I think it's about personalizing the issue and proving that it actually can make a difference because it's such an inherently invisible risk so many people aren't aware. So I think the family health frame is something that really kind of leaps out there. You have to show people the ramifications of an action and actually demonstrate how well stewardship can make a difference. So I think this makes risk communication and any further regulation look less like a kind of box-sticking exercise and more like something that actually can make a difference. You're listening to TAP Talk, the drinking water in rural America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health. And together, we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to episode 11. In this episode, we're chatting with PhD student Simon Mooney, who has explored important questions about environmental health communication efforts and risk perception in his research. Before we jump into the interview, we've got a TAP Talk tidbit to share. Each week, we're answering one of the most common questions we receive about groundwater and wells.
Steve, do you recommend routine shot chlorination of a well? You know, this is probably the most asked question we have through our private well class is about shot chlorinating or disinfecting a well. And we get questions all the time, like, should I pour bleach down my well once a month? Or, you know, a contractor told me just to pour a cup of bleach every month down my well and it'd be fine. All of those are really bad ideas. You should only disinfect your well or shot chlorinate it when you sample first and you found that there's actually coliform or E. coli or you have an issue. You don't need chlorine if your well is properly constructed and there's no bacteria in it.
There's no reason to actually add it. You should only use it when you need to. One of the reasons is that chlorine is an oxidant. So especially pouring straight 5% bleach like Clorox bleach is too concentrated and it will leach metals from not only if it's a bedrock well from the bedrock itself, but also from the piping or the pump material, brass fittings, those sorts of things will leach metals. And so it's really not recommended. And we see a ton of bad advice out there on disinfecting wells that just recommend doing those things. So the proper thing to do is to test your well once a year for coliform and nitrate.
Those are used to indicate a pathway into your well. So if you have either of those, either have coliform or nitrate at a higher than background level, it means there's probably a shallow pathway into your well, whether that be that your well is actually shallow and it's in the ground or whether it's somehow connected to things like your septic or a feedlot. In those cases, then you would go ahead and try to shock chlorinate it and hopefully get rid of it. Sometimes we see... Other problems like a shallow well that's actually, you know, especially in glacial geology, you can have a very thin seam of sand with all the more finer material, the clay and silt that runs throughout your entire property. It might only be three or four inches thick, but it's the pathway for water to move all throughout the area. And if your well intersects that, it could be that it's actually coming from your septic on the other side of your home, even if it's more than 100 feet away. And in those cases, it's kind of a continuous source or the same thing with a feedlot or if you have livestock. And when you have that situation, you can shock chlorinate your well, but within very little time, it'll probably be contaminated again.
And you would need to consider permanent disinfection, whether that be a chlorinator or UV, some solution to just assume you're going to have contaminated water and you have to treat it before it's actually drinkable. The other option would be to drill a different well, which is a pretty expensive proposition. There's some other issues too. You may shock chlorinate your well and it might still come back positive, which if you follow the recommendations, the one we use is from Minnesota Department of Health. It's on our webpage. But I was also just talking to a colleague and Ohio has a really good one too, which I haven't investigated yet.
But if you disinfect your system the correct way, then it should get rid of any bacteria that's in your system. That includes your premise plumbing and all your faucets, your shower, toilets, all that stuff. So if it comes back, then it's likely a source to the well. And so you need to consider a permanent treatment solution. One other caveat is it may take several tries. Sometimes biofilms have been allowed to build up either in the well or in any part of your piping. When you chlorinate it the first time, it may kind of kill off a layer, but not all of it. You might have to do it several times. And I'd always recommend that before you go to any continuous solution.
There's other caveats too that you should be aware of. And one is that the pH of your water matters. If the pH is above eight, chlorine is much less effective and you may need to consider an alternate disinfectant because it's not, it may take, you know, especially if it's well above eight, it would just will not, it takes a lot more of it to try to kill any bacteria. It's just not effective. And so understanding those things are important when, especially if you disinfect your well or shot chlorinated and it doesn't work, so to speak. Once you've done a shot chlorination event, you need to, after you cleaned out your lines from all the chlorinated water, you do need to collect another water sample and get it tested.
before you start drinking the water. I boil it until then to make sure that you've actually been successful. Thanks, Steve. And now our conversation with Simon Mooney. We're glad to have Simon Mooney with us, who is a PhD student in Dublin, Ireland, who's done a boatload, honestly, of private well-related research in Ireland and internationally, basically. And so glad to have you today. And first thing to start off, tell us about your PhD work and what's your role in work you're doing.
