Hey Ontario, come on down to BetMGM Casino and see what our newest exclusive, The Price is Right Fortune Pick, has to offer. Don't miss out. Play exciting casino games based on the iconic game show, only at BetMGM. Check out how we've reimagined three of the show's iconic games, like Plinko, Cliffhanger, and The Big Wheel into fun casino game features. Don't forget to download the BetMGM Casino app for exclusive access and excitement on The Price is Right Fortune Pick. Pull up a seat and experience The Price is Right Fortune Pick, only available at BetMGM Casino.
BetMGM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly. 19 plus to wager, Ontario only. Please play responsibly. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact Connects Ontario at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor free of charge. BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario. True Crime Brewery contains disturbing content related to real-life crimes. Medical information is opinion based on facts of a crime and should not be interpreted as medical advice or treatment. Listener discretion is advised.
Welcome to True Crime Brewery. I'm Jill. And I'm Dick. At 6 a.m. on August 28, 1965, Carl and Carmela Capolino's physician, Dr. Juliet Caro, was awakened by a phone call. Carl Capolino tearfully described to her how he had just found his 32-year-old wife dead, seemingly from a heart attack. Dr. Caro was concerned when she arrived at the house. Young women in their 30s rarely die from cardiac arrest. Join us at The Quiet End for the Love Triangle Murders. 41 days after his wife's death, Carl Capolino married Mary Gibson.
Imagine the chagrin of Capolino's neighbor, Marjorie Farber, who had moved from New Jersey to Florida in hopes of her being with Carl. Incensed by this turn of events, Marjorie went to the police and she told them that she had stood by helplessly as her husband had been strangled to death by Carl. And she had information to share about Carmela's death as well. So fascinating. It looks like the doctor was a busy man. Yes. A wife and two girlfriends. Yeah. And there'll be another. And two possible murders. Yes. And because one occurred in New Jersey and one occurred in Florida, I had my choice. And I went with a New Jersey beer.
So we're going to talk about Cricket's Nocturne from Cricket Hill Brewing Company in Fairfield, New Jersey. This is a Munich Dunkel beer, an underrepresented style, in my opinion. So low alcohol, 4.5%. These are pretty enjoyable beers. It's a dark brown, kind of a chestnut color with a thick tan head. Got a nice malty, smokier aroma. Some sweetness, probably chocolate. Mostly a malty taste. Some molasses. Still had that little bit of smoke to it. And a bit of chocolate. Medium body, nicely carbonated. Very enjoyable. Sounds great. And this is our first episode of 2024. So I just want to wish a happy new year to everyone.
It is. And for this case, we are going back about 60 years. So hop on board the TCB time machine. And like on Wayne's World, we'll go back to the 1960s. Way back. Way back. So open that beer.
All right, Dickie, down here at the quiet end, 2024. Let's hear it. New year, new you. Yes, I'm having all my work done this year. Okay. So Carl Capolino grew up in a poor family in Brooklyn, where his Italian immigrant parents ran a barbershop. Pushed toward getting an education by his parents, Carl earned a spot at the elite Brooklyn Tech High School. He majored in chemistry at Fordham and then studied anesthesiology at what is now sunny downstate in Brooklyn. In 1956, Carl married fellow medical student Carmela Museta, a doctor's daughter from Boonton, New Jersey. After graduation...
In training, he took a hospital job in Red Bank, New Jersey, and Carmelo worked as a research physician with a pharmaceutical firm. Just as his anesthesiology career was taking off, Carl became interested in his potential for hypnotherapy in medicine. He wrote journal articles on the subject that he expanded in how-to books for other doctors, and on the side he practiced some hypnosis. So I find that really weird, because being an anesthesiologist is a really good, really well-paying job. Yeah. It's one of the higher-paying jobs for a physician. Well, but at the same time, hypnosis could be useful in anesthesiology. Well, yeah, but I don't think he was just adding it on, right?
No, he wasn't. He's kind of going in another direction. I could see where you'd be interested in it, being an anesthesiologist. All right. Well, meanwhile, Carl had developed some complications in both his life and his career. At work, friction with a nurse there ended up with the FBI questioning him about a series of angry anonymous notes which had threatened the woman's life. And apparently the belief was that Carl had written them. And at the same time, this seemingly healthy young guy, Carl Capolino, began complaining of coronary insufficiency. His medical career was killing him, he said, so he took a disability retirement at the ripe old age of 30.
And later on, it would be rumored that he'd lied about his medical condition and had actually committed fraud to collect disability. So that's odd. You've got to admit that's pretty weird. Well, it is. I mean, at age 30. Just getting started. You really are. Yeah. In medicine. Sure. So it seems like maybe you practiced for a year or so. Not long. So in the early 1960s, Carl lived with his wife, Carmela, also a physician in New Jersey. While there, he began a romantic relationship with their neighbor. That's Marjorie Farber. She was about 20 years older. And at first, Marjorie's husband, William, tolerated this affair. But as it continued, he became more angry and resentful. And finally, he insisted that Marjorie stop seeing Carl.
Carl had actually been helping Marjorie quit smoking by hypnotizing her. She was older, but pretty attractive. And in 1962, while his wife Carmela was pregnant with the Coppolino's second child, he and Marjorie began having sex and having secret get-togethers. So eventually Carl and Marjorie decided together that her husband, Colonel William Farber, 52 years old, should be taken out of the picture so that those two could be together. So on June 30th, 1963, Marjorie Farber called Carl's house to say that her husband was having trouble breathing. So Carl ran over to the house, and then he called his wife Carmela.
When Carmella arrived at the Farber house, William was already dead. Aside from being blue on one side of his body, he had no outward signs of distress or injury, but at Carl's urging, Carmella pronounced William Farber dead from a coronary thrombosis. And she signed the death certificate, and then that seemed to be the end of things. Yeah, I'm just astounded. It is astounding. You can make that diagnosis. Well, you can't. You can't. To begin with. But what the heck, is she under Carl's control or something? I think so. That's the impression I got, is that he got her to do that. You just can't do that.
It seems like if Carl and Marjorie were planning to murder William Carver, that this was all planned out. She called the house and then Carl went over knowing what was going on or going to finish William off. I think one of the thoughts that will come out is that Marjorie gave her husband some kind of drug. And then Carl came over and finished him off. And then they called Carl's wife to kind of sweep everything under the rug for them. Yeah, because if they have an independent coroner or whoever, you might not have that diagnosis. No, in 52, I mean, a 52-year-old man having a heart attack or coronary thrombosis isn't that unusual. But it's not like he was really ill or anything. So it was a sudden death of a fairly young, healthy person. For the next year and a half, the affair between Carl and Marjorie was kind of winding down. Carl seemed to be losing interest, but Marjorie was really in love with him.
Then in April of 1965, the Capolinos moved to Florida, and Marjorie, likely still in love with Carl, moved as well. She actually bought an adjacent lot in a Longboat Key neighborhood. So Carl hadn't been practicing medicine for quite some time due to his own severe coronary artery disease. Alleged coronary disease. Yeah, alleged. And when Carmella failed the Florida medical exams, money became a big problem for the couple.
They'd been living off of his disability benefits and Carmela's salary. So without her salary, they were in financial trouble. Then Carl began to play bridge several nights a week, and that's where he met wealthy divorcee Mary Gibson. Carl eventually asked Carmela for a divorce so that he could marry Mary Gibson. But as a devout Italian Catholic who still loved her husband, they had two daughters together, Carmela would not agree to a divorce. And soon after the declined divorce request, Carmela was found dead in her bed.
