Skip to content
The PT Profession Has a Math Problem episode artwork

Aug 12, 2026 1 hr 1 min

The PT Profession Has a Math Problem

from PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy Hosted by Jimmy McKay, PT, DPT | Physical Therapy Podcast

Physical therapy has always told students some version of the same story: Work hard. Get the degree. Help people. There will be a job waiting. But what happens when the math starts to break? In this episode of PT Breakfast Club, Jimmy McKay and Tony Maritato start with a post from Richard Severin about the financial viability of the physical therapy profession. The conversation quickly moves into PT school ROI, student debt, academic program pressure, and whether the next generation of students is more willing to ask the uncomfortable question: Is this still worth it? Tony argues that the profession may be facing a bigger identity problem than it wants to admit. If a patient’s desired outcome is less pain and better function, PT is only one possible delivery model. AI, tech-enabled MSK platforms, personal trainers, hospital systems, cash-pay clinics, PTAs, techs, and other professions may all compete to deliver parts of what PT has traditionally owned. Jimmy pushes the business angle: if you own a private practice, you are not just in the physical therapy business. You are in the marketing business, the patient attraction business, the hiring business, the customer experience business, and the human resources business. The second half of the episode turns into a practical marketing lab. Jimmy and Tony critique a listener’s marketing pitch about targeting new families moving into a clinic’s area, then break down why so much AI-generated healthcare marketing feels cheap, loud, and generic. They use classic advertising examples like Rolls-Royce, Grey Poupon, Holiday Inn, and Volkswagen to show how better strategy leads to better creative. The episode closes with Prompt’s Career Connection program and the idea that maybe some clinicians do not need to leave physical therapy. Maybe they just need to leave the wrong job. Key Ideas PT has a financial viability problem, not just a morale problem. Students who really run the numbers may never enter the profession. “I just want to help people” is not enough if the career cannot support a life. The profession may need to separate outcomes from identity. Outpatient ortho under insurance may not be the future of private practice. If PT cannot scale the outcome, someone else will. Private practice owners are not only in the PT business. Marketing is not decoration. It is how the market understands your value. AI-generated design still requires strategy, taste, and iteration. Career matching may work better when it is human, specific, and trust-based.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The PT Profession Has a Math Problem

0:00 1:01:49
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Broadcasting way too early from three separate Wi-Fi connections, it's Peachy Breakfast Club with Tony Maritano, Dave Kittle, and Jimmy McKay. I'll be honest, this one feels, I heard something, I think Tony Maritano, not even something you said before we went live, just the vibe. You said something about the profession not existing. I mean, if that isn't a cold open, I don't know what is. Do we want to start with someone else's post? Is that what we want to start with? Are you trying to find that one? Yeah, I've got it. Let me pull it up. So Richard Severin, which I think probably most people know. I'm going to put it on the screen.

This was posted on his personal profile, the doctor of physical therapy students, a bunch of different places. And basically he's talking about the financial viability of the profession, right? He's like, I don't want to talk, make it all about finances. And there've been multiple therapists and educators in the profession talking about finance. But he talks about challenges to the financial viability of the profession, clinical practice. You know, this generation of students is more aware of their finances than ever before. Talking about return on the investment, putting academic PT programs under threat.

You talk to students. You kind of have your finger on the pulse. Before I keep going, what's been your experience? I don't truthfully think PT students in the programs are thinking about finances at all. I think they're thinking about it more than they did 10 years ago. Is that funny because I'm right or funny because I'm wrong? More is relative, right? Before it was zero, now it's 1%. Well, all right. It's hard to measure, but I don't think there was much discussion. There was zero 10 years ago, and now there's some, so that's 1,000% more, right? Exactly.

Yeah, I think I've said this before, and this is not a knock on education, but after eighth grade is ninth grade and after ninth grade is 10th grade, there's always a thing. So there was always a thing to land on. That's how it was for me now. The closer you got to the end of high school, the more your teachers were like, you know, you need to do some stuff, right? You can't just show up and sit there and then be moved along to the next number. Eventually, like you're going to get the boot, right? So I think, I think that was sort of like the idea 10 years ago when I graduated from PT school. And again, only 10 years ago was there's a job like you're going to work for it, but there will be one. And now some of those jobs, you're underwater in terms of like whatever you owe versus whatever it's paying. And that should be a wake up call that you need to do something different. It doesn't necessarily need more. I mean, listen to a guy like Chris Corner. He's like, you don't need to necessarily just keep working more hours, right? There is that whole.

I mean, if I heard if there's a cliche for the last 10 years, it's trade time for money. Yeah, it's ability for money. It's time for money. Right. But if you're in first gear and for every spin of the of the pedals, you're only getting one spin of the back wheel. Like, that's not good. Figure out something else to do. Maybe don't bail out of the profession altogether before you look around and say, well, what else do I like to do? What am I good at? What is no one else doing that a bunch of people need to do? Again, still shocked that no one's also adding.

food service. I thought your idea for like, like meal prepping with people who were either homebound or just don't have the time or like me, I have lots of time. I don't like doing it. And I would pay someone to do that, right? I'm not lazy. I just, I'd rather be outside mowing the lawn or weed whacking than I would cooking something and other people are vice versa. So I think the fact that if you don't know who Rich Severn is, he might be one of the last people to go out of the way, in my opinion, to talk about finances. Like this guy's all about colloquial excellence. He's in academia and he's the fact that he's doing this, but he's also seeing this full circle moment, I think.

