Skip to content
The Therapist Who Took the Interview While Driving episode artwork

Aug 23, 2026 59 min

The Therapist Who Took the Interview While Driving

from PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy Hosted by Jimmy McKay, PT, DPT | Physical Therapy Podcast

What matters more in a physical therapy hire: clinical skill, reliability, values, or fit? In this episode of PT Breakfast Club, Dave Kittle and Tony Maritato talk through the uncomfortable parts of hiring that rarely make it into job descriptions. Tony starts with a question every clinic owner eventually faces: what do you do with someone who is great with patients, but unreliable? Dave shares his interview process, including phone screens, Zoom calls, in-person skills assessments, reference checks, and the small behavioral details that can reveal whether a candidate is actually serious. The conversation centers on one memorable example: a candidate who took a scheduled interview call while driving. For Dave, that was the end of the road. Not because the person was evil, but because the moment revealed something about attention, preparation, and how seriously they treated the opportunity. Tony and Dave also explore whether employers should clearly spell out expectations or leave some things unsaid to see what a candidate does naturally. They talk about new grads versus experienced hires, hiring for core values, ambition alignment, long-term fit, and why one person can either elevate a clinic or quietly disrupt everything. Then the episode turns toward outpatient ortho and the future of physical therapy. Dave brings up a LinkedIn post from an orthopedic surgeon who says he prescribes less formal PT than he did 10 years ago. Tony responds with a bigger question: what if some routine outpatient ortho care is not the best use of insurance dollars? That leads to a spicy conversation about joint replacements, bundled payments, home exercise programs, AI, cash pay, private practice, premium models, scalable healthcare, Equinox, Planet Fitness, and where PT might be headed next. This episode features Dave Kittle and Tony Maritato.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Therapist Who Took the Interview While Driving

0:00 59:01
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Broadcasting way too early from three separate Wi-Fi connections, it's PT Breakfast Club with Tony Maritano, Dave Kittle, and Jimmy McKay. And we are live. Dave Kittle, Tony Maritato, Jimmy McKay. So before we went live, I said, we are never sick. And we've had this conversation before, but it's worth bringing up again. I've got a physical therapist assistant I work with. I told him a couple months ago, I actually got sick. I never get sick. I said, I don't think you've ever called out sick in like 15 years of working together. Finding somebody like that is so impactful, not just from the perspective of having a stable employee, but also just in personal life.

You know, when I think of my boys, I think of them meeting women that they're going to maybe potentially marry. I think of the personality, I think of other things. But one of the things I think about is, you know, what's going to happen if you marry somebody who maybe has a different. I'm going to use the word constitution. I don't know if that's the right word, but like somebody who gets sick a lot, somebody who has a weak immune system, somebody who has personal issues and disability. And while I empathize with individuals who are suffering and going through some of those challenges, I also look at, you know, what are my boys going to be facing, whether it be heaven forbid them dealing with it or them having feelings for somebody who's like that. Have you been in situations business-wise where you hire somebody who's an amazing therapist, but they're just always sick. They're always out. They're always unable to perform.

not to that extent luckily so far um what about you're a sports guy uh oh yeah of course of course um by the way just some of the things that you're talking about like there's some things that are maybe out of our control and then some things that are controllable but in terms of like showing up early showing up on time uh not bringing your personal challenges into work like not bringing your you know if your spouse you and your spouse or your family have an argument or something and like that's the way i operate i don't know like just like i'm not gonna bring in some fight or some i don't know like even if it was like um something like driving, like a, I don't know, like a, like a slow driver or something like that happened outside of work. I'm not gonna bring that into work. And luckily we haven't had much of that in terms of hiring, in terms of being on teams, whether it's work teams or even baseball teams. Absolutely. We're, we're just, we're.

players just ghost a team for a while then they come back and they're like like they're expecting like to be all good literally just happened this summer with our baseball team where um our our ace pitcher uh was just gone for like two months um and there were some signs that there was an assistant coach that kind of said like once it gets hot and once the you know once it's like the summer this guy is out like he's at the jersey shore uh he's partying and turns out the assistant coach was completely correct uh and then he just came back yesterday to pitch the the do the win or go home last uh championship game and we actually lost we were in the championship and we lost but this guy was he was he was good enough in terms of performance but you could you could tell that he was a little rusty and when he's on he's like really on like no one can touch a slider he's really on and so i don't know where we're going to navigate this to like physical therapy business or healthcare but like for me with that like it's hard to respect someone who has talent, who has such great ability to contribute to a team, but then lets the team down in one or more ways, whether they're coming late, they ghost the team for a while, they're not answering text messages, they're saying that they got enough, so many little stories around that, but yeah, there's some things that are in your control and some things that, you know, health-wise may be out of your control, but it's the things that are in your control, like we talked about before, like, you know, sleep and, you know, all the things that you could do to optimize your health to best participate with your team, whether it's a sports team, whether it's your job.

helping more patients, helping the team with the mission of impacting more patients wherever you live. So those are some things that come to mind. Yeah. So you work with a business coach. You work with 30. You've talked in the past about like interview processes, interview questions. My question to you would be one.

