A successful water system is the one that you forget entirely about, right? If you never hear about it, that's probably success, right? You turn down the tap, you got some safe water, it's affordable, you don't have to worry about it. You're listening to Tap Talk, the drinking water in rural America podcast. We believe everyone has a role to play in protecting public health. And together, we're connecting water and health professionals with ideas to extend and enhance our work. Whether you operate, educate, or regulate, this show is for you. Welcome to episode 18.
In this episode, we continue our conversation with our friends and colleagues at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. The conversation features challenges facing the water sector in the U.S. and around the world and how this team's work is creating solutions. So I'd like to hear more about your time working in Africa and Asia on water issues and how that helped prepare for your role as an academic at UMass and working on these small system issues. So I've been in the water sector for, I would say, 15 years, but the first 10 were all international. So I'm actually somewhat new to the U.S. water sector for the last five years. So I came to UMass primarily involved internationally, particularly in low and middle income countries, Africa and Asia. And these are working with communities that had really limited financial resources, challenges with having trained staff and staff turnover, aging infrastructure, climate change, creating new problems, people leaving rural communities for urban areas and putting more pressure.
on these systems. And that sounds really familiar, right? So I think that's what I was finding is when I started here and kind of started to learn more about the challenges of small water systems. They were an obvious draw because I just saw so many parallels in terms of the context of the challenges, obviously in a different context and some different concerns, but a lot of the issues were actually remarkably similar. So when I came here and it was just actually at the end of the Wynn Center, but Dave and Patrick and everyone were involved in the small systems and had this history of public engagement with it. So it was just a very natural fit for something that I felt like I could apply some of the things I had learned and lessons and get engaged here. Awesome.
So for all of us that I've never obviously traveled overseas for work on water issues or anything, so what are some things we should all know about water issues in developing countries where you've been that, you know, especially things we might not be aware of? What are the differences, I guess? Yeah, so as I mentioned, there's a lot of similarities and lessons, I think, that can be drawn across both. And I think that's something we don't always realize in the U.S. We think that the challenges are totally different. I mean, the water safety concerns are definitely different in lower-income countries. We're really focused on preventing infectious diseases. In the U.S., that is something that we take for granted at this point when we focus on smaller levels of chemical contaminants with longer-term impacts or impacts later in life and all.
But at the same time, I think in the U.S., we're seeing some of the long-term implications of some of our decisions about infrastructure that were made 50 years ago. We have maybe oversized systems in some larger communities, or we have rural systems that now have lots of populations and are now oversized. We're seeing maybe things that were too expensive that were installed to manage. So I think some of the exciting things that are happening in other places in the world are they're looking to some of the challenges that we're facing in the U.S. around aging infrastructure and some of the decisions, and they're saying, are there opportunities to do things differently? Innovations in treatment, decentralization.
holistic kind of one water approaches. Like there's one development just outside Nairobi in Kenya where the drinking water treatment and the wastewater treatment for this community are co-located in the same building. And so that's sort of, you know, that's something that you don't really see there and that there's more direct kind of either recycling or, well, the wastewater is going on to irrigation, but they were still able to, you know, share power supplies and resources. And just sort of, I think that there is some opportunity for learning from other places that don't have infrastructure systems to look at maybe some innovative, there's innovative payment or cross subsidy models between rural and urban areas and other places. So I think there's actually a lot of them.
A lot of kind of interesting ideas that we could take from elsewhere and try in the U.S., which is something I'm excited to be working on in my career, too. Sure. I mean, the big problem is that the government paid for all of that. I run a lot of systems that are oversized today. And, yeah, you know, back in the day, they put an earmark in and they bought you a new water system. And those folks are long gone. But the water system in the community are still there. So, yeah, we didn't do ourselves any favors by not being more cost effective back when we should have been, for sure. Can you expand on that a little bit more and how it connects to some of the environmental justice issues that we've discussed already?