Well, first of all, thank you for having me, Jennifer and Steve. It's an absolute pleasure to join you. So yes, my name is Sanna Mooney. I'm based in Technological University, Dublin, which is smack bang in the city centre. And I suppose to put it in a nutshell, I might expand outwards gradually, but really the objective of my research is to develop a modular evidence-based risk communication framework that targets private well owners. These are people often uniquely vulnerable to private groundwater contamination or water contamination in general rather. In Ireland, people in rural areas are actually four to five times more likely to contract a gastrointestinal illness via water. So there's quite a massive urban rural inequality there.
And in terms of, I guess, situating the work, the project is really trying to build on this emerging concept of socio-hydrogeology that was introduced by a quite brilliant hydrogeologist called Viviana Ray, who's currently based in Italy. So this really kind of conceives of the kind of dynamic interactions and feedbacks that occur between social and hydrogeological systems. And given the fact that private wells are so plentiful in the world, what we really have now is this kind of coupled socio-ecological system on both the macro level and the micro level. And I suppose if you sort of try to apply this paradigm, ideally, you would maybe have the kind of... bottom-up style risk mitigation whereby when it comes to modeling where it comes to groundwater mitigation and monitor contamination mitigation and modeling you try and involve local people however this is often very difficult due to monetary constraints and the fact that many supplies aren't actually inventory or indeed regulated so this makes government control very difficult so it's really all about behavior promotion that is really what local government and indeed national government actually can do to kind of solve the issue so this kind of really highlights the importance of risk communication but unfortunately this is kind of a set with its own
issues because you many diffuse stakeholders for instance i can speak to ireland that there's actually no real representative body for well drillers we have the we have the irish institution of them of audiology the igi but there isn't an awful lot there in terms of coordination well drillers you also have the issue of limited financial resources which also makes it difficult i think there have been numerous studies including my own that suggest there isn't really that expertise at local government level when it comes to communication i think it's been flagged in the us as well that it tends to not be an awful lot of draining so even from the communication side there's certainly barriers Well, so I guess this is also something I want to do in my research is kind of hone in on these issues that be stymied, successful risk communication. And there are also a whole host of issues that prevent householders from adequately maintaining the well. And maybe I might approach some of those a little later. So you mentioned drillers, even where they have associations and have continuing education and all those things, you know, in the States, we still see a lot of issues where well drillers, their continuing education doesn't necessarily get to those issues. And so we still see problems with information that's being given to well owners from drillers and all those things. So I certainly,
understand your problem. We still have a lot of that here. I mean, we do the Institute of Geologists of Ireland, the IGI, and they do have well drilling guidelines. And I guess the trouble is if you're a homeowner and you wish to consult with a well driller or contractor who will adhere to those guidelines, it's going to set you back an extra $2,000 or $3,000. So maybe your average rural householder who doesn't feel so inclined to take out that money might just go for the cheaper option and hire maybe a well driller who isn't so inclined to abide by those guidelines. Yeah, that's not allowed in most states here. So, all right, great. Before we get into kind of some more of the topics related to your work, can you tell us why research has a passion for you? Because it sounds like you're very excited about your work and we like to kind of peel back the layers of our guests.
Sure, sure. Well, I suppose it kind of stems back to roughly early 2015. I undertook a master's in planning in University College Dublin. That's another university just across the river, Liffey, which kind of separates north and south Dublin. And during that particular MA, I undertook a module looking at environmental issues. So it was a series of case studies around Ireland about things like water contamination, things about air pollution, etc, etc. And the private groundwater contamination issue just happened to be one of those case studies. And I found it quite fascinating.
It immediately became clear to me that it was quite a niche issue. It wasn't really receiving much traction in the media, despite the fact that it affected roughly really about a third of the population, if you think about it, because that is essentially rural Ireland. It's about 1.7, 1.8 million people. Also, there's a bit of family history there, too. I grew up in the suburbs, but my father and sister actually grew up in the Dublin main foothills, and they grew up right beside a field. And my father and aunt had terrible gastrointestinal illnesses as children. And when my father was roughly 14, my grandparents actually did an inspection of the garden and went outside.
to the fence just with the field right opposite the property. And they noticed a stream of effluent leading directly towards the well. And they put two and two together and realized there's a problem here. Oddly enough, there's also a bit of family history there as well. And I think it's really an issue that speaks to several things. I think it speaks to rural isolation, which is also quite an issue in Ireland. There's an awful lot of restructuring. There's maybe, if I could say, a small degree of bitterness as well. There's an awful lot of outward kind of rural migration into the more kind of rural areas.
So there's some cutbacks and things like police stations, things like services. I think also local government in Ireland. We don't really go beneath the county level. I mean, I know in the U.S. things like extension programs, for instance, where my universities can maybe partner with local institutions. I don't really think we have that here in Ireland. So I think it's a fascinating issue. And if I can maybe say one last thing, and this kind of goes into a whole other area of domestic waste water treatment system. But Ireland is a developed country.
