Welcome to Pod Save America. I'm Jon Favreau. I'm Jon Lovett. I'm Dan Pfeiffer. We just watched the second Republican debate at the Ronald Reagan Library in California, right here in the state of California. That was quite a debate. Quite a debate, guys. If you missed the debate, which I hope you did, here's just a flavor.
of of what it was like and i will say something you have more than time to explain your well if i was interrupted by a lot of people here and i want to be respectful because i believe these are respectful last but i do not believe in these we're sitting here in the reagan library yes i wish in honor of ronald reagan's library if i may from one admirer of ronald reagan to another from one admirer of reagan to another let's have a policy Worse than I remember. None of you would suck Reagan's cock the way I would. I'd get the job done. I'd get it done. We should point out that that was one of the more exciting parts of the debate. Yeah, it was real slog. General impressions. Dan? I like him. We're a little punchy here. It's late at night. We're tired. We're bored. We're drinking. I don't know what anyone was doing. The moderators, the candidates. It was a giant waste of time. And I was offended as a television viewer and a political professional because I don't know what any of them were doing.
I want to read you a statement about the debate. Okay. Tonight's GOP debate was as boring and inconsequential as the first debate, and nothing that was said will change the dynamics of the primary contest being dominated by President Trump. The RNC should immediately put an end to any further primary debates. Agree with the Trump campaign senior advisor, Chris Lesavita. This is like when somebody reads something from the Unabomber manifesto, and it's like, it was the Unabomber. Now how do you feel? I mean, I haven't agreed with any statement tonight more than that.
Yeah, what a waste of fucking time. I mean, we'll get to Nikki Haley. Nikki Haley seemed to have a plan and actually do something while she was standing there for two hours. Again, on Earth 2, yeah. When there's like another Republican primary with the people that were on the stage. Sure, no, I'm not defending it. Robert Costa, a reporter at CBS, tweeted, Lots of angst tonight among my top GOP sources about this debate. Donors concerned. Flurry of texts. Questions about where this race goes from here. They wonder, can anybody have a breakout moment? No. Do you want to go from here? Here. Here we are. Where we have been for months with Donald Trump winning easily and no one trying to beat him.
It was wild. Like there was a little more, they leaned in a little harder on the Trump attacks tonight. On one thing, him not being at the debate, the absolute stupidest thing in the world. Donald Trump was found guilty of fraud yesterday. No one mentioned it. He threatened to kill the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff this weekend. Didn't come up, didn't come up. Moderator didn't bring it out. Several of them know personally. It's not a human level.
It's really unbelievable. DeSantis went after Trump a little on abortion. For a second. He said, I wish he was at the debate to defend his comments. And their favorite thing, they all go after him on adding to the debt. So the Republicans on that stage, the worst sin that Donald Trump committed in four years as president is that he was a little profligate. Is that why those people were trying to rip the cops' limb from limb? Was it the deficit of the outliers? Is that what it was? I didn't know what it was.
So let's go through candidate by candidate. It was a terrible debate. There was nothing really interesting about it. But keep listening. But keep listening. We'll get into it. Ron DeSantis, first of all...
It took, I counted, 16 minutes into the debate for Ron DeSantis to even speak. It didn't even seem like he was there. And then... Best 16 minutes he's had in months. And then finally, finally he spoke. And this is what he said. Where's Joe Biden? He's completely missing in action from leadership. And you know who else is missing in action? Donald Trump is missing in action. He should be on this stage tonight. He owes it to you to defend his record where they added $7.8 trillion to the debt. So that was Ron's big moment. What did you guys think about Ron DeSantis tonight, huh? It's just... It's nothing. It's just nothing. This guy...
No one has told him in debate prep to fix the face stuff? I don't think it's fixable. Or the voice? Can't fix the face? Can't fix the voice? Well, none of those. Thank you. First of all, it's a hard thing. These people in the debate prep with Ron DeSantis, he may not be a person, but maybe they are. And it's a tough thing to bring up. Hey, we think one of our problems is your face and the noises that it makes when it communicates. That's a tough thing to fix. Every single answer he finishes, he just sits there and he gives this weird, weird half grin, half smirking for the camera. It's very uncomfortable. Well, they're all very rehearsed. His cadence is very rehearsed. Even that Joe Biden line was all very rehearsed. And all of them have this...
way of speaking these debates. Tim Scott does it. Vivek does it. Ron DeSantis does it. Nikki Haley does it. They all do it, which is this kind of like 90s style sentences like we're going to take them down and go up to the top and they want us to they want us to give up. Well, we're not going to give in and you can't surrender because of my strength and we're going to have victory, not victimhood. And it just doesn't work. We're going to turn up the heat and turn America around.
And see, that was one that worked. I'm really glad you brought it up. That's a good example of how it can work. Famously, in Iowa in 2007, 16 years ago, before the iPhone, it was a really good moment. I think you are correct that a lot of them do that, but DeSantis is the worst. There's, like, way too much alliteration. All of it sound canned. Like, Trump's attack on DeSantis is that he is a, like, of Washington. He's part of the swamp. And everyone's like, well, that's weird because he's, like, governor of Florida. But he sounds like a Washington... No one on that stage sounds like a Washington... Except maybe Mike Pence. Sounds like a Washington politician more than Ron DeSantis. Yeah, and it is really effective, too, because...
