The unspeakable evil that happened to Gabbi Doolin

Send us Fan Mail

Dare you tread the dark path which leads us to uncover the chilling tale of Scottsville, Kentucky's most devastating tragedy? Brace for impact as we unravel the details of merciless kidnapper and murderer, Timothy Madden, pulled from obscurity by the silent but damning witness - DNA evidence. Madden, with no prior run-ins with the law, became the embodiment of a community's worst nightmare, shaking it to its core. Hear the heartrending journey of a family torn asunder by this unthinkable loss, and the strength they displayed through a seemingly endless four-year wait for justice.

Join us on this emotional rollercoaster, as we navigate the tumultuous waters of Madden's trial - a spectacle of denial and pathos. A spectacle where Madden, ever the defiant convict, pleads not guilty to the charges of rape and sodomy, even in the face of irrefutable evidence. The courtroom, heavy with anticipation, resounds with the poignant impact statements of the victim's family, while Madden's own kin stand staunch in his defense. A life sentence seals Madden's fate, yet the plea deal that spared him the death penalty, and his inexplicable refusal to admit his full crimes, has left a bitter aftertaste in the mouths of many. Through this harrowing journey, the resilience of Gabby's family shines as a beacon of hope, a testament to human strength in the face of irreparable loss.

Support the show