Skip to content
The Venezuelan Crisis episode artwork

Sep 15, 2019 39 min

The Venezuelan Crisis

from What The Pho Travel Podcast

Here is our second documentary podcast and this one is a massive topic! In this doc we explain what has happened to Venezuela, we travel Colombia meeting the locals to see how the crisis has affected Venezuela's neighbour, we met Venezuelans making a new life in Colombia and we hear direct from Caracas, the Venezuelan capital. Join us on this journey to meet some fascinating people & places, and learn about the worst humanitarian crisis ever in the Americas! Do you or your company want to start your own podcast, or need help running your existing one? We've started our own company to help with exactly that! https://www.ant-podcastmanagement.com Also, if you want to join AirBnB then use this link to get money towards your first stays. We also get some credit so it's a win win! https://abnb.me/e/ABEgWvim4S ====================================== Follow us… Patreon: www.patreon.com/whatthepho Website: www.whatthephotravelpodcast.com Twitter: @phopodcast Email: [email protected] Facebook: Facebook.com/phopodcast Instagram: @whatthepho_podcast #travel #travelpodcast #wanderlust #backpack #backpacking #world #aroundtheworld #travelling #traveling #history #culture #Venezuela #Colombia #VisitColombia #TheVenezuelanCrisis #southamerica #travelsouthamerica

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

The Venezuelan Crisis

0:00 39:22
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The worst humanitarian crisis ever in the Western Hemisphere. Over 4 million refugees. 90% of the population living below the poverty line. Food and medicine shortages. Extreme inflation. This is the Venezuelan crisis. Hi and welcome to this What the Foe documentary podcast with Nick and Amy. Now this one is about the Venezuelan crisis and the effect it's been having on its neighbouring country, Colombia. Yeah, now this year we've been lucky enough to travel almost all of South America.

And this is the big topic. It's the big thing that's going on here right now. And I think every country we've been to, we have seen Venezuelan refugees, haven't we? Absolutely. Whether that's them being on the street with their suitcases or if they're working in a restaurant or a bar or a barber's, you know, so many different skills and areas of life that we've seen them. Yeah, that's so true. Such a good point. So that's why we wanted to, you know, we wanted to do something about it. We couldn't ignore it. We wanted to make some sort of podcast about it, telling the story and meeting people that are affected by it. So that is what this podcast is all about. Now, we wanted to focus on the side coming from Colombia because you can look into any news outlet.

and they will tell you what's happening in Venezuela and give you quite a real account of what's happening. So we didn't want to saturate that side of the media anymore. We wanted to tell you what it's like for their neighboring country, Colombia, because they've taken in a lot of Venezuelans due to their history, which we'll tell you about in this podcast. So in this podcast, you will hear from Colombians in Medellin. The thing is we need to control the situation with them and to legalize the situation with them because otherwise it's going to get out of control. We head to the front line, Colombia's border town of Cucuta.

We speak to Venezuelans making a new life in Colombia. It's not a surprise that it's hard for people that doesn't have a degree can find a job easily. And we hear direct from Caracas, the Venezuelan capital. Having a normal life from 99% of the country, it's not possible at all. So join us as we learn about how the situation happened and hear from the people affected by it.

Now, first, we need to understand how once Latin America's richest country has declined into chaos. My name is Pilar Marrero. I'm Venezuelan. I was born and raised and studied in Venezuela. I moved to the United States in the late 80s. But all my family is still there. My parents remain there, my brothers and sisters, my cousins. My parents are now deceased. And many of my cousins and nephews and nieces have left the country because there's really no future there. Pilar, a journalist and podcaster, is going to explain what went so wrong. We're talking about 20 years of policy, 20 years of...

Two governments, the government of Hugo Chavez and the government of Nicolás Maduro starting in 2013 when Hugo Chavez died. He took over after that. So it's the gravest economic collapse any country has ever had outside of a war or a natural disaster. It's a really dire situation. I mean, dire is not enough of an adjective to really explain it. But I think a large part of the explanation for these collapse has to do with what happened with the oil industry.

