Skip to content
TT013 - Water is an Economic Development Problem episode artwork

Mar 2, 2022 47 min

TT013 - Water is an Economic Development Problem

from Tap Talk

One of our goals with this podcast is breaking down the silos of our work in water. In this episode, which kicks off Season 2, Nathan Ohle reflects on his experience leading RCAP, the Rural Community Assistance Partnership, for the past five years and the deeper water sector context he'll bring to his new position at the International Economic Development Council. Visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to learn more and find the full show notes for this episode!

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

TT013 - Water is an Economic Development Problem

0:00 47:39
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Water and wastewater access is fundamentally about driving economic opportunity for communities. And without access to safe drinking water, without access to wastewater disposal in communities, it really hinders the economic opportunity for individuals, for families, for communities. You're listening to Tap Talk, the Drinking Water and Roll America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health. And together, we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to Episode 13.

One of our goals of this podcast is breaking down the silos of our work in water. In this episode, which kicks off season two, Nathan Oley reflects on his experience leading RCAP, the Rural Community Assistance Partnership, for the past five years, as well as the deeper water sector contacts he'll bring to his new position at the International Economic Development Council. Nathan, it's great to have you on our podcast. Nathan Oley, who's the executive director of RCAP, the Rural Community Assistance Partnership. And I guess to start out, if you don't mind just sharing a little bit about who you are, what's going on in your life, what you like about the work you do and all those sorts of things.

Well, first of all, thank you, Steve and Jennifer, for having me on. It's always a pleasure to be with the two of you. As Steve said, I'm Nathan Oley. I'm the CEO of the Rural Community Assistance Partnership, or RCAP. We're actually a national network of nonprofit partners working on a host of issues in rural and tribal communities across the country, but primarily focused on water and wastewater access, as well as work in solid waste disposal and obviously some work directly with private wells across the country. We are designed in a way that we have national footprint with a local approach.

So we have six regional partners across the country and through those six regional partners, more than 300, what we call technical assistance providers, folks on the ground in every state and territory across the United States, working on water and wastewater issues, trying to ensure that we can build capacity locally to create sustainable and resilient water, wastewater access, as well as ensuring that we are building the skills and expertise and sustainability locally so that the folks on the ground are taking on these issues, can confront those issues and address opportunities and ensure that communities of all sizes, but for us primarily communities of 10,000 or less, have access to state drinking water and sanitary wastewater disposal. Well, we have to, we can't forget that RCAP is how this podcast even exists in so much of our work. And we're very appreciative of that partnership. Well, we are too. You guys are tremendous partners for us. The work that happens, not just through this podcast, but all that happens across the University of Illinois and all of our other partners really is what makes this work special. We are the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and we take the partnership piece very seriously.

Can you share a little bit more about what's going on in your personal life in terms of your professional transition these days, just to give our audience some context? Yeah, it's an interesting time for me. I'm transitioning out of RCAP. I will be at RCAP here through the end of January of 2022. And then I'll be taking on a new role as the president and CEO of the International Economic Development Council. The IDC is the single largest membership organization for economic development professionals. It has members from across North America, as well as some in the European Union. And it's really set. They do all the certifications for economic developers and economic development organizations. They are a thought leader on economic development and really pushing for more economic opportunity.

communities of all sizes. And so I will be at RCAP through the end of January. I've been with RCAP now for about five years, and truly it has been one of the most amazing experiences of my life. The work, but more importantly, the people at RCAP and the partners that we've developed at RCAP really make the work incredibly special. And so it's a little bit of a bittersweet time for me, obviously excited for a new opportunity, but also in many ways sad to be leaving the RCAP family.

Yeah, you've been there five years. I remember when we met, I think it was at ACE in Philadelphia. It was. And everyone was so worried because you had an economic development background. And at the time, RCAP was really almost exclusively focused on water and wastewater. And I guess I just want to point out that how much RCAP has expanded under your leadership as far as looking at economic development, helping small communities. And I don't know if you want to speak to that or not, but the real rise efforts and the partnerships that are new. Yeah, it's been, RCAP's really expanded from our outside view, watching, looking in over the last five years.

It's been a really interesting journey, quite frankly. And when I came into RCAP, you're right. I think people were like, why is this guy in RCAP? He's not a water guy, right? And I wasn't. I knew just enough about water to be able to talk briefly about it, but I was not a water guy. But what I told everyone, whether it was the board of RCAP, whether it was technical assistance providers, whether it was partners, is that if you're in the water and wastewater industry, you're also in the economic development industry. There's such a key and crucial part to economic prosperity for communities of all sizes that really focuses and is centered on water and wastewater access. And so to me...