The investigating officer was satisfied that the doctor on the scene, Dr. Caro, had correctly listed the cause of death, so he actually bypassed the law that did require an autopsy to be performed. Carmela Capolino's body, unexamined, was then buried in her family's plot in her home state of New Jersey. So that's pretty shocking. It certainly is. 32 years old. A young mom, really. A young mother. Yep. Now, just five weeks later, after his wife's death, Carl went ahead and married Mary Gibson. His ex-lover, Marjorie, was stunned by this turn of events. And so she went to Dr. Caro.
and told her a sensational story that would fill the front pages of newspapers for months. At Dr. Caro's insistence, Marjorie reported the murder of her husband to the Florida police, adding that she believed Carl was responsible for Carmela's death as well. Marjorie claimed that Carl had hypnotized her into agreeing to murder her husband. Then, as she helplessly stood by, Carl had strangled her husband. Marjorie did seem credible to the investigators, but still there's talk about her being brokenhearted, malicious, wanting to get some revenge on Carl.
Because after all, he spurned her for another woman. Sure. And I would even say she probably was brokenhearted and wanted to get back at him. But at the same time, it seems true. It rings true to me. Because she really is taking a risk there of getting herself in trouble saying she stood by because this man killed her husband. She's put herself in the scene of the crime, basically. Absolutely. And there were many neighbors who thought that Marjorie was really upset about Carmella's death. I'm not sure if that's the case, because there's also the idea that Marjorie thought she and Carl would be together once Carmella was dead. So she could have known about that, too. But regardless, she found out that he married this new woman.
and was pretty flabbergasted, it seems. She did not expect that to happen. No. After all, they moved across the country, and they had plans to be together, at least in her way of seeing things. Yeah. Well, she was definitely upset with him. Yeah. No, I can see that she was upset with him, but just to be painted as the scorned woman who's just trying to get back at him, I have a problem with that. I really think there had to be more to it than that. Yeah. So eventually, after a lot of talk and investigation, authorities did exhume Carmela's and William Farber's bodies. Carmela's autopsy revealed a needle puncture mark in her left buttock.
Her heart was healthy, and there was no other discernible cause of death. The autopsy on Marjorie's husband found evidence of death by strangulation, and that was consistent with Marjorie's story that Carl had strangled or smothered him in his sleep. So these autopsies were performed by Dr. Milton Halpern, New York's chief medical examiner. He's famous. Is he? Or was famous. Oh, I never heard of him. It was a big one, huh? He was a big shot. He wrote up.
a book that was really well received. I saw the book he wrote. And I think at some point during the trial, it came out that he'd performed or at least been there for like 60,000 autopsies. So he seemed to know his shit quite well. So he found evidence of succinylcholine chloride, a neuromuscular blocking agent used by anesthesiologists to relax muscles during surgery. He found that in both bodies. Also, William Farber's cricoid cartilage was fractured, which indicates that he had been strangled.
And these findings led to two charges of homicide being filed against Carl Capolino. In Freehold, New Jersey, a grand jury returned an indictment of murder in the first degree in the death of Lieutenant Colonel William E. Farber on July 30, 1963. The grand jury returned this indictment after hearing the medical testimony regarding the 11-hour autopsy performed the previous Saturday on the colonel's body by Dr. Milton Helpern. So during the day while the grand jury was in session, Judge John Graham issued a fugitive warrant for the arrest of Dr. Carl Capolino at the request of the state of New Jersey.
Capolino was arrested at his home at 3263 Pine Valley Drive that evening by sheriff's deputies. He was brought in wearing Bermuda shorts and a sports shirt, and he complained of feeling unwell. So here again, we have to wonder, was he faking? Because if you fake it, you can go to the hospital instead of the jail cell, which might be preferable, at least temporarily. But after he was booked and advised of his rights, Capolino was examined by two physicians who did recommend that he be hospitalized. So he was taken to the Sarasota Memorial Hospital and placed under guard in a private room. So Capolino was served with a Florida warrant in his hospital room for his wife's death.
And after examination again by Drs. Page and Douglas, Capilino was brought back to the county jail from the hospital, which was just less than two miles away. And for two weeks, Capilino was kept in the maximum security section of the jail in a private cell in the area reserved for homicide defendants and overall troublemakers. He was under 24-hour supervision by the desk officers. And then on a bright, windy October morning, he was handcuffed and put in the police wagon in the alley beside the Hall of Records. And then he was driven up the hill to the courthouse.
So as you can imagine, this is in the news and this is a sensational story. Oh, yeah. You've got a doctor, you've got sex, you've got murder. Very, very big story in that day and age. Just what people like to follow. Yep, yep. Now, Coppolino had an unusually boyish look for a man in his early 30s. His voice was light and smooth and he spoke rapidly. There was some elegance about him in his fine-boned physical stance and his casual slouch. When asked by the court how he pled, he stood mute at the advice of his attorney, who contended that one could not enter a plea to such an indictment because of the improper wording of it.
So the judge ended up instructing the clerk of the court to enter a plea of not guilty on behalf of the defendant. Now, F. Lee Bailey, and people probably know him from the O.J. Simpson trial. Yeah, but at this point, he's just an up-and-coming lawyer. He was. And he had entered this case through kind of a coincidence of friendship, because he knew Dr. William Joseph Bryan of Los Angeles through having attended a seminar on the legal aspects of hypnosis that was given by Bryan, who was the president of the American Society of Hypnosis. Bailey had later brought Bryan to Boston to hypnotize his client, and his client was the Boston Strangler. So he did this in an attempt to find out the motivations behind Albert DeSalvos, who was the Boston Strangler, behind his crimes. He was also fresh off of a landmark win in the Sam Shepard case.
Very similar case. And was quickly developing a reputation as one of the top attorneys in the country. So Sam Shepard, he was the guy whose family got killed. And he said it was Manson type people who did it. Yeah, he was a doctor. Yeah, he was a doctor in the military. And it's also the story that gave rise to the fugitive. Yeah. Harrison Ford. Right. A very famous story.
So the Boston Strangler and Sam Shepard are two very big, prominent cases. Yes. So in November of 1965, accompanied by his new wife, Mary, Carl had gone to Las Vegas to sit in on a panel discussion of medical hypnosis at Brian's invitation. In July of 1966, when Brian read about Carl's indictments for two murders in two states, he had phoned Mary Coppolino and spoken with her. Then he had located Deathly Bailey and asked him to consider taking over Coppolino's defense. Bailey was on a case at the time. When he finished, he flew to Florida, talked to Mary and Carl, and took the case after spending four hours with Carl on Sunday.
So Capolino went on trial in New Jersey for the murder of William Farber. The prosecutor opened by saying that Capolino had not only broken the commandment, thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's wife, but also thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's life. Clever or not? I don't like it. Yeah, I don't really either. Because I think why I don't like it is because there's the commandment of thou shalt not kill, and that seems more pertinent to me here. Oh, it is. Yeah. Now, Bailey's main objective was to discredit Marjorie Farber, the one who had gone to the police. Sure. I tried and true formula. Yep, yep. And in his opening address, he said, in part, this woman drips with venom on the inside, and I hope before we are through, you will see it drip on the outside. She wants this man so badly that she would sit on his lap in the electric chair while somebody pulled the switch, just to make sure that he dies. So this is not a murder case at all.
This is monumental and shameful proof that hell hath no fury like a woman scorned. Yikes. So it doesn't surprise me that Bailey dripped with misogyny here because we saw him in the Simpson case as well. And he's really not known as a very good guy. Effective lawyer. Yeah. Total turd for a person. Right. Kind of, you know, helps with that whole belief that lawyers are pretty shady, pretty sus. Especially defense attorneys. They really are not well liked much of the time. Marjorie Farber was the first witness for the prosecution. She claimed to have been under Coppolino's spell ever since he had hypnotized her to help her quit smoking.
