Skip to content
The Unfinished Amendments with Kevin Devine episode artwork

Dec 4, 2018 24 min

The Unfinished Amendments with Kevin Devine

from More Perfect Hosted by WNYC Studios

In More Perfect's final episode of the season, listen to liner notes for two amendments that contemplate the still-unfinished status of our Constitution. "27" is an album that marks a particular point in our history: this moment when we have 27 Amendments to our Constitution. What will be the 28th? Maybe it will address our nation's capital. The capital has been a bit of a Constitutional anomaly for much of our nation's history — it's at the heart of the democracy, but because it's not a state, people in Washington D.C. have been disenfranchised almost by accident. The 23rd Amendment solved some of the problem — it gave D.C. the right to vote for president. But it left much of D.C.'s representation questions unanswered. D.C. still does not have voting representation in Congress. Instead, D.C. sends a "non-voting delegate" to Congress. For this liner note, More Perfect profiles that delegate, Congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton, and her unique approach to fighting for power in a virtually powerless role. The song for the 23rd Amendment is by The Mellow Tones, a group of students from D.C. high school Duke Ellington School of the Arts, along with their teacher Mark G. Meadows. The chorus, "Why won't you count on me?" reflects on the continued disenfranchisement of our nation's capital. The final amendment of the album, the 27th Amendment, put limits on Senators' ability to give themselves a pay raise, and it has arguably the most unusual path to ratification of all 27. The first draft for the amendment was written by none other than James Madison in 1789, but back then, it didn't get enough votes from the states for ratification. It wasn't until a college student named Gregory Watson awakened the dormant amendment centuries later that it was finally ratified. The 27th Amendment song is by Kevin Devine and tells Watson's story. In Season Three, More Perfect is taking our camera lens off the Supreme Court and zooming in on the words of the people: the 27 amendments that We The People have made to our Constitution. We're taking on these 27 amendments both in song and in story. This episode is best listened to alongside "27: The Most Perfect Album," an entire album (an ALBUM!) and digital experience of original music and art inspired by the 27 Amendments. Think of these episodes as the audio liner notes. You can listen to all of the songs on "27: The Most Perfect Album" on YouTube and watch music videos from the album. Follow us on Instagram, Threads and Facebook @moreperfectpodcast, and X (Twitter) @moreperfect.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Unfinished Amendments with Kevin Devine

0:00 24:00
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Listener supported. WNYC Studios. So to make a long story short, we decided to put together an album to reanimate these crucially important words through the power of music. And in the podcast, we're offering little liner notes to the songs. We're telling stories about these amendments, about where they came from, what they mean to us now. And we have two amendments left, two songs to go with each of those two amendments. And we will begin this final episode with the one I just mentioned.

Shall appoint in such manner as Congress may direct a number of electors of president and vice president equal to the whole number of senators and representatives in Congress to which the district would be entitled if it were a state, if it were a state, if it were a state. Okay, we arrive at Amendment 23. All those words just a second ago, what they amount to is simply this. The 23rd Amendment gives the citizens of the District of Columbia, the citizens of D.C., the right to vote for president, which for me begs the question, D.C. didn't have the right to vote for president? What?

The White House is in D.C., for God's sakes. How did it take us 23 amendments to give the citizens of D.C. the right to vote for president? Why, Julia Longoria? Why? And why didn't they have that right in the first place? The short answer is it was kind of an accident. The reason why this ended up happening is the founders wanted to put the White House in a neutral place. They wanted it to be outside of state politics so you wouldn't run into a situation where, like, the Civil War breaks out and the White House is in Alabama. Like, what would Abraham Lincoln have done in that situation? We wanted to make sure the Capitol would operate from a peaceful place of neutrality.

So the founders took corners of Maryland and Virginia and created a city that would be controlled by Congress. I don't think anyone meant to disenfranchise all of the nearly 700,000 citizens that live in D.C., but that's what ended up happening. Because D.C. is not a state, the Constitution didn't really address it. For instance, it didn't have electors in the Electoral College. Alexander Hamilton thought eventually we'd fix the representation problem in D.C., but that didn't come until 1961 with Amendment No. 23. It's crazy it took that long. And did it actually fix the problem in the end? No, actually. All the 23rd Amendment did is give the citizens of D.C. the right to vote for president, which, you know, is no small thing.

it left many things unanswered. It didn't really clarify what D.C. is constitutionally. Like, is it a city? Is it a state? The way our system of government works, you've got to be part of a state to have senators. You've got to be part of a state to have a vote in the House. D.C. is simultaneously not a state and not part of a bigger state. So it's definitely a thing, but it's like not enough of a thing to get it full representation in Congress.

You don't have a full democracy unless you're treated equally. And the district is not treated equally because we're the only jurisdiction that pay federal taxes whose member cannot vote and whose member has no senators. And that's you. You can't vote, right? That's me. This is Congresswoman Eleanor Holmes Norton. And I represent the District of Columbia in the nation's capital. She kind of sits at the center of the blind spot of the 23rd Amendment. She's the non-voting delegate.

