Skip to content
The Plague, Part 2: The Black Death episode artwork

Mar 2, 2020 37 min

The Plague, Part 2: The Black Death

from The Morbid Curiosity Podcast Hosted by The Morbid Curiosity Podcast

In this now three part episode, we discuss the three Great Plague Pandemics. In Part Two, we discuss the Black Death, Plague Doctors, and the Great Plague of London Become a Patron: bit.ly/morbidpatron Buy Us a Book: bit.ly/morbidwishlist

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Plague, Part 2: The Black Death

0:00 37:07
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This episode was suggested by Kristi Oh, and several other listeners. If you'd like to suggest a topic, you can do so on Facebook and Instagram at Morbid Curiosity Podcast on Twitter, at Morbid Podcast, and on our website, www.morbidcuriositypodcast.com. If you'd like to become a patron of the MCP, go to bit.ly slash Morbid Patron. That's B-I-T dot L-Y slash Morbid Patron, and you can support us for as little as $1 in episode.

This episode contains discussions of death by contagious disease. I want to emphasize that the plague is very treatable today with antibiotics, so there's no need to panic over this disease. After this advice, if contagious disease is still something you don't want to hear about, this may be a good episode to skip. Humans are fascinated by gore and violence, but even more so, the mysterious and unsolved.

Interest in these disturbing and unpleasant subjects is called Morbid Curiosity, and it has gripped hundreds of people throughout the ages. I am one of those people. My name is Halley, and this is the Morbid Curiosity Podcast. In part one of this episode, we discussed the cause of the plague, the bacteria on your cineopestus, which is a zoonotic disease of rodents.

The bacteria are transmitted by fleas to rodents, but when rodents move into close quarters with humans, due to a shift in their habitat or environment, the fleas can jump to humans, especially if the rodent population dies off because of the infection. In humans, the bacteria can cause four different forms of the plague, bubonic, pneumonic, septosemic, and abortive. The bubonic and pneumonic plague are the most common. Symptoms include high fever, headaches, joint pain, vomiting, dizziness, and bubos, or pus-filled sores on the lymph nodes nearest the fleabyte.

Pneumonic plague occurs when the bacteria infects the lungs, and in this form, the plague can be passed from person to person, through coughing and sneezing. Septosemic plague occurs when the bacteria move from the lymph nodes into the bloodstream, and infect multiple organs. This is the deadliest form of the plague. Meanwhile, abortive plague is the least dangerous, causing only a fever and swelling of the lymph nodes, but once recovered, the person develops immunity.

All forms of the plague are treatable with antibiotics today, but before the mid-20th century, this was not the case. During the plague of Justinian, which occurred in the 6th century CE, it was reported by several contemporary writers that around 33% of the population living around the Mediterranean Sea died of a plague-like disease. While your cineopestus DNA has been identified in the skeletons of individuals that died during the time of the Justinian Plague, it's hard to say whether your cineopestus was the sole cause and how devastating this pandemic actually was. As I mentioned in part 1, there were several recurrent waves of the plague after the plague of Justinian, usually happening every 8-12 years for around 200 years after the initial pandemic.

The last wave occurred in 750 CE. After that, there are few mentions of a plague with similar symptoms until the 1300s. In this second part of our plague episode, we are going to talk about the second plague pandemic, also known as the Black Death. Additionally, we've decided to do three parts, so in part three of this episode, we'll talk about the third plague pandemic, which began in 1855.

The Black Death, also called the Great Mortality, or the Years of Annihilation, refers to the first four years of the second pandemic, 1348 to 1352. The recurrent waves of the plague which stem from the Black Death occurred for around 400 years afterwards. The Black Death is considered to be history's most devastating pandemic. Over the four years that it affected Europe, Scandinavia, North Africa, the Middle East, and Central Asia, between 75 and 200 million people died.

It's hard to determine just how many people died due to poor record keeping and the sheer number of deaths. We know the mortality rate was catastrophic, however, due to the obvious population decline as well as references made to the plague in literature, art, and accounts from the time. The decrease in population caused by the plague led to economic and agricultural decline, increased criminal activity, and a general lack of value for human life. The most complete historical data we have for the Black Death comes from Europe, so this episode will mostly focus on the European aspects of the Black Death.