Do you address that? Do you have any, like some people will say, tell me about a time that, you know, you woke up, you were sick, you couldn't come to work. How did you handle that? Because they probably have a full caseload scheduled. They're going to dump all of that responsibility onto somebody else at the organization, or they're going to cancel all those people and you're going to lose basically the entire profit margin for the week. So like, are there interview questions that come into play before you hire somebody? And then the other part of that is.

And, or do you plan, do you build a system like I have in the past, built a system for somebody who, like your picture, this guy in the clinic was amazing. Everybody loved him, patients loved him, but he had a weak constitution. He was sick all the time. So I had to build a business model that supported and allowed him to come in when he was feeling good, call off when he was feeling sick without completely disrupting the entire organization. So I did that because he was good enough that I'd rather have him at his best when he was available than not have him at all.

So question number one is on the interview process, do you think about this? Do you look for this? Do you question any of this? I don't know if I question it directly because it's usually like, you know, hey, tell me about a time when you had a challenging patient. Tell me about a time when there was a miscommunication with a patient.

or tell me about a time when there was a challenge or issue that was confronted by your, where your manager or director or boss had to address, address something with you. Cause like, usually they'll be able to pull out something. You know, tell me about a time when you had a conflict with a coworker or a conflict with a patient or conflict with your clinical instructor or your boss or your manager, someone who was kind of like managing you. And with our process, 15 minute phone call, then a 60 minute zoom call. And then if they, if we continue, then it's a one hour meeting in person skills assessment. They evaluate me on the mock patient.

From those three touch points, I think you can, at least for me, it helps obviously with like interviewing more and more and more therapists. You can really get a good sense of someone, I believe, in those three touch points. Sometimes in the past two years or so, two, three years, after the mock evaluation, sometimes I will, depending on multiple reasons, we might go out. Like maybe I tell the therapist like, hey, there's this great place nearby or I'm hungry. And hey, like, are you, you know, if it's around lunchtime or whatever, then I'll say, hey, you want to like grab it? You want to grab some food? It's on me. Like grab some lunch nearby. I like this place nearby or whatever.

And then it's even more minutes of me observing how they just interact. Like, do they try to hold the door for someone else? Do they say thank you or no thank you or yes, please, whatever. Just like simple little things to the waiter or waitress. How do they navigate all that? And then now, if that's the potential fourth touchpoint, it's like a lot of minutes of how they just, how they interact. And you, Tony, know, and we all know that they're on their best behavior at the beginning of this whole interview process. So it's never, this is what Sturdy helps me with. They are never going to be better.

then that first three or four touch points for us, never. So it's like now when you interview more and more therapists, it doesn't matter if it's therapist or anyone else, any other type of potential employee or team member, they're never going to be better than that. So it's like, it needs to be like a heck yes to hire them. And if it's on the fence, like it's probably not the right fit or it's probably like someone who, yeah, like there could be challenges. So in terms of finding out, do they call out a lot or.

they're not gonna be reliable. It is a little bit challenging, but that's when you triangulate, like, do they, do they show up on time for the call? Do they answer right away? Do they, uh, and here, here's an example really quick. So maybe a month ago I had a 50 minute phone, phone screen, like the first step of our process, a 50 minute phone screen with a candidate that I had DMed on LinkedIn. We scheduled the time. I called the individual at, I don't know, it was 11 AM. I called the individual at 11 AM. They don't answer. I send the individual cause I like to over communicate. I send the individual a text and I think an email.

or LinkedIn DM. Like two touch points. I'm like, hey, we had a call scheduled for 11 a.m. I just called you and left a voicemail. But then I'm over communicating by saying I'm putting this in text and or email form so that now there's a paper trail of that, right?

The individual calls me back, I think like six to eight minutes later, which is already too long, like already too many minutes beyond. So already I'm like, this person's gonna have to like really jump over the high bar here to like wow me to even go to the next step, which would be a 60 minute Zoom interview. The point of this first phone call, the 15 minute phone call is to make sure and confirm, does it make sense for me to even invest, for me and you to even invest more time the next one hour on a Zoom call. The potential therapist calls me back at 1106 or 1108 or whatever. Already I'm like past four or five minutes, like that's not a good sign.

And guess what, Tony? I hear them driving. I hear the windshield wipers go in and I go, I'm sorry, I'm a little, maybe I'm out of line here. Are you driving right now? And they're like, yeah. And then I go, yeah, hey, I'm sorry. I mean, I didn't have this in like the booking of when you booked this with my county link.

because I didn't think I need to even say it. But when I do these calls, myself and the candidate, I don't do these calls when one of us is driving or a noisy background, not on a noisy New York City corner, not in a Starbucks. That sounds like green eggs and ham, not on a train, not on a plane. Yes, yeah. And so I said, yeah, I'm sorry, I don't do these calls if the candidate is driving, like I'm distracted. Maybe you could be distracted. I don't want you to be a distracted driver. And the therapist was like, oh, no, no, it's all right. It's all right. And I go, oh, no.