She said that she was powerless to deny him anything, especially when he told her repeatedly that her husband, otherwise known as the Bastard, had to go away. Yes, I'm not really on board with the whole hypnotized thing. That's not an excuse for participating in a murder. Oh. No, so that really wasn't great. According to Marjorie, Coppolino had given her a syringe filled with some deadly solution and instructions to inject Farber while he slept. At the last moment, her nerve failed, but not until she had injected a tiny amount of the fluid into Farber's leg. When he became ill, she called Coppolino to come over to her house. He gave Farber a sedative.
then attempted to suffocate him by wrapping a plastic bag around his head. As the two men struggled, Marjorie begged Cappellino to stop, but she said he smothered Farber with a pillow. So the cricoid cartilage was broken in Farber's neck. So that to me would be more than a smothering. There was some kind of fighting going on. He actually had to lay his hands or something on the man's neck. And that's kind of a problem because later on the defense would try and argue that this injury had occurred when the body was exhumed from rough handling of the body. And that would go back and forth between different experts with different opinions. But to me, it still adds up. You see someone suffocating someone and it's violent and there's a back and forth and the victim is fighting. There certainly could be a strangulation as well. Yeah. Yeah.
So on cross-examination, Bailey was brutal and belligerent. He began sarcastically. There'd been no murder at all. Everything she said had been a lie. A figment of her malicious imagination, instigated by her evil desire for revenge, on the man who had ditched her. Wasn't that right, he asked her. And over a torrent of prosecution objections, Bailey would press on. This whole story is a cock and bull story. That's what he said. So yes, a very outspoken defense attorney. After the prosecutor's objections were sustained, Bailey shifted tactics. He ridiculed Marjorie's claim of having been an unwilling but helpless participant in the murder.
saying he would produce medical testimony to prove this was impossible. He constantly reminded the jury of her adulterous and jealous behavior. And most of all, he focused on her age. Come on. Really? This 52-year-old woman was a repeated theme of his, as if that was reason enough to explain her making false accusations. Well, sure, we can't listen to a woman over 40 or over 50. Right. They're hysterical enough. They're hysterical, yes. They're not sensible. They don't think clearly. They're not logical. Especially if they're going through the change of life. Forget about it. Oh, that'll do it. Yeah. But it worked. And the mood of the court turned against her. So at the end of two days of cross...
She left the stand looking really defeated and confused about what the hell had happened. But next on the stand was the medical examiner, Milton Helpern. Helpern was an experienced expert witness, but he too reeled under Bailey's verbal assaults. At issue was whether William Farber had suffered from terminal heart disease and if the cricoid fracture had occurred before or after death. Helpern was emphatic that he had not suffered from heart disease, William, and that the fracture occurred before his death. But Bailey was able to get him to concede that there was no bruising about the neck as would normally have been present if strangulation had occurred.
Bailey speculated that rough handling of the body during disinterment, in particular, a gravedigger's shovel, had caused the cricoid fractures. How can a gravedigger's shovel go through a closed coffin? Yeah. Well, this was a thing. You know, there was talk that the lid had broken off, that things had been moved. It was just, it was kind of a shady defense, but it seemed to have some effect on the jury. It gave them some doubts. Even though Halpern really dismissed that idea, Bailey was able to bring in his own expert witnesses, and they did testify.
otherwise. Yeah. He found a couple of doctors to testify, Drs. Joseph Spellman and Richard Ford. They were both experienced medical examiners. And they said that not only was the cricoid fracture caused postmortem, but that William Farber's heart showed clear signs of advanced coronary disease, enough to have killed him. Again, you've got battling expert witnesses. That happens all the time. Yeah. And I think if you've got the money and the time, you can find an expert who's going to say things your way, which is unfortunate. Yes, it is. Yeah. So I'm thinking a 52-year-old man, he probably had some plaque in his arteries or...
things like that. And you probably could say, oh, well, he had heart disease. But a lot of people have heart disease that's not going to kill them. It just seems a little more cut and dry in terms of whether or not he had coronary artery disease. I don't see how you can argue much over that. Yeah. I mean, maybe he did. But how do you prove that that killed him? Yeah. I would think a lot of men in their 50s have coronary artery disease. And this is before there were statins and other medications. Oh, sure. I know that. Right. Well, I know you know that. I'm just throwing it out there as that could make it a little more iffy, a little less specific. Maybe. But here, on the one hand, I've got Halpern who says,
There's no evidence of coronary artery disease. Right. And the other docs say that there are clear signs of advanced coronary disease. Yeah. There's quite a difference between those two. There is. And they really didn't get into the specifics of how they determined that, which is, you know, a little troubling. But then Bailey's star witness was the defendant himself, Carl Capolino. So he was slim and nicely groomed, and he answered his accusers well, and he really did appear sincere. He came across as confident without seeming too cocky. Judge Elvin Simmel commented on the vast array of conflicting medical evidence.
and stressed to the jury that they must be satisfied of Kapolino's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Uh-huh. So see, that kind of says, well, if there are varying opinions and you need to be absolutely sure there's no reasonable doubt, he's kind of telling them you should lean toward the defense. Yeah. Isn't that standard instructions from judges? Yeah, you're right. It is. But this seems kind of specific. Well, it probably was an admonition that they took to heart. Yeah. Because after deliberating for less than five hours, they returned with a verdict of not guilty for the murder of William Farber.
Yep. So that was that for that one. That was that for the murder of Farber. Now we'll move from New Jersey to Florida to do Carmela's trial. Right. And that one ended up being moved from Sarasota, Florida to Naples. And Bailey was very confident at this point that he'd win this trial too. And so was Carl. Carl was kind of cocky about this. He got off on the first trial. Right. He's got the same lawyer. He's thinking, I'm golden, going to win again. Right. But the one difference is they really found definite traces of the muscle relaxer in Carmela's body. With Farber, they had found some of the...
Byproducts. Yeah, they found some of those, but they could also be in the body for other reasons. But with Carmela, it seemed much more definite that there were traces of succinylcholine found in her body. And this was the first trial in history to use science to detect succinylcholine chlorine antibody. But Bailey readily dismissed this science. And it's funny because decades later, he would ironically serve on OJ Simpson's so-called dream team. And this relied heavily on discrediting the reliability of the DNA evidence for which there was a bundle. Sure was. And they seemed to be effective in that.
Because OJ, as you probably all know, was found not guilty. OJ got away with it. Yep. So the Florida trial began April 3, 1967. State attorney Frank Staub, knowing that there was no direct evidence linking Carl to his wife's death, gathered up a pile of inconsistencies and motives for a murder. High on his list was money. Coppolino had been hurting financially. And when Carmelo refused to grant him a divorce, he began thinking about a bank account and life insurance of $65,000, which would be the equivalent of about $600,000 today. Right. So when you say $65,000, it doesn't sound like that much, but when you...
hear what the worth of that was back then. That's a shit ton of money. Certainly is. As persuasive as the state attorney's case was, the New Jersey case gave the public the idea that Coppolino would again be acquitted. Coppolino's reputation as a ladies' man and a bit of a sketchy character, though, had preceded him. The jury gave medical examiner Milton Halpern a more favorable opinion than the New Jersey jury had. So his task was pretty much the same as before, to explain the presence of succinylcholine chloride in Carmelo Coppolino's body in lucid terms that a layperson could understand. So, of course, Marjorie Farber was there again.
