EPISODE · Jun 1, 2026 · 6 MIN
The Holloway Sisters' House on Muddy Creek Road
from Holler Tales — Fexingo Horror · host Fexingo
September 1987, just outside a town called Mercy — Luna remembers the summer she was fifteen and her best friend Cassie Holloway stopped talking about what was happening in her own house. The Holloway sisters — Cassie and her older sister Rennie — lived in a sagging farmhouse on Muddy Creek Road, a dirt lane that flooded every spring and turned to deep red mud that stuck to your boots like clay. That summer, Cassie started showing up with bruises she couldn't explain, and her room — the one she shared with Rennie — began to smell like wet earth, even when the windows were open. Luna tells the story of the night she finally went inside that room, and what she saw in the crack of the closet door: something that had been living under the house for a long time, something that Rennie had made a bargain with — and that Cassie was paying for. A slow, quiet story about what children do when no one believes them, and what stays in the hollow long after the house is gone. #HollerTales #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #AppalachianHorror #MuddyCreekRoad #MercyTennessee #HollowaySisters #CassiesRoom #RenniesBargain #UnderTheHouse #RedClayMud #September1987 #SistersOfTheHollow #TheCreekRemembers #BruisesThatCantBeExplained #SlowBurnHorror #AtmosphericHorror #SoloNarrated Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
What this episode covers
September 1987, just outside a town called Mercy — Luna remembers the summer she was fifteen and her best friend Cassie Holloway stopped talking about what was happening in her own house. The Holloway sisters — Cassie and her older sister Rennie — lived in a sagging farmhouse on Muddy Creek Road, a dirt lane that flooded every spring and turned to deep red mud that stuck to your boots like clay. That summer, Cassie started showing up with bruises she couldn't explain, and her room — the one she shared with Rennie — began to smell like wet earth, even when the windows were open. Luna tells the story of the night she finally went inside that room, and what she saw in the crack of the closet door: something that had been living under the house for a long time, something that Rennie had made a bargain with — and that Cassie was paying for. A slow, quiet story about what children do when no one believes them, and what stays in the hollow long after the house is gone. #HollerTales #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #AppalachianHorror #MuddyCreekRoad #MercyTennessee #HollowaySisters #CassiesRoom #RenniesBargain #UnderTheHouse #RedClayMud #September1987 #SistersOfTheHollow #TheCreekRemembers #BruisesThatCantBeExplained #SlowBurnHorror #AtmosphericHorror #SoloNarrated Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
NOW PLAYING
The Holloway Sisters' House on Muddy Creek Road
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.