The Republican Party Is Dead

The Republican Party used to stand for something. You can argue about whether what it stood for was good or bad, but it had a platform. It had principles. It had ideas that existed independently of any single person.That party is gone.What replaced it is not a political party. It is a loyalty structure built around one man. And the psychology behind how that happened is not new. It is one of the most documented patterns in the history of democratic collapse.The Fateful AllianceIn 2018, political scientists Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt at Harvard University published How Democracies Die. They studied democracies that collapsed not from military coups or foreign invasions but from the inside. From elected leaders who dismantled democratic norms while using democratic institutions to do it.What they found was a pattern so consistent it had a name. They called it the fateful alliance.The pattern works like this. An extremist emerges who is too loud, too angry, and too popular for the political establishment to ignore. The establishment does not believe in him. They do not respect him. But they see an opportunity. He brings energy. He brings voters. He brings people the party could never reach on its own.So they let him in. They make the deal. They tell themselves the same thing establishment parties have told themselves in every country where this has ever happened.We can control him.They never can.The extremist does not assimilate into the party. He consumes it. He replaces the party’s principles with personal loyalty. He replaces policy debates with performance. He replaces internal disagreement with purges.And one by one, everyone inside the party who refuses to fall in line gets destroyed.The PurgeLiz Cheney voted with Trump the vast majority of the time. She was the third highest ranking Republican in the House. She was Republican royalty, the daughter of a former Vice President. None of that mattered. She voted to impeach Trump after January 6th and her career was over. The Republican National Committee censured her and ceased all support. Not because she lost an argument. Because she refused to pledge loyalty.Mitt Romney was the Republican nominee for President in 2012. The party chose him to represent them on the biggest stage in American politics. He became the first senator in American history to vote to convict a president of his own party during an impeachment trial. Donald Trump Jr. called for him to be expelled from the GOP. The party’s own chairwoman, who is Romney’s niece, publicly rebuked him. He did not lose an election. He was forced out by a party that no longer had room for anyone who would not kneel.Adam Kinzinger served in the Air Force. He was a Lieutenant Colonel in the Air National Guard. He was a conservative Republican from Illinois who was once considered a rising star in the party. He served on the January 6th committee and was censured by his own party for it. The RNC voted to cease all support for him as a member of the Republican Party. Not for being liberal. For telling the truth.These were not fringe members. These were the center of the Republican Party. And they were destroyed for one reason. They refused to put one man above the party and the country.The PatternLevitsky and Ziblatt documented this same sequence in democracy after democracy. In Venezuela, Hugo Chavez was invited into the political mainstream by establishment figures who thought they could use his popularity. Within years, he had hollowed out every institution that could check his power. In Hungary, Viktor Orban was a mainstream conservative before he systematically dismantled judicial independence and press freedom from inside a democratic framework. In Turkey, Recep Tayyip Erdogan rose through democratic elections and then used his power to eliminate the independence of courts, media, and political opposition.Every case followed the same playbook. A conservative party invites in an extremist. The extremist takes over. The party disappears. And what remains is not a political party anymore. It is a vehicle for one person’s power.What’s LeftThe Republican Party in its current form does not have a platform that exists independently of Donald Trump. It does not debate policy. It debates loyalty. It does not ask whether an idea is good for the country. It asks whether the idea is good for Trump.The internal structure of the party is no longer organized around ideology. It is organized around proximity to one man and willingness to do whatever he asks. The question that determines a Republican’s survival is not whether they are conservative enough. It is whether they are loyal enough.That is not a political party. That is a loyalty cult with a voter registration card.The Republican Party is dead. The people who killed it still walk around wearing its name. And they are not smart enough to realize the difference.SourcesSteven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt, How Democracies Die, Crown Publishing, 2018NPR, “Liz Cheney Removed From GOP Post Over Trump Criticism,” May 12, 2021NPR, “Republicans Censure Liz Cheney, Adam Kinzinger for January 6 Committee Work,” February 4, 2022Reuters, “Romney Says He Will Vote to Convict Trump in Impeachment Trial,” February 5, 2020Deseret News, “Why Mitt Romney Voted to Convict Trump and Mike Lee Voted to Acquit,” February 13, 2021Axios, “Republicans and Democrats React to Mitt Romney Voting to Convict Trump,” February 5, 2020Time, “GOP Congressman Adam Kinzinger on Where the Jan. 6 Committee Goes Next,” June 2022ABC News, “RNC Votes to Censure Cheney, Kinzinger for Roles on House Jan. 6 Committee,” February 4, 2022 This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit lucasbean.substack.com/subscribe