The Girl Who Always Ordered Cherry Pie episode artwork

EPISODE · May 10, 2026 · 6 MIN

The Girl Who Always Ordered Cherry Pie

from Last Call at the Diner — Fexingo Horror · host Fexingo

At the Diamondback Diner outside Waco, Texas, in the summer of 2016, Luna worked the 3-to-11 shift. There was a girl who came in every Tuesday night, always alone, always ordered a slice of cherry pie and a black coffee. She said she was driving through, but she never seemed to get any farther. Her name was Marisol. She wore a silver locket that she never opened. One night, a man in a gray sedan followed her inside. He sat two booths away, watching. He didn't order anything. He just stared at the back of her head. Luna tried to warn her. Marisol just smiled, like she'd been expecting him. Then she told Luna a story about a road that doesn't end, a debt that can't be paid, and a promise she made to someone she loved. By the time Luna looked away and back, both of them were gone. The pie sat untouched. The coffee went cold. And Luna has never forgotten the way Marisol's reflection didn't match her face in the diner window. #LastCallAtTheDiner #DiamondbackDiner #WacoTexas #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #AnthologyHorror #SoloNarrated #LunarTales #CherryPie #SilverLocket #GraySedan #PhantomPatron #TheRoadThatDoesntEnd #SouthwestGothic #MidnightEncounters #StorytellingHorror #AtmosphericHorror #LooseEnds #DinerHorror #LateNightHorror Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo

At the Diamondback Diner outside Waco, Texas, in the summer of 2016, Luna worked the 3-to-11 shift. There was a girl who came in every Tuesday night, always alone, always ordered a slice of cherry pie and a black coffee. She said she was driving through, but she never seemed to get any farther. Her name was Marisol. She wore a silver locket that she never opened. One night, a man in a gray sedan followed her inside. He sat two booths away, watching. He didn't order anything. He just stared at the back of her head. Luna tried to warn her. Marisol just smiled, like she'd been expecting him. Then she told Luna a story about a road that doesn't end, a debt that can't be paid, and a promise she made to someone she loved. By the time Luna looked away and back, both of them were gone. The pie sat untouched. The coffee went cold. And Luna has never forgotten the way Marisol's reflection didn't match her face in the diner window. #LastCallAtTheDiner #DiamondbackDiner #WacoTexas #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #AnthologyHorror #SoloNarrated #LunarTales #CherryPie #SilverLocket #GraySedan #PhantomPatron #TheRoadThatDoesntEnd #SouthwestGothic #MidnightEncounters #StorytellingHorror #AtmosphericHorror #LooseEnds #DinerHorror #LateNightHorror Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo

NOW PLAYING

The Girl Who Always Ordered Cherry Pie

0:00 6:30

No transcript for this episode yet

We transcribe on demand. Request one and we'll notify you when it's ready — usually under 10 minutes.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is this episode of Last Call at the Diner — Fexingo Horror?

This episode is 6 minutes long.

When was this Last Call at the Diner — Fexingo Horror episode published?

This episode was published on May 10, 2026.

What is this episode about?

At the Diamondback Diner outside Waco, Texas, in the summer of 2016, Luna worked the 3-to-11 shift. There was a girl who came in every Tuesday night, always alone, always ordered a slice of cherry pie and a black coffee. She said she was driving...

Can I download this Last Call at the Diner — Fexingo Horror episode?

Yes, you can download this episode by clicking the download button on the episode player, or subscribe to the podcast in your preferred podcast app for automatic downloads.
URL copied to clipboard!