Because at 11.59 on the clock, you have students. And at 12.01, you have academics and programs. And now I think they're both touching each other, right? I mean, somebody had a staff the other day of how many colleges there were in the country and how many of them were financially in trouble. And the number wasn't good. It was a significant amount. I think Rich is looking at it from a lens of like, well, if these schools are in trouble, who's going to be teaching the next generation of PTs? The answer might be no one. And then what happens?

Other professions absorb the things that we did. I think that's the route that you were going. And that's the route. That's sort of what I didn't even read Rich's post. I didn't see it. But I've listened to Rich enough to go. I think I know where he's going. Rich isn't the guy trying to get loaded. He ain't the guy trying to get rich. Rich, ironically, is trying to just teach people and be happy and be good. So I'm on a diatribe here. So I think students are more aware of it. And one step further, I think the ones that are hyper aware of it aren't making the decision to go to PT school. I think the ones that are actually crunching the numbers and looking at them and saying, this math, don't math. We never hear. I never meet them. They never listen to this podcast because they never make the decision. They're gone.

Right. Yeah. And that's what it is. You know, basically what I'm taking away from his post is if the financial situation and clinical practice improves, the value of the profession improves, we attract more people. And when I look at that, I mean, it goes back to chicken or the egg. Are we as a profession past the point where maybe back in the day we were able to kind of bring people in, attract students who just want to help people? Right. That's what we did. Now it's not financially viable anymore to just want to help people because the people helping people.

need to buy a house, need to buy a car, need to raise their kids, like do all of this stuff. So all morning I was playing around with AI and I was talking to AI. I'm like, how do you differentiate between the healer, physical therapist who wants hands on the patient, the therapist who wants an hour dedicated to each individual, make a fully customized treatment plan versus somebody more in my world where I'm like, look, we're all humans. We need to walk or locomote. We need to move through space. However, we do that. We need to lift and push and pull and carry. I can develop a plan that pretty much works everything, you know, and I just, I haven't taken a student.

for probably almost 10 years. Since before COVID, I haven't accepted any students. Yesterday, I talked to a local high school. They're like, I've got this young girl. She really wants to be a physical therapist. She's in her senior year of high school. Can we do this arrangement? I was like, yeah, we'll take her. Because now we're kind of in a better position to provide the student with what I believe they need. But with that, one of the main things I'm going to show this student is, look, here's 10 humans that all walk in with different conditions, a back, a shoulder, a knee, a hip, or whatever. They all have different histories. They're all unique personalities. They're all kind of snowflakes in their own way. But at the end of the day,

every single one of them will benefit from doing these five things. Walking across a balance beam, carrying a weight, resisting this motion, whatever it is. And that's where I go back to, I'm like, first we have the identity issue of, am I the person who has to do the intervention? Or am I the person who now analyzes the situation, determines the plan of care, and then lets the technician deliver the intervention? Not even a physical therapist assistant, but an actual unlicensed tech that's been trained by me. And if we continue down the road as a profession, fostering the culture that, nope, everything has to be done by the PT or the PTA, nothing can be outsourced to the technician working under the PT or the PTA.

I just think we've passed that replacement population growth where now we're declining. And at some point, at some point, we're going to be replaced. And it's not so much that I'm going to replace. It's what I deliver is going to be replaced. OK, this person walks in, they have shoulder pain, they want to reduce pain and improve function. I don't I'm not the only option to do that. I'm one option to do that. And if I can't do it at scale, somebody else is going to come in and do it because these individuals need that outcome. Funny part is this last weekend, I was at a like a prompt growth summit. He's brought a bunch of practice owners in.

And my job for two of the sessions, and you're going to love this, was poke. Ask a question until you've got enough people talking, and then shut up, which is harder for me to do, but I did it. And the only rule was we can talk about the ideas that were there, just like RAM sessions at that one conference. Just don't say who said what. And the idea of PTAs or care extenders were brought up, and all these practice owners, most of them were larger footprints. Most of them were in agreement that it was a great idea. In fact, if you're not doing it, that math don't math. And these are the people who are paying attention to their own math. They're not using hypothetical math. They're using their math.

in with their payer mix in their state with their staff their overhead their costs and they're all saying yeah we are doing this as much as we possibly can and if not we should be doing it more yeah so is it ego is it i'm these these are the hands of a healer is it that is it we're taught that we're the one don't let someone else do the thing that's the magic but you and i i think both agree that these aren't magic it's you know it's supposed to be this and sort of this like i don't know I think it's a combination of, you know, I go back to listening on TikTok, this particular OT that I listen to a lot, who I completely disagree with all of her perspectives. I don't know her name and I wouldn't say it even if I did. What are her perspectives? What is her? Well, it's just back to each individual needs a customized, you know, dedicated plan. And we've got all of this knowledge in our head, which we do. They basically want the patient to get a thousand dollar experience.

but they refuse to allow the patient to pay for it. They expect the taxpayer in the community to pay for it. And they refuse to provide the service for less money because they need to make money. So they want to get paid more. They want non-patients to pay the bill for them. It's like they want all of these things together. And then this is where I really struggle also. I'm like, where do you draw the line between personal responsibility versus this kind of victim mentality where she's like, hey, I was burnt out. I couldn't stay in the clinic. I'm out of patient care, but I'm still an OT.

And I want other OTs to be more like me. Well, if everybody's like you, nobody's going to treat patients. Everybody's going to teach people how to treat patients and nobody's going to treat patients. Yeah. So again, that's not a sustainable profession. I can't hire somebody like that. That's why I've given up on hiring clinicians. I just can't do it. Who would be perfect for you? How would you describe the person who you'd love to have walk in and you'd hire? What would their vibe be? What would drive them?