All Ron DeSantis wants to do is sit in a room and work really hard on the sentence he's going to reuse to rebut the argument that he pre-plans everything he says and sounds like an automaton. And he can't get out of it. And his strategy tonight was he kept going after the D.C. elites. Like someone must have told him, you've got to get your outsider status back. So every single answer, he hit the D.C. elites. What was that? You know who people don't think is a D.C. elite? Donald Trump. Right. That's why it's just a weird... This is true of every single person. Donald Trump is up by 30 points in Iowa and 30 points in New Hampshire. But in the CBS poll that came out yesterday, 80% of the voters in both of those states are open to someone other than Trump.
And no one tried to do anything about that dynamic. I think they don't know why people, why that many people are open to someone besides Trump. Like they haven't figured out. They haven't tried. They haven't tried a single argument. Yeah, they haven't. You spend too much money. It's insane. I don't think any of them want to win. But they think they've decided they can't win and they're trying to just navigate the, lay on the plane of their failing campaign in a way that maximizes their position in a Trump Republican Party. Or they believe that nothing they can do can change the fundamentals of this race. So they want to be there as the first among fucking duds in case something changes in the criminal process, in the race that's outside of their control. Unless he dies. That's it.
They're just waiting in case he dies. They want to be there. I think that there's like nothing. There's no other reason. I mean, the trial is not starting until after all the delegates are allocated. Right. At the most optimistic case. I mean, do we think a conviction at this point would sway the Republican electorate?
Also, by the way, as they're all doing this, Donald Trump earlier, we're going to play this clip of his speech in a bit, but a part of his speech in Detroit, he said that none of the people running he would pick as vice president. It's just incredible. These people are picking these little fights with each other. Tim Scott's going after Nikki Haley. Nikki Haley's going after Vivek. Vivek is going after Chris Christie. Meanwhile, Trump's in South Carolina. You hear about this? These whales are dying up by 40 fucking points. Unstoppable. Unstoppable. A Republican consultant who is supporting.
Ron DeSantis said to Semaphore before the debate, if he doesn't do well here, in my opinion, he's got to drop out if he doesn't want to be embarrassed. Do you think he did well enough not to drop out? I think that's a time machine question. Yeah, he was, he was, I will say this about Ron DeSantis. He was better than last debate, but he still sucked. He still was not like the best at this debate. As long as he's Ron DeSantis, he's going to suck. He doesn't, it's not there. He does not. And I think part of his problem was he, and we'll talk about Nikki Haley next, but she's sort of stealing the mantle of the non-Trump alternative from him, or at least that field has become too crowded now. And Ron DeSantis does not look like he is.
in second, like, look, according to polls, he's still second place nationally. And depending on which early state poll you look at in early states, but he certainly didn't act like that or seem like that on the stage tonight. Yeah, that's sort of what I mean when I say that I feel like, you know, it's not going to do anything, but at least it's, it seems like she had some sort of goal for what she was going to do in the debate. You know, I do think she's taken that mantle. I think she was feisty in a way that Chris Christie wasn't, right? Like, I think she actually was the only one to do something with that time. Let's hear some of Nikki Haley's feistiness from tonight.
Did you get a gift receipt for those fucking curtains are not, Nikki? They'll take the credit. They'll take the credit. The curtains exchange was one of the... dumbest exchanges of an otherwise very dumb debate. Yeah, two people in single digits in the polls arguing each other over a curtain purchase from the State Department in 2017. Literally, that's what that was about. The beginning of that clip, when she said, I'm dumber every time I hear you speak, was about Viveka Ramaswamy, which was, I wanted to cheer when she said that, I think, because he is extremely annoying. But I think, like, so she was feisty, sort of went after a bunch of other candidates, but I also think that her answers were, there's, like, solid answers. She seemed like she commanded the stage more than almost anyone else. Again, I don't, she's not in danger of becoming a Republican at all. Tell us what you like about Nikki Haley.
Yes, she commanded the stage more than Doug Burgum. You are correct. To the extent that she has a plan, and I agree she has a plan. It's not a plan to win, but she... Then what is it? What is it a plan? Well, it is a plan. I'm curious. What she is doing, Nate Cohn, I thought, wrote about this very smartly in the New York Times this morning, is she's appealing to a faction of Republicans. She is appealing specifically to the non-Trump vote. She's not doing it by attacking Trump, but she's trying to be the normal Bush-like Republican, traditional Republican. DeSantis' problem is he has no constituency because he's trying to just be a worse version of Trump, and the Trump voters are very happy with Trump, so why would they do that? Nikki Haley is... And that may be...
why she goes after Tim Scott because Tim Scott is her competition for that lane. Yeah. Yeah, that's right. And I think she genuinely hates Vivek. That was sincere. That's the only moment of sincerity on that. And I think that's one thing that brought them all together. And maybe America. Yeah, because there was a moment when she... They've all got sort of like oppo research on Vivek. They've got these oppo files that they've just been waiting to use. There was like, you know, reports that some of them were going to use them in the last debate, specifically around DeSantis because of Super PAC. Like they're flooding their torpedo tubes. Right, yeah. And some of it has to do with business in China. I don't know. They all hate China. That's all they talked about all night. When one of them attacks him on China, suddenly like four different candidates on stage were just like...
