Uncle Bob can fix just about anything around the house, at least according to him. But when it comes to natural gas appliances, they should always be inspected by a qualified professional. Learn more at embridgegas.com slash safety. True Crime Brewery contains disturbing content related to real-life crimes. Medical information is opinion based on facts of a crime and should not be interpreted as medical advice or treatment. Listener discretion is advised. Welcome to True Crime Brewery. I'm Jill. And I'm Dick.
So Michael Cochran's murder really shocked a quiet West Virginia community and would expose a pattern of deception that had been building for years. What looked like a medical emergency quickly led to a criminal investigation, uncovering fraud, manipulation, and a deadly plan carried out by the one person that he should have trusted most. Join us for The Ponzi Widow. We are following the evidence from forged prescriptions to financial schemes to murder to reveal how the truth finally emerged. Through case files, trial testimony, and media reports, we're examining the choices that led to Michael's death and the fight for justice that followed. And while we do this, we're going to be drinking beer. So what have we got today, Dick? I've got a really nice beer. It's a Saison, brewed by Weathered Ground Brewery in Ghent, West Virginia. And the beer is To the Place I Belong, which I think is a good label for a beer. Yeah, who's saying that? That's John Denver. West Virginia, yeah. That's cute. I like a good beer name, a clever one. Yeah, this one's good. Yeah. So it's a hazy pale yellow color with a big puffy white head. Leaves a fair amount of lace.
And like any good Saison, it's got that funky barnyard aroma. Grass, hay, some spice. And I take a little bit of citrus. A nice spicy taste. Pepper, clove. And in walks that citrus again. Get some orange. Well carbonated. It tickles your nose through the carbonation. And it tastes fantastic. I can't wait. You know, I love me some citrus. I know you do. I know we have an essential oil diffuser. And one of my favorite oils to put in it is the citrus, the orange. And if you mix the orange with the vanilla, you can make your house smell like a creamsicle. So you might want to try that. Our house smells good, right? People come over. They always say, oh, it smells good here.
So either they're being polite or it's a nice thing. Well, I think if they're being polite, they wouldn't say anything. No, that's true. If you don't have anything nice to say, right? Right. Okay, well, let's open this beer. Let's do that.
Now, you know, I'm a fan of the funky barnyard. So that's really nice. So it's like you're at a farm. You're sitting out there with the nice animals and you're smelling some citrus. Really nice. Really, really nice experience. Yeah, I like it. I don't feel like we've had a great beer in a while and this may be a great beer. This is inching up there. Yeah, really. Okay. So come on down to the quiet end. Why don't you? Let's sit down. Okay. So Michael met his wife, Natalie, when he was just 17 and their relationship really took off quickly. They started dating soon after they met and they went to college together.
Then they got engaged during their first semester. And these two were married by the time they were barely out of their teens. So it all moved really fast. And from the outside, it looked kind of like a typical young romance, you know, first love type of thing. And it would last a long time. But, you know, in hindsight, there were some early signs of tension. And this was mostly around Natalie's need for control and some bad interactions with Michael's family.
She really clashed with Michael's mother even before the wedding. And she tried to keep his parents from attending, which is very weird. Why wouldn't you want your intended parents to come? It's going to be tough to exclude parents. Yeah. And even if you're not crazy about them, you think for his sake, you'd want them to be there. But they did come. And later on, though, there was a rift. And this was something that happened while they were in college that she'd never apologized for. But nobody has really come out and said what that was. But at the time, these moments just seemed kind of like normal relationship conflict.
But if you look back now, they kind of fit a pattern of manipulation that would become much more pronounced later in the marriage. So Michael Brandon Cochran was born on December 23rd, 1980. So almost a Christmas baby. And he was born in Beckley, West Virginia. He was the only child of Donna and Michael Cochran. Now, when he was eight years old, his stepfather, Ed Bolt, entered his life. And these two developed a really close relationship. So he was like a dad to him. According to Donna, Michael was really an exceptional student all the way through school. He consistently made the honor roll and he participated in lots of after school clubs.
He was very athletic from a young age and developed a very strong interest in sports and physical fitness. He began lifting weights at the age of 10 after getting his first set of barbells, and he later would win first place in a powerlifting competition. So he met Natalie Jessup at a sporting goods store when he was 17. He had visited the store with his mother, and Natalie was working at the register. And his mom would say that she noticed Michael and Natalie were flirting with each other. So there was definitely an attraction from early on. Shortly after that, Michael and Natalie were dating. Both graduated from high school and enrolled at West Virginia University, and Michael studied information technology.
while Natalie worked on a degree in pharmacology. And then during their first semester of college, they became engaged. But it sounds like they were both very good students, pretty smart. Yeah, they were so young. Very young, yeah. So in November of 1999, Natalie and Michael told Donna that she and Michael planned to get married. So the wedding would be in May 2000. Donna was very concerned about how quickly the relationship was moving, and she said she preferred if Michael would focus on his education. But he still did well in school, even though they went ahead with the marriage. They were in love and determined to marry. During the couple's senior year, that's when there was some kind of incident that caused tension with Michael's family.
Like I said, Donna hasn't shared these details publicly, but she has said that the situation created some conflicts with Natalie. So from early on, she wasn't totally on board with Natalie. Michael did apologize to his family about this incident, whatever it was, but Natalie refused to. And then there were additional disagreements around the time of the wedding. That included an argument that led to efforts to cut out Donna and Ed's involvement in the ceremony at all. But, you know, things went ahead. They were married. Eventually, they had two children, a son and a daughter, Nicole, who is now an adult, and the family settled in Daniels, West Virginia, on a four-acre property that Michael mostly renovated by himself. So for all outward appearances, they lived a typical and comfortable life as a family. Michael working in IT, and Natalie was working as a pharmacist. Both were really active in their community, too.
Michael coached his son's baseball and football teams, while Natalie managed sports-related activities, handled the jersey orders, and she would eventually serve as treasurer for the middle school baseball program. So through their many community connections, the Cochran's had some close relationships, friendships, and particularly this was true with Chris and Jennifer Davis. Chris was definitely Michael's best friend. Chris coached alongside Michael and later became the family's attorney as well. So these two families spent significant time together, even going on vacations together, because Natalie was a pharmacist specializing in diabetes education and management.
She helped the Davises when their son was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes and taught them how to administer insulin and how to manage his condition. Another friend, Tony, was a mother whose husband had died from leukemia. And she later explained that Michael became a very supportive presence for her children, often taking them to sports practices, fishing, and just being involved in their lives, kind of filling the empty space that losing their father had left behind. Then in 2017, Natalie announced she was leaving her job as a pharmacist to start a government contracting business. This business was called Tactical Solutions Group. That's a mouthful. TSG.
She said she was inspired by the film War Dogs, which depicts small businesses bidding on military contracts. TSG was described as a company that supplied weapons, healthcare equipment, and other large-scale items to government agencies. Yeah, so when she started this business, she would ask anyone that was employed by her to watch that film War Dogs, which really wasn't the type of film that you would watch to understand a business or do better in a business. It was actually kind of like a comedy. These were troubled people in the movie, so it was really just kind of a weird thing that she would even bring that up. Yeah, it's not going to get you any business.
No, it wasn't like a documentary or a learning thing at all. Maybe it was just an attempt at comedy. I don't know. I think she was really taken with the idea of the huge numbers. You know, the money was huge with government contracts. And that really turned her on. So Natalie, we're going to find out, really loved money. A lot. Yeah, a lot. So to fund this business, Natalie went out and sought investments. And she got these investments from friends, family, and people in the community who knew her and trusted her. She told potential investors they could expect substantial returns quickly.