That's a great question. I think a big part of it is you don't have to do what I do. You don't have to do it the way I do it. You can do your own thing. But you have to have a passion for putting the numbers together, understanding the finances behind it, making conscious decisions of, hey, I'm willing to sacrifice more income because I'm going to do what I want to do versus I want to do what I want to do and I want to make a premium income. Dave's not here today, but Dave makes a premium income for what he does.

I'm okay taking less money. I take a lot less money for delivering what I still believe is an outstanding patient care experience. And so what I would look for in an individual who potentially could join the team would be somebody who they're a self-starter. They think independently. They know what they want to do. They know what they want to achieve. They understand the finances behind it. They can find a middle ground between making enough money to be comfortable, achieving their financial goals, and still delivering an experience that the patient wants, even if it's nothing like the experience that I deliver.

But that person is doing it themselves. And there's no reason for them to come work for me. If I if I worked for you or Dave, I would have stayed in clinical practice longer. The reason I left was my brain don't brain. Like some people were like, oh, you're the angle of the force that you're using on the tibia. Jimmy, you're 10 degrees off, buddy. Like, what do you do? And I just remember being like, I don't know, like I sort of felt like getting to move their leg was like more more. That was 85 percent of it. So I felt like the places that I worked were.

way focused on the wrong thing. And I kept looking at myself in the mirror being like, you are round peg in square whole world. You gotta get the hell out of there. Like, I feel like more people need to talk about that. What you're talking about. And you know, my physical therapist assistant and I talk about this. We're like, it doesn't really matter. It doesn't have to be that technical. There are cases where it does need to be that technical. And that's where I think the value is. Those therapists are working for institutions where they're not being monitored. They're not, you know, productivity standards aren't at 120%.

You can have three patients working with a patient who had a stroke and all of that resource going into that one individual because that institution is making all their money somewhere else. Yeah. The overhead is covered. You could do nothing and the overhead is covered. Right. Right. But in my situation, it's more like, hey, we just need to move. We need to work out like the individual just needs a little more fit. Now, I will say real quick. So yesterday I had two situations where I evaluated a patient. I expected a specific outcome during the treatment.

I found new information that changed my perspective on what this person actually needed. Hence, I changed what we were doing. If I had delegated that out to a technician that is not a therapist, I don't think that would have been necessarily identified. It might have been identified two, three sessions later after some of that money had been wasted. So again, I'm still trying to find that balance point where, yeah, I can have a standardized protocol. Everybody comes in, they do the same 10 things. They're all going to get some level of improvement, but there are going to be people who need more direct supervision, more direct analysis.

I don't know where that point is, but I go back to like, all right, there are therapists who have to go and do legal depositions. They've been documenting for 20 years, preparing for the one time that they have to go do a deposition. That is a whole lot of over documentation for the chance that one time in 20 years I'm going to get called into a court of law. And like these are the kinds of things that I'm like, you don't over treat everybody just because occasionally there's going to be one or two cases that do need more. You know, let's go the other direction, figure out a system where if there is something, a red flag that pops up, we can identify it. Then that person goes to the specialist. Not everybody goes to the specialist. Right. Yeah. Horses, not zebras. When does this when does this break? You brought something up very briefly that I think actually tips the scales.

We don't have a problem right now, or everybody tells me at least most of the time problem is not finding patients. Right. But when there are less humans. I imagine right now, right now, the biggest two problems, there's gonna be three problems, right? The biggest of the two of the three right now are, well, I'm getting paid less for doing work. I've got to figure out how to take $100, but provide something for $60 so I can at least make 40, right? So it's the economics, we'll call it the number. And then it's, I need more people who want to do the thing that brings in the revenue. It's not the patient's thing. What happens when we throw the third problem on there? And I'm sure AI could map this out with a bell curve of where the population dip is, right? Because the end of the baby boom is in their 70s. I think my dad, the end of the baby boom, he's 73. So like,

Yeah, in 10 years. What's that? I mean, is that going to be the thing that really, really puts the pressure on all of the things that we're talking about now? That's a good question. Yeah, I think there's that. But then you go deeper and you're like, okay, well, how much is Hinge and Sword going to take off our plate for the individuals? How are they going to commoditize at scale simple orthopedic cases that would have come to a live physical therapist that don't really need a live physical therapist? They would have taken care of that. How is AI and technology going to develop new interventions? I mean, AI in healthcare, robotics in healthcare. I do think this is going to have a major impact where maybe we don't have as many people who are going to need the services of human physical therapists.

Are we going to advance technology quicker than the population of licensed PTs is going to decline? Who's going to get to the finish line first? I don't know. Or is the educational system going to change and adapt? You know, are they going to change the culture of who are we putting out into the profession? Who are the students we're attracting? Why is it that chiropractors tend to go into private practice more than physical therapists? Is it because the educational programs?

of chiropractic care are attracting more entrepreneurial people like they want to help people i want to help people they want to do it in different ways why are so many chiropractors in private practice where pts which is fine i am totally a proponent of look just wipe out all outpatient orthopedic from insurance-based care if you want to do outpatient orthopedic go work for a hospital go work for an institution go work for a place that you can focus on being the best therapist you can be without doing marketing without answering calls without scheduling patients and accepting co-pays like just go do that and then let's change the the face of outpatient private practice which You weren't on the episode, Dave and I were talking, I think, with the PTs who are teaching personal trainers how to do PT. But yeah, you and I talked about it because you did active life interview. And yeah, like maybe that's the future of outpatient ortho. We just completely move away from insurance, completely move away from calling a PT. We're still providing the same outcome. And I think that's what's important. Yeah, that's the question that, you know, would have rose with any other name smelling sweet, right? If I was licensed on Monday, but dropped my license on Tuesday and still did the same thing on Wednesday, is it still the same? And the only difference is I can't bill insurance.

