Eric Shuski's weekly U-demon. This dude abides. He's never out of his element, so sit back with a Cesterilla and enjoy. These six traits make a person a Gnostic.
I subtitled this a diagnostic of a Gnostic, actually that's courtesy of my youngest daughter Tess. I thought that was pretty funny. That's pretty good, so I went with it. All right, Eric Voglin was to modern narcissism, what Newt Rockley was to donate football.
Rockley didn't start the ND football program, and Voglin then discovered modern narcissism, but they took their subjects to much higher levels. It was actually the Swiss theologian Hans-Arzmann Balthasar. He was supposed to be the first person to draw parallels between the ancient Gnostic heresy and modern theories in Prometheus that was 1937. It was an examination of modern German thought.
Then Albert Camus did the same thing, or similar thing, in his book The Rebel in 1951, and I read parts of The Rebel, which is difficult. I can't even find about the Balthasar's Prometheus frustrating book. I'll get through both of them eventually. But be that as it may, Voglin took the strain of thought much further in his book, The New Science Politics, 1952.
The book became a kind cover story, and voila, narcissism was in the limelight, at least among nerds. Granted, later in life, Voglin said he wasn't sure narcissism was the best term to use, and thought perhaps it received too much attention. But he didn't remotely conclude that the term didn't work. I mean, far from it.
His last popular halfway popular book, and none of his books are really popular, but his most popular and assessment book, Science Politics and Narcissism, came out in 1968 when he was 67 years old, and he was still using the term and carefully examining narcissism. So he clearly, I mean far from abandoned, he still thought it was a good term. Okay, now here's the thing. We're gonna be looking hard at narcissism probably for three, five, six podcasts.
I have a big podcast episode, by the way. If you go back and you mind through the old weekly demon episodes, I dedicated four or five segments to narcissism, and I made to put all those together and put them out at once, but no matter. For now, let's just look at narcissism, and what you need to be careful of is just don't accuse everyone you disagree with being a narcissist. Here's the thing, narcissism is both precise and vague.
It's vague in the sense that it touches on the dau and transcendence, but it's precise in the sense that specific characteristics need to come together in order to keyhole someone as a Gnostic. We all know we tend to label our opponents. If we can label a person, we can dismiss a person. It's practically a trope that doesn't even need to be mentioned, but most of us do it anyway.
You know, he's just a Gnostic at them. Vogel himself expressed concern that we would overuse the Gnostic label to characterize anyone we disagree with in politics, thereby warden it down to the point that it's no longer useful for analyzing the modern political world. Now, he didn't need to be concerned. We do that with fascists.
Everyone's a fascist. But that's what he was afraid of. Just like everyone throws around the term fascist now. He was concerned everyone would throw around the word Gnostic.
Still, people do use the term Gnostic. People like Vogel and tend to use Gnostic in the same way. I mean, a little while ago, I read this idiot who claimed Donald Trump is a Gnostic. I mean, Trump might be wrong.
He might be a demagogue. He might be a lot of unfortunate things. That's at the point, but he was not a freaking Gnostic. He's not even close.
He's possibly the furthest thing from a Gnostic we have as we'll be completely worth these things. And I say he's not even on the Gnostic spectrum and I'll be talking about the spectrum later. Anyway, there is a thing called the Gnostic attitude. In science, politics, Gnostic, and Vogel and set forth the six traits, six traits that together quote unquote reveal the Gnostic attitude.
Now, if you go to the show notes, I have in the footnotes to the show notes, I have all six traits laid out in Vogel and words. And I'm going to apologize. It's dry stuff. But that's not my fault.
They're Vogel's words. But I'd say it's not even Vogel's fault. And we're dealing with the subject. Oh, it was a difficult subject, rather.
And he was breaking a lot of new ground. He probably didn't have the time or possibly the personality to water it down for popular consumption. And to be honest, that's why I'm trying to do it in these series of essays and podcasts. I mean, I want to be the Vogel and Vogel, the Vogel and vulgarizer.
And I'm starting by trying to recast the six Gnostic traits in the framework of the existence strikes back project. If you only listen to the podcast, if you go to existence strikes back sub stack or go to the daily demon, the existence strikes back page, you'll see all these about 50 essays I've written so far, probably wrong 50 to 60,000 words in this project. Okay, now shifting back these six traits, recasting them in the existence strikes back project framework, it's been hard. I mean, really hard.
I've rewritten the six traits five times in the past week, getting ready for this podcast. And prior to that, I probably rewritten it 10 times. That might be an exaggeration, but not much. And I'll probably keep working on it.
But I think I have a close enough for now. And I might tweak it as the existence strikes back project unfolds. But Vogel and continually treat his analysis as years went on. So maybe I'm a good company.