I mean, I think, you know, in the water sector in the US and internationally, right, we're talking a lot more about equity of water supply. So equity of water access, you know, equity between communities, you know, small systems versus larger systems and differences in resources, but also within communities. I think that's something, right, that we're starting to pay a lot more attention to as well. And this is something I feel like in a lot of lower and middle income countries has been a bit more talked about earlier, you know, who actually gets, say, connected to a pipe supply and who doesn't. You know, that's a very kind of more obvious one. But, you know, that's happened historically in the US with redlining and there were entire communities that were left out of.
of piped water and historically as well. So I think that's something that, you know, it's talked about a lot outside the U.S. I feel like in the U.S. I've definitely been, you know, there's a lot more focus on environmental justice and equity of access, especially with small systems. The other thing I noticed in my international work, there's been a focus for a long time on actually gender equity in the water sector, especially on workhorses. And I feel like that's something I've seen some of here, and I feel like it's taking steam, but thinking about gender equity, particularly for water operators and for leadership of utilities. And I know that's something that is growing in interest us here as well. I see a lot more today, though. I mean, I was on the board for only Section AWA, and we have...
Yeah, a fair number of utility superintendents now that are women and certainly our board. And as a great example for civil engineering, I went to speak to our student chapter about what's the program AWWA has where they go out as a group and it's like Engineers Without Borders are involved. I can't think of the name of it. Anyway, I went to talk to them about that program to see if any of the students would be interested in helping out with the project in Illinois. And there were 27 women engineers and I believe two men engineers, at least in the club. So, you know, it was surprising and it was also awesome.
And so, yeah, a couple of the young engineers there ended up helping out with the project, I believe. So I certainly saw it. Go ahead. I think it's changing. And I think, you know, when thinking, you know, we're talking about the big wave of retirements coming in the water sector and especially the challenges and finding operators in small systems. So, you know, I think sort of diversifying the workforce around that is going to help with the challenges of just having enough operators and having enough workforce. And so this is sort of maybe part of the transition that's happening right now. Awesome.
So I'm going to switch it up a little bit. Patrick, you're the acting director of the WET Center at UMass. And so could you tell us what you do with that? You kind of described it at the beginning, I know. And what are some of the accomplishments you'd like to share related to the work you do there?
Sure. So the Water and Energy Technology Center is a small building on campus located next to the Town of Amherst wastewater treatment facility, wastewater treatment plant, which is a 4 to 7 million gallon a day plant designed for 4.7. It's also next to a local surface water, the Mill River, which drains from the Atkins reservoir of Amherst main surface water supply. And we have intake lines for both wastewater and surface water to do pilot-scale studies as we wish. company, private company wanting to test the technology, water treatment technology, especially wastewater, you have to go collect wastewater to test it, right? And that can be challenging. Even collecting the surface water that you know anything about, any of the water quality parameters, can be challenging. So the WET Center has several different kind of types of clientele, but primarily we work with private companies, a lot of chemical manufacturers, filter membrane manufacturers.
on all sorts of projects. I know this past talk is related to drinking water, but I'll have to cross over into the dark world of wastewater briefly. But we work with those types of companies to do a variety of things, but primarily third parties validate their claims or their technologies. So we help companies gain traction and the technology readiness level. So a company that's a TRL one or two might come to us and hope to get to a three or four. Some companies that come to us are very commercial ready, well-developed technologies that they need some validation testing that there's some challenge testing. So we work with startups all the way up to multi-million dollar corporations on testing technologies in all sorts of capacities.
Some examples would be electrochemical oxidation companies that are more often startups than not, but we work with some large ones too. We help design reactors, validate the amount of oxidants they output with their new reactor design, determine if they create any byproducts, or are they leaching anything from there. set up into water, things of that nature. We work a lot with chemical companies, oxidation companies, ozone and paracetic acid, both in the drinking water and wastewater world, and then a lot of monitoring companies. The world of online water quality monitoring has come a long way in the past 20, 30 years with the capabilities. One of our first projects was monitoring the Mill River during storm events for changes in water quality parameters, including DOC, online CHM analysis, and online COD chemicals.