But our current rates of virotoxigenic E. coli, that's, of course, the pathogenic strain of VTEC that leads to liver failure, kidney failure, obviously for old people and young, it's a pretty significant issue. Our current rates of VTEC are about eight times the EU average, which is pretty awful in a country that usually kind of prides itself on being very eco-conscious and very green. So I think right there, that's another thing that makes you kind of take a step back and realize that there's quite a big need for improvement when it comes to communication. So before we get into any more details, what's one personal fun fact about you? We've asked everyone this. We've got a lot of variety of answers totally off the wall. And so let's tell us something that's a fun fact about you. Oh, my goodness. You kind of caught me off guard. I don't know.
Well, I have an uncle who's a bit weird one. I have an uncle who's very much into genealogy, and he actually managed to trace my ancestry back to, I guess, the illegitimate offspring of the French aristocracy. And I guess there's also a little bit of friction in that I'm also descended from Cromwellian ancestry. He was one of the British settlers who came over to Ireland and essentially kind of kick-started them. So essentially the colonization process. So I guess in a way I'm a bit of a muck. So I guess I'm interesting enough about that. Aren't we all? I mean, that's for sure. Jennifer's Swedish, and we actually went to Sweden, did a bunch of genealogy work a few, two years ago, so last year. Interesting stuff. Not to belabor the point too much, but I have a big interest in American geography, and I guess also the spread of the populations over the last few centuries. And I do know, I think the over Midwest, there were a large number of Scandinavian settlers, I think, in places like Minnesota especially. Michigan, Illinois, yeah, Chicago, yeah. It's really fascinating.
So we also always ask our guests about their water hero. So somebody who's influenced you in your career and your path and really made a mark. Maybe I'd mention, could I mention my PhD supervisor if that's okay? Yeah, I think Paul Hines is a fantastic place to start. I mentioned the planning MA that I did in 2015 where I really became involved in this issue. The summer of that year, I did an internship in Antasca, which is basically an Irish NGO that advises on planning applications where built heritage and environmental heritage are potentially in jeopardy. And during the course of this research, I actually was looking into the private well issue and also the septic tank issue because it's the number one point source contributor when it comes to private well contamination.
And in 2013, because the EC, the European Commission, knocked on our doors for not regulating, and septic tanks in rural Ireland were hit with a hefty fine, and the country basically had to initiate a national inspection plan for septic tanks in the country, and they had to introduce a register. And as this was implemented, a before and after survey was completed, just to measure the progress of the plan, to see if there was any uptake in terms of engagement, in terms of increased actions on behalf of well owners. And my present supervisor actually put together those particular surveys, and the post one happened to be unavailable. So I contacted him about it. I said he'd be able to hand over the findings briefly for the purpose of research. And we kind of talked for a bit. And essentially, he's now my PhD supervisor. And he's done an awful lot of work in terms of quantifying the risk when it comes to microbial groundwork contamination in Ireland. Him and a few other hydrologists that came before, like Lawrence Hill, they've been absolutely instrumental in bringing this issue forth. And I think were it not for this work, we wouldn't quite be aware of the risks. And maybe the need for communication wouldn't really be as great as well. And I think there are countless other people as well who've done fantastic work over the years, particularly in Bangladesh. I think we all know about the issues of arsenic, which is, again, something I've come across in my work as well.
I feel like he's actually a very good place to start. Great, great. Yeah, I've seen a lot of his work. All right. So, you know, this is for the private well class program and our water operator program here in the States. So one of the things, one of the reasons why we wanted to have you on was just to talk about the differences in private wells and really private well issues in Ireland versus in the U.S. and your perspective on those things. And so, yeah.
Yeah, I mean, in terms of differences, I mean, we'd be predominantly drill wells, first of all, which is relatively common. But I think there are quite a few similarities as well. I think we have a very similar reliance to the US when it comes to private wells. I think in Ireland, you're talking about roughly 16% of the population. I think it's relatively similar in the US. Would that be correct? Yeah, some of the estimates are lower than that, but it's probably between 15% and 20%.
I think maybe potential other, I mean, I guess you can kind of split the private water sector, if you like, when it comes to unregulated supplies. Individual domestic household wells, then you also have community-run schemes. So these would be referred to as private group water schemes. So these are community-run schemes. And if it serves less than 50 people, then it qualifies as an unregulated supply.
So, yeah, I don't know if America has something similar. I'm sure there kind of is. But, you know, essentially you would potentially 47, 48, 49 people availing of this. But maybe you'll have only one or two households that actually undertake that maintenance. Now, they might do their due diligence. There might be routine monitoring, routine checks. But I think it's interesting that you, you know, potentially a few dozen other families who might not necessarily have that. And that's actually something that cropped up in one of my survey findings is that when it came to surveying people who had a household well and comparing to those who actually availed the community scheme, it was actually people at the household level that tended to know a little bit more when it came to well maintenance history, contamination hazards, the actual structure, age and depth of the well.
