Hi, I'm Solana Pine. I'm the director of video at The New York Times. For years, my team has made videos that bring you closer to big news moments, videos by Times journalists that have the expertise to help you understand what's going on. Now, we're bringing those videos to you in the Watch tab in The New York Times app.
It's a dedicated video feed where you know you can trust what you're seeing. All the videos there are free for anyone to watch. You don't have to be a subscriber. Download The New York Times app to start watching.
From New York Times Opinion, this is the Ezra Cline Show. One thing we've been exploring more on the show this year is taste. I have this view that the taste is becoming more and more important. In this age of so much being algorithmic, so much being served up to you, AI moving to this world or creating a derivative version of anything is that much easier.
Knowing what you like, what you think is good, what you think is bad, what you respond to. That really matters. That is a way to maintain both humanity and the capacity to do great things. But after taste, there is this work of getting the thing to where you want it to be, right?
If you know something is bad, you feel it's not there yet. How do you get it? Where it needs to go? The thing you are trying to do there is editing.
I think we have an overly narrow description of what editing is. We think of it as marking up the grammar of a sentence with a pen. But great editors, and I've worked with a lot of great editors, they're mystics of a sort. They're not technicians.
They see something that isn't there yet, whether of their own work or your work. And not really knowing how to get there. They help you get there. Not really knowing how to get there.
They help themselves get there. So this is the thing I've been wanting to explore because it's fuzzy. We don't have very good even language for it. But they're really great editors out there.
Adam Moss is one of them. He's considered by many, considered by me to be one of the truly great magazine editors of his generation. In his 20s, this is back in 1988. He begins this in average story, a publication called Seven Days.
It survives only two years in Winston National Magazine Award for General Excellence. He comes to the New York Times. He remakes the New York Times Magazine. It becomes a key home for a great narrative journalism, for great essayists.
He goes to New York Magazine, which he just turns into one of the truly great magazines. It still is today under his successors. In 2019, Moss steps down from New York Magazine. He spends more time painting and becomes interested in how artists get from something fine to something great.
So he begins asking them and the result is his new book, The Work of Art, has something comes from nothing which tracks alongside 43 artists. Some great piece they did, be it a visual art, a piece of music, a piece of journalism, from where it began and he gets them to turn over their drafts, their sketches, their notes, and tracks where it ultimately goes and how they get it to there. So this is a conversation really about editing, about him as an editor, about these artists as editors, and about how we can all become better at editing, how we can all even understand when it is that we are editing. Obviously in the conversation we discuss some visual art that doesn't translate that well into audio, so we will link the images of those works in the show notes they are very much worth following up on and checking out.
As always my email as a con show at nmytimes.com. Adam Moss, welcome to the show. Thank you guys for having me. I had a rumor that this book had an earlier title.
It was something like on editing. Is that true? Close? Just called editing.
Just called editing. I'm so glad that was true. Because that was the thing I kept thinking about in the book, the thing I think about with your career. What does it mean to edit?
I think any editing is just a heightened level of sensitivity to reaction. I think you're just being super sensitive to the way in which your mind is reacting, or your heart is reacting. It's not just an intellectual thing, it's also very much an emotional thing. Bob Gottlieb in that carot documentary described editing as reacting.
That is pretty good definition. But it's not just reacting. It's trusting the reaction. It's trusting the reaction.
Then there's another port which is kind of separate, which is figuring out what to do about it. I would write all over manuscripts. Sometimes I would have solutions, but often it would just be a reaction. I spent a lot of time praising the stuff that I thought was good and withholding.
But I didn't think it was good. Instead of saying this is bad, people could just read. You just uncalled. It's horrible.
You must be fun to be in a relationship. I was an editor for a long time. I was a editor in Chief of Vox. I'm still an editor on the show in a way.
I think it took me at least a decade, maybe more, to even come to the idea that I should trust my own reaction. One thing that I think happened to media somewhat destructively in the same period is that editors stop doing that, and writers stop doing that. You begin to look at social media for the reaction. You begin to look outside.
We knew what people cared about because they were reading it. We knew what. One thing that I think held in New York magazine, and has held even since you've left, is it feels like it is for somebody, not decided by everybody. I started to understand that it's more radical and more necessary.
But it's also a tremendous act of faith in yourself, against the whole world. How do you come to trust yourself, your reaction, as valid? It's like trusting yourself in any context, which is that you get a little courageous and venture out and try something. I do think just, if we're going to get on the subject of journalism a little bit, one of the reasons that the thing that you're describing is true, is that magazines have been so newspapers, everything has been so disaggregated.