China this, China that, China. Like they all jumped on. I also dislike China. Yes, that was also something I was going to do. He likes China. I don't. He likes China. He has a history with China. I don't. I like to interrupt to say that was something that I was going to also say that was something I plan to do about now. And I'm going to do it now. Am I doing it? I'm not doing it now. Got it. Vivek Ramaswamy, who I think in the first debate, I was like, he's extremely annoying, but maybe there's the part of the Republican base that likes Donald Trump would like what Vivek Ramaswamy is selling. Tonight, I cannot imagine why any human being of any political persuasion would enjoy spending any time with Vivek Ramaswamy. He's the most annoying. Yeah, here's my takeaway. I missed the first debate because I was on vacation and that was my time.
And you couldn't have it. But so this was my first time seeing him in this kind of a forum. And it is a testament to the fucking charisma vacuum. Don't have it. Tomaton losers that are on that stage that anyone thinks this guy has any charisma. He is. He and Ron DeSantis are from the same mold. They have the same style. They have the same appealing way of explaining things to you. And I just I don't get it. Yeah, he's he's less robotic than DeSantis, but just as annoying. Maybe more. He's annoying in a different way. Different way. Like just like smarmy know-it-all kind of way. I don't know if we're gonna play the clip, but there was this the moment where he was talking about how I'm here to listen.
I came to listen and learn. Right before Nikki Haley fucking destroyed him. And it does seem like there must be some feedback they're getting about how unappealing and kind of mansplaining these guys. I think there was a thought because he really did dominate the stage. The last time he was the only person who drove a narrative, who he had most of the speaking time. People were responding to him, which felt completely out of nowhere given the fact that most of the Americans had never seen him before that moment. And I think there was a sense that, oh, is he going to be the breakout candidate from this debate? And he did not. He's actually, I think, lost a little bit of ground since the debate in the national polling average.
And I am positive from having watched this that their focus groups say that people found him annoying and pretentious. And he went into this debate. People, I guess those voters were correct. And he went in this debate where they plan to try to sand down the edges of that annoyingness, which is why he did not, when people came after him, that's why instead of fighting back as he did last time, he was just like, Ronald Reagan, 11th commandment, policy debate. And then he did that completely rehearsed routine about saying that he would listen to people and get advice from older people and all of this. Do you think that his polls might be affected by the fact that he has the hairstyle of your third pick for a DJ for a bar mitzvah?
His hair gets bigger with every debate. What the fuck is that? I didn't really like that joke. I kind of got stuck in the middle. Leave it at. I don't care. This is free. He talked a lot about kids in social media. It was a big problem of his. I'm going to book him on offline. That's his response to being on TikTok. He's the only Republican kid on TikTok. Oh, yeah. And so he's got a lot of crap for that. He also talked about getting drugs on Snapchat. Yeah. One just small.
somewhat serious point, which is it is really despicable that Dana Perino decided that one thing she wanted to get out of this debate was some kind of pledge from each of the candidates to pass a federal law to require, I guess, teachers and school nurses to out kids to parents if those kids come to those teachers and tell them that they're gay or trans or non-binary, what have you, that that's what she viewed as a really interesting and exciting way to make the most of this debate, to get some kind of yes or no answer on this question. She pegged the question off an answer that Christy gave to Stuart Varney, one of the co-moderators, like just last week, which is wild. And it's the only question that she followed up on like 12 times. Like she tried to pin Doug Burgum down repeatedly on it. Like that's what she thinks is the most important thing she can do on this forum is try to shift the Republican Party to the right on the issue of trans and gay kids. That's giving her, I think, more credit than she deserves on having any kind of strategy because all three moderators just were like bowled over by the candidates. They were like interrupted all the time. They couldn't get a word. It was wild. It was wild.
more at the University of New Brunswick. UNB is a world-class university offering a world-class education. Get personalized support to explore career opportunities, build the skills and confidence employers value, and connect with mentors and future employers. From class registration to career preparation, UNB is where you'll do more. Visit domore.umb.ca to learn how.
Longplay, our docu-series exploring the people and forces shaping the South, is back. Newsflash, the South is the new political epicenter of the country. Democrats are way on their heels in this region, but Republicans are going through their own reckoning in the South, too. We're in the final stretch of the midterms, and the political map has only gotten more competitive, with new states and districts emerging as potential flips. So we thought it was time to get back out on the road and take a closer look at what's actually happening on the ground. I'm Erin Haines, journalist and expert on all things Southern politics. And I'm Jennifer Palmieri, former White House Communications Director. Tune in on Mondays to Longplay Series on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.
Let's talk about Chris Christie. Love its pal. You know, I think we said in the first debate, he didn't sort of take all the opportunities he had to really go after Donald Trump. His first question to him, here's what he said in this debate. And you're not here tonight, not because of polls and not because of your indictments. You're not here tonight because you're afraid of being on the stage and defending your record. You're ducking these things. And let me tell you what's going to happen. You keep doing that. No one up here is going to call you Donald Trump anymore. We're going to call you Donald Duck.
Love it. I think that was a great line that you gave him. I don't know if everyone's talking about it. Yeah, I mean, look, we did it. It was sort of like how the car sponsor, you know, we kind of worked on it together. Some of it was his. I don't remember if it was mine or it was his. It kind of went back and forth. That's our partnership. It's sort of like a gestalt.