And she often emphasized that certain contracts were part of classified government programs. So this was convenient for her because it limited the amount of information she could share with the investors. That's quite clever, actually. Yeah, she wasn't stupid. Although, you know, all criminals in the end make mistakes, especially when greed's involved. They don't know when to quit, right? Yeah, that's the hook. Yep. So Chris and Jennifer Davis, their best friends, invested a total of $511,000 after Natalie approached them about a contract. Michael's mom and stepdad, Donna and Ed,
invested about $245,000, and this was pretty much their entire retirement savings. So you can see that this is a huge loss when they lose that money. TSG was registered as a legitimate business, and Natalie later established a second company, Technical Management Solutions, TMS, and described this as an IT consulting firm. So although Michael eventually worked full-time for TSG, his role was focused on finding contracts to bid on, while Natalie handled the operations and all of the finances. She was listed as 51% owner, with Michael holding 49%.
And she explained this structure by saying that way they were qualified as a woman-owned business, which could get them certain advantages. So as the business was seeming to grow, the Cochran's family lifestyle changed dramatically. So they bought additional properties, vehicles, jewelry, just lots of luxury goods, and even bought an airplane hanger while Michael pursued his dream of getting his pilot's license. So Michael did have a part in spending a bunch of this money, but he also made several charitable contributions. including funding a weight room for a local school and actually buying a house for a youth pastor in need. So although TSG did well on paper, the business was not operating as Natalie was presenting it to people at all. And by people, I mean, especially investors who were giving her money. The financial returns that she promised to the investors weren't coming in. And the structure of the operation would turn out to be a Ponzi scheme with funds from new investors used to pay for earlier ones. But there were no contracts at all, ever. None. Totally made up. Hard to imagine, isn't it?
So Natalie claimed that her company, Tactical Solutions Group, was a leading supplier for agencies such as the Department of Defense, the CIA, and Homeland Security. To fund the business, she sought startup capital from people. And these were people within her own circle, friends, relatives, people in the community. So she's really just fucking over people who trust her and care about her. And, you know, that's a Ponzi scheme for you, I guess. Well, that is. I mean, you got to keep on recruiting new people so you can pay off at least some of the old people. Right. Just to keep it going. But eventually it's going to fall apart. Eventually it's going to topple over because you're not ever going to be able.
To get enough income coming in. And it didn't seem like she was even making an effort. Like you think, okay, you're doing this, but you don't really want to steal from people. Maybe you would put some effort in to actually get contracts or do something. But she didn't seem to do that at all. She was just out spending money and lying. Investors believe they were supporting a legitimate venture. They were totally unaware that the operation was functioning as a Ponzi scheme. And how would they know? You know, she made up fake documents with fake letterhead. And if they see some money coming in. Yeah. Things are working well. And she's a pharmacist. So she seems like she'd be trustworthy, right? Right. Pharmacist, mom, all that. I'd like to know how she got this idea.
And here she is with a home and children. I know. She had everything. She has a job. A good job. Right. One year marriage. Yeah. And she's looking to do this. Yeah. I don't know. It's like a mental illness almost, isn't it? Yeah. It's just like all of a sudden one day she wakes up and she's turned evil. Well, I don't know if it's all of a sudden. I mean, like Michael's mom said, there was always something about her that wasn't quite great. But yeah, just the fact that she did this and went so way out there with it. There's something wrong with her. And, you know, we'll find that out because she even goes further with her, you know, terrible things that she does.
So in a Ponzi scheme, the funds from new investors are used to pay earlier investors, and for a while that can create the illusion of profit and stability. So the offenders often rely on trust, familiarity, and social credibility to secure these investments. So I looked at some research on financial fraud, and it showed that individuals who run Ponzi schemes frequently use personal relationships as leverage. They present themselves as knowledgeable, confident, and dependable. And they may also employ urgency, secrecy, or exclusivity to limit scrutiny and to discourage any questions.
So these tactics can reduce the likelihood that investors will verify claims or request any documentation. And she did make fake documentation. And then she had some things on her side because there was a government shutdown for a time. And that was an excuse for not paying people. There was COVID. And also it was clever that this was the kind of business where she could say, oh, you know, top secret government. And that's why I find it hard to see how she was able to hide it from Michael. So she must have been pretty damn clever because he wasn't a total idiot.
Well, the authorities are certain that he had no knowledge. Yeah, we'll get into that a little bit with the trial. But yeah, it definitely seems like he did not know. Although towards the end, he was probably figuring it out. And that was, you know, a big problem. Yeah, I imagine it is. Yeah. So Natalie used several strategies. She told potential investors that she preferred to submit bids at the last possible moment, which meant they had limited time to consider whether or not to invest their money. She also described the contracts as classified government programs. So, of course, this is another way to say she couldn't share details.
So this approach did make it difficult for investors to ask any follow-up questions or to confirm how legitimate this was. But the people investing knew her personally and trusted her. So remember that Chris and Jennifer Davis invested over $500,000 after Natalie approached them. And Michael's parents, Donna and Ed, invested about $245,000, their whole retirement savings, after Natalie told Donna that her own mother had already earned a $60,000 return. So across multiple interactions, Natalie consistently promised large...
rapid returns on all of these investments. And many investors later described a sense of group confidence. I mean, you see these other trusted families making investments with her. And you also see Natalie and Michael are rich. They're living quite the lifestyle. Yes, they are. I mean, they're flying all over. They're taking trips overseas and taking people with them and paying for it. This is huge amounts of money they're spending. Yeah. They have their own plane. We don't fly commercial. No, they don't fly commercial. Right. That's right. So this is like really wealthy. So this I can see would make you think, wow, look how well they're doing. Yes. I need to get in on this.
But concerns did start to grow. They grew when irregularities surfaced in the local sports league's finances, so this might have been the first little tip-off. As treasurer, Natalie had access to the baseball program's account, and an audit revealed that funds raised during a 2018 fundraiser approximately $32,000 were missing. So transactions showed purchases unrelated to league activities, including sporting goods, but not for the team, expensive coolers, a bow and arrow, ATM withdrawals of cash, and then retail spending, like boutiques and Botox and that kind of stuff. Now, although the findings did suggest...
pretty much confirmed misuse of funds, no formal action was taken against Natalie. Well, I'd be thinking that she's certainly guilty. Of taking the baseball fund money. Yeah, but this is just really a drop in the bucket. I realize that. But it tips you off to her dishonesty, right? Yeah. And she's probably thinking, well, I got away with it for a length of time. I'm going to keep this Ponzi scheme going. Right, but taking that money from the baseball team, it's not that much money in the big picture. So why do that? It's just very careless, very greedy is all I can think. Yeah, there's no reason to do that. No, there isn't. Well, there's no reason to do any of this.
Right. She and her husband both had good jobs. They had a nice house. You know, there was nothing wrong with their lives. It was just really greed and selfishness. And I don't know, like real problems with her. So as 2018 came to an end and 2019 began, investors started questioning the status of their money. Many of them did approach Michael directly, but he often didn't know how to respond to them. So he's starting to wonder what's going on. He only knew what Natalie had told him, and she was providing a series of shifting explanations. So one of her first claims was that TSG was undergoing an audit.
and that the company's accounts were temporarily frozen. So we've heard that excuse before somewhere. I can't release my tax returns because they're being audited. Oh, yes, I think I'm being a candidate for president. Something like that, yeah. She assured investors that once the audit was complete, payments would resume. Another explanation used was the December 2018 U.S. government shutdown. So during this time, Natalie told people that if the government wasn't issuing payments, then she couldn't either. So I'm not sure about that. Now, the timing of the shutdown made this excuse appear plausible, but it was also very convenient for her. Now, if they're doing government contracts...
