Skip to content
The Trojan Horse Affair - Part 3 episode artwork

Mar 18, 2022 38 min

The Trojan Horse Affair - Part 3

from Serial Hosted by Serial Productions & The New York Times

In a state of surprise, Hamza and Brian leave a meeting with the man the Trojan Horse letter was first sent to. And they learn about an internal investigation report that local officials have kept hidden, but which they think could contain a bombshell. To learn more about our shows and get a look behind the scenes, find us on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook by searching “Serial Productions”. Have a story pitch, a tip, or feedback? Email us at [email protected]. for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

In a state of surprise, Hamza and Brian leave a meeting with the man the Trojan Horse letter was first sent to. And they learn about an internal investigation report that local officials have kept hidden, but which they think could contain a bombshell.

Ready to play

The Trojan Horse Affair - Part 3

0:00 38:06
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hi, I'm Solana Pine. I'm the director of video at the New York Times. For years, my team has made videos that bring you closer to a big news moment, videos by Times journalists that have the expertise to help you understand what's going on. Now, we're bringing those videos to you in the Watch tab in the New York Times app.

It's a dedicated video feed where you know you can trust what you're seeing. All the videos there are free for anyone to watch. You don't have to be a subscriber. Download the New York Times app to start watching.

From Serial Productions and The New York Times, I'm Brian Reed. I'm Honsa Seid. This is the Trojan Horse Affair. Here's what Honsa and I have figured out.

The Trojan Horse Affair wasn't a mistake. The government didn't overreact simply because they failed to investigate the source of the Trojan Horse letter. It hadn't tricked them. They hadn't actually missed.

They linked to Adderley Primary School, and were Zwanadar, and then pressed ahead anyway, with teacher bans, legal cases, school takeovers, enhanced national security policy. To tell you the story of how we figured that out, we're going to go all the way back to our very first week of reporting. To interview we did with a key figure in this saga, the first person the Trojan Horse letter was sent to, a man named Sir Albert Boor. It came to me in a brand paper envelope.

Does that never matter about the envelope? The envelope was just addressed to me. Now that would have been November. When the Trojan Horse letter arrived in November 2013, Albert Boor was the leader of the Birmingham City Council.

He's not leader anymore, but he's still a council member. He's one of the longest serving in Birmingham, first elected in 1980. Council Boor's a physicist by training, with bushy-gray eyebrows and a shirt with its three top buttons undone, and a gold chain against his chest. He was given a knighthood in 2002 for his service to local government.

This conversation we had with him. It was before we'd done any digging into Adderley Primary School ourselves, before we'd really focused on Rizwanadar and the legal troubles she was facing when the Trojan Horse letter popped up for training her as an innocent victim. At this point, I'm reporting we were still just gathering basic info about the letter. My staff, they opened the letter and brought it to me and said that...

We were hopeful Council Boor might have something useful to share, because not only was he the first person to receive the letter, but he seemed like one of the few politicians likely to be candid with us. I remember back in 2014, during the Hoopla, he came across as a skeptic on the Trojan Horse letter. He publicly said the letter was probably a hoax and called it a famitary. He also attacked the Department of Education's decision to send former County Territory of Peter Clark to investigate Birmingham schools.

He told hand in the inquiry to a high-level terrorism investigator was overkill, and risked alienating Birmingham's Muslims. It's not that Albert Board dismissed the idea that there was something worth looking into. The Council did appoint their own non-terror investigator, but overall he'd been a defender of the city and its schools. So here inside the city Council building, Council House, Albert Board walked through his very first moments of the Trojan Horse letter when he arrived here in his office.

I of course looked at it, read it, reread it. And he brought that up to the attention of other top officials at the Council, as well as the local police who got back to the Council and said, this wasn't a matter for the cops. They didn't see that at that point, there was anything illegal going on or unlawful, and therefore their view was, there was nothing there for them to investigate. That surprised me a little then, and it surprises me a little now.

What surprised you about it? Well, because statements in the letter, which would have indicated that there were individuals who were acting in a manner which was leading to changes in schools against the normal, against the sort of change that would be allowed for by the regulations, if you like, within which we operate. I sat there, next to Brian, confused. For one, Council was always seem to be exerting a normal amount of effort to construct a sentence.

It always sounded like he was saying in those sentences, was he always be the letter seriously, as a viable threat? There appeared to be a systematic attempt here to change the ethos of a school. There were things going on which we could not condone, and it was about dealing with. But he said back then that it was probably a hoax.