So the country is a petro state, meaning all of its economy is based on oil, like 95 percent of the economy. And this is before Chavez. This was true before Chavez. This was true after Chavez. This is still true today. This is one of the reasons or the foundation of why it's doing so badly. The country has the largest proven reserves of oil in the world.

You know, it's somewhat justified to think that you can base all of your economy on something like that. But everyone also knows that the price of oil goes up and down. And there are times when everything's up and there are times when it goes down. And that when it's up, you should be doing certain things like saving for a later day, like fixing the whatever the infrastructure, keeping up the infrastructure of the oil industry, et cetera, et cetera. Hugo Chavez takes in in 1999 when oil was very low. But then in 2003, it shut up.

to its highest point, over $100 barrel. So he says, OK, I'm going to use this money to implement all the programs that I want to implement, to deepen the socialist revolution, et cetera, et cetera. So what happens is that he starts spending like crazy. And instead of saving something and putting some aside, he actually starts going into debt. At the same time, he wants to deepen the socialist revolution. So he starts taking over private enterprises, taking over private corporations. Essentially, he wanted the state to own all the means of production, which is what socialism is, right, in its purest form.

So what happens is that the production by the private enterprise, by private companies, you know, starts going down, starts disappearing, companies start leaving. And so instead of using those companies and growing those companies, many of those companies go under. Or those companies are taken over by political appointees, like eventually happened with the oil industry. And of course, that brings in a whole host of problems. It was essentially the oil industry was deep professionalized. So there was a strike.

The leaders of PDVSA, which is the oil industry, went on strike. Many of them were in the opposition. They were against the policies that were being implemented, etc., etc. And what Chavez does is he fires 20,000 people from PDVSA. So at this point, he starts putting all these political appointees and people from his party in charge. And what happens is there's a lot of corruption. There's a lot of lack of investment. There's all this disarray going on. When the oil starts going down, which happened a little bit before he died and then after he died, oil prices really started to go down. Already, the economy of Venezuela was very weak. Production had fallen.

And in fact, I think Venezuela right now produces less oil than it produced 50 years ago. So for a country that fully depends on oil, if your oil production falls four or five times to something that's not sustainable, that's not producing the dollars you need to buy imports, because Venezuela produces nothing else. So they have to buy everything from the outside. And you need dollars for that, right? So all of it is compounded. And it creates all of these crises when the prices go down. And instead of spending less...

You keep spending, like you still have the money and getting more and more into debt. So Maduro comes in and he goes into debt with China. He goes into debt with Russia. So he keeps spending to try to keep the social programs, try to keep his supporters happy. But it's impossible because he just simply doesn't have the money. That's a huge part of it. Of course, in 2017, the United States imposes financial sanctions. And then this year it imposed oil sanctions, which, of course, is going to deepen whatever problems Venezuela has.

However, the deep economic recession that Venezuela was in, the problem with the collapse of the oil industry was already a problem even before 2017. So this is the summary. Of course, now you have to go and explain, you know, and go to what happened with the electricity grid. What happened with, you know, the public sector services is that they also collapsed because they were not being kept up. They were not being maintained. There was no investment in them. So it's a really sad situation. But the reality is that all of this was preventable. All of it.

We're in Colombia, Venezuela's neighbor and the country that has taken in the most Venezuelan refugees, over one million. Here is the Colombian president, Ivan Duque, being interviewed by the Financial Times in mid-2019. He was asked if he wants to sit down with the Venezuelan president, Nicolas Maduro, and discuss a solution about the Venezuelan refugee situation. Maduro is a dictator. And let me begin by saying something. Most of the countries in Latin America did not recognize the results of the last election where he manipulated all the power to remain in his seat. So when we look at that...

He's obviously not a fan of Maduro, but listen again to how he describes the Venezuelan people. Now, to understand why he's referring to them as brothers, you need to look back at the two countries' history. From 1819 to 1830, Colombia and Venezuela, along with Panama and Ecuador, were part of the same country, Gran Colombia. If this wasn't a strong enough bond... Historically, Colombians have actually fled to Venezuela to escape their own internal conflicts. Maybe Colombians feel like they owe it to themselves and their neighbors to help them out. That's one of the things that we're here to find out.

