Her behavior just doesn't seem right. So when she called for help that morning, she had told dispatchers this story that she'd woken up and found her husband cold to the touch. She said he was lying unresponsive at the foot of their bed. Now, according to Corey, she had spent part of the night sleeping in the other room with one of the children. And then when she returned to the bedroom, she realized something was wrong. Eric wasn't breathing. The children were in a room nearby while the questions were beginning.

On that 911 call, Corey sounded, you know, kind of teary, like she could have been facing the worst moment of her life. She told the dispatcher that Eric wouldn't wake up, that he felt cold, and she didn't know what happened. So we've got a husband who went to bed, a wife who finds him dead, and then the whole family about to learn that this man, really important in their lives, is gone. So at first, there's really no reason to suspect anything more than tragedy. And last, you're on the inside. And I think that Eric's family very early on was suspicious. You know, Eric was young. His death was shocking. But sometimes sudden deaths do happen.

Families are sometimes left with no warning, no final goodbye, and no explanation that really makes sense. So in those first few hours, grief did come before suspicion. Three boys had lost their dad, Corey had lost her husband, and friends and relatives were told that Eric was gone, and that the life they knew had just ended overnight. But investigators have a real responsibility to look past that initial, superficial story, of course. So they examined the scene, the timeline, the statements, and all these details that just weren't quite fitting. So they had to listen not only to what was said, but to what wasn't said. And in Eric's case, these early questions would eventually lead to some much darker ones. We've got the story about the closing of the real estate deal, the Moscow mule. And on the surface, it seems kind of insignificant. Maybe the kind of thing a married couple might do, you know, normally, a drink after work, a little celebration, a quiet evening at home. Prosecutors later allege, though, that this Moscow mule...

wasn't just a cocktail. They argued it was the vehicle used to deliver the fentanyl that killed Eric. So if true, this transformed an ordinary domestic moment into something very chilling. Not just a weapon drawn in anger, but a drink handed over in trust. So very conniving, very manipulative, and very cold-hearted.

So we know Eric had not died from a mysterious medical event. He had fentanyl in his system. And according to the court filings, this amount was extraordinarily high. And this wasn't the kind of fentanyl that is created by a drug company. This was street fentanyl. So it might have other things in it. Yes. And that tells you that someone bought it off the street. Right. So I guess the big question was, how did it get into Eric Richen's body? And that answer would become, you know, a real central issue in the case.

If Eric knowingly took fentanyl, investigators would be looking at one type of death. But if he took it accidentally, that suggested a whole other type of death. If someone had given it to him without his knowledge, then we've got a homicide case. So from the outside, sympathy just came naturally. The family had been devastated. A father was gone before his children were old enough to even fully understand what they had lost.

So whatever would be later alleged in court, that loss was undeniably real. In the days after Eric's death, life inside the Richens' household revolved around grief. Family members gathered, they had to make difficult phone calls, questions from the children went unanswered, and Corrie publicly spoke about grief and the challenge she had of helping her sons navigate the loss of their father. So at the time, there were many people, many friends and outsiders who saw her as a grieving spouse, just doing her best to hold the family together. But what they didn't know right then was that investigators were beginning to look far beyond the morning that Eric died. And one detail that would later attract a lot of attention was what had happened in the hours after Eric's death. So according to investigators, the day after Corey found her husband dead, she closed on a real estate transaction and later hosted a large gathering at her home. Now, according to Eric's sister, who is no fan of Corey's, let me tell you that. He had two sisters, Katie and Amy, but Katie was the more outspoken one. But still, it was just the day after he died.

When Corey got a locksmith to come in and open a safe in the house, which held Eric's will. And when his sister Amy saw this, she just lost it. And that's when she told Corey, this isn't your house. Eric had changed everything over. He had put his sister in charge of the estate. She was the trustee. And as you can imagine, Corey was not happy. Corey actually hit her in the face and the neck and the police were called. So she would be found guilty of assault. And this party was really kind of weird, if you ask me. So they have this large gathering at the home. Friends and acquaintances came.

but it was described more like a celebration. And Corey tried to tie this to the property closing. Some witnesses later said, and a video later showed, that there was a lot of drinking, socializing, and it just seemed kind of festive, like doing shots and playing music and laughing. A lot of people found that really distasteful. And that includes me. I have a hard time with that. So close to the death of her husband. Yeah. You'd think she would just be a lot more devastated. Yeah. Well, the celebration for the real estate transaction could have been a little more quiet and muted.

Well, Eric's sister's idea is why in the hell would you even be thinking of doing that? You could put that off. Well, sure. And Corey had told Eric's sister that she wanted to sell the house. And this was like within a day or two of his death. It's just not normal, if you ask me. Well, she's not thinking well. Well, she's certainly not thinking that this is a loss. She seems more like someone who wants to move forward. So even if you're trying to give her the benefit of the doubt, it's difficult to do. So whether you look at it as like a gathering where they're just, you know, remembering his life, where there may be in shock and denial.

Or if you're looking at as a celebration of Eric's death, you know, that's something that's debatable. But what's undisputed is that reports and court records describe a sizable party taking place at the Richens' house shortly after Eric's death. And what about his kids? His kids were there. So this is just something that would become part of the larger story surrounding the case. But things that just make Corey look guilty, inappropriate, it's just all piling on pretty quickly. So days after his death were filled with this confusion and these questions about what happened.

And then those tensions exploded when they had that issue with the safe that Eric had kept locked away. So Corey wanted this locksmith to drill into it. And that's when Eric's sister told her about being the trustee of the estate, that Eric had changed it. He had changed it secretly. And you see this a lot. Now, if you didn't trust your spouse and you were going to change the money over to someone else, wouldn't you tell the spouse so they wouldn't kill you? I mean, if you don't tell them and they think they're still going to get the money, you're still likely to get murdered. Well, it makes it more difficult, that's for sure. Yeah. So I just wonder why he wouldn't have told her unless he's just trying to keep things, you know.

Wyatt, because he did see a divorce attorney at one point. So he was making some plans. So Corey's no longer positioned to inherit certain assets that she thought she would get. So this turned into a family dispute and became a legal incident after that confrontation broke out and Corey hit her sister-in-law. So as we know, a death investigation rarely focuses only on the moment when someone dies. We have to look at the months and years beforehand, right? Absolutely. I mean, just the fact that they found that he changed his will for the executor or whatever of his estate. Right. That definitely sounds like there was trouble in the marriage. Yes. So they had to ask difficult questions? Oh, yeah. I mean, got to look at what was happening inside the marriage and not just in the immediate past, but over time. Right. You know, even maybe all the way back to the beginning, because I kind of feel like this was...