Which is probably one of the reasons why people don't want to work for, I'm not just going to say a hospital system. I don't think they're the big bad wolf all the time anyway. I don't want to be told what to do. I am an independent, autonomous thinker, which I agree with. But if you want more flexibility.

you got to take more risk, right? If you want to hang your own shingle, you have to be the one responsible for doing all the things. I had a post on LinkedIn that I think it's one of the few times that everybody agreed with me. I said, if you want private practice, you are not in the physical therapy business. You are in the marketing and patient attraction business. You're in the customer experience business. You're in the human resources business. When I got promoted in radio, my boss sat me down and was like, all right, today's your first day and you're officially in charge. And then he said, are you ready for someone on your staff to come in your office and cry? And I was like, no, why would that ever be a thing? And then three months later, someone's crying because they needed a weekend off because their grandma died. And I was like,

I didn't realize I was in the people taking care of their emotions business, but I was, my job was to manage people. That doesn't just mean like yell and tell them what to do. In fact, it's the opposite. If I just treated them well, I didn't have to tell them to do anything. I'm getting a little off track, but the idea there is, yeah. So your idea would be outpatient physical therapy under insurance. Let the hospitals have it. They're getting paid more for it anyway.

Everything else is cash? Is that what you mean? Like we just take cash? Yes, that is exactly what I mean. I wish I would have grabbed the screenshot. There was a physical therapist in one of the Facebook groups who said, I think it was a she, she went to physical therapy at a chiropractic owned clinic. She saw a physical therapist. The bill went through for like $750. The clinic got paid 400 and something dollars. She's like, first, she said it was obscene to get paid that much for an hour of physical therapy. But what was she charged? A copay? I don't even, yeah, I don't know.

But she mad because she got screwed or she like mad that someone else was getting paid so much. She got mad that somebody else was getting paid so much and she was getting paid so little when she was the physical therapist, not the patient. Are you mad they're doing it? Are you mad that they're doing it better than you? And I think you know the answer to that. What's the opposite of schadenfreude? Schadenfreude is like the idea of like you're happy when you see like someone trip and fall. This is like someone's mad when someone's doing well. Dude, take that dude to lunch and be like, hey, how'd you do that? What's what are you doing? And it might just be a process issue or a contract issue. Instead of crapping on that person, like buy him dinner and be like, teach me. Teach me. What are you doing? What are you doing differently?

You're not competing as much with that person as you think. You are competing against other time, gravity, skin cancer. We're competing against all those things. Those are the things that are actually trying to kill us. The dude down the street is just trying to do the same thing as you. I think that's I believe that. Well, this goes back to the culture question. Is it a societal change or shift? Is it something within the universities which tend to skew more liberal? There are PTs right now who trying to I'm trying to walk this line where it's like, look, somebody launched a business outside of health care.

grew this business to the highest valuation ever for a business. Now that business has lost 30, 40% of its value from its peak. And there are therapists celebrating that this business, which has lifted hundreds of people above a million dollar valuation, lifted thousands of thousands of people out of poverty. They're celebrating because they don't like the person who started the business. And so the business has lost value. It's a them versus us. It's this whole thing that's pervasive through politics, through life, through everything. Now I could just be an old guy who's like, oh, back in my day.

right but but i just i see this we're not celebrating the success and you say it all the time when the success happens people want to tear down that success unless it's happening to them and then they're mad that it you know um so i don't know did you see the movie air the michael jordan like sort of i did not worth it worth it ben affleck matt damon A good movie. It's a good movie, even though you and I are old enough to know the story. But even there. And there's a scene, the scene, the pivotal scene, where Matt Damon is like, I don't know, like one of the agents for Nike. And he's telling, he's essentially pitching Michael Jordan as the third or fourth best shoe. Everybody's doing Converse. Nike's not a thing, man. And he's like, you're going to win championships. The world is going to build you up because you're a great story. You're this guy that was cut from his high school team. And then you won a championship in college. And he's like, you're going to reach the mountaintop. And then they're going to tear you down. Because when they build you into something that doesn't exist,

They can't let you exist. The scene is so fantastic because that's true with an athlete, an actor or actress, a musician, a company. These all have faces, right? Like all these companies have faces. The first time someone pointed that out, who has more Instagram followers, Steve Jobs or Apple? And I was like, well, obviously Apple, it's a company. No, it's the face. It's the face. So yeah, when you see someone down the street doing better than you, I forget who said it first, but success isn't cake. If I got a big old slice, our mentality is from when we're little.

I don't want that toy until my brother touched it. And then my brain doesn't need to be taught. One toy, if he has it, I have zero toy, right? That's not success though. It's just not. It's the world's too big with too many opportunities to be focused on that. I mean, Jerry breaks it out more than anybody, I think, with that statistic. And I don't even, it's been said so many times, I'm not even sure where the hell the statistic came from, but that 92% of people who could use physical therapy don't even get it. So we're competing over the 8% instead of the 92%, right? I told that story about...

When I ran the radio station, we had a budget for this one day, St. Patrick's Day in Scranton. And every year we pitched to get our budget funded by the boss. And eventually the boss said, what do you want to do on St. Patrick's Day? And I said, nothing. I wanted to take that money and spend it in April, May, and June. Because I saw you're all fighting over one day's worth of attention for 10 grand. I'll just take my 10 grand and I'll go spend it where no one else is. I'll go build.

on cheap, cheap real estate and wait for the people to eventually move there or give them a reason to girls gone wild, right? Super bad, super horrible, like VHS empire built on buying every ad from 11 PM to 5 AM because it was cheap. And that's when his audience was awake, right? We keep trying to out PT each other. The people who win will not, they will figure out a strategy to reach people in a different way, which is a good segue that I can go to unless you have something else. Yeah, go ahead. So we got a listener voicemail.

