I Stayed Because I Thought It Was “Right”: How My Faith Kept Me in an Abusive Marriage
from The Prodigal Journey
Sensitive Content Disclaimer: On this episode we will be talking about sensitive topics related to abuse that may not be suitable for all audiences. We hope and pray that the open conversation on this episode brings education and hope. However, if you are likely to be adversely impacted by these topics, please refrain from listening. —————————— SUMMARY/INTRO: We dig into why people stay in abusive relationships — Dawn shares her story of being married to Sean, the years of coercive control, shame, and the church pressure that told her to “do the right thing” even when it cost her health and identity. I (Dawn) talk about how a fast courtship, an unexpected pregnancy, isolation, and messages about submission made me doubt myself, stay in survival mode, and even feel “so incredibly faithless” at times. We unpack how well-meaning pastors focused on behavior modification instead of root issues, how a friend and counselor (shout out to Brandy and Andrea) finally helped give permission, and how worship and reclaiming the gospel became the lifeline that led me to leave. Ben and I also wrestle with how churches can enable abuse by telling victims to go back, why one person believing a victim matters, and how marked repentance — not platitudes — is the line between restoration and danger. I share the painful aftermath — Sean’s suicide, my journey to forgiveness, and the hard, hopeful truth that there is hope for victims and for abusers who turn to Christ. If you want candid, sometimes raw talk about faith, safety, and how the church should actually protect the vulnerable, we walk through it here. —————————— SHOW NOTES: Why do people stay in abusive relationships? From the outside, it can seem simple: if someone is being mistreated, why don’t they just leave? But the reality of an abusive relationship is much more complicated. In this episode of The Prodigal Journey, Ben and Dawn have an honest conversation about Dawn’s experience in an abusive marriage and the many factors that made leaving so difficult. Rather than telling her entire story, they focus specifically on the question people often ask: Why did you stay? Dawn shares how the relationship began in a church community and how she initially believed she knew her husband well because they had been friends for years. Looking back, she can identify red flags that she dismissed, including jealousy, accusations, boundary violations, and controlling behavior. The short dating and engagement period also meant that important conversations never happened before marriage. After they married, Dawn found herself isolated, depressed, ashamed, and increasingly focused on simply surviving. She describes losing her joy, stepping away from church and music, and struggling to understand what was happening to her. Meanwhile, her husband viewed his role primarily through the lens of providing financially, while the emotional and relational needs of the family went largely unrecognized. The conversation explores why abusive relationships can be so difficult to leave. Dawn talks about the cycle of extreme highs and deep lows, the good moments that made it possible to keep hoping for another good moment, and the way shame can cause someone to hide what is happening rather than ask for help. The episode also takes a hard look at the role of the church. Dawn describes seeking help and receiving advice that focused on changing behavior rather than addressing deeper patterns of manipulation, control, and abuse. Ben and Dawn discuss the difference between dealing with the visible “fruit” of a problem and addressing its root. They also examine how teachings about submission, marriage, and religious responsibility can become harmful when they are applied without recognizing abuse and coercive control. One of the most difficult parts of Dawn’s story is what happened after she first left. She describes feeling religiously pressured to return and believing that doing the “right thing” meant staying, even when she knew she did not love her husband. She believed she needed to pray more, read her Bible more, and become a better Christian. Eventually, trusted friends helped Dawn recognize what was actually happening. They encouraged her not to return without a marked pattern of repentance and meaningful change. That support became part of what helped her understand that leaving did not necessarily mean abandoning God or failing in her faith. Dawn ultimately shares the moment when she finally stood her ground, recognized that the situation had become dangerous, and left. Even afterward, threats and controlling behavior continued, reinforcing how complicated and frightening leaving an abusive relationship can be. The episode closes with hope for people on both sides of abuse: those who are trapped in abusive relationships and those who may recognize abusive patterns in themselves. Dawn shares how worship, Scripture, community, and trusted relationships helped her rediscover her identity and continue trusting God through the process. This is a conversation for victims, survivors, friends and family members, pastors, church leaders, and anyone trying to understand why leaving an abusive relationship is rarely as simple as saying, “Just leave.” LINKS TO DAWN’S FULL STORY: Miracle Hill Podcast (More full story): YouTube Spotify Reconcile Stories Podcast (Episode on mental health and the local church): Youtube Spotify TAKEAWAYS: Leaving an abusive relationship is often much more complicated than simply deciding to leave. People may dismiss red flags because of infatuation, hope, shame, or the belief that they know their partner well. Abuse can involve patterns of jealousy, control, manipulation, accusations, verbal abuse, and coercive behavior. Good moments in an abusive relationship can make it difficult to recognize or act on the seriousness of the bad moments. Shame can cause victims to hide what is happening and become isolated from people who could help. Religious beliefs can sometimes become entangled with an abusive relationship, making it harder for someone to recognize that leaving may be necessary. Faith does not make someone immune to abuse or automatically give them clarity