Maybe not true love for her. Maybe initially it was just based on the money. Well, the way it's been presented, it sounds like she was a calculating woman. Yeah, yeah. And I was thinking, this is a wealthy guy. It'd be my benefit to marry him. Sure. And who stood the benefit from Eric's death? Well, she sure thought she did. Were there financial pressures in the family? Well, yeah. Not only the things that she'd done with the family finances, but she was millions of dollars in debt from buying that mansion that she was supposedly going to flip.

We're talking a lot of debt, debt that I can't even imagine having. So even though he was making a very, very good income. Yes. This was going to be harmful financially to him. Well, yeah. And then after she killed him and found out she wasn't going to get all the money, she still has that debt to deal with. Plus, of course, it seems like a pretty strong motive for murder. So according to prosecutors, the answers pointed toward a troubling picture that involved money, insurance policies, a huge amount of debt, some forged documents, growing marital tensions, and Corey had a boyfriend.

So they determined that Eric's death was not a sudden unexplained tragedy at all. It was not a suicide. He was not a drug user who accidentally took too much. It seemed all planned out. And part of that was that Corey had asked a housekeeper, Carmen Lauber, for drugs. And after the sandwich, she'd gone back to Carmen and said she needed something stronger. I believe the quote was, I need that Michael Jackson shit. Okay. Now we know Michael Jackson died of propofol, but Corey probably didn't know that.

So it didn't sound good. And of course, this housekeeper who got her the drugs would be very important when it came to trial. I'm sure. Yes. So of course, Corey did maintain her innocence from the beginning, and her attorneys would argue that investigators became convinced of a theory, and then they interpreted the evidence through that lens. So confirmation bias. Hear about it all the time. So they're not just, yeah. I think that's the new buzzword for defense attorneys. Yeah. Well, you can kind of see it, but...

If you're trying to confirm a theory, it doesn't necessarily mean bias. It means that that's just the theory that's working out to be the truth. Well, I would look at it that way, that you're not necessarily, well, you're not investigating that one particular person as part of it. But if that person is giving you more and more evidence that she was involved in his death, you're going to keep going after her. So by the time of Eric's death, the marriage was portrayed as deeply troubled, with a lot of distrust and growing conflict going on. And although they did outwardly appear to be a successful couple, raising three beautiful boys, the relationship was described as very strained behind closed doors. At the center of this were money and business pressures. Eric really had built a successful masonry company, while Corey was very involved in real estate investing and house flipping ventures. But these carried significant financial risk.

I mean, just think about it. If you're going to buy a property for millions of dollars and then try and flip it and make millions more, you really have to know what you're doing and you have to have the support. But you have to know your audience too. Right. You can say, oh, I'm going to pay X amount of money for this and I'm going to renovate it and fix it up and charge this much money. But there might not be many people that would afford that. Well, yes. Right. And the cost of renovating it might outweigh any profit you would make. Yeah. So it's not cut and dried that you're going to flip a house and make oodles of money. No. And she wasn't successful in, you know.

most of the other ventures either. She actually ended up financially screwing over some people who were friends. So then the case becomes about marital problems. You know, if you're focusing on financial struggles and deception and disputes over money, that's a motive. And the prosecution would argue that Eric's death really fit into a broader pattern involving insurance benefits, her expectations of what she would inherit and what she wanted to do afterwards. So the case ultimately became more about more than the marital problems. So the prosecution argued.

that Eric's death fit into a much broader pattern. In short, the marriage was presented as a relationship increasingly defined by money, mistrust, and competing financial interests. And those issues became central. One of the most unusual aspects of the case was what happened in the year after Eric died. In March of 2023, about one year after his death, Corey self-published that children's book titled Are You With Me? The book was written, she said, to help children cope with the loss of a parent and was dedicated to her three sons. But really, it was just another money grab. She thought she'd get rich off of this.

Which she was wrong, of course. She had big dreams. Yeah, she did. And as part of this book's release, she gave interviews and appeared in local media. So she went on this local like morning show, speaking publicly about grief, healing and helping her children navigate the loss of their father. So she's the one who had contacted the show repeatedly. And her performance was a little weird. I mean, she went on wearing a leather jacket, didn't present herself very well. Not that well spoken, really. But of course, the people on the show, they felt sorry for her. They saw her as a young widow.

Plus, she's saying that she wrote this book because she wanted to bring comfort to families who were facing similar losses. But, you know, these appearances helped to bring attention to the book and her personal story and probably had a part in making this case even more notorious than it would have been. And then it was just weeks after she promoted this book when the story took a very dramatic turn. On May 8th, 2023, just a year after his death and about two months after the book's release, Corey was arrested and charged with Eric's murder. So we've got this contrast between her public role as an author of a children's grief book.

and these allegations surrounding Eric's death. So this drew a lot of national attention, transforming what might have been a local criminal case into a story that was followed across the whole country. And we've got this fentanyl evidence, which was a real turning point in the case, because once investigators knew about this large amount of fentanyl causing his death, they had to look into, how did it get there? And according to their theory, he didn't accidentally take it or seek it out himself. Instead, someone close to him secretly gave it to him. So the toxicology reports show that fentanyl was the cause of death.

But investigators still needed to determine who obtained the drug and how it was administered, and that's what led them to examine Eric's final night and that Moscow Mule cocktail that Corey said she made for him. They also looked into these previous incidents where Eric became mysteriously ill, and they looked into the financial and marital problems. So a lot of that case really centered on the testimony of Carmen Lauber, the former house cleaner for the family. So she would testify at the trial and tell jurors that Corey had asked her to help get pain pills and later requested something stronger. Investigators argued that these drug purchases connected Corey to the same substance that was later found in Eric's body. Now the defense was able to challenge her credibility because Carmen Lauber...

You know, she had a sketchy history. She was a drug addict. So she was an easy, you know, witness to try and discredit. So they challenged her credibility, pointing out inconsistencies in her story and arguing that she had her own reasons to cooperate with investigators. They maintained there was no direct evidence showing Corey putting fentanyl in Eric's drink and noted that no fentanyl was found in the family home. And I think those are really the two strongest things for the defense is they didn't find a glass in the sink with fentanyl on it.

There were some pill bottles that weren't tested for any kind of residue of fentanyl. So there really was no physical proof of where the fentanyl had come from. Yeah. I mean, you know, it got there. You know, it got there. But how did it get there? Well, if you believe the housekeeper, she sold it to Corey. Right. But then there were also some issues with the drug dealer that the housekeeper got the drugs from would later change his story and say it was oxycodone he sold. Okay.