However, I will do my best to include what I can from the Middle East and Central Asia as well. The name Black Death comes from a Latin term, Atzramorz, used by French physician Gio de Corbe when he described the symptoms of the plague in the 12th century. It refers to the darkening of the large bubonic sores, which occurs as the disease progresses due to internal bleeding within the sore and subsequent tissue death. However, this term wasn't used as a name for the second pandemic until much later.

The beginnings of the Black Death are usually traced to 1347, when an army of the Mongol Empire lay siege to the port city of Caffa on the Black Sea, which was inhabited by merchants from Genoa. If you recall from part one, it's theorized that the original Yersinia pestis reservoir was located in Central Asia, specifically in Mongolia, northern China, or the Russian steppes. Chinese historical sources mention a large outbreak of pestilence in Mongolia around 10 years before the Black Death began, while Arabic sources indicate that pestilence raged in China and spread along the trade routes toward Europe. Wherever it originated, the plague made its first well-documented appearance in the Crimea.

The army of the Golden Horde, led by Johnny Begg, attacked the Crimean city of Caffa, now known as Theodosia in 1347. Caffa was a bustling port, and very important to the famous land trading route, the Silk Road. Around 70-80,000 people lived there. At the time, the city was held by the Italian city-state of Genoa, and the Genoese had control of all trade going in and out of the city.

The Mongol Empire, founded by Genghis Khan in 1206 CE, was the greatest political and military power in the 13th century. In the 14th century, the empire had split up into four connades due to struggles over succession and disagreements over the future of the empire. The Golden Horde in the northwest, the Chagatai in Central Asia, the Ilkhanate in the southwest, and the Yuan dynasty in the east, which was based where the modern-day city of Beijing sits today. Ten Shen between Genoa and the Mongol Empire had been brewing since around 1343, thanks to disagreements surrounding trading rights.

When a Muslim merchant was killed amidst these disagreements, Johnny Begg, the Khan of the Golden Horde, revolted against the Genoese and besieged the town of Caffa. Surviving documentation written by Gabrielle Demusi, a notary from Piacenza, Italy, reported that a mysterious illness began to affect the military camps of the Golden Horde during the siege. According to Demusi, the Golden Horde army used a catapult to fling the bodies of their diseased dead over the walls of Caffa, either to be rid of their dead, or as the first instance of biological warfare. This story may be apocryphal, it's more likely that while the Golden Horde couldn't get into the city, the rodents that inevitably took up residence in their camp could, and the plague made its way into the city via infected rodents.

The population of Caffa began to die, as did the soldiers of the Golden Horde. The siege ended in either April or May of 1347, with the dying army fading away, and a few surviving Genoese fleeing in their ships. In mid-1347, 12 of those ships landed in Sicily. Accounts described the ships as being laden with dead bodies.

Other ships from Caffa arrived in Genoa and Venice in 1348, and eventually in Pia. The plague also traveled south. It reached Alexandria, around the same time as it appeared in Sicily. From there it spread to Gaza, and then moved north to Jerusalem, Damascus, and Aleppo, and south toward Yemen.

By 1349, it had traveled as far as Antioch and Mecca. Historian Ibn Khaldun stated that the plague traveled to Syria among merchants coming from the Crimea. He also said that so many perished that it was, quote, as if the voice of existence in the world had called out for oblivion, end quote. By early January 1348, most Italian port cities were refusing entry to any ships suspected of carrying sick passengers.

Therefore, many refused ships sailed further north, and due to a lack of quick communication, they were allowed to dock at Marseilles. An outbreak began there in late January. By June, the plague had spread from France and Italy to Spain, Portugal and England. From there, it spread north and east, through Germany, and arrived in Norway in 1349.