about what to do. Focusing only on the “fruit” of abusive behavior can miss the root issues of manipulation, control, and sin. Churches have a responsibility to care for people experiencing abuse rather than simply prioritizing keeping marriages together. A victim may not initially have the words or understanding necessary to explain what is happening. Marriage counseling or behavior modification alone may not address the deeper patterns behind abuse and coercive control. Trusted friends can play a critical role in helping someone recognize abuse and find safety. A genuine pattern of repentance and meaningful change matters when evaluating whether an abusive relationship can be restored. Separation does not automatically mean divorce, and leaving an unsafe environment can create space for clarity and safety. Someone experiencing abuse may need another person to tell them that it is okay to leave. Christians should be careful not to use biblical language about marriage and submission to enable abuse. God cares about people made in His image, not merely preserving an institution. There is hope for people who are experiencing abuse—and also for people who recognize abusive patterns in themselves. Healing can involve rediscovering truth, identity, community, and trust in God. —————————— CHAPTERS: 00:00 — Why Do People Stay in Abusive Relationships? 05:24 — Falling in Love & Missing the Red Flags 21:52 — Shame, Pregnancy & Pressure to Get Married 24:51 — Depression, Isolation & Surviving the Marriage 36:39 — The Moment Dawn Realized She Had to Leave 41:37 — Leaving, Returning & Religious Pressure 51:26 — When Faith Becomes a Reason to Stay 01:09:33 — Finding Support, Protection & Real Repentance 01:13:00 — The Final Straw & Leaving for Good 01:18:08 — What Should the Church Do About Abuse? 01:25:20 — When a Church Enables Abuse 01:28:17 — Hope for Those Still Trapped —————————— Thank you for supporting conversations about Faith. Struggle. Becoming. If this conversation encouraged you, you can support the podcast here: theprodigaljourney.com/donate —————————— Affiliate Links: I host my podcast with Captivate, the world's only growth-oriented podcast host™ - you can too, and get your first 7-days on me! Use my affiliate link below to get your free trial and it helps the podcast. <a href="https://www.captivate.fm/signup?ref=nte5ndk" rel="noopener noreferrer"...
Embed this episode
What this episode covers
Sensitive Content Disclaimer: On this episode we will be talking about sensitive topics related to abuse that may not be suitable for all audiences. We hope and pray that the open conversation on this episode brings education and hope. However, if you are likely to be adversely impacted by these topics, please refrain from listening. -------------------- Welcome to The Prodigal Journey where we celebrate Christ's power through our weakness! On this episode I talk to my wife Dawn and we explore the different complexities that abuse victims experience when they are trying to leave an abusive relationship. It is not always easy or simple. There is trauma and so many other things that have an affect on a victim's ability to leave. If you want to hear a different part of her story where she talks about "Suicide Loss, Grief, and Mental Illness", you can find that episode on these links below:https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/suicide-loss-grief-and-mental-illness-with-dawn-and-ryan/id1631027030?i=1000590822620 (https://podcasts.apple.com/us/...) | https://open.spotify.com/episode/2dTNeRgcRKhCclGd1wvoZk?si=5J5qZ1D8RgWDbl6GsYYwTw (https://open.spotify.com/episo...) | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8HUhYvIrm7Qandamp;amp;list=PLOsdNX-BpW0JvAcILB4ymPNF5tQNx2IBrandamp;amp;index=14 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?...) -------------------- If you are experiecing domestic abuse and need a safe place to go, The Hiding Place is a non profit ministry that can provide transitional safe housing for you. Please reach out to their 24/7 hotline at (888) 341-9568 if you need help. They are located on a 40 acre safe property at an undisclosed location in Pickens County, SC. Not only do they provide safe housing but they are partnered with other oganizations within the community so they can provide you with trauma counseling, group counseling, community support groups, job training, case management, financial literacy classes, transportation, job placement, etc. For more details or if you want to help in any way you can call their office at (864) 424-7865. The Hiding Place is a non profit ministry of Channel Missions. You can find more info on their website https://channelmissions.org/the-hiding-place (https://channelmissions.org/th...). I personally know the 2 women who run The Hiding Place and they are women who are committed to helping people recover from domestic abuse, but more than that they love Jesus and want others to experience that love through their healing. -------------------- Affiliate Partner - Covenant Eyes: Covenant Eyes is the pioneer of Internet and screen accountability. In a culture that continues to grow in its stance against the family, and so much of our culture being fueled by harmful imagery, we need a company like Covenant Eyes to help us in the fight to keep our families safe! Affiliate Partner - Upside: Why not make cash back for something you already buy? Upside provides cash back to users at many major gas stations. You can get up to 25 cents back per gallon of gas, up to 30% cash back on groceries, and up to 45% cash back at restaurants, depending on deals available in your area. Help out our podcast by clicking the link below and signing up today!
Chapters
- 0:00 Why Do People Stay in Abusive Relationships?
- 5:24 Falling in Love & Missing the Red Flags
- 21:52 Shame, Pregnancy & Pressure to Get Married
- 24:51 Depression, Isolation & Surviving the Marriage
- 36:39 The Moment Dawn Realized She Had to Leave
- 41:37 Leaving, Returning & Religious Pressure
- 51:26 When Faith Becomes a Reason to Stay
- 1:09:33 Finding Support, Protection & Real Repentance
- 1:13:00 The Final Straw & Leaving for Good
- 1:18:08 What Should the Church Do About Abuse?
- 1:25:20 When a Church Enables Abuse
- 1:28:17 Hope for Those Still Trapped
No transcript yet.