But to me, that's not that strong because I feel like when you go to a drug dealer, you're really not sure, right? You're taking a lot of interest. You are. And I'm sure there have been many people who thought they were buying some oxycodone and ended up getting fentanyl. And that has caused some overdose deaths. That's right.

So Corey would be held in jail awaiting her trial and that's when the infamous walk the dog letter was found. So this was a six-page handwritten note that was found in her Summit County jail cell in 2023. Prosecutors say it revealed an attempt to shape testimony and to coordinate stories with her mother and brother while she awaited trial for Eric's death. So the phrase walk the dog but take vague notes so you remember appeared on top and investigators interpreted this as coded instructions to memorize the script and destroy any written evidence afterward. Well, it's kind of suspicious. Yeah, it's very suspicious. It is. Not so much walk the dog. But the rest of it. Although she shouldn't need to tell that. Of course not. Take vague notes so you remember. Well, the letter actually outlined a detailed narrative that prosecutors say was fabricated to help her defense. And that would include claims that Eric had secretly used drugs and

that he'd bought fentanyl from Mexico or from some of the workers for his company from Mexico. It also directed her brother to testify about these alleged conversations and warned her mom to meet him in person because their phone might be bugged. Now, other sections included media messaging plans, financial talking points, and cryptic references to people nicknamed Lotto and Katie's daughters. And this was suggesting broader attempts to reshape the surrounding story. So jail staff found the letter after Corey suffered a seizure from incorrect medication and was removed temporarily from her cell.

Prosecutors filed it in court on September 15th of 2023, and they would call it evidence of witness tampering and consciousness of guilt. So that's really bad for her. Yeah, that doesn't look good. No. Now the defense, or Corey, or both of them, argued this was fiction and that it was improperly obtained, but the judge would allow it into evidence. So Corey basically said she was working on another book, and that's what this was. But that's pretty lame. Well, of course, yeah, but that's not the greatest thing to come up with.

So like we were saying, the fentanyl evidence was a big point in this case. And once investigators learned about the extremely high level of fentanyl in Eric's system, that's when they were really getting into how did it get there. According to the prosecution's theory, Eric did not accidentally take it or seek it out himself, but someone close to him secretly gave it to him. Toxicology reports showed that fentanyl was his cause of death, but of course investigators still needed to determine who got the drug and how it was administered. And that would lead them to examine Eric's final night.

that Moscow mule cocktail that Corey said she made for him, and also those previous incidents, including the sandwich on Valentine's Day. And that's when Eric had become mysteriously ill and actually suggested that he thought Corey had poisoned him. And of course, on Valentine's Day, we'll find out she wasn't with Eric. She spent Valentine's Day with her boyfriend, who will testify. A major part of the case centered on the testimony of Carmen Lauber. Yeah, that was fascinating to watch. She's a former house cleaner for the family.

She told jurors that Corey had asked her to help get pain pills and later requested something stronger. Investigators argued that these drug purchases connected Corey to the same substance that was later found in Eric's body. The defense challenged Laura's credibility, pointing out inconsistencies in her story and arguing that she had her own reasons to cooperate with investigators. They maintained that there was no direct evidence showing Corey put fentanyl in Eric's drink and noted that no fentanyl was found in the family home. The other interesting thing about this fentanyl, somehow they determined that it was street fentanyl.

I guess they can tell in the toxicology. Yeah. So this wasn't a prescription? No. I really don't think a lot of people have a fentanyl prescription anyway. It's really not the kind of thing you give an outpatient. It's more of a hospital surgery type of drug. Yeah. I think if you're able to say that this is illicit, that's an important thing to know. It is. And there was actually a recording of Corey calling the ME's office, kind of fishing for information to see what they did know. And when they say it was illicit fentanyl, she's not the brightest. She says, oh, does that mean it's made from the pharmacy?

technician or whoever she was speaking to at the ME's office tells her, no, this was made illegally by a cartel or something like that. But you can just tell she's kind of looking and trying to find out what they know. She says, is there a way that you can find out how he got it and things like that? So anyway, it was suspicious that she called there, especially the way that she spoke. In the end, the case was built largely on circumstantial evidence. Yeah, pretty much. Yeah. Yeah. Not a lot of physical evidence at all. Prosecutors argue that the pieces fit together. Financial pressure provided a motive. Fentanyl provided the means.

And the privacy of the marriage provided the opportunity. Yeah. They pointed to the alleged Valentine's Day poisoning attempt, the reported drug purchases, and the fatal toxicology results as part of a larger pattern. The defense argued that suspicion was being mistaken for proof and that the state had built a story around assumptions rather than on direct evidence. Yeah, there was really a lot of bashing of these two defense attorneys, these two women, but I really think they did the best they could with what they had. Well, they also came in late because her primary attorney withdrew from the case. Yes. Well, there was something to mention about... Conflict of interest? Yeah, thank you. Okay. Well...

The trial did finally begin in March 2026, so almost four years after Eric was found dead in the couple's Utah home and almost three years after Corey's arrest. The opening statements gave jurors to very different versions of what happened inside the Richens' marriage. Now, the prosecutor, Brad Bloodsworth, was seriously scary. I mean, he was really committed to this. You could see that he really was portraying how guilty he thought she was. And I wouldn't have wanted to be in Corey's place, let's just say that. He actually did a very good job. But, you know, these prosecutors, they're powerful.

And when you're in the position of being a defendant, you are very vulnerable. That's for sure. Guilty or not. Yeah. So the prosecution argued that Corey killed Eric for money and for a fresh start. According to their opening statement, Corey was facing serious financial problems, carrying millions of dollars in debt, and believed that Eric's death would give her access to life insurance benefits, his estate, and many assets. They also talked about her extramarital affair and how she was already planning a future with this other man. Jurors heard that Corey had allegedly booked a vacation with her boyfriend before Eric's death.

And they had exchanged messages describing dreams of leaving Eric, building a home together, raising children, and starting a new life. So the prosecution portrayed the affair, the financial troubles, and life insurance issues as key parts of the motive. So this boyfriend is certainly no longer in the picture. No, but you know, I thought he was kind of heartbreaking. Well, he was. He seemed like kind of a nice guy. He was from down south. He had done a lot of work for her. And she was kind of taking care of him financially and kind of leading him on, it seemed. Oh, no question. Look at the texts that were going back and forth between them.