Why couldn't she pay people if she had the money? She's saying that the government's not paying the money, so she can't give it to them. But you would think the lifestyle they're living and she's evaluating this business at hundreds of millions of dollars. How can she say we can't pay you? So, you know, people aren't stupid. These people trusted her, but only to a certain extent. And they're starting to get some concerns and suspicions. Just the idea of investing your entire retirement in anything is terrifying to me. Yeah, I don't know how that guy that lost 500 grand, how you can do that. I don't know. It's just really scary.
But when these explanations that she was giving could no longer be used, that's when Natalie introduced a new story. Crazy story. She told the investors she had cancer. So she lied about having leukemia. And she even told people, you know what, I'm not going to seek treatment. I'm just going to go with God and live my life as long as I can and just, you know, leave my fate to the heavens kind of thing. Friends and family were very alarmed by this. This is a young woman with children. Why wouldn't she get treatment? Some of them just went out and underwent bone marrow testing to see if they could help her, if they could be donors. But then her friend Tony, and that's the friend whose husband had died from leukemia.
recognize Natalie's inconsistencies in this story because Natalie claimed she was in stage three. But as we know, leukemia is categorized by type, not stage, correct? Correct. So she should have known this, you would think, or at least maybe did a little research, but she fucked up with that. Now, she also showed people a bald spot that she had on her head and she said it was caused by chemotherapy. But Tony looked at it and believed that it looked like she just shaved a spot. So it wasn't like medically induced. And, you know, what about that first claim that she wasn't seeking medical treatment for cancer? If she's losing her hair, that would be related to chemotherapy, which she claimed she wasn't going to get.
But I guess the story kind of evolved that she was getting treatment. So she was really pretty good at fabricating some official looking correspondence as well. She sent emails and letters to investors using government letterheads, including the Department of Defense. So that looks pretty official. And these had explanations about any delayed payments. She even used a Department of Defense letterhead and claimed to be in correspondence with someone from the department. And these tactics reinforced the lie that TSG was engaged in legitimate.
high-level government work. So we also find out that she was tricking her husband with this. She was actually giving him email addresses to write to about these contracts with the government. So he would send these emails out to fake email addresses. And she'd even write back to him sometimes. So this was just really a scheme. There's no other way to look at it. Yeah, but what she's doing makes her company look good. Well, yeah, for a while. But we know these Ponzi schemes really rely on interpersonal trust. So offenders are targeting people within their own social networks.
And research on financial fraud shows there are several common psychological patterns with these individuals who run schemes like this. So what I thought was really interesting was affinity exploitation. And this is that offenders use shared identity, family ties, community involvement, religious affiliation, or friendship to lower any skepticism that may arise. So investors assume that someone they know personally definitely would not deceive them. And with most people, I think that's fair. But with Natalie, no. No. There's also something called authority signaling.
And this is when fraudsters present themselves as experts or insiders. And in this case, Natalie claimed to be working with agencies like the Department of Defense and Homeland Security, and she was using official-looking documents. And this all reinforced this image that would make it difficult to even question her about this. Another thing that was important that she used in getting the investments was urgency and very limited transparency. So Ponzi operators frequently create a sense of time, pressure, or secrecy. Natalie told investors that contracts were classified, limiting their ability to ask questions or to verify any details.
And she had layered excuses like when payments failed, offenders will typically offer explanations that sound plausible. And that's what she did. Audits, banking delays, government shutdowns, or even personal crises like the cancer. Now, saying that she had this very serious illness was a particularly powerful tool because it elicited sympathy and it would discourage anyone to question her. You know, I'm not going to question the lady with cancer. You feel like you're beating up on somebody. Right. But how do you do this and have a conscience? I think you really have to be able to.
compartmentalize what you're doing, like separate fraudulent activities from your personal relationships and convince yourself that the deception is temporary or that it's somehow justified. And this can make it easier for people who do this kind of thing to maintain close relationships with their victims while they're continuing to scheme and steal from them. So some investors never received any money back. Michael's mom, Donna, didn't get a penny from Natalie at any point. Natalie had told people that her business was worth $500 million. It's a claim that further encouraged confidence in the company's success. But this was an outrageous claim, nowhere near that much money. By early 2019,
Pressure is mounting. Michael's mother and friends were asking him direct questions about their investments, and he had no answers. Text messages between Michael and Natalie showed his growing confusion. On January 31st, 2019, Natalie wrote, I'm on the phone with Bank of America. Michael replied, are we 1,000%? She responded, yes. She's sending them with tracking. Days later, Michael texted her, money isn't there. So Natalie replied to this with detailed explanations about wire transfers, verification delays, and large incoming amounts.
Yeah, well, I mean, Michael eventually responded, doesn't make sense to me. And his messages would suggest genuine confusion rather than any complicity in the scheme. But I think at this point, we're really getting tipped off that he's questioning things and getting suspicious. I think that really, you know, he's not going to buy these explanations forever. Yeah, he can only go so far. And remember, his best friend has invested over half a million dollars. So he had to be worried about that. So by early February of 2019, Michael was really getting close to uncovering what Natalie had been doing. On February 6th, the two were scheduled to charter a flight to Virginia.
And they were going to meet there with the Bank of America branch. Bank representatives believed they were meeting to open a new account for multi-million dollar deposits. But Michael thought they were going to discuss why the payouts for investors had not arrived yet. But the accounts that Natalie had referenced to Michael did not exist at all. So Natalie's in a real corner here. She needs to prevent the meeting and prevent Michael from learning the truth about what she's been up to. So she needed a reason to cancel that.
So that morning, just before 7 a.m., Natalie texted the bank representative and the pilot that she and Michael had to postpone because she said she was sick. So they had a private flight ready to go and a meeting with some bigwig at Bank of America. So, wow. So then she went to a doctor's office and got a steroid injection. And this was the second steroid dose she had sought that week. Two days earlier, she had texted her friend Stephanie Hamilton, who was a physician, asking for steroids because she said she had pneumonia.
So Stephanie had agreed to provide some steroid pills, but Natalie specifically requested an injectable form and said she could administer it herself. After that doctor's visit, Natalie texted Jennifer Davis to explain that she was too ill to fly. She told Jennifer that her doctor had given her a high dose of steroids. and that her illness was worsened by her supposed cancer. She also said she needed insulin because the steroids were raising her blood sugar, which is something they do. Jennifer, wanting to help then, prepared a bag with insulin and some other items, and she had her husband Chris deliver it to the Cochran's home. Two hours later, both Chris and Jennifer received a very disturbing text from Natalie. So this text had a photo of Michael collapsed on the kitchen floor, kind of in the fetal position, but really kind of face down. It was very disturbing. It's not normal. So when they asked Natalie what happened, she just downplayed the entire situation. She told them that Michael had had a seizure and he had fallen.
She also claimed that contractors had come and helped her move him to the couch where he was sleeping it off. Several people came to the house that day after receiving similar messages, and that included their friend John, who was a state trooper. John came in and took one look at Michael, and he said he needed medical attention immediately. But Natalie refused. She insisted that Michael hated hospitals and that he had told her she would regret it if she ever took him to one again. So that just seems crazy. I don't believe any of that. Even if someone said that to you, if you cared about them, you wouldn't just keep them home unconscious. Nope.
Now, Natalie referred to Michael's earlier hospitalizations as part of her justification for refusing to get him any medical care. Back in October and November of 2018, Michael had undergone back surgery and had also been evaluated for some respiratory problems that they thought may have been related to black mold exposure. So some cases of exposure to this mold can cause respiratory issues or immune system complications, according to some sources. But Michael had reportedly told a friend he believed he was being poisoned. So there's a red flag. And that really adds another layer of suspicion about what Natalie had been up to. But throughout that day, every visitor who showed up at the Cochran house expressed real alarm at Michael's condition, and they urged Natalie to seek medical help. But she continued to refuse, even though every person who stepped foot in their home that day had the exact same reaction, that Michael needed medical attention immediately.