Man, no one has ever been so close to landing a plane on a beautiful and clear day. Exploded right on the runway. It was a great moment. And then it lands on Donald fucking Duck. What's going on? Who are in these debate prep sessions with Ron DeSantis, Chris Christie, all of them. Donald Duck? And he has, oh, the Donald Duck line. They're all like, yeah, yeah, sir. That's great. Do the Donald Duck line. That's what?
It was wild. I mean, before we came in here, I decided to do a little prep, so I clicked on a news article from NBC News that was six takeaways from the debate. Number three was Chris Christie got Donald Duck trending on Twitter. It was a good moment for him, too. We were all like, oh, this is a good moment. This was a good hit. And we're like, here we go. How does it end? He's looking at the camera. It was like, all right. Now that's the Chris Christie that I fell in love with. That's the Chris Christie from my younger days.
It was just... He hit Trump for not building the wall. Trump said he was going to build the wall and have Mexico pay for it, but he only built 52 miles, and if Mexico knew it had only been 52 miles, maybe they would have paid for it, which is like... It's on its way to something. Is it 2017? What is happening? Again, just cut to an insurrectionist being like, only 52 miles. Tim Scott? Tim Scott got his note from the last debate was, you didn't say anything.
You were too quiet. So you got to make your case. Sir, we looked at some of the crosstabs after your performance in the first debate. Our view is strategically, we think you should speak. And obviously that may not help. We're probably not confident that speaking will have as much of an effect as we'd like. But it's the only thing we can do on a debate station. He did speak. He did speak a lot more of this debate. But Tim Scott kind of did a, I'm going to give different parts of my stump speech. And someone obviously told him, lean on your personal story. That's where you're inspiring your hope message, all that kind of stuff. So he sort of did a lot of rhetoric around there.
often it didn't make sense with the question that was asked to him. And I don't know. To no one. Why are you running president? I still don't know. Well, he got the first question, which was about the economy. And I literally looked at my computer and looked up and he was talking about fentanyl on the border. Yeah, he did that a lot. A lot of them just sort of pivoted to another question or topic that they wanted to talk about. And not the topics that might be easier, more conducive to a good moment for them. There was one moment where Dana Perino's best moment was, I think it was Pence who went on some tangent and she's like, I believe the question was about healthcare. Yeah, it was about healthcare. And his answer was...
I would pursue the federal death penalty for anyone involved in a mass shooting. Expedited death penalty for a mass shooting. Yeah, that'll do it. That's healthcare. That's his healthcare plan. Hey, why didn't we think of that? So Mike Pence was at the debate. He passed out some jokes again. He had one terribly lame line about, you know, Joe Biden shouldn't be on the picket line. He should be on the unemployment line. Pause for laughter. Mike Pence's problem is like no one in the audience, not a lot of Mike Pence fans out there. A lot of Mike Pence, we should hang him people, but not a lot of Mike Pence fans. A lot of people want to hang, but not whiff. He's struggling with the whiff. So at one point, Chris Christie's talking about teachers unions and he's rambling against teachers unions. Speaking of railing.
Yeah, go on. And then a really sort of gross attack on Joe Biden. He says, oh, well, Joe Biden's sleeping with a member of the teachers union because Dr. Joe Biden, the first lady of the United States, is a teacher and a member of a teacher union. I don't think it's that gross. That man fucks his wife. What's the problem? Well, it's just like, it's the first lady and you're just like, he's sleeping with a member of the teachers union. I know you're a Christie fan. What? Listen.
Listen, whatever comes next is going to be edited out. I think if more people thought Joe Biden was fucking Jill Biden, maybe these age problems wouldn't be as big of a deal in the polls. How about that? Okay, that's a fair point. Thank you. Anyway, well, Mike Pence heard that and said, I got to get on in this. I mean, in the debate. Jesus, what are you talking about? You sound crazy. Well, listen to what he said. First, you mentioned the president's situation.
My wife isn't a member of the teachers union, but I've got to admit I've been sleeping with a teacher for 38 years. Mike, you know what? Great. This is great. Look at these people. They're being sex positive on a debate stage. That's unprecedented. Unbelievable. And then we finally come to Doug Bergen.
My guy, Doug, he was wild. I don't know what else to say about him. He like interrupted a lot. Again, someone must have told him, sir, you didn't speak much last debate. So he just like interrupted on every single question, but he didn't answer the question. He just like said something else. One point he like interrupted to say the strike is happening because Joe Biden's interference in capital markets. And it was like he kept doing this thing of like, I'm sorry, but I just have to interrupt to say what nobody's willing to say. A different version of what you've all been saying. I'm Doug Burgum.
You got Bergen. So just to wrap this up, one of Dana Preeno's last question, I think it was her last question, was a little wild. Here's what she asked to wrap up the debate. If you all stay in the race, former President Donald Trump wins the nomination. None of you have indicated that you're dropping out. So which one of you on stage tonight should be voted off the island? I vote Donald Trump off the island right now. That was it. There was a process by which they came up with this idea. They ran it by large groups of people.
