Skip to content
The Trojan Horse Affair - Part 2 episode artwork

Mar 18, 2022 53 min

The Trojan Horse Affair - Part 2

from Serial Hosted by Serial Productions & The New York Times

Hamza and Brian think the source of the Trojan Horse letter might be hiding in plain sight. After learning about the petty personnel dispute that probably gave rise to the letter, they’re even more bewildered about how it ever could have been taken seriously. To learn more about our shows and get a look behind the scenes, find us on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook by searching “Serial Productions”. Have a story pitch, a tip, or feedback? Email us at [email protected]. for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Hamza and Brian think the source of the Trojan Horse letter might be hiding in plain sight. After learning about the petty personnel dispute that probably gave rise to the letter, they’re even more bewildered about how it ever could have been taken seriously.

Ready to play

The Trojan Horse Affair - Part 2

0:00 53:19
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hi, I'm Solana Pine. I'm the director of video at the New York Times. For years, my team has made videos that bring you closer to big news moments, videos by times journalists that have the expertise to help you understand what's going on. Now, we're bringing those videos to you in the Watch tab in the New York Times app.

It's a dedicated video feed where you know you can trust what you're seeing. All the videos there are free for anyone to watch. You don't have to be a subscriber. Download the New York Times app to start watching.

Hamz and I are sitting behind two children's school desks. We're in the covert classroom at the front of Tahira Loms House, talking about the Trojan Horse letter, those four pages that painted Tahira as the ringleader of an extremist plot. But here clearly has strong suspicions about who wrote it. The motive was quite an interesting one.

Even though the plot wasn't real, the Trojan Horse letter still prompted authorities to investigate and ultimately dismantle the education movement to hear was leading. A successful movement, outcomes for Muslim students, had improved dramatically. The national government also beefed up counter extremism policy and tried to prevent to hear and as colleagues from ever working or volunteering in schools again, all in the aftermath of the letter. Tahira believes if they'd ever bothered just to investigate who wrote the thing, it would have been very difficult for the government to justify its actions.

Because he says it would have been obvious. The letter had nothing to do with conspiracy or with him. He's sparse on details with us this first day, but he does give us that tantalizing hint that the letter came from someone close to him. But whoever wrote the letter, they knew, you know, they knew me, I think.

Or possibly more than one person. Were they from Birmingham? Were they involved? They are from Birmingham.

They are well known to me. I know them quite well and they know me quite well too. I know them and I meet them often, you know, in an educational kind of environment and setting. Is there a reason we're playing 20 questions here?

Can we just ask you who it is? Because I'm not able to, obviously I don't want to name anyone because I can't prove that. I'll give you a clue if you read the letter, just from a literary point of view. Just read the letter and all you have to do is, who is being defended?

Just read the letter with that in mind. Who is the letter defending? Is the question you have to answer and you will arrive at your own judgment? From Serial Productions and The New York Times.

I'm Brian Reed. I'm Hundesayat. Let's see if we can figure out who wrote the Trojan Horse letter. Alright, you want to do this?

Okay, so let's move these drawers. We're going to have to drag them. We need a place to hunker down, a place to scrutinize the letter, a place to think, a place to throw names on the wall. We need a headquarters.

And for this purpose, Hamza has generously offered up his parents' bedroom. I think I'm a Thunkus. I'm a fifth of five. Hamza has been crashing into his parents' old flat here and Birmingham.

They live in Abu Dhabi these days and are planning to retire to Pakistan. So I guess they're not here that much? I hope not, because we're completely rearranging their bedroom. Oh my god.

Pushing the bed up against the closet, sliding the bureau into the corner, packing away Hamza's mom's jewelry at his insistence. You want no reminder that this is your parents' bedroom? I'm serious about this. It's headquarters.

Do you have a toolbox? Yeah. Clearly. Being in England, sleuthing for the author of a mysterious letter, alongside a doctor, was having an effect on Brian.

He was going fully into Sherlock Holmes' mode. He detached the TV from the wall and replaced it with whiteboards, a court board, a multi-colored note card which was connected with a string. Success. I don't have the hard to tell him that.

Sherlock, you don't really do the whole mode of warthink. What are you seriously going to do when your parents come? I'll just tell them to sleep in different rooms. You know what I mean?

Like really? It's cute. It's cute. It was ready.

Operation Trojan Horse didn't very carefully talk through and tried and tested with the Birmingham. Hamza sat in his parents' bed and read the letter aloud as I paced around, scribbling names and schools on the whiteboards, circling some, crossing off others. HT Springfield. Okay.

Give a moment. All right. So here it told us, read the letter and think about who is it defending. That word choice seemed deliberate.

Defending. Remember, the whole conceit of the letter is that it's written as if it's from a accomplice of Tahiras and Birmingham to a co-conspirator in another city, describing how they can start implementing this plot to hear a devised. Called Operation Trojan Horse. The author of the letter breaks the plan into five steps, all aimed at pushing out headteachers, what they call principles in Britain, so you can bring in your own leadership, who will make the school more Islamic.

You're supposed to get conservative Muslim parents to get the headteacher a hard time about classes such as sex ed, install a sympathetic governor on the governing body to basically spy on the head from there, find staff to complain about the headteacher from within the school. But the author also explains what Tahir and his co-conspirators are currently up to in Birmingham. The author names four headteachers at four specific schools, who the plotters are on the verge of successfully unseating, and explains how they're pulling it off. At one school, they'd framed the head for doctoring test scores, and now she was under investigation.