While it may have felt a little foreign to be specifically focused on water, to me, it was also a direct connection to economic development and economic prosperity in communities. And so I've learned a ton over the past five years, and I would happily say now that I am a water guy. But truly, water and wastewater access is fundamentally about driving economic opportunity for communities. And without access to safe drinking water, without access to wastewater disposal in communities, it really hinders the economic opportunity for individuals, for families, for communities. Well, we're going to touch on more of that in this episode. That was one of the big topics we wanted to discuss with you today, because I think you have this unique position of where you sit, where you've been and where you're going to be able to share that, particularly with our more diverse audience, because we do cross the core drinking water and wastewater industry as well as the public health community. And I think it's important that we all have this foundational understanding. But I'm curious, in your past, you know, this past five years, what have you grown to really love about working in water? Well, first of all, to me, water starts with people. You can't start a conversation, you can't end a conversation without engaging with people in this industry.

And the people that are in this industry are incredibly passionate about the work that they do, the opportunities they're providing and the communities that they're serving. And so to me, that is what has been the most striking about the water industry is the people and the passion for the work, as well as the commitment to making sure that the work that they're doing is not only fulfilling for them, but for their community. There is truly a lifeblood through communities that runs through water and wastewater. And so to me, that has been the most important aspect of the work. It's been the most striking, but it's also been the biggest opportunity to really engage and create new partnerships.

in this way by really making that connection directly with people. And in the end, all this is about relationships. It's about relationships with water. It's about relationships with the earth. It's about relationships with people and community. And so building that connection, helping others understand that connection and being a part of that has been just such a fun part of the job. You know, there are people that have been doing this for 50 years. There are people that are just starting to get into this industry and seeing the opportunity, seeing the mentorship that happens.

you know, in many ways, very naturally in the water industry, I don't think that's the case in every industry has been a fun part of the job for me. It's been something that has taught me a lot about my own way of interacting and working with people. But also, it's truly been over five years, we've seen a real transformation in the narrative around water waste water access. Five years ago, if you would have told me that we had $15 billion that was going to be appropriated through the legislative process in the federal government, I would have thought you're crazy. There was not a real collective voice for water.

in a national narrative in many ways. And we've seen articles come out and talk about the issues that some communities are addressing, but I think we've really seen a coalition of water organizations and people come together to talk about not only the issues, but more importantly, the opportunities that exist within the water industry. And that has been just a really special part of the last five years is to see that start to build and obviously come to fruition in the infrastructure dollars that were just passed a few months ago. For sure. And I think one of the things that's been exciting is that mentorship component that you mentioned, because I know there's a lot of attention and even funding going towards workforce development. And those relationships are important. And I even experienced it myself when I started this industry. And some of it was that fun, like, I'm going to ask you a really hard question that I know you don't have the answer to so that you can learn the answer and just start growing immediately. And that's just been fun, rewarding. And I definitely felt that care from the industry veterans to let's get you up to speed here. Yeah, absolutely. It is truly.

It's just ingrained into the industry. And I think everyone understands that you've got this so-called silver tsunami coming of large retirements in the water industry. And so it's going to be vitally important to get young people engaged in this industry and help them understand the public service aspect that exists in here and how that can drive people that are really mission-oriented and want to give back in some way. But there's also such a wide variety of ways to get engaged, whether it's communications, whether it's directly in operations, whether it's in management or specific treatment technologies. There's all sorts of ways to get engaged and new opportunities, especially for young people to get engaged in this industry.

Awesome. So before we get started really with our episode topic, we always ask everyone one personal fun fact. And so whatever you'd like to share, it's been a really interesting set of fun facts we've gotten so far. And so what's yours? So for me, I'm a big, big baseball fan. I've always been a big baseball fan. It was the sport that I enjoyed playing the most and watching the most as a kid. It was something that I spent a lot of time with my dad going to different ballparks. So I've been to 24 of the Major League Baseball stadiums. The goal is obviously to get to every one of them. But for me, baseball has been such a big part of my life.