And now here I was, watching him reach across the table for our copy of that same letter. I just look at, and I've opened up the letters to look at the steps that the letter sets out first step. Identifying the school. And reading through the plot of steps.

Third step, putting some governance. As if there were real plans for real conspiracy. These steps were having the desired effect in a number of schools. What was he doing?

Why was he waving the letter around talking like this? I thought I'd better say something. I wanted this matter to be looked at and looked at urgently. This is like, sorry, but equally from the very start.

I didn't go well. Mental note, stop skipping class at journalism score to go do these interviews. Who do you think wrote the letter? Do you have a thought about that?

I have no idea. You've never considered it. I sometimes ask the question, I wonder who the hell wrote this letter. Someone set this out.

For what purpose? Was this a hoax? Was it not a hoax? Who might have written it?

Who might have sent it? These were questions which were always about and never answered because they couldn't be answered. They still can't be answered. Well, yeah, I guess like for me, I discovered who wrote the letter.

It's not just a curiosity, it's about figuring out the motivations of the person who wrote it. If you find out more about the person who wrote it, you might figure out more about whether the allegations made within are actually real or not. Look, you're seeking to become an investigative journalist. I commend you for trying to find out who wrote the letter.

Your objectives are good, but those objectives weren't my objectives. My objectives were to find out whether steps one to five in any way happened amongst Birmingham schools. I was at a bit of a loss of how to proceed, which is acting so differently than I expected. For why I knew, Abba Boor had a well-established relationship with Muslims.

He represents a ward with lots of Muslims in a city with a big Muslim population. He's a member of the Labour Party, which is the Labour Party most British Muslim support. He was married to the first Asian Muslim woman elected to the Council. He has Muslim kids.

He was put in stock in the Trojan horse letter, despite his initial misgivings about his authenticity. And despite what he'd seen with his own eyes in his Birmingham. For instance, part of the school I've been having such success that I brought Abba Boor's seat such as prior to the Trojan horse allegations. Council Boor visited that school.

I can tell you, I went to part of your school and I was amazed by some of what they were doing. Absolutely amazed. This is before Trojan horse. I think you understand what I mean about the nature of this letter.

You marvel at the same school that is at the edge of the convention. I know, but educational achievement is one thing. But operating a school with ethos, with other values, is something we also have to reflect on. And ethos, other values.

Words I'd become pretty familiar with, from classic civilisation, type texts, that argue Muslims are incompatible with the Western way of life. We pushed Council Boor to explain what he was eluding to with these words. What have you learned that you are shocked by? What precisely had the Muslim educators who were working in the schools done that were so concerning to him?

You kept referring to reports from the Trojan horse investigators. But when we asked Abba Boor, what from those investigations had shocked him? It was telling that apparently nothing was disturbing enough that it stayed with him. You could only point to how governors and staff in his Birmingham had created what he called ominously, an atmosphere.

Where a school governing body is putting unacceptable pressure on teachers. Unacceptable pressure on the head teacher to do things in a way which is not acceptable to enable certain objectives to be realised in that school. You're saying certain matters and certain objectives. What's the inappropriate thing that was happening?

Because words like things are a little vague. Well yeah, well sure they're vague. But if you read these reports, it's quite clear that things were happening, which was against the run of what you were happening in that school. I don't find it so clear.

I feel a little confused by the reports, having read them recently quite honestly. What exactly about this is bad, you know, like undue religion against what standard is that being measured? When you read it, it's a little hard to get your grasp on what exactly the report is saying. And I've read it in good faith and really try and understand it.

This is why the reason we'd come to Albert Bora to try and get some clarity. The evidence and conclusions in these reports seemed to be fussed to us. So we were hoping that Albert Bora could help us understand what had made officials go from celebrating these schools, for incorporating the students' faith in culture to condemn them. Instead, what we got from Council Bora were insinuations.

There were, quote unquote, matters of concern, he said, a set of activities, individuals acting in common. By the end of the interview, it'd come up with exactly one example of a practice that was found going on in these schools that appalled him. In some schools, there were certain activities which appeared were being done on a single sex basis. And those activities, Albert Bora told us, were PE and sports.

And that was because of the Muslim, so-called Muslim ethos that was being applied. Is that unusual for schools? Oh, totally yes. It's totally against the normal activities of a school.