So why didn't anyone call 911? I'll never understand. Yeah. You got all these people that are concerned about him. Yeah. And earlier in the day, he may have been saved, right? He'd just been so long. Yeah. So Natalie's explanations and refusal to allow medical intervention created real confusion and fear among Michael's friends and family. Combined with a canceled bank meeting, her behavior marked a real turning point, really in the unraveling of the Ponzi scheme and in the even more horrible events that would follow. But, you know, she was still sending people texts saying, oh, is O2SATS good? And kind of pretending that he would respond to her. So she's really downplaying it.
The state trooper who visited their home tried repeatedly to convince her to take Michael to the hospital, but she refused. He didn't call 911, though, and he didn't insist that he was taking him either. He did eventually call his wife Stephanie, the same physician friend Natalie had contacted earlier about the steroids, and even Stephanie couldn't persuade her to take him to the hospital. She even tried to tell her that if Michael woke up in the hospital and was angry about it, she would happily take the blame for it, but Natalie insisted that he should just sleep it off on the couch. So yeah, many people wondered why Stephanie or any of these other people didn't simply override Natalie and take him to the hospital, or in my opinion, call 911, because then as soon as they get there, they can start treating him. I always think it's better to call 911 than to drive to the hospital, unless there's some reason 911 would take a long time, right? Now, several factors did complicate the situation, and I think one is that Natalie had a doctorate in pharmacy, so that did give her some medical authority in the view of these people. She told everyone that she was monitoring his vital signs too, and she would assure them that this was the safest choice.
As his wife, she claimed to know his wishes, and she sent texts implying he was conscious, saying things like he doesn't want to go to the hospital. But we know in reality Michael never regained consciousness after being on that kitchen floor. So at one point, Natalie's sister Penny showed up, and she, Natalie, and Natalie's daughter changed Michael's clothing because he had urinated on himself. So this should have been a huge red flag, a clear sign of severe medical distress. But no one called for help. Hours passed before Chris Davis, Michael's best friend, arrived that evening, so several hours have passed. And after seeing Michael's condition, he finally refused to accept Natalie's explanations.
He carried Michael to his vehicle and drove him to Raleigh General Hospital, with Natalie riding along in the back seat. So once they got to the hospital, the staff found that Michael's blood sugar was 21, and a normal range is between 80 and 120, so he was hypoglycemic. And if left untreated, this can result in seizures, a coma, and death. Earlier that day, Natalie had told people his blood sugar was normal. And Donna, Michael's mother, later said she only learned the real blood sugar number much later because Natalie had controlled all communication with the medical team. So despite efforts to stabilize him, Michael continued to be unconscious. Donna didn't learn what had happened until after 10 p.m. that night when her husband brought her her phone and showed her the text Natalie had sent. First, a photo of Michael collapsed on the floor. Now, can you imagine sending a picture like that to someone's mother? No. What the fuck? I mean, anyone collapsed on the floor. Call 911 pretty much, right? You got it. Yeah.
So then she sent photos of him in the hospital to his mother. And Donna, who'd been a registered nurse for 30 years, said she would have taken him to the hospital immediately if she'd seen that first photo. But instead, she found out hours too late to do anything to help him. Michael was transferred from Raleigh General Hospital to Charleston Area Medical Center, CAMC, where he would remain for days. Natalie initially sent Donna to the wrong hospital, too. And she had previously told her that she wasn't allowed to visit her son at all. So she's just trying to shut her out completely.
which I guess is not surprising when you think back on their relationship. But Donna did eventually get to the correct hospital, and she witnessed a brief kind of moment of hope. A nurse there performed a sternal rub, which is a painful stimulus used to assess consciousness, and Michael suddenly sat up and opened his eyes. Everyone was relieved about this except for Natalie, who did not appear pleased by it at all. In fact, throughout his hospitalization, she spent most of her time on her computer working on contracts, even texting Donna, Michael's mom, he's in the hospital, and she texted her about a bid that she wanted to submit.
while Michael was critically ill. So that's crazy. And despite this brief glimpse of possible improvement, Michael's condition continued to decline. So tell us a little bit about why they couldn't keep his blood sugar at a normal level and how they figured out he had been administered insulin. I'll answer the first question first. So he was given a big dose of insulin. Right, but they didn't know that at the time. No, but they knew that his blood sugar was not able to be maintained. And that's a sign of an insulin overdose. That's a sign that he has hyperinsulinism. Okay. You don't know whether that's accidental or due to an illness or what. He could have an insulin producing tumor. Oh.
But he didn't. No, he didn't. But you have a situation where you recognize that he's got a low blood sugar and you're treating that by giving glucose infusions to keep the blood sugar up. And if you can't do that, it's because there's too much insulin to handle. So being in this perpetual state of hypoglycemia, I guess, is that okay to say it that way? Yeah. So what causes death then? What does that do to his body that would kill him? Well, you need glucose for your cells. You can have cardiac arrhythmias, cerebral edema.
respiratory issues, but it's mostly the effect on the central nervous system, the cerebral edema. So basically brain death is what we're talking about. Yes. I'm just going to cut right to the chase here. So it caused brain death. It will, or it could, yes. So he was on life support a couple days, right? And they eventually decided there's no way he's going to recover. So I'm assuming that was because there was no brain activity from everything we know about it, right? That would be correct. Yes. Okay. So despite that brief glimpse of possible improvement, his condition was declining. And then on February 10th, Natalie decided to sign a do not resuscitate order.
And shortly after that, he was transferred to Bauer's Hospice House to die, which is quite shocking. This is a 38-year-old man, healthy, active up until that day. It's horrible. It's a horrible thing. It had to be a horrible shock to his family, his kids, his friends, everyone. So hospice cares for patients with terminal conditions or patients who can no longer recover from a severe medical crisis. So in Michael's case, several factors contributed to his need for hospice. So we have the prolonged hypoglycemia. So that is extremely low blood sugar. And it can cause irreversible brain injury if you don't get to it quickly.
So a blood sugar of 21, as you said, normal is like 80 to 120. That's a significant blood sugar in terms of being able to harm the patient. So you'd like to get it, I would think, at least above 50. Otherwise, you can end up having coma, seizures, permanent damage. Okay. Plus, there was that extended period of time without any medical intervention. And that was purposely done by Natalie. We know that. He remained unconscious for many hours before receiving any care. And during that time, his brain and organs may have been deprived of adequate glucose, oxygen.
And circulation. So we have organ failure, multi-system decline, after prolonged unconsciousness and severe metabolic imbalance, the body can begin to, you know, basically in layman's terms, just shut down. Yeah. Right. Just shutting down. Just shutting down. So hospice is often recommended when they can't do anything. So the focus is just on keeping him comfortable, which, you know, that wasn't even really a thing either because he was just pretty much gone, just a body lying there, unfortunately. I'd like to know that blood sugar of 21, that was when he was admitted? Yes, that's what it was on admission. And follow-ups?
Well, it remained low. I think it would go up a little, but they couldn't maintain it at a normal level, like you said, because of the, what did you call it? Hyperinsulinism. Hyperinsulinism, right. So the thing is, we don't know if she gave him insulin more than once. We don't know how she initially gave him a shot of insulin. Although it is true that she had gotten a prescription recently for benzodiazepine.
She may have snuck that into his coffee or something, made him unconscious and then given him a shot of insulin. That's what a lot of people have theorized, although we don't know exactly how she did it. She would have to give it by injection or intravenously. Right. You can't pour it down his mouth. Exactly. So that's why I'm saying he must have been sedated because he would have known she's giving him a shot, of course. Yeah. Yeah. So I don't know what she did to him. But given all those factors, you know, the medical staff had determined that it was not reversible. So he went to hospice for end of life care. So tragic. This is someone who the day before was a healthy 38 year old father of two. A lot ahead of him, really.
