Groundwater is a difficult thing to study because it's below ground. You know, it's not easily accessed. If you're studying a river, you can, you know, you can take a boat out or if it's shot enough, you can walk out there and do whatever you want. But with groundwater, you got to put a hole in the ground or use someone else's hole. And it's expensive. And it's a three-dimensional issue too. So an aquifer could be 100, 200 feet thick. And the water quality in the top of the aquifer could be totally different from the quality in the lower aquifer. And this was kind of brought home to me how poorly mixed groundwater can be.
You're listening to Tap Talk, the Drinking Water in Rural America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health. And together, we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to Episode 10. In this episode, we're chatting with groundwater geochemist Walt Kelly about our organization, the Illinois State Water Survey, risk communication in groundwater supply planning, and approaches to studying some of today's biggest water quality issues, such as microplastics and lead.
Before we jump into the interview, we've got our Tap Talk tidbit to share. Each week, we're answering one of the most common questions we receive about groundwater and wells. So, Steve, why are hand-dug and bored wells more of a risk than drilled wells? Well, typically, you install a large diameter hand-dug or bored well. You know, in the old days, they were hand-dug, and now they're bored by a boring machine in areas where there isn't really an aquifer. So, you're getting water from the shallow, usually glacial or alluvial material, and typically, one, they're not as deep.
And two, they're getting water that infiltrates mostly from the surface. And so just by that nature, they're more likely to have surface contaminants or they could. And so a typical board well uses three or four foot concrete tile like you'd have going under a road, circular tile, and they're just set on top of each other in four foot sections. And every one of those seams allows water to infiltrate in. So in a board well, at least in Illinois, the law requires you to have 10 feet of impermeable material above the top of the well. And so after 10 feet.
water can get in at every four foot section, which depending on how dry, where the water table is, we see in like areas of Illinois that are glaciated, we see some of the surface geology where it's dry and cracked. And so those cracks allow water to seep right in tens of feet into the ground. And so, or if it's an old brick line well, like the one I grew up on, it's just a hole that was dug in the ground. It was only 14 feet deep and brick are laid around to keep it intact. And water can seep in between all of the bricks all the way to the surface. And so those situations, and there's just a lot of those wells still left in use. And when states pass laws that require well construction code, they grandfather in any existing wells. So we still see a lot of these wells in use. And so it's really just the nature of where they're getting the water from. It's no different than if you have a sand point and you've driven it in yourself and it's only 10 or 12 feet because the water table is really high and it's really sandy soil, you're much more likely to have contamination. Some states have outlawed sand points, for instance, but they're really a bad idea. They're just not that safe and they're more susceptible to surface contamination.
Thanks, Steve. And now, our conversation with Walt Kelly. Today, we have Walt Kelly with us. He's the groundwater section head for the State Water Survey and also a researcher and geochemist. And so, well, I guess the first thing is, tell us about what you do, where you work, what's your role.
OK, well, like you mentioned, I'm the head of the groundwater section here at the Illinois State Water Survey, which is part of the Prairie Research Institute, which is part of the University of Illinois at Venice-Champaign. We always have to give the full title. I've been here almost 30 years. I came on as a groundwater geochemist and doing that. I'm still doing that. But in the last, I think, about eight or nine years, I've been head of the section. And we have about non-COVID times in the building. We had 20 to 25 people come in and work on various projects. Now most people are still staying at home, but I guess that's it. Yes, we all miss those times. Yes, we do.
So I think we have to say that Walt is our boss. And Steve and Walt share a wall in between each other. Their offices are next to one another. So this is a colleague conversation here on this episode. But Walt, can you share more about what you love about your job and what has kept you in it for so long?
Inertia probably kept me in as much as anything. But no, what I really love about the job really is the people and especially the people I work with, but also just kind of people throughout the state that I've encountered during my work. Just various stakeholders, various scientists. It's just been some wonderful experiences that I've had working with people. Yeah, and there's some interesting problems that I've been able to work on. I love looking at data. That's one of my geeky things I really like to do. And we produce a lot of data here at the State Water Survey, as well as other entities like the USGS that we have access to. So, yeah, it's been a lot of fun, actually. I feel like a very lucky career working here at the Water Survey. I think that's well put. I agree. I think about some of the stakeholders we work with regularly and become actually kind of friends over the years because we work on so many issues together. That does make it a lot better, for sure.
So, go ahead. I was just going to say, you know, occasionally you run into the person who doesn't want you to sample their well or kind of nasty about it or whatever. But, you know, there's few and far in between. And you can kind of understand what their hesitancy is from. I'm from the government, you know, and I'm here to help you. And, you know, right. Thanks. But, you know, we're not really part of the government anymore. We used to be until about 15 years ago, I guess, when we became the Institute. We're now no longer.
you know have any kind of governmental powers like we had very few in the past but we did have some yeah and then those are gone which is fine yeah no it is it hasn't hurt us it doesn't seem like so yeah i don't think so either well before we get started uh what's one personal fun fact about you Oh, you know, I'm really a very boring person. I was kind of scratching my head about what's something interesting about me. And actually, what I came with was that I've been commuting by bicycle since the 1980s. And I like to feel like I was on the vanguard, the cutting edge of foot-powered transportation. Bicycle? Yeah. And, you know, when I first came to Champaign, Champaign is a very easy city to bike around. It's nice and flat. People are generally pretty...
Safe, respectful. Yeah, that's right. But it's just in the last few years, it's really blossomed. And every time they do any kind of road work, they put in bike lanes now. So it's much, much safer. Many, many more people are riding their bikes. And I think it's just great for a number of reasons, health reasons, environmental reasons. It's just being out is fun. So I love riding my bike. And I hope to continue to do that for many more years. That's awesome. Yeah, I was just wondering if you didn't have a fun fact, we would have to start listing them about you. Yeah, I had trivia at the top of my list. Oh, that's true. Yeah, we were all on a trivia team together, weren't we? I wonder if I was going to be able to do that again. I hope so. And it's pretty fun.