And Marjorie testified to overhearing Capolino on the phone after his wife's death, saying they've started the arterial work and that won't show anything. Further questioning clarified that this referred to the fluid used by embalmers to replace the blood. So this was damning. Certainly was. So the prosecutor had another witness testify that Carmela's death was wrongly ascribed to a heart attack because Capolino persuaded a physician that she had suffered chest pains earlier on the day she died.
So that's kind of what led to the family physician saying it was a heart attack, although I still think that was very irresponsible. Oh, no doubt. And actually, Carmelo's father would later testify to relate how Coppolino claimed an autopsy had proved that a heart attack was the cause of death, though, in fact, no autopsy had been performed at the time. So State Attorney Schwab brought in Dr. Edmund Leslie Webb as a witness for the prosecution. This was specifically to support the succinylcholine as the murder weapon. He was an anesthesiologist licensed to practice medicine and was associate director of the E.R. Squibb & Sons Laboratories. So kind of a bigwig. Definitely.
After establishing that Webb knew Carl, Schaub asked, have you ever furnished him with any medicines or drugs? And Webb answered that he had. When asked what he had given to Coppolino, he answered, pronestyl, vitamins, and succinylcholine. So what's pronestyl? Pronestyl is a drug that's used to treat cardiac rhythm disturbances, arrhythmias. It's pretty benign for the most part, but it's got a narrow field of efficacy. There's not too many conditions that you're going to use it for. And I'm not sure it's used at all these days. So it's interesting that he would want it. Yeah. Yeah. Well, if you...
given overdose, you can develop heart rhythm problems. Okay. So maybe it was something that, as an anesthesiologist, he'd certainly be familiar with it. So maybe that was in his plan to do away with his neighbor and his wife. Yeah, maybe he thought that would show signs of a heart problem that would add to the whole idea that they died. There's a possibility, yeah. If you're going to talk about dying of cardiac disease, it could be. So what's really interesting here, Dick, is that Webb testified that he had sent succinylcholine to Carl Capolino on two occasions. And one was in early 1963, and the second one was on July 21st, 1965.
So you can match this up because Farber died on July 30th, 1963, and Carmela died on August 28th, 1965, less than 30 days, a little over 30 days. That's very interesting. Yeah. I'm not sure. You look at that, it sounds, well, that's it, but that's quite a coincidence. Yeah, I think that that really counts as some circumstantial evidence. If you get this drug on July 21st, and then she dies August 28th, what's that, five weeks? That's pretty damning, in my opinion. Now, according to Webb, Coppolino had requested the drugs, writing a letter that he was interested in doing research to see if succinylcholine can be detected in cats.
And there's no evidence that he did any research. He didn't work in a lab or anything. He didn't work. He didn't work. He played bridge. When they went to Florida, he played bridge like five days a week. Plus he had, you know, his affairs or at least one. Well, remember he had cardiac disease and was on disability. Right. So yeah, I don't even know if you can go and work doing research if you're on disability. But on July 22nd, 1965, but on July 21st, 1965, Webb had sent six bottles totaling 2,800 milligrams of succinylcholine, a very large amount of the muscle relaxant. And Webb testified that he had known Carmela. He had met both Carl and Carmela.
at the same time when they had come to intern at the Methodist Hospital in Brooklyn. And Dr. Webb had been in his first year of residency at the hospital. He had spent a good deal of time with them, Webb said, and they actually lived together for almost a year. Carmela left the hospital in 1959, but Carl stayed on for some years, and Webb saw him frequently. He said he had visited their home on several occasions and that they had talked about medicine. Carl had never made any comment about Carmela's having any heart condition. Shaw then left a witness to F. Lee Bailey for cross-examination. Yeah, so Bailey asked Dr. Webb 144 questions during his cross.
In both the New Jersey and the Florida trials, there is a considerable amount of testimony regarding the use and properties of succinylcholine chloride, and much of it is a repetition of the testimony given in this cross-examination. Bailey conducted the cross-examination without notes. He asked his questions quickly, and Webb made immediate responses. In swiftness, control, and as an example of how thoroughly the trial attorney must absorb principles alien to his training, this is really considered as a classic example of the cross-examination of an expert witness in a highly technical area. So it did gain Bailey some more regard and actually a little bit of fame.
Webb stated that part of his duties at the Squibb laboratories was to review the literature that accompanies the drugs to physicians, that the Squibb brand name for succinylcholine is sucostrin, and that it is produced by other pharmaceutical houses under other trade names, and one of these was a nectine. Bailey asked him to explain what happens when an injection of succinylcholine is made intravenously into the human body. And Webb explained, first of all, weakness develops. This weakness usually starts at the head and shoulders, the arms and legs, and this is closely followed by a complete relaxation if the dose is sufficient. Bailey then asked him, is it possible for a person who has just received an intravenous injection to walk or move? And Webb answered, it would depend on what you mean by just received. I would estimate there would be a period of 15 to 20 seconds where you would be fully capable of walking. So not very long. Nope. That's pretty close to immediate in my opinion. It is. Well, so quickly it works. Right. And this is a scientific answer.
15 to 20 seconds isn't immediate. Nope. Nope. Almost. Yeah, close. Webb said that an intramuscular injection is absorbed and takes effect just much more slowly than an intravenous dosage. Succinylcholine is called a depolarizing drug, which is hydrolyzed and rapidly destroyed. If the dose is not excessive, then it breaks down very quickly. But an excessive dose that's more than recommended obviously would take longer. So the maximum dose recommended by Squibb is between 30 and 90 milligrams, Webb said, and it can be repeated. It causes a block at the myoneural junction. That's where the nerve tells the muscle what to do.
Keeps the patient from moving, but it does not block pain or cause sedation. So something else has to be given for anesthesia to prevent pain. Once you've been injected with succinylcholine, you're not able to breathe because you have paralysis of the diaphragm, which you need to operate the lungs. So it's common practice for the patient to be intubated and given artificial respiration until the drug wears off. And that's where I saw most of the uses for it. As you're getting ready to intubate a patient, you give them some succinylcholine, they can't move. It's much easier to intubate. Yeah, so it's a very common drug for an anesthesiologist to use. Absolutely. But you've got to be able to breathe for the patient. And if you're not able to do that, your breathing is going to stop and you're going to die. Yeah, and that would make it something you could murder with. Certainly would be. So Bailey then asked about what amount is necessary for a given period of paralysis. And Webb said it was very difficult to determine that exactly. The weight of the patient would be a factor.
In giving intramuscular injections to children, the recommended dosage is one and a half milligrams per pound. Bailey asked him how quickly the drug hydrolyzed, meaning how quickly it would break down in the bloodstream, into its separate chemical compounds. And Webb said that would happen very quickly, and it's destroyed in two processes. First, succinylcholine is changed to succinylmonocholine and to succinic acid. The second part is a longer process. So at this point, some oversimplified chemistry is helpful to understand Webb's answer.
The drug before injection is a complex molecular linkage, which contains two molecules of choline and one molecule of succinic acid. They're combined to form the more complex molecule of succinyl di, meaning two, choline. To hydrolyze means to break down into simpler molecular forms, which were originally combined in the laboratory to make the basic drug. Webb said that fairly rapidly, the drug would lose one molecule of choline, and this would become succinyl monocholine. And then over a longer period of time, this new compound would separate into one molecule of choline and one molecule of succinyl acid.
eventually all that would be found in the bloodstream of the person would be succinic acid and choline. Yeah, so that's all pretty much to say that that's what you're going to find on autopsy. Right. Right. So Webb referred to the literature which says that a certain proportion is excreted under changes in the urine. And if this was found in the urine, this would be preliminary evidence that the drug had been given. So Bailey switched then to the two occasions when Webb had delivered succinylcholine to Dr. Capolino. Webb said he had a record on the second shipment, but that the first was delivered by hand by Dr. Webb in the early part of 1963, but he couldn't remember the exact month.