It reached northwestern Russia by 1351. More isolated areas, such as the mountainous parts of Poland, Belgium, and the Basque region, as well as communities in the Alps and Himalayas, were spared. It was difficult for humans to travel there, meaning no rodents or fleas traveled there either, and it's theorized that it was also a bit too cold for your cineopestus to survive. In India and China, there are no records of any devastating epidemic matching the symptoms of the plague, from either the Yuan dynasty or the Delhi Sultanate.

However, these areas were devastated during the third plague pandemic, which I'll get to in part 3. At this time, there was a very limited understanding of how disease spreads and little effective medical knowledge. Most physicians were of one of two camps when it came to disease. Either it was brought down on humans by God, or it was due to the alignment of the planets, causing pockets of bad air to appear and cause disease.

This bad air theory, also known as miasma theory, was very popular around 1345. Not only planetary alignment could cause bad air, rotting organic matter such as grain or corpses could do it too. Miasma theory was a step toward germ theory, as rotting things are breeding grounds for harmful bacteria, but it wasn't close enough to prevent most disease at this time. The Black Death did, however, bring about a new form of medical writing, the plague tracked.

It was one of the first forms of popular literature in the West during the 15th century. These tracts were written by physicians, clerics and surgeons, and contained what these writers believed to be preventative measures and remedies for the plague. Some even included the writer's philosophy on what had caused it. The most famous of these is the compendium or report of the Medical Faculty of Paris, commissioned by King Philip VI of France in October of 1348.

As the plague had to be recognized in order to try and prevent it, its symptoms and some detailed records of who died from it also appeared, mostly in Italy in the 16th century. These reports weren't just written in Latin, either. Many were written in Italian, and therefore readable by anyone, not just learned physicians. In 1575, Giovanni Felipo Ingracia wrote Proto-Medico, the most influential and longest treatise on the plague in the 16th century.

It suggested that it was the duty of the rulers and local authorities to enact public health measures such as plague hospitals, quarantines, organizations to report on the health status of their location, clearing filth from the streets, and improving sewage. It also tracked the progression of the disease across Europe. The chroniclers of the plague began to rely on their own observations rather than traditional medical doctrine. They observed that the disease must be contagious by how it affected whole households and that bloodletting, a common treatment for everything at the time, actually weakened those with the plague.

Despite all these records, estimating the severity of the pandemic is hard as the records aren't detailed enough, and there were so many deaths it was hard to keep up with the reporting, or many times there was no one left to report. What we do know is that as the disease spread, a huge issue became what to do with the dead. Thanks to me asthma theory, people knew that corpses were in some way harmful to the living and had to be removed somehow. There weren't enough consecrated burial grounds to bury them all individually, so many communities were forced to dig large trenches where many bodies could be buried together.

The Monty Python skit, Bring Out Your Dead, isn't actually that far off. Cards went through towns and villages collecting corpses to take to these mass graves. While the popular vision of these mass graves are pits piled high with bodies, in actual plague pits, bodies were laid out in rows. Despite the dire situation, those left alive showed as much care and respect as they could to the dead.

This has recently been shown in an article published in February of this year that discusses the discovery of a mass grave in rural Lincolnshire from around 1348. The grave contained 48 individuals and DNA tests revealed the presence of your cineopestus. The layout of the graves shows that all the individuals were buried within the space of a few days, but they were carefully shrouded and laid out side by side. Even though these mass graves were done as respectfully as possible, they weren't the most efficient way of removing the contagion.

The best solution would have been to burn the bodies in a remote location, but the Catholic Church, which was the highest authority at the time, prohibited cremation due to the idea that the soul needed to return to the body at the end of days. As for the medical treatment of those that were alive but suffering from the plague, there were very few options. Those with the means fled to the cities and headed to locations that were said to have good air. While this may have removed them from plague-ridden areas, it likely also helped spread the plague further.

For those who couldn't afford to flee, there were several measures taken toward off the bad air, such as holding flowers to ones or carving across over the doorway of their homes. In Italy, more drastic measures were taken. The government issued several decrees forbidding passage in and out of plague-ridden areas. While this was supposed to contain the disease, it wasn't actually that effective, as it was the rodents, not the people who carried the bacteria.

