A vacation rental should come with support, not surprises. That's why Verbo comes with a Verbo Care guarantee and 24-7 live support from real people. So if something goes sideways, Verbo Care can help. If the host cancels, Verbo Care.
If the listing says heeded pool, but there's actually no pool to heat. Definitely a Verbo Care thing. If my teenager starts calling me Leslie instead of Mom. That's a family thing Leslie.
That's sense. Book with support, not surprises. Verbo Care and 24-7 live support. If you know, your Verbo, turn supply.
ZVerbo.com slash trust for details. I'm Mr. Cline. This is the Ezra Cluncho.
There's this quote. I think it's from The Elder Goss Pison. And I think about it a lot. It says quote, The universe is under no obligation to make sense to you.
And something I love about that is it, it also implies, and I think basically everything we know about physics, particularly quantum physics gets here, that what we experience is probably quite far from what the universe really is. And nowhere is that true than time. I mean, nothing is more fundamental to our experience than time. We live in time.
We are marked by time. We feel the seconds passing when we're bored. We see the time flies when we're on vacation or in the midst of a great conversation. But one thing we do not have more of is time.
Our entire lives are bounded by time. And you'd think from there that what time is to be pretty clear. But talk to scientists who study time and they are fundamentally confused about it. What time actually is, particularly outside the human brain, to say nothing of how weird the human brain is in the ways it measures time is just fascinating.
And you get into these really, really weird questions. Like a lot of the math suggests that maybe time is already there. Maybe the future is exactly as real as a present. Does that mean it's predetermined?
Does that mean our understanding of causality is entirely wrong? What does that even mean? My guest today is Dean Bon Bono. He's a professor of neurobiology and psychology at UCLA.
And his book, Your Brain is a Time Machine, what a great name. It gets at these two levels of time. The time that we experience. And the time that exists as best we understand it outside of our experience.
This is one of those conversations, one of those topics that at times, ha ha, you might feel like you've taken a handful of mushrooms. Because it's weird. Ultimate reality to the extent there is such a thing is weird. But that's why I love these topics.
Reality remains such an unbelievable mystery to us. We see only the tiniest of our of it. And for me, appreciating that mystery, appreciating how little the world has to accord to my perception of it, how little I will ever know about it. It's a pretty deep spiritual practice.
It's fun. As always my email is your client show and my time is stuck out. Dean Bonamal, welcome to the show. Thank you very much for having me.
So let's imagine there are no human beings, there are no animals, the universe is cold and dead. What is time in that universe? Well, that's a tricky question. We define time in a number of ways.
So time is actually the most common noun in English language. And one of the reasons that's the case is because it means different things depending on what we are referring to. So in your scenario, time would still be changed. So things are dynamic, even in the cold universe, particularly if it's in the initial part of the universe, things will be dynamic and changing and expanding.
So time exists in the sense that the universe is undergoing a change. Now, practically, there's a couple of ways to sort of try to define time. One is simply clock time. And clock time is a bit circular, right?
Because time is what clocks tell, so the definition is a bit circular. But in a way, that's mostly what we mean by the passage of time. And all the clock is, is a device that changes in a predictable manner. So even particles that disintegrate with specific temporal properties are in a sense.
Clocks. So there's clocks all around. The universe is a clock in a manner of speaking. But other aspects of time are subjective time.
So this, you said in a universe without animals and humans, so we wouldn't have that subjective time, what you and I are aware of, the flow of time that's passing. And then we also have this idea of what we could call a natural time or the time of physics, in which the question is, is if time is a dimension much like space, in which time is sort of already laid out and the past exists in much the same way as the present exists, and in much the same way as the future exists, they would all coexist, if you will. And that's an ongoing debate in philosophy and physics. I want to come back to that physics level of time.
But first, I want to get at the human level of time. So let's now think about the world that we do inhabit, where we exist and animals exist and time exists. You write in the book the human brain did not evolve to understand or to experience the true nature of time. Tell me what you mean by that.
