The PCA's Christian Nationalism Report: What They Got Right and Wrong

Does the PCA Understand Christian Nationalism? What They Got Right... and Where They Went Wrong The PCA has released its long-awaited report on Christian Nationalism, and many people had already chosen sides before reading a single page. Some dismissed it because it came from the PCA. Others praised it simply because they oppose Christian Nationalism. In this episode, Pastor Joseph Spurgeon and Zach slow down and do something increasingly rare: they actually read the report. The committee was made up of faithful churchmen wrestling with difficult questions, and the report contains several important biblical affirmations that deserve recognition. At the same time, it raises significant concerns by blurring biblical commands with prudential judgments, narrowing the breadth of the Reformed tradition, and making historical claims that deserve closer examination. Together we walk through the report's affirmations and denials, discussing where we agree, where we disagree, and why these questions matter for every Christian who believes that Jesus Christ is Lord over every sphere of life. Chapters 00:00 Cold Open: Before You Pick a Side...02:00 Introduction03:40 What We Ate & Dad Jokes06:35 Why the PCA Created This Study Committee11:40 How Study Committees Actually Work17:20 The Report's Biggest Strengths24:30 Affirmation #1: Civil Government Under Christ30:00 Christian Political Engagement39:40 Does the Church Speak to Civil Government?48:00 The Westminster Confession & Church-State Relations58:00 Can the Civil Magistrate Call Synods?1:08:00 Historical Claims and Prudential Judgments1:18:00 Where We Agree1:28:00 Our Major Concerns1:38:00 Final Thoughts     About the Show The Patriarchy Podcast features in-depth conversations on faith, culture, theology, and leadership. Each episode equips Christians to live boldly and biblically in an age of compromise—exploring the challenges and opportunities of standing firm for truth in the modern world.   Support the Mission We’re still raising funds to expand Sovereign King Academy and keep tuition affordable for families. Want to invest in the future of Christ’s Kingdom?Give here: https://sovereignkingacademy.com   Connect with The Patriarchy Podcast YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ThePatriarchyPodcastSpotify: https://tinyurl.com/58tm5zjzApple Podcasts: https://tinyurl.com/f3ruzrsaWebsite & All Links: https://linktr.ee/thepatriarchypodcast Follow Joseph Spurgeon:Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ThePatriarchyPodcastX/Twitter: https://x.com/PatriarchyPodInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/thepatriarchypodcastGab: https://gab.com/thepatriarchypodcast   Sponsored By Steadfast Cigars – For men who reject passivity and take dominionOrder: https://steadfastcigars.com/ Fit Father Project – Dr. Balduzzi built the Fit Father Project to help men stop drifting, reclaim discipline, and get strong for life. If you're ready to take ownership of your health, don’t wait.  This is the first real step toward lasting strength—for your body, your family, and your legacy. Start: https://secure.fitfatherproject.com/a/transformation/4539 Books by Joseph Spurgeon:It’s Good to Be a Boy – https://a.co/d/7zpEh5DIt’s Good to Be a Girl – https://a.co/d/6VlBTzS   Final Call to Action Subscribe for more conversations that sharpen men for battle.Turn on notifications so you never miss an episode.Like and share to support biblical masculinity.