Skip to content
The Lost Tribe Hoax episode artwork

Nov 15, 2012 9 min

The Lost Tribe Hoax

from Witness History: Archive 2012 Hosted by BBC World Service

In the 1970s the Filipino government annouced they had discovered a group of cave dwellers who were still living as people did in the stone age. But the tribe turned out to be a hoax that fooled the scientific community. Photo: Members of the Tasaday tribe photographed by Oswald Iten in the 1980s after they admitted the hoax.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Lost Tribe Hoax

0:00 9:28
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, and thank you for downloading Witness on the BBC World Service. It's 40 years since National Geographic magazine broke the story of a group of Filipino forest dwellers who had been so isolated from the modern world that they were still living as people did in the Stone Age. The tribe was an astounding discovery. It also turned out to be one of the biggest hoaxes in the history of science, as Chloe Hajimathaya reports.

It's 1972, and in the dense jungles of the Filipino island of Mindanao, a small group of men, women and children are living in caves, surviving by eating berries and roots, much like our ancestors did some 10,000 years ago. Journalists and scientists have been allowed to visit this previously isolated people for the first time, and images of the primitive tribe have begun to reach the public around the world. Tonight, Stone Age cave gunners found living in the Philippine rainforest. Can we unlock the mystery of a lost tribe?

This was a big sensation, that during a period when people were flying to the moon, there were still some people living in caves. There were just 26 people, without any outside contact. It looked like a kind of paradise. Oswald Eaton is a Swiss journalist who recalls reading about the Tassadai tribe in National Geographic magazine when it first hit the headlines.

When National Geographic met them, they were living in the caves. They had no textile clothing. They were just having this simple leaf cheese thing and nothing else. Since the time of Rousseau, you have the imagination that these savages are innocent, and especially with the Tassadai, which were said to have not even a word for war, and which the only protein that they collected was tadpoles.

They didn't even hunt. The man who claimed to have come across the Tassadai a year earlier was the Filipino Minister for Minorities, Manda Elizalde. The cave dwellers called him Diwata, God. He was a hugely wealthy member of the Marcos government, and he kept tight control over access to the tribe.

We feel that we do not have a right to, or anyone has a right to really come in and try to bring any change about when they are, in fact, as you can see, much happier than men of the modern world could ever be. The Minister of Minorities, Manda Elizalde, was a scion of a big family there who manufactured arms and whiskey, a very flamboyant man, and very early on there were some Filipino professors who said it cannot be that this is a Stone Age tribe. When some scientists went there, when they had doubts, immediately they were removed, and so it was really a very strange situation. Suddenly, in 1973, all access to the Tassadai ended.

Manda Elizalde announced that the tribe and the land they lived on had been given protected status and would not be open to the media or to scientists anymore, and it would be more than a decade before Oswald Eaton would come across the story of the Tassadai again. In 1985, I was in the Philippines reporting on the war, and I met some people from the area where this so-called Stone Age tribe was supposed to live, but the bishop of the area told me that this was a host, that there was not such a tribe as the Tassadai, but they were rather Tiboli and Manubo, these are local tribes, they live in little settlements. I went back home and studied everything which was written on the Tassadai, and there were so many contradictions that the Tassadai could have never prevailed in an environment by just foraging, not even hunting, because otherwise they would have probably starved. In 1986, when President Marcos was deposed, Oswald used the ensuing chaos to set out to meet the Tassadai for himself.

Nobody ever walked to that place, they were all flown in by the helicopter, so then nobody had an idea exactly how far away these caves were. The caves were actually only two and a half miles away from the local settlement called Bleat, and that is already visible in aerial views from the 1950s. So in fact, it would have been impossible for them not to have any outside contact, in your opinion? Oh yes, it was absolutely unthinkable.

As Oswald made his way towards the caves, passing through small villages, he was surprised to find familiar faces that he remembered from the decade-old pictures of the Tassadai. They were in the National Geographic magazine, pictured in the 1970s, but now they were wearing jeans and T-shirts. The next morning, we went to the caves, that was about one hour away, and people were just joking and laughing how they were set to sit in the caves, wait for the visitors. So what exactly was the story they told you about how they had ended up in the caves in the 1970s?

They told me that the Manda Elisalde had instructed them to put off their clothing and go in cheese drinks. Nobody of the visitors went to sleep at the caves, so at night they went back to the settlement. I don't blame the Tiborium and Nubo. They were forced to do it.

The hoax was committed by Elisalde. Oswald was not the only journalist to be following rumours of a hoax. The German magazine Stern went there, through the help of former Elisalde aides. In the caves, the Tassadai was waiting for them, but now there were suddenly 50 Tassadai, not 26, like 15 years early.

So asked how is it possible that these Stone Age 12s are multiplying that much in a very short time. The explanation was, well, the Tassadai went now finally to the village and they marry girls from that village. Of course, that would have been the very first case where socially and economically much advanced population would give away their girls to people who live in the caves. But when the Stern reporters pointed out that they weren't very convincing Stone Age tribesmen, they began to turn nasty.

Now, under the leaf cheese string, you could see some orange underpants. So when the Germans said, why can't you stop this whole masquerade, they were kidnapped. The journalists were released after paying a ransom and they published an article similar to Oswald's about how the world had been taken in by an enormous hoax. The stories made fools of the scientists who had published studies about the Tassadai and many, like linguist Carol Maloney, speaking to the BBC in 1989, continued to maintain that the tribe was real.

I was quite sceptical about the Tassadai, but having gone there and having learned about their language and imagine the children sharing in this conspiracy that they would never slip. It's simply very implausible. These are authentic, primitive people. But Oswald believes there are perfectly simple explanations for much of the so-called scientific evidence surrounding the Tassadai, including their language.

When Mrs Maloney went to the area, she wasn't the speaker of these local languages of the Manobo and Tupoli. So all had to be translated by a translator supplied by Elisalde. I think it's really a good organisation how he was able to control the information. Many were fooled.

Why do you think that Elisalde came up with this idea? What was in it for him? For him, it was a question of becoming famous abroad. He was going with Gina Lola-Pricida, Charles Lindbergh, to visit the Tassadai.

He was running for Senate then, so he could use any sort of publicity. All of these accusations are absolute lies, based on gossip, on rumours, and have no basis in fact. Manda Elisalde continued to deny all accusations of a hoax until his death in 1997. To date, the Filipino government maintains that the Tassadai really were authentic Stone Age people, although they admit the tribe have now left their caves, and have become indistinguishable from the neighbouring tribes with whom they live.

Witness was written and presented by Chloe Haji-Mateo. For details of our complete range of downloads and our terms of use, go to bbcworldservice.com slash podcasts. For more information, visit www.bcworldservice.com slash podcasts.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Witness History: Archive 2012?

This episode is 9 minutes long.

When was this Witness History: Archive 2012 episode published?

This episode was published on November 15, 2012.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Witness History: Archive 2012 episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.