Skip to content
TT003 - Mastering Well Owner Education episode artwork

Sep 16, 2021 48 min

TT003 - Mastering Well Owner Education

from Tap Talk

How do you protect public health when there are no regulations that provide minimum standards for well construction? In this episode we're chatting with Bryan Swistock about his experiences in outreach, education, and research at PennState Extension, one of the oldest and most robust private well programs in the country. Visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to learn more and find the full show notes for this episode!

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

TT003 - Mastering Well Owner Education

0:00 48:35
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

More people maybe are realizing that construction is a problem and that we can help them with solutions to that. But still, it would be awful nice if we had some regulations in place to equal the playing field and make sure that all water well drillers are drilling wells in a set way, at least to a minimum standard, so that we can prevent a lot of the problems that we see. You're listening to Tap Talk, the Drinking Water in Rural America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health. And together, we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to Episode 3.

In this episode, we're chatting with Brian Swistock about his experiences in outreach, education, and research at Penn State Extension, one of the oldest and most robust private well programs in the country. We'll talk specifically about the unique challenges of working in a state where there are no regulations that provide minimum standards for well construction. But before we jump into the interview, we've got a tap talk tidbit to share. Each week, we're answering one of the most common questions we receive about groundwater and wells. Steve, coliform bacteria is one of the most common sources of contamination in private wells. Can you explain how that happens?

Well, so coliform bacteria is pretty ubiquitous in the shallow environment and from waste and shallow sources. So usually it happens in a well for one of two reasons. Either there's a shallow source that your well is getting its water from, or you have a well that's not properly sealed and protected near the surface. So as far as the well goes, we see a lot more coliform and bacteria or E. coli problems.

where it's an older well that maybe doesn't meet code or it's a dug well that has not a proper sanitary well cap. It's instead got a concrete pad or we've seen things even like folder scans or whatever. Or it does have a sanitary well cap, but it's not properly sealed. The gasket's bad or the vent to the screen isn't on it. And that allows bugs, rodents, other things to get in wells. And a lot of times that's when we see that. The other possibility is the source of the water in the well.

That's not as common, but it certainly can happen with things like sand points, which are a shallow well in a sandy aquifer where folks are driving that in with a sledgehammer. It may only be 10 or 15 feet deep. There's no grout. And so anything from the surface can make its way down into where the well intake is because the soil is so sandy. Or again, an old dug well where it's getting water from the water table. It may be getting water from just a few feet below land surface. Or there's maybe a very thin, more permeable unit like a sand lens.

that's fairly shallow and it runs throughout the entire area of their homestead. And so it may be picking up water from their septic field or from a livestock feedlot or some of those things. The only other areas where we see this are where it's vulnerable geology. And sand points I mentioned where it's highly permeable soil is one type. The other is karst, which karst geology is weathered limestone or weathered rock. So cave formation, sinkholes. You know, we see in southern Illinois, Indiana, Tennessee, Kentucky, as well as a lot of other parts of the country where there's karst geology.

water can run straight into the aquifer from the surface and so those are it's the source is bad and there's really no way to put in a well in that unit and not have it be contaminated so as far as solutions if it's a well or a well cap it's obviously a good option to properly seal the well to surface and make sure there's no cracks in the casing if it's the source then many times you can't get a safe water supply. And in those cases, we would recommend that you add disinfection, whether that be continuous chlorine or another popular choice so that for folks that don't like the chlorine taste is UV. Ultraviolet light will kill pathogens, bacteria. But also staying proactive about local potential sources of contamination would be the first step, right? Sure. You need to understand your surroundings, right? If this is a farmstead and you've got livestock, or if maybe it's an older home and the well's on the same side of the house as a septic system.

If you're well shallow, those are all things to take note of and be aware and understand you're well. If you don't know those things, you need to learn them so that you're able to protect yourself. Thanks, Steve. And now our conversation with Brian Swistock. Brian, thanks for joining us today. I know you're Penn State, you work at Extension, you're a private well expert. Tell us what you do and what your role is. So yeah, I'm officially what's called an Extension Associate, but the more practical title is a water resources specialist with Penn State Extension. I've worked there for almost 34 years now, doing all kinds of water-related extension work. So our job is to take the research that we learn here at the university and extend it to the public. So just like people here teach students, we teach the public about what we're learning here on campus. And some of that's research we've done.

on private water systems. Some of it's research other people have done on private water systems that we extend. That's a great way to put it. You know, I work with a lot of extension folks and that's probably the best explanation of extension that I've ever been given. Oh, I totally agree. It's been perfected over 34 years. So what's kept you in this job for 34 years? What do you love about it? Well, it's the satisfaction of helping people because when I first started, I had a split appointment between research and extension. And so I did a lot more kind of basic science research. And in that case...