The government gives statistics on how many schools teach PE to boys and girls separately, but the department for education specifically allows for it. And from my own experience, I'm going to school in England. And every Brit, I can remember ever talking to about this. That's pretty standard in schools, Muslim ethos or not.

Council Bora said, he thought there were other inappropriate changes. Chainty said, would it be okay, by the way, if these have been to not be in school, which they weren't? But again, he wasn't positive what Chainty was talking about. And now two and a half hours with him, PE was all he could remember for sure.

So there's no evidence of anyone being incited to violence, incited to join a group that- I don't think there's any evidence which could lead you 100% to that view. That might be evidence around. Council Bora picked the Trojan horse that backed up. It's a partial letter.

Well, it appears to be. You see, there was something before this first page and would appear that could be something after the final page, because it says I would also like, and then it stops. So that sentence is- He's referring to the bottom of the last page of the letter. That final sentence fragment I would also like, as if I thought would have continued on the following page, had it ever been found.

So this was part of a bigger document. Was there some further steps towards the end of this letter, which is about Islamic extremism? I don't know. So, all right, well, we learned where Albert Bora stands, right?

Fucking surprise, I'll tell you that, man. Hamza and I headed out of Council House. We put its columns and dome and clocked tower behind us and started walking. Hamza was animated.

That's fine, but now to sit here and talk as if from day one you received this letter, you accepted it, you went around and tried to get other people to reflect your urgency. No one else was on board like you were. No, bullshit, mate. I love how mad you are.

Mate, I'm pissed. Why? Look at the power that the letter had on official them, right? Look at it.

Four years on, it is so ingrained in their mentality that, you know, all these things are sinister as fuck. All these things were happening, that they had to be stopped, these practices, these blocks, these steps. Fuck was concerning, tell me what's concerning, mate. Just break it down to me.

You're literally poking me in the chest right now. I'm seething. Audacity to say that the results. Hamza and I kept walking around City Center, passed the clothing stores in the cathedral and a lane called Needless Alley.

Then passed the clothing stores in the cathedral and Needless Alley again. It occurred to me. We're not actually going anywhere. I'm just like, I couldn't believe it made the way in which he was describing a situation, the terms in which he was kind of like addressing this issue.

I'm like, fuck it, I'm like, you're saying some radical shit. Essentially about me. I cannot think of the top of my head at the moment where I've sat opposite someone and they have just, you know, disarroged Muslims in the way that boarded today. Really?

Honestly, I have not. Without quite doing it openly, but in a kind of like, not in a winky kind of way, suggested that, come on, these guys are fucking extremists, let's be honest. Do you know what I mean? And do it so casually, comfortably.

I guess council boards attitude towards the Trojan Horse affair shouldn't have been such a surprise to me. What he had to say that led to was probably a hoax, defamatory even. One of the back-ass early statements. I don't just say he had always equivocated, but vain the same logic that so many others had.

That even if the letter wasn't genuine, it could still be pointed to serious issues. What pissed me off though was council boards reliance on the letter through our interview, and the vague language he was using alongside it, is any windows about extremism. I don't think our borders are racist. I believe he has a sick and certain sensitivity about Birmingham's Muslims, but he still managed to make people like me sound alien and dangerous in some way.

And he didn't feel good. And I actually thought at one point I'd like to see, no, what my name is. Obviously he's been corresponding with Brian Reed. Does he not just have to say it in this room?

Where's the name is I opening? Really this interview? Yeah. It's a conversation I've had with my friends, my conservative Muslim friends, who've always held his belief that there's a bigger wide conspiracy, you know, and everyone's against Muslims, and there's no success for us in the West, and I never entertain any of it.

I know what's common for us immigrants to get twisted up and ask a bit of culture and existence, but honestly, I've been able to make it work for me. I grew up in a conservative Pakistani family. We always lived in white neighborhoods. I'm a Muslim, but I went to a mostly white Catholic school, and wasn't my service more than a mosque.

And it's helped me carve out a pretty sweet spot for myself, a brown person, who white people wear ease around, because I dress like them and speak like them. I can get them to pay attention and care about what I have to say, like convincing a Brian Reed to fly away from New York to join this hunt. This is part of what I was hoping to do as a journalist. I thought I could get access to white rooms of power and focus them on our brown issues.

So my Muslim Pakistani mates, who aren't as native to white spaces, tell me that the West has it out for all of us Muslims. I've always denied it. I've always said they're paranoid. And it's talked like that.

