Skip to content
The Gnostic is a Believer episode artwork

Jan 23, 2023 10 min

The Gnostic is a Believer

from The Daily Eudemon Hosted by Eric Scheske

Did you take a sociology class in high school or college? Did you know sociology’s founder, August Comte (1798-1857), was kind of a dick? The Encyclopedia Britannica says he was “ungrateful,” “self-centered,” and “egocentric.” If those aren’t bad enough, other biographers say he was a megalomaniac, cruel, and downright nuts. Comte, on the other hand, considered himself a relevant man, to put it modestly. He was born at the end of the Enlightenment and fully embraced its ideals,[1]which Isaiah Berlin summarized as: 1. Every genuine question can be answered. If it can’t be answered, it’s not a genuine question. 2. The answers to the questions can be discovered, learned, and taught. 3. All the answers are compatible with one another. Those ideals are captured perfectly by science. Science is the discipline of power: it answers questions and puts them into neat boxes. Physics is especially good at this. Comte concluded that the principles of physics could be applied to society: “social physics” is what he initially called it before calling it “sociology.” By applying scientific findings and mathematical truths to social interactions, the government and its intellectual advisers could greatly improve society. He was positive it would work. He was so positive, in fact, that he popularized the term “Positivism” to describe his and other contemporary academics’ extremely positive expectations of science Comte was hailed as an academic hero. The French erected statues and monuments in his honor and named streets after him. He had replaced the hidebound restrictions of tradition, king, and pope with the only thing that could be trusted: science, bolstered by math. No more religion, just facts. SHOW NOTES HERE

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Gnostic is a Believer

0:00 10:51
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The weekly new demon full steam ahead. All right, back after a week hiatus. Hope everyone doesn't mind this new approach. Basically, it's probably gonna be more or less a substantive essay in the existence strikes back vein every two weeks on the off week will be a lighter essay slash podcast on the newsletter type thing.

Hopefully that works for everyone. So did you take a sociology class in high school or college? Did you know sociology's founder, August Comte, was kind of a dick? I mean, things like the Peter Britannica says he was ungrateful, self-centered, and egocentric.

And if those aren't bad enough, other biographers say he was a megalomaniac, cruel, and downright nuts. Comte, on the other hand, considered himself a relevant man, to put it modestly. This was not a man lacking in self-confidence. He was born at the end of the enlightenment, and he fully embraced its ideals, which if you recall, Isaiah Berlin summarized the enlightenment ideals as follows.

One, every genuine question can be answered. If it can't be answered, it's not a genuine question. The second premise of the enlightenment. The answers to the questions can be discovered, learned, and taught.

And the third element is all the answers are compatible with one another. That's enlightenment thinking and their ideals. They're captured perfectly by science. Science is the discipline of power.

It answers questions and puts them into neat boxes. Physics is especially good at this. And Comte concluded that the principles of physics could be applied to society. Social social physics is what this idiot actually called it before he called it sociology.

At first it was social physics. It would be the laws of physics to society, and we all have a perfect place to live. By basically by applying scientific findings and then mathematical truths, government and its intellectual advisors could greatly improve society, if not make it perfect. He was positive it would work.

He was so positive, in fact, that he popularized the term positivism to describe his and other contemporary academics' extremely positive expectations of science. Comte was hailed as an academic hero. The French erected statues and monuments in his honor and named streets after this idiot. He had successfully replaced the high bound restrictions of tradition, king, and pope with the only thing that could be trusted, science, bolstered by math.

No more religion, just facts. Good old Comte. But maybe not. Comte himself, and possibly his only one genuine insight, he did not think it was possible to get rid of religion.

Comte believed, or he was positive, that modern science can reform society, but to do this, Comte taught, God and questions of being must be wholly excluded. But he also understood that such things could not just be stomped out. They had to be replaced. He said, quote, only what is replaced is destroyed, unquote.

Comte seemed to sense, seemed to acknowledge that we exist as a greater whole. He knew mankind needed to worship, that such an urge is at the heart of human nature. He just wanted mankind to worship humanity instead of God. Humanity, for Comte, was, quote unquote, the only true great, excuse me, the one truly great being, unquote.