You don't get that fulfillment. The big fulfillment is you get a grant. So you go around and give high fives to everybody else that got the grant and you do the work and then you publish it in a journal and then that's it. You move on to the next thing. That's the satisfaction of it. And that was just kind of a little bit empty for me. Whereas in Extension, you're solving people's problems every single day. You're helping people every single day. And I came from a father who was a state policeman and a mother who was a nurse. So my family was very much into helping people in one way or another. And I thought Extension was a good fit for me to help people solve problems. That's awesome. Yeah, I totally agree. I also was a researcher earlier in my career and I get so much more out of it today.

doing what we're doing. Oh, yeah. Yeah, there's no, not even close. The biggest thing you got in research was you used to get reprint requests. You get a little postcard from somebody saying, hey, we want a reprint, and you celebrate. Well, somebody read this, and I get to send out a reprint, whereas doing this work, every single day this morning, I've helped three or four people with problems that they had, not just private wells, but other kinds of water problems. All right, so before we really get started, what's one personal fun fact about you you'd like to share?

Well, I'm a big dog lover, and so I've always had English setters. I do field-type English setters and Gordon setters, and I've trained them for field trials. I've had international champions in English setters. I'm not quite as active in it as I used to be, but I used to travel all over the place and show dogs in field trial settings, so they're bird dogs. So you used to trial them outside in the woods, basically in front of judges, and I got a lot of fun out of that for many, many years. That's awesome.

You know, I grew up on a farm and we had farm dogs and nothing. They're all mixes and crossbreds, whatever. And so I've always hunted as a kid without a dog. And I just remember the first time I actually went with someone who had a dog. It was just so eye opening how different that is.

Well, it's a real progression. You know, when I first got introduced to bird dogs, about when I started my job, I was a hunter already, but I had never hunted with a dog and I got addicted to it. And then I got to the point where I didn't even want to go hunting unless I had a dog. And then I fully transformed to the point where I didn't even take a gun anymore. I just took the dog and a blank gun because I just wanted to watch the dog do the work. And that's kind of where I'm at now. I don't even take a gun. I just take a blank gun. I don't even own one anymore, but you can do when you're a kid in a rural area for sure. Yeah. Well, that's really interesting. Thanks.

One of the questions we love to ask our guests is, who is your water hero? This could be someone past or present who's had an influence on your career, your passion, and really just made a mark for you. That's an easy one for me. My predecessor, Dr. Bill Sharp, who was the water resources specialist in extension when I started. So we had an overlapping career of a good 15 or 20 years, actually, because I kind of worked with him for many years before I really took over his role. And he's the one that really started all this private water system work here in Pennsylvania back in the mid 80s. Right when I was starting, he was also working with some other people to start this private water system work. And so, you know, you don't learn about this stuff in school. I came into this job. I knew a little bit.

about water quality, but I didn't know anything about private water systems. And so traveling all over the state with him and just learning on the fly by answering questions at meetings and going and doing 20 drinking water clinics in a week all over the state, I just learned everything from him. So really he started this program. I just have kind of kept it going, but he was the person who really had the foresight to see that we needed to be doing this work with private water system owners. And he really gets all the credit for starting all of this.

Yeah, I think you're a little humble because you're certainly someone a lot of us look up to because of your knowledge. And I totally agree with you really have to do it. We're having that issue now. We're trying to find another person, a public health person, to work on our program. And to find somebody who's got private well experience is nearly impossible. It's just surprising. And it was great working with him because he started me out slow. We would go out to do a program, a two-hour program, and he'd say, okay, you take this topic and just talk for 10 minutes.

And then after doing that a while, he'd say, okay, take half an hour and do these topics. And then before you know it, he's like, okay, take two hours and I'm going to sit in the back and watch you drink my coffee. But that's the only way you learn. And answering questions is the true learning. Just getting people bombarding you with questions about their unique problems, that's really how you learn. I totally agree. It's been quite a learning experience for us too. And there's certainly a lot of questions we still can't answer. That's the interesting part of all this. You said they're all unique. I think every single well is different in some way. It's really crazy.