that's fine that you're okay with it. I'm not okay with it because I don't think that it's, I think it's hard for you to be all in on this phone call because in this 15 minute block, this is potentially the future of your career and you're not looking at it that way. And so we ended it and I said, Hey, best of luck. Take care. Um, this is, you know, the end of the road for us. I wish you all the best and, you know, thanks for reaching out or I guess I reached out, but thank you for scheduling the call. But I don't think this is a, I don't think this is the right fit. And, uh,

be well and take care. And we ended the phone call. And so it's like, that is so wild. Like these days, like, and even though my son's going to grow up around like all this technology and stuff, like I'm going to bake in, I'm going to hammer the importance of all of that. That if you are serious enough to interview with someone, why in the world would you schedule it when you're like on the go? Like you obviously are not serious. And then the therapist is kind of saying like, no, no, it's all good. Like basically they're saying that they are serious, but guess what? The rest of the world is not really going to judge that to be serious. Does that make sense? It makes sense. So now my question to you is,

To you, that was a lesson learned. Like in your mind, you're like, I can't believe he even considered multitasking when we're doing this interview. In his mind, he was like, what's the big deal? I'm just going to answer a bunch of questions. We're going to talk like, who cares? My, for you though, moving forward, lesson learned.

Now, do you communicate that to future candidates? Hey, this is an important meeting between us. I want you to be focused. I want you to be in on it. Don't drive. Don't do this. Don't watch kids in the background while you're talking to me. Or do you leave that information out, that context to see what they would do naturally? I think leaving it out is what a lot of employers would consider doing because they want to see what this person does naturally. But I think that's a bad strategy because

you're setting them up for failure effectively. It's like, I'm not going to tell you what the expectation is. You need to meet the expectation or exceed it without even knowing. And the expectation is totally in my mind. I don't like that kind of interview, but I'm just curious what you, what you're doing moving forward. So I'll have to check. Maybe I can check it as we're talking about my Calendly link. So right now I send someone a link and they grab a 15 minute call slot and it should say some instructions. I know for sure. Cause the next step is a separate link through my Calendly link or calendar where they can book a time for the 60 minute zoom call. And that absolutely has instructions, the zoom call. Cause it's like,

Please be in a quiet place with solid wifi. Please check your wifi before the zoom call. I suggest earbuds, headphones, headset, although it's not required, but for audio purposes, that's optimal. Screen at eye level with a light or, you know, light or window facing you. So it says it for the zoom call. Yeah. It might not for the intro phone call, but maybe, you know what? I don't know. Like there's, there's pros and cons, but it's like the historically, like the right fit for us. Yeah. It's just, it's just not, they're just not going to ever consider taking this phone call.

in the subway with a screeching train in the background, five feet away or whatever, you know, or on a busy corner with cabs beeping and cars beeping and people shouting. So I think there's pros and cons. Yeah, I agree. Again, this is the best that they will. behave ever in the beginning of the interaction in the beginning of the interview process so with this therapist in the car and it was like kind of like it was not that it wasn't subtle it was like i hear the road i hear the windshield wipers i mean not that i have you know any significant type of levels of hearing like anything different than anyone else so um in my opinion that therapist just was like ah like whatever and not taking it seriously enough and so That's a huge flag. But the ones that start with us and the ones that stay with us would never do that. That's the thing. So it's like, if we put it as a heads up, maybe some of the bad fits slip through maybe. And maybe that's not a good thing.

Well, and that's how my business evolved. You know, I go back to the first probably five or six years that we started the business. I was in the mindset of, I don't want to taint the pool. I want to see what they do naturally. I want to see what their behavior is, what their core values are. It was all about them kind of proving to us that they're a good fit for the organization. They're going to fit the culture. Then as things kind of migrated toward, well, wait a minute, I don't need these guys to be my best friend. We're not hanging out at happy hours anymore. I'm not going out with the crew anymore. The business was growing. Locations were opening.

Now it's like, no, I don't care about any of that stuff. This is what I want. This is the expectation. Now you make the decision candidate. Are you going to fit this or are you not? You know, and I think it's interesting that you've said it a couple of times. The interview is the best they're ever going to be. They're putting their best foot forward. What's interesting to me about that, and I don't think I ever thought about this. I've been saying on the AI side of things, AI is never going to be worse than it is today. It's like the polar opposite of what we're looking at. You know, it's like I buy a bar of gold.

It's just going to be more expensive in the future. I run ads today. They're just going to be more expensive in the future. But when we're talking about staff, when we're talking about employees, it shouldn't be that way, though. Like, don't you say you are a better therapist today than you were 15 years ago? Yes, but we're not talking about clinical skills. We're talking about behavior and how you're handling yourself. Theoretically, you would be a better person as you gain life experience, as you grow and mature. Yes. Theoretically, it sounds great and it makes sense. However, we're talking about behavior.

And when people get comfortable six months in 12 months in whatever to a job, they let their hair down. They get more comfortable. Maybe they say things that are, you know, off, off color, or they, um, like, like what you're describing the guy that was, you know, chronically calling out for you. That was good and performed when they were there and patients probably love them. Uh, but then calling out more and more and more, whether that's PTO or on their own time, but it's still someone who is not reliable. So we're talking about behavior and behavior is something that.