I had the opportunity to go to the Field of Dreams game this past summer with my dad and my brother and my son. So we had three generations of bullies that all have a love for baseball that got to be a part of that. The White Sox are our team. So there was obviously an even bigger component to that game. But for me, getting to go to ballparks and seeing the different cultures around those ballparks has been just a really fun part of my baseball journey and baseball life.

So as a scrapbooker on the other part of my life, I have to know, how do you keep track of the ballparks you've been to? Pretty simply, I just have a list. So, you know, it's interesting because I've been to somewhere. I've been to the old park that has now been torn down. And, you know, in Milwaukee is a great example of that. And same thing in Chicago, old Comiskey Park. And I still call it Comiskey Park, even though it's not Comiskey Park for the White Sox. But we just keep a running tally of the stadiums that we've been to and the cities, obviously, that are part of that as well.

You know, it's so funny. You and I have talked about Michigan State, especially football, basketball, because I'm an Illini fan, obviously, with the school here. I did not know you're a White Sox fan. I've been a lifelong Cubs fan. You know, I'm from a very small town. Our school was so small, we didn't have football or wrestling. We had two seasons of baseball, fall and spring. And so baseball is my passion as well. And I'm older than you, but so far I've got you. I've been to 28 of those. Oh, my goodness. Including both Comiskies, the old Detroit Stadium and the new one.

I had no idea we should have had this conversation a long time ago. We will absolutely have some additional conversation about this. I'm not a Cubs fan, obviously, but I love Wrigley. It can't be both. Exactly. It's a little ironic. Both my parents grew up in Chicago, which is why I'm a Chicago sports fan. My dad actually grew up in the Northside, ironically enough, grew up as a Sox fan living on the Northside. I grew up in Michigan being a Chicago sports fan, which in many ways was a lot like being a Northsider rooting for the Sox. I love Wrigley. I just can't root for the Cubs. I'm with you. I can't root for the Sox or the Cardinals. That's just the way it is.

What a deal. Yeah, that's encouraging to know. So, all right. So one of our other recurring segments is your water hero. So this is someone whose work you've admired, past or present, could be someone personal to your life or someone who's more of a public figure. And we're just curious, who has influenced you? So I have two, if you'll allow me to. And they're very different kind of ends of the spectrum. The first is Radhika Fox. Radhika is currently at the EPA Office of Water, running the Office of Water, but was previously at the U.S. Water Alliance. And to me, Radhika is such a great example of...

of a very strong and committed woman who's passionate about this work and passionate about ensuring that every community has equitable access to water and wastewater. And she has spent her career thinking through how to better do this. She's now stepped into public service to actually continue to do that. I have a lot of respect for anyone who steps into public service, whether there's military or in the federal, state, or local family. And it's not easy.

You don't take you certainly don't take those jobs for the money. You take it for the passion and for for the commitment to the work. And so we become very close personal friends through this process. But she she's one person that has just stepped into the void in many ways. And that's such a great example for other especially other young women in the water industry to be to be a part of that. The second one is actually a group of women down in Georgia in Alcovy Shores. They call themselves the Golden Girls of Alcovy Shores. It's a story of a very small community. The system that they in their community serves about 250 people. So, you know, a really small community. And one of the women, Juanita, her husband used to be the operator for the system.

And he tragically passed away one day unexpectedly. And there was no one in the community who knew anything about the water system whatsoever, other than Juanita who had gone to help him run the pumps a couple of times. And so at the age of 63, Juanita went back and got certified as a water operator, recruited three of her best friends, and now a fourth. And so now there's five women all over the age of 70 now who are running this water system for their small community. And it's just to me, a great example of what the water industry is all about. It's people that are committed to their communities, committed to the work, committed to ensuring safe access to drinking water for folks in their communities, and who will literally step into a void to make sure that others are served.

I can't imagine at the age of 63 deciding to go into a whole new arena and commit yourself to that community in the ways that she and her friends have done. And it's just one of the stories to me that shines a light on why the people in this industry are so special and why people of all ages, of all sizes, of all creeds come into this industry with really a purpose to try and serve their community and really step up in ways that in many ways are unmanageable. A great story. I love that, yeah. Yeah, I hadn't heard that before. So you've got the new RCAP logo up there on your screen. You know, it's weird to see it, I'll be honest. For us, we've been working with RCAP since 2009. But you went through a major rebranding effort recently. And so what are some of the important understandings or shifts from activity that we should all be aware of? So this process has been a long journey for us. It's been a two-year process where we really wanted to make sure we had the voices of our technical assistance providers, the voices of our communities, the voice of our partners in this process. RCAP has been around for almost 50 years, and it has evolved over time.

