EPISODE · Jun 4, 2026 · 6 MIN
The Night She Called from the Payphone at the Rusty Nail Bar
from The Last Voicemail — Fexingo Horror · host Fexingo
October 2009. A Tuesday night somewhere west of Flagstaff, Arizona. I was drinking black coffee at the Rusty Nail Bar when the payphone by the restrooms started ringing. No one else was in the place except the bartender and a man in a dusty cowboy hat who never looked up from his beer. The phone rang eleven times before I answered. The voice on the other end was a girl I hadn't spoken to in seven years. She said she was calling from a payphone outside a gas station in Texas. She said she was in trouble. She said she couldn't remember my number but somehow it came to her. Then she asked me not to hang up. This is what she told me. #PayphoneHorror #RustyNailBar #Flagstaff #Arizona #October2009 #LateNight #PhoneCall #OldFriend #Texas #GasStation #StrangeRoads #Disappearance #SmallTown #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #SoloNarration #AtmosphericHorror #Anthology Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
What this episode covers
October 2009. A Tuesday night somewhere west of Flagstaff, Arizona. I was drinking black coffee at the Rusty Nail Bar when the payphone by the restrooms started ringing. No one else was in the place except the bartender and a man in a dusty cowboy hat who never looked up from his beer. The phone rang eleven times before I answered. The voice on the other end was a girl I hadn't spoken to in seven years. She said she was calling from a payphone outside a gas station in Texas. She said she was in trouble. She said she couldn't remember my number but somehow it came to her. Then she asked me not to hang up. This is what she told me. #PayphoneHorror #RustyNailBar #Flagstaff #Arizona #October2009 #LateNight #PhoneCall #OldFriend #Texas #GasStation #StrangeRoads #Disappearance #SmallTown #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #SoloNarration #AtmosphericHorror #Anthology Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
NOW PLAYING
The Night She Called from the Payphone at the Rusty Nail Bar
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.