It was much more necessary for the whole to be tied together with a single sensibility. Now, many people, when they read, listen to anything, when they take in media, they don't necessarily even know where it was from. So that I think that people have surrendered a little bit of that thing, which I also value a tremendous amount, the feeling that it came from somewhere, someone, something that I can feel and identify. So you are considered by me to be one of the great magazine editor of your generation.
Yeah, I know. So I've listened to interviews with you. I know you don't like that. So what you then do is you say, well, I've just worked with a lot of great teams.
That's true. I know. So it's very hard for people to say why their judgment is good. But somehow the thing you did at seven days, which was the magazine you did in your late 20s and 30s, the one in National Magazine Award as a close down, then did it New York Times Magazine at New York, these were different teams.
I have tried the higher editors. In fact, I have higher editors successfully. They've worked for me. It is extraordinarily hard to hire editors.
Writers, you can see what they write. So if it is just about your great teams, which I don't fully believe, but it's clearly somewhat true, you clearly hired great teams in a bunch of different places. I'm a very good hire. I will give myself a few more in editors.
How do you find good editors? You talk to them. We all do that. But maybe listen for different things than I do.
What are you listening for? I listen for confidence, but not too much confidence. I listen for just an interesting mind. Usually I'll ask fairly banal questions and see where they take them.
I would kind of just keep prodding them to see how the gears of their mind work. If I was bored, I would hire them. If I was excited by the conversation, if I learned something from the conversation, and if they seemed like decent people, which is not small, a lot of people come in and they show signs of being the kind of editor that I think is destructive, rather than constructive, which is to say that they'll run rough shot over the writer talent or the visual talent or whatever they're in charge of and there needs to be a certain humility in an editor, but also they need to have a really interesting mind. Did you go to interview questions?
I would ask them to try to form story ideas on the fly of whatever happened that day in either news or their own experience. And important that question was to see how alert and well read they were, but also how fast their mind worked in formulating the raw data of experience into story, into narrative, into essay. And then I listened to my own reaction. Was I excited by this person?
Did I want to be in their company? I think it's really unlike you're sitting in the dinner party and someone's interested in you or they're not. But do you not worry about being misled by charisma? I think charisma is a big part of it actually.
So yeah, I could be misled by charisma, but I'm pretty good charisma volstitector. Some people are great fun to talk to, but they're not great at doing the thing. I've run into this. You get that and the flip is I've known people who are actually not great fun to talk to.
They're introverted, they're nervous in the interview, but they're amazing at doing the thing. And I've known editors like that too. I have to, although I think I'm pretty good at getting shy people to relax. They have to be able to have the conversation no matter what their basic personality inhibitions are.
And then in terms of doing the thing, there are tests and stuff like that that you give them that you evaluate that. But also I really think that you can teach people how to do the thing and you can't teach people to think. I agree. Yeah.
I think that is the hardest part of hiring. Yeah. So I want to go back to something we were talking about a minute ago about this theory that editing is about reading your reaction and being able to work with that reaction. So you have this great interview with David Mandel, share a show that I love.
And the interview talked through a single joke on the show. And the way Mandel hears all these alternatives and uses his own reaction to guide to the final form of the joke. So can you just talk through that joke first? One of the embituses for the book was that I went to the set of the, I was invited by Frank Ritchie, who was a both a friend of mine and executive producer of the show.
And he just, you know, just as a lark said, hey, come, I was in Los Angeles, come visit. So I did. And I sat there behind Dave and watched him. It was just some stupid joke that landed on a Jewish holiday.
And Moses led his people to the land of... Can you shut up, Nikhil? When they got stupid hat is too small for my young guy. Fine.
Stupid hat is too small for my young guy. It's okay. Yona. Conversion to Judaism is about a commitment to the Jewish lifestyle.
Okay. Because I was learning to give me a yamakake. So you don't even focus on that whole routine, right? You might think of that routine as an object.
But no, just that. Just one word. Just one word. Tell me one change variable in it.
So there's this thing that they do called alts where they actually take most jokes and they try to squeeze them as much as possible to get the most Jews that they can get. That's one of the things when I was beginning to think about the book that I watched with such admiration. I don't know. This moment is like three seconds in the show and they take hours on it.
Even though it just zips right past most viewers wouldn't even pay any attention to it. So what were some of the alts? So the alts in this case, it's scripted and shot. Jonah is saying that land is called New York, Hanukkah.
That's the one they used. They also wrote Egypt, Milikonzi. It's like a Yiddish name. Anyway, these were the various ones.
They did shoot New York and Hanukkah. And Hanukkah is the one that they finally used. New York could be kind of funny. Yeah.
So tell me about what Mandel is doing there. What is the edit happening? How does he make the decision between them? He describes making the decision purely by reading his own reaction.