Yeah. So one of our favorite segments is we ask our guests who their water hero is. So somebody who's influenced you over the course of your career and, you know, just made an impact that you wanted to share. So, yeah, that's a really great question. I was actually walking last night trying to think of who I should say. And there are a lot of people. The field that I'm in, kind of the groundwater geochemistry, is really not that old. It really only kind of got going in the 1950s and 1960s. And I was really privileged to meet some of those guys. I mean, they were all white males, but sort of like founding fathers of the field. And a lot of these guys are at the U.S. Geological Survey. And one of them was named Bill Back. I got to meet him. Wonderful person. Very encouraging.
And anyway, but actually I decided the people that I wanted to mention were a couple of people that really helped my career early on. When I came to the water survey, there really wasn't anybody quite like me at the water survey at that time. There was like nobody really doing geochemistry really, except for kind of more on the chemical side. And I came from the geology side. And a couple of guys over at the State Geological Survey, Sam Pano and Keith Hackley, really kind of took me under their wings and got me involved early on in some of their projects. Very, very generous people, very wonderful scientists. And since then, we've worked on many, many projects together. They're both retired from the...
the ISGS now. Keith has gone on to a second career working at Isotech Laboratory. But I still talk with them. And just the other day, I sent them some data and some graphs saying, hey, what do you think of this? It's a little unusual. I'm not sure what to make of it. I mean, I still rely upon them to help me understand my data. And I mean, I'm a really collaborative person. And so I don't really like to work alone too much. So it's been great to have colleagues like that for the bulk of my career here. Yeah, certainly. Both great guys, sure, for sure.
Well, I think the idea of collaboration is really at the heart of this podcast and that we're trying to emphasize how important those collaborations are, both with those who are kind of close to you work-wise, as well as those who maybe do something totally different and can lend a different perspective. And so that has come out in so many of our episodes so far. Yeah, it's such a multidisciplinary field. I mean, you just can't know everything. One of the reasons when I went back to grad school that I wanted to go back was because it was just when they were trying to understand how microbiology was affecting geochemistry, the groundwater environments.
When I first went to college, I didn't think that bacteria even survived below the soil zone, basically. And I knew nothing. You know, and so that's why I went back to grad school to learn something about that. And I still don't know that much about microbiology, just a little enough to make me dangerous. But, you know, in my career, I've been working with people like economists, public health officials, researchers, you know, stuff that I know nothing about. But I know that there is a connection there that we need to help each other to understand these kind of complex and important problems. That's awesome.
I think it also just highlights the importance of ongoing research because we're always learning something new, you know, because I'm a little bit younger than both of you. And when I was, you know, growing up in school, you know, the things that you talked about, those were, they were facts. This is what we know. So, you know, there wasn't a question about it. So it's just, it's so interesting. And I think we're going to highlight some of that in our conversation with you, with your research and how we're, we're always learning things so that we can make even better decisions in the future. And I hadn't considered how young you mentioned our field is so young and it really is. And some of the people we have met, you know, Tom Prickett used to come in our office every Friday and things like that. You just can't.
you know, developed one of the first granular flow models in the world. And he's a world renowned guy in his day. And, you know, we're very fortunate in that respect. And I agree. Yeah.
So you mentioned the water survey and how, I guess, it's a great place to work. I totally agree. So we just had our 126th anniversary this year. And I guess one of the things that we wanted you to discuss, if you would, is really about how the water survey with its public health reach and water resources efforts and stuff kind of give us a tour, if you will, or information about how the water survey started, what it used to do and what it's doing today and kind of work that we do. Sure. And Steve, feel free to chip in because you know as much as I do, probably not more. But, you know, the water survey started, it was a chemist on campus at the University of Illinois named Arthur Palmer, and he was interested in waterborne diseases. I think particularly typhoid fever was a problem, especially up in the Chicago region. So this was before the rivers were reversed and Chicago was sending their sewage out into the lake and then, you know, pumping them back in for drinking water purposes. And in the summer, they always had an outbreak of diseases and sometimes fatal. You know, quite a few people, I think on some of the worst ones, hundreds of people died.
from this disease. So he was very interested in that. And I think for the first five or 10 years, the water survey, I'm not even sure it was even called that, but it was he and a lab tech and a secretary. I think that was it. And they were just kind of surveying the water quality of public waters in Illinois. It started with surface water, but then moved quickly to groundwater, since that's such an important water resource in the state. And then from there, over the next few decades, we expanded to basically the entire water cycle. We now have the state climatologist on our campus. We have the state hydrologist doing surface water work.
You mentioned Tom Prickett. We've done some fundamental work in a number of areas, one being groundwater flow models. We were some of the early developers, both here at the water study and up on campus. And yeah, tell a little story about that, actually. I don't know if you were here, Steve, but a couple of years ago, two, three years ago. So Illinois in the 60s and 70s was a real hotbed of groundwater research on campus. And a lot of the big names came through here as grad students or professors. And one of them was John Cherry. And he's very famous because anybody who took a groundwater course probably used his textbook, Alan Fries and John Cherry.
And it's still in use today. It's actually an online resource now. Anyway, he was getting a distinguished alumni award from the geology department. And he was here for a couple of days. And he wanted to come down to the water survey and talk. And so we brought him down here. We're having a discussion. And then we walked into the conference room to show him the analog model.
