Skip to content
The Readership of Theseus episode artwork

Feb 5, 2026 1 hr 24 min

The Readership of Theseus

from Comic Lab Hosted by Dave Kellett and Brad Guigar

Cartoonists Brad Guigar and Dave Kellett dig into the many ways we react to humor — from full-on belly laughs to the silent internal “that was good” response. After that the way, they tackle some big (and surprisingly relatable) topics: Are they actually going to use Patreon Quips? Dave’s Bad 2025 — what went wrong, what he learned, and why it matters Why you never stop building an audience, even when things feel “established” And yes… being scared of Reddit comments is universal! Summary In this episode of Comic Lab, hosts Dave Kellett and Brad Guigar dive into the nature of humor in comics, prompted by a listener's question about whether funny comics truly elicit laughter or if they are simply enjoyable. Brad and Dave explore the subjective nature of humor, sharing their own experiences with laughter and recognition of craft in comedy. Next, they delve into the ongoing journey of building and maintaining an audience in the ever-evolving landscape of comics. They emphasize that there is no such thing as a 'built audience.' Audience engagement is a continuous process that requires constant effort and adaptation. Drawing on the metaphor of the Ship of Theseus, they discuss how creators must regularly replace and update their strategies to keep their audience engaged, acknowledging that audience members may leave for various reasons, including life changes or simply forgetting about the content. The conversation also touches on the emotional toll of negative feedback, particularly on platforms like Reddit, where creators often face harsh criticism. Brad and Dave share personal anecdotes about dealing with trolls and the importance of focusing on the positive aspects of audience engagement. They conclude by reinforcing the idea that the creative journey is ongoing, and that every creator must continually learn and adapt to thrive in the industry. Takeaways "Not every year is going to be gangbusters." There's no such thing as a built audience; you're always in building mode. Audience engagement is like the Ship of Theseus; it's constantly changing. You should aim to gain 2-6% new audience every month to replace those who leave. Negative comments often come from unhappy individuals; don't take them personally. Every creator must continually learn and adapt to thrive in the industry. You get great rewards when you join the ComicLab Community on Patreon $2 — Early access to episodes $5 — Submit a question for possible use on the show AND get the exclusive ProTips podcast. Plus $2-tier rewards. If you'd like a one-on-one consultation about your comic, book it now! Brad Guigar is the creator of Evil Inc and the author of The Webcomics Handbook. He is available for personal consultations. Dave Kellett is the creator of Sheldon and Drive. He is the co-director of the comics documentary, Stripped.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Cartoonists Brad Guigar and Dave Kellett dig into the many ways we react to humor — from full-on belly laughs to the silent internal “that was good” response. Later... why you never stop building an audience, even when things feel “established.”

Ready to play

The Readership of Theseus

0:00 1:24:09

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Nerd on the Street Kaori Akari and Jason Rayn Welcome to our block! Kaori and Jason Rayn have been running Nerd on the Street for 4 years and have no intentions of backing down. Join us for all the nerd talk. We have anime, comic books, Disney, Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter! You name it, we got it. Follow our IG: Nerdonthestreet4life our personal IGs: witchblade22 and jasonrayn423. Subscribe to the YT channel Nerd on the Street and follow us on Tik Tok! Jasonrayn and KaoriAkari. Let's have a good time! Explicit RetConversations Retconversations Have you ever wanted to understand a comic book storyline but didn't have the patience or sanity? Leia and Josh to the rescue! They take a guest through a comic book storyline step by arduous step! Explicit High and Dry Podcast with Oisín Hanlon and Darach McGarrigle Darach McGarrigle and Oisín Hanlon Join comedians Oisin Hanlon and Darach McGarrigle for jokes, stories, and more.Oisín Hanlon is an Irish comic with a high energy act who has performed worldwide throughout America and Europe at legendary clubs like The Comedy Store(London) Caroline’s(New York), Upright Citizens Brigade(New York), New York Comedy Club, Laugh Factory (Chicago).– Finalist of the Amused Moose Competition 2018, Edinburgh Fringe Festival.– Headlined stage at Dublin Vodafone Comedy Festival 2018– Headlined stage at Barcelona Comedy Festival 2019– Founder of the Riff-Raff Comedy Club based in Dublin and Galway.“Brilliantly Funny” – Irish Independent“There’s definitely something funny and distinctive in Oisin Hanlon’s bones…he’s got an appealing, intriguing vibe and a winning, offbeat flow.” – Steve Bennett of Chortle.co.u [http://chortle.co.uk/]kPatreon: @oisinhanlon [https://www.patreon.com/oisinhanlon]Website: oisinhanlon.com [https://oisinhanlon.com/]Insta: @oisinhanlon [https://www.instagram.co Explicit word balloon the comic book creators interview show john siuntres audio interviews featuring pop culture discussions of comic books, Films ,TV, DVDs, Animation, Novels, and other cult entertainment. Explicit

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Comic Lab?

This episode is 1 hour and 24 minutes long.

When was this Comic Lab episode published?

This episode was published on February 5, 2026.

Can I download this Comic Lab episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.