Webb said that he was aware at the time that Capolino was not working because of his heart condition. He said he had given Capolino 1,000 milligrams of an actine, a dry powder form of succinylcholine, which, when mixed with water, would form 1,000 cubic centimeters to be given by injection. Webb testified that regarding the 1965 shipment, Dr. Capolino said that he wanted to kill a cat. He said that the request came in a personal letter, which he had put aside and had been unable to find. But to the best of his recollection, he'd gotten the letter in June of 1965, near the beginning of the month, and he'd ordered the succinylcholine to be sent on July 1st.
but it actually hadn't been shipped until a couple weeks later. And Bailey asked him what the shipment consisted of. Webb told him there were four bottles of sucostrin, 200 milligrams each, and two bottles, 1,000 milligrams each. Each bottle, he said, had contained the same amount of fluid, 10 cc's, so that four of the bottles had a strength of 20 milligrams per cc, and two had a strength of 100 milligrams per cc. So the 20 milligram strength is the dosage intended for intravenous injection, and the 100 milligram strength is intended to add to dextrose saline and given intramuscularly. Webb explained that the intramuscular injection would act the same way as the intravenous injection.
Just more slowly. In intramuscular injection, breathing would stop in 75 seconds to three minutes. Paralysis of the lungs is very difficult to answer because it really does depend on the dose. It can be anywhere from one minute to five minutes. Still very quickly. Still pretty quick. That's right. He also said in order to cause death in a healthy 32-year-old woman of about 120 pounds, which matches the description of Carmella, it would take approximately 90 milligrams IV to stop breathing. So going back to the shipment to Carl Capolino in July of 1965, in response to Bailey's questions...
Webb said that Carl had explained that he wanted to do some research on cats to find out whether there was evidence that succinylcholine would be detected in the bodies of cats after death. But again, there's no evidence that anything like that was ever done. And Coppolinos did not have all of the drug at home where he could say, look, it's all still here either. Right. Webb said he had seen Carl and Carmela in March, just before they moved to Florida. And through a series of questions, Bailey established that Coppolino had requested the drug openly, had made no attempt to have Webb conceal his request in any way or refrain from mentioning it. But to me, that would just be evidence of him being very cocky.
And not thinking that he could ever be found for anything. Doesn't mean that he had nothing to hide, right? Exactly. Webb said the drug was available generally to doctors and hospitals, used frequently in various kinds of surgery, was not rare, was not a narcotic, and thus sales of it did not have to be reported to any special agency. He established that an anesthesiologist could walk into a drug supply firm and pick it up without making any record of the purchase. So if that's true, why didn't Capolino just go get it himself? Then there would be a record of him getting it. Yeah. Well, Capolino's thinking he'll eliminate that possibility. Right. That's how I see it.
So Webb was then asked about what contact he had had with Carl Capelino after sending the drug to him. He said he'd had two or three letters from Carl with no reference to the drug in them. Carl had called Webb's office the day after Carmela's death to tell Webb of her death, but Webb hadn't been in and the secretary had taken the message. But then Webb had tried to call him back that night and hadn't been able to get in touch with him. And he didn't think he had spoken to Capolino since, nor since the death of Carmela had Capolino gotten in touch with him in any way for the purpose of asking him to forget about the Saxino-Polene transaction. So that could work either way. Right. It could work as evidence that he was avoiding him because he's guilty or of evidence that, you know, he didn't try and cover it up. He didn't call him and say, don't tell anyone.
Which would have been stupid anyway. Yeah, he was probably smart enough to know better than to do that. But Webb did have copies of the shipping orders of all shipments made from Squibb to Coppolino in the folder he'd taken with him to the witness stand. He stated that he had been approached by law enforcement authorities and questioned about the drug transaction, the effects of the drug, and its traceability, but had not been approached by anyone representing the defendant. He testified that since he had first been questioned about this, he had not conducted any tests on the drug, nor had he been requested to. He had had conversation with the medical authorities conducting such tests, Drs. Halpern and Umberger, and he had given them Squibb's cicostrum for their tests. Now the medical examiner, Dr. Halpern, also testified for the prosecution. He testified that a complete toxological examination was done and all of the organs were submitted to the chemist. Most of the organs were submitted for routine analysis for ordinary toxic substances, such as sleeping pills, narcotics, heavy metals. Those are the various substances that are routinely tested for.
This portion of the analysis was carried out very extensively, and nothing was found. Now, ordinarily, this would have been the completion of the toxicological examination. But on the basis of information received, further examinations were made, particularly for succinylcholine. And after a very tedious analysis, he received a report from the chemist that the component portions of the drug were found in the body. Right. And the toxicologist or chemist was Dr. Umberger, who would also testify in the trial.
Now Dr. Halpern had opened his briefcase on his lap and dug out a document of two sheets stapled together and handed it to Mr. Bailey along with another document. Then Bailey, looking at the three pages, asked what it was in those reports that justified the conclusion of an evidence of the drug in Carmela's body. Halpern pointed out that the succinic acid was marked positive. It comes out in a particular fraction of ratio and also the choline is marked positive. This was interpreted as evidence of succinylcholine in the body. All of the other analyses were essentially negative except for the fact that certain substances were found.
which are the constituents of embalming fluid, and everything else was negative. So the positive chemical findings indicated significant quantities of the substances, which when present in normal or medicinal amounts are not detectable. succinylcholine is rapidly broken down into choline and succinic acid following absorption. So this, along with the autopsy findings of no disease and an injection mark, led to the conclusion that Carmella had been injected with succinylcholine. Remember they found a needle pole? Yes, they did. In her buttock or leg or something? Yes, so that was very important too. And additionally, Dr. Burt Lau, an expert in pharmacology, found a positive reaction for a monocholine derivative of succinylcholine that is stable in fat tissue around the needle tract and in the surrounding fat.
It's really interesting that the reaction became less intense as the distance from the puncture mark increased. So this is all very damning. Certainly is. Now, Carl Coppolino's new wife, Mary, was called to the witness stand. She was an attractive woman, about 40 years old, with dark brown hair, worn in a trendy, at least for that time, bouffant boyish cut, with bangs. After establishing her name, address, and relationship to the accused, the prosecutor asked her if she had known Carl Coppolino in August of 1965. She said that she had. She didn't remember the exact date, but believed it was in mid-July of that year. She took a bridge lesson and Coppolino had been in her class.
Right, so this is all going toward motive. Mary's manner was snippy and combative. It is possible that her attitude could have come from two factors. First, her attorneys had led her to believe that because they had been able to block all attempts to subpoena her and take a statement from her, the prosecutor couldn't cause her any problems once she took the stand. She'd have her attorneys present and she would submit to his questioning without worrying. Also, she couldn't be blamed for feeling hostility toward the prosecutor because she believed that he was personally rather than professionally involved in what to her was a misguided campaign against her husband. She believed that Frank Schaub...
alone was responsible for the weeks Carl had already spent in the Sarasota County Jail, and maybe she thought that she was handling him successfully, but she wasn't. So the prosecutor was able to get from her that she had seen Carl almost daily at the bridge studio. He had also driven her there. and they had visited the beach together. She said that she had been to the beach twice with Coppolino, but he didn't pick her up at her house. And under questioning, she did describe the two occasions. First, she said that she had expected to meet his family there, but it had worked out that they couldn't go, so she just met him there. Convenient. She said they walked down there together, and she showed him some rocks. When asked how many times Coppolino had been to her house, Mary said it was hard to say. When you've lived with someone so long, she said, it's hard to remember how many times they ate at your house. But she said that she had never invited Coppolino to her house as a lunch guest.