So I think that's something relatively interesting to look at in Ireland. And there's also a professional organization called the National Federation of Reporters Games that does an awful lot of work in encouraging these games to undertake routine monitoring. I know they also have national conferences, which is 3D positive. I think there's also some top-down funding from governments, which is good. But yeah, I don't know if America has something similar. I'd actually be fascinated to hear briefly.
in terms of community-owned schemes where it's involving... Yeah, it's based on 15 households or 25 persons. So it's a much lower threshold for being a regulated entity. And then they have to meet the requirements of the Safe Drinking Water Act. But we also see things like developers building rural subdivisions where they'll put in one well every five to eight homes just so they don't have to meet the requirements of the Safe Drinking Water Act. And I get what you're saying about the folks who live in a scheme with, say, 30 or 40 people.
that only a few people are interested, and the others all assume that somebody else is going to take care of it, would be my take on that, because that's just what people do. Yeah, interesting. So for a paper you published in 2020, interviewed 50 private well and miscommunication experts. So what did you learn from that work? Very fascinating piece of research. I guess where to start? So yes, the expert interview elicited the opinion of 50 experts. So we basically kind of looked at four main spheres. We looked at communications, engineering and science, policy, and I suppose broad risk perception. So these would range from academics to people in local government, maybe involved in environmental impact assessments, maybe during a development. So I'd like to think that we got a fairly wide base when it came to expertise.
And so there was a series of semi-structured qualitative interviews that were undertaken with 25 people nationally and also 25 people internationally, mainly in North America, but also a few people scattered around Europe, particularly in Central Europe. And I suppose, perhaps unsurprisingly, a lot of experts noted financial costs, knowledge and social norms as, I guess, primary barriers. So I guess if you're talking about social norms, prospective groundwater, you're kind of talking like things. For instance, maybe perhaps acquired immunity, that a family may have acquired an immunity over time to water contamination, therefore they may not be aware. I guess even now there's still the long-standing belief that because of the protective benefits endured by those subsoil layers, the groundwater is still a perennially pristine, safe source. That's also something that lingers. Then I guess something mildly controversial is also...
the issue of water diviners, that there are these people that possess the power to draw water from Ireland. It's quite a contentious issue. You know, some people still swear by that, but because it's so plentiful in Ireland, wherever you go, you're going to yield water. So anyway, maybe I've gone off topic a little bit. But maybe to get back to the experts, what I found really, really fascinating was lack of organization knowledge as a barrier cited by experts was actually significantly associated with expert type, and it was flagged far more by people.
actively involved in communications or with a communications background than people otherwise. I think 95% of experts within that sphere mentioned it compared to, I think, was it 75% kind of within kind of policy areas, but significantly lower for risk possession and engineering science experts is around the 50% mark. So this would maybe indicate that some of the people who are involved in monitoring and other such protective actions aren't necessarily aware of the need to communicate or maybe believe that it actually wouldn't make an awful lot of difference. And I think this maybe speaks to the barrier between communication scientists and environmental health practitioners, particularly at the local government level. And with respect to I guess, the kind of engagement mechanisms that were most recommended was mainly local. So you're talking things like maybe seasonal events, local radio, workshops, and community meetings. And in terms of actual message framing or strategy, an awful lot of family-oriented, discursive approaches. So I think something quite a few people within health communication mentioned was maybe the idea of a radio testimonial, whereby maybe you consult with a family that was affected by the issue and had previously not considered a particularly big concern.
So they would then go on the radio and maybe recount their experiences. Maybe a household member got sick. Maybe a friend or family member was affected. I think it's about personalizing the issue and proving that it actually can make a difference because it's such an inherently invisible risk. So many people aren't aware. So I think the family health frame is something that really kind of leaps out there. You have to show people the ramifications of an action and actually demonstrate how well stewardship can make a difference. So I think this makes risk communication and any further regulation look less like a kind of box-taking exercise and more like something that actually can make a difference.
And that there are actually one or two kind of expert regulations I can recall, if you'd allow me to just go a little bit deeper. There's a particular expert that was very much involved in waterless communication in developing, socially non-free developing countries, particularly in South and Southeast Asia. And as you know, the media tends to be very poorly understood in the water sector. The mass media is actually very powerful, but the content needs to be very, very well done. So a lot of people maybe conclude that the mass media is something that's kind of dull, that you can't do that much with it, but that's actually not the case. It's about really hooking in people and using the mass media as a way of getting their attention.
really holding in on the emotional aspects of the issue as opposed to simply disseminating a message. It's kind of going beyond the information deficit model where you need to do more than simply indicate that there's a risk. So it really depends on what you do with it. Then also, I think trust is crucial when it comes to risk communication. So this maybe speaks to the importance of maybe a local hero or someone that's very much trusted.