The interview process typically will prompt most people to behave above their average of when they get comfortable, they will default to their natural mechanisms or their natural behavior, which might be not what they're initially demonstrating. Now on the positive side. there are the great therapists that we hire, they will be closer to like their initial behavior demonstration. Like they'll actually be able to maintain that. And it's like, that could be actually how they are. That maybe that's their ethos. That's actually their constitution. That is how they operate. And so that is the challenge. And that is why ultimately why we have so many steps in the process to make sure folks are the right fit. That would be an interesting trait or skillset to try to identify. I'm thinking back to experiences in my life. You know, you always hear about like,

marriage, obviously, you know, divorce rates, things like that. And how, as you get more comfortable with your spouse, you start to take them for granted. You started to not do the things that you did in the beginning. Um, but I, I like, I spent a lot of time in martial arts. I joined the martial arts Academy. I think my senior year in high school, I had no idea. I'd never been involved in martial arts. And I think that going through that system, as I went through the ranks, there was more responsibility placed on me. I felt that I was setting the tone for new students coming into the martial arts Academy. I eventually became an instructor. And as I'm thinking about it, I believe.

I improved, I contributed more, I added more value. I held the standard to a higher level as I rose through the ranks. And I just wonder if an employer now, you know, say I'm going out looking for a job, if there was a way for them to identify the fact that I had had that experience, I understand the pitfall of, look, when you get too comfortable, you get lazy, you start cutting corners. You know, is there a question? Is there, is there something in the interview process that that person, that hiring manager could tease out of me, whether I realize it or not to say.

I understand this tends to be the natural path. People are on their best and then they decline because they get comfortable and they get lazy. But there are also situations where people start on their best and they just get better. They actually get better as they commit more, invest more, build the organization with us. It's an interesting idea. I've never considered that when hiring, but I do think that there is an opportunity to find those individuals. This is why also we do reference checks.

But there's pros and cons, right? The cons of reference checks is that I'm going to cherry pick my three best relationships and three best people who I know are going to sing my praises, right? So what I do is I will call each reference. Usually it's during the business day on purpose. Usually they don't answer because it's a different number. I don't always text them ahead of time because here's the thing. Also taught from Sturdy. I don't want them to answer on the first call. When I call the reference, I want to leave a voicemail and I want to say, hey, Tony.

John is interviewing with us and he said that you were his manager last year or two years ago, whatever, at XYZ Physical Therapy. He's interviewing with us to be, he's a candidate for a potential job with us as a full-time W2 physical therapist. And I'm calling you to ask you, if you were going to interview him again, would you hire him? Right. And thank you very much. And that's it. So now the call to action is, they will only call me back if they were going to hire, if they would hire that person, that therapist again.

If they don't call back, then we say to the candidate, well, you know, I called Tony and I left him a voicemail and I haven't heard back. So now the candidate John needs to nudge Tony and say, hey, Tony, like, you know, I want to, I want to move forward with this practice. And, you know, can you, can you call Dave Kittle back at this phone number? He said he left your voicemail and then that'll make, it's just, it's trying to get more signals. It's just trying to get more signals around this candidate. And so if you do that with two or three people, then if, when I do get them on the phone, then of course, usually they're going to say like, oh yeah, like, of course I would hire them again or whatever. And so I say on the phone, like,

Listen, like when we do these reference checks, like everyone is always like, you know, it's all good and easy peasy. And like, they were great. Everyone says the candidate is great. There's gotta be one thing where they can improve. What's the, what's the one thing that they can improve on? And if they go clinical, I always want to push them to like the behavioral, right? So like, I leave it kind of open format, but I want them to say something like, and that's when, if they say something like your guy that you previously, or your therapist that you previously had.

that was you know kind of late or not taken seriously or calling out a lot whatever i i would want to i would want to try to get that pulled out of the reference check because the reference check might say like oh yeah they were great and they were you know patients love them and they were always about learning and blah blah blah so i always want to say like you know listen on these calls like it's almost like a formality come on like let's be honest here i kind of make it like a joke like listen i get on these calls and like obviously the candidate i would do the same thing the candidate cherry picks like the three best the three best people the three best relationships that they know it's going to be a glowing reference and so um get what's one or two things where you would believe that they have like areas of like needs improvement. Just like very open-ended. So then they might say, maybe it's clinical. Maybe it's confidence with patients. Maybe it is showing up early or maybe it's being more efficient with evals and visits and the visits are going over time, whatever. So whatever those things are, then you want to kind of triangulate that behavioral thing or that clinical, whatever that thing is. And then you want to try to find it with those other two reference check calls. And then, you know, if you have the time and I think it's always worth it.

can you can you find someone who's adjacent who's not on the reference list but someone who worked with that person but they but the candidate didn't give you that name and use LinkedIn use Facebook whatever um if you can find someone who was even a co-worker like just another staff therapist you might be able to find out from them because now that person doesn't have like the onus to give like a glowing review. Cause they might just be, they might, they might be a little bit more honest because they're not on the reference list. So that, that's another thing. Again, it takes some time and effort. It depends on how much time and effort you have and how serious you are about the whole interview process. But to answer your question, I don't know if there's like a direct question, um, again, for the same type of thing.

