The Shocking Truth About Peter, the Keys, and Papal Authority! | Matthew 16 Pt. 3 | Weighed in the Balance Ep. 13

Send us Fan MailWas Peter really the first pope? Or have we misread one of the most famous passages in the Gospels? In this episode, Jonathan and Alex take a deep dive into Matthew 16 and the Roman Catholic argument for papal authority. They unpack the grammar, explore the Greek, and show why the “keys of the kingdom” may not mean what you’ve been told. Along the way, they compare Matthew 16 to Matthew 18 and the Great Commission, argue that Christ—not Peter—is always the focus, and offer a distinctly Reformed take on ecclesial authority and church discipline. If you've ever wondered what Jesus really meant when he said, “I will give you the keys,” this episode is for you.This is part 3. If you haven't seen part 1 or 2 look for them in previous episodes!Scripture references: - Matthew 16:13–20- Matthew 18:15-20- Matthew 28:16-20- 1 Peter 2:4–9- John 20- Philippians 2- Acts 1–10Resources:Cameron's Original VideoJohn Chrysostom’s Homily on Matthew 54John Calvin’s Commentary on Matthew 16Support the showDo you think this claim is found wanting? Let us know on social!! Click here to find us everywhere!!