Because in the eyes of maybe your typical rural household, certainly in Ireland, one expert noted that this is something that's going to take up their time. It's going to affect their schedule. It's going to cost the money. And for all they know, in the end, not much is actually going to change. So maybe you need someone easygoing, someone who's trusted to prove that this isn't something that's bureaucratic, that it's a real issue. So I think maybe kind of secondary information disseminators are very well, particularly where there's been a breakdown in trust. And I think this is especially important during COVID times where I think internationally, there's still a little bit of distrust and a little bit of hesitancy when it comes to trusting certain government institutions. And I could be wrong.
Yeah, I mean, it really is. I mean, just, you know, I was curious, I think 15 of the experts you talked to were from the U.S., out of the 50. And did you see any, you know, common differences among what was said related to the U.S.? And we have all those same issues, meaning a local hero, all of those things. But I also think that scientists aren't necessarily trained in...
not even risk communication, but communication in general. And so it takes, you know, people sitting in multiple locations and ensuring that while those media messages can be really compelling to ensure that they're also accurate. Because Steve and I love to watch TV and we'll say like, hey, watch this, it's about water. And then we're just counting the number of factual inaccuracies in it because they obviously didn't have a reliable expert informing them and making sure that. Especially in the private well world, you know, there are so many fact sheets and, you know, brochures and everything else out there and on the web and, you know, half of it.
isn't necessarily accurate. Or we run into well owners all the time who have had an expert tell them something that isn't actually true or correct. That's a very interesting point. And I actually can mention maybe some of the differences that I noticed between the US and broader North America and Ireland. What struck me is that when it came to state government websites in the US is that the degree of information and the degree of detail actually tended to be generally better than here in Ireland if you go on to a typical county council website.
Maybe you would have a little bit of information about private well maintenance, maybe taken from our environmental protection agency or elsewhere, but there was nothing particularly tailored towards people. It was very much going to be your typical generic communication, some of it quite difficult to read, not the most legible or user-friendly. The majority of information actually pertains to a private well brand scheme. So this is basically money people could save if they were looking to have a well installed or retrofitted. So this is maybe on average about 60%, 60% to 70% of the content on any given local authority website, not so much when it actually came to supply and maintenance.
When it came to the US, far stronger, particularly in some of the Canadian provinces, actually. Alberta and Ontario scored very high. It was step-by-step. It was well laid out. And there's some information that actually informs your typical well-owner about how themselves and their family may be affected. It was also pleasant to read. I think, crucially, there was also some information on climate change adaptation, which I think is something that's often forgotten when it comes to private wells and rural water. I think, I know flooding is a big issue in the UK, but I think when it comes to a lot of water-related risks, I think the focus tends to be very much municipal sometimes, as opposed to rural. Well, yeah, I would say that.
The few hurricanes we've had, especially in 2017, certainly affected in Florida and Texas thousands of wells. It's just I think the challenge then is just the distribution network of making sure that they're getting the support they need. So you mentioned the typical well owner. Are there other universal truths that maybe you've identified through your work about well owners? Because they're across the globe.
Yeah, I mean, I'm just trying to recount maybe some research that myself and some of my colleagues have looked at. Certainly things in Ontario, for instance, that kind of tend to square with Ireland. Research undertaken in Ontario, Canada, I think one or two studies certainly found that respondents with dug wells tend to exhibit more negative attitudes and higher perceptions of risk associated with groundwater quality than drilled well users, which is interesting. And as, of course, dug wells are typically more susceptible to pathogen ingress, well characteristics may actually act as potential motivars to awareness, and this might in turn influence risk perceptions. I think certainly relative distance of supply from households and invisibility of groundwater has also been demonstrated impact upon it. I think something that is unquestionably universal is the importance of organolectic properties. So this is basically sensorial aspects like taste, odour, appearance, et cetera, et cetera. And I think this is certainly something that tends to maybe pull the wool over people's eyes because if the water looks translucent and tastes okay, people will assume that everything's fine. And that's not necessarily the case. I think also because contamination of private wells relative to other risks is such a...
Such a slow onset risk, it can take potentially weeks or months to actually occur while you can kind of get that false sense of security, certainly. I think there are certainly some other issues. I think lack of knowledge certainly is very, very, very common. I think distance and time. I think in Ireland this is very pronounced because it wouldn't necessarily have the volume of local health departments and certainly laboratories that America would. So, I mean, I guess the solution here is drop-off points and things of that nature because we're all around this so isolated logistically.
it's quite difficult. I think similarly, the cost of drinking water treatment systems may also limit the willingness of well-users to engage in maintenance behaviours. They just might see it as too steep a cost, or they might even be aware, or they might confuse a water softener with something else. They might actually think they're treating their well, whereas perhaps they're not. And yeah, I think that's certainly some kind of commonalities we've seen. Maybe one or two others actually I found from a recent survey is that gender norms actually tended to play a role when it came to well-maintenance behaviours. A higher degree of male respondents reported actually taking action.