So let me ask you one more aspect to this from your perspective as the business owner. There are businesses that view themselves as a platform for growth for their clinicians. They put a ton of time in, effort in, they train their people, they bring everything they can resource-wise into helping that employee be the best possible professional they can be. There's the other aspect of the business where it's, I'm not hiring you to educate you and train you and teach you and improve you and do all of these things for you. I'm hiring you.

to come with those things. I want you to be better than me so that I can put you into that role and you do the things that I can't do. Where do you fall? And I'm going to call it a spectrum. Where do you fall on that spectrum? Because I see you putting a ton of time and effort and money into training and educating and improving as opposed to maybe being the business who's looking to hire the professional who's better, smarter, faster, you know, better looking, younger, richer than you and putting them into that position.

I'm certainly open to, and I'm becoming more and more open to maybe hiring like newer grads and kind of investing the time and effort for them on the clinical improvement or the navigating like our whole model, like out of network and demonstrating value and trying to get, you know, doing pre and post tests and trying to demonstrate like clinical, like effectiveness, like getting more patient buy-in to the plan of care and getting a therapist comfortable with our premium dollar amounts and visit, like the eval visit and packages and programs and multi-thousand dollar programs and all that. But a lot of it is I'm looking for therapists that have a lot of that already.

And then it's like, I just need to tweak them a little bit with like, Hey, like you're actually going to be where you worked usually is like in network typically, or like Medicare Part B home visits where those therapists literally never had to talk about money. Money was never a thing. They never had any rejection because some patients would just stop coming and ghost them. But there were so many new patients all the time that like the therapist never really cared about it. And with us being like lower volume, because we're more premium, um, you maybe feel it a little bit more. Maybe you realize like, oh wow, this is like a little bit more challenging. Um, this is definitely more unique. So in general, the therapist that we've kind of hired the past year or two.

have already had a lot of those things. They've already had the confidence, the clinical experience, they're well-behaved, they're professional, they're prompt, all that type of stuff. But I'm open to maybe having, you know, more of my time and effort in filling up their cup, like kind of coaching them more, mentoring them more if they're younger, if they're a little more like newer in the field. And they, but the thing is they have to have, typically it helps in this situation. Let's say someone's like three years out of school. So I haven't really hired someone that was just three years out of school, maybe ever. And so that I can recall.

If someone's three years out of school, I need them though, to have been frustrated with like an in-network model where they were treating 15 to 25 or 30 or whatever patients a day. I need them to be, I need them to have experienced that either on a rotation or at their first job. I need to hear from them that they don't like that, that they don't, they want more time. They want less notes, less patience, all that. So then it's, then it's like really easy. It's like, well, here's what our model looks like. And it's, there's a safety net. There's a, there's a, there's a base salary and there's weekly performance pay. And oh, and here's some pay stubs and here's some figures from some of our therapists and here's what they're making.

you know four five six seven thousand dollars every two weeks uh so it's pretty even pre-tax you know or after tax it's pretty good really good uh and so i'm open to it but generally who we hire it's like they're already bringing that to the table and they're kind of plugging that into our system because they want to unplug from the other systems like the network or all that Yeah, makes sense. I think we historically had always been on the new grad side, like right out of school. I don't want you to have any clinical experience. I don't have any baggage. I don't want you to have any of that. And I was looking for people more. And I've said this candidly to the person I'm hiring. I'm like, look, you've got the personality that I'm looking for. You've got the core values that I'm looking for. You don't have the experience and the clinical skill. I would rather get you on the team for two years, help you develop the clinical skill because that stuff's easy.

Take the benefit of your personality and your core values, and then move on. Like, then you go, then you go to the next level. You go to the bigger, the newer, the different organization. I always kind of viewed myself as a residency, even though we weren't a formal residency. And I was totally fine with that because I enjoyed teaching. I enjoyed the engagement, the interaction. It made me better. It kept me kind of on my toes and like them asking questions. But I think what happened for us was there was a gradual shift. And I don't know if this is a demographic, a generational thing. The candidates that we were interviewing and talking to, they didn't think they needed to learn anything. And so I was getting to the point where I was like, well, I can't force you to want to learn the stuff that I think is important.

And if you think you already know everything, you're beyond what I can offer. So just go work somewhere else, you know? And I think for us, because we always say like, know the business you're in, the delivery of service was not the business we were in when we were growing. We were in the business of taking young, eager clinicians who wanted to learn and gain experience while getting paid and prepare them for their next big opportunity. And when that dried up for us, and I felt like when I talked to a therapist about an intervention and they were just blowing me off because they felt like they already knew it. I was like, that's it. I'm done.

There's nothing of value that I could offer here. And that's when we basically stopped hiring. That's when we basically said that opportunity is no longer available to us. Let's just cash in on what we've got, the delivery of service and not even bother trying to hire new clinicians. And that fundamentally, you know, was the death of that business, even though technically the LLC and the name Total Therapy persisted, we never really found an opportunity to grow the business anymore.

Interesting. Let me ask you. So you said, Jeremy, who you have there, PTA has been with you for 15 years. So the way you were kind of approaching any of the hiring, even the therapists and the PTAs and other folks that have come and gone. Do you recall, I know it's 15 years ago, it's a long time ago. Do you recall when you interviewed Jeremy, was there anything in the first several interactions in whatever your interview process was at the time? If you can think back, which 15 years is a very long time, was there any signal or anything with like behavior or confidence or anything that stuck out then where you look back now and you're like, oh yeah, like, of course, that's why he, you know, that's why he stayed here or that's why he, patients love him.