So for those of you who don't know about groundwater, the mathematics behind it, Darcy's law is the fundamental governing equation for groundwater flow. And it's the exact same format as Ohm's law. So electrical movement, however you want to put that, is a direct analog for groundwater flow. And so the very first models, not computer models, but physical models, were capacitors and resistors that were put together to simulate groundwater flow. And John Cherry, who is a...
well-known hydrogeologist, but a very kind of formal stayed guy. He saw this and he just lit up. And the reason was when he was here as a student in the 60s, he had helped build one of those. And so he wanted to take pictures with him and show him like group shots of all this. And his face just lit up when he saw that because he had worked really hard because that was a lot of work putting those things together. And from there on, and Tom Frickett, who you mentioned, was one of the guys who was working on that. And then very soon after that, they moved on to computer models as the computer capacity was able to handle those equations.
you know, Moore's law. Now we've got, you know, huge statewide groundwater flow models. So I think I kind of got off track there a little bit. That's all right. So, well, one thing I'll mention real quick is we, we did a story map on some of the historical stuff from the survey and we'll make sure and include that link in all the notes for this podcast. So the folks can see, you know, it's hard to envision what it looks like, but it's thousands of resistors and capacitors all hand soldered. Right. I mean, I can't imagine how many months it took just to put it together. Right. Yeah.
Yeah, it still works too. But getting back to the water story, I'll just mention a few things that have been really important to me here. It's just the wealth of data and records that we have here. One of the first things I did here was I had gone to a Geological Society of America conference. It was right after my getting out of grad school, but I'd already started working here. And I'd heard a guy doing research up in Toronto and looking at...
chloride concentrations going up because of road salt runoff. And I thought, well, I wonder if that's a problem here in Chicago because no one had actually looked at it. And I realized talking with some of our database people, we had a ton of data that I could look at. This was back in the day when you had to print everything out. But yeah, and it was going back to the 1890s. We have tens of thousands of samples that have been analyzed here. And they go into a database with some other sources of data. And we're able to use that data to look at historical and temporal trends and spatial trends and things like that. And I was just...
Very happy, actually, because that was sort of one of the things I really like to do is to dig into the data and look for relationships. That's really a lot of what geochemistry is and water quality research is looking for relationships and then trying to understand why this thing might be affecting that thing. But we have a public service lab here. Any well owner in the state can send a sample here and have it analyzed. It used to be free for many, many years. And then about 10 or 15 years ago, we had to start charging. And starting this year, we're going to have to charge even more, which is very unfortunate because I'm worried that it's going to limit the amount of data that we're getting from our lab.
And so now what it does do, though, is open up and our lab can collect samples from anywhere in the country, I believe. That's true. We'll see how that plays out, I guess. Yeah. So, yeah. So, I mean, like I said, we're doing all sorts of research. We've had many different interesting projects related to water quality and other things here at the Water Survey. One time we had the Center for the National Atmospheric Deposition Program that was looking at acid rain throughout the country and actually internationally. We've had the Midwest Climate Center for a while here.
We had people who were doing work research on tornadoes back in the 1940s and identified using radar, which is a brand new technology basically at the time. So the Water Survey has been on the cutting edge of a lot of really practical research. You know, not really so much the basic stuff. That's not really our role here. Our role here is to kind of help people solve problems related to water resources. I think that's what makes it special, honestly. Yeah, I agree. Like we have a modeling group in the groundwater section. And, you know, those folks are helping communities solve problems they have today. And also looking in the future, so to speak. And now with the accuracy of all that stuff, we're, you know, we're getting more and more sought after. Excuse me.
um because we have a capability to really help folks understand why they need to change their water supply or what they need to be concerned about with water quality all those things yeah we agree yeah it's a lot more fun to do applied research than uh basic research in my opinion but Depends on the person. Yeah, you might get some arguments on that. Yeah, maybe. And I've said before, I think doing more outreach and education now later in my career, I actually enjoy a lot more. I mean, one of the things that I think we've really made headway on the last few years, and I don't recall this really being part of our work before, is the discussion of risk. And we have done some, I think, really kind of groundbreaking communications work on communicating risk to the public. What does it mean that your aquifer is running low? I mean, what is the risk? It's a very difficult concept for people to understand. And they're like,
well you know the water is thousands of years old it's not rain that falls on the surface it's not going to get down to that aquifer what does that mean as far as the longevity of your aquifer um so the guys here the modelers have developed some really cool tools and um um you know color-coded things like that to help people understand what the risks are and what the timeframe too is. You've got a problem that's going to manifest in 20 or 30 years. You might want to start thinking about how you're going to deal with it because if you wait 20 years, that's going to be too late. Then you're going to be playing catch up and paying big bucks to solve your problem. You could have done something now, which probably will be costly, but it'll be cheaper than if you ignore the problem. Well, and you can spread it out over a much longer period. I think our job and what they've done a great job of is helping communities figure out that they actually have to do those things.
So because I know one particular community that's having a problem now in the Chicago area, I think we told them for years that they were going to have an issue with their aquifer. And they never listened. And honestly, it took a change in personnel. It did. It did. It's sad. I mean, I think part of what we've learned is we've got to repeat our message over and over again. And we've got to go to different groups. And I think we just finally hit a critical mass, a tipping point or whatever. And just everything came together. And people said, all right, we've got to make a change. And what do we need to do? And so they started moving forward, fortunately. And even so.
