Lion Rock Resources is advancing high grade gold and lithium in South Dakota's Black Hills. The Volney Project, phase one drilling complete, early stage, high potential. Follow the results at lionrockresources.com. I'm Mr.
Glenn and this is the Ezra Clangio. So one of the things I do for the show is I try to keep an eye on the bestseller lists. And a few months ago, I began to notice something strange. The body keeps a score, which is a book about trauma from 2014, was backed up near the top of the New York Times list.
It's the number one is I write this in the books 147th week on the paperback nonfiction list, 147th. And if you know what this book is, that is wild. The body keeps score. It is a searing read about the way trauma disconnects our minds and our bodies.
It's pretty clearly written with a professional audience in mind. This is a book very largely aimed at other psychiatrists that so many of us are turning to it. It says something profound about where the national psyche is in this moment of yeah, trauma. I'll be honest with my own history of it here.
The body keeps score is one of those books people told me to read for a long time. But I thought I knew what it was about. I'd heard it discussed so many times and I'd read it written about. So even though I hadn't read it, I thought I knew it.
You know, trauma lodges in the body. We carry a physical imprint of our psychic wounds. It's all very hard to heal. Got it.
But I was really wrong about that. The core argument is I want to use words subversive here, certainly subversive in how it will leave you thinking about yourself and those around you. It is a traumatic experiences, sexual assault, incest, emotional physical abuse, war and much, much more. They can disconnect our body and our mind.
That is when an experience becomes a trauma when it disconnects us. And this is a part I didn't understand from the way the book is talked about. The devastating argument it makes is not that the body keeps a score. It's that the mind hides a score from us.
The mind it hides and warps these traumatic events and are narratives about them in an effort to protect us. Human beings are social animals and our minds evolve to manage our social relationships. So when we face an event that could rupture our relationship with the community or the family, particularly for children, the family that we depend on, that the mind often talks us out of it, obscures the memories or convinces us our victimization was our fault or it covers the event in a shame so thick we refuse to discuss it. But our body, and that's an imprecise term here, but the parts of us are more automatic that manage and respond to threat.
Our body doesn't forget that. Our mind can't talk that part of us into feeling safe again. And it's this disconnection of mind and body where trauma lives. So how do you reconnect them?
Bessel Vanderkolk is the author of the Body Keeps Score. He was a leading researcher and psychiatrist active in many of the early battles to understand post-traumatic stress syndrome. But more recently, he co-founded and leads a trauma research foundation and has been studying ways to try to heal these deeper parts of our psyches, everything from movement therapies like yoga and dance to EMDR to internal family systems therapy to MDMA treatment. We talk about all of it in here.
But I do want to offer disclaimer. The research on some of these novel treatments is really promising, but these are often new studies with pretty small sample sizes. So I don't want anyone to mistake this conversation for direct advice from a psychiatrist who knows your situation and psyche. So if anything here connects for you, talk to a professional about it.
Don't just drop the treatments you're using or the medications you're taking and run to something new. But with that said, there is so much to learn from in this conversation. I really haven't stopped thinking about it since we recorded. As always, my email at nytimes.com if you want to send me further suggestions or recommendations for things we should read or look at again as our client show at nytimes.com.
Bessel Vanderkolk, welcome to the show. Hi, good being here. You have this very powerful line in the book from the writer Jessica Stern, where she says quote, some people's lives seem to flow in a narrative. Mine had many stops and starts.
That's what trauma does. It interrupts the plot. Tell me a bit about how trauma interrupts the plot. Well, trauma is really a wound that happens to your psyche, to your mind, to your brain.
Suddenly you're confronted with something that you are faced with horror and helplessness. There's nothing prepared for this, like, oh my God. And so something switches off at that point, your mind and your brain and the nature of trauma is that you get stuck there. So instead of remembering something unpleasant, you keep reliving something, very unpleasant.
So the job of overcoming trauma is to make it to a memory where your whole being knows this happened a long time ago. It's not happening right now. But the nature of traumatic stress is that you keep reacting emotionally and physiologically as if these events are happening right now. What is trauma?
Is it the event itself, or is it your reaction and processing, or I guess lack thereof of the event? It really is a reaction that you have to something horrible that's going on. And different people have different responses. Although I must say having that is work as long as I have, I don't recall ever seeing somebody in my office coming for too many steps.
I go, oh, this seems like a trivial issue. Like having your child run over by a car, you go like, oh my God. And usually my response to hearing about people's trauma is, oh my God, and you're still here. I'll say that for me was the hardest part of reading your book was just being faced with something I already know, but being faced with how much pain people are simply carrying around with them every day.
That it's one way reading the book made me just look at the world a little bit differently. It's just a reminder that you have no idea what somebody is carrying. That is so true. And of course, we do need to wear our blinders and we cannot face up to all the bad stuff that's happening in the world.
But to give an example to what you're just saying here, when we first put this diagnosis PTSD in the textbook, we said this is an extraordinary event outside of the usual realm of human experience. That's the original definition. Nobody talked about how common incest is. Nobody talks about how common child abuse is how common domestic violence is.
And it's really quite startling where you get to see how much people actually are coping with. At various points in the book, you argue that trauma is the most costly public health problem that we are dealing with. This is before the era of COVID, of course. So let's keep that to the side.
But do you want to talk a bit about that at a scale that what it means that so many people are holding these kinds of experiences and pain? Yeah, that statement actually came from the Centers for Disease Control when Vince Feletti at Kaiser Permanente in San Diego did his research more than 10 years ago right now, where he asked medical patients, insurance carrying, large education, white people, did anybody ever hit you very badly? Did anybody molest you? Did you witness your parents having physical fights?
And the data that came back were just stunning. How much really very scary stuff the majority of people experiencing their lives. And what the studies that slowly showed is how evasive and devastating these effects are on people capacity to recover also. The big issue is that people tend to think about trauma as old as events having a bad memory about something.
That is nothing about it is that once you get traumatized, it changes your brain and changes how you see the world and it changes how your body reacts to your environment. And so it's not only a thing that goes from your survival system into your mind, it goes also into your body and the stress hormones continue to erode your system, where you have been traumatized, your chances to die much earlier and to have many diseases go up very dramatically. And so much of what we can think about major social issues in the world to be living are actually the social elements that contextually owners are terribly important. Tell me a bit about the conditions under which an event that could be traumatic becomes a trauma.
