Hello and welcome to another episode of the Autotrader podcast. My name is Wendy Lesishi. And I'm George Mee. I was like, where did George go? I was trying to get my headphones turned up, but it's fine. Perfect, perfect. But yeah, it's a new episode. And it's October, which means, you know, it's also motoring month. So lots of things are happening within the motoring space right now. One of which being the Smart Mobility Africa conference, which you attended yesterday.
Yes, I did indeed. Yeah, it's primarily just a green energy sort of competition. Well, it's smarter mobility. So, you know, it covers a whole range of possible topics and possible technologies. It's not only about the vehicle. So to give you an example, one of the panel topics was something that the government is actually very heavily driving at the moment, and that is a single ticket payment service. Single ticket payment service for what does that entail? The name escapes me.
Single ticket payment service essay. I'll see now what it's called. If I can find it. But anyway, I don't want to waste your time. But we can put it up as a strapline when we publish this. But basically what it is, is for people to have a single method of payment.
across any public transport system. So you get onto the Gautrain, the Gautrain card, right? Let's call it the Gautrain card. It's not going to be the Gautrain card potentially, but let's call it the Gautrain card. You can use that card to get into a taxi. You can use that card to get on a public train somewhere else. You can use that card to use other mobility services. So there's this single ticket kind of idea. And then, you know, another topic was mobility as a service, which I... But how would that even, like, I can understand the convenience of having one sort of payment solution throughout whatever you're going to be using.
But I mean, I can't see any other benefits of having to integrate the system. There's so many things that you have to do. Yeah, so many things you have to do, but one of the ideas was a wallet-to-wallet transformation. So it doesn't go through the banks until a certain point. I mean, I'm really...
you know, scraping the barrel here, but it doesn't go through the banks at every transaction because there isn't transaction fees incurred. Oh, I see. You know, so it's trying to minimize those transaction fees. So kind of creating a digital wallet of some sort that you can put money in, you can use across the network of partners, and then at some point somebody kind of like either draws off a real bank account or puts into a real bank account. If it's digital, I think it's a good idea because, I mean, I used to take the Gautrain. Yeah, I didn't. I just used the Gautrain card as an example, but yes, digital. So fully digital.
Wallet on your phone, some kind of thing. That's pretty interesting. But, I mean, other things. So you're saying that Smart Mobility Africa is not just about green energy vehicles. It's really about the... It's about Smart Mobility. Smart Mobility. So it's in the name. You know, using technology to... Because even using, you know, wallet payment systems reduces your carbon footprint. 100%. So, you know, so there's a... There's a better way to just do mobility. Exactly. And, you know, a large portion of it is moving to new energy vehicles. Yeah, of course. I mean, that's kind of the hot topic. Speaking of, so one of the new energy...
solutions that have been flagged right now is hydrogen. So hydrogen fuel cell vehicles. And I don't know if you saw it yesterday. I mean, you were there. But Toyota and Cecil and the company called Air Products basically collaborated to introduce hydrogen fuel cell vehicles in the country. I mean, it's been around for a while, hydrogen fuel cell energy. But I don't think there's actually a vehicle in the market that's hydrogen fuel cell that you can just go and buy. I think they're still kind of trialing it out. But this posed a question for me. I had this huge argument with my father yesterday. Is hydrogen...
an option? Is it the future? Is it an alternative to electric vehicles or battery electric vehicles? Or is it just another option that's going to be available to consumers? I think it's going to be just another option that's available to consumers. I don't...