That's held us back. It's talked like that. I used to fight with them every opportunity I had. I've always, always argued against that.

And then I said opposite, I'll put more. I mean, look, I didn't feel like I was sitting in front of a bigger. Just a rational man. Well, educated, well-learned in a position of power.

He's even married in the Muslim ones. And yet, here is someone who can only look at this matter in terms of like something sinister. He was more willing to entertain the idea that the page I was missing at the end of this Trojan horse rider. This was going to ultimately lead to radicalization extremism.

He was more willing to entertain that than he was willing to entertain the idea that actually, that might mean something good happening in his schools. And these kids were actually thriving. Is that making you rethink the stance you've taken in the past, I guess? Or is that what you're saying?

It just makes me think that as much as I was convinced that the air stance wasn't right. Maybe my stance wasn't right either. And that makes me a little bit uneasy. Did you really believe that stuff?

Yeah, I mean, God. It was very important for me to believe that. It gave me the impetus to kind of explore other fields or the careers. Because I didn't think that was, you know, some kind of fundamental distrust of Muslims.

Who the fuck was I defending? What do you do with these feelings as a journalist? I wonder. I don't know, man.

Because like, for me, the worry is, and I don't know why I talk about this. Because for me, the worry is, what if you become the Muslim reporter, right? Say this is a society that you're operating in where? If Muslims take over a school and turn it around, it's a threat.

Then imagine if Muslim journalists are coming in. What do people start listening to their words? Is that not equally a threat? If you want to hear on the story with me, I don't know if what we arrived to together as a conclusion.

Even if I arrived at the same conclusion on my own, we'd have enough credibility. Because these words are coming out of my mouth. They're going to be received differently. But the she-she can we get a vanilla rose?

And can we just get a pot of mint tea as well, please? When it got dark out, we ducked inside a she-she cafe at Hukalauj. It was cool. It was up at the top of this abandoned movie theater.

I put my recorder down. I thought we were done for the day. Hamza picked it up. What I should like, ask you questions.

At some point, I should ask you questions, he said. Which, fair enough. Yeah, that's fine. Because like, okay, so I want to know.

Why was I here? He asked me, doing this story with him. What was I hoping to achieve? I did this story this summer where I went to Alaska.

And of course, Alaska. It's exactly where I thought this would go. Keep writing, keep writing, keep writing. Go through Anchorage, you keep writing other like five hours.

Ryan told me about how he'd been reporting a story about immigration every Sunday in a town called Homer. At the end of the road in America. And that's Homer. I googled the place after we talked.

Pictures of bearers, blakes, and mountains popped up. A fire cry from Birmingham UK. You're having this fight about immigration in their town? Do they have no immigrants?

Repounding, stories about places like Birmingham had influenced people out there. Ryan kept interviewing Alaskans who told him they were afraid and angry Muslims because they were online having Europe. We'd taken over large swat of cities and turned them into so-called no-go zones where non-Muslims can't enter. On a Fox News segment, Birmingham's famous day he was taking over entirely by Muslims.

The whole city. He said it struck him how powerful these fears were. In a place where Muslims were basically a theoretical idea. There was only one Muslim guy as far as Ryan knew who lived there on a boat apparently.

Then I walked to Bryan backstage who was looking to report a story in one of these supposedly captured European cities to dispel the myths about them. Do you have two no-go zones, mate? We don't want to know right now. No.

I heard all of Birmingham's. Yeah, I mean, it depends on which outfit you tune in to. What do you think which island anyone's might? I buy anything.

Is that even an important ambition to hold or does it not matter? I don't think about that. I don't do it a story because I feel like it will often lead to disappointment. The things that motivate you to do a story or because it's a good-ass story.

I don't want a delicate story and I feel like it can have all sorts of byproducts, like changing people's minds. But for me, I think I would get disappointed a lot. Whereas if you're doing a story where you personally want to know the answer to something, you personally want to do the best story you can, then that's like where I'm trying to derive the motivation from. No, I didn't know.

Why would you do a story if you didn't care what impact it would have? So, that was our first week in Birmingham. And like I said, it was before we knew much about Adderley Primary School or the resignation case against Riswanadar. But in the coming months, once we pieced together the resignation story and we saw just how strongly it suggests that the Trojan Horse letter was written to influence that Adderley case, we sharpened our strategy.