And in particular, I was very struck by how much of your research suggests that trauma is an event plus a kind of instigated social crisis. There are objectively catastrophic events like 9-11 that were less likely to cause trauma because they were shared by the community where on the other hand, things like child sexual abuse is very reliably traumatic because it disconnects you from your family. So can you talk a bit about the social structure of trauma? Yeah, but we tend to leave out of most of our discussions about human functioning is to what agree we are primates.
We have brains in order to get along with each other, to be with other people, to connect to other people. That's really what we are fundamentally all about. And so much of trauma is about a rupture of the safety of the people who are supposed to protect you and the people who are supposed to come to your health. So basically the way that we are wired is that we are wired to not be able to do everything by ourselves but to be able to look for help and for other people to take over when we can no longer do the job ourselves.
And that's perfectly normal. But if at that point the people you can count almost are not there for you, like you don't have been killed or whatever, then it's entirely up to you. It is a much harder thing to deal with terrible situations. I just want to tag something you said there for the audience because we're going to come back to quite a bit which is we have brains in order to get along with other people.
I think that's going to be really, really important to this conversation. But this gets to something that I've been really rich in the book. So the body keeps the score. I mean, as a book, it's a phenomenon, as a social meme, it's a phenomenon.
So I felt like I knew what it said, even though I hadn't read it until recently. But then when I read it, what really struck me about it is how much of the book is about not just how the body keeps the score, but how and why the mind hides the score. Can you tell me a bit about that? Yeah, really.
We are created to survive. We also created to be loyal and to be part of a group. And sometimes in order to survive, you need to keep your realities different than people about you. So when you go through a terrible reality, like 9-11 in New York or terrible natural disasters, oftentimes people get very close together.
Because it's out there, everybody can see it, people help each other, part of our nature is to be altruistic and to be generous when people in distress. But if your feelings conflict with your loyalty, let's say if your own mom or dad beats you up and you don't feel safe with them, you cannot tell other people about it either because you're supposed to love a mom and dad. And so you need to keep it to yourself and then start festering inside of you. And so the reason why you do psychotherapy is mainly to help people to to find words for their reality that they have delphas.
And oftentimes, that are realities that are not acceptable for the people around you. You talk about the difference between the parts of the brain that create the autobiographical self and the parts of the brain that create the experiencing self. Can you discuss that a bit? Yeah, so we have these layers of the brain that have different different functions.
So the deepest layer has to do with what Antonio de Masio calls the housekeeping of your body, being able to breathe, go to the bathroom, go to sleep, have appetite, being able to engage in caregiving and sexual relationships, have very elementary, we have that in common with all other mammals, basically. But then we have these meaning making systems that come on top of that, starting with a larger limbic system that has a more complex way of organizing your perceptions, what reality, so basically your limbic system is a part of your brain that forms a map inside of the world outside of you. And so your brain gets programs by experience to know what to expect and what sort of reactions people will have to certain behaviors. And so it really experiences very much shape your perceptions of the world.
So if you are terrified of the people who take care of you, it's very likely that you will either, or combination of really be extremely compliant with people in power and hope that they will hurt you, or you become chronically angry and oppositional or a combination of those two. But that inference of, I'm not safe with people who say they care for me, becomes an imprint of you, how you come to perceive the world. And those are not rational thoughts. And these cannot be abolished by pointing out to people how eventually they are, because that's the way our brain becomes hardwired to deal with the reality in which it gets formed.
It was astonishing to me reading some of the stories in the book. I think all of us have the experience of telling a story about ourself that is not true to how we feel. But you treat patients who the stories our minds have told or the memories our minds have hidden are really shocking. So why do victims of abuse, particularly child abuse?
So often I forget what happened to them or blame themselves for it. So the issue there is that we need our parents or caregivers to take care of us. And so the moment we give up and take care of us, little kids, we're done for it. So the way that a child is wired to stay as close to the people who are supposed to take care of them as possible.
And with that, they will deny the reality of being beaten or the imprint is very much like I'm being beaten or being molested, because I'm a bad person. I must deserve it. So yeah, identity becomes basically I'm fundamentally a bad and flawed human being. And if I'd been a nicer child, people would have loved me and taken care of me.
If I'd been a worthwhile child, people would have done these horrible things to themselves. And actually when you get into treating these issues, the hardest thing to actually treat in people is this deep sense of being defective, something being wrong with you. And but many of my patients also deal with is that I must have made this story up. This is too horrendous for people to do it.
I cannot believe that it's happened to me. I must feel this way because I'm crazy. And oftentimes that gets reinforced by the environment or you're just a difficult child. You're just making up false memories.
And but in fact, that what happens over time, the reality slowly starts filling out. This was a real epiphany for me in reading a book because you read about cases like this, read about false memories or you hear about or even know people who blame themselves for horrible things done to them, child abuse or rape or a beating or whatever it might be. And you think what would happen that brains would be defective that they would do that? Like that doesn't make any sense.
But the point of your book, I think in part is that it does make sense. There's an evolutionary fitness reason for the brain to do that, which is that it's a story that allows you to maintain within a family or maintain within a workplace or maintain within a community. Because if you told a real story, it would rupture your family, would rupture your workplace. Exactly.
And you know, these thoughts didn't come from me, of course, which really my only thoughts I've been thought before. But the great hero here is John Bolby, the attachment researcher, who really showed how children really to cling to their caregivers and will do anything they can to keep a semblance of connection going so they don't die or get totally abandoned. And the price they pay for that is very much this very profound sense of self loathing oftentimes, disguising yourself, getting into a lot of difficult behaviors because I'm no good anyway. And it's deep sense of I may as well put myself in danger, I may as well take drugs because I'm no good anyway.
So then you get into these cases where people are telling a story about something, either telling a story that admits something or telling a story that normalizes something that their body doesn't believe. And so you have these kind of two systems, like the kind cerebral system of what somebody is sitting in front of you saying. And then the fact that they collapse into a ball at the touch of another human being or hide in drugs or have all these other coping behaviors. So can you talk about why the system that is rationalizing is unable to convince the body?
Because you would think maybe that would be just one system all the way through, you got to you got to live the lie. But part of what you're getting at is you don't live the lie, you just held the lie. Yeah, you live the lie. You really believe that I'm fundamentally defective, and that's why this happens to me.