Yep. And every so often, I still get a question that I've never been asked in 34 years. And that's what keeps you going. I'm really sick of answering, how do I get rid of coliform bacteria? Well, I've answered that one a million times, and I could just play a record for that one. But it's those really unique gems that keep you going, keep you interested in it. And they're out there still for me. I want to take a second to really highlight that point you made about mentorship, though, because it's one of the conversations that we're having in our office right now as our staff. Some are returning to the office, but some are not. And how do we have that same deep level of mentorship between a younger staff member and a more seasoned staff member if we're not all together anymore?

Yeah, and in our case, we have virtual meetings still, which are not the same, but they're as close as we can get at this point. And so we meet very routinely as a team and talk about things. We meet every month, actually, and talk about different problems that we're seeing or questions that we've got. And I still, to this day, when I get a unique question and I forward it on to them and say, hey, here's something I've never gotten before, and here's probably how we should approach this, or we'll get their ideas of how we should approach it. So we really do try to maintain that interaction between team members that are working with private water systems, but we just have to do it more virtually now. Sure. It also sounds like Bill was a really tremendous mentor.

Uh, as far as mentors. Oh yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. He was, he was awesome. And, uh, like I said, he, he had the vision of starting this program. He was the one that recognized that, Hey, we've got a lot of private water system owners in this state. We have no regulations. They're on their own. They need help. And nobody else was helping them before he started. That's awesome. Okay. Um, so I'm talking about your private outreach and education program. You're in Pennsylvania, um, where you just mentioned you have no regulations still. And so, um, are there, what are the highlights of your program that you'd like to share with us?

Well, I think there are a couple. We've always had our safe drinking water clinics, which were the thing that Bill Sharp started with others, which are these workshops for private water system owners. And when we were doing face-to-face workshops, we used to do a lot of those for people. And over time, we've transformed that into some of the things that we saw we needed to kind of build those drinking water clinics. And one was to have an actual lab that we could work with here on campus. So we developed a water testing program here on campus now that tests about 2,000 to 3,000 private water systems a year. Now it's commercial, so people are paying for that. We sometimes get grants that provide some free testing.

But making sure that everybody in the state had access to water testing from an unbiased accredited lab was one of our big goals. And it took us till 2007 to do that. But now we can provide water testing to anybody in the state, whereas people used to have to drive long distances sometimes to get to their water labs. And that was a big barrier to getting water testing done. So developing that water testing program, continuing those safe drinking water clinics, and then the development of our volunteer program, our Master Well Owner Network in 2004 was a big help also because one of the problems we have is there's only a handful of us and there's a million private water systems in the state.

And another big barrier was how do we get all this outreach out to people? It's more about logistics. We have the information. It's just about how do you get the information to the public? And our idea was to have volunteers out on the ground, out in the communities. They could talk to their friends and their coworkers and their neighbors.

and give that basic private water system education on the ground as a volunteer. And that's why we developed that program. Again, Bill Sharp was instrumental in that. He and I developed it together in 2004, not long before he retired. And it's now trained over 900 volunteers. We have about 60,000 contacts through that program. So they've been able to educate a lot of people that we would have never been able to reach with that proactive education. You know, that's always the problem is...

The reactive education are the people that come to you. They're the people that have the problem, right? But how do you stop the problems from happening, right? How do you be proactive? And most people, as long as the water turns on and it doesn't smell bad, they're not going to be proactive. But if you have people out on the ground saying, hey, have you ever tested your water? Because, you know, not everything smells in water. And there can be things like lead and bacteria you wouldn't even know are there. Maybe you should test your water. So that proactive education is really a challenge. And that's where the volunteer program has been very helpful. And it's also the most successful.

Um, and you can reach out to people and, you know, when just, we went to the state fair this year and some people didn't think we should. And, um, but there's a conservation world there for all these volunteer groups and stuff. And we reach so many well owners that way. Um, you know, four or 50 contacts each day and, uh, people who tell me what County they're from. And I'm like, Oh, Tazewell County. Well, you know, we have arsenic in our water and Muhammad there. And, and that really gets them hooked or whatever.

But if you don't get that chance, we would have never met any of those folks and they would never even consider even talking to us. Right. Right. Yeah. And one of the things we would often use as a hook is just a sanitary well cap at a display because they're not required in Pennsylvania. So a lot of people would be walking by our display and say, what is that? And we'd say, oh, it's a sanitary well cap. Oh, my well cap doesn't look like that. No, it doesn't. That's because they're not required in Pennsylvania. But here's why they're important. So having those little catches to get people to stop at the display and then you can tell them lots of other things that might be important. We use a groundwater flow model, one of the tank models, and also have an old hand pump that we let kids pump.