We started asking people, important people. Did you connect the Trojan Horse letter to the Adderley dispute and what did you make of the connection? But when we asked these questions, it became apparent that Adderley Primary School was the no-go zone. How about Adderley, the school that's talked about at length in the letter?

What did you do in terms of taking that on? Wait, what have you been taking it on? Ian Kershaw, the consultant Albert Bourbroughton, to investigate the Trojan Horse letter for Birmingham City Council, we pressed him on the Adderley dispute. Did you read up about that situation, Adderley?

I loved it a lot at the time. Can you give us a bit of a detail about that situation? No. It is particularly important that I don't.

Kind of touching, huh? But I'm certainly not going to comment on it any further than I have already. We understand that. When we started filing Freedom of Information requests with the Birmingham City Council, for documents we suspected had information about Adderley.

They were touching too. They solved, issued ridiculous denials, were found by a regulator to have broken the Freedom of Information law numerous times in their efforts to improve the situation. When I asked the Employment Tribunal for its records from the Adderley resignation case, the Birmingham City Council hired a fancy barrister to fight me. Not only did they not want the records released, the council wrote to the tribunal that the case file ought to be destroyed.

And oddly, the City Council submitted that request on behalf of Rizvan Adar and her husband, Kadeer Arif. Even in Westminster, things were weird. We went down there to the House of Commons to talk to the member of Parliament who represents Al-Mrak, a guy named Liam Byrne. We thought he'd be helpful because Adderley primary schools in his district, and we knew that one of the teaching assistants who accused Rizvan Adar of faking the resignation letters, was a good person.

And Rizvan Adar of faking the resignation letters had gone to Liam Byrne for support. We knew he sent a letter to the Birmingham City Council about Mrs. Starr, saying he wanted her investigated immediately. Saying this was so serious, he wanted to talk to a council representative directly.

That Rizvan Adar was still at the school and quote, has the freedom to destroy evidence. But when we tried talking to Liam Byrne about all that, about Rizvan Adar and the way she was described in the Trojan Horse letter. This is the second page of the Trojan Horse letter, this section in particular by Adderley Primary School, which is in your position. Did it stand out to you in any significant way when you read it?

No more than the rest of the letter. He would not engage with it. We brought his own letters to talk to him about, but he sat there, refusing to look at them. It was really awkward.

It's right there. Next to you, if you want to read it on night. I think you would like to look at it. Seriously, I'm just not going to comment on anything to do with one of those representations for any of your constituents.

You don't need to do that. I think we're going to conclude it here. So you never had a conversation with anyone else about Rizvan Adar being the author of the Trojan Horse letter? I can't talk to you about...

Why can't you talk about that? We're talking to you. Leaving us? What?

I don't understand. You're waving us goodbye. He stormed away. Meanwhile, back in Alum Rock.

Oh, another door slammed on us. This is moments after a former chair of government is at editing. Jawa Wariqbal. Shai Sperndorn faces.

It's not like we'd surprise him or anything. We'd had a friendly conversation the week before, and he knew we'd be coming by. But this time, he's trying to call the police on us. The third person to make that threat in a month.

So weird if someone makes you feel like you're doing something criminal? That move? We're trying to criminalize what you're doing, which is completely upfront and decent? You know?

You're struggling with this more than I am. I'm a fucking minority, mate. My entire life is this. What are we doing in this story?

Do you realize the story you're reporting on? Who are you talking to? So weird to have people criminalizing you? You don't behave it.

Shut the fuck up. You know, mate. You got me. Appreciate the mirror you're holding up to me.

I'm glad you're having these moments, mate. Welcome to my fucking world. It's Ruckus. On the one hand, officials were insisting that they'd barely thought about where the Georgia horse had a mighty come from, because it didn't matter.

And yet, when we'd asked them about the relationship of early primary school to the letter, it triggered an almost pablovian response to them to run away as fast as they could. But one afternoon, in a fear of research, Brian came across a clue as to what they might be running from. We followed that lead after a break. Hi, this is Ashley.

I live in San Francisco with my boyfriend. We would love to officially share a many-year time subscription with separate logins. We both love cooking, loving in the kitchen, but I'm a 30-minute and under-efficient dinner-a-girly. I want a sheet pan meal.

He is a elaborate. He wants to get into the storytelling. I want to be able to save my easy meals and check off the ones that I've completed, and I think him having his own profile would be great. Ashley, we heard you.