We begin our journey in Medellín. Once the world's most dangerous city and the setting of drug wars, this place, as well as the whole of Colombia, has come a long way. Tourists only started coming to Colombia in numbers in 2014. That's Daniel, who provides tours around Comuna 13. A few years ago, Comuna 13 was considered the most dangerous area in Medellín. Remember, the most dangerous city in the world. Tourists didn't dare set foot here and locals were too ashamed to admit they lived in the favela, or barrios, that clings to a mountain in western Medellín.

Now, it's a very different story. Comuna 13 has undergone a complete transformation. The area is no longer known for gang violence, police raids, cartels and illegal trafficking. These days, Comuna 13 is known for graffiti, street art performances and walking tours. Being a Medellin resident, we wanted to ask Daniel if Colombians here want to help Venezuelans. Yes, we do help them a lot. People come to live here and we open our doors to them so they can live with us.

It's the same as we would do for you or anyone else. Since the crisis in Venezuela, has there been a negative impact here in Colombia? Yes, there has been a negative economic impact. We support them, as I was explaining to you, because they're human beings, but everything has its consequences. They come here and offer their labor very cheap, and for that reason, that has complicated the job market for my fellow Colombians. And yes, that has made things tough, but we would not reject them for that reason.

Now we just want to pause for a second to say a massive thank you to long-term listener Carlos Fabrega. We want to say thank you so much because he actually translated and read out that last interview. So thank you for supporting the show and helping us out. Thank you, Carlos. Now, during our time in Medellin, we also were able to talk to Mauricio and Meli, a young, engaged couple living and working in the city. We wanted to know if they shared Daniel's views.

It's not easy for them. They're professionals, they're doctors, engineers, and here they're just waiters. And you've met those people, haven't you? You were in a restaurant and you were being waited by a doctor. Yeah. How does that make you feel? It was weird because he could speak like English, Portuguese, Spanish, and he was a doctor in Venezuela. And then he was here as a waiter and earning like nothing of money. So it was sad, but he was happy because he could help the family with that little money. It's sad. They're trying to survive. Yeah.

We think we should help them because in the past when in Colombia the situation it was not that hard but it was difficult for us and a lot of Colombians go to Venezuela to have a better life so now they are coming and we have to help them but it's been too much Venezuelans on the streets and it makes the city look like there are a lot of homeless so it looks like insecurity or unsafe tourist or local people think it's hard to live with that situation.

We asked, apart from homeless people making the streets appear unsafe, are there any other negative impacts on Colombia? Yes, because of the change of the money. So the money that they earn in here helps a lot to people in Venezuela who lives there. So they earn the money here and they send it home. So that helps a lot. So in here they give their job for less money than a Colombian do. So it's hard for Colombians to get a job because obviously for us we need more money to survive and they need less. In restaurants, in stores, in a lot of places.

It's full of Venezuelans because it's cheaper for the employer. And they're illegal. A lot of them are illegal. I think that's the main problem. As Mauricio said, many of the Venezuelans are illegal. We were told that one of the main reasons for this was because the Venezuelan government actually stopped producing passports a few years ago. This has meant that many desperate Venezuelans have had no choice but to leave without papers. Mauricio and Meli want to help these people and Colombia by legalizing these refugees so they can get proper jobs and they can pay Colombian taxes.

At this stage, we thought we had to get closer to the crisis. It's nice that people here in Medellin want to help, but some might say that they're slightly removed from it all. Somewhere that is not removed and is smack bang in the middle of the crisis is Cúcuta, a Colombian city on the border with Venezuela. Against the advice of some people, we boarded a plane from Medellin, very anxious, but very curious about what we'd find there. And what we found there really surprised us.

A normal, nice town. People were enjoying their lives, laughing and dancing, only a matter of meters away from the worst humanitarian crisis ever in the Americas. For our time in Cúcuta, we were staying with a couple, Daniel, a Colombian, and Gustavo, who is Venezuelan. They agreed to show us around their city and to take us to the border tomorrow, but for today, they invited us on a night out. So the next morning, after what was a really good night out, we had a great time, there was great music, and just the whole, I have to say, the whole time we were in Cucuta, it wasn't this big, scary place we thought it was going to be. It was a normal, nice town, wasn't it? Absolutely. Yeah, I was actually really impressed with it. So after our nice night out with Danielle and Gustavo, they drove us to the border. It's actually a bridge that connects the two countries over the river Tachira. And when we got there, again, it wasn't this big, scary place we thought it was going to be, the border, was it? No, actually, our two hosts said to us that they don't like going to the border. It makes them slightly nervous. So that, in turn, made us a bit more anxious. Yeah. But when we arrived...