And the brand is part of that evolution as well. And as you referenced earlier, Steve, RCAP has grown and expanded to do work even outside of water and wastewater. We're now doing work in economic development and entrepreneurship. We're doing work in disaster recovery. But all of it really stems from the foundation that's been built over those four and a half decades of the organization. And so we wanted to make sure that we honored the traditions and the foundation that have been set before us, but still were able to show the evolution of the organization. And we heard that really routinely through our technical assistance providers, through our partners, through communities, through a host of surveys and focus groups and other pieces.

And so we set out to say, we don't want to change, we're certainly not changing the name, but we also don't want to change the brand and the logo in a way that walks away from what we have traditionally been. But we also want to refresh and make sure that it really represents the organization, the people in the organization, the communities we serve in a really unique way. And so the ArcCAP logo has always historically had blue in it. Blue has always been a big part of it. Water is obviously a part of that. And when we thought about the color scheme.

We also thought, you know, we also need to represent the wastewater side of the work that we do. And so the green and the blue that you see combined together is the water wastewater synergy that happens. But you also, in the logo, see what look like almost two hills or mountains. And that represents the communities that we serve. That in rural communities, they look and feel differently depending on where you are. But there's a great connection between the community and the water story that we bring in that community. And we want to make sure that we can continue to have that evolution be a part and present.

We also redid our website. Our website was almost 15 years old and clearly needed a refresh. And we wanted to make sure it was much more visual, more vibrant, more video and stories telling story rather than content and words. And so you'll see if you go to our website, which is RCAP.org, you'll see a much different view of RCAP and the work that we do with still the exact same programs and stories that we've always tried to tell. We, as a part of our work, view ourselves as storytellers. We want to help raise the voice of the communities we serve. We want to help raise the voice of the work.

and showcase and highlight it in new and unique ways as a part of that storytelling process. And so for us, the website is a big piece of that to ensure that we can show videos and pictures and content that really engages people in new ways, but still holds true to the work that we've done, that we've always done and will continue to do in the future. I noticed you have a storyteller as one of your staff now. We do. We've got a director of storytelling. Molly Shekhar came on last March. It was a really intentional piece of our work to say, hey, we are storytellers. We want to help others become storytellers, and we want to help raise the voice of those who feel like they can't tell their story themselves. That's awesome.

So as we mentioned, your time at RCAP is concluding soon and will have by the time this episode goes live. But what are your, do you have any additional big takeaways? You've already definitely hinted at some of those were lessons learned or were there even any surprises you had about doing this work and becoming involved in the water sector? Great question. So I think number one, water for the everyday average citizen or resident or person in this country and across the world, for most people, water is just something that comes right out of their cap. Like they turn on the faucet or they turn on the sink or turn on the shower or they flush the toilet and it magically happens.

What most people, especially in the United States, don't understand is there's almost 2 million people in this country that don't have access to safe drinking water. And in a country where we pride ourselves on being the world leader, we in many ways have still left behind in many communities. And in the water industry in particular, small communities are oftentimes left out of that conversation. The thing that hit me right in the face as I started at RCAP was there's 150,000 public water systems across the country, and 97% of those serve communities of 10,000 or less. 72% of those serve communities of 500 or less, which means we have a huge number of systems serving really small populations. And the issues that confront those systems...

are things they're dealing with every day. Because oftentimes when a pump fails or a larger system fix needs to happen, the dollars that come to serve that are supported by the residents in that community. And so if you're pulling from a community of 500, that's much different than pulling from a community of 500,000. And so the issues that confront really small communities, and whether you're talking water, wastewater, private wells, can be really difficult, especially for small communities to deal with. To me, the biggest lesson learned is we've got to find better ways to raise the voice of those communities, to raise the issues and opportunities that are presented at those community levels. To think about how we create more opportunities for people to collaborate with one another and create regional approaches is really vital to ensuring sustainability and resilience of systems of all sizes across the country. There's going to be issues we continue to confront, whether it's PFAS that are evolving, whether it's lead service lines, which are a big issue obviously right now. All these issues are going to confront communities of various sizes, but we've got to create solutions, opportunities, and programs and funding that are going to serve communities of all sizes in the way that they need to be served. And they're going to provide them the opportunity to continue to provide safe drinking water, sanitary wastewater.

