TOO COOL TO COMPETE: Are the 2025 A’s The Softest Team in MLB History?

This episode is a raw, unfiltered gut-punch — a 3AM, two-game, eight-loss reality check for the A’s. After watching every pitch of the latest back-to-back collapses, I dive into the mounting frustration and the deeper problem festering beneath the surface: this team is lifeless. I break down the defining moment of Tuesday night — a routine fly ball that fell between JJ Bleday and Lawrence Butler like a metaphor for this roster: no communication, no urgency, no trust. I talk about how that one play symbolizes a team that doesn’t sell out for each other, that plays like individuals trying to look cool instead of a unit fighting to win. Then comes the real heat — Kotsay’s postgame pressers and Forst’s interview before the game that lit the match. Their soft tones and excuse-laden comments were the final straw.From Kotsay’s Sunday stroll demeanor after a seventh straight loss to David Forst’s calm acceptance of failure as a “rough patch,” this episode calls out the lack of fire from leadership and demands better. I rip into the idea of “saving Mason Miller’s bullets” while games are being flushed down the drain and warn against the organizational obsession with talking up prospects like Luis Morales while the current major league team is sinking. It’s not a hit piece — it’s a passionate call for this franchise to rediscover its identity. This isn’t a rebuild problem. It’s a heart problem. And if this team wants to turn it around, they don’t need more time — they need to start caring like it actually matters. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.