It's why we created the New York Times family subscription. You get your own login, and Mr. elaborate, it's his. Plus room for two others.

Find out more at nytimes.com.com.com I was noodling around on this site one day called WhatDoTheyKnow.com, which helps people make freedom of information requests in the UK and keeps listings of them online. But I found a reference to a Birmingham City Council record with a title that piqued my interest. Final Audit Report, Adderly Primary School, Alleged Falsification of Documents. Huh.

I saw that a woman named Pauline Gagan had requested this document, which looked to be an investigation report from the Council in 2014, and the Council responded that they would not be disclosing it. Pauline had asked for it again a couple of times over the years, and each time the Council refused her. Don't recall this bit. So we met Pauline for dinner to find out what she knew about this report at her favorite Italian restaurant, Birmingham City Centre.

How's it fish? Oh, lovely. Though that makes the dinner sound like a much more normal evening than it was. Pauline's the kind of person who cultivates a certain mystique.

She wouldn't tell us the name of the restaurant to meet at, for instance. She directed us to rendezvous with a statue instead, though as we find out the statue no longer exists. And we finally did make it to the Italian place, the proprietor beck and Pauline to the host station, where he wanted to have a few words with her privately, which seemed mysterious in the moment, but we later learned was because she had paid him the last time she was here, because of the locusty taste of unusual. You have evidence?

Oh, well, he's a little story. Now, as we're eating dinner, I'm trying to coax out of her anything she knows about this report, about the falsification of documents and Adderley. But she keeps telling me to turn my recorder up. Don't go down there.

I'll kill you. I'm still not clear what Pauline's profession is, by the way. But for our purposes, I'm going to go with vigilante local journalists. She used to run a Twitter account called News in Brum.

Brum is Birmingham's nickname. The Trojan Horse scandal was one of her biggest stories. Our dinner with Pauline was a bit disjointed, so we met her again the following week. This time she, Hamza and I, packed into a carol at the Birmingham Public Library.

Our suggestion, she'd wanted to meet on a gallery bench in the art museum. She came bearing a bunch of old notes from a time reporting on Operation Trojan Horse. You can see how much I was immersed in it. I can tell you where I'm immersed in it from before.

Oh, yeah. Because I knew people lying, that's why. People shouldn't be at all levels. And people who paid a lot of money to be leaders and honest and open.

Pauline told us that while she was covering Trojan Horse, she got a tip from someone close to Adderley, that after the TAs there, had complained to Birmingham City Council, that Mrs. Dar might have fabricated their resignation letters. The council did an investigation, and that an audit report was written, which I have seen some of, but not all of them. Despite many tenacious freedom of information requests, which have been rejected by the council.

I'd requested it too, before meeting Pauline, and the council also denied me. Oh, I can't know about these times. I've asked for it. We saw it at least twice.

I've asked for it more than that because I've asked privately as well, not put it on what do they know.com. Clearly they don't want us to see it. Because so many people have asked for it. I know other, I believe BBC people have asked.

I've asked, I know other journalists that work independently. They've asked you, nobody's getting it. Really? If you wanted to put your money into anything in this investigation, it would be get that audit report.

Test, test, test, test. Test, test, test. Okay. We hold it in the right.

Okay, so we, we have just been given the audit report. Final audit report. It's in my hands. This makes it sound easy, but I have to take my hat to Brian here.

Getting this audit report was quite an ordeal. At least because, as we would learn, one of the reasons the council was so sensitive about this report is because they eventually rather mystifying me, retracted it. Which we'll tell you a whole story about later. Anyway, it took some maneuvering for Brian to take it back up.

At Catchum Late at night, in his hotel room, his phone, sobbing messages with sources, he'd say, about this audit report. He went around the middle of a football match we were watching together to continue some secret conversation. I was weeks away from flagging his behavior to his wife when one day he came up to me and said, Watson, I said stop calling me that. He said, follow me.

And we had it. We had the audit report. I can't say much about how we got it, except that we obtained it legally. We were able to authenticate it by cross referencing with other documents.

And the honest way it was, it was held with gloved hands. Honestly, I feel like we should have acquired state secrets. That's what it feels like. It really does.

Except it's about primary school. It's the cover page restricted. 16 pages. The document was put together by internal investigators.

Auditors, including the Council Fraud Specialist at the Birmingham City Council. You can enter dispute resignations from the 4TA's, to determine whether the resignation letters have been falsified, and if so, whether Mrs. Dar was involved in their production. The report stated the 3rd October 2013.