She remembered one time in particular that he did come by. She'd been out all morning and he'd been trying to call her to see if she wanted to play bridge. When she came in from school with her children, they were in summer school, Capolino came because the phone was out of order. And she remembered that he had a sandwich with them that day and couldn't remember any other times when he had visited the house. The prosecutor asked Mary if Capolino had been to her house every day in August of 1965. That's the month Carmelo died. She said she didn't know. When Schaub rephrased the question, she replied, I'm not in the position to give you an answer. I don't know. So it sounds like she was very snippy. Yeah.
A little bit evasive. A little bit, yeah. When the prosecutor asked Mary about a letter that Mary had gotten from her ex-husband on August 27th, 1965, there was an energetic objection from F. Lee Bailey. This letter stated that if Mary didn't tell Carmela about her and Carl, he would tell.
But Mary denied ever receiving such a letter. So he moved on, talking about the day before Carmela's death, August 27th, 1965, which was a Friday, and asked Mary when she first saw Carl that day. She said she'd had a bridge lesson in the afternoon at the Maxwell studio, and Carl was in that class. She said she went to it by herself and did not leave with him when she went home in her own car. She said that on Friday evening there was a bridge game rather than a lesson at the studio, and she met Carl there and played bridge with him. When asked if she had left the game with him, Mary said that she had walked out with him.
Then Mary testified that she had left in the same car with Capolino and thought that it was about 10.30 when the games were usually over. She couldn't remember what time it was exactly, though. The prosecutor asked her if it could have been 11.30. Twice, he asked her if she had gone to Capolino's home that night. She said she was never there in August at all. She was there in July for lunch one day, she said, and that was the only time she'd ever been in the Capolino house. Shobb asked her if she had been there on the 28th of August, and she said she hadn't been in the house that day, that she'd picked up her children at a neighbor's house across the street, and she testified that she had heard from Carl around 9 a.m. that day and had been asleep when he called her on the phone.
But now we have another witness who's going to really contradict a lot of this. And this next witness was Patricia Adamat. Attorney William Strode performed a direct examination, establishing that Pat Adamat had lived at 3267 Pine Valley Drive for 20 months. This was right next door to Mary Capolino and had known Mary during that period, having met her while their houses were both being built. She said her house was immediately next door to Mary's and that she had a clear view of it and knew Carl Capolino too, having met him around the end of June or the 1st of July in 1965. Adamat said that she had met Carl at Mary Gibson's house.
after he and Mary had spent the morning at the beach. For quite a while, she said she had seen Coppolino at Mary's house every day. She began to see him there in early June before she had met him. She was familiar with his car. It was a green 1965 Oldsmobile. Yeah, so according to Adelmat, Coppolino's car was at Mary's house every day in both June and July. The only exception was when Mary was out of town, which was only a few times. She said he would arrive at Mary's house in the morning, not leave until the afternoon, and then usually come back in the evening. Often then, Mary and Carl would go out in the evenings like they were dating.
So the defense objected and asked that they get down to a specific date instead of going over the whole summer of 1965. The judge sustained the objection and requested that the prosecution ask more specific questions of Adomat. So through his questions, the prosecutor established that Adomat had seen Carl and Mary go into Mary's house together in June, but she had no way of knowing whether they were there alone or if one or both of the children were there. She also said that she had been in the house with them in July. She described them as being very happy and joking a lot. But when Mary introduced her to Capelino, she told her that Capelino was married.
And Adomat said she was shocked to hear that. She thought they were a couple. After again establishing the morning and evening routine of visits during August as observed by Mrs. Adomat, the prosecutor directed her attention to the 27th of August, the day before Carmelo Capolino's death, and asked her if she had seen Carl on that day. Adomat remembered seeing him in the evening that day. He and Mary were going out in his car at about 7 p.m., and they waved to her as she was out emptying the trash. The prosecutor asked if there were any children with them, and Adomat said they were alone in the car. She didn't know what time they returned because she didn't see the car again that evening.
She thought she had seen Dr. Capolino there on the evening of the 28th, too, but she couldn't be certain about that. In response to more questions, Adamat testified that she didn't say anything to Mary Gibson about this situation, and that she and Mary continued to visit back and forth. She hadn't seen the Capolino children or their mother over there at any time during the whole summer, she said. Carmela's father, Dr. Carmelo Uzetto, also physician, was called to the stand by the state. This was his fifth appearance under oath. He testified at the preliminary hearing in Sarasota, and before that to a grand jury in New Jersey and two grand juries in Sarasota.
The prosecutor began by going directly to Mosetto's recall of a conversation he'd had with Carmela and Carl on an August weekend in 1963, immediately after the death of Colonel Farber, and the conversation was about Farber. Mosetto had been discussing the hot weather in their presence and how this type of weather is at times detrimental to men at a certain age who work behind a desk all week. Then Carmela had said to him, well, there's an example right up the street, pointing to Colonel Farber's house. That man died of a coronary, and apparently it was work he did over the weekend as a gardener that brought on this attack, and he died of a coronary. Mosetto then said that was unfortunate and asked who had treated the man.
Carl Cappellino said, oh, I treated him. And Mazzetto said to Carl, you did what? What did you do for him? Carl said, yeah, I treated him. Carl then told him that the cardiologist had not been called and that Carl had said he made no attempt to hospitalize Colonel Farber. Dr. Mazzetto said he admonished his daughter and son-in-law, reminding Carl he had a heart condition for which he's drawing disability insurance that could be cut off if the insurance firm learned that he had treated a case. He reminded Carl that his treatment of Colonel Farber went out with high-button shoes and that he was subject to a suit because he had not followed the correct procedure.
Okay, so went out with high-button shoes means that was something they did like back in the... In the olden days. Like in the 1800s. High-button shoes? Yeah, late 1800s. Yeah. But Dr. Macedo did testify that Carl told him he was qualified and he was able to take care of it. So Macedo asked Carl if he had signed the death certificate. Then Carmela spoke up and said no, she had signed the death certificate.
So this really shocked her father and he was reprimanding both of them. He said his daughter then told him that she had signed it to protect Carl. He asked Carmela if she had seen Farber while he was still alive and she told him she hadn't. She hadn't seen him until after he was already dead. So then Macedo said that he asked if this death was reported to the medical examiner or coroner. Carmela told him no. Macedo then asked how long the man was ill. Was it within 24 hours? How could you make this diagnosis? Carl then told Macedo that he had told Carmela the diagnosis and she had put it on the death certificate. So Macedo, remember he's a doctor too. He was really upset by this.
And he said to his daughter, my God, Carmela, I didn't bring you up that way as your father. So he had seen it as pretty fishy. It's just amazing that the authorities hadn't done anything about it. No kidding. So after his testimony, it was F. Lee Bailey's job to try and destroy his credibility. Dr. Macedo had spent his active professional life in Boonton, New Jersey. It's a small city where a relatively large percentage of the population was Italian. Dr. Macedo, over the years, had developed a large and profitable general practice. He was respected in the community and believed to have been a really good doctor. With a good bedside manner, gentle and reassuring with his patients.
So his first wife had died of complications following the birth of her second child back in 1935, a week after the baby boy was born. She had been just a few days past her 31st birthday. Then the infant, Andrew, had lived just a month and one day. Carmela had been 22 months old when her mother died. Dr. Macedo had married again, a woman four years older than his first wife had been, and by her he had one child, Angela, who was Carmela's half-sister. His second wife took her own life in 1963 at age 62 after suffering for years with a mental illness.