So all animals exist in time, of course, and they have to anticipate and interact with other beings, other cons specifics and predators and prey. But humans are unique in our ability to represent time and to have a conceptualization of time of long temporal periods to make cause and effect relationships between now and one year from now. So while humans have the ability to conceptualize time, that's sort of what gives us the ability to have this discussion of what is the nature of time, what's the difference in past, present, and future. So this ability that humans have to conceptualize time, I think, is what makes Homo sapiens sapien, so it makes us wise.
But at the same time, we're not very good at it. We know what we mean by time, but it's something we're still struggling to understand. There's the famous quote by St. Augustine, which has translated various ways, but the gist of it is, if you don't ask me what time is, I know what it is.
If you ask me what it is, I do not know. So we struggle to define time. And so that's what I mean, that the brain didn't evolve to understand not only time, nature, time, but a lot of things, including the fundamental nature of the universe. And it remains to be seen if the human brain can understand the human brain.
So the brain is a very limited information processing system. And I think an awareness of that, both in science and in society and our day-to-day lives, is actually rather important. So we did evolve to survive, to reproduce. So what kind of relationship to time did we evolve with?
What do we use time for? So all animals have the ability to anticipate what's about to happen, and make cause-and-effect relationships that if they hear a sound, that sound might reflect a predator prey hidden in the bushes. So we, like all other mammals, we inherited that ability, because in many ways, that ability to predict the future is one of the brain's main jobs, right? The brain's main tasks, in many ways, is to use the past to anticipate the future.
And that's something everybody's doing right now. You're unconsciously tapping predict the future. And if I were to pause my speech there, sorry to make you nervous, you would notice that pause because you were predicting I was about to say something. I created a temporal prediction error.
So all animals have this ability to anticipate and predict time and be aware of time on the short scale. And the degree to which animals predicted what's about to happen translated very effectively into the evolutionary currency of survival and reproduction. But humans came along and did something radically different. They were able to not just try to predict the future, but create it.
So think about something like agriculture for most of evolution, animal sought food, and survival required figuring out where food sources would be. And humans came up with the idea of creating food, in essence, planting a seed and reaping the fruits of that action sometime in the future. And that ability to conceptualize cause and effect across months or years is something that really evades the cognitive capacity of most animals. It's not that complex, right?
The idea of agriculture. But because the brain of most animals is not particularly good at linking cause and effect across large periods of time, agriculture wasn't invented by other animals. So this ability to create the future, this ability to engage in what we call mental time travel is really in many ways the defining cognitive signature of our species. You think of something like tool use, which we often relate to being a unique to human beings.
But in many ways, the key cognitive breakthrough with tool use is not simply carving a tool out of obsidian stone. But having the conceptualization say, I'm going to use this at some point in the future. I'm going to still create this. I'm going to store it because it will come in handy.
That's the cognitive breakthrough that at some point we achieved. Tell me about the relationship between our sets of time and our memory. Time and memory indeed are tightly coupled in a number of ways. So when we talk about our perception of time, there's two distinct frameworks that we should be aware of.
One is prospective timing. So one is as you're living in the moment and time might seem to be going quickly or slowly. This came up a lot during COVID. It was widely felt that during lockdown periods, time was going by slowly.
So that's what we call prospective timing. Now interestingly, when you're looking back at what happened, sometimes you have this paradoxical effect in which we call retrospective timing. And maybe during the COVID period or the Q part of COVID period during the lockdown, looking back, it seemed to have flown by, it seemed to have gone by very quickly. And that's because it's linked with memory.
And so our retrospective judgments of time are really in many ways sort of guesstimates based on how many items we have in memory. So this goes back to William James, Henry James's brother, who made the observation well over a century ago that moments of time filled with new experiences seem to go by quickly in passing, but seem to have lasted very long in retrospect because you have to not a lot of new memories to being formed. So you can imagine, in the extreme case, somebody with very severe amnesia. So there's actually a couple of famous cases when a gentleman called Clive Waring, who has no ability to form new, no new memories about his own experiences, no new autobiographical memories.