Yeah. So because his blood sugar dropped to a critically low level and stayed there for many hours, his brain was without the glucose it needed to function. And with this prolonged hypoglycemia, the brain couldn't produce enough energy to maintain normal electrical activity. So he probably had confusion at first and then seizures. And then he was in this state of deep unconsciousness. So his neurons had suffered irreversible injury and the body's stress response triggered dangerous heart rhythm changes. And you had mentioned that. So it was a metabolic collapse. Could you say that? Oh, absolutely. There's a lot of things that could happen from that.
By the time he reached the hospital with that blood sugar, his brain and organs had already endured an extended period of time without adequate fuel, glucose, leaving him with comatocin, unable to recover despite medical intervention. So it was really just too late. Yeah. I'm just interested in the length of time all this took. Well, we know he was pretty much at home all day. And she probably did this early morning because she was canceling that flight and that appointment. So I don't know. I would guess at least 10 hours. It seems to me that they kind of threw in the towel fairly quickly. At the hospital? At the hospital. Well, something must have led them to that. And that's why I thought maybe they did...
electrocephalogram. I would think they'd have to do that before they'd give up on a 38 year old. Yeah, that's what I'm saying. Yeah. It sounds like he got to the hospital. They decided they couldn't do anything more for him and sent him to hospice to die. Well, no, it wasn't all that. It was a couple of days. It took longer than that. They transferred him to a higher level of care and they did try to give him glucose and whatever else they did for, I think, at least two days. It wasn't as fast as it sounds when I tell the story. There was some time that evolved there and it wasn't determined that the hospital did anything wrong. So I think we're just not privy to every detail. So once he was in hospice, the staff had to remove him from the ventilator.
And he briefly did breathe on his own. But at 12.18 p.m. on February 11th, he died. His cause of death was recorded as brain swelling resulting from severe hypoglycemia. So the manner of death was listed as natural. Now, despite that classification, the circumstances surrounding his death were very suspicious. Yes. So I'm just shocked that they could say natural. There's nothing natural about refractory hypoglycemia. Right. Due to insulin overdose. Of course, I didn't know that. All I know is his blood sugar is dangerously low.
and cannot be brought up despite massive infusions of glucose. Right. That's true. So the day of the meeting was February 6th that she canceled, and that was the day that he was on the floor. And then he was pronounced dead on the 11th. So there was some time. Yeah. So two days after his death, Natalie organized a small service, and she described it as what Michael would have wanted. Now his mom, Donna, disagreed, noting that it was rushed.
and it excluded many of Michael's closest friends and just felt completely out of character for him. Soon after that, Natalie resumed her business activities. Both TSG and TMS continued operating, and she still sought out more investments for more people. So this woman's lost her mind. Well, she's created her own monster. Yeah. She's got these financial obligations for some of the earlier investors. Right. Yeah. And she's not getting the new investors in. So she's continuing to feed the monster. And she's going to be running out of money. Right. Well, here's another thing, though. So following his death, Natalie created a scholarship program in his name, the Coach Michael Cochran Legacy Scholarship, which sounds great.
So in May 2019, she promised eight students full-ride scholarships covering up to eight years of college. But you know what? These scholarships weren't real. There was no money there. But based on these scholarships, she told the students to cancel their student loan applications. And she told their families she would cover all expenses. She even offered each student $7,500 in personal spending money. So wow. So these parents believe they'd really received a life-changing opportunity. Like, wow, we're all set because you know how expensive college can be.
Putting your kids through college is very expensive. Yeah, well, I'll continue to fall back on this statement. It sounds too good to be true. It probably is. I mean, it sounds great. Full boat scholarship, $7,500 spending, personal spending money. I know. Sign me up. It sounds great. And I, you know, I'm not going to blame the victims here. I could see why they'd believe her. You know, her husband had died.
She was this big businesswoman who had a company worth $500 million or whatever. So you'd believe it. I mean, I think you would, even though it does sound too good to be true. I understand what you're saying there. But by June of 2019, the situation really unraveled. Earlier that month, Natalie negotiated to sell 49% of TSG to a local dentist for $4 million. So he paid her a $50,000 deposit, but then canceled the whole thing when on June 25th, police executed a search warrant at Natalie's home. So federal authorities had been alerted by dissatisfied investors.
and early investigative findings suggested irregularities in her business operations. Investigators were also very concerned about inconsistencies in Natalie's story of Michael's death. So during that search, investigators found a bottle of insulin in the refrigerator, and it was left among some ordinary food items like Snickers bars and little sauce packets from takeout. So neither Natalie nor Michael had diabetes, and Michael's mom Donna later confirmed this to investigators. who told her and Ed, also for the first time, that none of the contracts Natalie had told them about were real and that Michael's death was suspicious. So investigators did not explicitly state that they suspected foul play, but they indicated that the case warranted further investigation. Donna and Ed, they've not only lost their son, stepson for him, but now they're going to find out they lost their retirement savings. I can't imagine what these people went through. Of course, the loss of money cannot compare to the loss of their child, but it certainly isn't great. It's like the shit on top of a shit sandwich, really. Yeah, it is. It's just horrible.
So over the following months, the investigation expanded. An undercover officer visited Natalie's home while she was having a garage sale and selling some personal belongings, you know, mostly Michael's, and he observed behavior that raised some real concerns. Authorities also had continued looking into the missing funds from that youth baseball league. So on July 23rd, investigators had concluded that TMS and TSG were not legitimate businesses at all, and records showed that Natalie had not bid on or won one single government contract since the whole thing began in 2017. The day after that, she filed for bankruptcy, but...
violated bankruptcy law by failing to list her investors as creditors. So in September of 2019, Natalie was arrested and indicted on 26 charges. This included defrauding investors, defrauding banks, wire fraud, aggravated identity theft, and related offenses. So she was not charged in connection with the missing baseball league funds. Yeah, well, that's enough charges, though. Yeah, I mean, the baseball funds, really, $32,000 is a lot of money, but in this case, not so much. Right. So according to the indictment, Natalie operated the Ponzi scheme from June of 2017 all the way through August of 2019.
defrauding individuals and financial institutions of more than $2.5 million. You know, it seems like she thought after Michael died, she'd just keep going. Well, now I don't have to explain to him. I'll just get more investors and keep this thing going, I guess. That's a reasonable supposition, yeah. So federal prosecutors sought forfeiture of at least $1 million and moved to seize any assets she had.
Despite the severity of the allegations, though, Natalie really received a very lenient outcome on this. After posting bond, she was able to negotiate a plea agreement in which she pled guilty to just two of the 26 charges. That would be one count of wire fraud and one count of money laundering. So she ultimately received a sentence of 11 years and three months in federal prison and was ordered to pay $2.6 million in restitution. The judge noted that he would have imposed a longer sentence if the plea agreement had allowed it, but this was actually the maximum permitted under the negotiated deal. So at this point, Natalie would release a written statement in which she said, In the interest of my family and children, I have decided to plead guilty to one count of wire fraud and one count of unlawful monetary transaction in relation to the companies owned by my husband and I.
I realized that I am responsible for any action taken by the companies as a controlling member. I look forward to the day I am provided with the opportunity to go into more detail regarding the events that have transpired in the last few years. It was my goal that every investor would be made financially whole in regards to their interactions with the business and that my children and I can finally put this behind us and move forward with our lives. So she's suggesting here, if you haven't noticed, that Michael was doing all this and she didn't really know. But she's a good person and she's going to take responsibility anyway. That's the way I interpret it anyway. Yeah, I like that. Okay.
