The Hostage Crisis After 638 Days: Hope and Heartbreak at Hostage Square

In this deeply personal and moving episode recorded on Saturday, July 5th, 2025, host Marc Schulman reflects on nearly two years since the October 7th Hamas attack that led to the current hostage crisis. Speaking from Hostage Square in Tel Aviv, Schulman shares his observations from the weekly rallies he's attended for months, chronicling the emotional toll on families and the Israeli public.The episode explores the historical context of Israel's hostage rescue ethos, from the Entebbe mission to the controversial Gilad Shalit prisoner exchange that released over 1,000 Palestinian prisoners—including future October 7th architect Yahya Sinwar. Schulman examines how that precedent may have influenced Hamas's strategy and analyzes the current state of negotiations.With 20 living hostages still held in Hamas tunnels after 638 days, Schulman discusses the latest diplomatic developments, including renewed hope for a partial deal that could bring home the first group of hostages. He addresses the painful reality of "selectia"—the agonizing process of deciding which hostages return first—and the political constraints preventing a comprehensive agreement.The episode also touches on the broader war's impact, ongoing military casualties, and recent antisemitic attacks in Australia, while maintaining focus on the human cost of the prolonged conflict and the urgent need to bring all hostages home. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit marcschulman.substack.com/subscribe