And he's essentially locked into an eternal present. He has a diary in which he writes down 11 o'clock and just woke up and then 12 o'clock and just woke up and two o'clock and just woke up. So if you don't have the ability to form new memories, you really are locked into eternal present. You don't have any real conscious access to your recent history.
So we can only imagine how disorienting that is. This gets to something that you brought up at the beginning about this difference between subjective time and perhaps other kinds of time. This idea that the way we experience time actually shifts depending on what we're experiencing in it. You mentioned a minute ago that the less it happens, the quicker things can go by.
And that's what I always heard too. And I feel like in some points in my life it felt, but I was struck by some researching a book or some experiments, I guess, more to the point where people would volunteer for one reason or another to be functionally in a cave or a dark room for quite a long time. And then months or a year later they would come out and they would think much less time had passed than actually had. And given our view that time to speed up when nothing is happening, the fact that for them it's so down is really interesting to me.
What do you think that is? Yeah, that's a great point as well. So it is absolutely the case that when we're measuring passage of time or subjective experience, if you're in a fun movie or you're enjoying yourself with your friends, we report subjectively that time seems to be going by quickly. So that's as if the external clock is going by more quickly.
And when we're bored, the opposite happens, it seems to be the external clock is going by more slowly. And there's a couple of famous cases when one of the first was Michelle Seifree, a Frenchman who spent maybe six months in a cave, we infer that they would be quite bored. And thus that as time is going by, they would report it to be going very slowly. The reason I think has a different factor in clay there.
And that's the circadian clock. So the circadian clock, of course, is what keeps track of our daily rhythms in terms of when we're hungry, when we go to sleep and when we get up, the circadian clock seems to actually, in those cases, have slowed down. And so his circadian rhythm has gone over our standard of approximately 24 hours. And he gets the impression that he's fewer days have gone by when he's in the cave.
So this has happened time and time again in those studies in which they're in for say six months, six months later, somebody comes knocking on the cave door and says time to go out and they're saying, whoa, already, it's I thought it was only four months. We believe that's in part because the circadian clock has expanded their periods. So they're oscillating their sleep cycle is probably significantly over 24 hours. And it's important to realize in these cases that unlike the clocks on our wrist, which are amazing technological achievements and that they can tell time on the scale of microseconds, seconds, minutes, hours, days, years, et cetera, we have clocks in our brain that can also tell time across those time scales, but they're fundamentally different clocks.
The circadian clock doesn't have a second hand and the mechanisms in your brain responsible for say timing the duration of a traffic light don't have an hour hand. So the notion that subjective time is sometimes distorted as during under the influence of psychoactive drugs or during periods of isolation during the COVID pandemic or simply moments of boredom or excitement. When I'm writing or really engaged in reading or having a really remarkable conversation, and I have that sense you just mentioned of this passage of time falling away, what's happening in me when that occurs? These are conscious experiences.
So this is a fundamental mystery in neuroscience is what is consciousness. So the feeling of passage of time is one of the many flavors of conscious experiences. So it's very hard to address what defines the feeling of time passing slowly or quickly without understanding consciousness, which we don't know yet. But I think one of the things that's happening there is a large part of your neural circuitry, if you will, is devoted to whatever task is at hand.
And you're not doing this parallel processing and phasing in and out of different modes of thinking going back and forth while should I be doing this and you're not daydreaming and so forth. So I think it's just a cognitive state in which you can imagine chess players or athletes being in very critical moments or anybody who's engaged in writing, as you said, or programming that they're very engaged in a task. And most of us find that fairly rewarding. And so it says if the brain makes that rewarding, although it's very challenging and difficult, presumably because it's also in many ways adaptive to be focused on certain types of tasks.
But these are deep questions. We just really don't know the answer to in terms of what causes these distortions, because the distortions are distortions of subjective experiences. And we don't really know what causes subjective experiences to begin with. You write about some research that has been done on people who've survived life-threatening accidents.