So people really very deeply come to rationalize their very bad feelings. And that actually allows them to continue to survive to somebody. And that's a different part of the brain. But of course, your core survival part of the brain picks up the danger signs and keeps continuing to secrete stress hormones, immunological abnormalities, muscle tensions, fibromyalgia, a whole bunch of physiological systems where the body continues to behave as if it's in great danger.
While the mind says, don't pay attention to him, he's lying, he's not a terrible person. So it's that the conflict between the body feeling very unsafe and the mind not wanting to accept the reality of this happen to you is at the core of this. This is a strange idea to wrap your mind around. How is it possible that your body, which on some level is controlled by your mind, I mean, it's getting electrical signals from the brain, how is it possible that you can have such disagreements within one system?
Well, because they are somewhat different systems. The system that helps you to sleep, for example, is a system that most of us have very little control over. And so you may actually know that it's important to go to sleep now and life is safe and I have nothing to worry about. But something in the back of your brain, your survival brain, seems to give you messages of I'm in danger very commonly when people have had sexual molestation or issues like that early in their lives, they are with somebody, they have a sense of desire and suddenly their body shut down and they become very angry or very frozen.
And they say to themselves, there's something deeply wrong with me because I really like this person who I'm with and I really like to have a good time. But my body won't let me because the primitive survival part of the brain is still stuck back then when they felt in danger. But the frontal of mental vegetable. One of the main ways you say the mind hides a score is through applying shame.
You write at one point that for trauma survivors quote, shame becomes the dominant emotion and hiding truth, the central preoccupation. Can you talk about what shame is, what it is as an emotion and in the role plays for people after trauma? Yeah, shame is really a feeling of wanting to hide and you don't want anybody to see you. Shame comes from having feelings that are fundamentally unacceptable.
Like if you're talking very nice with me and I may have a feeling like I'd like to kill this guy. And I do think to yourself, what a terrible person am I to want to kill somebody who's very nice to me. And they say, I must be crazy. There's something wrong with me.
As it happens to me, maybe you have a particular accident or a way of talking that maybe might be on a very deep level of somebody who beat me up when he was a kid. And I have this intense emotional reaction to you. And I feel like what's wrong with you, Bessel, that you have such a terrible reaction to this nice person. And he probably already has picked up that I tried to hide something from him because I feel so angry with this person who's actually being very nice to me.
So that's the confusion and the shame that tongue does people live with. One thing that struck me about that passage is, and I apologize because I can't remember where I read this distinction, but I once read that guilt is an individual emotion and shame is a social emotion. Guilt is I feel bad about something I did. And shame is that I am afraid the community will look bad upon me for something I did.
And within this context of trauma often relating to things that happened that would create rupture of the community, it seems interesting and also profoundly sad that shame is such a constant companion to that because it's a way of fearing that your community will turn on you, potentially, if the truth were to be known. Well, we are communal creatures and we survive terrible things by communities, so that people who are able to come themselves together. As for example, New York did after 9-11, New York had a spectacularly effective way of dealing with the time of 9-11. And what you have to do is to go with you, you're not ashamed of yourself anymore because your neighbor may have the same feelings of terror and fear if you have and you don't feel crazy and you don't feel like you're worthy of extrusion.
So one of the things that is driving this whole trauma issue is that you feel cut off from your community. You do things that embarrass you blow up at people, your kids want to play with you and you get angry with the kid and you feel bad about being angry with the kid and you start yelling at his child and you go like, oh my God, what's wrong with me? I'm yelling with the child and you start trying to control yourself with alcohol or with drugs. And so you have these reactions that you hope people will not see and the longer they last the more isolated you become.
So one of the things that I've seen, much of them I distress, is that when we started this field in our particular window of history, as a very communal issue, as women got together around our bodies, ourselves, my friend Judy Herman, of any incest groups, I was running group for veterans and they got a lot of comfort and support from each other and they shared their very scary thoughts and their angry thoughts. They said, oh, I feel the same way. I've had the same experiences. I also make people very angry who I feel close to, etc., etc.
So I'm finding people to be with as the 12 step programs so brilliantly have done. I'll give you a sense of not being alone despite the fact that you feel very damaged and ashamed about yourself. I want to put a pin in New York in 9-11 because I want to come back to that and the question of whether or not there are things we can learn as a society whenever it will be the case that we can begin to recover as a society from COVID and whether or not there are things we can learn in that experience for how to do it well. But I want to ask about another way that we end up hiding what we feel, which is that trauma is a way of numbing people to their feelings, to their emotions, even to their basic physical sensations.
And something you talk about, which I didn't realize is that when that happens, it becomes hard to construct a coherent sense of a self. Can you talk about how that works? Yeah, when you are evolving your trauma and you are continuously reacting to stuff, you can't trust yourself and you don't really know what's right because you keep in trouble again. You try something and you freeze and you try something and you explode, and you do something and you feel terrible about yourself and you don't know where that comes from.
And so you try to make sense out of this turmoil that's going on in your sensory system. And if you're lucky, you are talented and you're a good basketball player, a good guitar player, a good accountant, and you can hide yourself in your particular talent where you can find a safe area for yourself. But when it comes to the complexity of dealing with teenage children or relationships, and it may be too much for you, and you keep falling apart. And so your identity becomes like, I cannot be with other people.
I'm no good. And so in the sense of trusting yourself, predicting yourself, knowing who you are, knowing how you will react to things becomes very damaged. For more information on how to beat the heat. Oh, yes.
Conditions apply. See website for details. So, I want to ask you this way, because a lot of us who have had experience with therapy have primarily had experience with talk therapy, where you go and you sit in a room and you ask questions about your parents and you try to answer them. What can that do and then what can language not do in these cases?
Language is really great when you have kids as you do or grandchildren. I do. You can see kids develop language over time and you can see how as they develop language, they're able to communicate about what they like or they don't like and to form common realities with other people. As long as you don't have language, you really don't know how to form a sense of community.
So, having a language that allows you to define your common reality is terribly important. And of course, traditionally, psychotherapy is very much about developing that language for yourself, which is very important, but understanding why you screwed up doesn't necessarily stop you from being screwed up. Now I know why you're freezing, but somebody touched me. Now I know why I get so angry, but the anger and the freeze may still happen.
