Skip to content
The Truth About Getting Published (From a Literary Agent) | Joy Eggerichs Reed episode artwork

Oct 26, 2026 45 min

The Truth About Getting Published (From a Literary Agent) | Joy Eggerichs Reed

from At Sea with Justin McRoberts Hosted by Justin McRoberts

Writing the Book Is Only Half the Story Literary agent and author Joy Eggerich joins Justin McRoberts for a conversation about the realities of modern publishing and what it means to pursue creative work in an industry that doesn’t always reward the things artists value most. Joy explains how the publishing landscape has changed, why traditional publishers have become more cautious, and how the rise of independent publishing has created new opportunities for authors. Justin reflects on his own experiences self-publishing his early books, including CMYK, and how those experiences helped him develop a healthier relationship with his work. Together, they explore the tension between artistic freedom and commercial expectations. Topics include: The changing publishing industry Why traditional publishing is more complicated than it once was. How publishers evaluate potential books. The growing importance of an author’s platform. What authors should understand about publishing contracts and rights. Writing versus publishing Why writers shouldn’t chase publishing trends. Separating the creative process from the business process. What Justin learned from self-publishing. Why independent publishing can be a valuable learning experience. The role of a literary agent Joy’s unconventional journey into publishing. Why she became an agent. How writing her own books has made her more empathetic toward authors. What makes a strong book proposal. Why comparable titles matter. Marketing without losing yourself Why authors don’t necessarily need to become social media personalities. Choosing marketing approaches that fit your personality. The importance of personal relationships. Why word of mouth remains valuable. Understanding who your book is actually for. Creativity and the long game Why meaningful creative work requires learning. The importance of mentors and guides. How publishing can become part of an artist’s development. Why success doesn’t always look the way we imagined. Books and resources mentioned CMYK: The Process of Life Together — Justin McRoberts Get to the Publishing Punchline — Joy Eggerich Bega — Joy Eggerich and her father You’re So Strong — Leslie Harderburg The Correspondent — discussed as an example of word-of-mouth success Punchline Agency Punchline Publishers Links For Justin: Read Justin's Substack Order In The Low - NEW Book with Scott Erickson Coaching with Justin Order In Rest - New Book of Poems Order Sacred Strides JustinMcRoberts.com Support this podcast NEW Single - Let Go NEW Music - Sliver of Hope NEW Music - The Dood and The Bird The Book - It Is What You Make it Hearts and Minds Amazon Barnes and Noble

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

What does it actually take to get a book published today? Justin sits down with literary agent, author, and Punchline Agency founder Joy Eggerich to explore the changing publishing industry and what aspiring authors need to understand before bringing their work into the world. They discuss traditional publishing versus self-publishing, the importance of understanding book proposals, why publishers care about an author’s platform, and how writers can market their work without sacrificing their mental health or creative identity. Joy also shares her unconventional journey into publishing, the lessons she’s learned representing authors, and why she believes writers should pursue ideas they’re genuinely passionate about rather than chasing industry trends. Ultimately, this is a conversation about more than publishing. It’s about learning to navigate the business of creative work while protecting the curiosity, joy, and relationships that make the work worthwhile.

Ready to play

The Truth About Getting Published (From a Literary Agent) | Joy Eggerichs Reed

0:00 45:13

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of At Sea with Justin McRoberts?

This episode is 45 minutes long.

When was this At Sea with Justin McRoberts episode published?

This episode was published on October 26, 2026.

Can I download this At Sea with Justin McRoberts episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.