What tends to happen to people's time during a car crash or a seeing accident? So there's, as you may or may not know, I guess I should hope that you don't know, many people have this report of time dramatically slowing down often reported as they're life-flying before their eyes. And I think this has been debated as what's possibly happening in the brain. And there's a couple of different views of this.
One idea is that your brain is really functioning at a very high speed. It's sort of like boosting the clock speed of your computer called overclocking. That's probably not what's happening to a large degree, because the brain can't be overclocked in any significant way. It can't be sped up.
Neurons can only fire at specific rates most of the time. Another view is that it's sort of an illusion in the sense that it's just that you remember everything that happened very well after the fact, after you're recounting what's happening. And that's sort of an idea that it's sort of like a flash memory of what happened during your accident. But more generally, I think this speaks to the general challenge of understanding our subjective experience time to begin with.
So it's not surprising that time gets distorted because it's subjective experience and all subjective experiences get distorted. So when people are reporting these experiences, they often report space being distorted as well. I recount my personal anecdote in that situation when I was hit by a car and my car was spinning around, I recall thinking to myself at the time, wow, time really does slow down when you're about to die. And so that, to me, led credence to the theory that it's not a trick of memory.
It's really that your brain is processing information at a different level. So I think it's a bit more akin to an hallucination and perhaps to the influence of psychoactive drugs or equivalent to the influence of psychoactive drugs creating temporal spatial hallucinations. Some songs that I've written, I started on a piano that happened with All In One For Christmas Is You? If you couldn't tell, that is Mariah Carey.
I'm John Caramanica, one of the critics behind The New York Times is 30 Greatest Living American Songwriters Project. We interviewed some of the songwriters on our list, including Taylor Swift, who hasn't sat for a video like this in a long time. These are not ordinary conversations. You're going to watch these videos and learn about intimate approaches to craft in ways that you rarely have access to.
My mommy got me this notebook and I was just writing it really small because I didn't want anybody to read what I was writing. Okay, Jay Z's teenage notebooks. I need to see those. Watch all the video interviews for free and check out the entire 30 Greatest Living American Songwriters Project at nytimes.com slash 30 Greatest or In The App.
And let us know if you agree with our picks. I bet you won't. When Mark Clarkson did and how to the best is we understand it, how they change our experience of time. So the evolution of human culture and civilization has really tracked the creation of more and more sophisticated clocks going back from sundials to hourglass, to water clocks, to mechanical clocks, pendulum clocks, quartz crystals, and today atomic clocks.
So human civilization has been accompanied by this endless quest to measure time with more and more and more accuracy. And this quest has been absurdly successful in that today we measure time with more accuracy than we measure anything else, including distance or mass. Indeed today we define space using time. A meter is defined by how far light travels in one second.
So for reasons that are always immediately clear, we have had an obsession with measuring time and it has had profound impacts on society and culture. You know, some people have argued that during the Industrial Revolution that was driven by the invention of the steam engine. But other people have argued that well it was really the availability of clocks, of cheap clocks, that were widely available to the population and the people who worked in factories that allowed for the Industrial Revolution. Because in the factories, you need to synchronize human behavior, you need to synchronize work hours in which everybody had to show up at the same time to do the production lines that were being created at the time.
So there's no doubt that we have become more and more synchronized. Clocks have allowed us to synchronize our behaviors, like meeting you today at a specific time that 500 years ago that those type of things would not be possible with accuracy that we have today. Indeed, it's an argued that even Einstein's theory of special relativity was in part related to the need to synchronize train schedules to synchronize clocks that were being used locally and in other areas in different cities and different states in order to synchronize train schedules. So clocks have a profound effect on our technology from computer technology to GPS technology.
So I think it is one of the most successful or most impactful technologies on human civilization. Is there anything to lament in the dominance of omnipresence of clocks? We know a fair amount about societies before clocks. We know of certain tribes even now that don't much use them or in recent history have any use of them.
What is lost by being a member of modernity with the constant tick of the clock behind you? What would my experience of the world be different to what would be enriched by its absence? I think there's always things that are lost when we rely on certain technologies. With the advent of the sundial, there's this famous poem by a philosopher lamenting that the sundial took away his free will and was telling him when it was time to have dinner instead of being guided by his own eternal clock.