Yeah, so this was Josh Grossman. And it had to be painful for him to sit there and hear all his texts proclaiming his love for her and the things she said to him in public. I just can't imagine what that would be like. Me either. So in the year from the murder to Corey's arrest, they were together? Yeah, it just kind of fell apart. It's funny how murder will do that. Yeah, isn't it? Yeah, it seems to happen a lot. So the boyfriend must have had some suspicion. Well, I don't know if that was it, but he would testify about her asking him what it felt like to kill someone because he was in the Iraq war.

So that would be used as some kind of evidence. Plus she told him, can you just hang on until Friday? Yeah. You know, right around the time that her husband died. So you really can't overlook that. And it really reminds me a little bit of the Caleb Flynn trial where he's saying, oh, I'm going to divorce my wife tomorrow and tomorrow comes and his wife is dead. So this is very similar in that way. Certainly is. Yes. But I think this Josh Grossman seemed like kind of a simple, honest, forthright man. And I felt really bad for him. Yeah. Which I felt really bad for a lot of her friends too. She had several friends.

It wasn't like she's a hermit. Oh, no. No, she was very gregarious, actually. But the state went on to argue that the murder was planned. And they talked about how Corey had first tried to poison Eric on Valentine's Day 2022. And that's when he became seriously ill after eating a sandwich that she gave him. So when that murder attempt allegedly failed, I guess we don't need to say allegedly because she's been found guilty. They said she got stronger drugs through the house cleaner. And according to the prosecution, the plan culminated on March 3rd, 2022. And that's when Corey served Eric a Moscow mule containing a lethal dose of fentanyl.

He also highlighted her actions after his death, and that included alleged internet searches, deleted communications, and other behavior that they believed showed consciousness of guilt. How do you put the fentanyl in a sandwich? Crush it? Yeah, I suppose. But if it's like a sandwich with a lot of mayo or something, you could. Yeah, I wonder what it tastes like if it has much of a taste. Yeah, I don't know if it tasted funny to him or what really happened with that. He got sick after the fact, but didn't blame the sandwich. Well, he kind of did. He suggested to one friend that Corey tried to poison him.

When her friend would testify about this, she portrayed it as a joke, like Eric had been joking. So that kind of backfired on the prosecution. So the defense told jurors they were hearing a compelling story, but no proof. Attorney Catherine Nestor argued that the state's case relied heavily on circumstantial evidence and witnesses whose credibility could be challenged. The defense stressed that no one saw Corey put fentanyl into Eric's drink, no direct evidence tied her to that fatal dose, and investigators had built a narrative.

That made every event in the marriage appear suspicious once Eric was dead. So they really urged jurors to keep an open mind and not focus on financial problems, marital issues, some questionable decisions, or even infidelity with proof of murder. Because you can be unfaithful, you can steal money, you can do a lot of things that don't necessarily make you a murderer. No, but the more these unconnected things go on, the more you're going to think that it is resulting in his death. Yes, yes. If she was okay and just had infidelity and no financial problems or...

anything else. Yeah. You might say you can't really connect that. Right. But if I'm going to look at financial problems, marital issues, bad decisions, infidelity, that kind of adds up. Yeah. And like we mentioned, those texts between her and Josh, one of them even said life would be perfect if Eric was gone. Yeah. Yeah. So anyway, the prosecution's opening statement was all about greed, infidelity, debt, and a carefully planned poisoning. While the defense argued that the state had woven those facts into a dramatic story without directly proving that Corey murdered Eric.

And I could kind of see their point. I mean, I'm easy to sway. So sometimes I listen to the prosecution and I'm like, yeah. And then the defense and I'm like, yeah. So I can go back and forth. I'll admit to that. You can desolate. Yes, I can. But the thing is, they really didn't have any proof in the house. And I think they made a mistake by not testing some of those medicine bottles for residue of fentanyl. So I found that strange. But the prosecution called dozens of witnesses, nearly 40 before it rested its case. Yeah, it took 13 days. Yeah. To present the prosecution case. Yeah. And I remember watching probably 90% of it.

So there's no short official list of every witness. However, these were the most significant prosecution witnesses and what their testimony was intended to prove. So I think the first one, I know she was at least very early on, but I'm almost sure she was the first one, was Eric Richens' sister, Katie Richens Benson. She testified about Eric's relationship with Corey, his estate planning decisions, and his efforts to protect assets for his children through a trust rather than leaving them directly to Corey. prosecutors were able to use her testimony to support their theory that the marriage was deteriorating and that financial issues really contributed to the motive. He must have had some clue that she wasn't being totally upfront with money because he was trying to protect assets for his kids. Remember the $250,000 loan. That's a good indication. That's a lot of money. Then Eric's father testified.

And he was able to help establish the timeline surrounding Eric's death and described some family concerns after his son's overdose. His testimony also gave some background about the family and about Eric's character. So, of course, the sister and father, they raved about what a wonderful person Eric was. And if they didn't hate her before, they certainly hated Corey at this point. That they did. Yes. So then there was Deputy Vincent Nguyen, who was the Summit County Sheriff's Office. He was among the first law enforcement witnesses, and he testified about the initial response and investigation following Eric's death.

helping jurors understand how the case developed from an apparent overdose into a homicide investigation. Yeah, Chelsea Gibson testified, and she described the physical evidence collected from the Richens' home. She was the lead crime scene technician. She also was able to discuss multiple searches conducted by investigators. And her testimony, I would say it focused really on documenting the scene, any recovered medications, electronics, and other evidence used later by the forensics experts. First responders and medical personnel, they testified about the circumstances they encountered when Eric was found unresponsive.

Their testimony helped establish the condition of the scene and a sequence of events immediately before and after Eric's death. One of the bigger things was that he'd been dead for a while. He'd been dead for quite a while, and there was no sign of any attempt at CPR, even though Corrie said that she had been doing it. And then, of course, Carmen Lauber, the former housekeeper and a key cooperating witness, was one of the prosecution's most important witnesses. She testified that she got drugs for Corey on multiple occasions, and she also said Corey had asked for something stronger, leading to transactions involving fentanyl shortly before Eric's death. Now, she really, I found her to be a good witness. Even though she had a very checkered past and a history of lying, she teared up.

She actually seemed to feel bad if the drug she sold had been responsible for Eric's death. But of course, the defense tried really hard to tear her up, and they were able to quite a bit. Although I really felt like she held her own. Yeah, I thought she did pretty well. Then Robert Crozier, he was the drug addict that gave the drugs to Carmen, who gave them to Corey. And he testified about the chain through which the drugs could be obtained and about his interactions with people connected to Carmen. Prosecutors used his testimony to corroborate parts of Carmen's account and the alleged fentanyl procurement process.

