Skip to content
The Problem with Hiring a VA Nobody Talks About episode artwork

Jun 27, 2025 10 min

The Problem with Hiring a VA Nobody Talks About

from Well-Oiled Operations with Stacy Tuschl

Are you hiring help… or accidentally setting yourself up for burnout? In this video, I'm breaking down the biggest mistakes business owners make when hiring Virtual Assistants (VAs)—and why it often leads to more stress, not less. If you've ever hired someone and felt like it's just easier to do it yourself, this is for you. With over 20 years of experience and multiple 7-figure companies, I've built teams of employees, contractors, overseas VAs, and executive assistants. I'm sharing what works, what doesn't, and how to make the right hire based on what your business really needs—not just what you think you can afford. ✅ You'll learn: The #1 myth about hiring VAs (and why it's costing you time) What kind of support you actually need (VA, freelancer, EA, OBM?) Why hiring for tasks isn't the same as hiring for ownership How to match compensation with the role's responsibility The real cost of under-hiring (it's not just money)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Problem with Hiring a VA Nobody Talks About

0:00 10:59
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I just need help. That's usually the moment a business owner types VA into Google. They're overwhelmed, they're overworked, they're desperate for someone, anyone, just to take tasks off their plate. But here's the hard truth that nobody talks about.

Most business owners say they want help, but what they really want is leadership. And then they go out and hire somebody for $5 an hour and expect them to operate like a $50 per hour decision maker. In this video, I'm going to break down the most common mistakes I see when hiring VA's virtual assistants, why it's happening, and how to hire the right person for your current and future business needs. By the way, my name is Stacy Tushall, and I have been a business owner now for over two decades, and my business is produced over $10 million in annual revenue.

And I'm not here to tell you what kind of team member is good or bad. My team is made up of employees and contractors. We probably have about 90% of full-time US-based full-time employees in my company. But I also have contractors.

I have virtual assistants. I have virtual assistants overseas, some in the United States. So I have all of the above, and I want to share with you some of the lessons I've learned. The core truth is you can't pay for hands and expect them to breathe.

So let's just say it. Sometimes hiring a $5 per hour VA and expecting them to lead, think, strategize, take initiative. It's just not unrealistic. It's unfair.

This is the trap that so many business owners fall into. You want to be less busy. You want to get somebody who just gets it. You don't want to micromanage.

However, you want them to be able to anticipate your needs, own the outcomes, and solve your problems. But you haven't paid for that. The person you hired, they might be incredible at what they are trained to do, which is follow instructions, not write the instructions, not improve the systems, not make strategic calls. And it's not that they're incapable.

Many overseas and junior-level VA's are brilliant. They are loyal. They are hard-working people. But they aren't trained, experienced, or paid to think like an operator.

So when you hand over a role that requires ownership and expect someone to just figure it out, it's a recipe for disappointment on both sides. And again, it's not their fault. It's yours if you hired someone for a task-taker role and expected them to act like a leader. So let's talk about why smart business owners make this mistake over and over and over again.

Number one, the price tag feels like such a win. When you're stretch thin, the idea of hiring someone for $5 to $10 per hour feels like the ultimate productivity hack. You think, even if they take something off my plate, right, it will be worth it. And sometimes that's true.

For simple, defined, repeatable tasks, what ends up happening is you spend more time explaining the task than doing it yourself. You are constantly revising, correcting, or cleaning up after them. You still have to be the brain behind every action. So now you've paid for the role, you've trained for the role, you've monitored the role, and you are still stuck being the owner and the manager.

So it might not be saving you time. It's actually multiplying your mental load. Number two, you didn't hire for the real problem. So most business owners don't actually take the time to define what kind of help they really need.

They just know they're jonning, they're exhausted. They're tired, so they hire for tasks instead of hiring for thinking. But here's the thing, if you're exhausted, if you're behind, if you're overbooked, if you are the bottleneck in your business, and you're over-saduled, it's not because you can't find someone to go do the admin work, it's because you're the only one who is thinking about strategy, thinking about performance, quality control, and customer experience. So you don't just need more hands.

You need someone who could actually own their lane and drive results without needing to interrupt you and explain every single step all day long. Number three, you would expect results without the investment. This is a hard truth, but it's one we all need to hear. If you want someone who leads, you have to invest like eight liter.

A $5 per hour VA is not the same thing as a $50 per hour executive assistant, and a $30 EA is not the same as a $100,000 per year director of ops. So if you're asking somebody to manage your client communication or represent your brand, speak up in team meetings, own their deadlines, their tools or their outcomes, you can't expect that from someone who's never been paid, trained or empowered to think and lead at that level. So there is no shortage to team maturity. You either need to grow your people or you hire at the level your business demands.