So one can only imagine what he would have thought of today's precision in terms of our 10 minute meetings times to the second or the initiation of events on TV that are timed to the second. But in many ways, it's not the clocks that are imposing that. It's our use of the clocks. So we can, this is true in a lot of technologies.
It's not the technology itself that might be constraining our behavior in ways that aren't always helpful. So not having free time. So having just ability to not have anything on our schedules and have an open period of think is something that is invaluable for how our brains work. Our brains need time, empty time to consolidate memories, to rehearse what we've already learned.
And when we have continuous exposure to things in terms of social media, streaming, TV, and so forth, I think that takes away a bit of our really, really to absorb information and reflect upon that information. But again, that's not so much the fault of the technology. That's the fault of how we use the technology. But I'm very curious as I mean, so what's your feeling about that?
How do you feel that clocks constrain or enhance our life as individuals and as society? I think this is a little bit like asking a fish when it's like to not live in water. I mean, I'm so clocked in my life. I've had periods though, you know, education here, there, or camping trip, or the ingestion of some kind of substance that really warped or detached me from clock time.
One effect of that in each time has been a sharper focus on the present. I think clocks and particularly scheduling and so on that they encourage keeps you constantly living, particularly in the future and with the constant eye on what's coming and where you are and how much time has passed and what did you do this morning. And then I think that there is a false precision to how long a day your life is that actually strikes me as a quite profound question. I mean, there's so much emphasis in question of life extension and can human beings ever become immortal or you know, what if we could add 50 years or 20 years and I think a lot of these questions are pretty subjective time, at least gently pose a question of what if our lives could feel longer and what if we are doing things so that it's always making them feel shorter.
And I certainly have the experience that a highly scheduled life makes my life seem to fly by in a way that open time creates a spaciousness in the flow of time that feels a little bit more satisfying. I don't know what to do about that because I got to get things done and my kids got to get places and I got deadlines but it's not lost on me and actually something that I think about quite a lot that I seem to live a life that is speeding up my own passage through time in a way that doesn't always feel good as I'm watching it or feeling it slip through my fingers. Yeah, I think that's a good way to put it and it is certainly in terms of sort of trying to imagine what if you were a fish what it is to be outside of the water and this notion on the present and we're encouraged to live in the present and focus on the present and that's really solid advice in that I think it helps our enjoyment and not only enjoyment but ability to process and reflect upon what's happening. But it's a double edged sword in the sense that we want to have as much time as possible but if you're only living in the present you will actually have less of a future because survival requires planning and preparing for the future.
If you were a native of the Amazon forest and you might not have to think about the future as much as food is always available but if you're an Eskimo and you're not thinking about the future in terms of what to prepare and say for the winter you know you're not going to have much of a future so there's this balance between preparing for the future and living in the present but many cases living in the present can include thinking about the future and that's often how I try to think about it is that what we mean is not necessarily living in the present but focusing on whatever it is we're doing even if that is a future oriented behavior and as we've discussed this future oriented behavior is something very unique to humans other animals don't seem to have this capacity to engage in mental time travel but just because we humans are capable of it doesn't mean we're very good at it indeed I think that many of the most significant problems we have as individuals and as members of society reflect our lack of long-term thinking and preparation for the long-term future at the level of individuals that's clear in the context of saving for retirement or exercising or taking care of one's health and at society level of course this comes up in the context of climate change that our ability to take actions in the present that might require short-term sacrifices for large payoffs or large advantages in the long-term future are very difficult for our species to take. I want to segue here into a very different view of time that you mentioned at the