But when it came to risk receptions and to some degree knowledge of health impacts, it was actually female users that tended to display a bit more knowledge. So I think that's interesting. When it comes to concern, maybe female households tend to, maybe their ears would tend to prick up a bit more. But when it comes to maybe actions, it's the males that tend to do more. So maybe there's a bit of a disconnect there. I think it's gradually changing. Is it Ireland or globally? No, this would be something I found nationally. But I think it has been found internationally, as far as I know.
That's interesting. So we mentioned flooding a second ago. I know you've been involved in some extreme weather event type of work. What have you learned from that? What recommendations would you have? Yeah, that was a very fascinating one. Yes, actually, I should go back to the survey. I developed and circulated a survey looking at extreme weather events relative to private groundwater contamination risk reception in 2019.
Quite an interesting process putting that together. Myself, my supervisor, decided to look at five recent extreme weather events. So this spanned heavy rainfall, flooding, drought, and snowfall, because of course that will eventually melt. So we looked at five roughly from 2014 to 2019. So we based in the east with major snowfalls in 2018, with the summer drought of 2018, and a series of other floods and storms that affected the country. So stormophilia, storm Deirdre, and these were generally nationwide.
So, you know, well owners might not necessarily be able to recall. They may have been abroad at the time, but these were national extreme weather events. And what we tried to do was see if well owners who actually experienced those events tended to have a higher risk perception when it came to groundwater contamination. That is, they believe that it was more likely to affect them, that the impacts would tend to be more severe. So what's really fascinating is that those who did experience extreme weather events actually were significantly more likely to have high-risk perceptions. And also those who actually noticed a change in maybe volume of water when it came to extracting water, also organoleptic factors, again, like taste, they also tend to have high-risk perceptions. So people do actually notice an extreme weather event occurs. It actually will make an impact. And as extreme weather events become more and more frequent, maybe we will see a gradual sea change.
But it's also important to, I think, update guidelines as well, because I think if you go on to many government websites for guideline documents, even in North America and countries that score it very high, the recommendation is still to maybe test two or three times a year with extreme weather events. It's going to need to be potentially more frequent than that. It's not necessarily going to be seasonal. You might just literally need to do it off the cuff. We tell well owners in those cases, though, it really depends on the well, how it was constructed, if it's properly sealed, if it's been grouted. You know, certainly older dug wells or shallow wells of the game water have more potential for that. But some.
you know, are protected pretty well. And so I think that really depends on other factors as well. But yeah, we certainly see a flooding event like from a hurricane impacting a lot of private wells in a given area. I think something that's also potentially interesting is honing in on the climate change issue. And I think maybe we're all guilty of this to a degree. I know I have been in the past. I think there's still a perception when it comes to extreme weather events as those events being something quite foreign, maybe something that tends to affect islands in the Pacific or less developing nations that tend to be predisposed. But I think this is becoming less and less the case. It's becoming far more universal. And we're starting to see this in Ireland now with droughts where you host pipe bands, where the government is starting to actively encourage people to conserve their water. It's gradually changing, but I still think there are some certain norms that persist when it comes to climate change that can in turn impact how people undertake other...
behavioral actions potentially. Yeah, we're seeing the same thing here in the U.S. You know, what was talked about as the mega drought at the beginning of the summer is now there's language around it being that this is actually just true orification of the West, that these are more permanent changes than just a temporary change. So we're definitely seeing that as this is the, you know, we're most summer on record. So we mentioned several times that risk communication is so challenging. I'm curious what your work has said about, you know, the differences between either the U.S. and Ireland, or maybe when you're communicating about certain different contaminants and constituents.
Yeah, well, I might go back to kind of one of the earlier pieces of work I put together during the PhD, where I undertook a global literature review of private groundwork interventions. So in terms of the timeframe, we went between 1990 to 2018. A few very fascinating things came out of that. One was that when it came to, I guess, the global distribution of interventions, that is risk communication interventions, predominantly situated in South Asia, so Bangladesh, of course, due to the arsenic contamination issues that kind of arose from the tube well construction during the 70s and 80s. Obviously, millions ingested arsenic, so it is very much a focus of interventions in the developing world.
Attended to that, also North America, the vast, vast majority of interventions were located in North America and South Asia. There's one in Uganda. We found absolutely nothing in Europe, South America, or Australia. Now, in some cases, this may be to do with the language barrier, but I thought it was very fascinating that the vast, vast majority of interventions published in the peer-reviewed academic literature tended to broadly originate from North America. When it comes to North America, particularly in Ontario, the upper Midwest, and particularly New England, the Mid-Atlantic, and stretching slightly down to Virginia, I thought that was very fascinating.