Yeah. Over the years, there have been... over 150 proposals to change this. Ideally, Eleanor wants to solve it by making D.C. the 51st state of the United States. But it's become like this political thing where like D.C. is very blue as a city. It's also 47% African-American. What's happened over the years is that some Republicans have found ways to block Eleanor Holmes Norton's efforts to get representation. Some people say it would be unconstitutional. A huge disappointment to me, but very frankly, I'm used to uphill battles, so you can get yourself together. A thing to know about Eleanor Holmes Norton is that long before she was the congresswoman from D.C., she was...

A civil rights activist. I will not heal, sir! A student organizer with the Mississippi Freedom Summer in the 1960s. Equality is not an ingrained part of this society, and I might add, of almost any other diverse society. Amazon made a show about a lawsuit she won for young women researchers at Newsweek. The idea of women's equality.

begins yesterday. When she was a lawyer at the ACLU, she won a historic First Amendment case where she represented white nationalists. Sometimes I gotta defend people who would not defend me. I mean, the woman is fascinating. She was the first woman to head the EEOC, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, and wrote the first federal guidelines that helped make sexual harassment illegal under federal law. And Eleanor Holmes Norton led the push so that Anita Hill could even be her. She was one of the people who demanded that Anita Hill be able to testify before the Senate.

She is a revolutionary. I would like to invite Congresswoman Norton up. Thank you so much. Which is why I found it strange to see her in this position. Thank you very, very much. Why would she choose this job? I christen this ship Potomac Water Taxi 2. Soon I hope to have a real name. The day we visited her, she was speaking at an event at The Wharf, a neighborhood on the water that she helped develop, to christen a new water taxi. May she bring...

And I know politicians have to do that sort of thing. But the juxtaposition of the revolutionary I read about. And this woman. Who I see smacking a staff against a yellow water taxi. It was confusing. You've been doing this for a long time, right?

Since 91. And I'm curious, you've had a really varied career. You know, I watched the Amazon special that's loosely based on your life. And you were the first woman, you know, all this. I wonder why you've made the turn to be in this position where your hands are tied. Ironically, my hands aren't tied in the least. I can't do the final vote, but by the time the final vote comes in the House, it's a done deal. So I have to do the work ahead of time, which is what every member, even those who have the vote.

What made things even more confusing is that she insisted that even though she cannot vote, her job is no different than any of her colleagues. I go to the House floor like everybody else. I work in committee where most of the work is being done. I go and talk to the members of the Senate. And it kept coming up. She kept harping on that point. My job is no different. Frankly, I do what everybody else does if you want to get a bill passed. At one point, she got really upset with us. This is why I don't like this. I have more. Just a moment.

Because we made the mistake of comparing the situation of D.C. to the territories, which also don't have voting representation in Congress, places like Puerto Rico and Guam. These are completely different places. It seemed almost like an insult to her to ask questions about this thing which seems so obviously true. Every single respect, except not having the final bill on the House floor, we are a state. What was that? What do you think that was?

The irony of this comes out almost cartoonishly when the press person that we talked to was in the room, Ben. He had told us that there was this buzzer that goes off in the office when there's a vote on the House floor. Ben was talking about a sound that happens when there's a vote or something like that. No, there's no vote. What is that? I don't know what that is. What is what? Now there's a vote. When you hear the bell, you know there's a vote. And this warns you that you have 15 minutes to go to the floor. Or when they signal whether it's a vote on the rule or on something else.

So that is supposed to signal, like, get your butt over there kind of thing? It does mean that if you have a vote, you should be preparing to go to vote, yes. And for you, what does that signal to you, or how does that make you feel? Well, that may mean I've been on the floor already to discuss the bill. I can discuss any bill, including bills I can't vote on, which is most bills, which are all bills.

I didn't know how to make sense of this irony. This woman, who's been representing disempowered people all her life, she's almost choosing to be in a role with virtually no power and then insisting in these moments that she's not disempowered at all. If I were going to demand change, it seems like I would shout from the rooftops that I don't have a vote, that my job is completely different, that I'm completely disempowered. But in these moments, Eleanor Holmes Norton had almost this willful denial of the miserable situation that D.C. finds itself in.

I only had about 15 minutes with Congresswoman Norton and I went home from D.C. totally baffled by the interaction. So I started looking back at her speeches and her writings, deep, deep cuts on C-SPAN. And I found this one panel from 1987 at the Sag Harbor Initiative. It was called The Retreat from Equality. And it clarified things for me. I do want to say something about the constitutional myth. Thurgood Marshall did a great service to the country in reminding it that revisionist history is very un-American and reminding us of the evolution of our own constitution.

But it is very important that myths not be associated only with negative aspects of American life. No society continues to grow without its own powerful myths. One of the only remaining powerful myths in American society with all of our diversity is the myth of the Constitution, the myth that all of us somehow have brought in, whatever our religious or ethnic or political background, into that wonderful, powerful myth. The fact that that myth has not always been real or true is quite beside the point. The myth of God is true.