So on May 1st, 2021, she reported to the Federal Correctional Institution at Hazleton to begin serving her sentence. Only a few months after that sentencing, in November, Natalie was formally indicted on a charge of first-degree murder. Prosecutors alleged that Michael was killed because he had begun uncovering the truth about the businesses and that that February 6th bank meeting would have exposed her crimes. So they asserted that she caused Michael's death by administering a lethal dose of insulin, though proving that would be very difficult. In April 2023, prosecutors dropped the murder charge, not because they believed she was innocent, but because they decided they needed more time to build a case.
So they sought a second exhumation of Michael's remains to perform specialized testing for insulin in tissue samples. The first exhumation occurred in September of 2019, and by the time of the second, decomposition had made detection impossible. Even so, the medical examiner concluded that an insulin overdose was the most likely cause of death, explaining that the severity of Michael's hypoglycemia left no plausible alternative. Would you agree with that? I would agree that hypoglycemia led to his death. Well, there was really no other way, I guess, that he would have become so severely hypoglycemic. Well, yeah, he had excess insulin in his body. Right. And there was no other explanation for it than it being administered, right? Right. Well, there are rare cases of tumors that produce insulin. Well, I would think they would have checked for that. Although I could be wrong. Maybe they didn't. That must be very rare, though. It's pretty rare. Okay. So maybe they didn't even check for that. I mean, there are a lot of circumstantial things that pointed her as well. Well, you can also tell where the insulin came from by measuring a C-peptide. I don't know if they did that, though.
Because by the time they exhumed him the second time, I don't think they really could do anything. Yeah, I think there was a failure early on to do a thorough autopsy and toxicology report. So I do think that they should have done better with that. So on October 23rd of 2023, Natalie was re-indicted for first degree murder. She was arraigned on January 29th, 2024, and she entered a plea of not guilty. A trial date was initially set for August 12th, but the case soon became mired in multiple delays. Some postponements were requested by the defense and others by the prosecution.
The lead prosecutor eventually resigned while under investigation for some unrelated misconduct. But of course, that caused further delay. Raleigh County Prosecutor Tom Truman came out of retirement to take over this case. And the final major delay was granted just to allow him and co-counsel time to review the more than 70,000 pages of case files. Oh, geez. Yeah. That's a daunting task. It is. But you know, they do have electronic ways of reviewing this now. They're not sitting there with papers going through it all. I hope not. So it's not as daunting as it sounds, but I'm sure it's a lot.
So he received the case in September of 2024, and the trial began on January 13th, 2025. So there was quite a bit of time that went by. Prosecutors argued that Natalie's motive for killing Michael was clear. He was beginning to uncover the truth about her fraudulent businesses, and the February 6th bank meeting would have exposed her. So their case centered on the allegation that she obtained insulin from her friend, Jennifer Davis, under the pretense of needing it for herself, and she used it to deliver a fatal dose to Michael. They maintained that she then constructed an elaborate narrative to convince friends and family that he had suffered a seizure and simply needed some rest.
which I still can't get past that. I think the friends and family really failed there. I know that Jennifer Davis, though, did feel a lot of guilt, as you can imagine, for bringing the insulin to the home. But I think we can pretty safely say that Natalie would have found another way to kill him. And of course, Jennifer Davis had no idea. So to establish this motive, the prosecution needed to show two things, that Michael was a healthy 38-year-old man who had no medical reason to collapse from severe hypoglycemia, and that he had had no knowledge of the Ponzi scheme.
demonstrating his health was essential because it really underscored how abnormal it was for him to present at the hospital with this blood sugar of 21. And showing he was unaware of the fraud would support the theory that Natalie had acted to prevent him from exposing her by finding out what she had been doing. The defense attempted to counter this by portraying Michael as unhealthy. They claimed he used unsafe steroids and supplements allegedly purchased from Mexico and argued that these substances could have caused his collapse. They also suggested he had a history of seizures and attempted to frame the February incident.
as consistent with prior medical issues he'd had. And I have to tell you, the defense tried really hard. Well, it's a tough case. Yeah, for both sides. For both sides, yes. So the prosecution's first witness was lead investigator Robert Heinsman, and he testified that Michael had no knowledge of the Ponzi scheme. Now, although the defense emphasized that Michael benefited from the money, investigators found no evidence that he was involved or aware of the fraud.
multiple witnesses confirmed that Natalie handled all financial matters while Michael's role was limited to identifying potential contracts. Right. Now, Jennifer Davis's testimony was really important here because she explained that Natalie had asked her for insulin and that her son's insulin pump meant that there was no reason for insulin to be stored in the Cochrane home. because Natalie was saying, you know, I just kept it for emergencies for my friend's son. At the trial, she's trying to have her lawyer say that she kept it there for her friend's son. Yeah, so if he was over and had problems, she had some insulin there to give him. Yeah, which, you know, come on. I mean, the mom could carry some with her. No reason for a family friend to keep it in her refrigerator. So she also described Natalie's extensive knowledge of insulin's effects. Remember, she's a pharmacist, so she should know more about it than anyone, really, because she also specialized in diabetes management. So this was really consistent with her background. Jennifer recounted the events of the morning that Michael collapsed, and she testified that Natalie...
had once asked her to help place a pillow over Michael's face while he was in hospice. So this raised some eyebrows, as you can imagine. I guess. So they're in hospice, and the friend Jennifer says, you know, what can I do to help you, basically? And Natalie says, can you help me hold this pillow over his face? What the hell? Give me that pillow. What the heck? I can't even imagine that. Was it because she didn't want to look at his face? I don't know. Did she want to make him die sooner? I don't know, but that's really shocking. So on cross-examination, the defense pressed Jennifer about Michael's alleged supplement use and his past hospitalizations.
But she maintained that he appeared healthy, that he appeared healthy. And she had never seen him inject himself with anything. Also, a Bank of America employee testified that Natalie was always the point of contact for any financial matters. And this reinforced the argument that Michael was not involved in the Ponzi scheme. Stephanie Hamilton, the physician friend who had provided Natalie with the steroids days before Michael collapsed, described her observations of his condition that day and Natalie's refusal to take him to the hospital or call 911. Michael's best friend, Chris Davis, was very emotional on the stand. He stated that Michael was healthy.
had only used like standard supplements you get from the grocery store and had no history of seizures that would resemble the February incident. He also described the events of that day that he transported Michael to the hospital, which were very sketchy. Additional witnesses included a contractor who remembered Michael expressing fear that he had been poisoned back in 2018 and an FBI chemist who analyzed substances found in the home. So investigators discovered a vial labeled as a testosterone boosting medication, but the contents had been replaced with an unknown substance. An endocrinologist testified that excessive insulin can be fatal.
and that Michael was not taking any medications that would have caused his blood sugar to drop so severely. So the medical examiner, who had performed the second autopsy, explained that although decomposition prevented detection of insulin in any of the tissue samples, the severity of Michael's hypoglycemia pointed to insulin poisoning as the only plausible cause of his death. Investigator Timothy Bledsoe's testimony helped connect the remaining pieces. He reviewed Michael's text messages. which showed confusion rather than complicity, and confirmed that investigators found no evidence that Natalie had ever been diagnosed with cancer. He also described three interviews with Natalie in 2019, noting that she introduced the idea of insulin use before investigators discovered it. Her explanations changed across interviews, from blaming supplements to claiming Michael injected himself with insulin for bodybuilding, none of which aligned with the evidence. Well, the defense presented fewer witnesses, but they did attempt to raise some reasonable doubt. They argued that Natalie, as a former pharmacist,
would not have used a substance as traceable as insulin if she intended to commit the murder. They questioned why she would keep insulin in the refrigerator for months afterward if it was the murder weapon. And I'm not sure why. If she was overly confident, you know, or sometimes smart people have no common sense. Yeah, that's true. Right? But they also emphasized that she made no effort to hide any evidence, suggesting this was inconsistent with any intentional wrongdoing. Despite these arguments, the prosecution maintained that the evidence pointed clearly to insulin poisoning and that Michael's death could not have been accidental. The defense did argue that Natalie's behavior on the day Michael collapsed.
didn't align with the actions of someone who was attempting to conceal a crime because they noted that she allowed multiple people into the home rather than claiming she had simply found him unconscious. But I think that was all part of her plan. She thought that would make her look less guilty if there were many witnesses. They also questioned how insulin could have been administered because they emphasized there was no evidence of a sudden physical struggle or injection at the moment he fell, which is valid. But again, I think that she probably gave him some benzos or something before she injected him. Like I said, there was not a complete toxicology breakdown, unfortunately.