And that seems to bring at least the kids by a lot. So, yeah, sorry. I'm just wondering if you think there is a difference between the individual being in a volunteer capacity versus those in a professional capacity, maybe your county extension offices. Do you think their neighbors listen better to the volunteers? That's probably more the case these days than it has in the past. There's more and more skepticism of even us at the university. Now, it didn't used to be that way, but now it's becoming more that way where people don't necessarily listen to people from academia. And so having friends and family and coworkers tell you those same things probably is more successful today than it's ever been.

It's a sad situation, but it's very good. And yes, you know, finding the local champion, if you will, obviously is a great approach. That's why your master well-owner program is a great model. I think you're the only state that does it. Some of the other states have gone with well-owner networks instead of volunteer programs.

having actual homeowners that just become part of a well-owners network. And that's a slightly different strategy that has worked better in a lot of other states. Our volunteer program, we've tried it in a couple of adjacent states and had a lot of trouble getting it off the ground. Part of that may be because the other states have regulations and so people feel better protected by the government regulations that they already have. I'm just surmising, I don't know, but we've had more trouble getting a true volunteer program in other states. One of the difficulties is, you know, volunteer programs are usually built around a real interest that somebody has, like master gardener program. They love gardening, it's their hobby.

nobody's going to have a hobby around water wells. And so this is not exactly something where people get engaged and just are thrilled with it and are glued to the screen to watch everything. Our volunteers are usually a year or two, maybe three years of providing some education and then they kind of move on and we have to constantly train new volunteers and we accept that and know that is going to happen. But it's the different style of volunteer program than a lot of the others in extension. I think it's just really valuable to know your audience though and to know that life cycle and have that going into the program, not expecting they're going to make that lifetime commitment like somebody would domestic gardeners.

Yeah, I mean, we have a few that have. We have a handful that have been around since 2004 that continue to do the work and really enjoy it. But they're the exception, not the rule. Most of them give, like I said, a couple years at most. And then they've already talked to all their family and all their friends and their neighbors and their coworkers, and they're ready to move on from that. That's awesome. So you mentioned that there's no statewide well regulations in Pennsylvania. How did the state get to that point? Well, it's really just political. It's very simple.

The science is very clear. A lot of states adapted water well legislation because it makes sense, right? It's common sense that you should do that. But that didn't happen here. And so what happened quite a long time ago is the state came to us and said, hey, we would like you to do some research to prove that these regulations make a difference. So we did that research.

and gave that to the General Assembly. And they looked at that and said, yeah, well, okay, but can you prove that people are getting ill because wells are poorly constructed? Well, that's another big hurdle to overcome. Again, you can use common sense and say, if pollutants are above drinking water standards, people are probably getting ill, but it's a lot harder to actually go out and document that on the ground. So that's been one of the hurdles is kind of this level that they want to see proof of why is this important. And the big concern among the politicians has been the extra cost.

And I had one politician after I testified the one year came up to me and said, yeah, you know, we know that this is a health issue, but we're concerned that it costs more money and we're not going to do anything if it costs more money, even if it means people's health. So when you have that kind of an attitude, you know, what can you do with that point? Of course, it's going to cost more to properly construct it. Well, it's not a lot more, but it is more. So when you have that barrier, it's very difficult to overcome. And the challenges have been mainly ultra conservative property rights people that believe this is some sort of infringement on their rights.

and believe that any regulation is bad regulation. And so every time it comes up, those groups get motivated and they start with their sort of disinformation campaign. Some of them are very humorous, actually, about how the state regulators in camouflage are going to army crawl onto your property at night and check your water well to make sure that it's compliant and you'll get a thousand dollar fine. I mean, none of it was even remotely true, but it was very effective in mobilizing people against it. And so that's really why we're where we are. It's been disinformation and it's been legislators that don't want to have any extra cost passed on to well owners.

You mentioned that maybe that this landscape has benefited the program because you've been able to really gain a foothold because we've had interested volunteers. Has it affected your program in any other ways? Well, yeah, and I hate to use the word benefit because it would be so much easier if the regulations were in place and we didn't have to constantly deal with non-sanitary well caps and ungrounded wells and so forth. So it's probably provided more interest in our program, which is a benefit. It's kind of a secondhand way of saying it's a benefit to our program because more people maybe are realizing that construction is a problem and that we can help them with solutions to that.

