The Tragic Story of Timmy Wiltsey

Send us Fan MailWhat really happened to five-year-old Timothy Wiltsey at the carnival in South Amboy, New Jersey, back in 1991? Join us as we dissect the frantic search efforts, the initial investigation that cleared Timmy's father, George, and the devastating suspicions that fell upon his mother, Michelle Lutzinski. Through harrowing eyewitness accounts and police reports, we uncover the conflicting stories and public scrutiny that plagued Michelle, culminating in the heart-wrenching discovery of Timmy’s remains.In a shocking turn, we explore the New Jersey Supreme Court's 2021 decision to overturn Michelle Lutzinski's conviction due to insufficient evidence. As Michelle walks free after years in prison, we examine the emotional and legal ramifications of this ruling, as well as the lingering question: was true justice ever served for young Timothy Wiltsey? Tune in for a gripping episode that peels back the layers of a case that continues to haunt a community and challenge our justice system.Support the show