Although, since his initial interview with police, he had changed his story and said that it was oxycodone. And we did discuss that, how when you're buying street drugs, you really aren't guaranteed what you're getting. You're kind of at the mercy of the seller. Well, yeah, and I think that's a big cause of many fentanyl overdoses, is people don't know there's fentanyl in what they're buying. So there were forensic scientists and toxicology experts who explained the laboratory findings that showed Eric died from the fentanyl poisoning. Their testimony was central to establishing the cause of death and also supported the prosecution's claim that Eric's overdose was intentional.

rather than accidental. Also, Cody Wright, Eric's business partner, testified, and he described Eric as hardworking and stated he had never observed him using drugs. He was also able to testify about Valentine's Day 2022 when he got a phone call from Eric where Eric sounded frightened and urgent. And this was evidence that the prosecution would link to an alleged earlier poisoning attempt. George Throckmorton, who's a handwriting and crime scene expert, he testified regarding signatures and documents connected to insurance matters. Prosecutors relied on this testimony.

to support the fraud and forgery allegations that accompanied the murder charge. And finally, there's Detective Jeff O'Driscoll, lead investigator. O'Driscoll was the prosecution's lead case investigator and one of his final witnesses. He tied together evidence from witnesses, phone records, searches, and the broader homicide investigation. Right. And remember, there was that PI that the Richens family had hired, and he came in in a neck brace and said he didn't take his pain pills that morning so he could be clear-headed. He was impressive to watch. He really made a good impression. He got up off the sickbed to testify. Yeah.

Now, overall, the prosecution's case focused on the three themes, motive, financial problems and insurance money, means obtaining fentanyl through intermediaries, and proof that Eric's death was an intentional poisoning rather than an accidental overdose. So instead of presenting witnesses, the defense attorneys focused on attacking the prosecution's evidence through their cross-examination. But once the prosecution rested and the judge asked the defense who was going to be their first witness, they said, can we have a minute, Your Honor? And this was quite a moment. I thought it was fascinating.

It was like they were whispering, discussing who their next witness would be. And then all of a sudden, the attorney stands up and says, actually, we're going to rest. No witnesses. It almost seems like they were prepared to put Corey on the stand or at least put some witnesses for her on the stand and realized that they didn't have anyone. Yeah. Or I think that they thought that any witnesses they would put on the stand would be easily impeached by the prosecutor and actually make things worse, which is pretty much what happens when defendants decide not to testify. It's not because they don't want to testify to the questions that they're...

Defense attorney asked them, it's the cross-examination, the dreaded cross-examination that they want to avoid. That's where you get beat up. That's a big risk. It's worked for some people, but I really don't think it would have worked out for Corey. So mainly the defense's argument was, where's the proof? And they were kind of right about that. They argued that investigators never found any fentanyl in Corey's possession, so they never found a murder weapon. And they couldn't show exactly how the fentanyl had gotten into Eric's body, although they did know that he'd taken it orally.

The defense said the prosecution had a theory, but not enough hard evidence to prove murder beyond a reasonable doubt. But, you know, one of the prosecution's most dramatic pieces of evidence was that walk the dog letter. That really, I think that did her in. I don't know that there's any reasonable explanation for that. No, it's just to say that it was fiction and it's just not believable at all.

So we've got these two fundamental disagreements. The prosecution says all the evidence pointed to Corey getting the fentanyl, having these motives and poisoning her husband, while the defense said the state's case was relying too heavily on assumptions and circumstantial evidence, and that too many important questions remained unanswered. So I would say the defense's strongest point was that investigators never recovered any fentanyl or any physical evidence directly linking Corey to giving Eric the fentanyl. What do you think? Well, that's true. But there's a lot of other evidence. But it is a circumstantial case. Totally. Yeah. But there's plenty of circumstantial cases that have been judged. Yeah. It doesn't necessarily make it a weak case. No. Well, I mean, if you're being told it's a circumstantial case, the implication is that it shouldn't be a case. Right. Well, I mean, that's something defense attorneys say. Sure. Yeah.

But I think most jurors know enough to know that circumstantial evidence is still evidence. Thank you. Right. Well, the jury went out. And how long did it take them to get a verdict? It was... Three hours. Yeah, a little less than three hours, I think. She was found guilty on all counts. But the aftermath of the case has been as tragic as the trial itself. A jury convicted Corey of murdering Eric after prosecutors argued that she got fentanyl and used it to poison him. The defense never called any witnesses and instead argued that the state had failed to prove exactly how the fentanyl was administered.

or produce direct physical evidence. Now, it's not that unusual. I think we've seen many cases just recently where the defense doesn't put on a defense. And their argument usually is, well, the prosecution didn't prove the case. They've got the burden, so we don't need to put on a case. But it usually doesn't seem to work out very well. Though it was pretty shocking to a lot of people that she was found guilty of everything because, you know, regardless of anything, it's a big deal to put someone away for life. Then they had the sentencing hearing, and the focus shifted from proving guilt to really what the impact of the crime was.

prosecutors emphasized that Eric's death permanently changed the lives of his family, especially those three boys. They also pointed to evidence such as the walk the dog letter, which the prosecutors said showed an effort to influence testimony after her arrest and also showed a consciousness of guilt. The story didn't end with the verdict. Even before his death, Eric had taken some significant steps to protect his assets. He changed his estate plan.

created the Eric Richens Living Trust, and placed his sister, Katie Richens Benson, in a position of oversight for the benefit of the children, rather than leaving control to Corey. Was Katie the one who has custody of the kids? She dots her and her husband. So Utah has a law that if one spouse is suspected of killing the other spouse, the family of the dead spouse can take custody away. And that's what happened early on, even before she was found guilty, which is kind of hard to believe. She lost custody of them, even though she was, at that point, you know, supposed to be presumed innocent.

But, you know, most of the attention since the conviction is centered on the three boys. Their dad died in 2022, and now their mom is incarcerated following her conviction, leaving them dependent on other family members. Public reporting and trial testimony show that Eric's family, particularly his sister and others involved with the trust, have really played a major role in safeguarding the children's financial interests and future. The estate and trust arrangements were designed to ensure that the money and assets that Eric left behind would benefit the children directly rather than pass under Corey's control. Well, yeah, he's thinking if she gets her hands on any of that money, his kids are not going to see it. I know, but I just don't understand when he was alive why he didn't say that. Because maybe she wouldn't have murdered him if she knew that. So I would just tell the person. It's like, who was Lori Vallow's fourth husband that was shot? Charles. Charles Vallow. Yeah. He had changed some things around. The life insurance wasn't going to go to her. It was going to go to his sister. But he didn't tell Lori that. So she killed him thinking she was going to get the million dollars. Now, I'm not blaming the victims for this. I'm just saying.