And it made it to the debate stage. And you know what? Like Chris Christie, he gave it a, he gave it the old college drive. He had to be called out because he did not volunteer at Stuart Varney. Had you come back to him later and say, I saw you writing something down. What did you write down? So what happens is Dana Perino starts this question. And as Reid pointed out before he recorded, it's on its way to actually an important point, which is if you all stay in the race, Donald Trump is the nominee. None of you can, if all of you are here, none of you can succeed. What is the process by which any one of you is going to be the one to take on Trump? And you're all down like 40 points. Does anyone have a strategy?
to win. But then she turned it to this, now write someone's name down and gave Ron DeSantis his best and most human moment of the night, which was like, I'm not going to do that. That's not fair. Everybody put on suits. When I would have simply said Doug. But what's funny is as that's happening, Chris Christie's writing down a name and he's like, I agree. We shouldn't be writing down any names. And he's like, you, Governor Christie, you've written something down. Tell us. No, I didn't. No, I didn't. I wrote down terrorism. I wrote down Chinese communists. I wrote down whatever you think I needed to write down. I didn't write down one of these people's names, not Doug Burgum, not this freak. Doug Burgum has no business being here.
Yeah, and then he said, you know, Donald Trump shouldn't be on the island and blah, blah, blah. And then someone interrupted him. Vivek again. Yeah, Vivek came in. He was like, I think Trump was great. I love Donald Trump. And they're like, that's it. That's how we're ending up. Which actually was, yeah. You guys think this debate moves the needle at all for anyone? Maybe Nikki Haley creeps up a little bit. Maybe she captures some of that. She gets to the tweens. Some of that Ron DeSantis, some of the Ron DeSantis voters go to Nikki. Maybe some of the Tim Scott voters. Maybe some of the Mike Pence, the two Mike Pence voters. Let me, hold on. Let me just, let me get myself on a cable news panel for a second. You ready for a second? Yeah, yeah, let's do it. Look, I think, you know who won this debate tonight? Donald Trump.
It's the titles for Dan's message box tomorrow. I gotta rewrite it. Anyway, all right, let's talk about, let's talk about Donald Trump. Sure. Who is, you know, the likely Republican nominee at this point. Fuck, fuck. He was at a, he gave a speech in Detroit. He tried to counter-program the debate. He made a big deal about going to speak to auto workers and workers in Detroit and blah, blah, blah. Turns out he spoke at a non-union shop. He was invited by management. They make car parts. Unclear if there was, it doesn't seem like there was any UAW workers in the crowd. It certainly was unclear if there would be. And...
Basically, he gave the speech, you know, it was his typical bullshit, but he was really, really thirsty for the endorsement of the UAW during the speech. Let's listen. But your leadership should endorse me, and I will not say a bad thing about them again, and they will have done their job. If they endorse me, they will have the easiest labor leadership job anywhere in the country. If you could speak to Sean, he's listening right now, I'm sure. Sean, endorse Trump, and you can take a nice two-month vacation, come back, and you guys are going to be better than you ever were. So here's what Sean Fein, the head of the UAW, had to say. I find a pathetic irony.
that the former president is going to hold a rally for union members at a non-union business. I see no point in meeting with him because I don't think the man has any bit of care about what our workers stand for, what the working class stands for. He serves a billionaire class and that's what's wrong with this country. So there you have it. You're saying there's a chance. Really thirsty. The Detroit News was there and they interviewed some people in the crowd. One person in the crowd had a sign that said union members for Trump. They interviewed her and she said she was not a union member. And then another person had a sign that said auto workers for Trump and they interviewed him and he said he was not an auto worker.
This is encouraging their fellow autoworkers to be for Trump. That's malicious, as you suggest. What do you guys think of the Trump speech? There's plenty to make fun of. I think that, like...
It's interesting watching Trump speak and then go into that debate. He is trying to make this argument to try to peel off some share of Biden voters in these states. And I think we should take it seriously. The argument that basically, you know, EVs are bad for the Midwest, EVs are bad for unions, EVs are bad for American workers, especially when one of the arguments that UAW is making is the fact that a lot of these battery plants aren't union, that this shift to electric vehicles could mean fewer union shops in the United States. It is a real and serious argument that could resonate with people, even if Trump is the worst messenger for it and was an incredibly anti-union, anti-worker, anti-middle class president.
So I think the question is, like, how do Democrats and Biden make sure that he doesn't get away with that? It's a great question. Can we fly another drink in for Dan? I think, Lovett, Lovett's point is you have to wade through. We watched the whole speech, which no one else is going to do. It was on Newsmax only. Yes. So you all know. And by the way, midway through on Newsmax, they did a picture-in-picture of a fucking fundraiser for Rudy Giuliani's legal defense fund. The picture of him up there looked like he was dead. Yeah, when he died, they just crossed it out in a memorial fund. Yeah, they alternated between that picture and then please buy a gold coin. Yeah, just buy gold. And if you buy gold, you'll get, say, take control of your finances was the slogan for the gold company.
But if you watch the whole speech, there's a ton of insanity in there. But buried in there, which is what most people will see, either through clips that are shared or more likely in the billions of dollars of ads that Trump's campaign and Republican Super PACs air, is a very... This potent grievance message targeted at workers who've been left behind in this economy. Now, Trump doesn't mention that he is someone who was the most anti-worker president in American history, who passed a tax cut that most of the defense went to the rich and encouraged and led to the more offshoring of American jobs, who got rid of overtime pay for 8 million Americans, costing them more than a billion dollars in wages. So he has a record there. But what we have to take very seriously is...
He is speaking in a language of populism that works in an environment where people are very unhappy. And all of the polling shows that we are in a very fertile environment for that sort of economic nationalism and populism. It doesn't match up to his record, obviously. But the only people who are going to make sure that that is known is us, right? It's Democrats and people who want to defeat Trump. The press isn't going to do it. It's not going to happen on its own. We're going to have to make that case to fight back against it. And also speak to those concerns ourselves with our rhetoric. We can't just simply be, look at everything we've, not that Joe Biden is doing this, but look at everything we've done.