Awesome. Okay, so why, going back to the water infrastructure issue, which is really one of the biggest for small systems, going back to the 70s when all that federal dollars were available, now they're not. Why is the water infrastructure problem really an economic development problem, which you've already kind of hinted on? And how can the broader water community do a better job of communicating those issues and doing the storytelling you're talking about? So one of the issues I see, both from the way that we do federal funds, but also the way that communities think about these issues.

is we put them inside us. We say, well, we're going to deal with water here. I'm going to deal with broadband here. We're going to deal with wastewater here. I'm going to deal with economic development planning there. And we don't have those communities or those individuals that are part of those processes talking to one another. They don't think about the impact of having safe drinking water on an opportunity to drive more talent into a region. We don't think about the opportunity to have wastewater disposal and the direct correlation to companies and businesses that actually need that access to ensure that they can continue to operate. That, to me, is a fundamental flaw in the system.

We do not have those communities, those individuals talking to one another, but they also don't think about their effect on one another either. And so as we think about water and wastewater infrastructure, and we think about the opportunity to drive that, we also need to think about the jobs that those are providing as we think about infrastructure projects themselves. But more importantly, how do we make sure that water operators and the managers for those systems? feel like they're a part of this larger process and a part of their community themselves. We also need to think about how do we, as we ensure that water and wastewater access exists, how do we also create a narrative that showcases the impact of water and wastewater access and economic development? We don't often spend any time, if any, on the storytelling piece and on the narrative arc of water and wastewater access and what that means to a community. Quite frankly, there's no business that's going to start or grow or stay in a community without wastewater disposal. And there's no family that has the means to stay or move. There's no family that's going to stay in a community without access to state water at their home.

And so we need to start there. That to me is the most basic piece and use that narrative and that journey to talk about the impact that water and wastewater have on economic development and economic opportunity for communities. And quite frankly, how those things are all intertwined at the community level, at the state level, at the federal level. Yeah, it seems like the storytelling component is going to have an increasing necessity as we go forward, particularly as the next topic is related to funding, but making sure that the voices are growing louder together to be able to get the funding to where it needs to go. Particularly in the private well sector, we know there's lots of challenges when you have someone on a private well who has serious issues, and how do they get the funding to be able to fix that when it's just their home and their property and their family? And most people, right, don't even think about the private well until they go to sell their home, right? That's usually the impetus for this, right, is, oh, we actually need to check and make sure this is...

operating the private well where there's no contamination happening. And when you've got such a huge number of private wells across the country, how do you actually message and communicate to all those folks and help them understand it? That's why this podcast and so many other things that the two of you at the University of Illinois are doing are so vitally important. And same thing when you're talking about water and wastewater treatment. The communications that happen between those systems and the community is vital. If you've got to do a boil notice, how are you communicating that to the community? How are you being proactive and helping them understand what's happening, why it's happening, and when it's going to be fixed? The communication piece is often overlooked or overlooked, excuse me, but especially in small communities where you don't have a communications person writ large for that system, right? You may have one operator or maybe a part-time clerk, and that's all you have for a system or for a community. And so helping those folks understand the role they have to play in the community and communicating out to the community when things are happening.

Because proactive communications is such a vital part of being successful in this industry and ensuring that communities feel safe as a part of this process as well. You know, it's small communities from a small community have such pride in their community. But I think that's one of the places, water and wastewater, where they don't understand that they need to show that same pride in order to work together, if you will. You know, we've struggled with, you know, you brought up the communication piece. We've tried in so many ways to look at how we could support small communities by being that communicator. And it sounds like, you know, RCAP has always been that.

that person, so to speak for a lot of small communities, but it sounds like the focus is actually increasing, which I think is, it will certainly make a difference. People need to realize all the things, you know, the best example I have is I went to visit a plant and we met with a village board member person and he took us to the wrong plant. He took us to the wastewater plant instead of the water plant. So it's like, how do you not know? You know, just like I talked about how the water sector needs to see themselves as part of the economic development sector. We also need.

the individuals in the water sector to feel like they're part of the storytelling process, that it's vital for them to participate, to understand, to be active. And if they can't be, to figure out how do they get others to help them with that process? Because again, in small communities, the water operator may also be the mayor of that community, may also be a farmer, may also be a part-time firefighter. And so those people are intertwining the community already. And you're seeing everyone in that community at the grocery store or at church or other places. And so thinking about their role, not just in the community, but how do they make sure water...

and Water's role in that community is a part of the everyday conversation. It's just a critical thing. It's not easy. It's not necessarily intuitive to everybody to think about their own role in the storytelling process. And Water's role in the community's well-being is not necessarily an intuitive piece to this work. And so it's really vital and important for us to educate and help people understand the role they play in all of those pieces. As a communications person myself, it sounds like a fun challenge. And I'm excited for what's coming in the future. I think that with our work and our CAP's work and everything that all of our larger group of partners are doing is just really...