Everybody was just going along with their own normal lives. They were walking around, they were sailing. It was hectic South America, as the other countries are. I completely agree. It wasn't different to many other places in South America that we've been to. Yeah, so it seemed pretty peaceful. But there were plenty of people making the Daily Cross to buy supplies or to see friends and family. But this border hasn't always been peaceful. In February, the Venezuelan government closed this border and many others in retaliation as their oppositions tried to deliver food and medical aid supplies into the country. Most of this aid was coming from the USA and Maduro rejected it.

saying it was an infringement on Venezuela's sovereignty. Four months later, and the border has reopened, and long lines and thousands of Venezuelans poured into Cucuta. We were keen to ask Daniel how his city has changed since the Venezuelan crisis. Well, I think that it has changed, but it also hasn't at the same time. The quality of life in Venezuela has deteriorated a lot, but before the crisis, Venezuelans used to come and spend their money here in Colombia. Cucuta used to be like a small Miami.

People would come here with a lot of money. They would spend a weekend here. They would buy Christmas gifts, buy clothes, groceries. They would stay here and support the tourism. They would go out to eat, to have fun. And obviously, for us, it was not a problem. We benefited from it greatly because the Venezuelans would come and leave their money here. Right now, they still do, but the reason is completely different. They come to buy and leave here, but it stems from the crisis in Venezuela because right now, they can't get goods or medication. For example, the price is barely too much. Let's say that a bag of sugar cost 3,000 Colombian pesos yesterday. Then today, it costs 6,000 or 7,000 and doubles.

One may say it's normal for prices to go up, but over there in Venezuela, prices are going up about 10 times in a year. Basically, every month the prices are going up, so it deteriorates the quality of life over there. And the other thing is that many businesses are closing in Venezuela, we're going bankrupt. Businesses need quality and consistent electrical power, and it has been deteriorating in Venezuela. We have seen in the news that there has been power outages for two or three days at a time. Three or four years ago, we will see power outages for one, two, three hours a day, and it started to hurt businesses. Many companies, they were located in Venezuela or the border, they moved to Tucuta.

Also, a lot of people have preferred to come to Colombia. Venezuelans have various skills and qualified manual levers, so this has caused the work dynamics in the cities to change. They have lowered the cost for manual levers. If you go to a restaurant, you will see the waiter is Venezuelan, the chef is Venezuelan. If you go to a barbershop, a large percentage are Venezuelans. In one way, it's good to enrich the culture and the way we do things. As a country, we are not prepared to receive this amount of immigrants. It's been difficult for my city. However, looking at it from a positive side, it's made the...

people here stopped depending so much on Venezuela. For example, in the last few years, the fear of Cucuta has returned. Large commercial centers have been built, and hotels are popping up all over the metropolitan area. There are three large hotel chains in Cucuta. So I feel in one way or another, it has incentivized the city to bait the economy around Cucuta.

We're interested to know if these two groups of people living together, Venezuelans and Colombians, does that cause many problems? Are there many conflicts? Yes, I guess at times. But I've also always thought that we have been a country that has always immigrated to other countries because of the internal conflicts Colombia had for many years. This conflict lasted almost 60 years and resulted in Colombians going to Ecuador or Venezuela for a better life. There are many Colombians that went to Venezuela and they now have returned.

They think that close to 4 million Venezuelans have crossed through the border to Colombia. It's estimated 1 million Venezuelans are now living here in Colombia. That has displayed the labor force from one business to another. Many people have complained about this. Another thing Colombians complain about is this has put pressure on the healthcare system. The healthcare system in Colombia is vulnerable. I think it's good that many people are in favor of helping our Venezuelans brother because that's what we are, brothers. However, our health and education department have suffered. In addition, we also have defects.

within our system, we do not have good ways to control or administer tax money of the Colombian people. Many people have benefited or have basically robbed this tax money, which doesn't help Colombians or Venezuelans. So, unfortunately, political campaigns trying to get into power, they will use this conflict with Venezuela to their advantage. Finally, I must say that Colombian people are very eager to help. We have helped where we can, and perhaps there is no more we can do, but we have tried to do what we can.