At another, they'd instigated a nasty fight over one of the headteachers' disciplinary decisions. At another, they'd accused the headteacher of fraud. These schools and headteachers named in the letter were all real, by the way, and so were the scandals the letter described, or at least the gist of them. Each of these headteachers had been in actual trouble in real life for doctoring test scores, facing allegations of fraud, etc.

What the letter claim though, was that these weren't random incidents of supposed wrongdoing. Instead, the letter claimed all these incidents were the result of the Trojan Horse conspiracy, run by Tahir alarm, and his cronies. Therefore, it was these headteachers who we think Tahir meant when he told us to consider who the letter defends. Because in real life, these four teachers really had been at risk of losing their jobs, and then the Trojan Horse letter showed up, suggesting they hadn't actually done anything wrong, that they were victims, in fact, of Operation Trojan Horse.

Presumably, one of them could have written the Trojan Horse letter to help themselves get out of trouble, so I list these hints on our detective wall. We've narrowed it down to, we've got the headteacher at Regent's Park Community School, the headteacher at Adderley, the headteacher at Saltley School, and the headteacher from Springfield School. We take a step back and stare at the board, pensively, beard-strokingly, as the cogs turn in my partner's brain. As my partner swallows his first meditative sip of a British cover.

And after about, I don't know what was it, five minutes? We had ourselves a theory about where the Trojan Horse letter came from. The letter came from Adderley Primary School. That's the most plausible theory.

I told Brian this before he came to Birmingham, but he was new to the story. He reminded me I was new to journalism, and insisted we should start by analyzing the letter with an open mind, which we did. And then we went there by Adderley Primary School. In three years we've added almost nothing new to the Motor Wall.

Sorry for the trouble, Dr. Mrs. Saya. It's not really that sophisticated.

If you read the Trojan Horse letter, show the author goes on about a grand citywide plot, but there's one score that the author seems to be obsessed with, Adderley Primary School. In the middle of the letter, the author goes on his long tangent about bizarre employment dispute between the headteacher at the primary school and four teaching assistants there, four classroom aides. The author says this employment dispute is part of the plot and describes it in excruciating detail. None of the schools get more than a few sentences devoted to them.

Relaying information you could have read in the news or online, but Adderley gets paragraph stuffed with particulars that at the time were not public, including a bunch of different characters and events. We're going to wait to read this part of the letter to you because it's so in the weeds, it's going to make a lot better sense once you know more. But for now just know that there's no mistake in whoever wrote the Trojan Horse letter had deep inside of information about this Adderley case. And we're not the first to notice this, by the way.

More than a year after the Trojan Horse letter was made public, this employment dispute won in front of a judge. And in this decision, the judge said undoubtedly whoever wrote the letter had intimate knowledge of the allegations going through the heart of this case. What are your thoughts regarding that quote? In our first interview, I actually read the here, the slime from the judge, because even though he wouldn't come out and say explicitly where he thought the letter came from, I suspected he was talking about Adderley.

The quote is very insightful and very accurate. Okay. I think the judge there has made a good observation. So, okay.

Adderley. To hear his pointing there, this judge independently up to hear his pointing there, when you just read the letter as a lay person, your head goes there. But who, at Adderley? And why?

Well, let us tell you the perplexing story of what happened at that school. It begins not too differently from the story of Parkview, with a troubled school in East Birmingham, and an ambitious new leader who comes in determined to turn the school around. Adderley Primary School is about a mile from Parkview, on an industrial edge of the same neighborhood, Alum Rock. It's a red brick Victorian building inside a spiky blue fence.

It's a big school, almost 600 students, twice the size of an average state primary school, and for a long time it had a reputation for having a volatile staff difficult to manage. In seven years, it had been through nine head teachers, which wasn't good for the students. Offstep, the agency that had been in specks, sprinted schools, had labeled Adderley inadequate, failing. In 2008, the Birmingham City Council turned to, among others, to hear, for help.

By then to hear, had a reputation for revitalizing schools, and the council asked him to apply the Parkview formula at Adderley. He joined the Adderley governing body, which went searching for a new head teacher for the primary school. And they found someone they were excited about. A Muslim woman, who'd been a deputy head teacher at another East Birmingham majority Muslim primary school, which under her team's leadership, had vastly improved.

Her name was Rosavana Dar. To hear so she was a standout candidate. She was very ambitious. She was very passionate as a person.

She came across as being very child centric as well. In other words, children's interest comes first, rather than, let's keep some teachers happy and just keep the unions happy, which is part of the dynamics in schools. But she came across as being somebody who would put the children's interest first. That came first very strongly to me.

You won't be hearing from Miss Wannadar. She's declined to talk to us. But we're able to tell you what went down between Mrs. Dar and the teaching assistants, because they ultimately ended up in a knockdown dragout legal fight over this, in an employment tribunal, which means we've been able to read pages and pages of exhibits and witness statements and legal briefs, and the resulting judgment.

All of which sets out their competing versions of what happened. The people we have spoken to, who know or have worked with Rosavana Dar, nearly every one of them says she was super impressive. She has a genius mind. There's no question about it.