Maybe a good idea if you think someone's going to kill you to let them know they're not going to benefit from your death. Might be something to think about if you ever find yourself in that position. Are you speaking to me directly? No, in general, in general, right? Yeah. So what I'd like to do here, just as part of this episode before we move forward, is I'd like to play the victim impact statements from Corey's three sons. There were actually professional counselors and advocates who read the son's victim impact statements at Corey's sentencing hearing. And this was brutal for Corey and really sad for the boys, of course.

And wow, they had nothing good to say about their mother. My name is Jessica Black. I'm a licensed clinical mental health therapist and a registered play therapist. Myself and my colleagues are here today to read the victim impact statements for three children. We are here as advocates on their behalf.

After a developmentally appropriate process, the boys were able to decide individually how they wanted to share their statements. And this is what they chose. Our roles are to read their words exactly as they wrote. The boys want the court and the world to hear their side. This is from WR. I woke up to sirens and there were a lot of people at my house and I was definitely scared. I felt confused. I was in the bedroom with my brothers and I didn't know what was happening. At first I was really scared because I didn't know what was happening and I had no control and I felt helpless. I felt really overwhelmed. After my dad died, Corey was in the basement while she was with a neighbor.

I felt scared because I thought something really bad was happening again. She would take me to places that smelled really bad. Everything she did made me feel uncomfortable. When someone talks about Corey, it makes me feel hateful and ashamed. She took away my dad. It's made me have a hard time trusting people. I was scared that Corey's family would come to my school and take me. I had to go to counseling with DCFS in Hebrew and I did not like it. DCFS made me talk to Corey and I couldn't do things that I wanted to do. I felt not important to anyone. I feel a lot better about myself now than I did with Corey. I can't ever see my dad again. I want her to go to prison forever.

If she got out, I would be so scared, really mad, and I wouldn't want to go with her anywhere. I'm worried that she would take me away from Katie and Clint. Once she is gone, I will feel happy, and I will feel safer and relaxed and trust people more. I am Christina Green. I'm a licensed clinical social worker, registered play therapist, and I will be reading for AR. You took away my dad for no reason other than greed, and you only cared about yourself and your stupid boyfriends. You were not caring and watching over me and my brothers. I had to be a parent to W. C and I walked him to the bus stop, feed him to watch him. You were not concerned about our health. When we got hurt, you didn't even care. When C got run over by a side-by-side, you still made him go to the supper game that day without taking him to the doctors first. You would block C in his room, and I would...

have to go to the kitchen and bring him food. You shamed us when we didn't want to eat uncooked lasagna you made. We threw it away because we couldn't eat it. Then you made us watch videos of children starving warriors. You wanted to scare us into eating something that wasn't cooked. You wouldn't let our dog outside, and then the dog would pee inside. You created this problem, then you would smack my dog on the head as hard as you could. You wouldn't let me put my kitten in the garage for safety at night, and we found it eaten by raccoons the next day. You wouldn't let us turn on and use a heater lamp for the chickens and bunnies, and they froze to death.

He would always argue with my dad and lock the door. You were not playing the role as a real mother does. You were doing the opposite. Now my dad can't be my coach anymore. Can't be at any of my games. He won't be at my birthdays. He can't teach me how to drive. He won't be at my graduation and he can't take me camping or fishing. He made me paranoid about sleeping on my dad's side of the bed by saying I might die or get harmed when I was just trying to be close to my dad after he killed him. He took away.

Everything from me and my brothers. I don't want you out of jail because I will not feel safe if you are out. You have never said sorry for anything that you have done to me and my brothers. I don't want you to hurt anyone again. I know that you will need to stay in jail to fully take accountability for what you did to me, C, W, and my dad. With you and y'all, I will be able to continue to feel safe and live a happy and successful life without fear of you hurting me or anyone I love. Thank you, Europa. My name is Sarah. I'm a licensed clinical social worker and registered play therapist. And I'm going to read the victim impact statement for CR.

My name and age now, my name and age I was at the time of the crime. CR, age 12, now 13. I was nine when my dad was murdered. What I would like to see happen if the perpetrator is convicted of the crime, I would like to see Corey get a life sentence. My thoughts regarding an appropriate sentence for the person who is accused of this crime and if they are found guilty. I think Corey should get a life sentence because what she did is very sick. Because it had no reason to happen and it impacted a bunch of people, including me. These are some reasons why I think.

She should have a life sentence. The information I feel is important for the judge to be aware of in sentencing. I think the judge should know that my dad was a good person and very thoughtful and kind and helped whoever needed help. He was always taking the extra mile to help people. My physical injuries as a result of this crime are as follows. I was sleeping and then I went to get a drink of water, then went back to bed. And when I woke up shaking and Bailey called the ambulance and they came and I couldn't talk for a while, I think Corey had something to do with it because she didn't call the ambulance. She called Bailey and Bailey called the ambulance.

At the ER, Corey resisted to have my blood drawn, and kids who usually have this kind of seizure is when they are a few months old to a year old. I learned later that Corey bought more fentanyl and had it in the house when this happened. I think this is what happened. She did what she did to my dad in the living room. My experience of emotional injury because of this crime is described as follows. Sad. I feel mad that I have to feel sad. I went from being scared for my life to feeling really good. I was scared for my life because I didn't eat that much.

Cory was always drunk or gone. I was always locked in my room. I can't remember, but I'm pretty sure the lock was on the outside. Cory threatened she would kill my lizard because we didn't want to watch some weird show with her. All of our chickens died because there was no food or water. My rabbit died because we didn't have food or water. The goats almost struck to death because she bought moldy hay and she didn't water them. Nothing ever got fed or watered. It didn't feel good to worry about my animals. I felt like I had to take care of my siblings. Ash mostly took care of me, though, because I was locked in my room.

Ash would bring me food. Corey would lock me up if I told her she was drunk. This happened pretty much daily. I feel angry that she locked me in my room. I'm angry almost all my animals died. I'm angry she threatened to kill them. I'm angry she killed my dad. I started to feel really good when I moved into a safe place. It was safe because the people around me were safe. Katie and Clint. I felt safe at Jake and Shilina because I wasn't with Corey anymore.