I'm not sure it ever even occurred to Comte that questions of existence and being are hardwired into us because we are metaphysicians, creatures who exist in the metaxy, that area between transcendence and imminence that I talk so much about. We are beings whose reality is on the continuum of the Tao, essence, existence, the reality spectrum. Those things never crossed Comte's mind. He simply acknowledged that it was a fact, perhaps a vestige of a bygone era, and that the fact must be re-engineered through positivism to replace God with humanity.

Comte took positivism's role as a divine substitute seriously. This guy was dead nuts. He was nuts, but he was dead serious. He wanted to actually make a, quote unquote, religion of humanity.

Here is a handful, a handful of the crap he taught and pushed for to celebration. Again, he was a, people thought this guy was a genius, and again, he was just an idiot. But anyway, Comte taught that there must be a, quote unquote, positive priesthood to administer the new spiritual power created by social physics. He was convinced that he would be preaching positivism by 1860 at the cathedral of Notre Dame there in Paris, not the South End.

He'd be teaching this as the only real and complete religion. By 1860, he thought Catholics would be wiped out and posit the religion of positivism would reign, the religion of humanity. He envisioned that a great statue would be erected to the deity of humanity, which would sit atop the altar of Notre Dame, which would be repurposed for his new religion, complete with newly minted rituals and sacraments. Toward the end of his life, he thought a, quote unquote, positivist papacy had become a reality through his work.

I don't know if he thought he was like the first pope here of the positive papacy, but it sounds like it. And he thought that this would be carried on in the same manner the Catholic Church carried on from pope to pope. There'd be a positive pope, then the positive pope. He thought there there should be nine, quote unquote, social sacraments, including one that is received after death and resembles the Catholic Church's process of canonization.

He wanted society to adopt the new calendar, which would replace the church's liturgical year and the secular Gregorian calendar. This calendar would have 13 months, each named for a great man in European history, with each day of the year dedicated to other great men or women, thereby effectively replacing replacing religious holidays and saint feast days with secular equivalents. These are actual things he tried to accomplish. And he tried to accomplish it because he is exhibit A of the third Gnostic trait articulated by Eric Vogelin, belief.

The third characteristic is the belief that salvation from the evil of the world is possible. That's the Vogelin quote. So remember, the Gnostic is dissatisfied with her situation. That's trait one.

She believes her unsatisfactory situation is a result of a world that's poorly organized. Trait two. But instead of giving up, she embraces the belief that the world can be changed. It can be organized better with the result that her innate unhappiness and dissatisfaction can be eliminated.

This is belief trait three. It's not hard to see how the Gnostic belief attains religious fervor, which is a constant theme, by the way, of James Lindsay's ongoing critiques of Marxist critical theory and postmodernism. I'll get into those things later. But if you go in the show notes, you see a link here to James Lindsay's website, Social Counter.

I can't remember what it's called now, but there's a link there. So now let's get back to Comte, who is, I want to emphasize, the first modern Gnostic in these podcasts. I mean, Machiavelli, Bacon, Descartes, even Rousseau, they weren't Gnostics. Rousseau might have been.

He's just so bizarre. It's hard to say anything for sure about him. But make no doubt about it. Comte was a Gnostic.

The first Gnostic trait, discontentment. Comte was intensely unhappy and discontented, which spurred him to be cruel to his wife, a reformed prostitute that he persistently vilified in public, including the pamphlets that contained explicit details of her former life. The second Gnostic trait Comte had, you know, belief that discontentment is the world's fault. Comte's personal life seethed, seethed with this trait of discontentment.

And then the third Gnostic trait, belief that salvation for the world is possible. That's Comte's explicitly embracing that, his religion of humanity. So the bottom line is, you keep in mind, the Gnostic is a believer, and Comte was a fervent one. Now, there are three more traits to be covered.

Comte hits all those as well, but I'm getting ahead of myself. Traits four, five, and six will be addressed in future podcasts. As always, thanks for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Eudemon?

This episode is 10 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Eudemon episode published?

This episode was published on January 23, 2023.

Can I download this The Daily Eudemon episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.