But still, it would be awful nice if we had some regulations in place that equal the playing field and make sure that all water well drillers are drilling wells in a set way, at least to a minimum standard, so that we can prevent a lot of the problems that we see. Yeah, I mentioned on a number of our webinars that two states still don't have regulations or really, really licensed drillers. And I got an email from someone sending me the page where you can get your license as a Pennsylvania well driller. And then when I looked through the things, it's like, oh, anybody can be a Pennsylvania well driller. You just have to send in the 60 or $75. And so I changed that. And now when I bring it up, it's like, there's no continuing education requirements. There's no test you take to prove that you know how to drill a well properly, but you can get a license. Yeah, I mean, technically, yes, there is a licensing program, but it doesn't.

It's just basically a fee. That's all there is. There's nothing as far as compliance, nothing as far as education needed to get that. And I always tell that when I do drinking water clinics, I tell people, if anybody in here would like to be a water well driller, send in your money and you can start tomorrow. As long as you can afford a water well rig, start drilling tomorrow. It's interesting. It's sad how politics affects so many things. And yeah, something like you said, it's such common sense.

And it continues to come up pretty routinely. There's still interest, of course. And even the Well Drillers Association, people would think, oh, they're against this. Well, no, they're not. They're very much for it. The well drillers would like to have an equal playing field so that they're all drilling wells to some base level. The problem with the lack of regulations is even somebody who wants to drill a proper water well gets pulled down by the other people who are not because of cost. Because the average homeowner doesn't know what grout is, doesn't understand the sanitary well cap. So if you have two well drillers coming at you and their estimate is $2,000 versus $2,500.

you're going to pick the $2,000 because you probably don't understand why this one's a little bit more because they're going to put grout in around the casing and they're going to put a sealed well cap on top. Those questions don't get asked. And so the whole industry gets pulled down to the lowest common denominator, the person who's drilling the cheapest well, which is not the best well. So the Web Drillers Association has been very active in trying to get the legislation so that everybody's brought up to a minimum standard. That's awesome. I mean, it's great to hear. Yeah, no doubt. So switching gears, you mentioned lead. We were talking the other day. It's kind of one of the biggest health threats in private wells. Why do you feel that way?

You know, it is a big issue for sure, but how does it affect private well owners versus what you see like in Flint, Michigan, or Galesburg, Illinois, or any of the communities that have lead issues? Yeah, and it's a common misconception among people is that lead is an urban problem. It's in these older parts of cities where they have lead lines, and they never think about it being in private water systems. And I've worked with lead ever since I started. It was one of the first research projects that I got involved with, was looking at lead in private water systems. And it's just such an insidious.

pollutant because it has no symptoms whatsoever but yet if you look down through the health effects that can cause pretty much anything you can think of can come from lead pollution in water it's just a terrible thing to get especially for children it really targets infants and young children and The combination of the lack of symptoms and how just terrible it is for children really got me more interested in trying to do more outreach on lead. And the fact that most private water system owners never think about it. They just think it's a city problem. And so we've done several research projects looking at lead. And it's one of those few things, though, where there's good news, actually. It's getting less common. The regulations are having an effect over time. When I first started, we were a little over 20% of the private water systems in Pennsylvania had more than the action level of lead, above 15 parts per billion. So about one in five homes had a lead problem that were on a private water system.

Now we're down closer to about half of that. We're down to about 10%. And that's because of the federal regulations that have removed lead from the solders and from the fixtures. So most newer homes now don't have any source of lead coming from the plumbing. And the lead is almost never in the source water. It's all coming out of the plumbing components.

So it is a success story, but we still have a ways to go. Eventually, it's something that we'll rarely hear about, right? Because this trend will continue as more and more people in older homes are replacing plumbing. They're going to remove that lead. And we're going to continue to see a decline in this over time. But it's just such a terrible pollutant that even when it's down at 5% or 2%, that's still a lot of people that are exposed to a pollutant that really has nasty health effects. Certainly a million well-owners, that's a lot. Yeah, when you think about 20% of a million, 200,000 homes potentially at that time that had too much lead. Wow.

What do you do then? You said you've done some lead research. How do you help owners better understand this problem? Do you have a focus on that? Yeah, so what we generally do in extension is once we learn that information, we create fact sheets, we create publications, which we did for lead. We created those resources. We did inject that into our drinking water clinics. We did a whole section of our drinking water clinics. In fact, like I was telling you when Bill Sharp said, hey, just do this little part to start. That's what I was doing. I was talking about lead. And I was starting to do a special topic on lead as part of our drinking water clinics. And over time, we've kept that special topic in there really at the forefront to teach people about the importance of lead. And it has an effect because we see, for example, in our water testing lab.