Let me just read to you some of the subsections of the Inflation Reduction Act. Even though all that stuff is really good, there is a tremendous discontent. I think it says something about sort of the populist moment we're in, is that the Republican candidates were afraid. to criticize striking union members. With the exception of Tim Scott, who was like, yeah, you're asking for too much. That's all. That's what I have to say. But even he walked away from his own. But all of them up there, in Trump in particular, in a different environment, in a different moment, the Republican Party would be attacking union thugs and bosses. And why are they out there? And they'll say the union members are misleading the rest of the workers. But they will all look at that with such trepidation. And that is a moment that Democrats should own. A moment of worker empowerment and fight for higher wages. That is us. And Trump is trying to co-opt. And we're going to have to fight really hard not to let that happen.
I also think, you can just tell, he's just so much more comfortable in the role of challenger than he was as incumbent, right? Because his whole message, you know, people would call him like a feral genius, but it's not, it's pretty easy. Who calls him that? You know, all the annoying people. His message is easy and it always has been. It's like the establishment is awful. Everything's fucked up. I'm the guy who can fix it. I do good deals. And aren't you annoyed with what the elites and everyone in Washington has done to this country? Aren't you pissed? And I'm the vessel for your anger, right? Like that's his whole, that was his shtick in 2016. And it was complicated in 2020 because he was fucking president for four years and people didn't like what they saw generally. But now he can be like, oh, well, I know everyone has, you know, really short memories. So forget about those four years. You're pissed now. And I'm the guy that's going to go after the establishment. That's what he's trying to do. And so I think that you're right, which is you can't fight that by being like, no, no, no, everyone's wrong.
Things are great. What you have to do is just, as we've said a million times, like turn it into a choice. If he becomes president again, this is what he's going to do. And hold him responsible for the problems he is claiming to be the one he can solve. And he will get us right back into that. I mean, we just got to, that's why like every time, and it's also why Donald Trump doesn't ever talk about a second term agenda. All he talks about is like, you're pissed about that? I'm going to fix it when I get in there. It was great when I was president, I'm going to fix it again. But like, he's not laying out any fucking second term agenda because he knows that his policies are unpopular. Right, and where they are signaling anything around his agenda, it is a lower corporate tax rate to just to get that out there and to just sort of shore up those interests and remind everybody that, yeah, yeah, I'm going to talk kooky on that.
on the stump, but you can count on me when the chips are down. Long Play, our docuseries exploring the people and forces shaping the South, is back. Newsflash, the South is the new political epicenter of the country. Democrats are way on their heels in this region, but Republicans are going through their own reckoning in the South, too. We're in the final stretch of the midterms, and the political map has only gotten more competitive with new states and districts emerging as potential flows. So we thought it was time to get back out on the road and take a closer look at what's actually happening on the ground. I'm Erin Haines, journalist and expert on all things Southern politics. And I'm Jennifer Palmieri, former White House Communications Director. Tune in on Mondays to Long Play Series on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.
Do more at the University of New Brunswick. UNB is a world-class university offering a world-class education. Get personalized support to explore career opportunities, build the skills and confidence employers value, and connect with mentors and future employers. From class registration to career preparation, UNB is where you'll do more. Visit domore.unb.ca to learn how.
Long Play, our docuseries exploring the people and forces shaping the South, is back. Newsflash, the South is the new political epicenter of the country. Democrats are way on their heels in this region, but Republicans are going through their own reckoning in the South, too. We're in the final stretch of the midterms, and the political map has only gotten more competitive, with new states and districts emerging as potential flips. So we thought it was time to get back out on the road and take a closer look at what's actually happening on the ground. I'm Erin Haines, journalist and expert on all things Southern politics. And I'm Jennifer Palmieri, former White House Communications Director. Tune in on Mondays to Long Play series on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.
So Joe Biden, earlier than Trump the day before, did go and become the first U.S. president to ever join a picket line. And he joined striking autoworkers in Detroit. Here's a little sound from his visit. You guys, UAW, you've seen the automobile industry back in 2008 and before. Made a lot of second questions. Gave up a lot. And the companies were in trouble. But now they're doing incredibly well. And guess what? You should be doing incredibly well, too. You deserve what you've earned. And you've earned a hell of a lot more than you're getting paid now. Pretty big deal that he joined a picket line. Yeah, I can't real fuck you to the writers, but they're out there for months.
Wait, you don't like suits? You don't think the suits people should get a taste of his Netflix action? Joe Biden should have come to Hollywood and just hung out outside Netflix. Yeah. Just like... Yeah. I think that these room minimums... I think it's great that he went. I think it's a big deal. It was like, that's where he should be, both physically, but also that's the best message, right? That he's going to be the guy who's fighting for workers. And again, it doesn't have to be... Part of the message is, here's the things I've done over the last four years, but a big part of the message is, and this is why I'm going to keep fighting. And if you...
put me back in the White House and you give me a Democratic majority. We're going to keep fighting for workers. Here's the proof that we've been trying and we're going to keep going. And these Republicans are going to sell you out. And, you know, they had the Biden campaign in an ad today, like hitting Trump for being a fake populist, which is great. And, you know, so it's the right message. I also think it's like we're watching this debate and they all just go back to like, where's Joe Biden? He's in the basement. It's like, hey, hey, man, everybody's watching the news. He just got back from a foreign trip. He's at the UAW. He's not in his basement. Yeah. Doesn't work.