So it's, yeah, it's exciting. And of course, it is a big challenge. And I think part of that is going to come from this, as you mentioned, giant amount of funding. This is unprecedented level of funding for water and wastewater infrastructure. And so obviously, this is going to create a lot of opportunities. But I know in 5, 10 years and beyond, we're going to be talking about some of the challenges that happened, some of the things that didn't go well, because that's the reality of the world. So I'm curious, since we're in this really critical point, what do you think are some of the potential pitfalls that, say, HTA providers, communities, and operators need to watch out for as they're going into this onslaught of money? So first of all, it is an unprecedented and some...

sum of money. It is a generational investment in the water and wastewater industry. With that comes true opportunity, but also true issues and pitfalls. And so the thing I worry the most about is ensuring that the communities that need the funding the most get access to it. Anytime you've got federal funding opportunities, it's a complex web of how do you actually access funds? How do you make sure you've got all the environmental permits in place? How do you even ensure just some basic things? Like the system has a DUNS number that registers them with the federal government. And then how do you make sure that the community also understands how to manage those funds in the right way, how to report on them, et cetera. Because the minute that a community goes out of compliance or doesn't meet a loan or grant obligations, they can become ineligible for those things in the future. Now, let alone the health implications of obviously operating these systems in the right way. And so first and foremost, it's got to be about...

how do we ensure the communities need the most? And that's communities of all sizes, but communities that have not either received funding in the past or have not received funding in a long time, how do we ensure they understand the basics of how to access funding? Where do they go to understand what funding is available? What specifics do they need to make sure are in place so that as they go through an application process, they can be successful? How do we make sure from the state revolving funds that we get small communities in particular on the intended use plants? And this is a really geeky thing in the water industry, but if you're not in the intended use plant, there's no way you access the funding through the SRFs, let alone actually get to the end of actually accessing those funds. And so it's about building capacity in communities of all sizes.

across the spectrum to ensure that the folks on the ground both understand how to access the funds, they can do it in the right way, they can be competitive in this process. And how do we prioritize those forgivable loans through the SRFs to the communities that need the most? Because oftentimes what we end up seeing is communities that have capacity, that have grant writers that understand the process, get access to those funds, even when they may not need the forgivable loan portion of it, because there's always a pressure to get the funds out the door, right? There's 15 billion for led service line replacements, and there's going to be incredible pressure coming from Congress, coming from agencies, coming from communities to say, did we get the funds out the door? To me, We've got to find a way to provide some air cover to say, hey, yes, we need to get the funds out, but we also need to do it in the right way and make sure the communities that need the most access those funds in the right way. And so part of that is creating technical assistance opportunities to make sure that communities can access others that know the systems and understand how to get into the system and operate and be successful. Part of it is also making sure that we don't have such a frantic push to get the money out the door, that we leave those for those that have already been left behind further behind. Because if in 10 years or 15 years, the communities that don't have access to safety water right now or wastewater disposal right now still don't have access to it, that's on all of us.

because we then didn't do this in the right way. And so we've got to be intentional about it. We've got to create opportunities to drive technical assistance to communities that need it. And we also have to find a balance between getting the funding out and ensuring that it's happening in a way that allows for equitable access across the spectrum. And that includes tribal communities, includes small communities, includes big communities. It's really vital to ensure that we don't continue to exacerbate the gaps that already exist in the water and wastewater access and affordability and ensure that communities that do access these funds have the capacity to not only operate the systems, but also understand the financial and reporting obligations that come with the funding.