and correlating that to storm events and DDT formations. So the project range in scale anywhere from a few days, a company that needs a simple test done, to many months or many years. Some of these companies have been with us for over two years now. And so the original wet center was what we call the pilot plant. It was developed by some UMass faculty in the 1970s, around the time of the Clean Water Act happening. And the idea was that the Clean Water Act was going to be coming soon, and Massachusetts knew they were going to have to build secondary wastewater treatment.
for all wastewater treatment plants in the state. So the faculty at UMass convinced the state to fund a testing facility to test some of those earlier technologies, including activated flood units that came as a compact, you know, all-in-one packages, air strippers, rock trickling filters. some various types of problems or media filtration technologies. And so the original wet center was around for 15 years or so, operating and putting out a whole bunch of publications and consulting with the communities that were now building full-scale treatment plants. And then they did a lot of great work. And then it was offline for many, many years, 1985 to 2015, around the time when Dave and you all got the WINS grant. And so part of the WINS grant was outfitted a mobile drinking water trailer.
And so Dave decided to park it at the original pilot plant. Patrick, here's a pilot plant. It's kind of interesting. And that was about it. And he said, maybe we can turn it on. And I thought it was a joke that he thought we could turn it on. It was completely abandoned, overgrown with a forest. It was called abandoned by the university and all sorts of problems with it. But over the course of a year and a half, two years, me and some undergrads got it online again somehow. We managed to bug enough people at UMass facilities and campus planning to provide equipment and utility services to get it to a limping along state, barely breathing. We gave it the old...
electroshock to the chest and it came back to life and then we uh slowly nursed it to the state that it's in now and we currently my almost my full salary gets funded by it we have two full-time phc students another full-time research fellow and anywhere from five to 15 undergrads floating around working on various things and so the wet center has kind of i would say become a pretty interesting part of the department i don't know if importance is a key word but it definitely gets talked about a lot um so faculty and do anything water related really encourage their students to come see the wet center. You know, I probably had over 40 students in the past five years or more work there in some capacity to try to hire pretty much anyone that shows an interest in getting in the lab and working with water. A lot of people always ask what's the energy component. So we do a lot of reuse, wastewater reuse work for cooling, well cooling tower is one, but power generation. Power generating facilities use a ton of water and the modern ones need really clean water to do it. So we do a lot of reuse work.
And then we get a lot of pump manufacturers coming through, or maybe pump sensor companies. One came in the door just the other day looking to see if we could help challenge tests. They have this pump sensor that can determine if the pump is cavitating, clogged. There's a pump stuck in it, and all based on the electrical signal that you get from the pump operating. So the water, food, energy nexus, the wet center will take on any project or try to. Greenhouses is another one that gets people from the ag industry coming for either nutrients or greenhouse issues.
So the wet center, Dave and Emily can give kind of their opinion on it, but we kind of took what I would call basically nothing. And Dave gave me a credit card, which is a silly idea. And about a thousand trips to Home Depot, we got it into this facility that brings in a good amount of money. We're not rich by any means, but we bring in a lot of research dollars to do these projects. And it gives us some flexibility to try projects we like to try. You have not many labs, you can run 200 gallons a minute, right? We're on the far corner of campus. It's an excellent way to get rid of our water and source water. So we can get a piece of equipment there.
under 200 gallons a minute, we can test it to some degree. That's what I like about my job. The projects that come through the door at the wet center, I never know what's going to come my way. Last summer, I was getting quotes for $10,000 greenhouses. I'm like, why am I doing this? The same company is still talking to me about trying to make it happen this year. I never know. That's what makes it fun.
I've worked here 38 years and I've done 40 different jobs just because we're always chasing grant money. And so it's always what's the hot topic. And so, yeah, it makes it interesting for sure. Yeah, well, yeah, it is. And Patrick is very modest about it, but he's done a terrific job of creating this space. And it's really more of a lot of what I might call a maker space. It's very attractive to the undergraduates. So many of them want to work there because they learn all kinds of very practical skills in addition to the science and engineering of treating water and dealing with water. And so not only is it attractive to the students and it's.
It's been a real benefit to our department, a nice complement to the more conventional research laboratory. And it's been very attractive to local entrepreneurs and startups. We haven't had to do really any advertising at all. In fact, in many ways, we're a little under the radar. And people come to us and say, OK, we heard about you from some other person. And we understand that you might be able to help us.