I want the judge to know my dad was a good person and I miss my dad. I miss my dad, but I do not miss how my life used to be. I don't miss Corey. I will tell you that. Thank you.

They were 10, 9, and 6 when their father died. Yes. And then this was three years later. So you just have to think, did they always feel that way about their mom? Or being with Eric's sister certainly could have influenced how they felt about their mom. Oh, I think so. But they had horrible things to say about her. If she wasn't such a miserable human being, I would have felt some pity for her. But, you know, I don't think she really cared about those kids. No, they were just players. Yeah, exactly. So it's just a really...

Kind of heartbreaking human story. What began as the death of a husband evolved into this highly publicized murder trial. But the people most affected are those kids. We've got these battles over money, insurance and guardianship. But no matter what, it's going to affect them for the rest of their lives. I just can't imagine knowing that your mother killed your father. And, you know, the two older boys, at least, will probably remember that night. Oh, they'll certainly remember that night. Yes, exactly. So just really heartbreaking. It's time for listener feedback.

Okay, what have we got for feedback? I've got some voicemails and just one little tidbit to discuss. So we've got a voicemail from Mallory. Mallory, why don't you come on over, Mallory? I guess when I think of Mallory, here's how old I am. I think of Family Ties and Michael J. Fox's little sister was named Mallory. It's kind of an unusual but beautiful name. So let's hear what Mallory came on over to say. Hi, Jill and Dick. This is Mallory, longtime listener. And I actually started subscribing to your premium membership last year, which I love. So thank you guys for all your hard work.

reading about the case of Sidney Sutherland. And I had recently listened to your episode on the Sherry Papini kidnapping hoax. And I was struck by some of the similarities between what Sherry lied and said happened and what actually happened in this case. Sidney Sutherland went out for a run and disappeared and ended up being found out that she was murdered and sexually assaulted by someone she went to high school with. And he participated in the searches for her and was like very close to the investigation, which was weird. And I just thought that would be an interesting case for you. And I had never heard about it.

So again, love the show and I'll keep listening. Thanks. Thank you, Mallory. So the first thing Dick said to me was, what do those two cases have to do with each other? So I thought it over and I'm thinking, well, you know what? Sherry Papini probably read about that case and many others, or at least a few others, before she came up with her story. And I find that to be disgusting. It's insulting to true victims of violent crime to make up something like that. Well, this case was in 2025, which was after the Papini case. Well, there goes my theory. Okay. But I'm sure that Sherry Papini did look at other cases.

Yeah. You need to see what you have to do to make your story believable. Absolutely. And otherwise, I mean, both women were pretty attractive blondes who liked to exercise. But anyway, I just found Sherry Pepini to be disgusting. And of course, she blamed it on Latino women because it's always the minorities that you're going to blame, isn't it? Well, they're the best scapegoats. Yeah, absolutely. All right. So let's get back to Sydney Sutherland. We've kind of gotten off topic. So what happened with Sydney? Well, Sydney was a 25-year-old nurse who lived with her boyfriend for four years in a little town in Arkansas called Grubbs. Sydney was outgoing, intelligent, and quite attractive.

was very interested in keeping fit. A runner, right? A runner. Yeah. She exercised quite a bit. And at 5 foot 3 inches tall and 103 pounds, she was in excellent physical condition. Tiny. On the petite side. So one afternoon in 2025, she went for a run along one of her favorite routes and did not return home. She'd been seen by a UPS driver between 2.30 and 3 p.m., running easily with no apparent distress. She was also seen at that same time by a neighbor, Quake Llewellyn. Quake also told the authorities that Sydney appeared to be well. Well, yeah, she's out running. Yeah. So a massive search was undertaken. Her cell phone and Fitbit were found.

The next day. So that's not a real encouraging sign. No, that's ominous. And her mother found a small white bead from a bracelet that Sidney wore. And then not long after that, her body was found buried in a shallow grave. Oh, what a shame, huh? Now, one early suspect was the neighbor, Quake Llewellyn. He was actually already a suspect because he had a history. A history of peeping into windows trying to see younger women undressed. He stalked some people. And he had a history of cruelty to animals. Fucker. He was a married man. He had three stepchildren. Well, that's scary.

For those kids, I mean. It is. There wasn't any mention of anything when I'm between him and the stepkids. Yeah, but you know, a lot of that domestic stuff does not get reported. Yeah. So before the police approached him, Quake walked into the police station and confessed to Sidney's murder. He said he was driving down the street when he saw her running. He drove past her, made a U-turn, and he drove into her. Struck her with his truck. So on purpose? Yes. Oh my God. He then placed her body in his truck, took her to a remote location, and buried her. But not before he had sexual intercourse with her dead body. Oh my God. So Llewellyn was charged with capital murder, kidnapping, rape.

and abuse of a corpse. Before he was tried, a plea bargain was made with Sidney's family. They agreed to drop the kidnapping and abuse charges if Llewellyn pleaded guilty to the capital murder and rape charges. Well, you know, they just wanted to get it over with and not sit through a trial. Oh, that's for sure. You certainly can't blame them after going through such a nightmare. He got life in prison with no possibility of parole. All right. Adios, Quake. This guy's got a history. Yeah. So why was he even out? Was he out on parole or something? Or had he served his time? I don't know if he did any time. Wow. Well, you know, they say it's progressive. So if you start out peeking in windows...

You're likely going to work up to sexual assault. And many people will work up to murder after that. So it's just really scary. Okay. Another voicemail? Another voicemail from Tony. Tony. Hi, Dick and Jill. It's Tony from Australia. I've just watched the Heli investigation. It was very good. And I love it when you do a podcast and in the middle of it, you have a little bit of a giggle about something and you were giggling about something like a lunacy court or something like that. And as though, does this really exist?

In Australia, we have such a thing and it's called a Lunacy and Inebriates Act of 1937. That was actually brought into being in about 1898. And the funniest thing is that we actually have a master of lunacy, which sort of conjures up the idea of a wizard with a wand or something like that. And I had experience with this many, many years ago in a legal case where I had a solicitor who said to me, You probably should settle this case really quickly because this person could end up in lunacy court because they are quite mad. So I settled up fairly quickly. Anyhow, I love the case and I had a really good laugh over that lunacy act in it. Keep up the good work and thank you for doing a wonderful podcast. Goodbye. So we didn't think there was any such thing. Thank you so much, Tony. That is kind of hilarious. It is funny.