And when we first started the lab here, we give people options of what they want to select for water testing. And we found that, you know, about maybe 10%, maybe even less than that, to start probably closer to 5% of people were selecting lead for their water testing. Now it's up to about 25% of people that are selecting lead. So we're seeing still not the majority of people, but we also tell people, if you have a newer home with plumbing that was put in after 1990-ish, roughly, or if you have PEX plumbing and PVC, your problem with lead is probably going to be minimal, if at all. So a lot of that.

case where people aren't testing are people that maybe have newer homes and don't need to test. But we have seen a pretty good increase in the amount of testing, which is heartening to see that. People are getting that message and are doing more testing. Now, we like to take credit for that, but things like Flint, Michigan, for example, that overnight caused more people to get their water tested for lead because that was a big story that people really saw. And it was not good to see Flint happen, don't get me wrong, but it really increased the awareness of lead again. The lead was a big problem in the 80s and then it kind of went away and then Flint happened and lead came back onto the forefront again. Yeah, those are most teachable moments we really have to take advantage of otherwise when they're there, that's for sure. So what are some common misconceptions that you see with people relating to lead?

Yeah, and one of the biggest misconceptions about any pollutant, including lead, is that they think that if the water tastes okay and smells okay and looks okay, that they couldn't possibly have a lead problem or any other water pollutant. And lead has zero symptoms. Now, it often occurs in conjunction with copper, which does have some symptoms. And so we can use that relationship to help people with looking for things like blue-green stains and if their metal pipes are leaking. And if they get water first thing in the morning that tastes really metallic, but then that goes away as they run the water. These are all things that help people determine if they might have a lead problem. But there's still that misconception that if the water tastes okay, I couldn't possibly have lead, I'm fine, no problem at all.

That reminds me because just recently my daughter had an opportunity to drink some well water. She's like, Mom, I just realized that I really like well water. And I'm like, well, Emily, just because it tastes good doesn't necessarily mean that it's safe to drink. And so it creates the opportunity, though, to educate our children because they are such sponges and they remember those things. So if we can influence children and give them that one piece of information that just because it tastes good doesn't mean that it's safe, that can trickle up to the family members and the decision makers. Another good example of that are Roadside Springs, which we've done some research on. People travel.

great distances to go to these red side springs to collect water because the water tastes great. And I'll give them that. The water does taste great. But when you look at drinking water safety, it is not safe. It's almost always has bacterial contamination. Quite a few of them have Giardia and Cryptosporium. So yeah, that may taste great, but you're going to get pretty ill if you drink it. Yeah, no doubt. Yeah. So you mentioned some of the research that you've already done. We know you've also done work on the effect of well construction on groundwater quality, as well as the impact of shale gas development on private water supplies. What are some of the takeaways from your research work that you regularly share with the public?

Well, and first and foremost, I think working in academia, that's a great advantage that we have is being able to do that research, hopefully in an unbiased way. And shale gas is a prime example of that. When shale gas first got started, people were yearning to find information that was unbiased. There was a lot of information from the gas companies about how they drill wells and how safe they are for groundwater. But they really wanted to see that unbiased information. And we even had companies come to us and say, hey, we'll give you big grants if you'll do research.

on this topic. And we turned them down because we said, hey, we want to be able to present this information and have it be unbiased. We don't want people to look at it and say, oh, an energy company paid for this. Of course, they're going to say that. That's a big advantage that we have in academia is being able to do the research and be sometimes picky about what research we're going to do and who we're going to take money from to make sure that what we produce is a totally unbiased product. In the case of those two particular problems, the well construction issue came to us from the legislature where, again, they wanted to see what effect does well construction have on water quality? Is there a real relationship between the two that you can prove? And of course, we did find that there was an impact from well construction on water quality, predominantly bacterial contamination was the biggest issue. And then around shale gas, that was...

That gave me a lot of gray hair. You can see this gray hair and a lot of that came from that particular topic. And we all have those topics in our career where there's a great need to do it, but you know that there's going to be an emotional toll in doing that. And there was no greater example of that in my case than shale gas, where it was just such a politicized and such a dividing topic in the state that getting involved in that took a real toll. But we produced a lot of good information to help people decide about whether they want to do a loud drilling on their property and if so, what.

kinds of regulations did they want to dictate? You know, the state has regulations around what drillers have to do to protect drinking water. But when you lease your property, you can up those regulations. You can say anything you want in a lease, as long as it's more strict than what the state has. So we could tell people, okay, the state says that the drillers have to stay at least 200 feet away from your water well. If you don't like that, make sure when you're doing your lease that you put in a distance that you're comfortable with, whether it's 500 feet, a thousand feet, the sky's the limit. You can put whatever you want in there. If they sign it, that becomes the regulation for your property. Same with water testing. So we could explain to people what were the regulations and what they could do to make.

them better or what we thought maybe would be better to protect private water systems. And we had actual data that we could look at and show them what were the effects, if any, of gas drilling on private water systems. And it helped people make decisions. And that's really what we wanted to do in an unbiased way. It's awesome. You know, you think about that for communities or for states, you know, just like California has its own arsenic regulation. It's more strict than a safe drinking water act, but I've never even considered that on the scale of an individual property. It's an awesome idea.