And it happens in the editing room. It also happens on the set because they only shoot some of them. He fuses around himself with the joke and then people feed him various other alternatives. And he is just evaluating.
And he's evaluating not in a way that feels conscious at all. But he's trying to understand what makes him laugh. There are in my view three stages of making one of them as the imagining and the final one as the shaping. But in between, there is the judging, which is kind of what we're talking about here.
The editing and imagining gets a lot of space on YouTube videos and books that help you free your up to imagination, which is very important. And then the shaping gets a lot of attention because it's about craft and technique and how you make the thing that is at least close to something in your head. What kind of never gets any love is this middle ground, which is the judging. And after your imagination has spewed, whatever it is that it has spewed, there has to be a kind of functioning intelligence that is not intellectual necessarily, but is nevertheless your mind operating keenly, making sense of what you've done and then figuring out how you can best put it to use.
And you know, oh, this is so subjective. Everything is so subjective. There is no objective explanation of this word will work better than that word. But in his case, he just sits in that editing room and he laughs or he doesn't.
We should say here that the books in some ways motivated by you have gotten more deeply into painting. And the distance between what you think is good and what you're able to do is vast. And it seems to fascinate you. Yeah, it fascinates me and frustrates me and did actually motivate my, I felt like, well, okay, artists may look at the world differently than I do.
And there was a way of thinking that I didn't seem to have, so I went to talk to other people about how they thought. And that's kind of the motivating thing. The book is a number of the artists in your book talk about this idea of listening to the body. Twanitharp says when she's drafting a piece and she's a great choreographer.
She says, okay, brain, catch up with the body. Kara Walker, who made the sugar baby sculpture in the dominant sugary friendry, said she had to quote, put some paper on the floor and let my body do the work. Tell me a bit about the sense of the tension between the cerebral and the body. And the physical.
Yeah. It happens actually really unbelievable number of places in the book. And also there's this other very strange thing that happens in the book, which is over and over again, people describe being most creative when they're in motion. So whether they put themselves in motion when they're running or swimming or something like that or biking or even just on a train or an airplane, just moving the body physically in space, moving seems to unleash something in them.
But I feel this way, I don't know if you do things other than your journalism life because I do find that in my own painting, it's a physical sensation. It's a physical high. And it's one of the really satisfying aspects of it. I'm considering this.
Do I do first? Do I do anything such for my journalism? I do. I like to think I have a full life.
Well, I didn't mean that. I miss that state, which I think I used to achieve more often. And I think one reason I used to achieve it more often is that when I started out as a blogger, there weren't that many notifications competing for your attention. You have slack and not that many people emailed me.
And I find I break concentration much more now. The place where my body left up when you were talking was the plane. I find I achieve completely different mental states on planes. And I think it's because there is a little distraction.
And so when you're talking about painting, I mean, I assume you don't paint on a screen. I assume you paint on canvas. And I do think there is a tension between the body, that kind of embodied flow state and distraction and interruption. It takes time to get there.
And I think it is difficult to stay there sometimes. And at least for me, I remember being there more often when I was younger. Yeah, interesting. Well, people describe it as one of the rewards of creating is to get themselves into this thing that we've all come to know as the flow state.
This sort of period of utter absorption where all of the distractions in life just disappear. And I think that is real. I've even as a terrible painter. I've even experienced it.
But people actually seek a kind of physical sensation as well as a total absorption. I mean, I have this one chapter in the book of Ian Edelman who is this crazy, magnificent sandcastle maker. And that's why I want to talk to him. I want to talk to him about making this thing that would, that he has one day to do and then parishes at the end of the day.
I thought that was something quite beautiful. And he describes making sand castles not just in terms of the kind of crazy, almost supernatural focus, but also in terms of its physical sensation and describes it, compares it to the feeling he has on a bicycle riding in traffic in New York City, dodging cars. And that just seems like a fantastic metaphor because he's moving forward in motion. He's dodging cars.
When you make something, in a way, it's like, you know, this is totally not true. But I'll say it anyway. It's like a video game. You know, things are coming at you.
You have to deal quickly with them. You have to make decisions about what you're going to do with them on the way to something else. What do you think about the relationship here between speed and this kind of creativity or intuition? Because there are people here working very slowly.
And then something that comes up again and again is the power of the deadline. Yeah. The thing they did very quickly. Yeah.
Well, I mean, I think the people are different, right? Bob Dylan, for instance, famously said, he wrote all the songs in 15 minutes, 20 minutes, half an hour. I have a piece of stationery in the book that was filled with process artifacts of all kinds. It's a very visual book.