Is there anything there that maybe you can look at and say that's a potential signal for maybe other practice owners to try to notice or catch? Yeah, we basically had three people, two PTs and Jeremy at that time. Jeremy was a student doing his clinical rotation. Now he's a physical therapist assistant in case that detail got missed. But he did his clinical rotation with us. So obviously that gives us a huge advantage to see over several weeks what his personality, his culture, what he's like. This is a second career opportunity. He came out of like, I don't know what they call it. I'm going to say youth corrections, you know, correctional institutes for kids, troubled teens, that kind of stuff.

So already kind of knowing the environments that he had been in, seeing how much he enjoyed what he's doing now in outpatient therapy. He had an athletic background, played football, like in college, did other things like that. And just the general, the other two therapists, they were PTs, who were also kind of new hires at that time. You could just see, you know, I never had a patient tell me they felt he was arrogant. Whereas with the other two DPTs, multiple patients were like, he's just so arrogant. They just think they know everything, you know, like.

They came off with this era of like, well, I'm doctor so-and-so and this is what you're going to do. And this, you know, my way or the highway kind of thing. And they were good. They were good therapists and it worked for me for a very long time and we had great outcomes with them. I fundamentally would never do the treatment they do. They would never do the treatment I do. I think both of us had a level, those DPTs and me had a level of, I respect your independence and autonomy as a professional.

But I don't think what you're doing actually does what you think it does. And I think they felt the same way about me. You know, that guy, he's too lazy. He's too, like, he doesn't care about anything. He doesn't think anything matters. But there was a mutual level of respect there. And so...

I think the difference here is, you know, Jeremy and I can look at the same condition and maybe it's because we've worked together for so long and we've been like, yeah, like this makes sense. These are the things we want to do. We kind of share the culture of there is no hard and fast rule about it. Nobody knows what's going to work. We'll try some things. We'll work out a little bit. We'll make the person feel good and functionally they're going to improve.

Whereas other clinicians, other therapists are like, no, you got to do this special test. And if this works this way and you got to do this and you got to do that. And, you know, very, very regimented and what they believe is evidence-based where I would say there is no evidence. There's no evidence to support anything that we do. We can find evidence that sham is just as effective as any of the interventions, you know, so.

I think that's why it's worked out. And we're basically the same age. We come from similar backgrounds. We have very similar values. He's basically like a brother that I get along with to that level. I trust him implicitly with everything. And I don't want to mess with that anymore. So you just hit on something values, right? That's another thing that I probably have overlooked. I haven't conveyed on these shows about the interview process. So when we have the Zoom interview.

i'm asking questions that are that i can't say to them like hey our one of our core values is like respect is like a two-way street i'm not gonna say like tell me about a time when you you know you like tell me like what does that mean to you right i i have to pull out like i'm gonna say like tell me about a time when a patient disrespected you what happened and what did you do about it or tell me about a time when a co-worker disrespected you or maybe a referring physician or a boss or a manager or a clinical instructor or ci whatever so then whatever they tell me like the the experience that they had would then relate to our core values and in the zoom interview A lot of the questions are, Because they don't necessarily know, they probably don't know yet what our core values are. So I want to ask stories and life situations on how they navigated the world, what types of challenges that you might have had. And the responses will then tell us a lot of, are their core values close enough to our core values, right? And so that, what you're describing of like, turns out Jeremy has kind of like similar values that you have. And it's like, no surprise that he's stayed with you for so long, right? Because it's not necessarily just about communication or how much he's making or whatever, but like he just likes your vibe and you guys are like closer to the same page.

and even ambitions it's one of those deals where you know you've known me long enough like there are things i could do to make more money but i'm in a comfortable place right now i prioritize time with family over more money i prioritize ease of life over more money um and i think we share that as well it's really hard to have somebody who's like i want three million dollars a year and i'm gonna do everything in my power to make it and then put that person alongside somebody who's like, I'm good with 60,000, I'm comfortable. You know, like those two personalities clash because there's different ambitions within that. I think he and I are both very comfortable with a relatively modest life and we prioritize family and other things.

Which again, when I bring somebody in who disrupts that relationship, it's not even just that I want to grow or not grow or whatever the business is. I know that if I bring another personality into the mix, there's a chance that it disrupts everything, changes everything. And things are very comfortable right now. So those are business decisions that I think we make as business owners that somebody from the outside looking in might not consider. I know we're kind of running low on time. Let's say 10 more minutes. You shared something with me that I think is interesting. Do you want to talk about that LinkedIn?

I knew you would love it. I knew you would like this. I'm going to try to bring it up while you're talking. Yeah, I'm going to pull it up as well. So this was from LinkedIn. This was a surgeon who posted, I prescribe less formal physical therapy than I did 10 years ago and my patients move better. I'm just opening up the post now. So this is a hip and knee reconstruction specialist. So right up Tony's alley. This is a lot of stuff that we've already kind of talked about. I mean, I know for sure Tony's posted about it, but there was a big, long post, big, long post talking about an article, a perspective.