It's still kind of close. So one of the things that strikes me is in a previous episode, which, Walt, you didn't hear that yet, but we talked a lot about asset management. And the traditional asset management conversation is about the things that you can see. It's very rare that I've heard of the actual groundwater supply included as part of the assets. And it seems like that's going to need to be more part of the conversation, making sure that you have a supply to manage in the future. It's funny. You may have heard of Bedford Park. It's a community up in Cook County, I believe. And they've been one of the sponsors of the Chicago Cubs baseball games on the radio. And you'll hear a commercial. Bedford Park.
we have all this water, you know, they're getting water from Lake Michigan, but they're selling themselves to industry and commercial interests. Like we've got a ton of water come here and you'll have a secure source of high quality water for, for your business. Yeah. It's, it's, I never heard that before, but it's like some communities are like, you know, this is a real asset, having access really into perpetuity of really high quality water and let's use it. Let's use it to drive our economics.
You know, Steve, you probably remember back in the day when, when ethanol plants were a big deal, probably 15, 20 years ago. And oftentimes one of the last things those people would think of was water. They'd have everything designed and have the property picked out. And they were like, well, let's see, we need a few million gallons of water per day. Where are we going to get that? And they hadn't even thought about that. You know, and then they'd come to us and we're like, sorry, I don't think that property is, you're going to get it. You're going to have to pipe it in 10 miles away. And they're like, what? I know. And they're like, what? They already bought the property and they were happy because of the roads that were there. And there was obviously plenty of corn. They had to run a 10 mile pipeline, which I know cost a pretty penny.
And some end up not being built because of that. They pick out a property and there's just people need to understand where there is groundwater and when there isn't. And no one does take it. Everybody takes it for granted for sure. It almost seems like we're either in the future or a preview of the future because we've talked for so long about how so many of the economic decisions are going to be driven by the resource behind it and that water is going to be the main driver of all of it as well. And we're seeing that start to creep in. Yeah, I mean, you certainly see that out west with all the issues they have out there with droughts and lack of water and just trying to divvy up this Port Colorado River.
And I just can't handle it. And, you know, I kind of jokingly tell people that, you know, people are leaving the Midwest these days, but they'll be back, you know, because we've got water. We've got abundant water. It's clean for the most part. And we don't have to worry about it like Arizona or Nevada or those places. We also have very few natural disasters. We have maybe some tornadoes, possibly a big earthquake someday. But Steve and I are always talking about moving somewhere else. And we're like, but every other place has like hurricanes, mudslides, fires. Yeah, yeah.
Don't want to be where the fires are. People take as far as taken for granted. Even for Illinois, if somebody asked me, I'd say that we're a water excess state. We typically have plenty of water, but you can find all kinds of areas within the state where your local geology doesn't provide either safe water or water at all. Absolutely. Location, location, location, right? It's very local scale. We were at the state fair recently talking to well owners about what to take a private well class and all that stuff. And someone said, I live in St. Louis County, we got water here, blah, blah, blah. And I said, well, if you live up by Andrew, which is just a small town north of Springfield.
There's a whole group of homes where even their dug wells won't produce enough water and they have to haul every summer. And, you know, there's just tons of areas like that, but you don't hear about it because it's, you know, it's a few homes. It's, I mean, I say a few, a few dozen. And so it's understanding those things is just that important because, I mean, certainly Lake Michigan is a big resource, but even that is capped, at least legally, on what we can take out of it. But, you know, I mean, you look at Joliet, who we were kind of talking about without actually naming, switching from their deep bedrock, they had seven potential options.
They could have gone to a couple of Lake Michigan options. They could have gone to the Illinois River. They could have gone to the Deslaines River. They could have gone to the Kankakee River. You know, if Phoenix, for example, their water source goes bad, they don't have any options, really. You know, whereas Joliet, even with all the kind of mismanagement and the head in the sand type of behavior that they had for decades, they'll be okay. I mean, it's going to cost them money, but they've got, you know, a water resource. For sure, there's still water here. You're right. And even, you know, we talk a lot about, we're probably going to talk today about contamination of some of the shallow waters up there. And even that can be treated. So, yeah.
So yeah, jumping back into some of the questions we had for you, you've done a number of studies related to karst geology and contamination of groundwater in those areas. What have you learned and what advice do you have for anyone using groundwater as a water supply in those areas? And maybe start with, you know, because we have a pretty diverse audience of listeners here, just talk a little bit about what karst geology is and what the risks are because of that. Yeah, so karst geology is mainly limestone. It can also be dolomite, a few other rock types that have been dissolved. So think about caves, think about sinkholes, disappearing streams. So this is...
A geology with large conduits. So it's different from like a sand and gravel where you've got your kind of forest media. This is like a fracture flow. And it's common. I think, I can't remember now, something like 40% of them or 30 or 40% of the world gets their water from blankstone aquifers. And many of them are carved aquifers. So the Midwest has a lot of cars. So everyone probably knows about Mammoth Cave, the largest cave system in the world. Missouri, Wisconsin, Indiana, they all have lots and lots of caves and single areas. Illinois, not quite so much, but along the Western border, we do have some areas, especially south of St. Louis.
And so if you're living in a karst area and you have your own well, you need to keep on top of that because karst aquifers are easily contaminated. And the reason is because of these large conduits. So water falling at the surface and picking up contaminants or other dissolved materials is going to go directly into the subsurface. doesn't kind of pass through that soil zone, the unsaturated zone, slowly. It moves very rapidly. And so what you're doing at the surface can end up in the groundwater really quickly. And like during a heavy storm, you can just see water raging through caves and conduits as it's moving rapidly. I mean, it almost acts like storm sewers. And actually some of the modeling kind of uses storm sewer modeling, you know, is kind of the basis for modeling it. So we have some karst and mainly, like I said, along the western edge up in the southwest and the northwest parts of the state for the most part.
