EPISODE · Jun 13, 2026 · 5 MIN
The Night the Elevator Opened to an Empty Church Pew
from Empty Floor Twelve — Fexingo Horror · host Fexingo
It was late November, just before Thanksgiving, when the elevator opened on a small church in Truth or Consequences, New Mexico. The air inside smelled of old hymnals and dust, and a single woman sat in the third pew, facing the altar. She didn't turn when Luna stepped out. She just kept whispering something under her breath—a prayer, maybe, or a list of names. Luna sat down beside her, and the woman began to speak without preamble, her voice like gravel rolling downhill. She told Luna about the December her husband disappeared, about the letters he left hidden in the attic, about a motel room on Route 60 and a man who checked in under her husband's name but wasn't him. The more she talked, the colder the air got, and the shadows in the stained-glass windows began to shift in ways that had nothing to do with the moon outside. Luna stayed until the woman finished, then walked back to the elevator alone. The doors closed on that church, and she never saw the woman again. But she still remembers the exact cadence of her whisper, and the way the pew creaked when she finally stood up and walked away into the dark. #EmptyFloorTwelve #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #TruthOrConsequences #NewMexico #Church #Disappearance #MotelRoom #Route60 #Letters #Hymnals #StainedGlass #Whisper #November #Luna #ElevatorHorror #StandaloneEpisode #Unresolved Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
What this episode covers
It was late November, just before Thanksgiving, when the elevator opened on a small church in Truth or Consequences, New Mexico. The air inside smelled of old hymnals and dust, and a single woman sat in the third pew, facing the altar. She didn't turn when Luna stepped out. She just kept whispering something under her breath—a prayer, maybe, or a list of names. Luna sat down beside her, and the woman began to speak without preamble, her voice like gravel rolling downhill. She told Luna about the December her husband disappeared, about the letters he left hidden in the attic, about a motel room on Route 60 and a man who checked in under her husband's name but wasn't him. The more she talked, the colder the air got, and the shadows in the stained-glass windows began to shift in ways that had nothing to do with the moon outside. Luna stayed until the woman finished, then walked back to the elevator alone. The doors closed on that church, and she never saw the woman again. But she still remembers the exact cadence of her whisper, and the way the pew creaked when she finally stood up and walked away into the dark. #EmptyFloorTwelve #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #TruthOrConsequences #NewMexico #Church #Disappearance #MotelRoom #Route60 #Letters #Hymnals #StainedGlass #Whisper #November #Luna #ElevatorHorror #StandaloneEpisode #Unresolved Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
NOW PLAYING
The Night the Elevator Opened to an Empty Church Pew
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Nov 15, 2023 ·8m
Nov 15, 2023 ·8m
Nov 15, 2023 ·13m
Nov 15, 2023 ·13m
Nov 15, 2023 ·8m
Nov 15, 2023 ·8m