A few other things kind of arose from that. What's very interesting is that interventions that had an educational or research body as part of the information dissemination phase or actual strategy development tended to score far higher when it came to behavior and knowledge change. That was actually a significant finding. Also, that interventions that tended to be locally based, to go back to extension programs in the US, for instance, local outreach workshops, they also tended to score higher. So local really does work. And I think that was also the case in a lot of socioeconomically developing countries.
But of course, in that instance, there might actually be a bit less resistance on the part of householders because of things like less secure land title. Maybe there may be a bit less resistance when it comes to some certain outsiders telling them what to do. I thought what was also very interesting is the number of studies that could have actually made the cut, so to speak, when it came to the final literature review, but actually didn't evaluate behavior or knowledge. And I know I'm sure both of you will be aware that there have been countless interventions, even in places such as Guatemala, Central America, where maybe they say there's a well disinfectant or treat system that's maybe distributed around a village. Maybe there's a case in control to compare behaviors among those who did and didn't receive.
An awful lot of the studies could evaluate behavior, but an awful lot actually don't. So I think there's an awful lot of research that's perhaps more predicated on evaluating the efficacy of a treatment system than the actual behavioral outcome too. So I think maybe there have been a few missed opportunities over the last 20, 30 years to really look at long-term behavior change in many of those projects. That's something we found because there's an awful lot of research. But when it came to interventions that actually truly evaluated behavior change, there were only 40 in total. Sure. When we did our paper on methods for outreach, we couldn't find enough.
information really. And so we expanded that and looked at, um, a lot of other topics on smoking, teen pregnancy, heart disease, because when you're reaching out to a rural community, it's really about that behavior change. And so it doesn't necessarily have to be about wells in order to, um, to see what works and eliciting that change. So interesting. Absolutely. So I think you just really mentioned the next question was me about interventions and what's the fact of what's missing. You really just answered that question. It's really looking at long-term how those interventions actually.
cause of change. And I agree, I think there needs to be a lot more work on that. Sorry, I have a bit more to say on that, if you'd be willing to admit. I think something certainly that certain states in America have tried to do, I believe North Carolina, I know Jacqueline McDonald Gibson has looked at the private groundwork contamination issue quite a bit. I know she was based in North Carolina, I'm not sure if she's now. She's at Indiana University. Indiana, yes, yes. I know there have been attempts to maybe...
inform local geriatricians, local pediatricians, local doctors of the role that private groundwater wells can play. So perhaps when you have a patient coming in for maybe an annual checkup and they present a gastrointestinal illness, you could inform those doctors to maybe flag the issue. Do you own a private well? Do you recall any recent incidences of gastrointestinal illness in the family? I think it's a particularly useful control point also during the construction of a well because I think perhaps families who inherit lands and notice a well that they deem to be perfectly functional because it never caused a problem.
Perhaps over the 20 or 30 years they live there, they might not see a problem. I think these are critical control points that people need to pay attention to more. I think particularly even on some of the guidance websites, I think it's something that people really should flag. Also briefly from another expert in the US that I spoke to and something that really cropped up in the awareness paper. We basically looked at...
private well structure so age depth also actual structure whether or not there's a well cap ceiling well pump etc etc maintenance history and when we actually looked and broke it down in terms of age the biggest difference in awareness score was observed from the 18 to 24 year old category and the 25 to 34 year old category so i think this isn't really on the radar of young people so i get the impression that a lot more needs to be done at school or maybe even university level i mean immediately in ireland and part of the way i disseminated the survey was actually going to a series of agricultural colleges where young farmers kind of learn their trades And I was actually kind of struck at what an opportunity this was, but many weren't aware. I think this is perhaps something people only really care about when maybe they fly the nest and start a family and seek a house in a rural area on their own, whether or not they're inherited is another issue. But I think there could be more done at school level, certainly at university level, to raise the issue. I don't know if you'd agree. No, I think you're right. I think it's about the mental responsibility you have. I think we talked about that before.
And also, we had a conversation with another guest on the podcast about the trend towards young folks wanting to live off the grid and be more independent and ecologically sustainable. And that person may not have had the knowledge or schooling to know that they're going to have to develop their own water source and how to take care of it properly. And so I think that's another kind of avenue of communication that could be done. Yeah, because I think there's maybe this perception that... you know, for instance, with broadband becoming more, I guess, geographically predominant, that this stuff will almost kind of resolve itself, that people will become more aware over time as outreach and the media kind of ever expanding. But I think intergenerational learning and habits can still very much persist. So, you know, a young man who's looking to maybe purchase a property adjacent to where he grew up might inherit some bad habits that came before him and might not necessarily flag the issue. And I'm not just blaming rural people. I think we're all guilty of this, to be quite honest. Sure, but there's also a lot more of this information being made available at college.
in high school. And so I think you see some of that too. I think it goes both ways. I think where we see the most problem is with older folks who have drank it for four years and no one's got sick. And we try to convince them to consider their kids and their grandkids that might be coming to their house. You brought up something earlier about people developing basically an immunity to their well. And that's a huge issue because it really happens a lot, I think, with contaminated wells and people don't realize it. But if somebody else drinks their water, that's where the real risk comes in.