And as I mentioned to Sam Payne and Keith Hackley earlier, and that's one of the projects that they got me involved with. So we had, as part of those projects, sampled a lot of wells and springs. So these carcet areas oftentimes have a number of natural springs. And so we sampled them and we found a lot of contamination. You name it, nitrate, bacteria, pesticides. Some of our later work looked at PPCPs, which are pharmaceuticals and personal care products. We were one of the first...
groups to show microplastics in groundwater, and it was in some car systems in Illinois. That's been a really highly cited publication that came out a couple years ago. So, yeah, so got to beware if you're living in a carousel area about drinking water. So you want to keep, especially after major rain events, that's oftentimes when these things, these operas get contaminated. So I would, you know, periodically have your water tested. Probably only once a year. Yeah, yeah. But some of the, and the older your well is, the probably more vulnerable it is, because some of the practices weren't so,
protected it back in the old days. So the farther that you're cased down into the rock, the better. Like in the old days, sometimes they would just case down to the top of the rock and then just have an open borehole below that. And those wells are almost always contaminated. So the code has changed over the years.
The casing goes about much deeper into the aquifer. But they always kind of laugh when I see an ad for like Jack Daniels talking about their pure spring water. You do not want to drink that water. I'm sure the distilling process kills those bacteria. But yeah, you can find all sorts of E. coli and enteric bacteria and probably protozoans and things like that in springs. So I know one of the things we've been involved in over the years is in some of these areas like Pike County, they put in rural water districts just because, you know, the health department there will tell you that 80 or 90 percent of all the wells that they do samples on are contaminated.
And we actually write letters of support for those groups when they try to put in a rural water district and looking for federal dollars. And the case is just that. It's public health protection because there's really no way for a private well-owned. They're well-safe. It's the aquifer that's contaminated, not their well. Yeah, actually, we worked out in Monroe County, which is south of St. Louis, quite a bit. And we went back a few years, not too long ago, to look for some more wells. We wanted to resample some of those wells because we're looking for, like, you know, PPCPs and things like that. And we actually had a difficult time finding those to resample those. And the reason was they had gone on.
kind of raw water, which is good. It was a good outcome for the residents. It's not so good for us, kind of cramped our research style. You know, I tell people that, you know, you don't really want to talk to groundwater geochemists too much because we really like catastrophes. You know, we really like when bad news is out there. That makes our job interesting. You know, if we find, we get a sample and the results are like, oh, waterfall is really nice. You know, no problem here. That's boring. You know, that doesn't interest us. We're looking for the high levels of arsenic or nitrate or whatever. That's what gets us going. Probably the better way to say that is we're looking to solve those problems. Well, of course, that's what I meant to say. Oh my.
So I know you've done a ton of sampling in your career, all kinds of wells, all kinds of aquifers. And so one of the things that I know you preach and what we try to do when we collect data is both collect water at an outside spigot or for a walk for quality and at the kitchen tap, which would be more drinking water quality. So we were hoping you would talk about that a little bit and the differences and why it's important to understand both. Yeah, so that's something that I kind of learned through my career. So as a researcher, we're generally looking for the aquifer quality. So we want to purge that well. We don't want water that's been sitting in that well that chemistry may have changed because it's sitting in that well. So that's kind of been our goal for most of our sampling. But that's not necessarily what people are drinking. They're drinking water that's passed through their plumbing system and might have been sitting in their well. So you think about what a well is. A well is a hole connecting the surface to the aquifer. And you may be going through a couple hundred feet of...
till or low permeability units that was protecting that aquifer. Now you punched a hole in it. And that's a very easy way to get contaminants or water down through that hole unless it's properly constructed and sealed and all that stuff. And so it's important to, so there's not a whole lot of homeowner or well owner can do about the aquifer quality. That's just kind of, that's a regional thing usually. And what, how they, what they're doing doesn't really, they can't really change that.
But you can protect what's going directly into your well if it's becoming a conduit for contamination. So, you know, if you're, especially if you have an old well, you probably want to get the driller or plumber out there to do some kind of assessment, making sure that you've got it properly grouted. There's no cracks in the casing or things like that so that you make a direct connection from the surface. And then if you have a really old well, like, you know, Steve, you and I looked at some old, pretty nasty wells. I remember one of my first field days when I came to the water show, I went out with Ken Hlinka to an old...
dug an old brick line dug well and we had to fish a dead frog out of there and probably bloated to twice its size and and the woman was like yeah i thought that water tasted funny you know like if you got one of those wells yeah you want a new well you can't keep a well like that clean you know it's just it's just a connection to the surface and whenever hops in there or flows in there that's going down and you're drinking that water so But I guess we'll talk about lead later. But I mean, that's the other thing. Once you get into the plumbing system, that can also be a source of contamination. Let's go ahead and jump into that then. So we can go back to some of the other topics, I think, since we're on lead. Can you talk a little bit about, you know, what homeowners need to think about? And then maybe a little bit about the work that you've been doing on it. Yeah. So if you have an old home and it's when we just old means like pre-1986. So not really that old, but if you have an old home, there's a very high likelihood that you have lead in your plumbing.
if you have not replaced it in years. And that is where the lead is coming from. So lead as a metal is very insoluble. And so it's very unusual to find it actually in the aquifer. It's almost always in the solid phase. It doesn't get into the water. But if the water has corrosive, if it's corrosive, it can dissolve the lead and copper that are in the plumbing system. And that's where all the problems with Flint, Michigan came from because they switched water sources and the water that they...
started dissolving, not just before they got the lead, it was dissolving the scale that was protecting the lead pipes from the water. Yeah, I mean, lead pipes were required in Illinois. I guess it was part of the plumbing code. And by some counts, we have more lead service lines than any other state in the country. So we got interested. So when Flint came along, you know, people...
