The Warning That Came True: The Hart Family Case

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.Episode Notes — The Warning That Came True: The Hart Family CaseCase: The Hart family Locations: Minnesota, West Linn (Oregon), Woodland (Washington), Mendocino County (California) Period covered: 2006–2019Key people:Jennifer Hart and Sarah Hart — adoptive parents, ruled to have died by suicide after intentionally killing their six childrenMarkis, Hannah, and Abigail Hart — adopted 2006Devonte, Jeremiah, and Ciera Hart — adopted 2009; Devonte was the boy in the widely shared 2014 photograph hugging a police officer at a Portland protestPriscilla Celestine — one of the children's birth mothers, who fought to maintain contact after the original Texas removalTimeline:2006 — Markis, Hannah, and Abigail adopted via a Minnesota agency, placed from Texas2009 — Devonte, Jeremiah, and Ciera adopted through the same agency2010 — a Minnesota teacher notices bruising on Abigail; she discloses being beaten2011 — Sarah Hart charged with domestic assault; a Minnesota caseworker warns in writing that the children risk "falling through the cracks"July 2013 — Oregon investigates a new report with the Minnesota history on file; closes it for "insufficient evidence"November 2014 — Devonte's photo goes viral internationallySummer 2017 — Hannah discloses abuse to a neighborLate 2017 — family relocates to Woodland, Washington; new neighbors report food restriction and hours-long confinement23 March 2018 — Washington opens a CPS investigation; family flees within hours26 March 2018 — second failed contact attempt; SUV found at the bottom of a Mendocino County cliff the same day27 March 2018 — third failed contact attempt, after the deaths had already occurredOctober 2018 — a biological mother identifies herself via DNA match2019 — Mendocino County coroner's inquest jury rules the deaths a murder-suicideThemes covered:A documented, written caseworker prediction that came true almost exactly as describedInterstate adoption oversight gaps under the Interstate Compact on the Placement of ChildrenThe distance between a family's public image and its private realityBirth family erasure within the closed-adoption processA note on unconfirmed facts: No sweeping federal reform of the Interstate Compact on the Placement of Children has been confirmed to have passed as a direct result of this case. This is stated honestly rather than overstated.Sources: Mendocino County coroner's inquest findings, Washington Post investigative reporting, published work by journalist Roxanna Asgarian, and contemporaneous news coverage across Minnesota, Oregon, Washington, and California outlets.