beginning of the conversation and I said we'd come back to tell me about presentism and eternalism as theories of time and why eternalism has come to be more widely it is contraindutive it is surprising because on our day-to-day life there's nothing sort of as salient as the fact that the present is fundamentally different from the past and the future the past no longer exists we can't manipulate it in the future hopefully we can by our actions that take place in the present and so that is what we would call presentism this idea that the past no longer exists the present is where we exist and the future doesn't exist yet but the counter view called eternalism and that's similarly also called the block universe there the view is that in many ways here is to space as now is to time in other words it's arbitrary then now is arbitrary there's another now for some other version of me in the past or the future and here the idea is is that past, present and future all are equally real or coexist and if you could see me I would be doing air quotes because the word exists is a bit tricky in this context but the idea is that the temporal structure of the universe has already been laid out or is already there in a manner of speaking and that the past present future are equally real. So what you just described there eternalism it's very unintuitive but you say it's a more dominant view among the people who spend their lives studying the fundamental laws of the world so why do they believe that how can it be possible in a world where depending on what I do next the future changes at least seems to but somewhere the future is already laid out. It's a bit dangerous to say it's the dominant view I would say it is probably the most accepted view in philosophy and physics but certain people would probably take issue with that statement but the reason that view is favored is a couple of reasons one is that the laws of physics equations that are used in physics don't have any you are here in time they don't have any special role for the present moment so you can run the equations of physics forwards backwards starting in the future starting in the past the laws of physics don't tell us anything that hey the now is special anyway okay no that's not perhaps the best argument because the laws of physics don't also tell us that the present is not special so that's one reason the other reason relates certainly to Einstein's theory of relativity so Einstein's special theory of relativity established very compellingly and without a shadow of doubt that there's no present so it doesn't really make sense if i tell you it's 11 o'clock where i am to ask what somebody's doing on another planet in a distant galaxy at 11 o'clock there's no because time is relative or the absolute present is certainly relative and it turns out that one of the best ways to make sense of this or at least intuitively is to sort of assume that time is spatialized so sometimes people think of a four-dimensional block in which the past present future are all equally real or in a sense already present in the universe and relatedly in Einstein's so-called general theory of relativity the equations that he discovered or invented allow for time travel and they don't i won't say they predict time travel but they allow time travel why i'm bringing that up is probably the best way the most intuitive way to think of the difference between presentism and eternalism is that under presentism time travel as we see in the movies true time travel where you can go forward and backwards is absolutely impossible it's off the table because there's nowhere to go i can't go back to visit my grandparents because they no longer exist so under presentism time travel is off the table under eternalism time travel is on the table and that's why it's so sometimes so predominant in science fiction and it's actually hard to get away from i think nowadays so the fact that some of the equations of general relativity allow for the possibility of time travel i think has been one motivation for embracing the eternalist view among some physicists and philosophers i think that brings up an interesting tension between at least one of the the main views of what time is and in the way we experience time because for everything we've talked about here on the one hand there's the human experience of time connected to memory connected to clocks where we are taking information from the past applying it in the present in ways intended and as you say and perfectly so but in ways intended to change the future and then there's this idea that you know comes out of special relativity and other theories and physics experiments and equations that well maybe the future the present in the past are all laid out maybe they exist somewhere and so the sense that we are changing the future to what we do in the present based on what we've learned in the past isn't some at least linguistic tension with this idea the future is already out there that the future exists in some fundamental way how do you think about that?