Randomized study out of Brown University published in the Journal of Orthopedics talking about knee replacements and assessed them at two weeks. Then again, at six weeks, basically found no significant difference. The sample size, 248 patients were randomized. And so this physician was, and this orthopedic surgeon physician was saying that, he's not saying therapy doesn't work. He's saying that the routine prescription is not the therapy, the stratification is. That's a little higher level. But nonetheless, we've talked about this before where I think though, I think.

This is my take, and you can push back on it. I think the change of specifically hip replacement, but maybe knee replacement as well, definitely hip replacement, has been referred less to physical therapy over the last, I don't know, last five or ten years, maybe longer, but definitely a progression of less and less patients who get a hip replacement get outpatient physical therapy. Maybe they get some... home physical therapy for like just assessing walking or gate training, but not really like the manual therapy or, um, maybe they don't need it. I know Tony's going to have some, some, uh, some thoughts there, but, um, I think a lot of this was driven by the bundled payments. In my opinion, I could be wrong, but if, if a physician or health system is going to get a flat rate for the entire, the entire situation, meaning, uh, surgery, post-op visits and including the downstream outpatient physical therapy visits. And then once physicians heard that or hospital systems, maybe, uh, or physician groups, they were like, well, why would we refer out? And I'm not sure if that is the case. I could be wrong. Um,

Also, for rotator cuff repair, maybe they still do need a lot more of the outpatient therapy that Tony would do with them and that we would do with them. And so they still will prescribe and refer out for that, knowing that it cuts into their potential bundle payments. Anyway, that's a lot there, but I'll kick it back to Tony. Yeah, I think Medicare is growing or expanding the program where they basically say, we're going to expect... this much money be spent on a total knee replacement. If you're, the hospital's in charge, the hospital is local leadership. The hospital makes the decisions on, you know, who's going to see the patient for outpatient therapy, what other conditions are going to be treated. But if this hospital ends up spending more and this hospital ends up spending less and we've determined the median price is this, the hospital spends more is going to have to pay back some of that money. The hospital who spends less is going to get more of that money. Like if you go two or three layers upstream though,

we have to acknowledge the money is running out or already ran out. Like we're borrowing money to pay for healthcare costs. You know, we're borrowing money for all of these things. So Medicare itself, there's, there's less money going in than there is going out. Medicare is never going to look at increasing payments for anyone. And the same is true for all other third-party payers. So how do we, as one tiny sliver of the healthcare business, the industry, how do we show like, look, we're actually doing things to spend less, to improve outcomes, to make this more affordable.

This is where I think the research, like I said earlier, there's no good research anywhere saying physical therapy is the best thing, right? At best, it's no worse than sham, no worse than placebo. But now there's research that says, look, people who do a home exercise program at scale do just as good as people who don't. There are going to be cases. I get cases in here where the person is so freaked out. Like they're so anxious. They're so scared. They are legitimately bleeding. And, you know, they need that dressing change. They need the dressing looked at. Maybe they have a DVT. There is really something going on.

but that's a very small percentage of the total population. And when I share on my Facebook feed, how many physical therapy sessions did you do? I get people that are doing years of physical therapy two and three times a week after a typical knee replacement, you know? So like these abuses and I'm calling them for what they are of what insurance is supposed to be. I think it's getting called out. There's going to be a reckoning. And so this is where I think we have a responsibility. Let's look at what AI is good at right now.

If a home exercise program, unsupervised home exercise program has been shown to be just as effective as one-on-one physical therapy. AI is probably going to be better than that. So let's roll out some of these ideas, some of these innovations. And I still get therapists who are like, I can't believe you want AI to take our jobs. I want AI to do the stuff AI is better than me at doing. There's a lot of things AI is better than me at doing. A calculator is better than me at doing complex math. I'm going to let the calculator do it. But I think this is going to impact outpatient ortho more than any other aspect of our profession. And I think it should. I think 80, 90% of what outpatient ortho does should be wiped out tomorrow.

It is not something that insurance should be paying for. It should be out of pocket. Yeah. Yeah. It doesn't mean the patient can't do it. You know, and the people who have the argument to say, well, patients can't afford. If you put the power back in the hands of the business owner, they will build a business that patients can afford. McDonald's has built a business of feeding people at a price point they can afford. Like you just you've got to get it out of the government control. Right now, I can't deliver a Medicare visit for less than Medicare pays, even though technically I have the capacity to do it. Legally, I can't do it.

So like get the government out of that regulation. Let the private practices do what they want to do. A lot of them will go cash. A lot of them will go premium. That's awesome. But then they're going to be the big companies, the private equities that are going to bring an affordable solution out for pennies on the dollar. It's a lot. But I feel like I want to be part of the private equity that does the consolidating or the grouping or the portfolio effect of the premium options.