Rosavana for us is one of the locals to hear recruited into teaching. He lost his job after the government accused him of wrongdoing in the treasure horse affair. Rosavana worked under Rosavana Dar at Adderley as an assistant head, before they had a falling out, and Rosavana moved on to another school. Peanut Rosavana were close.

It wasn't that she was really good at one thing. She was really good at everything she did. She was really good at training teachers. She was really good at monitoring.

She was really good at planning. She was really good at assessing curriculum development. I've learned more from her in the career of teaching than anybody else. Rosavana Dar, Riz as lots of people call her, was a big part of the reason Rosavana Darley took a position at Adderley.

She was exciting to work for her. She was tireless. Rosavana says sometimes she showed up at 5 or 5.30 in the morning and leave at 10 at night. And she implemented many of the same kinds of changes that Tahir's recruits had at Parkview.

High academic standards, inspiring lack of days of staff, getting parents involved, making religious accommodations. And it was working within just a few years off the school inspectors raised Adderley from its lowest ranking to the second highest. They credited Mrs. Dar as a head teacher, a quote, great vision and energy.

But this is where the story at Adderley takes a turn for the unusual. Because a very peculiar series of events began developing at the school, the details of which would become an important part of the Trojan horse letter. One day in December 2012, about a year before the letter surfaced, Mrs. Dar calls a teaching assistant named Hillary Owens into her office.

We've heard some people involved in schools describe teaching assistants as quite frankly a nuisance, resistant to reforms and a drain on resources. And there are strong unions in the UK, so it's hard to just up and fire someone because you don't get along. But according to Mrs. Dar, her experience with Hillary Owens was on another level.

In a witness statement, Mrs. Dar describes Ms. Owens as rebellious and emotional, an employee who would take to quote, throwing her arms in the air, crying, lying on the floor or spreading herself across the table when she didn't get her way. One big disagreement between Mrs.

Dar and Hillary Owens was over the classroom Ms. Owens had been assigned to. There were specific grades and teachers Hillary Owens felt comfortable with, and she got in a health assessment saying it'd be better if the school could accommodate those preferences. When Mrs.

Dar didn't accommodate that, by Ms. Owens' own account she started weeping in a staff room, which led to her taking leave of absence, which meant the school had to pay her even when she wasn't coming in. And then came that day in December. Hillary Owens was back at work, and according to Mrs.

Dar's telling, Mrs. Dar finds an envelope in her mail company. It's a letter from Hillary Owens, tendering a resignation. Yemas Owens is still coming to work like everything's normal, so Mrs.

Dar calls Ms. Owens into her office. Hillary Owens sits down, and Mrs. Dar says, I've received her letter of resignation, I accept it.

Can I have your key fob please? You're free to go. To which Hillary Owens responds, what letter of resignation? I didn't write a letter of resignation.

I haven't resigned. Hillary Owens also declined to do an interview with us, but we have a recording of her describing this moment to the police. Yes, the police would eventually get involved. I said, but I have written a letter of resignation, and she said, you're now on guard and leave, I need your security fault.

Guard and leave is administrative leave, basically, when you're on your way out from a job. And I thought, did she hear what I said? She clearly didn't because she carried on talking. And I kept saying to her, but I haven't written a letter of resignation, I haven't signed a letter of resignation, I haven't given you a letter of resignation.

May I see the letter? She said, I don't have it. And she said, I need your security fault, which I was wearing my neck. I said, you may have this fault if I can see my signature on that letter.

And she said, this meeting is over. And with that, Mrs. Dar got up and stood by the door. It's pretty strange in it.

Get this though. Just a few days before this meeting with Hillary Owens, this also laid down the court records. Mrs. Dar says she received three other resignation letters from three other teaching assistants at Adley Primary School.

They were employees Mrs. Dar also had a difficult run with. They were three Muslim women who lived near the school and had worked there a long time. Like Hillary Owens, they weren't keen on Mrs.

Dar and the changes she was making to school. They too had been fighting with the head teacher for many months. And by this time in December 2012, we're all on paid leave due to work-related stress. When Mrs.

Dar received resignation letters from these three TAs, she quickly brought back to them at their home saying, I'm accepting your resignation, but to luck with your future. Each of the three TAs replied, what are you talking about? Where am I resigned? Paid to be a broken record here.

We'd love to hand the story after those TAs, but they've also declined to talk to us. So, to the court files. These TAs were named Raheenahanam, Shanazbibi and Yasmin Nachthar. They were close, two of them were sisters, one had sent their kids to Adley.

And Hillary Owens was friendly with them, sometimes she'd give one or the other left home. When they learned they were all in a similar predicament, they've asked them they resigned, they started coordinating. The TAs asked for a copy of the resignation that is they were supposed to have sent, and when Mrs. Dar provided them, they said someone had fabricated these letters and forced their signatures.

Mrs. Owens is forensic about this and her interview with the police. A cop shows that the letter supposedly signed by her. I was not my signature.

First thing I said was not my signature. Is it similar to yours? No. No.

It's not at all. The A is wrong. The C is wrong. The O is wrong.

The S is completely wrong. The A is wrong. It's not even close. I don't understand.

So, four of her aspiring DARS employees were insisting someone had forged their resignation letters. But Mrs. Dar, as she later explained in a witness statement, still believed the letter were authentic. Despite what her employees were saying, she refused to let them come back to work.

At which point, the TAs came to the conclusion that Mrs. Dar must have been behind this. What did you make of that story? Well, I mean, that was completely amazed because it seemed quite far fetched really, the notion that a head teacher forges resignation letters.