It's certainly a big problem because that's what ends up happening all the time is the small systems that don't have the wherewithal, unless they're already on somebody's radar, they are just falling further behind. It's, yeah, it's right. It needs to be intentional and somebody has to have their back. That's the bottom line. Absolutely. Well, and I'm curious, we've talked for decades now about the opportunities that come from restructuring and other types of partnerships. I'm curious what you think that this funding is going to do to that dialogue. Is it going to make it go faster or maybe even slow down because...

communities can feel a little bit more autonomous with that funding? So I think there's opportunities to shape that conversation in a really positive way. I think it has to probably happen state by state, quite frankly, because these funds are going to go through each state. There's ways to incentivize regional partnerships through this funding. And part of that is the forgivable loan aspect of it. Part of it is other incentives that states can provide, technical assistance that states can provide to ensure that regional conversations are happening. And when we at RCAP talk about regionalization, it's a full spectrum of opportunities. Anything from some basic things like sharing the cost of a water operator across communities or the back-end accounting system across communities, all the way to the physical connection of pipes.

To us, it is not necessarily about consolidation. It's about how do you build economies of scale and opportunities for communities to think collaboratively. And this is interesting because it's happening not just in the water sector, it's also happening in the economic development sector. How do communities think about themselves as a larger part of the region and the benefits of their community also benefiting the communities, you know, five miles down the road or two miles down the road or 10 miles down the road. I think there's a huge opportunity to continue to push the conversation around regional approaches and regional partnerships.

But we also have to be aware that that's going to look and feel differently in different parts of the country. And the opportunities are going to be different in different parts of the country. I don't think we can say, hey, we need to consolidate all these systems and bring them to a much smaller amount of systems. I think what we need to say is, how do we make sure the systems are talking to one another and collaborating where they can and where there are opportunities to facilitate more of those conversations? We need to prioritize that. And a lot of the work that RCAP does on the ground is facilitating those conversations as an objective mediator.

For us, we don't have an end goal in mind in those regional conversations. It's about bringing communities together, having them talk to one another about what their needs are, what their opportunities might be, and seeing where there are opportunities for them to work collaboratively. In some cases, it won't work. There's some geographic pieces that could come into play there. There are some political conversations, quite frankly, that come into play. And there's jurisdictional issues that come into play. But where we can facilitate positive conversations and help communities think about how they might collaborate, that's always a positive. And states, I think, are going to have to think about how do they incentivize those kind of conversations happening through this process, because otherwise it's not going to happen on its own.

So when I was in second grade, my school consolidated. Middletown consolidated with New Holland. So my class went from a class of, I don't know, 10 maybe to a class of 22 or something like that. My parents graduated from Middletown High School. New Holland was the enemy, competed in basketball and everything else. We still see so much of that. That ends up being a real issue in so many cases when you talk about even sharing an operator, which is a much better solution, I think, because communities have a lot of pride, especially small communities, and they do want to keep their autonomy. So I don't know.

And it's, I think, I guess the question is, how do we convince them that it's worth their while, you know, to do, to forget about all that stuff and just do what's best for everyone? It's sometimes an issue. That's a big question in general these days. Yeah, no doubt. I wouldn't think about it like that. Someone asked me a couple years ago what I thought was the biggest impediment to regional approaches in rural communities. And I said high school football. You know, high school football and basketball, those things, especially in small towns, are big deals. And their rivals are usually the community that are closest to them.

What we found in our work with communities is oftentimes they're already doing some kind of regional collaboration. They just don't call it that or know that that's actually where it is. And you have to start small. You've got to find small, easy ways for communities to think about working or even just talking to one another. Once you find some small successes and build a little trust, then you can start to go a little bit bigger. It's not a process that's going to happen quickly. It's not, oh, in three months, we're going to have this figured out and it's going to be done in maybe three years and maybe seven years, quite frankly, in these conversations. And so starting small, helping to educate them on what all of those opportunities could be, laying out the options and opportunities.

and why they may be good and why they may be bad for the community. And being very transparent about all of those things is critically important. It's about building trust between communities. It's about having facilitators and mediators that don't have an end game as a part of this process. That's really critical because if you have one community that's trying to facilitate with another community, oftentimes their interest is going to override what might be best for both. And so finding ways to have others facilitate those conversations is what we found to be very, very successful because you have an objective party that's bringing folks together. And when you start small and start building upon that, that's where you start to see a kind of...

see real transformative change. I was just saying in the key issue with that RCAP person or whoever that mediator objective person is, is that they have to develop trust with both communities first. And we see that too. And it's certainly the best way to go. Yeah. Well, I just love that example that some of those partnerships might exist well outside of wastewater infrastructure, anything like that. The best example I can think of is Steve and I go to Park County, Indiana every year to their Covered Bridge Festival, which is this, you know.