Could you run a pilot of this sort? And oftentimes we can. We don't have as much bandwidth as we'd like, but we're generally maxed out most of the time. And Patrick manages to find all kinds of students who want to work on these projects, and they get great experience. And they get to know the technology. They get to know how to run pilots, how to make things, make things sometimes from scratch. And then they get to know the companies as well. That's really cool, yeah. That sounds like a great, go ahead. I was going to say, Patrick, you also lead the technical assistance program for the state DEP. How were the overlaps with that program and your other work at UMass?
Sure. So yeah, I coordinate, do a lot of work with DEP. And so without getting into two, I do, I am the lead of the small systems program. We also have a lead in schools project and a PFAS monitoring project, which are DEP funded and overlap a little bit. But the small systems project specifically with DEP is called Small Systems Technical Assistance.
And so we manage a whole bunch of subcontracts, as you all know, and work directly with small systems to really try to provide solutions in boots on the ground, technical assistance, as well as training and developing relationships with other stakeholders who might benefit from such collaboration. So one example is the Pioneer Valley Planning Commission is an organization of region of governments. Let me restart. We work with organizations like the Franklin Regional Council of Governments, who there's 15, I believe, towns in it. And so instead of each having their own town governments, they've kind of decided to.
pool as one for and pool resources for things. I'm trying to think of some examples. Like the town nurse, for example, would be the one or the. It's building inspector. We might have free building inspectors that do a couple pounds instead of one. They can call on each other for help with police or fire, kind of have that relationship. But they didn't have anything for water. And water, wastewater and stormwater have started to become real issues in the past 15 plus years, especially with climate change and the degrading infrastructure. And so now we try to do things like get them to coordinate on their water and wastewater infrastructure.
And so there's all sorts of ways we do that. We host meetings, not with COVID that haven't been in person since March of 2020, but before that, we would help coordinate regional meetings. We provide free training for towns that need operators, and we are willing to help get someone certified and or pay for a short time an operator, an entry-level operator's wages to get them in the door and get them trained so that then the town can take over and have a new operator. So the big challenge, as many people know, is a shortage of water operators in rural areas.
Those are the primary aspects, I guess, of it, but it overlaps with everything we do at DEP because, I mean, at UMass and the web center, the class that Emily and Dave talked about is a really good example. A lot of the systems that were in those classes, the three or four systems that we worked with, are ones I still interact with on a weekly basis because we're trying to help them identify grant money, identify contractors that spend the grant money, usually for system repairs or upgrades. So we've used the, part of it is we get federal funds for infrastructure improvements to small disadvantaged communities. I work with, currently 10, we're about to add four more communities to identify a way to solve a water contaminant issue. So there's too much to say at once about what we do, but anything that the fall systems and the state needs, I listen to them at least, or DEP gets an email forward to me and says, is there anything we can do to help the town of, I'll say, Amherst, even though it's not one of the towns, but I won't give away any of the towns we work with right now in Massachusetts for that. I will, I'll listen to anyone.
you know, anyone's trouble with their system, see if there's a way that's whether it be UMAP or . So in doing that, how much do you work with the other technical assistance providers like RCAP or Rural Water or New England Waterworks or? Sure, quite a bit. So it's for training, technical assistance, boots on the ground, accounting and managerial technical assistance, and developing health-based training courses. We work with those providers. The majority of my work is probably with those providers.
It might be something on source protection or cybersecurity. It might be a PFAS seminar to non-operators, like the town managers, council-type folks, or boards of health. DEP usually gets a bunch of emails and requests, and then comes up with the idea and says, hey, this is becoming an issue. We should do a training on it, and let's see if we can do it in three or four locations across Massachusetts. That is now shifted to basically always be online. Certainly. Hopefully not for too much longer. Yeah, hope so.
