Skip to content
There Were These Gatherings, See episode artwork

May 4, 2025 19 min

There Were These Gatherings, See

from Never The Chameleon Hosted by Anna Madsen

Grace to you and peace from our Lord and Savior, Jesus the Christ. So in the early 2nd century, a fellow named Pliny the Younger was a Governor of Bithynia and Pontus. We don’t have much for which to thank Pliny, as you’ll hear, but he did write a now-famous and very valuable letter to the Roman Emperor Trajan—as a little sermonic card-tip here, he addressed it “Lord,” which in Latin was Domine, in Greek kurios: you might recognize kurios as the word Christians used for Jesus. ANYway, his little epistle gives us some huge clues to life as a Christian in the nascent early Church, so thank you Pliny. See, Pliny had been doing what good political lackeys do: he’d been faithfully persecuting Christians, according to Trajan’s bidding. Trouble was, once he had them, Pliny wasn’t so sure what he was supposed to do with them—clearly they posed a threat…though they were arrested with no exact named crime. The trouble with most Christians seems to be that they’d refused to offer the mandated obedience to Roman gods. They refused to pledge allegiance to the ruler, opting instead for some guy named Jesus. Obviously, that could not be tolerated, for it meant that this band of very bad people were collectively subversive, and, because they gathered, it didn’t take a rocket scientist (even though they didn’t have those back then, but work with me) to figure that they were organizing for more subversiveness. No autocrat can have that.Pliny the Younger considered himself also Pliny the Generous, noting that he gave Christians three whole opportunities to deny their faith before he killed them. “Those who denied being Christians now or in the past,” he said, “I thought necessary to release, since they invoked our gods according to the formula I gave them, and since they offered sacrifices of wine and incense before your image—which I had brought in for this purpose—along with the statues of our gods. I also had them curse Christ. It is said that real Christians cannot be forced to do any of these things.” See, just being Christian, just following the ways of Jesus, was enough for imprisonment and death, because aligning yourself with any principle or power short of the ruler was considered seditious behavior, and therefore intolerable to the Empire: any hostility to their edicts was considered hostility to the government, to the Emperor’s power, and to the supreme ruler’s intention to govern with his power unchecked. So the Christians needed to be checked. Pliny was so dedicated to rooting out these traitors that, in order to gather his indicting intel, Pliny tortured two “deaconesses,” and I’m totally going to take the quick opportunity to point out that this is a clear indication that there were women leaders in the early church. Anyway, exasperated, Pliny said he didn’t learn very much from them other than their “depraved, excessive superstition” in Jesus. What had became clear, he said, was that Christianity was spreading, both in cities and rural areas. There were these gatherings, see. At these common meetings, Pliny said, he’d learned that Christians had a custom “to gather before dawn on a fixed day and to sing a hymn to Christ as if to a god, and to bind themselves by an oath [the word here is sacramento] not for any criminal purpose, but to abstain from theft, robbery, adultery, fraud, and to repay debts. With this complete, it had been their custom to separate, and to meet again to take food—but quite ordinary, harmless food.” Pliny ruled right around the year 110. About 20 years before that, a certain John of Patmos—not to be confused with John the beloved disciple, who is not to be confused with the gospel writer John, who also was not John of Patmos—wrote seven letters, bound together. They became known as the book of Revelation—little aside pet peeve, here, it is not the book of RevelationS, just Revelation. He had time to write (though that he could write at all indicates that he was learned), because the Romans had imprisoned him on the island of Patmos for refusing to participate in their cult: it was the cult of those who followed their political leader, the Caesar, who at that time was Domitian. Domitian, yeah, he really grooved on public accolades and follower worship: remains of a temple and a huge statue, both built to glorify Domitian, have been found in Ephesus—as in Ephesians Ephesus. When I say that it was a cult, I’m not making it up, you see. No one knows exactly what John did to annoy the ruler—as an aside, in Revelation, John seems to be referencing not only Domitian, but also Nero, a corrupt, dangerous, and violent ruler: in fact, most scholars believe that the infamous number 666, so scary that some long books even skip from page 665 to 667, is simply code for Nero’s name, according to the Jewish numerology practice of gematria. To be honest, no one is even entirely sure who John himself was, but for a variety of reasons, the consensus hunch is that he was a leader, a prophet, within the young Christian community. Revelation, also known as the Apocalypse—which comes from the Greek word which means ‘revelation,’ or ‘unveiling,’ hence the name of the book—is even considered by some to be a letter of pastoral care. New Testament M. Eugene Boring believes John felt he had a “pastoral responsibility” to its recipients, people Boring says who faced the same threat—persecution, repression, and forced loyalty to the false god, namely the Roman Emperor and Empire—as he had. John wanted to acknowledge their fear and impart strength. Upshot: the entire book, that is, is a banger: an encrypted message written in Jewish metaphoric and numerological code—yes, it’s a bit psychedelic, but that’s because it dips out of the tradition of apocalyptic literature, and because John was clever: the Roman goons didn’t know Jewish imagery and numerology, but his people did. He needed them to know, but the authorities to miss the subversive word that God’s promises were true; that only God was worthy of adoration—not some paranoid and needy ruler armed with malice and hate; and that the Christian community was called to gather together regularly so that they could remain strong, buoyed, courageous, connected, and joyful, despite the threats of the beast. Lutheran theologian Rev. Dr. Barbara Rossing, whose expertise is precisely in the book of Revelation, writes that these early Christians “gathered together and worshiped God, convinced that, as Chilean scholar Pablo Richard describes early Christian ethics, 'Jesus has set up here on earth a community that is an alternative to empire.’ Early Christians ministered to the poor. They visited prisoners. They broke bread together, and they sang hymns to God and the Lamb.” This is what Christians did. Trouble was, this Way, being people of the Way really messes with the agenda of an autocrat. ~~~~~ An enormous part of our liturgy comes from the book of Revelation: did the passage from today sound familiar, for example? ‘Liturgy’ stems from two Greek words smushed together: laos, which means people—hence, for example, ‘laity’—and ergos, namely a work, or a task, that sets out to complete a specific purpose—think ‘ergonomics’—so it literally means “work of the people.” While modern folk are most familiar with word ‘liturgy’ meaning a ritual of worship, the word originally referred to the work, namely the business, the service, and the donations that privileged people in Athens and beyond offered to and for the well-being of the people, (the laity) of the community. When absorbed into the Christian world, though, laos specifically referred to the people of God; their shared mission—to worship God, to serve only God, and to be representatives of God’s will and ways in the world—became known as the liturgy. Their entire way of life, that is, rooted in worship, especially the meal and the water and the hymns, was their living liturgy: works by the people of God for the people of God, if you will. The Romans understood worship very differently, and t… Get full access to Anna Madsen at revdrannam.substack.com/subscribe

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

There Were These Gatherings, See

0:00 19:28

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Never The Chameleon?

This episode is 19 minutes long.

When was this Never The Chameleon episode published?

This episode was published on May 4, 2025.

Can I download this Never The Chameleon episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.