So you still need to rewire the physiological system and much of my research has been how do you get there? And one of the earlier studies we did was doing yoga. And somehow yoga helps people develop a more harmonious sense of the internal workings and internal body sensations moving together, does think together without people. Getting a sense of wisdom, which many people around the world, except in the Western world, use and drumming together, singing together, making music, we help you to establish this sense of community and being in sync with the people around you.
Later on, starting neurofeedback, and playing computer brain interfaces where you can actually play computer games with your own brain waves and help your brain waves become irrational. And our current research is very much also in psychedelic agents, which turn out to have a very dramatically positive effect on exactly that horror sense of defectiveness, self-loading, internal confusion, and our latest data really show that's, and the MA particularly can really help people. You get a much deeper sense of who they are and deep sense of compassion for themselves. We're going to go through a bunch of these therapies.
But one thing I want to ask about them as a group is that one thing lurking around your book, and certainly that I felt reading it and that I felt in my own life, as I've looked at various modalities for things that I've struggled with, is that there's a hierarchy of status to different treatments. So it's very accepted at this point, very rational to take a pill for depression or anxiety, talk therapy as a very long history. Nobody looks at scans of that. That's something intellectuals do in New York and they sit in a chair and talk about feelings.
And I don't want to say anything bad about either of those. But then you start looking at some of these other things like EMDR, which we can talk about, or dance therapy or yoga, and it feels soft. You're like, well, that's silly. That's holistic.
That's something I think your book is trying to get at is that maybe we have come to overweight, certain kinds of approaches to how we feel and underweight others. So before we get into how these therapies work, can you talk about that meta level of coming to respect therapies that maybe don't have a lot of social status right now? Very important point you make. It's a cultural issue.
You hear from my accent, I'm not a European, and North America is still very naughty European. World and North Europe developed two ways of dealing with bad stuff. One is advice to drink. And so taking a pill is a respectable thing in western culture to do.
And normal people ingest stuff to make themselves feel better. Nobody feels bad about it. Other places in the world may say, that's weird. Then the other thing, the rest of people are very good at stalking.
We're not very good at singing together, in moving together. And you go to China after a disaster, and people are doing qi going together. I said, that's interesting, or tai chi. And you go to Brazil, in terms of the area, and you see people practice capoeira.
You go to the tourist, or do the capoeira, because it does something to the way they relate to their bodies and their sense of self control. And so I think to some degree we attract in this post alcoholic paradigm that the only way to change is through taking pills or by talking. But of course, once you raise kids and hang around with the kindergarten teachers, they don't do a lot of talking. They also do a lot of singing together, and a lot of moving together, and a lot of tossing balls together, and a lot of things that help you to get in tune and in with them with each other.
And that's not the strong point of Western culture. So it all depends on the culture, or the real assumptions you have about what's helpful to people. This part of the book made an interesting connection for me. I had the journalist Anna Sale on the show a couple months ago for her book about having difficult conversations.
And something she says in that book is that we used to have more institutions and rituals and conventions and structures that guided us through the hard conversations and hard parts of life. I mean, things like churches and civic organizations, there is a lot of singing in those places. There is a lot of dancing in those places. I mean, you go to a Jewish synagogue, a lot of singing and dancing.
And one point she was making is that some of these institutions have faded in American life. We have been left without a template for these conversations, but reading your book made me think of it on another level too. A bunch of them who just talked about like Kapowehr or Chigong, I don't want to suggest they don't have therapeutic roles, but they're not primarily seen as therapeutic. They're just a bigger part of those cultures.
And I wonder if you think that one of the issues with trauma in America is that we have lost institutions that were comfortable with ways of being embodied, even if they didn't frame them. And the body keeps the score framework that we used to have. And so they were playing roles that maybe they framed themselves as religious or civic or something else or communal or ritual, but they were also doing things for how we process difficult issues or allowed us to get in touch with our emotions that they had these side benefits that we didn't understand and never knew how to measure. Yes, of course, there are important points.
But at the same time, institutions are dangerous. And sometimes you have to pay a price to keep along with your institution. So you may have to keep silent about an elder or respected person doing bad things to women or to children or to each other. So yes, that's comforted institutions and yet as a stage institution.
But also the emphasis in the circles that I live in, which I imagine is fairly verified, I see a lot of people exploring things. I see people going on meditation retreats and singing retreats and movement stuff and making music together. And so if you're somewhat privileged in our culture, people oftentimes believe sideways of re-establishing that sense of connection and community. And again, the issue of privilege and equality is a huge issue, particularly right now with the pandemic, is that some people have much better opportunities and have a much easier culture that they fit in than other people do.
That point about the dark side of institutions is very important and very well taken. But let's talk about some of the things that you explore in the book and that people are exploring. And why don't we start with one that folks may have heard of, but even if they have, even when I had, it's very alien, which is EMDR. Can you talk a bit about what EMDR is?
EMDR is a very simple and weird technique is that you ask people to call up the images in our mind about horrible things that happen to them and to remember what they felt like in their bodies, to remember what they saw, what they heard. But you don't talk about it because the moment you start talking to people, you change your story according to what you think that person must hear, talking always about the interpersonal process and talking makes you adjust your reality to what people able to listen to. So in EMDR, you keep it to yourself, you see these things, and then you ask people to move your eyes from side to side and respond to your fingers. First time I heard about it, it sounded like crazy.
And then my patient started to come back saying, I resolved things, I was able to just leave the memory behind. I did first initialize to mental health, thunder research on EMDR, our adult onset PTSD people had like a 78% cure rate, so clearly it made your positive effects. And so that was my introduction, which I'm very grateful for, of seeing something that is on the surface bizarre, but has a very profound effect that gets us out of this post-alcoholic paradigm of talking or drugs. I said, like, this is interesting, this is weird.
And so I got very interested in how does it work? And so two years ago, we finally did a study where we looked at both these eye movements cause, and what we saw, it changes the connectivity between different parts of the brain. And so what we saw is that it affected neural networks, and that for me was just so cool, because this really opens up the frontier of where our traipitancy to go is how do we repair these networks where the different parts of the brain are disconnected from each other, of which the result is that when people have this impotent trauma, they feel it as if it's still happening now. And what we saw in our neuroimaging study of EMDR is that the surface of the brain changed.