There's sometimes this delusional effect, right? I always refer back to like HGTV where this person comes in and their house hunting and they're telling their dream wish list of everything they want. You know, they want five bedrooms and four bathrooms and this huge open floor plan and they want tennis courts in the backyard and this walking closet. And then we get to, and what's your budget?

And their budget is $250,000. And you're like, that's never going to happen, right? This is what happens when we go to hire a VA. We have this idea of all the things they're gonna do and then we're willing to pay like this much for them.

So let's be real about what this mistake is actually creating for you. You're probably constantly reviewing, fixing or finishing the delegated work. You dread assigning projects because it's just truly easier to do it yourself. So now you start resenting your team or worse, you lose trust.

You start shrinking your vision because you can't support the scale. That's what no one talks about. Bad hires don't just cost you money. They cost you momentum.

And when you're in growth mode, right? That's the one thing you can't afford to lose. So the fix is hire for the role, not the rate. Before you ever post a job, stop and ask what do I really need from this person?

Do they need to think like me or just do what I say? Will they represent my brand or stay behind the scenes? Do I need consistency or do I need creativity? If the job requires decisions, ownership, client interaction or a brand voice, that is not a low level hire.

So you gotta get real. That is somebody who should be compensated accordingly. And when you do that, everything is going to change in your business. So we recently replaced a few of our overseas VAs with US based executive level team members.

And someone who could just really own the high level communication, I wanted them to manage the brand voice and proactively improve the systems. I won't lie, it was a financial leap at first, but the brand impact was instant. It just felt like a massive up level. Emails were more aligned and professional.

Questions stopped coming to me, right? Or to their managers, she was making suggestions and decisions that saved us time and money, and we could feel it. Most importantly, clients noticed the up level. So that's when I knew we didn't just fill a role.

We had elevated the experience of working with our company. So I wanna make sure that you are not hearing me say, do not hire overseas VAs. No, we still use overseas VAs and we have used them for many, many years and they took us to a level of multi-million dollars in annual revenue. So 1000%.

But hear me when I say, don't just assume you need a VA. So let's talk about how to decide where to hire and how much to actually pay. We've gotta figure out if you need a VA or maybe somebody US based. So we made a table for you to see what you need and maybe who you should hire.

So number one, you can see that if you need task support, this would be data entry, inbox, you know, scheduling those posts. Then an overseas VA could be perfect for you, okay? Now this is gonna be maybe five to $10 per hour and that might be so incredibly exciting to you because maybe you really wanna help but you don't know if you can afford to hire somebody right now. Great place to start.

Now if you need skilled education, I'm talking social media, email writing, maybe you've got certain software that you wanna make sure that they've been educated or trained on specifically. Now you're gonna want a specialist freelancer. And that person depending on what their expertise is and their experience, that person can range anywhere from $15 to $40 an hour, if not more, depending on how unique or high level their skill set is. If you need client facing support, think email replies, calendar management, sales support.

This is something I would look at as a United States based EA executive assistant. Price range here could be from anywhere from $20 to be $50 an hour, again, depending on level of experience and the types of jobs you will be giving this person. And then the next piece, if you're looking for strategy and ownership, think marketing systems, team oversight, project ownership. These are high level roles.

You may be looking for an OBM, an online business manager or a director of operations, an operations manager, maybe you call it a store manager, a general manager, an office manager, there's a million names for it. That could be somebody starting anywhere from $30 to maybe up to $100 per hour. The question isn't how little can I pay? It's what does this role require to thrive?

And trust me, I used to get excited when somebody asked for a low dollar amount, I thought you're hired. And then I realized very quickly that sometimes paying the cheapest amount is not going to get you exactly what you need. My biggest suggestion is hire for where you're going, not where you are. It's time to stop hiring help and start building a team that helps you grow.

So don't ask someone to think like a leader while paying them like a beginner. And that's exactly what we help you do inside of Well-Oiled operations. If you're ready to stop being the bottleneck and start building a team that actually gets you results, you can check out our entire framework for free at welloiledoperations.com. My next live training will be coming up very soon.

Because let's be real, you don't just need help, you need the right help. And when you hire right, everything in your business is going to feel lighter.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Well-Oiled Operations with Stacy Tuschl?

This episode is 10 minutes long.

When was this Well-Oiled Operations with Stacy Tuschl episode published?

This episode was published on June 27, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Well-Oiled Operations with Stacy Tuschl episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.