well in this debate in this tension between presentism and eternalism i clearly fall in the camp of presentism so to me it doesn't alter our intuitive view of that yes we can alter the future and i think that's a fundamental aspect of animal evolution in the sense that the brain evolved to survive in a world governed by the laws of physics and part of that as a result of that evolution we have this feeling of the passage of time and we have the feeling that the past and fundamentally different from the present which is fundamentally different from the future and i don't think we would have evolved that subjective experience if it didn't reflect some aspect of reality remember our subjective experiences aren't simply for our viewing pleasure they enhance our chances of survival so pain enhances our chances of survival love presumably enhances our chances of survival as do feelings subjective feelings of the passage of time or color and so forth so my view is that this is a case in which we have to trust our intuitive subjective experience that time is passing and that does tell us something about the nature of the universe now you're absolutely correct in the sense that under eternalism the question of free will is seriously put in jeopardy in that we wouldn't really have free will because things have already happened so i think at a level of your philosophical experience of what happening that is can be perceived as a blow i don't know if it should be either way but i think philosophically those have very profound and distinct implications for topics of free will but as i said as a presentist i strongly feel that we are in effect have the ability to make decisions in the present that shape future outcomes hi i'm jilliet from new york times games and i'm here talking to fans about our games so you plan your times games yes do you have a favorite connections h's scratch is an itch in my brain to the other box thinking with that game i play with my husband every night i refuse to let him play it without me he will always get the purple first and i always get like the fun ones that he doesn't think about i love that it's like a real life connection yes while you guys play connections very sweet i promise i didn't play that you can play on your times games at nytimes.com slash games or on our app you write about this this fascinating study that was done on a tribe of people called pudaha people in the amazon tell me about that study and what was unusual or interesting about the results yeah so this is mostly work by a linguist and anthropologist called daniel Everett and he has a great book by the way called don't sleep there are snakes and his report and i think we have to always interpret these reports with some caution because these cross-cultural studies are first place very very difficult to do and second place even more difficult to confer or replicate so i think these interpretations might be a bit controversial but he argues that in this tribe the pudaha that they're very present oriented that they don't think that much about the long-term future and the implication perhaps being that in that tribe maybe they didn't need to because the circumstances of that local environment for survival didn't require much um the long-term planning a long-term thinking so it is interesting if under those circumstances you know are they more satisfied or happier living in the present um i think that that's a reasonable debate but as we were just discussing yeah for most of us long-term thinking isn't necessarily prerequisite for long-term survival it is something that humans have to engage in for our long-term well-being um but something probably that we don't do enough so then i want to ask about our relationship with the future because we we know something about how we can change the way we mentally recollect the past we know some things and have some practices about how to be more in the present and people chase flow and meditation and so on you had touched on the way we have trouble treating even our own future as real as we would tell you we believe it is right trouble saving trouble exercising trouble preventing things we know we don't want to happen from happening or making things we do want to happen happen is there anything in our evolving understanding of the way the brain anticipates or thinks about the future that can help give us a healthier relationship to our own individual or collective futures yes so this idea of thinking about the future delaying gratification long-term planning is something that is as we've said unique to humans but we're not very good at it and that's not very surprising right because think about human evolution a hundred thousand years ago when the average lifespan was maybe 30 years the concept of saving for retirement was nonsensical because the idea of saving or planning for the future if the future was so unpredictable that you might either die of disease or of hunger or of predation or of tribal warfare in the next six months it really didn't make much sense to think long-term this is why we have a present bias so the present bias is this notion that if i'm offered a hundred dollars today or hundred twenty dollars tomorrow we have this bias to accept the present the short thing that's immediate even though it's a lower value so it's not surprising at all that we have this implicit bias for the present and for short-term decisions and it's hard to delay gratification if you will now what we can do about that of course is like many cognitive skills this comes with practice and part of growing up and part of educational system is helping people learn to delay gratification and think long-term even studying for tests is something that engages long-term thinking because you're studying today for something that will happen tomorrow and the earlier you study for the test in a way you're thinking in a longer temple scale and this goes back to the famous marshmallow tests with children and their ability to delay gratification in terms of waiting 15 minutes to eat their marshmallow and then get two as opposed to eating just one immediately and the ability of children to delay that gratification correlated weekly sometimes i think a bit too much is made of those those data with future academic success for example so practice is key and people have shown that exercises in terms of when you're faced with the decision well should