So it allows the mind to go, oh yeah, this was happening to me, but it happened back then, a long time ago, it's not happening right now. So the EMDR was my opening that there's ways of switching neural circuits. So your perspective on the issue becomes very different. Why would moving your eyes back and forth open that pathway?
That's the question we don't know except you go back to why Darwin wrote about him pothole wrote about about conditions with sponsors of the brain, start to react to how you move your eyes in a certain direction, but there's danger and there's maybe some evolutionary circuits involved with moving your eyes in the directional threads. We don't know because research funding would not really allow people to go into asking these questions at this point. I wish we would. And one of the other things that was interesting, I've not done EMDR myself, but in people I've known who have, who've had a very positive reaction to it, and then in the stories you tell in your book, one of the things about it is that you don't just tell the story of what happened to you.
Oftentimes you begin to alter it. There's an imaginative capacity or you're telling what happened in this trauma. And then also people begin rewriting the story saying things that didn't happen and that there's some healing that seems to happen here and in some of the other monalities that we'll talk about from in an open environment imagining the way things didn't play out. And on some level that's very strange to me, right?
That you can heal yourself not by just understanding what happened, but talking through what didn't happen, but it seems to be recurrent in these therapies. So can you talk a bit about the role of imagination in healing and counterfactuals? I was hoping for questions like this is great. So the way we deal with situations is by imagining how we can do things differently.
And that's really the glory about the brain. It's like, oh, if you get fires in California, I can imagine what we can do to prevent the forest fires, to anticipate how you can make a difference. Trauma destroys the capacity to imagine how things can be different because you get trapped in that traumatic moment. So you cannot imagine anymore.
That's going to be different. So a very big issue in helping people to overcome trauma is to experience the possibility of alternative outcomes. In my own work, I love to use sacri-trauma we are involved in theater programs where people actually get to play different roles and see what it feels like in our body to take a new position to imagine being Lady Macbeth. And so to be able to embody the experience of a powerful queen, you go like, oh, that's what a body feels like and feels powerful.
And so a very important part of my mind of therapy is to help people to embody new realities. There's a fascinating study you bring up, which relates I think to this very, very famous study where they are still following, actually, but there's one class of people from Harvard, of men from Harvard, from decades to decades to decades ago. But something the study found is that in the people who were traumatized by their experience in war, their memories never really changed. They told the same story 40 years later, they told right after it happened, whereas the people who weren't traumatized by it, their memories kept changing.
The imagination was telling and retelling the story. The cliché of the old war stories that never quite happened or the fishing stories or the fish keeps getting bigger. So can you talk a bit about that, about the way a weirdly healthy memory is actually a less accurate memory because what you need in life is not accurate memories, but a story that works for you in the world? Exactly.
My friend who went to sleep laboratory at Harvard, bought a stickled, short, very clearly with your dreams, your dreams allow you to retain what's most relevant and ignore about irrelevant and you slowly change your story about what happens in order to prepare yourself for the future. It's a very complex mental phenomenon and our memories are extremely flexible. For example, I got a family reunion with my siblings. I mean, all tell stories about growing up and look at each other, say, you grew up in a different family for me and we all created a different story about our past.
And that suits us. That's the story we like to live with. But the reality may be very different. What we first thought about trauma is that the problem with trauma is you cannot change the story.
But the story is the same damn imprint, the same vision, the same body sensation as we had 10, 30 years ago. And so what we need to do when we treat people is they get the normal processes of the brain to work so you can create a new story for yourself and not get stuck on the specific sensations of them. Speaking of family reunions, can you talk about internal family systems therapy? I've never come along as until the book but it's fascinating.
Oh, well, internal family systems, not about families, it's about how we all have families living inside of ourselves. It's really a very important evolution in the past. For the years or so, Jung already talked about the same thing, William James talked about the same thing. That we have a multiplicity of minds.
What bit of a poem about it that I contain multitudes. You strike me as a very loving and kind and intelligent and two-person. Oh, I thank you. I hope that's all there is to you.
But only the people who know your best know that there's other parts of you that people don't get to see. And that may be part of us that we may not be aware of sometimes. And that we have different ways of reacting or engaging that can be quite different from what we're regarding all the circumstances. And what I have asked particularly showed us is that when you terrible things happen to you, you create ways of being in the world's personalities that help you cope.
For example, if you get chronically humiliated, you may see to yourself, nobody is going to ever humiliate me anymore. And you become this stuff bully who puts people down before they can put you down. You may go home and be a very sweet and gentle person to your kid. But when you deal with a guy in the office, you may become a bully.
That doesn't mean that all of you is a bully. That means that a part of you is a bully that comes out on the certain circumstances. So we never know other people until we live with them for a long period of time, because there may be very hidden parts of oneself that we may have developed back then in order to cope with particular challenges that we face growing up. So my understanding of how IFS works in practice is it identifies if he's almost little personalities in the brain, that the managers who try to protect you from feeling unsafe and the firefighters respond to moments of crisis, the exiles who you're trying to avoid.
And that helps people identify these distinct parts of their personalities and how those parts come out and contribute to different reactions. And that seems like something that would be helpful even outside the context of therapy. In addition to all the water qualities in mind, you listed them in and go, I do a lot of meditation. And one of the things that years of that is making much more skeptical that there's just one of me in here.
When you're sitting there just watching your mind, the constant question is, well, who thought that? Who thought thinking that would be a good idea? I don't want to be there. And the mind has belted me for a long time.
Like it's more of a corporation, has different divisions and some of them have big budgets and some small, but family systems seem to get to that too. That one thing that actually causes people frustration and shame is they are told they're in control or should be in control of their minds. And then it's very frustrating. For me, as somebody who struggled a lot with anxiety and obsessive rumination, it's very frustrating to not be able to control my own mind, because that feels like I'm failing.
And the idea that it's actually not something I should be able to do, that it's not just one singular mind, but a lot of different minds or something vying to be heard, there's some relief in that. And it seems to me some accuracy in it. You know, it's a very helpful relationship that you can only survive your relationship if you can really understand how your partner gets very uptight or angry or shut off or something, and we sponsor certain things. And if you start understanding that this is a different part, and let's say if you're a wife, which will be in the perhaps you, but perhaps the many other people, someday they say to you, I hate you.