You couldn't imagine a head teacher going to those lengths. Jackie Hughes used to be assistant director for school improvement for the Birmingham City Council. When this resignation focus happened, she left that job. But Adley was a school she knew well, and Hillary Owens came to see her for advice.

She was just so adamant over and over again. Restar has lied. She has treated us very, very badly. We did not write those letters.

And the head teacher didn't want them in the school. That they were part of the old guard from the previous head. And that she was making up stuff solely to get rid of them so she could have her own people. I thought that was quite plausible because that's, you know, does happen, doesn't it?

But how about faking resignation letters? That is just the bit that is completely bizarre. Have you come up with an explanation for the bizardi? Erm, it strikes me, Reis likes to write the script for everybody.

You see, I like Reis very much as a person. However, she was quite ruthless in getting her own way and making sure that her school, and it would be hers, got the outcome she wanted. Some of the same people who told us that Mrs. Darwin was brilliant, who ordered what she'd accomplished, lifting Adley out of its academic abyss.

They also saw a flipside to her ambition. His former assistant head was one for ours again. Every single classroom had to look the same. The board had to look the same.

Every single book had to look the same. You know, there was a level of control down to that detail. Control-free, slave driver. These are some of the words people who know Reis Wannadar have used to describe it to us.

As Wannad says, she would monitor the most menial or employees tasks, the way workbooks needed to be collared by a subject. The margin-sized staff was supposed to be printing with. She would say, yeah, pencils need to be all together. They cannot be mixed with pens.

This is a real example. Yeah, absolutely. It would be very, very dictatorial. She would be aware of this, like a head teacher.

She would scrutinise. And she would like, micron to school, inspect anything. And expect the leadership team to do the same. You go to some head teachers offices, and you can tell they belong to a particular head teacher, but they're obviously places of work.

Dave Hughes was a member of the Adley Covening Body that hired Mr. Starr. He's an experienced governor, who served for decades on the Covening Body of Schools throughout Birmingham, including a Parkview with the hair. There's also married to Jackie Hughes, who sit next to him, eyeglasses hanging around her neck, nodding her head.

There might be a family photograph or something, but you tell this place to work a professional place. Reis's office was like an extension of her home. Lots of personal belongings in there, as well as professional stuff pinned on the wall. The whole school had the feeling of not being an independent institution which she was leading, but her thiefdom was how it felt to me.

Yeah, no, I didn't go away. Do you think that's wrong? Exactly right, yeah. Which is why I think she could be capable of doing whatever's necessary to protect that thiefdom.

Mrs. Starr saw the four TAs as a threat to her job. That's clear from the court files and her witness statements. She said they were miserable during the workday, constantly fighting her.

Reis wanted to start getting a lot of grief from parents about how she was running the school, in particular more orthodox parents. People Mrs. Starr referred to in the litigation as Salafee Muslims. Salafism is a conservative interpretation of Islam.

Groups of parents started sending in complaints or showing up at school to raise a stink. Efforts to which Mrs. Starr seemed coordinated. She knew the Muslim TAs at connections in the nearby Salafee community, and thought they were riling up these parents on purpose.

She also blamed Salafee parents for spreading rumors about her personal life, weaponizing the fact that she wasn't married at the time, and didn't wear a hijab. Mrs. Starr writes about this in her witness statements. I regularly stand in the playground, welcoming the children in the morning, or waving them off in the afternoon.

As I do so, I receive a high level of insults from parents. In response to my good morning, they call me bitch and slag and tell me I'm not a good Muslim, not a good enough role model for their children, due to not covering my head, that I should be married, that my clothes were inappropriate, and I was too modern and too Western. We haven't talked to anyone from Adderley who observed the abuse of behavior directly, but in witness statements, members of Mrs. Starr's leadership team say they saw behavior like this, and that the TAs were behind the bullying.

But the TAs say that Mrs. Starr was the real bully. They, along with a few other colleagues, lodged formal grievances against her through their union for bullying, intimidation, and harassment. The TAs claim that they were, quote, constantly undermined and belittled by Mrs.

Starr, and that some of them had to seek medical help and go on medication. These grievances were significant and serious. They had the potential to cost Mrs. Starr her job, and notably it was shortly after the TAs had filed these grievances that Mrs.

Starr informed them that they had resigned, that she had received resignation letters from them. According to the TAs, it was these official grievances. That's why Mrs. Starr was so desperate to get rid of them.

The TAs tried everything they could think of to get their jobs back. They contacted the Birmingham City Council. They contacted the representatives in Parliament. They made a declaration in front of a magistrate, asserting that they did not write the letters.

They filed a report with the police. None of it was working. They asked for advice around the neighbourhood. They said they wanted the job back, they wanted to leave and they were forced to resign.

So John Ochrehm used to be a teacher at Adderley, and he'd also been involved with hiring Mrs. Starr. He lives around the corner from one of the TAs. Were they upset?

They were upset. They were upset. They were upset, they were upset, they felt they were on. The last legs and legs had no ground to retain their jobs.

They were losing their jobs. So I said, the best advice I can give you is going to sit here. To hear was the guy you went to when there was a problem with the school in East Birmingham. Plus he helped recruit Rizvana Dard at Adderley.