Other treatments included burning exotic woods to dispense the bad air, eating special diets, taking herbal remedies, and opening and closing certain windows depending on the time of day. Bloodletting and leeches were also used. Some preventative measures may have worked to some degree in the case of pneumatic plague, such as covering one's mouth when near an infected person, and avoiding crowds. Of course, we can't talk about the Black Death without mentioning plague doctors, but before we get into that, let's pause for a word from our sponsors.

Lastly, if you like this podcast, why not sponsor the MCP yourself by becoming a patron on Patreon? Over 30,000 people download this podcast every month, but only around 90 people are supporting us on Patreon. For a mere dollar in episode that's $2 a month, you can get ad-free episodes, bonus behind-the-scenes info, give your opinion by answering polls, help choose episodes, and get updates on past episodes. For $3 an episode, you get monthly outtake reels.

For $5, you get a monthly quiz episode where I quiz my husband on past episodes. For $10, you get a detailed bibliography of all the resources I use while researching each topic, and for $20, you get a bit of miscellaneous morbidity, a short essay on a random morbid topic every month. Previously, we reviewed horror video games, discussed the medicine of Westeros, and the plague pits of London. All of these rewards aside, your patronage supports the podcast, and keeps new episodes coming.

I can't keep doing this podcast without you, so go to bit.ly-slash-morbid-patron, that's b-i-t.ly-slash-morbid-patron, to choose your rewards and support the MCP. You'll have my eternal gratitude. And now, back to the podcast. The infamous plague doctor didn't exist until the 1600s, long after the Black Death, but still in the grip of the many recurrent waves of the plague that struck afterwards.

Plague doctors were hired by the city or village to treat victims of the plague, as well as count and deal with the bodies of the dead. No qualifications were necessary beyond a strong constitution and being able to identify the symptoms of the plague. It was a very important job, as it was in constant need throughout the waves of the plague, and the economic downturn that followed. Plague doctors kept death records and served as witnesses for wills.

They were also allowed to do autopsies, which were usually considered a desecration of the corpse at this time, but in the case of plague victims, anything that might help identify the cause and how the disease spread was allowed. The costume, famously associated with plague doctors, was a waxed leather trench coat or cape, waxed leather gloves and trousers that served as a barrier against bad air, a face mask with glass eyes and a beak-like nose that was filled with aromatic herbs, also to ward off bad air. They carried wooden pointing sticks so they could examine the sick or the dead without getting too close. This stick and their wide brim hats marked their profession as plague doctors.

This costume is attributed to Charles de Lombe, a French doctor who wore it first in 1619. The Black Death didn't just kill millions, it affected almost every aspect of life, writing, art, law, theology and medicine are just a few aspects that were overshadowed by it. Death became personified in art as a skeleton with a reaping staff. The Black Death made regular people reconsider heaven and hell, God and Satan, and cast a mood of fear and helplessness everywhere it appeared.

Due to this mass fear, social conflict erupted, superstition and prejudice took over in many communities. Most plague chroniclers agreed with their religious leaders that the Black Death was divine retribution for the sins of humanity. Others, however, thought some nefarious human groups might be behind it, and several minority groups were persecuted, especially Jewish communities. Many Jewish communities in larger cities had already been isolated in ghettos which gave them some small protection from the plague.

The fact that the plague didn't hit these communities as hard as non-Jewish populations brought blame down on the Jewish people. They were accused of poisoning wells and being the cause of divine retribution. The worst accusers of the Jewish people were the flagellons. These Catholic religious zealots would whip themselves, which is called self-flagellation, in order to try and atone for the sins of all humans.

However, besides murdering themselves, they also attacked and murdered people of the Jewish faith. Flagellons were eventually condemned by the Catholic Church as heretics, as they preached that simply punishing oneself cleansed all sin, meaning that all other worship was unnecessary. The flagellons weren't the only ones to take violent actions against the Jewish community. This persecution was so prevalent that there were mass exterminations of Jewish communities in many major European cities.