And for you to know, oh, she's not triggered. And it was something I did not cause that angry part of her to come out. I know that that angry part is not the most reasonable part of her. So it is not the time to do for me to start arguing with her that I'm not the most selfish person in the world.
But you know that that part is out and you try to help her to know that this too shall pass. And I can see that I do think that we need to bother you, and I'll try to work on that. And she can say, I can try to negotiate with a very angry frustrated part. Little therapy might help in helping me to know where it's came from.
So that I don't get so out of control with you, but you don't do it. This is the single best piece of advice I ever got on marriage is that there is no use in thinking of your partner as a single stable entity that exists separate from you. There's only your partner in a dynamic with you. There's only who you also bring out in your partner.
There'll be somebody totally different with other people. But so the question always if things are going right or wrong, it's like which parts of the two of you are being brought out in relationship, not just who is this person and do I like them? And the exports extended, but you just said in your relationship to yourself and to really understand that you may have very different reactions at different times. And to really get to appreciate that no certain things make me very upset.
And to really start making decisions about do I want to give into that or do I want to do something about it or really start getting a perspective on this landscape that you discover inside yourself. And Mr. elaborate gets his plus room for two others. Find out more at nytimes.com slash family.
I need to mention you discussed glancing in the book, but it sounds from something you said earlier like you've been doing more work on is psychedelic therapy. It's been a lot more research since you did the book. It sounds like you're actually behind some of it. So given what we know now, I'm curious how you understand the role of psychedelics potentially in helping people deal with trauma.
I think psychedelics are a true revolution. And it's partially a revolution because we don't know how we work. There's all these explanations on our donut system or that default network. But what has happened in our world we live in is that people pay very attention what happens in the minds.
And what we see in our MDA research is that MDA seems to really trigger the capacity to look at yourself in a more compassionate way in the same way that MDA is being used at parties. And when we do our work, very painful, painful old things tend to come up. But people are able to go there and not get overwhelmed by shame or overwhelmed by the horror. And they're able to go there and say, yeah, this is what happened to me.
Oh my god, that's awful. And what is it? Actually, I'm working on that paper right now, which I think is very big deal actually is what you see. This dramatic increase in self-compassion.
People say, I know, can't really see what I went through. And how often it was and how I have survived it. And what's fascinating to me is that it gives people sense of perspective of who they are. And the sense of self gets very much enhanced.
This is who I am. This is what I went through. And this is what I've learned from my experience. It's really very dramatic.
And I think it's the sort of thing that may happen with very long-term psychotherapy, but I think very profound thinking that happened in a very short period of time. I'm very fascinated by the space for personal personal reasons. And something I was thinking about in context of the other treatments you bring up is the why. And I'm thinking here less about MDMA, which as you say has this profound self-compassion effect and more about things like mushrooms and LSD.
But something that came to mind, so Robin Carhart Harris, who is at UCSF now, and is one of the leading researchers on psychedelics, he's put forward this model, which argues that the mechanism by which psychedelics work is that they sort of relax our minds confidence in its own internal models and pattern matching and stories, which then allows us to experience some of these deeper emotions we have and begin assigning meaning and stories to them too. Which sounds actually a lot like EMDR sounds a lot like in a way what internal family systems work is doing, that ability to begin sensing something else and then trying to tell a story about it that your brain will actually believe and begin to give weight to. And I wonder if you think there's something to that that's a relaxing of like the model that is helpful here. Well, let's say that Carhart Harris has done more work at it than any of the best of us.
And I think his formulation is approximates. As you see here, I think the big thing in terms of trauma is that when you're traumatized, you live in a very narrow world. It's the world of fear and trying to stay under control and being afraid to get out of control and being afraid to get overwhelmed. So your world becomes more and more constrained, Pierre Janelle, who really voted about it 150 years ago.
And you get narrow-minded and much less than that. And also he says, when you get traumatized, the mind has a hard time continuing to grow. The mind gets stuck in his effort to try to control itself. It becomes very hard to open your mind up to new things.
So when you're traumatized, you often have to have the same patterns over and over again. You have a hard time learning from experience. Your mind closes down. I think that since Simon, Ayahuasca, Als Didu, is they open up a new universe inside of yourself that somehow you need to cope with.
The way you face it is a little bit too deliberately and cognitive for my mind that mind does something to become aware but even aware it's too conscious of that I'm a much smaller piece in a larger, larger universe. And the universal experience of these substances, which go hard hairs and fall down in all those people also would write about, is that you get to see your relative position in the universe. At the same time, as you change yourself as quite unique and special, you also get to see the rest of the universe as also be unique and special. And universally, in the culture, you always end up with the feeling of I'm a part of a much larger universe, but I'm an essential part of that part of the universe.
Which is of course the opposite of being traumatized. When you're traumatized, you go, I messed up, nobody else is, everybody's having a life and I don't. I usually feel alienated. And that sense of that all these mind altering substances to do of opening yourself up or being a part of a larger whole is very significant also.
So MDMA combined with therapy is now in phase three trials in the FDA for treating post-traumatic stress disorder. You've got to have other levels of the regulatory process. There's very much a vogue for all this. Do you worry that it is risk we're not paying attention to?
You know, I think societies have had a very difficult time legalizing and dealing with the outflow of these massive mind-expanding agents. And I'm very curious to what degree we're able to be able to stay reasonable about it, to be careful about it, to not have enough control. And I'm really delighted with Big Dublin who runs the multi-disciplinary association with secondary studies, maps, which is very hard to keep it very careful. But I'm very worried that things will get out of control.
Yeah. You were very much part of the rise of dispharmaceuticals to treat mental illness. You had one of your early studies on Prozac. And in the book, you've got a very complicated relationship with these drugs, which you prescribe and believe they can help people.
But you also worry that we overuse them, that we use drugs to ignore signals or numb signals of body ascending so that it becomes easier to not do things. How do you think about that space now? So I was a very young person. So I worked in the hospital, I did a lot of the early studies and they saw myself.
And it was an enormous promise that chemicals were the answer. And people said, mental illness is a chemical illness. And we just find the right chemical will cure it. And the billions of dollars on the chemical studies really haven't yielded all that much in terms of understanding what really mental illness.
