Skip to content
Three-Minute BizzleCast: Why THE WITCHER doesn't have the STAR WARS Canon Problem episode artwork

Dec 20, 2020 3 min

Three-Minute BizzleCast: Why THE WITCHER doesn't have the STAR WARS Canon Problem

from The BizzleCast Podcast by The Bizzle

Because we fans of THE WITCHER have already learned to reconcile differences and/or contradictions between Book Lore and Video Game Lore (and really it doesn't bother us much at all), the fight over what's "Canon" and what's not -- see: STAR WARS Canon vs. Legends/EU etc. -- hasn't been much of an issue with the TV series on Netflix and is really liberating to Lauren Hissrich and the filmmakers there. Here's a quick summation of how this fortunate set of circumstances came to be by yours truly, The Bizzle.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Three-Minute BizzleCast: Why THE WITCHER doesn't have the STAR WARS Canon Problem

0:00 3:17
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I think if Star Wars continues to have problems or there's just an extended problematic period, people will look back on the decision of canon as being the fatal flaw of the experiment. And what I mean by that is... There's a lot of Witcher fans, hardcore game and our book fans, who really like the show. There's a lot who really don't like the show, and then there's a lot in the middle who are still waiting to see for later seasons, and they're keeping an open mind or not, or whatever, which is fine. I don't really care. I loved it. But the reason I loved it is exactly the reason other people didn't like it, which is I specifically wanted this to be different enough that it would not be confused with book lore.

And, Jay Geek Girl, this is furthered by the fact that even though the video games are considered by fans almost to be canon because they are so loyal and because they take place in the future, you know, they're the episode 789 or whatever of the original trilogy, essentially. We can get, you know, an older Triss, an older Yennefer, an older Geralt, an older Ciri. and see where that goes but it's so loyal to the world and the fact that henry cavill is really playing gerald from the video game as much or more just vocally performance wise than gerald from the book which i want to ask you about with his long speeches and stuff which henry cavill's version is never going to do the violence is totally taken from the video game you know he hangs the heads of the creatures he kills on roach's saddle and stuff i mean that's all straight from the fucking video game so what i'm saying is witcher fans are already um not only accustomed to but acculturated into not having a contradiction in their brain between the fact that this can all work together but there's also going to be contradictions and we're just going to let there be contradictions and not have you know endless lore debates um and have this be what you know supposedly star wars is right which is a retelling of a retelling of a retelling like all myth you know is because which is fantasy i guess but also you know folk myth um there's not this oppressiveness of lore and honestly the fans biggest complaint

Like, the hardcore nerd dudes was that the Nilfgaardian's black armor wasn't badass enough in the first season. And they fired the fucking costume designer. And Lauren Hissrich came out and specifically outlined how they were going to restructure the Nilfgaardian armor to be more the black and gold evilness from the book. I mean, that's how much they care about this material. But, like, that's what fans care about, Janky Girl. And, you know, maybe there will be canon debates. I guess what I'm saying is the fact that there was a love of the books and the games already as these two huge source materials, and we already knew that they weren't official canon even though they worked together, has already conditioned...

us to accepting a TV series which has different interpretations of what's going on, I guess is what I'm saying.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The BizzleCast Podcast by The Bizzle?

This episode is 3 minutes long.

When was this The BizzleCast Podcast by The Bizzle episode published?

This episode was published on December 20, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The BizzleCast Podcast by The Bizzle episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.