Yeah, if it's a pollutant that's related to an activity. When you have something like arsenic that can have so many sources, then you have a little bit less control. Yeah, I just meant the idea. I mean, a homeowner take charge or landowner take charge of their – it's a great idea. I always – part of the emotional toll was that we would go around doing what were called leasing programs.

When the leasing frenzy hit, it was an overnight sensation where energy companies were coming in here and offering big money to people to lease their land. So there was this huge demand. We were doing programs routinely for 500 and 1,000 people. And we were used to doing programs for 20 and 30. And they were there to learn about leasing primarily because they were being approached about this. And so the people on the program, the first people would get up there and they would talk about the leases and how you should negotiate a lease and how you can make the most money from your lease. And that got people all excited. And then I was the Debbie Downer that came along afterward. And I said, so while you're doing your lease, make sure you're putting these water things in. And these are the kinds of problems that can happen.

And it was all kind of bad news in my case. I was just trying to prevent problems as much as possible, whereas everybody else was trying to make sure they made the most money. So I was always looked at as the Debbie Downer on the program and the one who brought everybody down at the end. It's important. There's always a cost, no matter how much money you make, if you're not doing all those things. I went to an NGWA conference in Ohio, right when all that stuff started. And somebody spoke, it was a shale conference or shale gas conference.

And some person spoke about what you should do and how far away and you need a sample and how to make it legally defensible. And then right after that, an energy company guy got up and spoke about testing they'd done. And these are low volume wells. And so they showed how much the chemistry changed from one hour to the next as the water level dropped 100 or 200 feet and all that was oxidized and basically said, you know, your one sample doesn't prove a thing. And the whole audience was just, you know, 250 people in there and it was just silence. No one knew what to say.

Yeah, and that's still a challenge to this day. Baseline sampling based on one sample, what it basically does is protect you from just a gross contamination incident where the change in chemistry is just remarkable. But what often happens is somebody might have a subtle change in iron or manganese or some other metal in the water, and they'll try to tie it to nearby drilling. And you're right, if they've got one sample, good luck trying to prove that, because those are the kinds of things that can happen naturally just from pumping or seasonal changes. And unless you have a pretty strong background in seasonal sampling at that well, you're going to be very hard-pressed to prove small changes.

water chemistry it's got to be something really pretty dramatic that is very closely tied to that activity to be proven with one sample. The other side of that, though, is to do more than one sample gets extremely expensive. Totally, right. One sample is expensive. They never need it. They never use that information and they're putting a lot of money out. Yeah. So are there other interesting questions that you'd like to answer, either as part of Extension or part of your work specifically? You mean research questions that we would like to answer? Yeah, projects that you'd like to start or what you think needs to be done, even just recommendations for the next generation of academics. Well, I think the big one right now is BFAS. They're starting to learn quite a bit on community water systems.

There's still almost no data on private wells, at least here in Pennsylvania. Now, there is a project starting up here in Pennsylvania that will be collecting some data for 90 water wells in the state. That's the other problem with PFAS. It's so expensive that it's hard to do it on a lot of wells. It's just too difficult to get the kind of money you need to do large numbers of wells. But we'll at least have a little bit of data on PFAS and other emerging contaminants, pharmaceuticals. We did a little project on that, but the difficulty there is when you find somebody has one part per trillion of...

amoxicillin in their well water, what does that mean? There's no drinking water standard. Other than being a little bit disconcerting that they've got amoxicillin in their water and they probably don't like that, what do we tell them when we don't have drinking water standards? So if we get some drinking water standards on some of these emerging contaminants, it'll be interesting to see how that develops over time because this stuff is everywhere. We saw it in our data, all kinds of emerging contaminants in the most remote places you could even imagine in water wells out in the middle of nowhere that was passing through septic systems and getting into their groundwater.