But the sad thing is that psychiatry as a profession became addicted to drugs. And so the notion that, oh, if we just fight the right symptom, we'll fight the right drug, still pervades among many professionals. And chemicals that can be somewhat helpful, it can help you to sleep better, to be less uptight. But the chemicals that really interfere with your natural capacity to deal with these things, and for me, very quickly after I did these early studies with not bad results, they certainly did not promise.
Their happiness really started to concentrate on what important mechanisms we have to deal with our own anxiety and without depression. And so I really discovered the world of the body and timesic traditions, and yogic traditions, and green traditions, and musical traditions that show that we actually are capable of rearranging our own internal physiological systems. And I wish that in every classroom in America, they would teach the four arts reading, writing, visiting, self-regulation from kindergarten to 12th grade of what can we do to calm ourselves down, to stay focused. But activities can be engaged into fuel control of ourselves.
And so that we get away from this culture, if you don't feel right, you take a drug, so if you don't feel right, you go for a bicycle ride. If you don't feel right, you go to your class. If you don't feel right, you need to do some body work to help your body to calm, or you need to do some tengo dancing, or you need to do something to re-evasion relation to your internal physiological state. Where do you think psychiatry and mental health sort of is a profession is in its evolution?
And I mean it in this way that it all feels very scientific, and there's a lot of studies and you can read journals. And at the same time, including when reading your book, it's remarkable how crude the tools we have are. I mean, we have medications that do things that we don't really understand, but seem to have some help for some people. We have things like EMDR, which do things that we don't understand, but help some people or theater therapy or yoga.
We know exercise is good. We don't always exactly know why. Now we're exploring psychedelics, which have profound effects and seem to, with the right level of integration, help with trauma. We're very like kind of throwing stuff against the wall and finding some things unexpectedly work in ways we don't fully understand.
So do you think that there are just limits to what we can access in the kind of deep psyche? Or do you think that 100 years from now or 50 years from now, our treatment today are just going to seem incredibly crude? Like we just had not discovered germ theory or something. All of the above and none to some degree.
I don't think we don't throw everything against the wall. We're doing actually the opposite. We're looking for yet another drug to do the same old stuff that we have done. You're looking at yet another talk therapy that will make people into sensible human beings.
We have as a discipline completely ignored our early data, where we first started to image trauma in the brain that the trauma sits in the right side of the brain. And so these right brain phenomena are glassing phenomena. And so the time has come to really start looking at what else can we do? Because basically the funding has been very much focused on talking therapies and drug therapies.
So we know we haven't thrown things against the wall. I'm still waiting for the study of comparing Tango dancing with cognitive behavioral therapy. I'm a scientist. It's an empirical question.
But I put my money on Tango dancing over CBT, or not from some people. So I think we need to explore much more. Is the world open for it? Yes and no.
For example, I was able to start a foundation and rather become a recipient of funding. I'm able to fund some studies. And the very first study we are funding is the study of touch and trauma. Everybody who knows anything about trauma is the trauma.
These people have very varied and oftentimes very anomalous responses to human touch. People have won no bell prices about vision. No bell prices about audition. Touch is basically off the wall.
The main way that people get comfort in life is for being touched. Once you have been in touch inappropriately, touch maybe together to feel this. That study touch we are synchronous human beings. The source of pleasure in our lives is to be in sync with each other.
The reason I like talking with you because whenever you ask a question, I get, boy this guy, we didn't guess it. I feel you're in sync with me, which gives me a tremendous sense of pleasure. So being in sync with people is critical for our sense of fun or feeling alive. So how can we increase people's sense of synchronicity without being so?
I don't know how to work itself out because in the world we live in, it's all everything gets monetized. And so we can tend to be able to study very expensive technical treatments more than simple treatments. And so where things will go? God knows.
But boy, are we missing the boat on exploring a much larger number of options? Yes, up to now we have. On the point of touch, there are a couple lines in your book that have really etched themselves in me. And one in particular here where you say that the things that call adults are the same things that call them children being held, being rocked and being shushed.
And I don't know, I just found that very moving. It's true. You see, you two and a half years ago, yeah, he's very young. But I need to do the same thing for him.
I need myself. But at some point, we make it very difficult for adults to ask for those things. You can maybe ask your partner and that's it. You really, particularly, I'll speak more for men here because I understand male relationships a little bit better.
But you really, as a man, you can't go to your male friends and ask to be rocked and shushed. Yeah, a little bit of the culture you have something to do with it. Yeah. And it just strikes me as a shame to the point you were just making.
We spend so many billions of dollars and so much effort to get the medications we think will help and to see psychiatrists. And we've also cut ourselves off from a lot of just very cheap things. We have culturally cut ourselves off from a lot of touch. We often live in very atomized ways.
I mean, there's very kind of cheap, natural things that are part of our deep history that we give to our children, you know, when, you know, or at least in many homes that I don't know, we've just decided our little somehow and coothed and we suffer for it. A very big part of what you're talking about is our socially-transferent system and our humongous income inequality. I sent my kids to schools where there was a lot of theater, music, dancing, creative writing, sports. They were always moving and creating things.
The poorer you are, the less you get any of these things. We're going to come back. We're definitely going to come back at the end to the bigger question of inequality. But before we do that, I want to reverse the way we've been looking at this.
We've been talking about the way traumatized people are disconnected from their communities. And I want to talk a little bit about what it means to be in community with somebody who is traumatized. A lot of the patients you talk about in the book, a lot of the behaviors that traumatized people exhibit, they're very alienating to those around them. They're difficult.
They can be dangerous. Can you just talk a bit about what trauma is like for those who love someone who is traumatized? It is very hard. You build somebody who's traumatized, who has suddenly shuts down, who suddenly blows up.
And it takes an enormous toll on relationships. And oftentimes, partners get blamed for the other part of behavior. And so it really finds its way into relationships. And so groups of survivors becomes very important.
Groups of incest survivors, groups of people who were molasses by catholic priests, people who struggle with addiction, helping each other say, I know what you're talking about. I'm not here primarily to condemn you, but to keep your company in your struggle for a survivor who is terribly important. In a couple of solutions, that's harder because you have a job to do a ways in case, etc. But these support groups can be very good to give people a sense of being a member of human race.
