EPISODE · May 18, 2026 · 6 MIN
The Night the Jukebox at the Rusty Nail Played Backwards
from Side B — Fexingo Horror · host Fexingo
A short drive off Highway 9 in Millbrook County sits the Rusty Nail, a bar that's been dying slowly since the paper mill closed in '94. The jukebox in the back corner never worked right — people put quarters in just to watch the mechanism jam. Then a regular named Walt claimed he heard something: a song playing backwards, slow and warped, with words that weren't English. Luna heard the story from the bartender's daughter, who heard it from Walt himself before he stopped coming around. By the time she got to the Rusty Nail, the jukebox was gone, but the hole it left in the room still hummed at a frequency you could feel in your teeth. This is a story about the things that get stuck in a place when the people leave. About the records we keep spinning long after the song is over. And about Walt, who never told anyone what he heard that last night — just that he wished he hadn't listened. #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #SideB #TheRustyNail #MillbrookCounty #FinalEpisode #Jukebox #RecordPlayer #BackwardsMusic #Walt #BartendersDaughter #Highway9 #PaperMill #SmallTownBar #AudioHorror #Atmospheric #Dread #Unresolved Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
What this episode covers
A short drive off Highway 9 in Millbrook County sits the Rusty Nail, a bar that's been dying slowly since the paper mill closed in '94. The jukebox in the back corner never worked right — people put quarters in just to watch the mechanism jam. Then a regular named Walt claimed he heard something: a song playing backwards, slow and warped, with words that weren't English. Luna heard the story from the bartender's daughter, who heard it from Walt himself before he stopped coming around. By the time she got to the Rusty Nail, the jukebox was gone, but the hole it left in the room still hummed at a frequency you could feel in your teeth. This is a story about the things that get stuck in a place when the people leave. About the records we keep spinning long after the song is over. And about Walt, who never told anyone what he heard that last night — just that he wished he hadn't listened. #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #SideB #TheRustyNail #MillbrookCounty #FinalEpisode #Jukebox #RecordPlayer #BackwardsMusic #Walt #BartendersDaughter #Highway9 #PaperMill #SmallTownBar #AudioHorror #Atmospheric #Dread #Unresolved Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
NOW PLAYING
The Night the Jukebox at the Rusty Nail Played Backwards
No transcript for this episode yet