But we still don't have the data to really say what those things mean. So I think getting more data on some of these emerging contaminants, more understanding of what levels are important versus unimportant. I still think we need to do more with nitrate. It's one of the most basic. contaminants out there, but there's still an awful lot unknown about long-term exposure to higher nitrates. And when I first started, that was a big issue. There was a lot of talk about lowering the drinking water standard for nitrate. And if that ever happens, boy, boy, is that going to be a political hot potato. I'm not saying that it will happen, but I'm not saying that it should, but I think there's some interesting data sets out there about long-term exposure to nitrates that are kind of compelling. Oh, interesting. Yeah, I know. So this is off topic a little bit, but you're talking about some of the research you've done and you've been doing it for 34 years.

What I've noticed is that like in the last 10, all of a sudden there's a lot more being done with private wells, you know, and it's, I mean, that's a great thing. So talking about, you know, a paper that nobody reads, well, now some of those things are getting more play. I think that's what's happening with PFAS with chemicals as well. And you're seeing a lot of States who are funding small studies, at least to sample private wells. And so I think collectively, if everyone starts talking and sharing that information and we may have more data out there than for any other emerging contaminant we've ever sampled for nationally anyway. Yeah. Just the mere fact that we're having this.

discussions is incredible to me because it used to be, I would do research and go present it at a conference and it would be the only talk on private water systems. And I would look across other conferences and I would never see any other talks on private water systems. And you really felt like you were alone. You're the only one doing anything. And now it's, it's just totally different. There's lots of other states.

So getting involved, you have your network, we have other extension programs starting up. So it's really good to see the amount of work that's being done on private water systems right now and the amount of money that's starting to be available to do research on it. Well, that funny story, the first NEHA conference I went to, which their partner with RCAP on our grant, it was in Orlando, Florida. And I just remember I was the only private well-taught. And NEHA's a huge, you know, their AEC conference is huge. And I was just, I felt like a duck out of water, man. It was just really interesting now to see what their conference, you know, they did a pre-conference workshop, they're doing webinars.

Environmental health has really picked up the ball, which is a great thing because that's who people go to when they have a problem with their well is they go to their local health department a lot of times. So I've noticed that over the last 10 years or so, and I think it gives a lot of hope for how other things we need to do with private wells. I think there's going to be more backing just because there's more information available and there's more people interested in it. So yeah, I hope so anyway. Yeah, I used to think that, gosh, if I ever retire, if we're doing this, nobody will ever do it now. I know, my gosh, there's all kinds of people doing it. And here at Penn State, we have a whole group of people now that are working with private water systems. Used to be just me. Now there's lots of people. That's awesome. Yeah, it's a good feeling to have. There's a lot more private wells out there than some people realize. So kind of coming full circle to making a difference with your work. Why do you think that research and the academic community is an important stakeholder in this larger dialogue that we're talking about, about drinking water and both public water systems and private wells and connecting that to public health?

Well, yeah, I've already kind of alluded to it, but the ability to do the research in academia and collect that information, again, in an unbiased way, if at all possible, so that you can provide that information to the public. That's where the extension model is so great, because it's tied to academia. It's about extending that information out to the public, just like students get. That's the real... great thing about academia that academia has to offer is that tie to research. And we can also tie into people with research appointments that don't have extension appointments. My job is not just to do research and then extend my research, but my job is also to watch for research that is being done by pure researchers that are maybe publishing it in journals. And then I can go to them and say, hey, this is really applicable to well owners. We need to put out a little fact sheet that summarizes this and get this information out to homeowners, not just to the scientific community. And that's where a lot of them, not a lot, some will say, oh, what is extension? What do you...

talking about? What is this thing? I've always just thought about outreach. Well, outreach is a broader term, but extension is specific to land-grant universities and does outreach here at the land-grant system. Yeah, our extension has been a partner on our grant, I mean, before we started our program. So we've got a good relationship with those folks. So yeah, awesome. Well, Brian, thank you so much. Are you on social media in any professional capacity where you'd invite folks to follow you?

Nope, I'm old fashioned. So we have our website, just the extension water websites, which people can easily find by just searching Penn State extension water. And they'll get to our water resource site, which has old drinking water residential site to it, but also has things on septic system and stormwater and other water issues. But that's as close as I get to social media. There's a ton of good information on our website, for sure. Videos, recordings, a lot of stuff. And we will include the link to that in our show notes for this episode. Great. Well, it's great to talk to you. Thank you. TAP Talk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois.

with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Tap Talk?

This episode is 48 minutes long.

When was this Tap Talk episode published?

This episode was published on September 16, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Tap Talk episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.