The most violent and extensive were those in Maine, Strasbourg and Cologne. Over 100 Jewish communities were destroyed by the end of the Black Death. This type of panicked reaction didn't happen everywhere, however. In medieval Muslim societies in Egypt and Syria, the plague was viewed by most as a mercy and martyrdom for the faithful and a punishment for the unfaithful.

Many calmly accepted its presence and didn't seek extreme measures in attempts to cure themselves. There were definitely those who began to question the tenants because of the plague's severity, but for the most part, the violent panic seen in parts of Europe was absent in the Middle East, despite the fact that both areas suffered multiple waves of devastating disease. The Black Death was only the first wave of the second great plague pandemic. While the disease faded in some parts of Europe and the Middle East in 1352, it was just beginning to appear in others.

The later outbreaks were smaller than the Black Death, but no less devastating. Italy, which had been hit first and the hardest during the Black Death, was hit again in the late 1400s and then again in between 1629 and 1631. It was during the late 1400s outbreak in Venice that extra plague hospitals, or Lazaretti, were needed to quarantine those suspected of being sick and one was built on the island of Povelia, which you can hear more about in our Povelia episode. The Great Plague of London in 1665 was the last large epidemic of the plague in England.

During the year and a half that it raged, the plague killed around one-fourth of the population of London, around 100,000 people. By this point, the plague had become endemic to London, meaning it was almost always present in small pockets. Thanks to the continuing lack of sanitation and hygiene, the dirty city was subject to several smaller outbreaks of the plague before the Great Plague, but thanks to some unusually warm weather, a larger outbreak of the disease occurred in St Giles and then spread quickly across the city. The government tried to instigate containment measures, but they all failed.

It was at this time that plague doctors traveled the streets, seeing to the sick and the dead, and the upper classes fled to the city. In 1666, the Great Fire of London occurred, destroying much of the city. Many people attribute the end of the plague to that fire, but it's more likely that the plague was already dying out by that point. The plague killed fewer and fewer people with every successive wave.

This could be due to the immunity built up by those who survived, but also as the population was depleted, there just weren't that many people left. The plague was still omnipresent in Europe and the Middle East into the 17th century. The last big outbreak occurred in France in 1720. This outbreak is used to mark the end of the second pandemic.

There wasn't another outbreak of the plague until 1855, but we'll talk about that in part 3. Over the course of the Black Death and its recurrent waves, recent research suggests that 45 to 50% of the population of Europe died. This mortality rate isn't a blanket rate, however. It was higher in some places, such as around the Mediterranean, where a rate of 75 to 80% is more likely, and lower in others, such as Germany, where it was closer to 20%.

Port cities suffered the most recurrences, and Baghdad had the most severe population loss out of all urban centers, losing two-thirds of its inhabitants. Remember that the plague didn't just affect humans. Dogs, cats, birds, camels, even lions, and of course rodents were mentioned in the historical reports as being affected with pubos and other symptoms of the plague. While we don't have solid numbers, we know many animals died.

It took decades for the human and animal populations of Europe and the Middle East to recover. As for why the Black Death occurred when it did, there are several factors that most historians and epidemiologists agree created the perfect conditions for our pandemic. The years leading up to the Black Death were generally unhealthy for both humans and animals. Most of Europe and the Middle East was war-torn, meaning there was a rise in destroyed or damaged buildings, fields and grain stores left to rot, and injured and dead humans.

All of these attract pests, which often carry bacteria. Cities were growing and becoming overpopulated. They were unable to sustain enough resources for all their inhabitants. People lived crowded together in confined spaces, and there was no such thing as sanitation services or waste management, so human refuse and garbage mined the streets.

There were few privies and open drains ran down most streets. People often lived with their animals as well, adding to the filth inside their homes. Personal hygiene was not up to today's standards either. People didn't bathe or change their clothing often.

With this type of prevalent squalor, it's very likely people weren't very healthy in general. Several skeletons from verified plague pits, which were revealed during the London Crossrail Project in 2013, showed signs of severe malnutrition nutrition on top of carrying eucinia pestis DNA. It's not known how much a person's health affects the actions of eucinia pestis, but it's thought to contribute at least a little to how severely the plague affects those it infects. The Earth's overall temperature was also in flux.