i spend this money now or should i put in a savings account for retirement few studies have suggested that sort of visualizing the future just engaging in exercises of you know being old what he will be able to do with that funds if he'll be healthy and so forth help people engage more future oriented behavior or future oriented actions in the present but again he on the longer timescale of generations and centuries evolutionarily there you can see it's even a bit harder but again i think it's a question of practice and discipline much like learning math is or learning programming is but these are difficult questions and i don't think we fully know the answers to them Ezra i want to talk about what all this knowledge about living in time might say about how one should live in time so to go back to something i was touching on earlier if you wanted life to feel longer how should you live so going back to this idea of retrospective timing being related to memory and the amount of information we have stored in memory the standard sort of view there is that the more novel experiences the more this goes to sort of the self-help genre of novel experiences new learning experiences help us have a life filled with memories and certainly give us the impression that it may have been a period well lived or that we have taken advantage of or put into good use so this is intuitive i think that we want to use our time for productive ventures whatever each of us finds or defines the productive venture which is clearly variable and a highly personal choice so i think these are just consequences of the fact that time passes inexorably and we are flowing through it depending on your perspective and these are just life choices like all choices we make in our life how we want to do what we want to do with our time who we are as individuals in many ways is defined by what we do with our time and the common piece of advice there is yes if you want to have the subjective experience of having a long period of accomplishments or of in your memories that the more diverse those experiences are the more likely you are to store those events in memory and retrospectively feel that that was a long temporal period that has elapsed but about our relationship with the present i mean there are deeper logistics and spiritual traditions that take our constant intensity to mentally time travel that's quite a profound problem many kinds of mystical and chemical and meditative experiences are about creating a deep relationship to this moment what does in your view what does it mean to be more present focused i mean what are we actually saying is happening in a human mind when we're saying somebody is is more in the present and is that something to strive for what is the relationship we should have with the present yeah i mean these are profound questions that i wouldn't pretend to know the answer to but in terms of what it means to be in the present strangely enough in many ways that often means to be very unaware of the passage of time so even in sort of these theories or hypotheses or models of how the brain tells time that one of the ideas is that the more we're using our cognitive apparatus our cognitive circuits to engage in a specific activity that's independent of passage of time the more you're involved in reading a book or playing chess or trying to figure out the rest move or developing a novel idea the less you are aware of the passage of time so in many ways living the present or being focused in the present means being unaware of the passage of time and the more aware of the passage of time you become a bit more cognizant of whether time's going by quickly or slowly now what that means for our day-to-day goals as we've touched upon i think it is important to and it's an important goal to be involved in whatever tasks we're involved in at the time even if that task is thinking about the nature of time or thinking about the future or preparing for the future i think that is a good spot of ambiguity to end on so always a final question what if we book to recommend to the audience the first is called noise a flaw in human judgment it's by canaman symbonian suntine canaman is of course famous for studies on irrational and biased decision-making in the context of framing for example that humans might be more apt or likely to choose a surgery that's framed as having an 80 survival rate as opposed to one that has a 20 more tally rate those of course being the same thing in this book he's focusing more on noise and variability of human decisions so for example given identical cases a judge might make different rulings perhaps influenced by whether is or her local sports team won or lost that we can the second book is a bit hard to describe it's sort of a fictionalized biography of real scientists it's when we cease to understand the world by benjamin la batout it's independent short stories and some are fairly dark so it might not be for everyone but the main story of the title is a dialogue between the founders of quantum mechanics nieus boar and verner heisenberg and they're coming to realization and grappling with the idea that at the quantum level the universe is stochastic and unpredictable and highly counterintuitive and beyond a really ability to understand what's happening and that's when we cease to understand the world this offers an important lesson in quantum mechanics is a good reminder of the limitations of the human brain and that it didn't evolve to understand or to grasp many of the things we're asking of it today and this may be the case in neuroscience it remains to be seen if the human brain can understand the human brain the third is the age of ai and our human future it's written by a sort of surprising trio of authors henry kissinger erksch mitbak co of google and an academic unlocker it's not technical but i think it's a good review and does a good job at conveying the promise the societal promise and dangers of ai personally one of the things i find interesting going forward in the context of ai is what our reaction to ai will tell us about ourselves. Dean Buonamano thank you very much thank you as well it was a pleasure. Buonamano is produced by mthaagawa and gavin jeff gell berschik karmat and kristen linn back checking by Michelle Harris and kitsen claire original music by isek jones mixing by jeff gell and isek jones and audine strategy by shannon buster.