It's old language. I see that. But just the way she put it, how the client was quite mad. Lunacy and inebriated action. Yeah. Amazing. So thank you for educating us about that, Tony. I'm sure many of our listeners got a kick out of that one. That is it for our voicemails. And Dick has done a little looking into this recent issue with Krista Pike. Now, this is a case we covered back in 2018. This was the murder that happened at...

A job corps. In Tennessee. Yeah. So tell us a little bit about the murder and then we'll talk about what happened with the execution attempt on Krista Pike. Well, Krista Pike, along with a couple other students, were responsible for the murder of Colleen Slimmer. This is in January 1995. Apparently, Krista was concerned that Colleen was stealing her boyfriend. This was not the case, but nevertheless, she was beaten to death and Krista was sentenced to be executed. So this is pretty vivid in my memory. And I know that the other two didn't get the death penalty. No, she's the only one. Actually, the boyfriend made a deal, right?

I believe it was him. Okay, so what's going on now? So the execution was to take place on September 30th. So she was, she got the death penalty. She was to receive a lethal injection of pentobarbital, a barbiturate, and that's following a protocol. Now that's different than what we used to have. Well, every state gets to determine how they're going to execute people or not execute people. The way it used to be, it was like a three medication mix. They would be given, and this is all intravenously, the prisoner would be given a sedative followed by a paralytic.

Followed by potassium chloride. To stop the heart. To stop the heart. And that was quite effective. It was. But I think that the prisons started getting into trouble trying to get these drugs. Yes, it was difficult. Yeah. And it stayed difficult because what they switched to was another barbiturate. And only that. And only that. But this one, this barbiturate would put you to sleep. And if you slept deeply enough, you died. Right. Well, it's basically like giving someone an opioid overdose. Yeah. Yeah. So what went wrong? Well, one more little comment. I'm sorry. Go ahead. They went from that.

three-tiered drug mix to one thiopental. That's the barbitrum. But that got to be short supply. So that's how they ended up with pentobarbital. And you're going to give that depending on the weight of the person. So the first sign that there's trouble occurred when they had real difficulty finding a vein. She apparently had little teeny tiny veins. There were several attempts. I think a half dozen or so attempts were made. Well, who's doing this? It's not doctors, right? No, it's staff. It's probably not nurses because it goes against the oaths of health care providers. Well, it certainly goes against the Hippocratic Oaths.

So, yeah. Volunteers, maybe? I guess you'd have to be a volunteer. I don't know. Yeah, that's something we should probably look into is who actually does this. Anyway, I interrupted. She was stuck, I don't know, half a dozen times or so before they finally found a vein that could be cannulated. So we're going to give this pentobarbital based on the weight of the person. And it's given intravenously. So it's mixed with some IV fluid, like normal saline or lactated ringers. Those are the common. When they gave the dose, Krista started screaming, complaining her arm was burning and quite painful. So probably an infiltration. So they gave a second dose and the protocols for this pentobarbital for...

executions allow for a second dose or repeat dose. So they gave her two doses. Well, you think you just keep giving it until they stop breathing. Why would there be a limit? You're killing the person. Well, why does it matter? In her case, the IV wasn't in a vein. So they were giving her subcutaneous medication. And why are they even bothering with the peripheral vein? They could go right for the carotid. Well, yeah, but that would require a little bit more expertise than might be available. And there is none. After those two doses, she's still breathing. Wow, what a nightmare. And it was taken to the hospital. So was this being witnessed? Yeah. Okay. And they took her to the hospital. It's just weird to me. They're killing her.

So why are they now taking her to the hospital? They have no protocol to give her another dose? No. Holy shit. I was wondering that too. This just seems, you know, like torture. I'm pretty acquainted with the murder and it was a horrible murder that Krista Pike committed, but this is torture. Just doesn't seem like a civilized way to deal with things. I was thinking to myself, oh, that sounds cruel. Why do you try to resuscitate her? Yeah. You're supposed to be executing her, but be that as it may. So she's in the hospital and just today it was reported that Krista's awake and speaking. Wow. And it's somewhat ambulatory.

Wow. So she has phlebitis and she has pneumonia. But one term prognosis is guarded because nobody can tell whether she suffered any brain damage or not. Yeah, but if she's speaking, it's probably not severe brain damage. So I know that they had a press conference. Her attorneys, yeah. Yeah. And what did they have to say? Well, they condemned the whole procedure, but they were doing it anyway. Yeah. Well, they're anti-death penalty. They've asked the governor of Tennessee to commute her death sentence to life in prison without parole. Fair enough to me. I would do that. But of course, we're not pro-death penalty.

because this is just torture what they did. And she was, you know, she was young when she did this. She'd been sexually abused. She'd had a horrible life. So there were, in my opinion, a lot of mitigating circumstances to her even getting the death sentence in the first place. So at the very least, I think she should have life without parole. Yeah, I mean, she's been on death row for 30 years. So that's a huge amount of punishment right there. Well, yeah, I think if she did this murder in Australia or most parts of Europe, she would have gotten out in 15 or 20 years. Yeah, but she did it in Tennessee. Yeah, that's true. Okay. So yes, it's fascinating.

I would love to hear opinions on this. So that's why I put this in. Yeah. So if any of you listeners would like to share your opinions, opposing opinions are very welcome. I'd really like to hear about it because I know this isn't the first time that they've had difficulty executing people, but this one just seems remarkable that they took her to the hospital and she's awake. Wow. Awake now. She wasn't awake when she got to the hospital. Well, no, but she's alive. Yeah. And now she's waking up. And here's another one interesting tidbit. Okay. A week after her failed execution, a guy in Texas was executed using the same method. And it worked? And it worked.

Well, I was reading in, I believe it was the Washington Post, an article saying that really the most humane way is the firing squad because it's a sure thing. And because the electric chair is very painful. So most methods are very painful. What's a humane method for putting one to death? Yeah. Well, yeah, that's why I'm really not for it. I think life in prison is probably adequate, especially for this person. Yes. Yeah. Okay. Well, we'll keep an eye on this and see what happens. And we'll be standing by for some feedback. It's actually been over a week that the attempted execution happened. It was September 30th.

Not to blabber on, but I really appreciate everyone being here and listening today. And I'd like to see you next time at The Quiet End. Please, if you don't mind. We'd love to have you. Yeah. So see you next time at The Quiet End. Come on down. Bye-bye. Bye, guys.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of True Crime Brewery?

This episode is 1 hour and 47 minutes long.

When was this True Crime Brewery episode published?

This episode was published on October 12, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this True Crime Brewery episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.