I'm getting voicemails now. Someone send me one of those voice messages. I'll get her name in a second. But she was approached by a marketing company who essentially gave her a pitch and said, listen, X number of people. It's a good pitch anyway. They thought from her seat anyway. X number of people are moving to your area. You own a clinic in this area.

here's five ways we can target those people before they decide who their physical therapist is. Now, I think this is a good strategy. I don't know if it's a good strategy for PT because I still think PT is pretty reactive, right? Like I don't move into a town and go, okay, I got to find a doctor. I got to find three good restaurants, one place to have a drink and who's my PT, right? Like we sort of look for PT arguably too late, right? Myself included, like I start thinking of who my PT is when my elbow hurts or when my knee hurts. But I thought this strategy at least was pretty good. I'm not sure if I can make this any larger.

So essentially, it was like saying, target the new families before they begin searching. So I like the idea. I just don't know if I love it for PT. And she was essentially asking us to sort of critique this pitch. I thought the image was designed pretty well. I'm sure if I was giving this image a prompt, I'd say, great design, lose 50% of the words though. Right, right. Keep the better word, maybe 70% of the words and just make the other words bigger.

but essentially their pitch was be the first physical therapy practice they discover. Okay. Let's, let's say, cause it does say families. Let's say you're a peds practice with a kid who's going to need PT forever. Like you're, you're in PT for life, right? That's a good point. That's a good audience for that. Yeah. Uh, second is they essentially say we serve your community in a 50 mile radius around where this person is in Kansas. So they're showing, we understand how people search for things. We're going to put you in front of them before they need, uh, before they need care. I'm trying to see what that estimated verified new families every month.

If that number is right, 2600 new families in a 15 mile radius in Kansas. I don't know. I'm not good with math. That seems like a lot. But if that's right, like if you got one percent of that, if you're in front of one percent of that, that would be good math. So thoughts on this strategy and thoughts on this strategy for a PT.

I like it. Let me start there. I like it. I can tell you candidly, when I hear a patient who would potentially fit into that category, a patient who moves somewhere and one of the first things they want to do is they want to find their PT, I get a little bit uncomfortable inside. Why? Because to me, now from a business owner perspective, it's like, yes, cha-ching. But from a therapist perspective, I'm like, that's not my ideal client. That's a little too dependent. That's a little too needy. That's the guy who starts texting you five minutes after the date is over to be like, hey, we had a great time. That patient's too expensive.

Not too expensive, just too needy. But that's expensive for you because like, hey man, you're going to demand way too much of my time. I'm never going to serve you. You're always going to want more. Right, right. So, you know, from that, but hey, there are therapists who love that patient and that patient could be your lifetime patient. Lifetime value of that patient is going to be incredibly high. That patient is going to believe that you are the healer that they've been looking for and they're going to want to be with you no matter what. So like, there's value in that, just not value for me. I like the idea of establishing yourself early in the process. I think the biggest barrier to this is we don't have the margin and the budget to afford.

to pay for that yeah yeah it's just it's more than what we're going to make on a typical outpatient orthopedic or neuro case right so that that would be the challenge um this is essentially what dave is doing instead of new families he's targeting we should get an update uh the last update we had is that he had a bunch of clicks and scans but nobody had followed through maybe one person did like a discovery visit he had done a postcard mailer The twist that I like, I mean, I like the postcard mailer idea. The twist that I loved was that each card had a specific QR code, like a trackable QR code. That's obviously an app because if I had to sit there and just make a new QR code, that way you can see like when was it sent, what building, yada, yada. But we also agreed, I think, or I at least didn't say, that card might sit in a drawer for six, nine months, a year before you're like, oh yeah, okay, I'll make that decision. So you don't know if you can attribute it to that. Yeah, I think you're right. The margin isn't there, but I think that marketing company was doing.

An honest job, at least, in saying, OK, let me think forward for you. And if these people have already made their decision, the people that already live there, and if there are 2,600 new families coming in, that's a lot per month. Yeah. In Kansas, what is that? I'm pulling it back up. You know, then the other stuff that you look at, like these are obviously very generic stock photography images. This is trying to sell whoever makes the decision about marketing in the PT business. This is trying to sell that person.

you know, have a condition that's going to need lifetime care. I don't see that here. It's not. Yeah. So I don't know. Let me see what her focus was. I didn't ask her for permission to share her stuff. I don't think she'd mind, but board certified serving area though. Unless, oh, mom and baby specialist. So yeah, mom and baby specialist. It doesn't come across in that message though. Right. Like it doesn't look like that. At least this pitch doesn't look like that.

because that's what because i was in peds i didn't understand that until i got in peds and like amy my mentor was like these kids are gonna be this this is tuesday at one o'clock till this kid's 18 then they go somewhere else or or even a couple years past 18. so that would be a good strategy for this because that involves a weekly need your pc for typical outpatient ortho i don't think it would be a great idea this would be a great idea if you were a chain like you said if you had the size and the margin to do that if you had your own marketing person this person you might hire for digital seo or okay you'd be mine i'll pay you two grand a month to find me two families two patients that come in that are that are quote in the new family bucket i wonder too if there was dr bow coming in with the stat kansas city metro largest in they're just outside of kansas kansas city yeah i think so gained about 8 000 residents total over four years oh so yeah so there's no way it's 2 000 a month unless there is that much out i'm not good this is not my strong suit Maybe they're counting each person in the house. Yeah. Well, I don't know. I think, think the things that 3,000 doesn't matter, but yes, that number is important. Cause you're going to say how much did it cost me to get, you need to know your customer acquisition cost.

