Skip to content
The Leopards Are At It Again episode artwork

Apr 13, 2023 24 min

The Leopards Are At It Again

from Laura Jedeed Hosted by Laura Jedeed

I like Matt Taibbi. I don’t like everything he’s done, I definitely do not like what he’s become, but I respect him. I hate to use the g-word—it’s gauche and pretentious and there can really only be one—but the fact remains: there just aren’t many of us left. Football season is over. Gonzo—more like gone-zo, am I right? Taibbi had that thing, he had that voice, he was iconoclastic and delightful to read. It’s comparatively easy to write an article about a Republican national convention or right-wing musical theater that reads like a 1AM bar conversation with a wasted and insane stranger, but Taibbi did it with the finance beat. You cannot talk me out of my fandom. I’m not here to s**t on my heroes but I’m definitely here to hold them to account. Taibbi just published an article on substack, which is free to read, about everything that led up to his explosive departure from Twitter a few days ago, and it’s incredibly instructive. We can learn from his mistakes. (for those of you who don’t know the Taibbi arc, congratulations and also here’s a summary of both the Twitter Files and the eventual falling out) Taibbi starts out with an analysis of Musk’s Twitter takeover that contains two of them: …From the Washington Post: “Musk’s ‘free speech’ agenda dismantles safety work at Twitter, insiders say.” The Post story was about the “troubling” decision to re-instate the Babylon Bee, and numerous stories like it implied the world would end if this “‘free speech’ agenda” was imposed. I didn’t have to know any of the particulars of the intramural Twitter dispute to think anyone who wanted to censor the Babylon Bee was crazy. To paraphrase Kurt Vonnegut, going to war against a satire site was like dressing up in a suit of armor to attack a hot fudge sundae. Your first mistake—and it’s one you make throughout this article—is letting people you don’t like determine which side you’re on—in this case, apparently, the first four paragraphs of a very long and nuanced article. Never occurred to you that maybe there are accounts worse than the Bee who no longer had a platform on Twitter Dot Com? Never occurred to you that some of them might be peddling ideas that are worth suiting up to oppose? Holocaust denial, white supremacy, endorsement of sexual assault, endorsement of physical violence against trans people? I don’t know for sure how you’d respond to this, of course, but your recent work suggests something like: “I don’t believe in censorship, I believe everyone should have access to a microphone.” and if so, that would be your second mistake. I would once again like to propose the potluck theory of appropriate discourse: if we are both at a potluck and I show up with a giant tray of olives and you hate olives, are allergic to olives, or had a traumatic experience with olives as a child, I still get to put my olives on the table. You don’t have to eat the olives but lots of people enjoy them and they’re good, wholesome food. If, however, I show up to your potluck with a giant tray of feces, you should not let me put that on the table. The problem with serving poop at a potluck isn’t that you don’t personally care for it; it is that eating poop is very dangerous, completely disgusting, and just having it on the table is going to ruin the meal for everyone. Put another way: You go on to make a third mistake, which doesn’t seem as morally fraught as the other two but might be the most dangerous misconception yet, in a roundabout way: This was an obvious moral panic and the very real consternation at papers like the Washington Post and sites like Slate over these issues seemed to offer the new owners of Twitter a huge opening. With critics this obnoxious, even a step in the direction of free speech values would likely win back audiences that saw the platform as a humorless garrison of authoritarian attitudes What year do you think this is, Matt? Do you think there’s a huge contingent of people in this country who actually value free speech? Forget about the s**t platter: the 2023 Internet is a place where people spend all day, every day, screaming about olives. Maybe the olives have Dylan Mulvaney’s face on them and maybe the olives are people who used an ableist slur back in 2010, but everyone seems to agree that the olives have to go. Did it ever occur to you to ask whether Elon Musk also had a penchant for banning olives from the table? Whether maybe, like so many other people, his “free speech absolutist” position was a euphamism for “free speech absolutist when it comes to speech I like”? Of course not. This was the context under which I met Musk and the circle of adjutants who would become the go-betweens delivering the material that came to be known as the Twitter Files. I would have accepted such an invitation from Hannibal Lecter, but I actually liked Musk. His distaste for the blue-check thought police who’d spent more than a half-year working themselves into hysterics at the thought of him buying Twitter — which had become the private playground of entitled mainstream journalists — appeared rooted in more than just personal animus. Once again, you are allowing your enemies to define your position. “I don’t like hysterical crying libs so anyone who also doesn’t like them must be friendly.” Incorrect! Patently untrue! I am infamously at war with mice right now, and leopards eat mice, but I am not going to invite a leopard into my apartment to take care of the mouse problem. Because then I’d have a leopard problem. I would have accepted such an invitation from Hannibal Lecter Well, there’s the trouble. Moreover the decision to release the company’s dirty laundry for the world to see was a potentially historic act. To this day I think [Musk] did something incredibly important by opening up these communications for the public. I haven’t written about the Twitter files because I haven’t carved out time to pour over them in earnest. They are interminable and difficult to parse in their current format, the story is really complicated, and you’ve also been sloppy. But you’re not wrong about the importance of the documents. I’m not like you, Matt. I don’t let my enemies determine my positions. I don’t forget the FBI is dangerous just because Hannibal Lecter is the one telling me so. It matters, a lot, that the FBI had intense pull over Twitter moderation. It matters a lot that tiny accounts got shut down over making dumb jokes about when election day was, and that the Hunter Biden laptop story was suppressed; the laptop is a nothing story but coordinated government suppression of an inconvenient headline scares the s**t out of me. Hannibal helps Clarice. She accepts that help. At some points she even likes him. But she never fully forgets that he’s a killer, a psychopath, a monster with an agenda of his own. Not you, though: Normally when someone comes to you with a story you ask what it is they want or expect out of press coverage, both so you can understand their motives and to avoid misunderstandings later on. I asked the question, but I can’t say I ever fully understood the answer. It didn’t matter. IT MATTERED QUITE A LOT ACTUALLY When we got into the Files, we were caught off guard. The content-policing system was more elaborate and organized than any of us imagined. A communications highway had been built linking the FBI, the Department of Homeland Security, and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence with Twitter, Facebook, Google, and a slew of other platforms. Among other things this looked more like a cartel than a competitive media landscape, and I had an uneasy feeling early on that publicizing this arrangement might create a host of unanticipated problems for everyone involved. Still, there was no question this was in the public interest. So we kept going. This one I actually get. You didn’t think it was going to be a big story and then it was a big story and by then it was too late, you’d felt that thing, that almost-painful heartbeat click when the story reveals … This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.firewalledmedia.com/subscribe

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Leopards Are At It Again

0:00 24:59

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Laura Jedeed?

This episode is 24 minutes long.

When was this Laura Jedeed episode published?

This episode was published on April 13, 2023.

Can I download this Laura Jedeed episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.