And this is just a written record of him writing, blowing in the wind and inverting a stanza or a verse. And some people do their best work really fast and some people take forever doing it. But it's important to remember that those people do it very fast. They're able to do it very fast because they have just getting back to the body.
Like an athlete, they have kind of body memory. They have skills so ingrained in them that there are impulsive decisions are informed by a lifetime of experience. I think another example of this just spitting the workout, at least at the beginning, is the chapter of Stephen Sondheim. So you're talking about that process for him?
There was a situation that's from the musical company. And there was a situation that the playwright wrote in which a bride is flipping out, having a full blown anxiety attack. And it starts and I have it in the book. It starts as this monologue or for having a kind of nervous breakdown.
It's a great little monologue. And he thinks of this as a song and he writes a song called The Wedding Is Off. And its function is to recreate this nervous breakdown in music. And it's kind of a disaster.
The singer can't sing the song. The rhythm's all wrong. It's jaggedy. It doesn't build.
He's made a bunch of mistakes and it becomes absolutely clear that the thing has to go. And just ruthlessly, ruthlessly, he goes boing. And just ejects the song right out of the show. And because he is Stephen Sondheim, the new song had different rules.
And so the new song would have to be started essentially from scratch. And he was able to write the song which is called Getting Married Today in a Week, which is crazy. Listen, everybody, look, I don't know what you're waiting for. It's a pretty star, pretty cool work.
Everybody promises fidelity for it. Which maybe the most horrifying word I've ever heard. Which is followed by a hundred years. Suddenly he'll realize he's sad with a naphonic on which he should.
Thanks so much. But I'm not getting married. You have fun because I'm not getting married. You've been grand, but I'm not getting married.
I don't just stand there. I'm not getting married. I don't chill cold, but I'm not getting married today. When you listen to the song, which is well known to be maybe the most dense, fastest song in all of musical theater and also one of the most difficult to sing, you will see it's incredible complexity.
It's really one of the great theater songs of all time. And he was able to do it in a week because he itself held the problems the first time. Hi, this is Ashley. I live in San Francisco with my boyfriend.
We would love to officially share my New York Times subscription with separate logins. We both love cooking, love being in the kitchen, but I'm a 30 minute and under efficient dinner at Gurley. I want a sheep and meal. He is a elaborate.
He wants to get into the storytelling. I want to be able to save my easy meals and check off the ones that I've completed. And I think him having his own profile would be great. Ashley, we heard you.
It's why we created the New York Times family subscription to get your own login and Mr. elaborate. It's his plus room for two others. Find out more at nytimes.com slash family.
The Amy someone chapter is the one that sticks with me most and it is worth the price of admission on the book just for that. So to give a little bit of background abstract painter and you have 36 or 37 39 39 39 of the iterations is one painting one through. And it transforms utterly, but it is never clear to me exactly why. And you have some of her reasoning, but she is also very honest and saying.
It's not very convincing. Her reasoning, right? Not at all. But she ought to.
She says. Absolutely. It's not clear that this would have been any worse if I had stopped at number seven. Yeah.
The first one was the best. I shouldn't have changed anything. And I actually could have done just about 100 over 100 iterations of this. I could have basically devoted the entire book to the path of this painting.
And so there is his question then is what you're listening to editorial intuition or neurosis? Well, there might be the same thing. I mean, it's part of her. I don't know what you would call it.
I guess her own self description that it doesn't actually matter where she stops. That the important thing in the making of the painting is the making and destroying and making and destroying. That that's actually what the whole thing is about. I use this phrase.
It sounds like a game of musical chairs where she decides to stop in that what I think is a fairly neurotic process. But I don't mean neurotic in a bad way. She is performing a kind of artistic ritual. And it happens to be that a great painting usually is the thing that she ends up with.
But also let me just tell you, because you can't really fully grock it until you see it. There's so many beautiful paintings on the way that she just ruthlessly erases. She doesn't really even think twice about it. And she doesn't have a particular regret about it.
In fact, as she puts it at one point, regret is kind of what the work is all about. One of my favorite chapters, Cheryl Pope, using felt in this absolutely gutting piece of art, mother and child in Blue Mat. I found it extraordinarily moving. Can you say who she is, what that work is?
She's a Chicago based artist. She works in lots of different media. She had been deeply upset while making this work, which of course, interested me. And she was just an absolutely wonderful person.
But the story here is that she had three consecutive miscarriages. And she really very much wanted to be a mother. I wanted to give birth to a child. And since she felt almost deranged, to in a sense create the child in an artwork, to have the artwork be the motherhood that she couldn't have physically.