About seven weeks before the Trojan Horse letter appeared at the Birmingham City Council. So this is the information the Council had about response and those resignations. as they were deciphering the Trojan horselayer. This report is a brutal document from Mrs.

Dar. The council investigators paint a picture of Mrs. Dar, trying to get her oceans 11 on, to set up the TAs, but fumbling at every turn. Let me share this one memorable detail.

Investigators observed that on the resignation letter Mrs. Dar insisted was written by one of the teaching assistants, a woman named Shunaz Beebe. Shunaz's name is spelled incorrectly. It's missing an H, meaning if Shunaz Beebe had written it like Mrs.

Dar was claiming, she misspelled her own name. Then a couple of weeks after Mrs. Dar announced that the woman had resigned, the school sent greeting cards to all four of them, parting notes, wishing them well for the future. That alone was quote, inappropriate for the school to do, the auditor rights, given that the employees were adamant that they hadn't resigned.

But on top of it, in the greeting card, Adley sent Shunaz Beebe. Shunaz's name is also spelled incorrectly. It's missing an H, the same H that was missing on her alleged resignation letter. According to the report, when the auditors tried to interview Mrs.

Dar for their investigation, she cancelled on them four times. The report says that lawyers were adily insisted in an email that Mrs. Dar under school, her quote, substantial evidence, witnessed testimony and forensic, that she had not forged a resignation letter, but they never provided any of the audit team. Adley's lawyer said advised Mrs.

Dar not to participate in the investigation, since the school was in a legal fight with the TAs. The conclusion of the inquiry, the audit is right, as although they found no direct proof confirming that the resignation letter was fabricated by Rizwananda herself. The manor in conduct and how she has chosen to deal with the resignations, and this audit investigation is concerning and undoubtedly calls her integrity into question. Wow.

We have determined that the resignation letters have been falsified. In the absence of any evidence to the contrary, it is reasonable to conclude that Mrs. Dar may have been involved in the fabrication of the resignation letters in order to terminate the contracts of employment of four individuals who each have an unresolved grievance raised against her. Birmingham audit will be seeking the directorate's agreement to refer the matter to the police.

Wow. It's so dramatic. There you go. This was new to us.

A bombshell. The city of Birmingham was all over this case. Their auditors have been scrutinizing it for months down to a graphical analysis of greeting cards. They determined that the resignation letters were fabricated, that Mrs.

Dar might have been involved in fabricating them, and as a result, they stick the police on Mrs. Dar. In the weeks before the Trojan horse letter appeared, at the request of the city council, Rizwananda Dar was facing a possible criminal investigation. That's incredible.

She was in big trouble. What we discovered in this audit report was proof that the Birmingham City Council, Albert Bores, Birmingham City Council, was intimately familiar with the Adderley case before the Trojan horse letter ever appeared. So when they read the Trojan horse letter, their investigators had already concluded that the scheme to overthrow Rizwananda Dar's head teacher, the most detailed example of Operation Trojan Horse, was based on the evidence they'd seen, not believable. They found no plot against her.

Quite the opposite. They thought, if anything, Mrs. Dar may have been the one who had plotted to oust her colleagues. They thought Mrs.

Dar was out there, possibly planting fake letters. Dude, this is something. This is something. I see you all this.

Next time on the Trojan horse affair, The Meeting and the Mole. The Trojan horse affair is produced by Hansa Syed and me, along with Rebecca Lax. The show is edited by Sarah Koenig, additional editing by Ira Glass and by our contributing editor, Aisha Manazar-Sidiki. Fact-checking in research by Mark O'Cronolly and Ben Phalen.

Original score by Thomas Miller with additional music by Matt McKinley and Steven Jackson. Sound design, mixing and music supervision by Steven Jackson and Phil Dhamahowski at the Audio Non-Visual Company. Julie Snyder is our executive editor. Neil Drumming is managing editor.

Supervising producer is N'Day Chubu. Executive Assistant is Alberto De Leon. Sam Dolnick is an assistant managing editor of The New York Times. Special thanks to Valerie Cesar, Leonardo Feynman and Phoebe Weng.

The Trojan horse affair is made by serial productions and The New York Times.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Serial?

This episode is 38 minutes long.

When was this Serial episode published?

This episode was published on March 18, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Serial episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.