And another brief pause to say a massive thanks to Karim there for reading out that last interview. And again, it was translated by Carlos. During our time in Cucuta, we were keen to hear Gustavo's story. He came to Colombia four years ago and fortunately found a job and a comfortable, happy life. But for many Venezuelans, this isn't the case.

The thing with Cucuta is that Cucuta has always been very open with the farmers because we are in the border and in the border you always meet people from the whole world. It's not only Venezuelan, we have Peruvians here, we have Equatorians and other people that came from the other countries where they born. And they came here, the city opened their arms because they see an opportunity for work or for make productivity for the city. And it's really... His mum still lives in Venezuela, but close to the border. Gustavo explains that she actually isn't affected too badly because the border has its own economy. Some companies close to the Venezuelan border actually even pay their staff in Colombian pesos.

She works as a teacher in a primary school. Gustavo explains one of the reasons why she wants to stay in Venezuela. She helps also their students because there are some cases that one child didn't eat from free days. And she makes things and helps her and talks with her friends and gets them some groceries or food or something. She's trying to help them. So I think that's the way why she didn't come here because she's thinking that maybe she's supporting something from people that doesn't have at all anything. Now it's time to go in to Venezuela. Not us physically, but we're going to hear from someone living in the capital, Caracas.

My name is Miguel Arturo. I'm from Caracas. I study psychology. Miguel lives in the city and has invited travelers on the Couchsurfing app to stay with him. He joined us on Skype to tell us if it's possible to have a normal life in Caracas right now. Well, the thing in Venezuela is that I think it's hard for some people to understand crisis because there are always places where rich people live and not the same things happen there. So Venezuela is not a different in that way, so there are places.

where you live and like all things are private properties and they have security guard and they have all tanks in their house some of them has electricity plants that work with gasoline which is really cheap so yeah that's the thing having a normal life from 99 of the country it's not possible at all because you depend on public services like water and electricity and gas it's not constant working i mean the electricity can be gone at any time during the day some places have already like every day the same time itself and some places which is the water more problems in carcassi it's usually better than the rest of the country. So yeah, it's not possible at all. Medicine is the hardest thing to find here.

So, yeah, it's almost impossible. There is actually, in the recent years here in Venezuela, we have started to see, like, kind of zombies in the city. People that, like, their job does not pay enough to pay the public transport, so you don't know what to do. So you cannot go to the work, but you can stay at home, so it's not much to do. So you just walk around trying to find something to buy or resell, and, yeah, that's it. It's really hard to find employees here, because most of the people live in places where they don't have access to public transport. 80% of public transport has the unit stay, like the bus. Once it gets broke, it's not fixed.

So it's a state, just broken. The people who can't find a job that pays enough money to make it worth going to work, how do they survive? Like you said, maybe finding things to sell, or do they rely on friends and family who are outside the country sending money back? Things change here every day. So in the recent years, that's what's been happening. Many people leave from the money that people abroad send. There is not a legal way to spend money here. So you have always to do it illegally. But other people just have their houses because they bought it years ago. So they only need to find food. If they get sick, they mostly die.

And when you ask someone for a diet, for a daily diet, it's really like yuca, which is like potato but cheaper, mango, which is in the trees in Caracas, protein, they don't eat meat or beans that has the protein, so a lot of problem with that. And the people are really, really starving, really skinny. Every day a lot of people go to leave Colombia, Peru, Ecuador, but at the same time it gets harder to find a job there. So we see more people going, but then I don't know how much cash is flowing into Venezuela. Do you personally have friends and family that have moved out of the country?