And so she created a work on felt in which she visualized the child. In fact, at one point, two children, then one child. At one point, the child and the mother had no faces because she was afraid giving them faces would be too specific for an artwork, but also too painful for her. And eventually she decided she needed to give them faces.
And after the work was finished, she regretted that decision. It's possible this is actually set in the chapter. But just while we were talking about it, the reason the felt is so affecting is it's something children make artwork out of. Yeah, it's not set in the chapter, but I think that's true.
The other thing that I felt about the felt was that it looks like yarn, I should say. Yeah, it does. Is that she has to punch through it. So the physical act we talked before about the way that physical action factors into the making of the art, but in this case the punching through, since this was built on so much anger and upset also move me.
One thing the book is very interested in is tools. And something I noticed was how seldom a digital tool was mentioned. I feel like the only people who use digital tools were the musicians recording into the voice memos app of their iPhone. Yeah.
Almost everybody else was using paper as some sort of another. The notebooks for paper, the sketching was paper. It felt like people were really pushing themselves, particularly in the editing process, in the idea generation process onto paper. First is that right and second why?
Well, it's not entirely right. There's a whole chapter that's the exception to that, which is a better guy named Tyler Hobbs as a generative artist. And why I like that chapter so much is that the machine is super important. It becomes the hand.
He creates algorithms, gives it to the computer, the computer spits stuff out. He reacts to it the same way that a painter might react to whatever they've painted with their hands. And then he changes the algorithm and just keeps going that way. Well, he's in a way become the editor of the machine, which I think I have a thing that is going to turn us much more into editors.
Because we're going to have to know if the thing is spitting at us. And evaluate it. Yes. The generative artist you mentioned, whose work is very cool.
He has to be working in code because he is trying to get the computer to create more interesting work. But the people for whom the question is how do they get themselves to create more interesting work felt to me almost ostentatiously oriented towards paper. Yeah. And that included the young ones.
I didn't notice a large page gap here. It wasn't like the young people were all typing away on an iPad. And so what is it about paper? Why are they doing that?
Well, paper for one thing is something you can throw away. So there is a thing that a lot of artists and writers do, which is the creative first pass that is perishable, that is meant to be disposed of. So they write in long hand as opposed to type something. They paint like in the Amazon example and mean to paint it over George Saunders, who did such a great episode of the theory that I listened to.
I listened to actually all this time. George Saunders gives himself six months to just totally screw around as the way to make the thing. So there is a kind of built in failure stage, very important, I think, and pretty universally expressed. Well, my theory, the thing that I am testing here to see if it comes out is that it is easier to achieve certain kinds of states with paper.
So I did an episode sometime ago now with Marianne Wolf, who's a great scholar of how people read in the reading mind. And the point of a lot of her work is that different things happen in your mind, reading on paper, reading on a screen, reading on different kinds of screens. What is happening with distraction? I mean, it just changes.
Form does change content. It certainly changes the reception of content. Yeah. I think you're more focused when you're working with paper.
I mean, I find at least in my own experience, and I'm a focus group of one, that my mind wanders more when I'm reading on a screen. I mean, even just thinking about the smoothness of a computer screen versus the texture of a page, one has a kind of scratchiness. In art, there's a lot of preoccupation with what the surface feels like, the toothiness of the surface. In fact, my book is sort of smoother than I would have wanted.
The smoothness was a compromise in order to get the image reproduction to be so good. So an image reproduction is really good. But I would have rather had a kind of almost mountainous kind of texture. Which the cover does.
Yeah, the cover does. The book is a, I really want to say this, and I want people to hear it. It's a piece of art. It's a beautiful object.
I mean, I enjoyed its physical form, more than I enjoyed the physical form of a book in a long time. Oh, that's nice. And that was clearly highly intentional. Yes.
Yeah, the cover is a, the image on it is a proof manuscript in which he had crossed the whole thing out with his giant blue X's. And then to actually get Penguin to agree to do the book in this cloth cover reproducing those X's, it just felt like, okay, that's really the book I'm trying to make here. And they were generous enough to do that. I like this topic of the way the feel of a thing or your relationship to a material or tool changes the way you think.
You have a great chapter with the musician, Rossam. And I want to play a bit of the song you talked about in a river. So he starts off playing the mandolin there, and then he switches to the guitar, which is such an unusual transition. And it just changes the tone of the song completely.
And what's wild to me in your interview with him is that Rossam didn't know how to play the mandolin before composing that song at all. And this just comes up repeatedly where people are using new materials for work that comes really important, like Kara Walker using sugar to make that massive sculpture. What's going on in this confrontation with new tools and materials and approaches? What does it unlock for these artists who really know something really well?