I'm guessing this was AI generated regardless. Looking at this, which is pleasant to look at compared to I shared this one with you. Yeah, I've seen this now way too many times. And again, I'm guilty of this. My YouTube thumbnails look very AI generated. You know, we can jump on a trend, but the trend is going to wear out. It's going to burn out. To me, this is part of the AI. As soon as ChatGPT started getting better workload with generating these kinds of infographics, it got overutilized. Yeah.

And so what are your thoughts when you see something like this? If you're the occupational therapist sitting there, you know, that's appealing to you. No, in fact, it would probably turn me off. It was I couldn't this poster for the podcast listeners. Put that back up. Put that back up. This poster is going to be great for the podcast listeners. This poster sounds.

Like a monster truck commercial. Sunday, Sunday, it's Grave Digger. Now hiring occupational therapists at $40, $40, $47 a night. This poster sounds like trash. This to me is why people call it slop. Designing something with AI doesn't necessarily make it slop.

It's when you can tell like you did one prompt and this thing popped out and it's trash, right? So now the curtains don't match the carpet, Tony. Like if this is a classy, if this is a place you want someone who's great to work at, this don't match. If this place is, you know, smells like stale cigarettes and, you know, old Budweiser cans. Yeah, this clinic looks fantastic. And I'm not, you know, trashing them except for this poster makes you look like that. I don't know who you are. I don't have my glasses. I can't even read what this person's from. But yes, this don't match.

I would say, though, the opposite or not the opposite. It's not completely opposite. A YouTube thumbnail designed sort of cartoony or caricature that's designed to get to get an immediate emotion to watch the video. Right. So I think you do need to balance what you look like. You can go too much.

where you're advertising with a flashy, too loud, too sloppily designed thumbnail. And then you click it. You're like, this is a very thoughtful video. I was expecting like someone screaming and a lot of zoom in, zoom outs. Where's the, where's the weird B roll transitions and stuff like that. And it's not there. So just match, match the curtains to the carpet, right? Like you got to make sure these two things match up or, or here's why you'll get the people that this poster attracts and you'll be sitting there going advertising doesn't work or, or the opposite is true. You design something super classy.

And classy people apply and then they get there and they're like, I don't want to work here. And you say advertising doesn't work. You're not matching the message to the audience. You're just saying, make it easy and make it get a lot of it. A lot of attention isn't good if it's bad attention. And yet there is bad attention. Good morning, Steven Dunn.

So that's what I was thinking. Taking that, what would you say to the AI to make that look more appealing? How would you change that? First, I would have, and this sounds like it's going to take you 15 minutes, but you're going to do it once. Once a year is you're going to design your own brand standards. Here's what we look like. Here's what we sound like. We use words like this. We do not use words like this. I say this all the time. We sort of feel like a mix of Apple design this without being pretentious.

you can do that until you find a brand standard and then you create, then you lock that into a design document. And then what's it called when you upload that to chat GPT, it's got a name and it's like, it sort of saves it in the GPT and you can refer to it. There's like a document, but like when you're designing a GPT, you're gonna use over and over again, you can upload a hard document. And then I use it with prompt. If I design something, I say refer to the prompt brand and voice guidelines in this. I'm essentially getting it to the three yard line. And then I'm like,

Yeah, but this is for internal. I still want to make it look great. I'm not going to call in a designer from the design team for two hours. It's not elevated to that. But make sure it's on brand. Design your brand standards first. I mean, do you think that that place is even that? Those are the business colors? I mean, those colors, right? It's like hot turquoise. I don't even know what you would call that. It's like electric. It's electric. I don't know. I don't know. It's electric swimming pool. I don't know what you'd call that. Yeah. So let's do a quick comparison. I got one more coming. Just look at what that does.

So this one, I basically took the original image, which was this. And I just said, can you recreate this as a more professional image infographic to attract professional OTs? And it kind of muted it down. You know, I wonder too, though, like I get a lot of people want to join my Facebook groups from India and other countries. And then I go into their profiles and I look at their stuff. And look, my mom was from South America. She was born and raised in South America, immigrated to the U.S. Like there are cultural differences. Yeah. What she was looking for and wanted to see was very different than what we were comfortable with here. So I just wonder, because this was posted by Fathi Mohammed.

And I did look at his profile and, you know, it's clearly an overseas marketer. I just wonder if this is because this is what he's used to culturally. This is what he's been brought up with. 100%. I went and looked up the company. This is now telling. Everything on here is a stock image. Stock image, stock image, stock image, stock image. They're a staffing company. Okay. That's what they are. Your gateway to top tier. And so they might be trying to attract people who are used to this. So that might be their strategy and they might be right on.

I don't know. I don't know how this still works in today's world. If you're trying to recruit people who have come from overseas, that's the only thing I can see. What you just said, if that were their target, that makes sense. If it's not, you're off. Because your image took 11 seconds longer and, in my opinion, looked more on point for paying someone $50 an hour. Now I said add in a Nike or Apple aesthetic. There you go. So if this was something that they were sharing, what would it look like? Yep. And now it took us here. Yeah.