I said, look, speak to hear. He would be able to help you because he's obviously in the know about legislation. I didn't know the truth about suspect, but I said, look, if anybody's got some influence over Rizvana, would sit here because they were respected. The women approached to hear.

Though to hear tells us he doesn't really remember much about it. He says he bumped into one of the TAs of the grocery store, and she explained a bit about the situation. But he says he doesn't recall it going any further than that. One organization did intervene for the TAs, their union.

Their rep was firing off emails to Birmingham City Council, which is Rizvana Dard's employer, saying that Mrs. Dard had, quote, fabricated the charade, and that in all her years, the representative had never seen someone more drunk on power. That's a quote, than Rizvana Dard. Until finally, the Birmingham City Council stepped in and instructed Mrs.

Dard that she should not terminate the TAs employment. The council warned her in a letter that if you treat these resignations as valid, and the employees sue the school for wrongful termination, we won't defend Adderley. We will not pay for your lawyers or any damages you're liable for, like the council normally would for one of its schools. You'll be on your own.

And Mrs. Dard, she ended the women's employment anyway. To no one's surprise, the TAs brought a case against Adderley Primary School for unfair dismissal, and the Birmingham City Council did exactly as it said it would. It left the school on the hook to pay for its own defense, and for any potential damages if the TAs won their case.

Mrs. Dard plowed ahead. And the defense Adderley Primary School submitted ahead of the hearing, with certainly novel. Daniel Zakis, a solicitor who represented one of the TAs, Hillary Owens, remembers when he read Adderley's argument.

Now he said that that case was that all four of the claimants engaged in, of course, the Condits over a period of years to undermine the teacher, and that their resignations were part of a plot. These four people, including Hillary, were part of a plot to undermine Rizvana Dard. To convert the school to one by some strict Muslim-sleece teachings. Salafi, being that more conservative interpretation of Islam, the interpretation Mrs.

Dard said, the parents from the TAs were whipping up against her, subscribed to. Daniel Zakis thought, that's an odd accusation to make about classroom aids at a primary school. And especially about his client, Hillary, who attended Engle in church every Sunday. Adderley's defense filing doesn't use the word plot, but that is what it describes.

The school's lawyers wrote that the resignation letters, quote, have been used as a contrived and malicious means of falsely creating a scenario which would bring into question the head teacher's reputation. In other words, the TAs had schemed together to all submit resignations and then pretend that Mrs. Dard forged them to get her in trouble. To say that they all resign, genuine resignations, they then all denied that they've resigned.

And that would then close up rule. It's not the greatest plot. Bear in mind, everything we've been talking about up to this point, this whole resignation dispute, that all happened before the Trojan horse had existed. So when Adderley's legal team filed his defense in spring 2013, this was the first Hillary Owen Solicitor was hearing about an Islamic plot in a Birmingham school to undermine a head teacher.

As a hearing day approached, handwriting expert was brought into analyser signatures on the disputed resignation letters, and the expert concluded that the TAs' signatures were, in fact, not authentic. They had been forged. By the month of the hearing, November 2013, Adderley's defense was looking pretty strained. Mrs.

Dard was facing the real prospect of the school losing the case. And it was that month that someone claiming to be an anonymous whistleblower forwarded the Trojan horse letter to the Birmingham City Council. Adderley apparently had written from one shadow we can spare it to another, describing a plot to our head teachers and majority Muslim schools. Adderley outlined the process of taking down a head teacher in five steps.

Step one, identify a poor performing school based in a Muslim area of town. Step two, quote, select a group of Salafi parents. Adderley is very specific about this. The parents should be Salafees.

The goal is to get these Salafi parents, quote, fired up and ready to give the head teacher a very difficult time on a daily basis. If you can get them to be very vocal on the playground, with a drop off or pick up their children, that will stir up other parents, end quote. Step three, put your own governor on the governing body. Step four, identify key staff to disrupt the school from within.

Hereto the letter is very specific. The best people for this job are TAs, because, quote, they are less educated and from the local community, so are much more easily influenced. The letter continues, quote, it is also important but possible to ensure you have an English face amongst the world. End quote.

It's played from the context the letter doesn't mean my type of English face. It means a white person, because according to the letter, this person can give coming to the fact that Muslim TAs are part of religious conspiracy. And finally, step five, start a campaign where you complain to authorities about the head teacher, including the city council and your local MP. If you're hearing those five steps and thinking, Adderley, you're not the only one.

And that's not even the part of the Georgia horse letter that's directly about Adderley. The Adderley part is a good half of page and it's about this specific resignation case. The author includes it as one of the main examples of how the plot is maneuvering against head teachers. Listen to how closely Adderley's defense in the case.

Mrs. Dar begins, is not a good Muslim and was not open to our suggestions of adhering to strict Muslim guidelines. She's very procedurally strong and so, we had to find a reason for her to be sacked into procedures. Three of our Muslim sisters and a governor have been disrupting the school and causing issues in Mrs.

Dar since she took over the school. These sisters are a great example of what can be achieved by only three people. They, along with an English woman, who is their close friend, have raised an allegation of fraudulent resignation letters against the head. Even though they actually write the letters themselves.

From there, the Georgia horse letter goes on to give a meticulous account of what happened with the resignation. How and where the T.S. drafted them, how they arranged to have them delivered. This account lines up exactly with the claims made in the employment case.