Do they move into using something they don't know that well? Well, I think the artist is drawn to things that will excite them. And I think that artists like anyone get bored doing the same thing over and over again. And so they sink new adventure.
One of my incredible frustrations as a painter, even today. And my painting is just very, very tight and conservative. And I just decided about two weeks ago that I would just put away all the brushes I had when touched them. And then I would just make paintings using whatever materials I have around palette and I'm sure about scissors, any ruler, anything that I had.
So that I could smear the paint so that it wouldn't have the kind of fastidious relationship to the thing that it really is in real life. And I wanted to just allow myself a little bit of berserk. So I myself trying new materials in order to produce something different. And actually, it's kind of working.
I was really struck by all that, too. That how many times in the show, Pope Chapter, for instance, she just keeps changing media. And she doesn't know, she tells me that she goes into Home Depot and she asks the salesperson, how do you actually do that? How do you use glue this way or how do you use felt this way?
What is the device I should buy? And they just continue to do it. The point I would emphasize here, because I found it both reassuring and frustrating to hear this over and over again, was that the reason they're able to do this, the reason they're able to work in a different medium that they don't know is because of their training. And one of the things that training does, the Rossnam example, Rossnam, I mean, as he describes playing the mandolin, it's just playing the guitar upside down.
And he has gotten a really rigorous early musical education, which enables him to be able to do the thing that I couldn't do. I don't know how to play the guitar. I would certainly not know how to play the mandolin. So anyway, it's a basic thing that kind of has to be said, that the training really helps.
There's not a lot of short cutting that goes on. But the other thing is, we talked about this a little bit earlier, is faith. Is that once they learn, they can actually succeed using new materials. They're moved to new materials again and again.
It made me think of Stephen Johnson's book, Where Good Ideas Come From. One of his arguments in that book is that great ideas often come from a Jason C. Somebody knows a lot about a domain and then looks over to the next domain and applies it. And that's what I see happening often here, which is a Jason C.
Rossnam knows a lot about, I assume, the guitar and other things, looks over to the mandolin and can feel something. Well, I would say that this whole book is exactly that. I never wrote before. I hate writing, and I have been a terrible writer for most of my life because I had this idea of how to write, that there was a way to write.
And so that way to write was pretentious and I couldn't stand it. And so the draft process was really teaching me how to write. It was like using my editor skills that I had honed in a lot of years and applying it to myself. And I kind of found out I was a pretty good editor of myself.
And I was able to strip this thing down, strip this thing down, strip this thing down into something I could stand. I still didn't like doing it, but I'm not horrified by what I produced. As a writer, I functionally cannot start writing until I can see the entire thing. So many of the writers I know, they write a little piece for here.
They start in the middle. They go to the end, nonfiction writers. I know tons of nonfiction writers who, they're very able to put together the pieces where they know what they seem. They have this argument and then they begin stitching.
For me, I will just be stuck until the entire structure reveals. Now that might not be the final structure that these things can change in the edit, but I need the whole thing there. Yeah, I think I'm more like you. But people are different.
That's the point here. There's 43 chapters in the book and there's 43 different ways that people make art. That's not to say there isn't anything that unites them. I mean, I do think that they are a little bit unusually a collection of freaks.
And that is that they have a kind of superhuman drive that enables them. This great quote that I found early on by James Baldwin saying, talent is insignificant, what matters are love, discipline, luck, and most of all, endurance. And one of the people who are really talented at things. Well, I think it's really, I mean, having done a kind of data set of these 43, that seems to be true.
And it's been a long time. They're hard work. Ultimately, they need to go the distance. They need to not give up when pretty much everyone else would give up.
So we've been talking a bunch here about artists who edit a lot, but I want to think about the other side of that too, those who go out more raw. So let's hear a clip by this performance artist, Grady West, who invented a character named Deena Martina. Do you have good salads? Definitely.
Oh, good. Then I'd like a small cesarean. But does it have glutton? I really don't want glutton.
I'll have your glutton. I'll have your glutton. You will? Yeah, just get it on the side.
Oh, that's great. Yeah, just have a glutton on the side. And Doreen, I think I'll hand things off to you. Because you're a red bull in a can or is it fresh?
A can. Oh, that's a shame. Do you have any breakfast wines? So Grady West is voicing the cesarean lady there.
That's Deena Martina. How did that act of persona come together? Okay, so he goes to this cabaret and he doesn't think about it for one second. The night before he finds out, we had a guy think and he smears this makeup on his face and he goes out with nothing scripted and just starts to talk.
And calls himself Deena Martina. This all happens without any forethought whatsoever. And he does have a very particular sense of humor. We were talking before about taste.