But we do know that two days before he collapsed, Natalie had been prescribed Xanax, and traces of it were later found in Michael's system. Michael was known to have an allergy to benzodiazepines, raising questions about whether he may have been incapacitated before she gave him the insulin. But there was no definitive evidence to establish the exact sequence of events. I would say the defense's most significant witnesses were the Cochran children, and this was really sad. Their testimony required careful consideration due to their ages at the time of their father's death and the circumstances under which they continued living with their mom afterwards.
So both children got on the stand and described changes in Michael's behavior in the months leading up to his death, and that included increased aggression, forgetfulness, and lethargy. They also said that he took numerous supplements daily, and that he had mentioned using steroids he'd gotten from Mexico. So their accounts varied on whether he ingested or injected these substances, and neither child reported witnessing an injection directly. Now for me, I think that the children could have been convinced in the months afterwards of how things had really happened, or, you know, according to their mother, how things had happened. Because I think it's pretty easy to influence children like that, especially when they're in a position of, you know, they don't want to lose their mom and they certainly don't want to think their mom killed their dad. So I think in the months after his death, when they're living with just her, she could have convinced them that things were a little different than they actually were. Right. And you can see that as a pediatrician that that could happen quite easily. Yeah.
So I don't think that the children were blatantly lying necessarily, but I think that, you know, someone who's such a manipulator like Natalie, who was able to manipulate many adults, could easily manipulate her own children. That's right. Yeah. Now Natalie's sister Penny testified that she had once seen Michael inject himself during a family vacation, though she couldn't identify what substance he was using. She also said that Michael disliked hospitals, and that was a point the defense was using to justify Natalie's reluctance to seek medical care for him. The defense also presented a medical examiner who classified Michael's death.
as undetermined, and a forensic pathologist who suggested that an enlarged heart, possibly linked to supplement use, could have contributed to his death. Throughout the trial, many expected Natalie to testify, but she ultimately chose not to. Donna, Michael's mother, was also scheduled to testify, but she ended up not testifying either. So after the defense arrested, investigator Robert Heintzman returned as a rebuttal witness. He reinforced the conclusion that Michael had no knowledge of the Ponzi scheme and noted that investigators found no evidence supporting Natalie's past claims of having cancer. He also described multiple interviews with Natalie in 2019, during which her explanations changed significantly. In her final interview, she introduced the idea that Michael had injected himself with insulin as part of a bodybuilding routine, despite there being no evidence supporting this. Do you see any reasoning in that, that he may have been giving himself insulin for bodybuilding?
He wouldn't be injecting enough insulin to make him hypoglycemic. Okay. Well, the jury deliberated for only two hours before returning a guilty verdict for first-degree murder, and the following day, the court held the mercy phase, during which the jury considered whether Natalie should be eligible for parole after 15 years or if she should serve life without parole. So the defense presented testimony from family members, including her two children, who described the emotional impact of her incarceration and argued for leniency. The prosecution presented testimony from Michael's loved ones, who described the profound harm caused by Natalie's actions.
So the most prominent statements from Michael Cochran's side came from his family and close friends. Donna, Michael's mother, described the case as long and painful. After the guilty verdict, she said it had been a long time coming and expressed gratitude that justice had finally been served for her son. Natalie's going to use Michael's children to get sympathy here today. She tried to do that with her testimonies during the trial. Judge, please don't fall for her con. That's what Natalie does. She only cares about herself.
She will use, abuse, and manipulate anyone to get in her way. But we know the real man, the Cochran, the thief, the liar, the taker of life, and the doer of evil deeds. Family members had endured years of delays, renewed investigations, and repeated court proceedings while seeking answers about Michael's death. During the sentencing phase, testimony from people close to Michael emphasized his character and the loss that was suffered by those who knew him. His very good friend Chris Davis gave emotional testimony about Michael and described him as healthy and active before this sudden decline and death. On the defense's side, although they weren't victim impact statements, the mercy hearing included some emotional testimony from Natalie's family. Her mother, Daphne Jessup, pleaded for mercy for the sake of her children and future grandchildren.
Natalie's son and daughter asked the jury to spare their mother from dying in prison, describing the personal milestones they hoped to share with her in the future and all that they had missed while she'd been in prison so far. Overall, the prosecution's position and the family's perspective centered on obtaining justice for Michael Cochran after years of litigation, while Natalie's relatives focused on asking the jury for mercy because of the impact a life without parole sentence would have on her children. After hearing both sides, the jury determined that Natalie should not receive mercy, and she was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Becoming the first woman in West Virginia history since 1991 to receive this sentence for murder, motions for acquittal and a new trial were all denied, leaving her sentence in place. Michael's family, who had endured years of financial loss, emotional trauma, and uncertainty, expressed relief that justice had finally been served. So Natalie's conviction leaves us with a couple of clear lessons, and first would be, fraud doesn't stay neatly contained. Once someone builds their life around deception, the lies tend to multiply, and of course the stakes go up.
Natalie's Ponzi scheme didn't just drain bank accounts, it created pressure, fear, and a whole web of manipulation that ultimately led to her husband Michael's death. Her case shows how easily trust can be weaponized, especially when the perpetrator is a friend, a spouse, or a community member that you trust. It also highlights how important documentation, verification, and some healthy skepticism is, even when dealing with people we think we know very well. So as for whether her prior bad acts should have been allowed in the murder trial, the answer to me is a resounding yes. In cases like this, earlier misconduct isn't just background noise, it's really part of the motive, the pattern, and the whole story of how the events escalated. Her lies about contracts, audits, medical conditions, and finances weren't unrelated. They were actually the foundation of the prosecution's argument that she had both the motive and the knowledge to commit the murder. Courts generally allow prior acts when they establish intent, motive, or the absence of accident. And in Natalie's case, those elements were just central.
Her fraud and her manipulation were not separate issues at all, but they were the lead up to the crime itself. So I really don't think you could try this case without bringing up the prior bad acts. Otherwise, you'd just be in a vacuum. It's so essential here. Yeah. I just have trouble back and forth with, should we allow prior? Sure. I mean, it sounds easy to say if it has a bearing on the case. Well, I think in some cases there's more of a gray area, but to me, this is pretty black and white. Yeah. But then another judge will say, no, that can't be used. Right.
I see what you're saying, yes. And many times, I don't think they should be used. But in this case, I'm just saying, I don't think you could try the case without it because it's just such an essential part of the motive. Yeah, you got to do that. Got to, right. So that was just a really super sad case. You have more than just the murder. You've got the Ponzi scheme. You've got the fake cancer. Just a big mess. So listeners, I'm just going to take a quick moment here to let you know, if you're tired of ads and you want to get some extra episodes of True Crime Brewery to binge, you can sign up for our premium show.
which is really just the shows we do now without the ads, plus a bonus show once or twice a month. So if you're interested in doing that, we'd appreciate it. It's very affordable. It's easy to do. Just go to tiegrabber.com slash subscribe. Or if you're a Patreon person, you can also go to patreon.com slash tiegrabber. And you can get a gift and no ads in all your episodes and some bonus episodes that don't have ads either, of course. And, you know, if you like to listen to us and you hate ads, it might be something you want to do. That's all. It's time for listener feedback.