One other thing happened, Dan, that you alluded to at the top of the show. Yesterday, a New York State Supreme Court justice ruled that Donald Trump committed fraud by exaggerating his wealth and the value of his assets on financial forms. Basically, Trump and his companies use the false information to they got better terms on loans, insurance rates, taxes. And this happened. This was a summary judgment from a judge. This is all before the fraud trial actually begins. It is slated for this fall. But now the trial basically focuses on.
how big of a fine Trump will pay, what the punishment will actually be. If the ruling stands, basically the attorney general's office, Letitia James, is seeking $250 million in penalties. And the judge could bar and may likely bar Donald Trump and his sons from running any business in New York. Should this have any, do you think this will have any effect on anyone? You think anyone wants to, anyone's going to be swayed by the fact that the guy who wants to be president was just found liable for fraud, can't do business anymore, was just lying about his net worth. No one watching the Republican debate because no one mentioned it. The fact that the guy is running to be in charge of the federal budget and he was just accused of fraud seems like a...
relevant piece of information you can share with voters. I mean, just to just add a little more detail here about like how big a deal this is, as we talked about before, your Attorney General Letitia James charged Trump with these crimes that was headed to trial. She filed a motion that said the evidence of Trump's fraud is so obvious it's not even worth having the trial over. Just look at it. It's so clear. There's not even a shadow of a doubt that he's guilty of fraud. So let's just rule on that right now so we can get to the business of penalizing him for the fraud that is so obvious. And that is what happened. David K. Johnson, who was a very well-known tax writer for The New York Times, was on Twitter, and he suggested that this could likely end with New York State repossessing Trump's properties, including his apartment in Trump Tower, which is a part he still owns, potentially parts of Mar-a-Lago.
And there's, of course, like, you know, Eric Trump and Donald Trump, too, in his statement. They were like, well, the judge said that Mar-a-Lago was worth this much and that couldn't be. And what really happened here is, like, when Trump wanted to lower his taxes, he would claim a low valuation for property. When he wanted to get cheap loans, he would inflate the valuation. So basically what he was doing is he was just changing the valuation depending on whether he wanted loans or whether he wanted to pay lower taxes. Not everyone gets to do that. And some of this wasn't just subjective, like how much is Mar-a-Lago worth? He lied about things like the square footage of various apartments, right? These are things that don't change. Yeah. Yeah, I do. Do you think Biden should, like, does the Biden campaign do anything with that?
Yeah, I think so. I mean, they don't do it right now, but over the course of time, it's a bit like, I think that a core part of their message is going to be about that we don't want to return to the chaos and corruption of Trump. And you're going to have to make that case and a judge finding him guilty of fraud for inflating his assets by $2 billion. Seems like after a jury in New York found him liable for raping Eugene Carroll. Like part of it is, is that Trump is not in this for you. He's in it for himself and his rich friends. And this is a piece of evidence to that, right? That is key because during his speech today, he was like, you know, Joe Biden, Crooked Joe is just out there enriching himself because he like makes up stories about how Biden.
China money and all that kind of stuff. So he said that. He's like, but I'm in it to help you. So he knows. He said I'm in it to enrich you, not myself. Right, yeah. He's like, I didn't need to do this. I was having so much fun living my life and I just did this for you and now I'm getting the shit kicked out of me but now I'm here. I could have done something else. Meanwhile. But you're doing it to stay out of fucking jail, man. Well, now, that's the thing. Look, one thing that comes across I think was true in the Meet the Press interview. It was true in the rally that we watched. He's running. The threat of prison hangs over him. Sharpens the senses. Yeah. It's made him a little more disciplined in his message. It has. But I will say like, yeah, there's political implications for the fact that they just found that we can go right to the damages phase for the fact that he's a fraud.
They're coming for his money. And he's been lying about his worth this whole time. And that has to be genuinely terrifying for him. There's a real threat that before he can ever get back to power, even if he does become president, whatever, that he doesn't have the ability to use politics to stop these people from taking his apartment, from taking his wealth, from forcing him to actually confront what his actual net worth is. That is scary. I honestly think that if he had to choose between being rich and wearing a jumpsuit, going to jail and coming out rich or losing all that he has, I don't think that's a close call for him.
I don't think he wants either. Who would? In fairness. No, and look, I should say he's a little more disciplined. He's also still talking about windmills and whales and confusing Jeb Bush and all that kind of stuff.
Yeah, that's also true. That's also part of it. He really, the whale thing. He sort of got the 16 message, which was me against the establishment on behalf of you, right? That was sort of the message and it was all bullshit and stuff like that. But that's what he did in 16. In 20, he was sort of like in a rabbit hole of fucking, you know, right-wing YouTube comments. Yeah, and sort of fascistic flourishes. Right, right. This was a bit more, like the speech today was a bit more sort of a clean, the parts that were the message around the working class, basically take that kind of broader message that he was doing for a long time. And he basically says, like, I have been fighting for years to take on the elites on behalf of the working class, which is a change. And which, you know, I would just.