It's clean, man. I mean, I don't know why the guy dunking the ball is there, but yeah, obviously some Nike, but it even still looks better, right? Right. But this is the thing. So back to now, we didn't even put any time into, like you said, I didn't give any information or context to who's the target demographic. Who am I trying to relay the message to? What are the emotions around, like, who is the OT? If this is targeting OT, who is the OT looking for a new job? Why are they looking for a new job? What is it that, what is the need that they're trying to fulfill? Like, there are so many deeper layers to this that we could get into writing sales copy.

copying old ads that came out. I was looking at old Tic Tac, the candy Tic Tac breath freshener ads. Like we could pull so much of that context into this kind of marketing. Yes. There's a great ad that my former boss had. He would have one of those desk calendars tacked to his wall. And underneath that was a newspaper ad. And I asked him, I'm like, why is it hidden under there? He goes, well, once a year, I could take this thing down and put up a new calendar. And he goes, I'd love to be reminded of it. And I want to find the ad because it was great. It was done by Holiday Inn.

And it was a full-page ad. And it had a towel, like a pile of towels there, like hotel towels. And they invented a holiday. And they called it Towel Amnesty Day. And they said, listen, we know what happens. Every once in a while, you accidentally bring one of our towels home. If you bring the towel back on Towel Amnesty Day, no harm, no foul.

This was holiday and being very, very self-aware before social media, in my opinion, because it got good attention. It was worth a laugh, right? So the other one reminded me of VW Bug was coming out in the 70s. And the car of the 70s was the Mustang, baby. It was all muscle cars. And if you were the marketer for VW, what are you supposed to do? So it's a full page ad, ton of white space, top left corner, 300 feet away, was a tiny little bug. And they said, think small. Think small, right? I'm not going to out Amazon, Amazon. You're not going to out market, you know, Google.

you're not gonna do it so don't do not do it you will do a piss poor job you'll say marketing doesn't work go where your strengths are so let's use this last oh what do we got here all right so great ad looks like yeah rolls royce And the copy reads what? At 60 miles an hour, the loudest noise in the new Rolls Royce comes from the electronic clock. This is a classic example that every marketer understands and knows. This is talking to a very sophisticated, specific audience. You understand that that individual is buying luxury. Yeah, they're buying precision. They're willing to spend the money. They have the money. They have unreasonable amounts of money.

And they value this kind of thing. So like this would be something where I would reference because that is so well-known and well-studied when I'm using AI, whatever the platform, I would reference that specific ad. I would reference that genre. Sometimes I reference direct response. Sometimes I reference something else, but Gary Halpert, Alex Ramosi, like I put in the names of the people that I want to embrace. And this is where it goes back to the difference between I can watch a YouTube video to learn how to stretch my hamstring, or I could go to a licensed physical therapist to learn PNF patterns, right?

I can be a marketing professional who understands all of this history and context, or I could see something online and be like, I'm going to do that. Yeah, you can. You can. I told you we have no budget. Do it. Good artists borrow. Great artists steal. Right. That was Picasso. So we've got 10 minutes left. Let's continue this conversation. But I want I want this is personal now. So now part of my job is I run this career connection program. And essentially, this is Prompt, who's an EMR company who should not be anywhere near the hiring game. Right.

But we just discussed earlier, what are the two biggest problems for clinics? Reimbursement. This doesn't really help that. Finding great clinicians. Prompt has essentially hired Jimmy McKay and said, how do we, an EMR company of all places, we're not in the top hundred of thoughts to get clinicians to come to our website to look for a job.

but we're essentially going to be a free matching service. I'm Chuck Woolery. I'm the dating game. My goal isn't to just place people. It's to place the right people. If I do five a month, I'm a hero. I'm a hero because right now you're doing, we're doing nothing. We're not charging the clinics that are prompt customers. We're not charging the clinicians. It's not an AI automated thing. It's not a job board.

So where would you go into getting people, and I don't want to use marketing terms, but getting people to at least know, like, and trust us? I've got a few ideas of what I'm doing, and I want to see what Tony's brain will do. Because the pitch is, instead of leaving the profession, what if it's this job, not the job? That's the problem. What if it's not physical therapy? That's the problem. What if it's just a place you're going to, and there's a better place three and a half miles that way that you just don't know about? What if I could help you find it?

are you talking about and it's a marketplace really bringing employer employee together kind of so what happens is tony goes i'm just frustrated here i got two options find a new place but i don't know where to look i've been to indeed i see i see ads online online that look a lot like this this is what the world is everything's trash everything sucks or do i give this one last shot and i go you tell me everything you want to know about you I then manually go and look and see who's in your area. What's their NPS score? What kind of quality? Who are they seeing? What kind of technology do they use? If you say, I hate documenting until nine o'clock at night, I go, we got an organization using this, that and everything. And our average close note time is this. You're telling me you hate this. I'm telling you this place doesn't do that. It's a manual search. It's Jimmy.

I think first you embrace the fact that the EMR is probably one of the biggest impact on a therapist job performance, right? Like there are countless Facebook posts, everybody complaining about documentation and EMR. It makes or breaks the job and the profession completely. So you have your hands on what could be the most impactful aspect, even knowing people will take less money to do the job if they have a better experience with the EMR. Correct, correct. So this is where you look at what are those pain points? How do I start these conversations? How do I bring...

uh this either onto linkedin or wherever therapists are and you're not even trying to recruit and hire therapists for employers you're just fostering this conversation around the frustrations the pain points hey we there are solutions for this and then as you identify the candidates that's when it turns into also hey we've got this employer they're using the system you know this could be the solution to your problem let me make a connection Do what you want to do. Let me just make you connect you with John at so-and-so physical therapy. Yep. Yeah, the process is you tell me about you. I then go hunt and search for three good options. I run those options by you before I make the connection. Like, hey, man, swipe right or swipe left. Which one do you want to do? Tony doesn't know which way to swipe. He's like, which one is the connect? Because you were never on Tinder.