That very understandably freaked out and started looking at, well, what are these sources of lead and what can we do about it? Let's even try to identify how much we've gotten. But they were only looking at community water systems, municipal systems. And that's what the laws, the regulations are written for. They're written for public water supplies. Anybody who owns a private well, they're on their own when it comes to water quality. There's no really rules. Once they'll pass that initial nitrate coliform test, no one's going to check their water quality. It's totally up to you. So our question was, well...
What about private wells? Homes with private wells, do they have a lead problem? We didn't know. We saw there was some research from a few other states. Virginia was one, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, I think Wisconsin maybe, that suggested, yeah, it could be a problem. We had very different geology from, say, Virginia, which had a much more acidic groundwater than we did. So we thought, well, we may have some problems, but it's probably not going to be near what Virginia has because our water is much more alkaline in general. But one of the questions I had had was, and I think we'll talk about this later, is up in the northeast, we were seeing increasing chloride levels to the road salt runoff.
A chloride is a major corrosive. And so my thought was, well, we're making more corrosive water up there. Is that going to affect lead in people's homes? So we got some funding from Illinois State, Illinois Sustainable Technology Center. And I was working with some public health researchers from Northern Illinois University. That person is not the University of Illinois. And University of Illinois in Chicago, which is the kind of main public health school in the state. And we were working with three counties, Jackson County down in the south where Carbondale is.
Peoria County is kind of central, and Kane County up in the west of Chicago, kind of a more urban county. So basically, the initial pilot studies we called was just to find out, do we have an issue? Is this something that we need to alert homeowners about? And the answer turned out to be yes. We did find lead in almost half the samples. We collected 151 samples. These are actually collected by the homeowners themselves because the water has to sit stagnant a minimum of six hours in the pipe. So we couldn't really design a sampling program to do that ourselves.
But almost half of what we call the first straw, when you open that spigot first thing in the morning and you collect that first liter of water, that's what we were measuring, as well as a more flush sample. And almost half of those samples had some lead in it. And there is a standard for lead. It's in the process being changed. It's just like, I'm not even sure what they call it, a health advisory or an alert reference level. It's not a health-based value. No, not health. And it's because...
As anyone, any health researcher or professional, there is no safe level of lead in water. And so detecting lead even at low concentration is a problem. And so that action level is 15 parts per billion. We found, I think about 3% were above that. The highest level we found was 76.
micrograms per liter. So, you know, it's at five times the standard or the action level. So now we've got some more funding for our follow-on study. This is funding from Housing and Urban Development. And we're going to continue with a couple other counties, Champaign and Whiteside. And then in the original counties, we're going to go back to those that had lead issues. And we're going to give them a plumbing assessment and a well assessment to determine what might be sources of lead in their system. And then we're going to kind of randomize them and give them one of four options for actually treating the water. One will be complete plumbing.
removal, because that's the only way to guarantee that you won't have any lead coming into your system if you replace all the pipes and fittings that might have lead in them. Second will be setting up a reverse osmosis system underneath the sink, so kind of a point of use. And then a filter, a filter that's an ANSI certified filter designed to remove lead. And then the fourth would be kind of our control, which would be we would give them like a Brita filter, so they wouldn't have to drink the water out of the tap, but it's not really designed to remove lead, although they seem to be pretty effective in doing that. And then we would go back in a year and...
reassess, you know, pick some more samples, see how they're doing, because they do have to maintain those systems, replace the filters, whatever. What type of communication did you do to the homeowners that had elevated levels throughout the first phase of the project? So we sent them a letter. We said everybody participated in the study letter with the results of the study. So not only do we give them the lead results, but we also measured the corrosivity of the water because that was part of the research and basically told them.
There's no safe levels of let. You may want to contact your health department if you have concerns. So I'm not a health professional. I didn't want anybody calling me with questions about health issues. I would be happy to talk to them about chemistry or plumbing or whatever from the physical chemical side of things. And then we had one of the health professionals, one of the public health researchers had their name on the list. But we didn't get any calls. Nobody actually contacted us. And I don't know if that's a problem on our end or a problem on the homeowner's end. And we never really quite figured out.
why that, why we didn't get a bigger response from people who had a lot of lead in their system. Like I would expect them to call them, what can I do about it? You know, but nobody actually called us. So then for those folks, they're still going to participate though. You've talked to them about other. So that part of the project is just starting. So that's all done through the health department. They do the recruiting and the conversations with the homeowners. And we wanted that local input and control because we didn't want someone coming in from Chicago to Jackson County saying, yeah.
Give us your water. So what's most interesting about this is, you know, in the work that Jennifer and I do with private wellness all over, you know, with your private well class, one of the biggest barriers for people testing is they're afraid of what they'll find because they don't have the money for treatment. And we've discussed with a number of different people over the years about, you know, that's the big problem is encouraging to test is only part of the story. You really need to be able to offer them options for treatment. And so, yeah, this is a refreshing approach in a way, just because you are actually trying to solve their problems. You got a grant to do it.
And the other thing, and you know this well, Steve, is that some people don't want to know because they might be selling their property. And they have to release that information if they know it. If they don't know it, they don't have to because there's no regulation saying you've got to do a water quality sample before you transfer property in this state, at least. Yeah, and that's an Illinois thing. But you do have to acknowledge if you know any problems. Right. And so I remember you telling me a story of a guy.