A sense of humor seems to be the same. Upward, sort of the same wavelength. He has now written Deena Martina for decades, I think three decades into an international stage act in lots of different places. I know him from Provincetown where he's kind of in residence over the summers, but it is an hour of a character completely oblivious to how anyone else would see him.
It has a bunch of characters. One of them, you heard Doreen. Doreen is the heir to the Codex fortune. He has a child named Phoebe, which is a puppet.
The thing is insane. It's just completely unhinged and it's perfectly intact in terms of a bizarre world that he has created. There's no cracks in it. And he developed it in one second in 19, what have you, into a sort of alternative cabaret context.
It's amazing. And then he now writes it. Now it's honed to it 55 minutes, but basically it's still anarchy. One thing I enjoyed about the book is the age range of the artist's profile.
Generalizing wildly, what is different? What are the hallmarks of great art produced early in a career and late in a career? For the most part, I think that one very important quality of an artist is that they have faith that they can make the thing. There's a great line that Michael Cunningham who wrote the hours said to me at one point.
He just didn't even realize he was saying it, but I was asking him how it was possible that when he'd written a draft of the book, he had to throw away the draft and I kind of probed about that. And that feel just really awful. He said, now there's plenty more that came from. And he just said it like that.
That is a one sentence description of a thing that is absolutely essential to an artist, which is the faith that they can keep doing it. And those people, as they got older, people had more and more faith. The flip side of that. And one thing I know from my own experience is that you make kind of wonderful things when you're young, when you don't know any better.
There was a magazine I did called Seven Days, starting out. It was really, it broke every rule in the book. It just was like, I didn't have a middle. It was just all side bars.
It was just, it was nutty. And the perspective of someone who understands how to build magazines, it broke every rule and for no good reason. And I would never make that in my life now or in the last 25 years. I would have just looked at it and thought it's kind of amateurish and stupid.
And yeah, it kind of worked. It was exactly the right thing for then. And I did something that I wouldn't be able to do later. Look at Leaves of Grass by Walt Whitman who wrote that book throughout his life.
There's the Young Man's Version and there's the Old Man's Version. And some of the language changes as he gets closer to death. And that's interesting. And the poem is in some ways better at the end, but not in all ways.
Best at the beginning. I know writers and primarily political writers and nonfiction writers. And my gloss on this would be that, pretty in politics, young writers are arrogant and overconfident and don't know what they don't know and don't know what's going to fail. And old writers are way too cautious and know too much what's going to fail and are too locked into what the rules have been.
And both sides are completely right in what they're annoyed at in the other. And the balance of that in any given career is really hard. It is. And it's not necessarily true that the middle age person has it all together.
No, I really mean this everybody is right. I've come to think of this kind of thing. And I think there are many dynamics like this. You have to think of it like an ecosystem.
We always want people to be the right balance, but ecosystems need to be a balance. You need like young political thinking that is kind of wild. And doesn't know that we tried this and completely failed. Absolutely.
And you actually need that just as you need the old thinking. And one is not better than the other. They need to both be there and asking one person to embody it all is not possible. Yeah, that's true.
I mean, I mean, I just think balance is correct in almost every context. And just to pull back to artists for one second. The essence of making art is having play and rigor in pretty much equal balance or child and adult in pretty much equal balance so hard. It's so hard to get the equilibrium right.
You're too childish. And you can make a glorious mess, but it has no structure to it. It becomes unintelligible to another human being. Too much adult.
And the thing has no fire. No. There's nothing animating it. So this crazy middle ground in all of these cases that we're talking about is somehow where you have to live.
And it's very hard to be there. One thing that comes up a bunch in the book is you'll know that people will find a much earlier version of a piece for you than they realize they had. Right. Right.
A jotting, a draft, something else. And it's far before they realize they were working on the thing they were working on. And you often you keep repeating. It was there.
It was already there. It made me think years ago, my story myself as a journalist. It's the whole thing about how I sort of learned to be a policy journalist, you know, writing about healthcare at the certain point in time. And somebody brought me some columns I had done for the alternative school newspaper when I was at UC Santa Cruz.
And this was before all that. And it turned out I just sounded like myself. Right. I was writing about John Kerry's tax plan.
And I was shocked to find out that I was writing about John Kerry's tax plan. I didn't think I had that interest at that point. And there is something that may come out or it may not come out, but there is often a sensibility buried somewhere that is trying to come out for a long time. What you can let it out is a question and socially dependent and a million other things.
But there is something buried in people that, for better or for worse, is often hard to get away from. Yeah. Well, okay. So just two responses to that.