It ends with an explanation of Hillary Owens' unique role in the Salafi plot. As the English woman dropped her letter off in the head staff box, it adds another angle of fraud against the head. And because she's English, she'll take the focus off the other Muslim sisters. If all goes wrong, everyone is briefed.

I will blame the English woman for planning and implementing the whole campaign to cause disruption amongst the Muslim staff and the Muslim head teacher. That's how the Georgia horse letter describes what was going on at a day. That supports staff at a primary school, three aunties from East Birmingham, and a Christian native from the Berbs, were in reality secret agents, conspiring with extremists as part of a broader side of the conspiracy to take down Riswannadar. It's incredible really.

The Georgia horse letter was just the evidence Riswannadar needed to support her version of the resignation. Up to the Foymania period in November 2013, hers had been a singular and unconvincing claim that she was the victim of a side of the plot by four of her teaching assistants. But now he was proof of that plot, one of the conspirators had conveniently written it all down. Incredible.

Riswannadar was accused of fabricating letters, and another letter materialized to come to her rescue. And rescue her it did. Riswannadar would go on to use the Trojan horse letter to clear her name. In the wake of the letter, the Birmingham City Council reversed course and paid for Adderley Primary Schools legal case.

The police raided the teaching assistants houses of dawn and arrested them for conspiracy to commit fraud. The cops didn't end up bringing any charges, but all of this delayed the TA's case against Adderley for years. Once the hearing began, and Mrs. Dar finally did go in front of a judge, Adderley's legal team used the Trojan horse letter as evidence to support the school's case.

That the TA's had conspired to unceit Mrs. Dar. In the end, the judge concluded that Mrs. Dar did not fabricate the resignation letters.

Riswannadar is the head teacher of Adderley Primary School, to this day. More after the break. I remember distinctly coming to mind was seems to be a lot of information about Adderley here. And the Trojan horse letter, a lot of it relates to Adderley and things that wasn't in the family domain.

Who else would notice? Who else at the time would notice other than Risdar? It was just so obvious. I just found it very strange that a lot of those things went in the letter.

The architect of this letter was somebody clearly out there to safeguard Riswannadar. She's written this to cover us. We've seen no direct evidence that the respondent are all through the letter, nor court has ever found that she did. And the Birmingham City Council sent us the letter in which they said any suggestions that Mrs.

Dar was involved in altering the Trojan horse letter and the teaching assistants resignation letters is false. But the content of the Trojan horse letter is timing, and the circumstances surrounding it point to words Mrs. Dar, or someone who's saying that she's not the case. Or someone who's supporting Mrs.

Dar, or maybe some combination of the two as the likely authors. And if it was Mrs. Dar, who brought the Trojan horse letter, the bit that might surprise you is that a Muslim could have done this. That a Muslim could write a letter, trafficking in Islamophobic tropes, with the potential to do untold damage to Muslims.

It is messed up, but it happens. I remember another case in the same area of East Birmingham actually, where a Muslim cop had a personal beef with a guy who ran a prayer center, and a cop called 911, well, 999, pretending to be a civilian, reporting that people at the prayer center were planning to kidnap and kill cops in the name of ISIS. Can't you tear a detective looked into it, realized it was a hoax, the crooked cop got a seven-year sentence. I think of this phenomenon, kind of like Judo, when you learn that you can use your opponent's strength as a weapon against him.

Here Mrs. Dar was up against the city council, which had abandoned her, an employment tribunal, which was about to sit in charge of her. Maybe she could manipulate those institutions by using the latent credulous Islamophobia within them to her advantage. Tell them that he is our Islamist plotters.

Race is Judo. Is it depressing me well-known move that us browns know we can make? But it's not an easy thing to accept. When a friend first suggested that the letter probably came from Mrs.

Dar. I dismissed it all. Not only was Mrs. Barnadaw a fellow Muslim in Birmingham, working in schools with a similar goal of helping Muslim children, this was someone to hear new.

He'd helped hire Mrs. Dar for the early head teacher position. On top of that, who's close to Mrs. Dar's husband, a guy named Qadir Arif, is hard for the hearing imagine that someone close to him, wanted to create a letter, aligning him as an extremist kingpin.

But as the hear read and reread the Georgia whole center, he couldn't shake impression that he'd seem designed to help respond to Dar. And then, when the letter leaked their press, the story started running by him being a dangerous extremist. The hear-weighted for a call from Qadir or a responder. Because you knew them well enough for them to check in or something like that happens.

Absolutely not. They were a phone meeting, same day, or following day. Not a silly squat. It is now five years and not one of them has contacted me.

Any lingering doubts the hear had about who wrote the letter. This silence quashed them. If the purpose of the Trojan horse letter was to help Mrs. Dar not of a very specific masjid gun herself into with a handful of TAs at her school, why would Mrs.

Dar, or whoever wrote it, take pains to smear to hear as a dangerous mastermind? To hear himself struggle to find an explanation. The best he could come up with is that Mrs. Dar got the idea he was helping the TAs in some way, with her unfair dismissal case, though he insists he wasn't.

We also talked to someone who was on the Adderley governing body with Rizwan Adar around this time, who said Mrs. Dar was really angry at the educational trust to hear ran for poaching some of Adderley's teachers. In any case, as the Trojan horse letter took off in the press, to hear tried to push back, he drafted statements, which he sent to various agencies and reporters, and posted online, imploring people to look into the origins of the letter, and he publicly pointed to Adderley and the TA's resignation case, as it's likely sourced. The only outlet we've seen that picked up this line of inquiry was some seriousness, was the Guardian.