Using dendrochronology or tree ring analysis, researchers have shown that the 14th century was a period of the most severe weather in around 2000 years. The temperature was far colder than normal and had been for a few years all over the world. This period is called the Little Ice Age, and the cold weather brought about famines, droughts, and flooding. China was lashed with cycles of rain and then drought and earthquakes were becoming common there, as well as in Italy and Austria.

The situation was similar in India. Parts of Poland were overrun by swarms of locusts, bringing on fear that the apocalypse was near at hand, even before the plague began. As we talked about in part 1, this change in environmental conditions could have driven certain animals, such as rodents, into new habitats. Rodents carrying fleas infected with eucinia pestis may have moved into an area of human habitation, or traveled along with trade caravans, carrying goods that the fleas could hide in, such as fabric or grain.

This is perhaps why the plague began to show itself once again. Both India and China were affected by a strange pestilence about a decade before the Black Death as reported by Ibn Al-Wardi, an Arabic historian, as well as in the chronicles of the Great Mongol Khanate. A boost in trade by both land and sea could have increased the spread further, taking the plague to pandemic proportions. Most historians and epidemiologists agree that the Black Death was caused by eucinia pestis, however there is still some degree of doubt.

Skeptics of the eucinia pestis theory point out that it's unlikely that the rodent population would have been big enough to cause this degree of mass casualty. Northern Europe's cold climate also doesn't cater to the flea population, as they die in freezing temperatures. On top of this, the spread of modern eucinia pestis is much slower, despite quicker transportation, and at the time of the Black Death, the disease struck crowded urban locations, while today it's mostly an issue for rural populations. Revuddles for these points include that the disease has changed since that time.

Bacteria evolve and change, developing different strains to adapt to any situation, and eight centuries have passed since the second pandemic. Also, urban areas today are much different than they were in the past, being cleaner and better sealed against rodents. Still, there are many alternate explanations for what disease the Black Death was caused by. One of the leading alternate theories is that anthrax caused it, which was suggested by Norman Cantor, a medieval historian.

Anthrax is another highly infectious bacteria that affects animals and spreads rapidly, infecting the skin, lungs, and intestines. Another theory is Ebola caused it, a rare but deadly virus that causes damage to the organs and uncontrollable bleeding. The last alternate theory is that it was several diseases, typhus, smallpox, and other respiratory infections combined with eucinia pestis. While most people fixate on the horrors of the Black Death, it should be mentioned that some good did come of it.

Due to the high mortality rate, there weren't many laborers or tradesmen, and those that were left had more power to demand higher wages and better treatment, which over time raised their standard of living. As many of the plague tracks were written by common people, they were written in common languages. This brought literature and writing to people who hadn't had access to it before, such as women and the lower classes. Also, critical thinking became more common, as people began to refuse to take often repeated traditional blanket statements as fact.

It's difficult for us today to understand the mortality, terror, grief, and sadness brought about by the Black Death. No modern epidemics can be compared to it. Thankfully, the plague can be treated today, but as with any other epidemic, panic is never the answer. All we can do is our best to understand, and try to prevent it happening again by supporting modern science and medicine.

If you'd like to know more about the Black Death, I'd recommend reading John Kelly's book, The Great Mortality, and Intimate History of the Black Death. It's incredibly detailed, but also very readable. In part three, we will discuss the third plague pandemic, so until next time, keep up that spark of curiosity. Please consider becoming a patron on Patreon.

You can also give one-time donations by going to our website, www.morbidcuriositypodcast.com, and clicking the donate button. On our website, you can also find links to all our social media and sponsors, and other ways to contact us. If you'd rather contact us by mail, this address is also listed on the website. Another way to help the show is by going to our Amazon Wishlist at Bitly slash Morbid Wishlist.

Any purchases from this list are greatly appreciated. We are eternally grateful for your support. My name is Halle, and until next time, thanks for listening.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Morbid Curiosity Podcast?

This episode is 37 minutes long.

When was this The Morbid Curiosity Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on March 2, 2020.

Can I download this The Morbid Curiosity Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.