And why don't you stop feeling like a member of human race? You chance it for wanting to survive, become very slim. How do you advise people to deal with a very difficult question of what you can ask of someone they love? I mean, the tension between recognizing that the reality that people's actions are often largely out of their control.
They don't want to treat us badly. They don't want to disconnect. They don't want to pull back. And also that we don't want to be mistreated or taken advantage of or hurt.
And that there's something you can ask of some people, right? Sometimes you can ask somebody to treat you better. And then sometimes you need to recognize that there is healing that has to happen before they're going to be able to do that. But it's often hard to know which situation is which.
Do you have advice for people who feel like they're in that situation? Yeah, I think that's really too largely that the relationships are all about. It's the continuous negotiation of what can be before each other. A relationship is about being there for each other.
So my job, if you're not in a relationship, is indeed to try to create situations in which you can feel safe and be productive. But your demands may be too much for me. And they need to be able to say, honey, I cannot do it. I really need to sleep in a bedroom by myself if you wake up screaming in light, guys, all right.
And it must be very hard for you if I cannot sleep in the same bed with you. But we both have needs. And these are very hard to negotiate. And I think you need to have a lot of consciousness and a lot of awareness to actually be able to sit down and to identify these issues and to talk about these issues.
But that is the nature of relationships. What can I do? What can I not do? What are the expectations?
To what can I fulfill these obligations? And to what degree do you need to get the resources for yourself from somebody else? Because I'm depleted. I cannot give you what you're asking for it.
So I want to go back then to this question of the broader society. You were talking about a minute ago with schools and inequality. On one level, it's clear, I think, that providing child care and pre-k and welfare schools and universal health care and better access to mental health services would help make a society that is better at helping people. But on some of that also can't be the whole answer because a lot of middle and upper class people's lives are full of trauma too.
So I'm curious what you think are the structures and institutions or even just social mores that would help us become healthier and help people who either be traumatized or help them more once they are. It's of course very complex and nobody has the answers but creating situations where parents can safely take care of their kids is terribly important. And of course that's much easier when you have money and if you don't have money. So almost every other society has universal health care and has support which we lack.
And so for me this is really a very big issue. Yes, it's because the system we live in, the majority of people I treat are people who come from relatively fortunate circumstances. Because if you come from very little education either in the high school diploma, there's no way you will find a way of getting to see an experienced mental health professional. What interventions for kids do you think would do the most good?
I mean if you could wave your wand and put some new structures into law that they have elsewhere or that they don't have elsewhere. You know what would the first couple of them be? First of all child care, you don't have to be locked after the same person all the time. It's very important for a kid to have the experience of being exposed to more than one adult and to see that other people have different ways of doing business.
So you can actually see oh my mom gets very upset as opposed to that's the world I live in. Now the second piece is to be involved in rhythmical activities with other kids. Moving together with other kids, dancing together with other kids, playing with other kids, exploring the world with other kids is so at the core of what creates a healthy mind and a healthy brain. That means that there is space and that people can actually explore things safely.
You can actually go out with your friends and try things out. So you don't live in an environment where there is so much danger outside the door or inside the door. You cannot play anymore. So I would say the most important thing for climate test kids is to go to places where they can play.
And that is even in some very well-known children's institutions that are hardly any places to play. Hard any place to move around, to sing, to play, to dance, to run. So kids are supposed to really move and move together with other kids and basically our systems are made to move in synchrony with the people around us. Where you can traumatize, you get out of sync on every and most elementary level.
But as the military do, you have people move together and march together to get them back in sync with each other. And it sounds to me like you think the same is actually true for adults that you need space to play, to move, to be in synchronicity with others, to sing, to dance, to have what gets called collective effervescence. Absolutely. Of course, you get frozen as we grow older, not cooking with people, serving meals to people, pouring that wine to other people.
Still, moving together is a terribly important way of feeding our commonalities on human beings. And then I want to return to a question I said we tackle here at the end, which is you talked about the ways in which the post 9-11 period in New York City was actually well handled from the perspective of trauma. One thing that led to us doing this podcast is your book has been back up all the way up on the bestseller lists. And I don't think that's an accident.
I think that has to do with people sensing a lot is wrong in themselves and in society, as we do, and in some cases don't recover from the coronavirus. So we've just been through a society-wide trauma. We are still going through it. But at some point, there's going to be the potential maybe for recovery.
Are there lessons from New York City after 9-11 for countries when they finally can turn to trying to recover from this pandemic? To my mind, the biggest lesson from in New York was for one thing, everybody knew the reality of what had happened. And nobody blamed anybody on the inside. So that immediately put the issue of secrecy and shame off the map, which is fairly rare when it comes to trauma.
The next thing is that people actually did things. People got together in neighborhood group, they got together with their family. And there's a lot of common analysis in New York. New York temporarily became a very kind city.
People really were lovely with each other. They made space for each other. And it was almost unrecognizable. The other thing is that money poured into New York.
It's something like half of all Americans donated money. There was no dearth of resources. So many people were traumatized, have no resources, they have no money. We don't have universal healthcare.
If you don't have good insurance, it's very hard to get many of the treatments that I talk about. So the issue of excess and resources is huge. And if we wanted to have good healthcare systems, we need to have universal healthcare. We cannot have one healthcare system for the rich and a complete different healthcare system for the poor.
I think that's a good place to end. So always our final question. What if three books that have influenced you that you would recommend to the audience? Yeah.
Eve Ensler, who now calls herself V, wrote a beautiful book called The Apology. She was, I mean her whole work comes from, has me feeling well, that's about her dad. And I think her book and her other work also is an extraordinary testimony of courage of facing up to yourself and to your experience and then going on. She's just marvelous.
The other book that comes to mind is Love in Goon Park. It's a book about Harry Harlow's Laboratory and discovery of attachment in one piece. So just a marvelous book about us as human beings being very much like interactive with other people and Harry Harlow's very flawed human being discovering that. Another book that I think is great, The Australian Guy by the name of Flanagan, who wrote a book called The Narrow Road to the North about more experiences and how more experiences impact on people and get split off.
We just go on and on the non-Caramel Antises book about what is left to go to war is an extraordinary description up there with toy stories about the more experience and his own journey to recovery. That's a free example. Vessel Vander Kolk, your book is The Body Keeps the Scores from Archibald. Thank you very much.
Thank you. It's a pleasure.