Anyway, here are the six characteristics that taken together again, taken together, reveal the nature of the Nazi attitude. This is my take, my framing. Number one, the Gnostic is dissatisfied, or what I call existential dissatisfaction, anxiety, and happiness. Two, belief that the dissatisfaction is because the world is poorly organized.
Three, belief that number two, the dissatisfaction can be remedied, which result in one being remedied. So you think that, hey, we can change how the world is organized and then I'll stop being so happy. Number four, a rejection of the reality spectrum, in the sense that by rejecting a part of the reality spectrum, the Gnostic hopes to affect his or her salvation through historical processes. Five, belief that he or she or the movement or cause can affect number three, which is the belief that the world can be organized better than it is by nature or God or the doubt or whatever it is.
And then number six, belief that special knowledge gives the ability to transition the world, change the world by implementing the flawed understanding of reality. Again, this is going to be pretty hard to listen to. My apologies go to the show notes page. You can read them for yourself.
All right. Now, I want to apply these and I'm going to use Prometheus Bound. See, Prometheus was the ark Gnostic, at least in literature and mythology. And I'm going to dedicate a podcast each of the six characteristics, although one and two might be combined the way the podcasts is coming together right now.
But I'll have four or five essays slash podcasts dedicated one to each characteristics. But now I want to look at Aeschylus's Prometheus Bound, which, if you go to the show notes page, you see I've done a podcast on this already, but I'm going to shift my focus here. And I think Prometheus Bound is a great starting point to vulgarize vocal. I mean, one, it's a well-known work.
English translations are available in the public domain for anyone who wants to read it for himself. And it's short. I read it in about an hour or reread it, getting ready for these podcasts in about an hour. And I think Vocal would approve of my approach.
I mean, he focused on Prometheus Bound twice, first in the world of the polis in 1957. And again, it signs politics and assets in 1968. So here's a big fan of those pretty telling. Now, before jumping into this, a quick note, when you're reading or thinking about Prometheus Bound, it's crucial to remember that Zeus is the reality spectrum.
It's the divine order, the whole shoot match, all of existence. And Prometheus is any person who rejects that reality spectrum. So you need to kind of keep that in mind to understand how the Gnostic works in his own mind. Zeus' reality spectrum, Prometheus, the Gnostic.
And here's a summary of the play then, applying those terms. Prometheus was the unhappy, restless man, who believed his unhappiness resulted from a world poorly organized by Zeus and that he would be content if the world were properly organized. Prometheus carried out his plans without regard to Zeus and assisted that his plans would bring about a proper world because he possessed ancient and immense intelligence, ancient because he was older than Zeus and probably smarter than Zeus. I'll rephrase that again.
There's another way of rephrasing Prometheus Bound. The Gnostic is the unhappy, restless man, who believes that his unhappiness results from a world poorly organized, and that he could be happy if only the world were properly organized. And by the way, it's important, probably organized in his mind. Well, he thinks it should be not properly, as a practic matter.
We have no say on how the world is organized. It's given to us. We receive it. Anyway, so he thinks he could be happy if only the world were properly organized.
He carries out his plans without regard to the reality spectrum and assists that his plans will bring about a proper organization of reality because he possesses the tools, intelligence, know-how, method, to do it. Now I'm going to rephrase it even further condensed into behalf the length of those other rephrasing. The Gnostic is a malcontent who thinks his discontent comes from outside himself, reality, and that he would be happy if reality were organized in the Gnostic's preferred manner. The Gnostic believes reality can be changed, that he or a leader or a movement has the tools to do it.
All right, we're going to be unpacking all that later, but please bear with me as you go through this Gnosticism in the coming months and trust me, it's riveting stuff. I will make it exciting. Well, at least not boring. I might even be able to incorporate a few sexual references for you.
Let's see if listeners out there, because Gnostic's have an unfortunate tendency to be perverts and they want to mold basically. And again, you start thinking a lot of this is all 20th century thought. They start molding their quote unquote truth, their version of reality to fit their sexual proximity. So perversion and narcissism often go hand in hand, you know, like hot chocolate and vanilla.
So anyway, I'll try to bring that stuff in and make it more fully accessible and entertaining. So bear with me, hoping you're enjoying it. I have gotten good feedback. I think people are very interested in the subject and they ought to be it's crucial, hope me time to send it in a Gilcrest cutting edge by what I think was probably the most novel and original, you know, most original thinker of the 20th century, that was crucial.
And there are others as well that he can't broken the ground. I think the Gilcrest is doing the same thing in the 21st century. So I think together they have a lot of things to say. It's gonna be a lot parallel and I hope to bring all that stuff forward.
But anyway, as always thanks for listening and I'll catch you next week.