I don't know what the outcome is. I don't think that every day, personally, this is my view, I don't think every consumer level car driving might be hydrogen. Definitely battery electric for the future of passenger vehicles. Hydrogen, I think, is more geared to the commercial environment. Trucking, maybe even down to double cab buckies and buckies. Toyota has just revealed that they're thinking of the Hilux as a hydrogen option. I did see something in Europe that actually launched a Hilux that was hydrogen.
kind of fuel cells. But yesterday specifically was the Mirai. A picture of it. Yes, it's a beautiful car. I mean, it's a beautiful, beautiful car. I went and had a look at it. So if we backtrack a little bit, a hydrogen-powered hydrogen cell in a vehicle, this vehicle, it's effectively, this is an electric car. It is an electric car, ultimately, yeah. Because it's using hydrogen to generate electricity. So all that's happening is the energy is coming from hydrogen as opposed to the energy coming from lithium. Yeah, exactly that. It's the only difference. So it'll come down to energy density. Yeah.
cost to deliver the hydrogen at the point of need. That's what it'll come down to. I mean, that's the biggest challenge right now with hydrogen fuel cell energy. I mean, ultimately, that's why battery electric right now is winning that race. It's because electricity is delivered to everybody's house. Exactly, yeah. And to a large part, that's the reason I think passenger vehicles and lithium-ion powered electric vehicles will win out. So, you know, if we had to kind of just...
Call it what it is. It's lithium-ion-powered electric vehicles or hydrogen-powered electric vehicles. That's what it is. So I'm excited about hydrogen as much as I'm excited about lithium because at the end of the day, it's still an electric car. It's not an internal combustion engine car. You said something interesting now now, which is the biggest challenge is delivery of the fuel ultimately that's going to be powering these vehicles. So I had a conversation with Chad, one of our journalists, and you were saying storage is going to be a big challenge, storing the fuel source of hydrogen, and then just getting the infrastructure sort of... Yeah, so look at the difference between lithium.
and hydrogen yeah okay um the uh the the the storage of lithium okay the storage of energy in in the lithium-ion batteries um occurs in your car. So you store it in your car, in your garage or in the battery. Same as hydrogen-powered electric vehicles. Stored in the fuel cell tank in the car, right? So similar thing. Both are places of storage. Then you backtrack into the system. Lithium-ion, the energy, the electricity that powers the car in the lithium-ion. Where is it stored outside of the car? It's in the grid. It's everywhere. It's not stored. It's not stored anywhere. It's generated on demand. And everywhere.
and yes so so the uh the power stations ramp up or ramp down depending on the demand and they can predict what the demand might be there's a little bit of loss there so you know where the power station might be running and the demand isn't high enough yeah but it's not there's no requirement for storage Okay, so let me finish the hydrogen part. On the flip side though, hydrogen is, you have to store it somewhere in order for the vehicle to fill up. So that's a challenge, because the distribution, that means that there needs to be a well-thought-through distribution plan. So that's why it's suited, I think, to commercial vehicles. Yeah, I mean, if you have a large enough storage facility at different points, then you can just kind of...
I mean, that poses another question or another pro of hydrogen. I mean, it's the most abundant substance in the universe. It's effectively a renewable energy source. So why do you think we've gone this route of not just doing hydrogen fuel cell in the first place and even introducing electric vehicles? I think it's because of transport and storage. Okay. You know, you'll be able to store the stuff effectively. And safely. And safely.
And that requires massive infrastructure. So you've got to build a car with a hydrogen fuel cell as well as now the storage facility. That's a massive capital investment. Who's going to invest in a storage facility if there are no vehicles? So do you expect the OEMs to build the vehicles first and then say, okay, now we've built the X number of these. All right, build storage facilities, please, and distribution facilities. Or does the fuel companies build storage facilities and distribution facilities and then say to the OEMs, okay, now we have all this. They can start building the cars. Okay, so a bit of a chicken and egg. Whereas with battery electric,
It's, the distribution of electricity is already there. It's already there. It was really built up. You know, you might argue that the DC fast charge network, that was the chicken or the egg. Yeah. But 80 to 90% of charging happens in your garage. Electricity is already there. 100%. Speaking of charging, I mean, that's one of the big pros of hydrogen, though, is with regards to, not necessarily range anxiety, but the charging time of, or the refilling time of a hydrogen vehicle happens, you know, you can fill it up in about 10 minutes versus filling up an EV, you know, at certain points, and, you know, a lot longer than that. Is that not something that I think
the hydrogen fuel cell vehicles has over EVs. Yeah, I think there's a lot of benefits in hydrogen. But the application will dictate where it's used. That's why I say for a passenger vehicle, get home, plug your car in, next morning it's full. There's no destination filling. When it comes to commercial application, like a truck or a Bucky, you're going to destination fill during the course of the use of that vehicle because it's probably going to be used most of the day. So you're going to have multiple fills. Whereas in a car, you're going to plug it in at night, wake up the next morning, do your 40Ks to work. That's it.