Yes, my brother is in Spain, my prima. Your cousin? Yeah, some family in Chile, in US, yeah, almost everywhere. You as a local person, is it safe just to walk around Caracas, like to walk around the streets? It has to get safe for Caracas and Venezuela. I know you see the news, and some people who live abroad, they see the news in Venezuela, all together with some other news, and they actually haven't been here, so it's like, well, I heard it wasn't food. Now it's a lot of food here, but people can't afford it. So when they change the stuff, I don't think people understand, so Venezuela used to be really unsafe.

Now it's safer. But the reason why it's because the government has implemented some, I think it's called hardline policy. There's police getting into the ghettos, favelas, I don't know how to say, barrios, to kill every young male around my age or younger who might be, who could be related to crime. They dress like civilians and they get into the ghettos, so they check the people, they take photos, and in the middle of the night they go in and kill them all. How about you? Do you have hope for the future? What do you think will happen in the next few years? Or what do you hope will happen in the next few years? We were keen to get some advice for tourists if they insist on going to Venezuela during the crisis.

You can't get into Venezuela, just it will be hard to your entry stamp because they will want you to pay for that. And then the harder thing is crossing through the country. There is a lot of police stops, and it's in the middle of nowhere, so they ask for money. And 100% sure they will ask you for money. And they can actually get you there for no reason and make you working for them like slavery. It happens every time. When you go through Venezuela, you see police stops that have civilians cleaning and do their job free because it's like slavery. They kidnap you, basically. But I have host people.

And they have survived because they say, man, I don't have money at all. They look like hippies, or even worse, they look like homeless. And it's like, dude, I don't have money at all. I only take photos when they phone, and I won't give you my phone because all my trip is in this one. So I don't know what you're going to do, but I won't do that. And I know it's hard. You need to be really, really strong because your embassy might not be here, your diplomatics. So you can now go to, okay, I'm German, you know, we'll go to the embassy and say, hey, this happened to me. Could you help me? No, no, there's no diplomatic relations. So it's like getting lost in North Korea.

It's possible, because people have done it. I always say, hey, come here, but don't bring any kind of expensive things. And some dollars into your underwear, and it's enough. Some clothes, all clothes, and you will survive. I've received some requests from car surfing. Many people ask me, a lot of people ask me in car surfing, can I go, can I go? I always answer the same, go, dress like a homeless, behave like a homeless. But it's a pity, because girls have to be more careful, I think. This is not a country where, like, I never heard about a rape or something like that. It's like, maybe you don't have money, but you are pretty, and they are old men, and they have no...

There's no idea of feminism here. No, no way, man. There's no other thing like that. Things change here every month. So you might find people that live, I don't know, one year in Colombia or wherever, and they might tell you, like, no, Venezuela is too dangerous. But things have changed. Change here every day without surface. You think I can go in three months to Venezuela? I can tell. I can tell. I don't know. Maybe three months ago, things were completely different. Now, yeah, they change every time. So it's hard to say. So when you understand Venezuela, it's always about following the news and reading papers. There are a lot of papers. Universities still publish good papers.

about it. So that's what people who are interested in understanding is what I should read papers, follow the news, trying to ask locals who just leave the country or are still living there because it's changing every day. If people are listening now, like in England or in America, anywhere, and they think, I want to help, but what can I do? Is there anything people can do to help? What they can do, 100%, is helping Venezuelans who are living now in their country. And understand these people have had a really bad time, so in some countries, Venezuelan people do bad stuff, so they start thinking all Venezuelans are the same. The people that go to live abroad, they really want to change, they really want to do their things right. So, yeah, the most helpful thing, you can find a Venezuelan community and trying to help them to find a job, teaching their language, I don't know, showing them helpful tips, give them some tools to live in their country.

A sad, depressing, but fascinating interview there with Miguel. So we do really appreciate that. It was really interesting to hear from inside Venezuela. We hope that this podcast has opened your eyes to the situation. And like Miguel said, maybe it will change your behaviour in the future towards Venezuelans next time you see one. Yeah, and of course, some have committed crimes and done bad things, just like any other nationality on this planet. But these people are desperate and they're going through something that can happen to any country, my country and your country. Mismanagement by the government and the general public are not at fault here.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of What The Pho Travel Podcast?

This episode is 39 minutes long.

When was this What The Pho Travel Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on September 15, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this What The Pho Travel Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.