Saying, yeah, you can take a sample and do a test on it, but don't send me the results. I don't want to know. I'm about to sell my house. And he wanted to be honest on the form because it's really binding. Exactly. I thought that was the oddest thing. But, you know, they do. Water quality and your well have big implications for home value or sellability. And, you know, I think some of the states that have made all that data available, I think that's where we all need to head eventually because we need to know if it's there and take care of it. So do you feel like the real estate industry is kind of coming around on that as well as far as?
making, uh, requiring that kind of information. I feel like I've heard more and more about this kind of a requirement to sell the property. And well, there's, there's five States that require you to, um, have a test done when you sell a property with a well now, and there wasn't only one for a while, New Jersey. Um, so now I believe there's five. And, um, so there, the real estate market certainly has had to fess up or at least get involved in, and make that part of their planning. Um, but in a lot of other areas, that's not the case. And so, you know, we actually do several webinars, um, once a year or so for realtors and we try to.
emphasize why it's whether you're the buyer or the seller, it's important to get a test first and understand what the water quality is and actually remediate it if you need to, because it protects both sides. And it's like any other profession. You have good apples and bad apples, and some people just want to get their house sold. And what we tell well owners is buyer beware. If, you know, we've had people call us and say, well, if I don't make an offer today, we're going to lose this house. I'm like, well, you have to decide if you want to take the chance that you're going to be adding treatment or having to spend money on.
uh, continual maintenance or whatever, if you haven't tested the water and know that it's safe, or you may buy a bottle of water, which is, you know, a 2000% markup on what your water costs or whatever. And it's, so it's, it's, I think you're right. Um, we certainly see some realtors who, um, have done some, uh, went leaps and bounds over what they need to, um, one actually in Colorado. I highlight them sometimes because they've got a website full of information about private wells, but it's certainly not the entire industry. Although I think most of them are conscientious. That's good to hear. Yeah.
So maybe kind of like wrapping up from all of your work, you mentioned so many different topics that you studied, arsenic, nitrate, road salt, pharmaceuticals, microplastics, you know, are there any kind of bigger picture take-home messages for both these natural and man-made contaminants? Yeah, big question. You know, one of the things I feel like I learned in this kind of, a lot of this came out of the arsenic work is how, and I don't know how to actually put this, but how poorly mixed groundwater can be. So we have a, you know. Groundwater is a difficult thing to study because it's below ground. You know, it's not easily accessed. If you're studying a river, you can, you know, you can take a boat out or you can walk out there and do whatever you want. But with groundwater, you got to put a hole in the ground or use someone else's hole. And it's expensive. And it's a three-dimensional issue, too. So an aquifer could be 100, 200 feet thick. And the water quality in the top of the aquifer could be totally different from the quality in the lower aquifer. And this was kind of brought home to me with our arsenic work.
You know, we had originally gotten some data from Paswell County showing a lot of arsenic hits in their area. And this was this was a period where the arsenic standard was being changed from 50 to 10. So it's going to make a big difference on treatment. A lot of municipal supplies. But we did we did a ton of sampling. And throughout the for those of you from Illinois, the Muhammad Aquifer system, which is a major it's a major water source through central Illinois. And it's a sand gravel aquifer. So.
But we would find arsenic in a well and then a mile away and another home, there'd be no arsenic. You know, it was just kind of typical to find this variability, this heterogeneity. And the research we did, along with some other people, we worked with some people at the university as part of this, indicated that it was the geochemistry that was really controlling the arsenic. And it was, we kind of, it came down for the samples we were taking that the organic carbon seemed to be a really key variable, but it was an impossible thing to predict. You know, one of the goals when we first started that research was, Well, we'll find out where the arsenic is. We'll tell the drillers, you know, in this area, drill to this depth or this area, drill to that depth. And we couldn't do that. It was just, it was the geology. I once heard some of the geologists say, Illinois has the second most complicated geology in the country after Michigan. And it's, I don't know if that's true or not, but we have, you know, the glaciers came over here several times back and forth and just chewed up things and deposited all sorts of, you know, heterogeneous deposits. And it's very difficult to make generalizations about.
about all these things. So I think I've learned, I felt that more and more with the sampling I've done since then as well, is that just because you have a well in an area, it doesn't mean you know what the water quality is for that aquifer. You know that point and you can make a few, you can surmise a few things from that, but you really know, you got a sample, you got a sample where you're really interested in. Well, Muhammad's a great example of that because, you know, you mentioned Tazewell County and And we did that study looking, trying to see how variable it really was, Tom Holm. We found two real subdivisions where all the homes were within, you know, a 40-acre block, 22 homes, I think, in one of them. And we saw more than an order of magnitude of difference. Sometimes the wells were less than 50 feet away from each other, 100 feet away from each other. So it's just, you know, it's the same thing, not just for water quality, for the actual flow of water in the aquifer. It really varies in the aquifer or in the aquifers if you have multiple aquifers. So, I mean, this kind of was brought home to me once I was driving. This is when I was in graduate school. I was driving back.
and forth from home in Kentucky and Virginia, go through West Virginia, and you'd see these road cuts. And in the wintertime, you'd see the water would be coming out. You can't really see it so much in the warm weather. But when it's cold out, that water freezes as soon as it hits the air. But it was very discreet. It wasn't just to cover a wall of ice where this aquifer was. It was just patches here and there. So the water was being focused into these narrow channels, basically. And so that has profound effects on the water quality as well, how fast the water is moving through a unit, what kind of minerals and other solids it's encountering. So it's a very complex system.
you know, trying to say that, you know, what the water quality of the area is, you know, you can make some general statements, but as far as like, what's, what am I going to find in my well? So, well, you may find a little nitrate, you may find a little arsenic, but I don't know until you drill that well and pull a sample. It does tell us though, that like for Tesla County, if I run into someone from Tesla County, I can say, well, you know, we, we know there's a lot of arsenic there in your well, but you should sample for it. So, yeah. And as far as, um, what I guess we call human contamination or anthropogenic contamination. My motto is always announce that prevention is worth a pound of care because once groundwater is contaminated, it's really difficult to clean it up. And if you let it go, it just takes forever to clean itself out. So anything you can do to prevent contamination from occurring, you're going to save in the long run, even if it seems like an expensive or difficult thing to protect that recharge zone. You really should do it because you're going to pay on the other end if you don't. I mean, you know, we talked a little bit about road salt up in Northeast Illinois, and that's just getting into our shallow groundwater and surface water resources because it's so soluble.