A couple weeks after the Trojan horse letter went public, a reporter there published an article raising the possibility that the Trojan horse plot might have been manufactured to support Adderley's defense in the employment tribunal, but Adderley wasn't having it. The school sent an aggressive statement to the newspaper, saying the operation Trojan horse plot was real, and suggesting to hear was the one who should be scrutinized, not them. The school also contacted to hear directly. I received a legal letter.

From the school's lawyers, saying his insinuations that the Trojan horse letter came from Adderley were, quote, holy baseless, and that. If I made those inferences again and so on, that I would be, you know, taken to court. You can explain to me something, I know we've had this conversation before, and I'm still struggling to understand it. If I knew that my friends essentially had written a document that was threatening to ruin my life, I don't know why you made no effort to go and speak to them.

There's one thing to publicly infer about something. There's another thing to pick up the phone, called Kadirarif, and said. What's going on here? I thought about that many, many times, actually, and perhaps that's a conversation that, you know, perhaps I should have had, actually, but I didn't think it was going to be unraveled by a chit-chat or a cup of tea, obviously.

I didn't believe that. Otherwise, I would have done that. It'd just be a no, and I didn't want to kind of, you know, sort of maybe embarrass myself. So for me to have an eyes and look, I look at you, how are you doing?

It's not easy for me to do. You have to appreciate that. You know what I'm saying? It's not an easy thing for me to do.

Take a second to consider how the story of the Trojan horse letter changes if you begin it with the infighting in Adderley Primary School. This theory of the letter is true. If it was created by Rizvan Adar or someone near her to strengthen the defense in the Adderley resignation case, think about the implications for Britain's understanding of Operation Trojan horse. Instead of news reports starting like this.

A leaked letter outlining a plot by hard-line Muslims to take over. A plot by hard-line Muslims to take over. My hard-line Muslims. Radical Muslims and Birmingham have got together to take them.

They would have had to begin with someone appears to have fabricated a plot in an attempt to defend a head teacher who's being sued for wrongful dismissal by four employees at a primary school who claims she forged resignation letters on their behalf. But the head teacher says the employees did submit resignation letters but that they were pretending otherwise. That's part of a plot. To uncedre.

Assuming you could even twist your brain around that headline, that story might make news of the weird or obscure employment law journal, but it's not going to dominate the national media for months. It's not going to command the attention of Parliament, the Prime Minister, the country's ex-counterterra chief. It's not going to change counter extremism policy. It's hard to fathom how this happened.

We're not dealing with deep throw here. You've seen how easy it is to lay the Adderley case alongside the Trojan horse letter and see how one could lead to the other. You can do it without much trouble from the comfort of your colleague's parent's bedroom. The government had so many professional eyes on this letter, multiple independent teams of investigators.

They must have looked into this theory and ruled it out for some reason. I draw no conclusion about the letter. Apparently not. This is an education consultant and former head teacher named Ian Kershaw.

He's the man the Birmingham City Council hired to conduct a thorough investigation of the Trojan horse letter. His resulting report was titled Investigation Report Trojan Horse Letter. And yet he proudly proclaimed to Hamzunmi. I draw no conclusion about who possibly rose it.

Why they rose it. I didn't write it. I don't know who rose it. Well, my job to find out who rose it.

Ian Kershaw says he didn't spend a single minute looking into that. In his 141 page report, he only mentions the case of Adderley in one bullet point, or at least he appears to. It's splattered with redaction, writing that he didn't have time to pursue that incident in any detail. Former counter-terra chief Peter Clark, the other main investigator who looked into the Trojan horse affair for the national government, does a similar pivot.

He does acknowledge in his report that whoever off the Trojan horse letter had detailed knowledge of what was going on with the resignation case in Adderley Primary School. But then he never discusses the case again. Both investigators, Kershaw and Clark, make clear that the letter itself, its origins, its authenticity, whether it was truly correspondence between two conspirators. That didn't matter to them or to the government agencies they were working for, which made total sense, Ian Kershaw.

Whoever wrote the letter, whatever their motive was, is not really the point of the council's point of view. Their question got to be, is there something going on in our schools that we should know about? So the source of the letter, in a sense, became irrelevant. I cannot overstate how crucial this choice was, the choice to respond to the Trojan horse letter this way.

It's not worry so much about its text, all its details, or even whether it was real. And to instead look at its overarching theme, the notion that Muslims were colluding with each other, to take over schools and potentially harm children. It's not clear where the specular and frankly Islamophobic logic first emerged, but once it did, nearly everyone, from Westminster on down to the local media in Birmingham, followed suit. Parkview and Adderley teacher, Razwan Faraz remembers giving interviews to reporters and investigators where he says he pushed them to look into the source of the letter and being frustrated.

The feeling I got was that they weren't interested in the letter, they were interested in what's going on. The inquiry was more like, you Muslims are getting up to bad stuff, aren't you, tell me why you're not getting up to bad things. As opposed to, we've heard that there's this letter, what can you tell us about it? And once that narrative solidified, it was insurmountable.

So that even years later, when Hamza and I started trying to talk to people about what happened in Birmingham schools, lots of people didn't trust us, that we were after something different. Just what did he bring on? It is a hard note from him. The weariness seemed especially stark among people connected to Adderley.