For those who believe in God, even when there is war and famine and pestilence, it is the myth that makes people live through the pestilence so that they can indeed live full lives once again. The myth of the Constitution is in a very real sense the handiwork of black people who enjoyed it at least when there was nothing but racism. They believed those words. Because they believed them, they ultimately made them live. Black people, therefore, have to be...

At the forefront of those who celebrate the Constitution, not because it is perfect, but because they have made it more perfect. One of the worst things we could do in a time when so little brings us together is to try to debunk or destroy the one powerful myth that continues to animate the society, the myth of the great American Constitution, which has been copied all over the world and which continues to drive us to a more perfect society. In some ways, I think Eleanor Holmes Norton kind of stands in for D.C. She lives in a state.

of suspended denial in order to keep fighting. If she or black people or women or any of the people who were not in the original we the people, if we ever succumbed to our powerlessness, gave up, it would all be over. But if Eleanor Holmes Norton keeps believing in the Constitution, believing in the myth that it tells us the myth of her own power despite the odds, despite even the reality of her situation, maybe she can make her reality match the myth. I mean, hey, we got the 23rd Amendment, didn't we? That was Julia Longoria with that liner note for the 23rd Amendment. As for the album, we asked students at Duke Ellington School of the Arts to make a song for us about the 23rd Amendment. This song was written and arranged by their teacher, Mark Meadows. They performed it in the classroom. And by the way, you can see a video of this performance, and it's great, at themostperfectalbum.org. Here it is.

Duke Ellington School of the Arts. That was sort of an edited version of a song they put together for us for the 23rd Amendment. You can hear the entire thing and see the entire thing as well at themostperfectalbum.org. I'm Jad Abumran. We will return in a minute. This is More Perfect. I'm Jad Abumran. Okay, so here we are at the finish line, the very last of the amendments to the U.S. Constitution, 27. When we started this project, most of us here at More Perfect didn't know how many amendments there were or exactly what each of them meant. Now we do.

But more importantly, we picked the name 27. We included the number in the name. 27, the most perfect album. Because while we were making it, we realized that this project is a kind of time capsule. Right now, there are 27 amendments. But one day, there'll be 28. Then 29. Because clearly, we have not yet gotten to that more perfect union. And each one of these amendments represents a time when we try to fix something in ourselves. This project is a testament, a love letter, really, to that willingness to change. We're thinking of this album as sort of an emotional musical.

snapshot of who we are as a nation right now and who it is we're trying to become. So it's fitting that our last liner note is short, and it's really about that. Kevin Devine, the artist who wrote about the 27th Amendment for us, tells the story of one guy who spent 10 years trying to get two-thirds of both houses, three-quarters of the states, to ratify an amendment. that had been written almost 200 years earlier. So I got the 27th Amendment for this project. 27th Amendment. Congressional compensation. No law varying the compensation for the services of the senators and representatives shall take effect until an election of representatives shall have intervened. It just basically says the Congress can't give itself a raise in its sitting term. It's just a sound, sensible thing.

It was apparently brought forth in 1789 and then not ratified until 1992, which is by 190 years or something, the longest margin. And the story of the people I was interested in were this college kid in the early 80s who writes a paper saying that he believes that it could still be ratified and his teacher gives him a seat. And tells him, like, there's no way that could be true. And then this guy kind of makes it like his, I don't know, he kind of like bangs a drum about it for 10 years. It gets resurrected and eventually the 38th state to vote to ratify was Michigan.

In his speech, the guy who panged the gavel and made it so said that some things take a year around here, but others take a little more like 200. And I kind of bastardized that for the first line of the song because I thought it was a really good entry point. And I got a kick out of it as a lifelong Northeasterner family here in Jersey. Jersey was in line to beat the ratifying vote, but Michigan took it out of their hands. So one more bridesmaid moment for my people in New Jersey. So that's it. Kevin Devine with the 27th.

closing out the most perfect album. Okay, before we go, if 27 is just a moment in time, and I mean, my God, it's not the most exciting of the amendments. Clearly there are more to come. There must be more to come. We need more. Let's just ponder for a second as we go out.

What will be 28? Whatever it ends up being. Assuming it happens in our lifetimes, we will add a song to the album, maybe make a whole new album. Until then, More Perfect is produced by me, Jad Abumrad, Susie Lechtenberg, Julia Longoria, Kelly Prime, Sarakari, and Alex Overington with help from Ellie Mistal, Michelle Harris, and David Gable. All truly amazing people. I could not be more grateful to them all, including Nora Keller for her help making our record 27th Most Perfect Album, and of course Jeffrey Wright for reading the amendments for us. Oh, and of course, to all the musicians who took part...

I have no words. You guys made this thing a reality. Thank you from all of us here. You can listen to all of the songs as well as read funny short essays and also see some crazy music videos that we made at themostperfectalbum.org. Thank you all for listening, for riding on this journey with us. We will see you soon.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of More Perfect?

This episode is 24 minutes long.

When was this More Perfect episode published?

This episode was published on December 4, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this More Perfect episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.