big craft fair, food fair, antique fair that covers, you know, six or seven little towns in Park County, Indiana. And I'm sure there's a lot of relationships that are already there because of this longstanding tradition. So if they want to really make some progress, that's one avenue to start with is who knows who and how can we gain their buy-in as influencers in their community first. That's just another great example, Jennifer, of thinking about the broader connectivity between communities that exist even outside of water, wastewater. And there may be relationships that you can build upon that lead to conversations in the water sector, wastewater sector that you never even thought about. And so thinking about

the natural connection and collaboration as opposed to competition is just critical. Yes. Awesome. Well, it's certainly good to talk to you. And before you go today, one of the things we wanted to ask is, I'm sure you've thought long and hard about your new position and all those things. What are you particularly excited about in your upcoming role? It's a great question. Number one, I'm really excited to be going to an organization that has an opportunity to be the leader in the economic development field. And to me, there's such an opportunity to continue to grow and expand.

the thought leadership around how do we think about how economic development can really positively impact communities of all sizes? How do we create opportunities that are going to allow for communities in whatever sector they want to try and grow in their own community, their own region? How do we create tools and resources to allow them to take those opportunities on and to really grow and expand? And how do we create equitable economic development outcomes? across the United States and quite frankly across the world. The international aspect of it very much excites me. I think there's a lot that we can learn from our counterparts overseas and a lot that they can learn from us. And again, that goes back to that collaboration piece. I think there's just a huge opportunity in the economic development space to build more partnerships, to think more collaboratively, to broaden the scope of how economic developers think about their role in the community and to get them engaged in conversations around water access or broadband or other things, other infrastructure pieces that they wouldn't normally think.

about their role in, but to bring them to the table to have conversations in those industries and also to invite those industries into the economic development conversations in a much more robust way. I think there's a lot of work yet to do in engaging communities and engaging industries to making sure that people are collaborating as opposed to competing. One of the things we've always seen in the economic development sector is a need to compete, and I think there's really actually an opportunity to switch that frame to one of collaboration. How can the benefits of a community 10, 15, 25 miles down the road also benefit me, and how do we think regionally about these approaches? Number one, it's an organization that has a great tradition, a great foundation. I'm replacing a leader that's been there for 35 years. And so there's a huge foundation to build from. And to me, I'm just excited to build on that foundation in many ways, similar to what we've done in RCAP and the history and tradition that exists there and finding new ways to grow and expand the existing work, but also invite others into the conversation.

Well, I can see there's a little bit of a subversive avenue there, too, that you're bringing the voice of water to that broader community, too, because of your experience. And I think we can all be grateful for that. I'm really excited to bring the water perspective into the economic development sphere. I'm also excited to bring the small community perspective there. In my background, I've worked in cities like Detroit and Baltimore and big cities, but obviously RCAP has been explicitly and exclusively focused on small communities. And I think there's a real need and opportunity to bring small communities into the economic development conversation in ways that they haven't been able to be engaged in the past.

Yeah, I was just going to say the same thing. I hadn't thought of it until we started talking today. But really, the five years at RCAP probably is going to yield a lot of benefits for small communities in your new role. I hope so. I hope so. That's the plan. And obviously, we're going to try and be as engaging as possible and look forward to engaging both of you in those conversations as well. That'd be great. Yeah, for sure. Are you on social media in any professional capacity where our listeners could follow you? So RCAP has a Twitter handle. It's just RCAP slash Inc. We also have a Facebook page and a LinkedIn page.

And I personally have all three accounts on Twitter. It's at Nathan Ole, N-A-T-H-A-N-O-H-L-E. And you can find me on Facebook and LinkedIn as well. Great. We'll include all those links in the show notes for this episode. Well, thank you. It's good to talk to you. We certainly wish you the best of luck and are excited for what you might bring to the table in support of small systems, even in your new role. So yeah, it's an exciting time, certainly. Hopefully your family and everyone is safe and well.

all those things and best of luck. Yeah, it's been a pleasure working with you. It's been a pleasure working with both of you as well and appreciate the opportunity to come on the podcast. But more importantly, appreciate all that the two of you and obviously the entire team at the university are doing in this work. It's incredibly important. TAP Talk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Tap Talk?

This episode is 47 minutes long.

When was this Tap Talk episode published?

This episode was published on March 2, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Tap Talk episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.