There were stretches when I was back home in New York, and Hamza was soldiering on and Birmingham by himself, knocking on doors in between classes and assignments at journals in school. And I would get these voice memos on what's out from him throughout the day. Abibraman was a former chair of Governors from Adderley, who previously agreed to get coffee with us. He doesn't think there's any value in the story.

Communities moved on, he's moved on, and eventually he just put the phone down. So he's a hard note. Hamza just knocked on for a chef-box door again. A former finance assistant from Adderley.

She answered, and she just immediately started saying, I'm busy, I'm busy, and started trying to shut the door at me. And I said, aren't you, I just have one question to ask, please just give me two minutes and shut the door on my face. Ask me if I can drive the door through the post box. So eventually I just felt ridiculous and I just come back for a car and I'm sure what else to do.

Hamza was like a tire that was slowly losing air. Anyway, so here's the update of the evening. First Dr. Regina, Hunum's house.

Regina Hunum was one of the four teaching assistants in the resignation case. And our husband answered. He was in place to see me there. He had an issue with his foot, so he had a walking stick with him.

He was hopping around, and I immediately felt guilty being there for Monast. It became quite apparent quite quickly, he was never going to let me speak to her. She was upstairs, supposedly busy. He also threw in there a few times.

Hamza told me, as we shot the shit driving around Birmingham, that the reason he went into journalism was to take on stories like this one, in which Muslims felt burned by the press. Hamza used it as part of the pitch he'd make to people when we called them or met them at the front doors. I get it. I'm a Muslim Pakistani guy from Birmingham.

He thought this would be his calling card, who'd give him access to sources and stories that other journalists might not get. Instead, he found himself sitting alone in his car on a side street of Allen Rock, talking into his phone. God, Hamza, I'm just looking at the message already, eight minutes long, so this is, I'm sorry about this man. Listen, I think some people tied to the Adilycase, I'd stuff to hide.

I would get to some of that. But regardless, I have to say, this is exactly how I would react to a British journalist coming to knock on my door. This is the same press that's been called out for systemic Islamophobia by its own media watchdog. The same press that's admitted that editors asked reporters to find Muslim stories because they sell papers.

And when these stories were analyzed, the majority were negative, with the most common theme being terrorism. The same press that went pleaded with by the head of a Muslim organization for more even handed reporting about us, because he feared people being poisoned like they were against Jewish people in the 1930s, responded with 21 articles, ridiculing his argument, attacking him, and asking for his arrest. So yeah, I had hoped that being a local Muslim guy would mean that people in Birmingham would treat me differently, that they trust me. But instead, me walking around Allen Rock introducing myself as a journalist only meant that after seeing all those headlines designed to hurt us, I'd go and join this industry.

That wasn't something different. I was also a sick person. I was also, apparently, an idiot. This is it, you saw this one question, the rest does not matter, the rest just kind of falls away with it anyway.

Back in the beginning, I'd rambled to Brian about our mission. Sure, the people I thought was helping went into me, but I still believed our goal was straightforward. All we had to do was focus everyone on the question of who wrote the letter. Turn everybody's head back to Adley.

If you could substantiate that it was indeed written by Riswanatar, or someone close to her for that resignation case. If this was a hoax and intended by someone for a different purpose and completely made up and you get that as proof, everything that comes after it doesn't matter. For me, solving who wrote this letter is more powerful than just this little case here in Birmingham. I feel like this becomes the flag that everyone can weigh then to be like, well, let's be skeptical about any accusations from here on, because look what happened with this one, spiraled out of control for no reason.

This story, this letter, then becomes bigger than this one series that becomes like an all-reference point. A reference point to be like, just be skeptical. There was a problem with my premise though. When I first got interested in Operation Troy Japorels, I thought the government in press had made a mistake in overlooking who wrote the letter.

A bigger mistake, but an honest one, I assumed, that this provocative document had surfaced and the media had gotten into its usual frenzy. Words like extremism and jihad were being thrown around. And in a rush to act, the government lost itself in hysteria. Instead of taking the rational approach of just looking into the Adley case, it ended up embarking on a thoughtless adventure.

I figured what I was trying to correct wasn't oversight. For now I know, it wasn't an oversight at all. That's next on the Troy Japorels affair. Sir Abbam, and I'm missing H.

The Troy Japorels affair is produced by Brian Reed and me, along with Rebecca Lex. This shows edited by Sarah Keating, additional editing by Ari Glass and by contributing editor Aisha Manazar Siddiqui. Fact-checking and research by Marie Kornley and Ben Faden, original score by Thomas Miller, with additional music by Matt McInley and Stephen Jackson. Sound design, mixing and music supervision by Stephen Jackson and Phil Dhamhoski, as the audio-non-visual company.

Julie Snyder is our executive editor, Neil Drummond, his managing editor. Superpising producers and Dave Chubu, executive assistant is our photo-delayon. Sam Dornik is an assistant managing editor at The New York Times. Special thanks to Hamza's parents, Syed and Atea Hatter, also Alvin Melith, Aviva De Kornfeld, Rasmus Bitch, Rumb Radio, Media Dog and Victoria McEddy.

The Troy Japorels affair is made by serial productions in The New York Times.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Serial?

This episode is 53 minutes long.

When was this Serial episode published?

This episode was published on March 18, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Serial episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.