So it's this sympathetic man that F. Lee Bailey had to destroy in the presence of the jury in order to win an acquittal for Carl Coppolino. And this would be a challenge. Certainly would. F. Lee Bailey performed his cross-examinations brilliantly, but each witness stood firm this time. And this time he got no assistance from the defendant. Coppolino refused to testify on his own behalf this time. Bailey was stunned by this. Later called it a terrible mistake. Well, apparently the jury thought so too, right? Yeah, although I'm not going to be able to explain their verdict. Well, no, it's kind of weird. But on April 28, 1967, they found Coppolino guilty of second-degree murder. So why second-degree murder?
I don't know. Under Florida law, murder in the second degree implies a lack of premeditation on the part of the killer, and anything more calculated than willful poisoning is really hard to imagine. But whatever their reasoning, this decision saved Coppolino from death row. Instead, the ex-doctor who thought he had carried out the perfect murder was led away to begin a life sentence at the state prison at Rayford, Florida. Ethley Bailey's motions to set aside the verdict or grant a new trial were all denied. He appealed the verdict to the Court of Appeals of the state of Florida for the second district, and that appeal, too, was denied.
For about a year, beginning in 1974, after Coppolino was transferred to a minimum security facility near Tampa, he was permitted to leave the prison with his wife on furloughs of up to 36 hours. That's pretty crazy, huh? Is this because he was a professional man? Because I just can't see them doing that with just anybody. Well, it was apparently a program. Yeah. So it's not just him. Well, no, but I wonder if people like him. Well, I would think that they'd look at each case individually and decide which ones were safe to do that program. Well, eventually they decided none of them were because the program was terminated for all inmates guilty of serious crimes after there were multiple abuses by other prisoners. So I guess they weren't choosing them properly. I think it's a crazy idea, personally. In October of 1979, the Florida State Probation and Parole Commission...
released Coppolino on lifetime parole, stating that the decision to release him was based on his record of good behavior in prison. So that's a really short time in prison for a murder. 12 years. Yeah. His release was also due in part to efforts of his second wife, Mary Gibson Coppolino, who headed up a campaign to have him released. And she did seem to have some pull in society.
Mary had focused public attention on the testimony given in the Florida trial by Dr. Milton Helpern, the medical examiner from New York City, who had done the autopsy on Carmela Cappellino. In 1977, Mary said that two toxicologists had been suspended by Dr. Helpern at the time of the trial because of their willingness to contradict him on the proof of succinylcholine, and they were now willing to testify again in 1977. When interviewed, these toxicologists said that they had acquainted F. Lee Bailey with their doubts, but that he had declined to call either of them to testify, so they couldn't have been that credible.
Or Bailey definitely would have jumped on that. I would think he'd want them to testify. Absolutely. So there's something we don't know about that. Well, anyway, after serving 12 and a half years in prison, Carl Coppolino was paroled in 1979. He holds the position as the only person ever charged with two entirely separate love triangle murders. Each case taken on its own might have resulted in acquittal. But coming in one after the other, the two cases were too much for the jury to chalk up both to coincidence. I suppose that could be part of it, sure. I don't know, but it seems like the trials went very differently as well.
Especially Coppolino not taking the stand in his own defense. Yeah, I'd love to know why. I would too. Because it seemed that it was beneficial in his first trial. I know. Very strange. Maybe he was afraid of being cross-examined by the prosecution. Maybe that prosecutor was more effective as a prosecutor. Intimidated him. Who knows? Could be. Plus, they did seem to have more medical evidence on Carmela than they did on William Farber. Yeah, they had the succinylcholine in her system. Right, and Farber was a 52-year-old man with apparently some heart condition or something, which you wouldn't think a 32-year-old woman would have. Exactly.
So in a UPI news story in June of 1979, Dr. Milton Helpern's widow, Beatrice Helpern, was reported as saying that she welcomed scientific questioning, as did her husband, especially when the guilt or innocence of a person is at stake. After his release, Capolino wrote a book titled The Crime That Never Was. Then he toured the country promoting the sales of the book. So this book is basically Capolino's autobiography of his 12 years in prison, based on his daily diary, which began on the day of his guilty verdict. In it, he claims the forensic evidence against him was manufactured by corrupt medical examiners.
He also said that F. Lee Bailey committed male practice in the second trial, and that the Florida prosecutors knew he wasn't guilty. However, his book fails to rebut the circumstantial evidence against him, such as his wife's refusal to give him a divorce just before she died, the absence of a history of heart problems in her medical records, the lack of evidence of heart failure discovered in her autopsy, his acquisition of the succinylcholine right before her death, at a time when he was not a practicing physician, and some other damning facts. He barely mentions his first wife and expresses no remorse about her death. The book has been described by many people as a narcissistic exercise in self-pity.
Well, just to overlook his first wife and not show any kind of sadness or concern or... Yeah, it's pretty shitty. Yeah. Writers and researchers have reached the conclusion that Capolino was a pathological liar, inventing his heart disease to suit his needs. He had an apparently healthy and long life in Florida, dying at the age of 84 in 2017. So that seems like that was all a charade as well. Yeah. And it's weird, because why would you want to go on disability when you have such earning potential? It's like you just wanted to go out and find a rich woman and play bridge, really. What if she stayed married to Mary? He did, and she actually adopted the two daughters he had with Carmela.
But they were just kind of despicable. There are photos of them, you know, after the trial and actually before the trial. And they're just laughing and having a good old time. So they just seem like some real fuckers. Remorseless, heartless, narcissistic. A good couple. Yeah. They're meant for each other. It seems that way. Yes. We see a lot of that. So thank you, dear listeners, for listening to us today. And I'd like to give a thank you to Mike McClellan for our music. And we'd like to share some feedback, right? We've got some feedback if you're interested. I'm very interested. My favorite part of the show. It's time for listener feedback.
I've got an email from Robin in Australia who has a case suggestion. It's a rather long email, but you'll see where we're heading for when you read it or hear it. Well, you must think it's worth putting in or it wouldn't be here, right? Oh, you got it. So Robin wrote, True Crime Brewery is my absolute favorite podcast and I have to admit to getting a bit excited every time I get a new episode. I love the way you investigate the crimes and show respect for the victims and their families. I always feel like I am on the quiet end with you. Thanks, Robin. She goes on.
There's a case in Australia I would really love to hear you cover. It is probably the most famous murder investigation in Australian history and is very well known to all Australians. It may have been suggested to you before. The case is fascinating and also heartbreaking. It is of particular interest to me because the woman who was charged with the murder of her child suffered such injustice over such a long time, yet she bears no grudge and has no bitterness. Her integrity over the whole saga...
and her ability to forgive are inspirational. She and her husband maintained their innocence all the way through their ordeal and never wavered in their story, even though they were offered incentives, even freedom, to change their story. In the end, evidence showed that they had been telling the truth all along. I also think the story needs telling, as the phrase, A dingo ate my baby, has become a punchline in the media outside of Australia, and I think people should be made aware of the terrible tragedy that those words represent. On August 17, 1980, nine-week-old baby Azaria Chamberlain disappeared from her family's tent.
near the largest rock in the world, Ayers Rock, or as it's now known, Uluru, in Outback Australia. Azaria's mother, Lindy, said she saw a dingo leaving the tent and called out to her husband and anyone who could hear. A dingo took my baby. Although no one at the scene doubted Lindy, doubts were raised by police and the media. So I saw a movie about this starring Meryl Streep. Yeah. Yeah, I can't remember the name of it. So she goes on. Lindy and her husband, Michael, were unusual people and Australia didn't tolerate that very well. Lindy was judged as being hard because she didn't cry at the appropriate times or grieve in an acceptable way.