I hear what you're saying. Okay, so let's backtrack to the conversation that you had actually with Andrew Kirby. So they obviously launched the Mirai yesterday. Well, they didn't launch it. There's two in the country. Yeah, they're just showcasing the technology, right? What is his view, if you've even spoken about it, what is his view on even introducing this vehicle in the market like South Africa? Well, remember, the Mirai's not introduced in South Africa. It's not launched in South Africa. It's just a year as a showcase for the technology, right? So Air Products, the company, Toyota and Sasol have partnered to do this showcase and this...
initiative. And based on the outcomes of this, the future will be dictated. So, you know, let's have to put the cart before the horse. This is really just a beautiful car and looking at ways to build out a strategy effectively. And, you know, hats off to Sasol, Toyota and Air Products for putting this together. What's the point of this project, though? Is it just purely to showcase R&D, understanding what the potential is? I think the latter. I think it's the latter. Understanding what the future is.
and then mapping that out during this phase of that partnership. I'm quite interested to know, specifically with Toyota, because it seems like they've probably invested in this outside of BMW. So don't throw Toyota out as a baby with bathwater. Toyota is hedging their bets. So they have this principle of allowing the consumer to decide. So they're investing in hydrogen. They're investing in battery electric. They're doing research on solid state batteries. They're still building ICE vehicles.
So they're really positioning themselves as, okay, whichever road this takes, we want to be there. Not the leader, necessarily. We want to be there. We want a shot at it. We want a shot at being the leader. At the moment, Tesla's the leader in battery electric. But Tesla's nowhere with hydrogen. Tesla's nowhere, I don't know, well, maybe I'm wrong, but I don't think they're anywhere with solid state. Maybe they are. But Toyota is putting their stakes in every single fire. If you look into the future, what do you see in terms of mobility? So you're seeing...
You're seeing that we're going to be using a wide range of different sources. It's not just going to be this idea of, you know, back in the day it was just petrol or diesel, ultimately. Something will win out in terms of the Pareto principle, 80-20. I think that might be battery electric. Battery cells will change over time.
Electricity will come from different sources, renewable sources, and that will proliferate over time. Remember, electricity production doesn't require storage, and I think that's quite a big factor in that value chain. You require the ability to produce it, either wind, solar, or coal. But its distribution is pretty much there. And it's on demand, so there's no storage needed. Storage might be decentralized in everybody's homes.
So my home, for instance, a battery pack there. So I'm storing Eskom's electricity or the sun's electricity, effectively. But in some instances, Eskom's electricity, I'm storing those batteries. So the storage becomes decentralized. The cost of storage becomes decentralized and fragmented. There's no one company that does all the storage electricity. Other energy sources like fuel, hydrogen, require a storage facility that is not your home. I'm not going to put a tank under my house. With hydrogen or fuel. There's no way. It would be like bombs everywhere. Every single, you know, bombs everywhere. That's exactly what's going to happen. I mean, if you take the five factors that...
that's been plaguing everyone in the industry, that being range, charging, the safety and the emissions and the cost of ownership. In most places where hydrogen and EVs are available, hydrogen is still more expensive than battery electric. I don't think that would be the case in South Africa. I think the only reason why we're having high battery electric vehicle costs is just because of taxes, right? But if you take those five factors aside... No, I don't think it's taxes. I think it's the lack of incentives. It's the flip side of taxes. So there's an element of tax on the import between 18 and 25%. So therein, your statement is right. So you're kind of half right, just don't which half.