Tony's like, I don't know what that is. Before my time. You give me three thumbs up. I then send three emails. I'm introducing you to A, to B, to C. And I go, this is on you. Good luck to both of you. I check back in two weeks and go with each of you. What happened? How was the experience? Good experience, bad experience? What was wrong about that? Help me understand where we missed and maybe I can go look again. So it's sort of the rotary phone to the AI chatbot in 2026, where it's manual. It's meat to meat. It's people. And that's sort of why I like it, which is.

I'm not going to out AI or out volume. Indeed. I'm just not, I'm not going to be able to outreach LinkedIn jobs, but I can have conversations where people are having conversations and those conversations all touch on. Why are you leaving? What would keep you? What do you, why do you love your job and you hate yours? What's missing? This is different for everybody. Yeah. Right. I mean, this ad is great because it just screams luxury. It doesn't, it's not about the clock, right? The Rolls Royce at 60 miles an hour, the loudest noise in the new Rolls Royce comes from the electric clock. Ironically, it's about everything except the clock. It's about this, this entire piece of machinery is put together so well, you don't hear a squeak.

I mean, think about the mustard company that did Rolls-Royce level advertising in the 90s, 80s and 90s. Great coupon, baby. I mean, imagine the marketer. We got to judge up mustard. Well, let's talk about where we recruit, where we get our bean, our mustard beans from, and we're being organically sourced, and our mustard is the cheapest. It's like, no, we're the most expensive mustard, and we are for these people. And fancy people buy the mustard, but also people who want to be fancy in a little way buy the mustard. That's a smart play.

All right. So while we were talking, I put the ad into chat on the same thread. And I said, now, you know, take this, put it into the ad that we're looking at. The best occupational therapy jobs still let you be an occupational therapist. But see, you touched, you just hit on something that I don't even know that you knew that you were going to do when you got there. Look at the difference between this ad and this ad. We are more sophisticated in terms of technology. You can have a $100 a year Canva account and design.

million-dollar ad campaigns, visuals. It still takes skill to do that, though. That's the problem. So we've got all the technology in the world at our fingertips with an AI, anything. You can do it by type. You can just do it by voice. And we generate this. Or you think about it and you go, what is the opposite of that? This. Or this. This would be the best. I might steal this for the campaign I'm working on. Why? Because there's no color. It's quite literally the opposite of this. And it will stand out because...

I mean, the 28 immutable laws of marketing or whatever, make the big small, make the small big, make the visible invisible, make the colorful monochrome would be one of those laws. Make the loud quiet. I don't know. Maybe I steal that. I know we have about two minutes left. My question to you, what do you think about the fact that it stayed black and white? It stayed like dated. You know, I'm assuming the occupational therapist is the woman. Of course, occupational therapy has a huge percentage of women over men. What do you think of the aesthetic of actually even considering just sticking with this picture?

Why do I think the AI got there or do I like using it? Do you like using it? Would this be something you would use in 2026? I might judge it up a little bit, but I like the fact that it's dated because it's so anti that. Or do you do, there was a Tobey Maguire movie years ago where they got teleported back to the 50s and their life was in black and white. There was a way to make that look a little modern. Like, I don't know. I think, is that what you're asking? Like, would I use that straight or would I judge the picture a little bit to make it look modern, but black and white?

I like it the way it is. I'm just saying, like, we are looking, effectively, we are looking for a call back to tradition. Pleasantville. A slower time. Pleasantville, exactly. Yeah, yeah, like, I think it stops the scroll. I think it catches attention. I'm sure there are going to be people offended by it, but that's not a bad thing either. It's not, it's not. You know, so.

Yeah, it's really interesting. And this was the fourth iteration. We went from the first to the second to the third and now we got this. I think that's the problem with people using some of these tools is they do quite literally one input and they go, well, I guess that's it. I guess because I don't know what I'm doing. Listen, if you ask me to design something like from scratch, it's going to be a B minus, right? But I can look at work and go, man, I love looking at great graphic design because a good graphic designer, in my opinion, it's not the this, it's the this and being able to turn this into an image. It's their fault. All right, let's wrap it up. So parting shots.

I thought that's it. Oh, it did say orgasms. I thought it said orgasms, organisms, orgasms. Oh, is that what led to the return of color in Pleasantville? I might have been too young to understand that. I'm sure Beau knows. Wasn't there an official diagnosis of hysteria? Hysteria. Yeah. Women were being sent to doctors to be...

Unhysterical. All right. So I think we had a great real-time illustration, how to use AI, how to, you know, get, extract a little more value out of the tool. It can't just be a one shot. This is what I want. That's what you get. This ain't it, but this could be, this is better. This could be better. It depends, but I think we agree. This blends, this blends into the background. This image that I'm showing, if you're watching live stream, screams like a monster truck commercial for a grave digger. And this says, we're looking for great occupational therapists. It still has the same information. It just does it a different way. Right.

Right. What's your parting side? I'm done. I would say understand what game you're playing and either hire someone to do it or learn how to do it really well. Because as a great professor told me once, you're either doing public relations or communications well or you're doing it poorly. There is no in the middle. Like just saying we don't have to do marketing. When people say we rely on word of mouth and I say what words and whose mouth? Like you're doing this well or poorly. You get to decide what it is. All right. See you on Thursday. See you on Thursday.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy?

This episode is 1 hour and 1 minute long.

When was this PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy episode published?

This episode was published on August 12, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.