So why don't we do a little feedback? Yeah, that's a good deal. Let's try it. All right. I've got an email I'm going to start with from Mina in Michigan, my old stomping grounds. And she writes, Dear Jill and Dick, I've been with you guys from the beginning, and I will listen to True Crime Brewery for as long as you continue making episodes. Thanks, Mina. Yeah, she's pretty loyal. Yeah. I'm writing today to recommend the unsolved case of Paige Renkowski. So Paige was a 30-year-old substitute teacher from Okemos, Michigan. We have a son that lives in Okemos. He was a small world. Yep.
So Paige disappeared on May 24th, 1990 in a case that is one of the state's most enduring mysteries. After driving her mother to Detroit Metropolitan Airport and visiting a friend, Paige was last seen on the shoulder of westbound Interstate 96 near Fowlerville. I think we went there and I had lunch with my mother a couple of years ago. Fowlerville, right? Yes. So witnesses reported seeing her talking with two unidentified men beside a maroon minivan and said that she appeared upset. Later that same day, her silver 1986 Oldsmobile Cutlass Calais was found abandoned on the highway, still running with her purse and shoes left inside.
The investigation has generated thousands of leads over the decades. Early mistakes complicated the case as the responding officer initially treated the vehicle as abandoned rather than a potential crime scene. Authorities have done numerous searches and pursued various leads, yet her body has never been found and no one has been charged in connection with her disappearance. The case remains open and investigators continue to seek information that could finally explain what happened to Paige more than three decades ago. There's a recent episode about this case on Hulu's Somebody Knows Something, so I would love for you to take a look and maybe a deep dive.
Well, absolutely, Mina. I did see that show come up on Hulu. It's got, is it Kara Robinson who escaped a serial killer in one of our episodes? Is actually the host of that, I believe. You're more into that, keeping track of people. I'm so terrible with names. But yeah, I always like looking at unsolved cases. I know you do. So we'll watch that. Not that I've solved any of them. Well, if you keep watching them, maybe one day you will. You never know. You never know. I mean, that's the whole thing with this show is somebody knows something. So the whole theory there is that somebody will hear about this and know something to help solve the case. Yeah, you just got to find that person who knows something. Exactly. And it could be you, Dickie. We'll see.
All right, next we have an email from Caitlin in Seattle. Why don't you read this one? Okay. Do I have a case for you? I watched this trial and just keep wondering what you two would have to say about so many things. Kevin West, a former battalion chief with the Kamas Wasugao Fire Department in Washington, was charged with murdering his wife, Marcy West, after her death in January 2024.
was ruled a homicide. Prosecutors argued that West strangled his wife so he could continue an affair and begin a new life with his mistress, pointing to incriminating text messages, letters, and forensic evidence. The defense claimed that Marcy suffered a medical event possibly related to existing health issues and challenged the prosecution's interpretation of the physical evidence. After deliberated for just over two hours, a jury found Kevin West guilty of first degree and second degree murder and is later sentenced to 25 years in prison. And I'm not sure why first degree and second degree for one murder. I should have looked that up. Must have been some extenuating circumstances for that to happen. We'll have to check on that.
So this case is especially compelling for a true crime podcast because it combines several elements that draw public interest. A respected public servant accused of a shocking crime, allegations of infidelity, conflicting forensic theories, and a deeply divided family. The emotional impact was unbelievable when the couple's children took opposite sides at sentencing, with one defending their father and the other condemning him. Wow. The contrast between West's public role as a fire chief and the prosecution's portrayal of him as a calculated killer creates a dramatic narrative that invites discussion about motive, deception, family loyalty, and the challenges juries face in murder trials. That does sound fascinating. I do believe that I watched a couple of hours of that, a couple of the witness testimonies, and it did look super interesting. And this guy was a real scumbag, but he was able to present himself quite well, which, you know, a lot of these people are able to do that. So his public persona was way better than his private persona.
Yeah, but you know, the people who knew him from work and, you know, family friends, they all kind of were getting the gist of who this guy was. So it's sad for me that one of his children was defending him after losing their mother to him. I mean, that's just horrible. Yeah, it's a tough one. Yeah. Okay. And one more email, last but not least, from Nate. I hope this message finds you both doing well. Hopefully it's less hot in New Mexico now that the summer is over and that you both had a good summer. Yes, thank you, Nate. But summer is still here for a while. Yeah, we still have summer for probably another month. Yeah, we do have summer till the end of September, at least. We hope we don't get too many hundred degree days.
No, I'm starting to notice a new freshness in the air. Mas fresco. So Nate continues. I have a case suggestion for you both to consider. Bernard Getz subway shooting in 1984. Quite controversial then and still just as much so now. Curious what you both think of it as you were alive at the time. Thanks for pointing that out, Nate. And I had just been born two months before it. I wish you both all the best. Well, if he was two months old, he probably wouldn't be watching it. No, I would hope not. So a little background on December 22nd, 1984. Getz shot four black teenagers in a Manhattan subway.
So in 1996, the teen who had been paralyzed in the shooting... took him to court in a civil suit and was awarded $43 million. I don't think he had $43 million. He didn't have $1 million. No. So Goetz lives in the same Manhattan apartment he lived in before. He's a vegetarian and he rehabilitates injured squirrels. Now, I don't know if I was really watching this case back then. I was still pretty young. I wasn't two, that's for sure.
Yes, young teens. So I guess what I'd say is there was a lot of coverage because I remember seeing it on the TV and in the newspapers. There was lots of coverage. Yeah, it was a big deal. It was a very big deal. What do you remember about it? Just how they were getting into the racism discussion. Oh, yes. And Getz is white. Right. And he said he was afraid of them on the subway. You hear that all the time. Yeah, I wonder what the other people on the subway car had to say. Do you know? Varying things. Different opinions? Yeah. Okay. I was pretty much divided by race. And I know the outcome of his trial for the shootings. A lot of people didn't like that.
No, I'm sure a lot of people wanted him to be convicted. Lots to figure out, though. Were the teens armed? I'm guessing not. It's not with guns. I just looked up some Wikipedia stuff and didn't see anything. It said they were armed. Okay. Well, I think this could be a good case to cover, maybe on the premium show. And I think that lots of issues, actually, that we could talk about with that one, huh? Oh, yes. Yeah. These are all very good suggestions, if you don't mind my saying, I like them all. And I bet that's why they're in the episode, because you knew I'd like them all. I did. Yep. Okay. Well, I am going to watch Somebody Knows Something, and I bet there are other cases that are interesting on there as well. And I'm very curious about...
Kevin West. I think if we're going to cover Kevin West, we'll just watch the trial because I know it was televised, so it'll be in the court TV archives. Often that's the best way to really get down to the bottom of it. Sometimes you want to get a book and some more information on the backgrounds of the victims or the perpetrators, but I also find that you're going to get the most accurate information for sure by looking at court documents and watching the trial yourself. So I think we'll do that. I know what I'm doing in the next few days. Okay. So I've got you all booked. Thank you. All right. Well, thank you everyone for listening and thank you for your feedback.
Please keep it coming. We do enjoy feedback an awful lot. And we will talk to you soon. Where? Well, probably at the quiet end, I would guess. We'll be there. Okay. Lots of room? Plenty of room. Come on in. All right. Bye-bye, everyone. Bye, guys.