She was considered a bad mother because she had sometimes dressed Azaria in black. The Chamberlains were badly treated by the authorities and the media, and I remember as a teenager and young adult participating in jokes about dingoes and babies and not really appreciating the gravity of the situation. Lindy was tried and convicted of the murder of baby Azaria, and Michael was convicted as being an accessory. Lindy was to spend life in prison. At the time she was convicted, she was eight months pregnant with her second daughter, who was immediately taken from her after birth. One of the most crucial pieces of evidence was the supposed presence of fetal blood under the dashboard of the car, which was later proven to be a false finding.
The jury accepted that it was Azaria's blood and Lindy was convicted. This is the medical angle for True Crime Brewery. After many disappointing appeals and legal processes, and honestly some of the most incredible coincidences, Lindy and Michael were pardoned. They were not satisfied with this, however, and kept fighting to have their convictions quashed. As late as June 12, 2012, they were successful in having their names cleared. Sadly, their marriage did not survive. Michael died in 2017. Lindy is still interviewed regularly about the events that dominated her life. There are a lot of sources for this story.
including a musical. Honestly, you could spend the rest of your life researching this case. And then she goes on to recommend three, which I won't share at this point because it's kind of long and we will look at those. We will. The movie you're referencing was Evil Angels, but outside Australia, the title is A Cry in the Dark. And Meryl Streep was Lindy and Sam Neill was Michael. Meryl Streep got an Oscar nomination for it. And Robin says she was the first American I've ever heard do a decent Australian accent. Well, Meryl is like our top actress of all times. She can do any of that. But I do remember that movie. Oh, yeah. Yeah.
Did the movie show them as being guilty? I can't remember. Or was it uncertain in the movie? I'm not sure. But for some reason, I recall seeing the movie and thinking she wasn't guilty. And I don't know if that was my own thing or if that's the way the movie led it. Not sure. Anyway, there's some great sources here and we will keep them to use and cover this case, Robin. Yeah, I think, as Robin said, there's been a mountain of information about this. It might be a good time to look things over and see what we get. Yeah, I really was not aware that there was that much out there about it. I thought it was more simple. So sounds like a great case to do. Thank you. Yeah.
Then I have a voicemail. I have Justin. He wants to give us a couple case suggestions. All right. We've heard from Justin before. I think actually, didn't we just cover that Rhonda Reynolds case that he recommended? He did. All right. He wants us to look at these other two. Plus, he had mentioned when he gave the voicemail about Rhonda. Also had another case that he still wants to look at. So there's a mountain of material he's giving to us. We do appreciate it. Okay. Let's listen to Justin's voicemail and then we'll chat about it. Hello. It's Justin again. I'd like to thank you for doing a Rhonda Reynolds case. I think you've handled the situation very well with information that was given.
I actually corresponded with Barb Thompson last year. She's a very wonderful woman, and I think that Ron got away with murder on many things and a lot of injustice. I'd like to hope you could actually consider doing the Dawn Hackney case that I mentioned earlier. She was the young lady who burned in the fire, and later her husband was found guilty. I also have a couple case suggestions. There is the Sarah Johnson case. She was a young lady in eastern Idaho who was very much not happy with the situation with her parents, and she decided to take justice in her own hands. I have a beer suggestion for that.
There is the McCall Brewery in McCall, Idaho. It's on the other side of the state. They have a McCall coconut porter, which is very good. Like Dick, I like coconut porters. I also like stouts. I do like IPAs, but I'm more into stouts and dark ales. I also have another case suggestion of the murder of Little Miss. She was a young lady who was on her way to see her boyfriend in Wyoming and then make it to Montana as her final stop. After a missed appointment, took up the boyfriend. The boyfriend called the authorities of concern. Her mom, who I met, Sheila Kimmel, is...
a great woman who I worked with at Arby's. She was actually one of the area managers. And the lady in question of the murder is Lisa Marie Kimmel. So if you could do those cases, I greatly appreciate it. I appreciate all the good work that you do on True Crime Brewery. I don't get to enjoy the beers when I'm listening, however. I usually have Maxwell House or Folgers because I'm a long-haul truck driver. But I always look for anticipating new cases, and I go back to the old cases. And I enjoy listening to everything that you do. And I've actually looked at the books. You've actually suggested the cases, so I'm getting more into reading, which I greatly appreciate. Thanks for all your work. Thanks, Justin.
Yeah, I think audiobooks is probably a good thing for you. Audiobooks are great for these things. Yeah. I think that they take a long time to listen to an audiobook. So when I'm researching a case, I usually just read it. But they're great if you're doing something like driving a lot. Yeah. Certainly if you're a long haul trucker, you got plenty of time to listen. Absolutely. So that's great. But you have to listen to your podcast first. So the first case that Justin recommended, the Sarah Johnson case, she was pissed off at her parents because they were strict or whatever. Yeah, these cases never fail to amaze me. I know. And this is a horrible crime.
Shot them. Geez, yeah. With a shotgun. Her mother was sleeping in bed and the father was taking a shower. She went to the bedroom, shot her mother in the head. Yikes. And then opened the bathroom door and put two bullets in her father's chest. So she actually did this all on her own. Lots of times these young girls have a bad boyfriend who does. No, but she was on her own. Yes. And what was her reasoning? Any idea? We weren't letting her do the things she wanted. Wow. That is amazing and terrifying. Definitely. Yeah. Now her sentence has been appealed up to the Idaho Supreme Court and the sentence has been upheld.
Yeah. Well, that's not someone you can let out of prison. If you can do that to your own parent. Yeah, I think she's probably dangerous. Yes. Yeah. And in the second case, the interesting thing about Lisa Marie Kimmel, she disappeared somewhere between Denver and Wyoming. She's picking up her boyfriend. She never picked him up. Okay. So eight days later, her body was found. She'd been beaten and stabbed. And then they didn't find a killer. So her murder went unsolved for 14 years. And at that point...
DNA from her rape kit got submitted to CODIS. There was a hit on it. Okay. So we know who did it now? Did they get convicted? We don't know. No, I forget. I think he's dead. Oh, okay. But it's solved, is what you're saying? Yeah, it did get solved. Okay. All right. Well, 1988 and then 14 years later, either early 2000s. So yeah, DNA was being used quite a bit by then. All right. So two very different and very interesting cases. Two cases for us. So was Lisa an adult or a teenager? She was 18, 19 years old. A young kid. Yeah, that's really sad.
Well, thanks, Justin. Two great cases that we will look into. We appreciate your case suggestions all the time. We welcome them. Absolutely. So before we say goodbye, a quick reminder about our premium option of TCB where you can get early ad free and bonus shows. We do a bonus case or sometimes two every month. We send new subscribers a gift with a personalized thank you note. And you can subscribe at tiegrabber.com forward slash subscribe to get all of your TCB episodes early and ad free. If you prefer, we do have a Patreon as well. Patreon.com forward slash tiegrabber. Some other ways we'd like to ask for your help are if you enjoy the show.
please leave us a positive review on Apple Podcasts. And we would love to get your feedback. If you do have feedback or case suggestions, you can send an email to truecrimebrewery at tiegrabber.com. And voicemails can be recorded right on your laptop or phone or iPad or whatever. And they will go directly to us and probably get played on the show. We do try and play most of them. If they're repeats, we don't. If they're repeats, we just send an email. But we do like to play them for sure.
So thank you so much for listening to us. And I'm wishing that all of you are going to have a really awesome 2024. So let's get started on that. Let's do that. Okay. So we'll see you next time at the quiet end. Come on down. Bye-bye. Bye, guys.