That's very true. I think maybe that raises another point, and that is maybe the place in time where this issue actually entered the public consciousness. I know I mentioned briefly the issue in Bangladesh. The British Geological Survey did an awful lot of work to install tube wells during the 70s and 80s, adding correct debts. And of course, because of that oversight, millions of Bangladeshis ended up attracting arsenicosis, developing skin lesions. It was pretty unpleasant stuff. I think that was certainly maybe not so much a sea change, but certainly a point in time where people in that particular region started to become more aware, I think certainly in North America.
I do believe there have been some issues in Ohio and some other states, but perhaps the biggest one, the most notorious one, even though it was a public water supply, was probably the Walkerton issue at the turn of the century. Certainly the most advertised. Yeah. I mean, you mentioned a lot of older people. I mean, this probably wasn't flagged as an issue when they grew up, whereas now it is gradually becoming more known.
Yes, for sure. So we thought we'd wrap things up by talking a little bit just about private wells in farming areas. So what have you learned about the relationship of farming, contaminants, and farm families, and how they address their private wells? It's very interesting. I might speak to some of the research that my supervisor did. I'm a co-supervisor, actually, Gina Dora. I should also mention her. Some of their research actually looked at cattle density relative to private groundwater contamination, and they actually did find a significant relationship there. So where there's higher cattle density, where wells tend to be close to adjacent fields, there actually is a significant relationship between rates of private well contamination and agriculture.
And I think also maybe this speaks to some quite poor practices during the welding phase as well. In Ireland in the late 2000s, when this issue was starting to just kind of simmer and gradually boil, there was a study done by Trinity College where I think they selected, I don't know how many wells, but there was a fair number of wells randomly distributed across Leinster, which is basically kind of a large province in the east of the country. And I think they found that only 5% were situated in the correct soils and at the correct depths. So that's certainly an issue adjacent to that. I think also from the survey, farmers actually tended to be less conscious of climate change, which I thought was very interesting, a little less aware when it came to risk perception relative to private groundwater contamination. So that's also something that cropped up. So there's a climate change, though, in so many ways is a political issue. That's true. And so, you know, I would say here a lot of farmers that would say they don't believe in climate change just because they may not have the facts. They just it's political issue, period. And so, you know, those things are that's why extreme weather events.
is really the way to approach a lot of that, because we are seeing a lot more of it. And whether people want to admit that that's climate change or not, we all need to be prepared for those changes that we are seeing, like more hurricanes and more drought and higher temperatures and all that stuff. So, yeah. Yeah, I mean, it really does bear it. I mean, to go back to the survey, I undertook some cluster analysis. So this is really kind of about finding latent trends in the data. And we found three when it came to the risk perception of extreme weather events and tribal oil contamination based on overall score. So weed high, low, medium, and more often than not, farmers actually tended to.
land in the medium and low so i think this is certainly something that's an international finding or international relevance for sure But, you know, I think I don't want to sound like I'm attacking farmers because there have been a lot of progressive schemes. There have been a gloss scheme where it comes to being climate change conscious. And this affects everything from grazing to low or high intensity farming. So an awful lot is being done. But I think certainly there is a bit of a disconnect when it comes to water quality and farming behaviours. We wouldn't necessarily have an awful lot in the way of licensing applications for manure spreading fields and things like that. To be honest, I don't know if maybe the United States are further ahead of us in that regard. I honestly couldn't tell you. But, yeah, I think there is certainly a little bit of a gap there for sure.
It's my understanding, Steve, maybe you can correct me if I'm wrong. There's kind of inconsistent rules across the country in terms of what's allowed. Say it again. That the regulations across the country are inconsistent and really state by state in terms of what's allowed. Oh, certainly. Yeah. In some areas, home rule states, they'd be even more local than that. So that's the unique part of it, I guess. Well, Simon, this has been so fascinating. We will include some links to your papers in the show notes for this episode. Are you on social media in any professional capacity where you'd invite others to follow you?
I think a Twitter account is maybe long overdue. And I do have a research profile. Okay, that counts too. Absolutely. I do think I should set up a Twitter eventually. I think even monthly notifications can be a big help in getting your research out there. And obviously, of course, podcasts such as this are helpful too. But my social media presence probably isn't what it could be. I'm working on that. No problem. All right. Thanks for spending time with us. Well, thanks for your time. Thank you so much.
CapTalk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.