Like to understand the environment this is happening in. This is a much, much, much more fertile political environment for Trump's message than it was in 2016. 2016, economy was doing fine. People weren't particularly grumpy. Trump largely won because of complacency in a sense that things were fine after eight years of Obama. Now there's a Pew poll that came out a couple weeks ago that it's part of the regular series that looks at the political, at how people's feelings on the political system in this country and the percentage of people who hate both parties, highest in history. People who are exhausted and frustrated politics, highest in history. People who think politics are corrupt and politicians are corrupt, highest in history. Like we are, people are angry.
and they think the system is not working, and they're mad at both parties, and that's going to have very real consequences. This is not the 2020 environment. And they don't like Donald Trump. Most people don't like Donald Trump. They do. More people, Donald Trump, for all the crap about Joe Biden's favor ratings, they're better than Donald Trump's. For most working class people, this isn't working. We should just get all that out there. But again, an election in 2020 that was decided by 40,000 votes across three states, it doesn't take much. It doesn't take much. So for all the silliness and pointlessness of the Republican debate, who seems to be the most likely nominee...
Donald Trump is out there and is, you know, going to be as tough to beat as he's been in the last election. So everyone should get to work with SaveAmerica.com. Okay. We were going to call Tommy, who's going to go to the debate, but Hannah wasn't feeling well and he had to stay home and take care of Lizette. So no Tommy at the debate, which honestly, good for Tommy.
Yeah. Yeah. Don't go to the Reagan library unless you have to. That's an old saying in my house. Yeah, I think he won that one. We do a few housekeeping notes before we go. Before you fill up your fall calendar with apple picking. Jesus Christ. I love it when you read the housekeeping. Usually I try to read it first. That's why that was good. You don't need that many apples.
Also, Pod Save America is going on tour. There it is. We'll be in D.C., Louisville, Cleveland, New Orleans, San Diego, and San Jose. Make sure to get those tickets before they sell out. And while you're on the events page, don't forget to check out the Love It or Leave It tour dates as well. Hey, did you not eat housekeeping? Love It is heading to Atlanta, Asheville, and Chattanooga next with amazing guests like Atlanta housewife Candy Burris, comedians Ms. Pat, T.S. Madison, and many more. Remember, there are apples at the store. He's got to close the loop on the apple thing. Go to cricket.com slash events to get your tickets now. Also...
Listen up. Oh, this is for you, I guess. Listen up, Crooked fans. Tomorrow, I, but not me, John Lovett, will be joining the Friends of the Pod group thread. I love this housekeeping. We'll be joining Friends of the Pod group thread on Discord at 2 p.m. Pacific for an AMA. 2 p.m. 4 p.m. 4 p.m. It's not 2 p.m. It's 4 p.m. Pacific. 4 p.m. AMA. Okay, Lovett just learned of this. Lovett, you're going to have to be on the Discord. You're going to answer some questions from all of our subscribers and anyone who decides to subscribe after listening to this, which you should if you want to ask Lovett some questions. Head to crooked.com slash friends to sign up and, you know, you get to talk to Lovett and you also get to be on the Discord for nights like this where we all had a great time on the Discord. Here
It was a hate watch, but we did it together. And that was nice. I love the way we just throw around Discord as a term. It's a group chat. If you're old like us, it's a group chat. That's all you need. All right, everyone. We will... I guess we got an impeachment hearing on Thursday. And then the government may be shut down by the next time we record. It's midnight Saturday. So when you hear from Lovett and Tommy and I on Tuesday, we could be in a government shutdown. A lot of news. A lot of news. A lot happening. We'll talk to you then, everyone. Have a good weekend. Bye, everyone.
Pod Save America is a Crooked Media production. Our producers are Olivia Martinez and David Toledo. Our associate producer is Farrah Safari. Writing support from Hallie Kiefer. Reid Cherlin is our executive producer. The show is mixed and edited by Andrew Chadwick. Jordan Cantor is our sound engineer, with audio support from Kyle Seglin and Charlotte Landis. Madeline Herringer is our head of news and programming. Matt DeGroat is our head of production. Andy Taft is our executive assistant. Thanks to our digital team, Elijah Cohn, Haley Jones, Mia Kelman, David Tolles, Kirol Pellaviv, and Molly Lobel. Subscribe to Pod Save America on YouTube to catch full episodes and extra video content. Find us at youtube.com slash at Pod Save America.
Finally, you can join our Friends of the Pod subscription community for ad-free episodes, exclusive content, and a great discussion on Discord. Plus, it's a great way to get involved with Vote Save America. Sign up at crooked.com slash friends. Long Play, our docuseries exploring the people and forces shaping the South, is back. Newsflash, the South is the new political epicenter of the country. Democrats are way on their heels in this region, but Republicans are going through their own reckoning in the South, too. We're in the final stretch of the midterms, and the political map has only gotten more competitive, with new states and districts emerging as potential flips. So we thought it was time to get back out on the road and take a closer look at what's actually happening on the ground. I'm Erin Haines, journalist and expert on all things Southern politics. And I'm Jennifer Palmieri, former White House Communications Director. Tune in on Mondays to Long Play series on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.
Do more at the University of New Brunswick. UNB is a world-class university offering a world-class education. Get personalized support to explore career opportunities, build the skills and confidence employers value, and connect with mentors and future employers. From class registration to career preparation, UNB is where you'll do more. Visit domore.unb.ca to learn how.