One is one of the really fun things about the method of this book was to actually show the various artists, the early work or the early version of the thing, which would usually amaze them. And it would get them to speak truthfully and to remember exactly how it went and away different than their memory has distorted it over time. The second thing is that yes, people have a sensibility that is theirs that they can't escape. And this, again, this is a refrain.
Oh my God. How many people said you can't run away from yourself. You can't. You are yourself.
That's it. I mean, Gregory Kootzen, who is a photographer who makes these very unusual photographs, which are kind of like film sales and they're giant and very beautiful. He was just apologizing in a sense over and over again for the fact that all of them inhabit a certain kind of common sensibility, which I thought was marvelous. But he was, he says, you're just constantly trying to escape it.
Cara Walker, you know, when she was making the sugar sculpture called the subtlety or the marvelous sugar baby. She was tired of the antebellum silhouettes that had kind of made her famous. We're not tired, but she felt she exhausted them. And she was trying to do something different, but how different?
She says at one point, you Cara, who are you? And that is kind of a question they're all asking. I kept, you know, talking to Thomas Bartlett, who was a music producer. And we were talking about this record, which was people doing covers, Martha Wainwright or Justin Vernon of Bonivare.
Their own versions of covers of Neil Young's harvest, I think. And no matter what their intention was, the song would sound like them. It would not sound like Neil Young. It would sound like them.
And they were not trying. This was just something they couldn't get away from. So this, I think obvious, but still impossible, not to marvel at fact, is that you are who you are. And with something very related to this, which is this distinction or question of whether you're editing for yourself or editing for the audience, I found myself pulling a bunch of media back to magazines over the past year.
One, I think they remain in many ways, my favorite form. They're just remarkable acts of duration, almost every single one of them. And I found myself once again, in what happened for some time, just sort of desperate to feel like somebody actually liked this. Maybe I wouldn't, but somebody somewhere did.
They chose it. They maintained an intentional decision. And I want to bring it back to New York Magazine, the magazine you edited. I love New York Magazine.
Long time subscriber, it's my favorite magazine. And the thing that has always amazed me about it is that I cannot describe why it all goes together, but the sensibility is very coherent. And it has survived you, which is more impressive, right? It has been great since you've left, which means that what you did was not just you sitting there telling everybody what to do, that there's something that emerged.
You guys do all or did do all kinds of Washington DC profiles. But I know you would not really profile Jake Sullivan. But there's another kind of profile you would do. I cannot extract out of it the description of it.
So how were you figuring out what went with what? Was it an idea of the audience? Was it just you? You were just editing for yourself and you are the audience?
Who's on the other end of that process? Certainly the latter. I was always editing for myself. And the reason I left the magazine is that I felt like I was no longer the audience for it and the audience needed to be younger than I was.
And they needed to have a certain way of looking at the world that I didn't have anymore. So I left. It's very poignant to me that the curator, the editor, the decider has become of less importance in these times. But I don't know how I never knew.
In all of my years as an editor, I never knew how to edit for somebody else. I had to edit for myself. I had to have this thing that we talked about at the very beginning of this conversation, this thing that you trust. And the only way to trust it is to feel it.
I think that's a nice place to end. So then always our final question. What are three books you would recommend to the audience? Okay.
There are three kind of related to this project, but there are all three books I really like. One of them is a book of interviews with Francis Bacon by David Sylvester. I think there's nine of them. I learned more about art from reading these interviews.
I'm not a wild fan of Francis Bacon's art. I am a wild fan of Francis Bacon as a thinker about how art gets made. And I learned so much from that book that went into this book that I wrote. So that's one.
Another book written by one of the subjects of the book, Amy Syllman is a book called FOPA. She's a great painter. She is an amazing writer. And this book is so much fun filled with her own ear edition, absolutely, but also illustrations, chartlets.
It's just a fun object and also really smart and wonderful. And then because nobody talks about these when they come here, I want to throw in a purely visual book. It's the sketchbooks of Richard Dibancorn. It's just pages and pages and pages of years and years and years of his sketchbooks, his drawings of his wife himself, some pencil, some ink.
I can just sit and live in those pages imagining him as the drawer, which is kind of what my project was all about. So there you go. Adam Moss, thank you very much. Thank you.
This episode of The Other Clunge Show was produced by Annie Galley. In fact, checking by Michelle Harris, our senior engineer is Jeff Gell with the Digital Mixing by Isaac Jones. Our senior editor is Claire Gordon. The show's production team includes Roland Hu, Kristen Lin, and Amund Sahoda.
We've original music by Isaac Jones, Audien Stravji by Christina Samuuski and Shannon Vassa. The executive producer of New York Times Opinion Audio is Annie Rose-Strosser. And special thanks to Sonya Herrera, Rachel Baker, and Shains Burnett.