It makes sense for all the private equity to back all the big, you know, Ivy Rehab and Athletico and ATI and, you know, all the big guys. Most of them are PE backed to catch the, like, to have the widest net, right? To take every insurance and all that. But it's like, you could have, I mean, it's a different investment and, like, the approach is different. But knowing that you can hire almost any therapist, potentially keep any therapist in terms of compensation, have way more margin.

and then just reinvest profits back into paid media or other things like videos and stuff that you're putting out and all the other ways to attract more of those patients. I mean, there's plenty of other private equity that does back more of like the premium restaurants and other brands. So it's certainly possible. That's what I was going to ask you. So what are examples outside of healthcare where private equity or just investor money in general comes in and supports a premium service-based experience? Like I know they're rolling up plumbing businesses, they're rolling up roofing companies, they're rolling up some of those things.

But like, are there examples where they're going to come in and if the standard rate, I mean, standard rate for a roof, I'm making this up is $20,000. Is there a $50,000 roofing company that a private equity is going to come in and consolidate and roll up? I didn't think there was, I thought their sweet spot is kind of medium to low price point and just get lots of those businesses. I'm going to have to get back to that. I know that there's definitely the, the investors that back the, maybe like the middle range. Like I don't know if you've heard of like the Darden group, D-A-R-D-E-N Darden. And they, they own a bunch of brands like restaurant brands. Yeah. And those brands are not McDonald's. Um, but I would say they're definitely like mid tier. Um, I think they own bonefish grill. I think they own maybe, maybe Carrabba's like some of those types of brands. Um, because I remember getting some of those Darden gift cards and then it's like, you flip it over and you see like, I could use that, you know, five or six of these different restaurants or brands nearby. And it's like,

multiple so some of those brands are those restaurant brands are like the Maybe the $2 and $3, like what you see online was the dollar amount. They do both. They have Olive Garden, Longhorn, Cheddar's, Yard House, Bahama Breeze. But then they also have Ruth's Chris, V's Prime, Seafood. So it looks like they're at both ends. But my hunch would be that the majority of it comes from that middle tier, like you said. Majority of what? Majority of profitability and revenue. I don't think a Ruth's Chris or anything in that price point, $100 plus meals, individual meals.

I don't think that contributes as much of the profit. Maybe it's more profitable as an individual restaurant, but over the umbrella of the organization, I've got to think, and we can look into it. Olive Garden, Longhorn, those things contribute more profit in absolute terms and more revenue in absolute. McDonald's is more profit in absolute terms because it's so huge compared to even something like Chick-fil-A. Everybody wants to say, oh, Chick-fil-A does 2 million per location and McDonald's does less or whatever the number is. But in absolute terms, there's a whole lot more McDonald's than there are Chick-fil-A.

Almost 40 or 38,000 extra locations. More than Chick-fil-A. In absolute terms, I can open thousands more average physical therapy clinics that deliver an average patient care experience that isn't bad compared to a high touch point, premium, amazing, pro-level athlete physical therapy clinic because there's just way more opportunity in that pool. Okay. Yes. And as time goes by, every five years, every 10 years, with inflation and cost of living, which one becomes easier to operate?

The middle of the road one. How? When your margins are getting squeezed. How does that become easier to operate? Because you have economies of scale. You have other opportunities within the opportunity. And again, I'm speculating. I'm thinking that's what happens because I see Coca-Cola versus, you know, some champagne company. I see McDonald's versus Ruth's Chris. Like in my mind.

Looking at the entire pie, there is far more opportunity for those big businesses that are highly scalable than there is for the premium level service. But we need both. Let's do parting shots. My parting shot is always going to be, we are still, anybody watching this, I guarantee we are all still at the minuscule level where the person you bring into your organization, even if you have 100 employees already, one person can either be a cancer that kills the rest of the organization, or it can be a net. benefit that elevates the organization you have to understand who it is that you're hiring yes um oh i know so we got to wrap up but one of the examples is equinox equinox def i don't know what the investors are we'll have to look it up and we don't have time right now but we have talked about equinox recently and they are the premium option close enough to physical therapy compared to the planet fitness which is 10 20 a month equinox is what we've seen 250 350 400 a month depending on the location that is the premium option so we have to look at what are those investors who are those investors and they're absolutely investing in

Way, way more like taking longer to get their money back. And it's more of the premium option. But knowing that we recently discussed, I think it's at Equinox that their average customer is paying like, I forget what it was, like $4,000 a year. And they think in the next five years, they can go to $6,000 per year in the next five years. So it's like they have the opportunity to continue to get more of like their customer's wallet share if they're delivering value.

And Planet Fitness will not. They're going to sell $5 t-shirts and they give away free pizza. How else will Planet Fitness have more share of their customers' wallets? That is a good question. Planet Fitness has way less of an ability to have more of wallet share of their customers because they already chose the lower cost option. All right. I'll do the research. I'll bring it back. Guys, come back on Thursday, 8.30 in the morning. Dave, you have an amazing rest of your day. That's it. We're out. Boys, what the hell are you doing? Follow Tony Maritano on YouTube at Total Therapy Solution. Find Dave Kinnell at Concierge Pain Relief.com.

And hey, just a reminder, none of this was for advice. This was for entertainment only. Our lawyers say that counts. Thanks, Keith.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy?

This episode is 59 minutes long.

When was this PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy episode published?

This episode was published on August 23, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this PT Pintcast - Physical Therapy episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.