Even if we stopped today, we have not seen peak concentration yet because that water is moving so slowly, relatively slowly. I mean, it's pretty fast for groundwater. But the bulk of it has not gone through the system yet. So it's going to take a while to kind of heal itself, if you want to put it that way. So you mentioned earlier, you know, adding chlorides increases the corrosivity of the water and stuff. So in Kane County, were those shallower wells? And is that why you were seeing more lead, do you think?
So it was interesting. In the end, the three counties had almost identical results as far as the percentage of wells that had lead in them. And also corrosivity, interestingly enough. So the main corrosivity calculation we're using was the Larson's Cold Index, which was also coincidentally invented at the water survey. There are several different equations you can use. None of them are ideal, but this was the one that seemed to work the best for us. But it's like chloride and sulfate on the top and alkalinity on the bottom.
And King County did have a lot of chloride in it, but they also had very high alkalinity values. So that decreases the corrosivity from the Larson's Gold Index and didn't have much sulfate either. Whereas down in Jackson County, no chloride, but they had kind of low alkalinity and they also had some elevated sulfate in some areas. So it's a complex thing. It didn't turn out to be as straightforward as I was kind of thinking it might be. What I think I could say is that the corrosivity of water in King County is going up. So, but to not compare that to Peoria or Jackson County, but just that if you're adding chloride to your system.
You may end up causing the water to be more corrosive and may have problems down the road because of that. Yeah, and a lot of people just consider pH. And pH is important. And that was an interesting thing we found out in Jackson County. So as part of that project, we also went out to some of the wells that had high lead levels and took a sample ourselves from the well because we wanted to make sure that the lead was coming just from the house. And so in almost all the samples we collected, there was like the highest was in the first draw and the medium amount in the seventh liters was our flush sample. And then nothing was found in the well, which is kind of what we expected. Except in Jackson County, there were three or four wells that had a little bit of lead in the well water, but they also had pHs of like five and a half, five and eight.
Really, really acidic water. I've never seen that acidic water in Illinois groundwater before. And it's a karst area. And what happened, it had been a wet spring. And the water had just, it was basically rainwater, which has a pH of, I don't know what it is down there, but around five probably. And so it didn't really have time to buffer. And the water went right into those wells with that low pH. And so I think it was actually dissolving some components inside the well itself.
i'm sure not much but it was enough to you know keep it up yeah well you see you know um the connections on those pipes or they couldn't be galvanized pipe for the drop pipe right right if it's an older well yeah that has potential to have some lead right because i know that's in virginia that's where they see um they've got 600 foot wells all galvanized pipe and so they see a lot of uh lead coming from the well itself yeah i guess you don't know until you open that well up right take a look you have to know the construction material yeah so how did they do you know did they actually open up wells or did they just have it from their records you know i don't know for sure um yeah because we you know we did a wet lead webinar last week it was in 2018 we had kelsey piper right and uh she did all that work and um talked about galvanized drop pipe so um either where they open them up yeah we've had that conversation about we don't really want to open up the well you know you need to disinfect them if you disinfect yeah kind of a lot of work yeah yeah We don't really have the funding to disinfect all these wells, but I don't know. Awesome. Yeah. Well, thank you, Walt. Are you on social media in any professional capacity, including LinkedIn or something like that? Or can we link to the water survey social media accounts? Better go with the water survey. All right. You aren't the only one. Let's go. Yeah, sorry. No, no, it's all good. We just wanted to give people a chance to reach out through those mediums if you were on there. So they can always find you at the water survey. I am on LinkedIn, but I surely don't do anything on it.
I get, what do you call them? Little reminders that someone wanted me to be part of their network or something. Just did one with Gary Clark today, actually. Gary's still active. That's awesome. He's been a big supporter of the work we've done over the years, that's for sure. Yeah, I actually want to have him in.
Sometimes when we're all able to regather together to do his water law, because I think, I don't think any of the new guys, new people have heard it yet. Oh, no, sure. So, and Gary Clark, he's worked for IDNR in the Office of Water Resources, and he is a water law expert for Illinois, for sure. Yeah, it's kind of sad that he's been retired that long, and he's still the expert. No one else, I would know who to ask. No, right? Yeah, he's been retired probably at least 15 years, I bet. I think that's right, yeah. So.
Well, thanks. It's good to talk about these things. I learned something about your lead project today. I didn't know. Yeah, I'm interested to find out what happens with the treatment choices and which ones, especially the long term, which one was maybe the most sustainable and protective for the homeowners. Are you going to talk about costs there too? Because obviously to replace someone's entire plumbing system is... Yeah, no, that's part of the grant. The homeowner doesn't pay anything. No, right. But I just, I mean, hopefully they'll be shown what it's cost. You know, EPA did something similar with the arsenic demonstration program. They replaced entire treatment systems on some small community water supplies.
And then they ran them for a year, all free to the utility. But they kept track of what it costs, how much time, what experience the operator needed, all those things. And it was really some of the most valuable information. And so in the end, having, you know, on average, the, I don't know how many houses you're going to replace the plumbing on, but to know what that costs versus what it costs for the RO and if you had any problems with people maintaining it and how protective it was, would be really valuable. Yeah. All right. Well, thanks again. You're welcome. Yeah, that's good. Thank you. All right. Take care. Bye-bye.
Tab Talk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.