So you're right between 18 and 25%. But even if we bring the import taxes down immediately from 18 to 25, massive benefit in that 7%. That's not going to get scale. What's going to get scale is incentive. So that's what we're missing, is incentivizing OEMs to build electric cars, incentivizing consumers to drive electric cars, incentivizing the component industry to build electric car products. 100%. So if you take those five factors, though, can you say one's better than the other, ultimately?
Or do you think it just depends on hydrogen fuel cell versus battery electric? I don't think it's binary. I don't think it's one or the other. It depends entirely on the application. So I think, again, the Pareto principle will play out, the 80-20 principle or theory, in that 80% of the world's vehicles would be battery electric. That's just my own personal kind of insight. And then 20% will be everything else. No, 100%. And then there will be...
certain applications that might buck that, like the commercial environment, like heavy-duty trucks, for instance, might be 80% hydrogen and 20% battery. Or even a hybrid system of, you know, there might even be something that's new that's going to find a way to put these things together. Before I leave you, George, obviously, so you were at the show yesterday, and one of the questions that I had was, what's happening with regards to our adoption rates of EV vehicles in South Africa? What did you see yesterday? What are some of the things that you were shocked by or not surprised by or any sort of insight that you can sort of lay on us for something you didn't go? You know, so what's nice to see at Smarter Mobility is the numbers in terms of the attendance. Yesterday's attendance was brilliant. I mean, we had two chock-a-block, packed-out panel sessions. The Sasol partnership with Toyota and...
and air products as well as the future of electric vehicles, the panel that I moderated, which was nice to see. So I think the trade side, the industry side, is taking this much more seriously than I ever have. On the consumer side, you know the numbers. We're seeing search and sales double every single year, more than double. So it's going to take a couple of years before that becomes exponential.
But I think the demands there, industry is playing a part to create the supply in clever ways. And it's much further than battery electric vehicles, which is also exciting to see. I mean, going back four years when we started doing the buyer survey with our partners, one of the things that you mentioned was there was no partnership. Well, not no partnership, but there was a lack of partnership and the correct kind of partnerships. So are you seeing that definitely happening now? I mean, it sounds like that's what you're saying. Well, look at the Toyota, Sassel and Air Products partnership. 100%, yeah. You know, there's an example of something innovative, something different.
you know, in a very difficult piece of technology, which is hydrogen, you know, in terms of distribution and where the application is. So it's definitely happening. You know, there were scooter businesses, I saw at least two to three of them, were stands up at Smart Mobility. They're golf carts, and golf carts have been around in electric form forever. Maybe they get hydrogen ones.
There's a market right there. Yeah. And so I definitely think it was, it wasn't just about battery electric, which I think was my main takeaway. 100%. I think the market's evolving nicely. Yes. You know, in our, if you go to reports.org, you can download the EV buyer survey that I presented yesterday.
You know part of the presentation was also hybrids being the middle step and and so so there's just it's becoming so much choice for Consumers soft hybrids plug-in hybrids back full battery electric now. We're exploring exploring hydrogen and all of those things just kind of like the The bricks will land in the way they need to land and it's technology. I think that's why the prices you know Yeah, until you get to scale the price will come down 100% so that's pretty much all the time we have for there's no race this weekend Well, no, no, there's no race don't push that button yet I don't think there's a race this weekend last week yeah i think there's a two-week break yeah i think there's a little bit of two-week break so we'll catch that one we'll definitely just see where the next race is yeah it's this weekend It's going to be a Max show. Well, it's at this sprint race that Max can win the championship, right? So they need to pull out all stops to stop it. Just do anything you can. Don't injure the man. But do what you need to to stop this man so we can have a couple more races without a champion. He needs to fight for it. He needs to absolutely fight for it. Anyways, let's see what happens. He's done great, so I'm not going to crash the dude. And now, Mr. Puget, you can go into the jungle. Thanks. We'll see you next time.
Search AutoTrader.