Well, it sounds like they really lean on you as a trusted partner to extend their capacity. We know that state programs are often very limited in what they can do internally. And so it's kind of a unique role in terms of what happens in other states. Especially for university. Yeah, and I think, you know, small systems one is just one of the projects we do. Maybe Dave touched on the PFAS project because that collaboration, if not, is probably bigger than our small systems and systems project. Yeah, with the PFAS free testing program that's supported by the state through the state supplemental budget.
We've been looking at sampling all 1,600 public water systems plus about 3,500 private wells across the state. There's a lot of logistics involved with this. And it is all essentially being done through UMass because the State Environmental Protection Agency, DEP, didn't have the bandwidth and capacity to do it. So they came to us. We ended up hiring, over the course of a couple of years, about 60 different people at different times. And some of them were professionals, but most of them were students.
that we gave, we taught them how to do some of the work, whether it be outreach to private well owners, all the way to overseeing and assessing the technical competence of the labs and the submitted data and doing QC on the data, cover the whole gamut. And it's been a huge, huge project, but it's, again, it's something that the state really needed help with, and we were there. We should probably have a separate conversation about that project at some point, just because especially the private well side, I had no idea you were sampling 3,500 private wells. That's awesome. Yeah, yeah. It's a pretty big project. Wow. So maybe to close out this conversation, we've covered a lot of ground. Maybe all of you could share, literally and figuratively, could you all share what you see as the top challenge facing small systems and what you think it might take to deal with that challenge? I mean, it's easy to say money, but I don't really like that, especially at least with the work I've done in Massachusetts, because I think the financial solution, there's always some solution, even though it's not.
People have to bite the bullet sometimes to get something fixed. You need really smart people to solve these problems and also people that work selflessly. you know, there's not much thanks to being the water operator. You know, no one going around and, you know, the water truck doesn't go to the Christmas parade and wave or be Santa Claus. You know, you're on the back burner and no one, you're behind the scenes. So, and that goes to the town management that deals with it, the boards of health, and typically the only attention they get is negative attention. Something's going on. So, I think doing things like having water education at a college level as well as early education through grade school will be a unique approach. It doesn't have to be a full class, but I think what we're lacking is...
a surplus of people getting into the field that are willing, that are not looking to get rich because you won't in the field, but are willing to be helpful and advocate for the benefit of water. People do praise water, clean water, let's give everyone clean water and not pollute the environment. But I don't think the public eye has much perspective on how challenging that really is and how much work goes into it. And the people that, how hard the people are working that are currently doing it. So I think technical and managerial are the two big issues facing small systems today. And identifying solutions to support those are going to be huge. I think with one unintended maybe positive consequence of COVID is that we're realizing how people can collaborate and meet virtually so well and so efficiently and effectively that you can get.
powerful minds together to come up with creative solutions between, not between systems, between towns. Pooling resources to benefit the greater good of many, I think is a good idea. I know Steve mentioned to me, I'm not familiar with this, but in Illinois, you guys have that. You have one company that runs all of the water, it's a quasi-private water supply. Is it Illinois, Steve, the state that you've once referenced that does that?
I'm not 100% sure. As far as, I mean, they charge the same rates for everybody? Yeah, same rate there. Yeah, that's not only American, which is American water. They actually, at least in Illinois, that's the way they operate. But from what you said, two things struck me. Being from a small town, you have to have people in the town with community pride who are willing to not worry about what's best for them, but what's best for their community. And people have to understand the value of water. Those two things help a small community a lot. I think that's, to me, that's what I got out of what you said a minute ago.
Yeah, so I think it's very true. And I think we see a lot of examples of that. Small towns where you wonder how they're going to make it, and yet they find a way because they're actually installing the meters themselves. They have a water board. They're doing everything they can to cut costs, and then they're putting their own time into it. And unfortunately for really small communities, I think that's one of the things that has to be a piece of it to be sustainable long term. Emily, what about you?
Yeah, I think this is something I know, you know, Patrick and I have been talking about last year and saying, you know, successful water system is the one that you forget entirely about, right? If you never hear about it, that's probably success, right? You turn down the tap, you got some safe water, it's affordable, you don't have to worry about it. So I think that speaks to this whole, you know, get it. the value of water and, you know, not forgetting about it. You want it to be so successful that you forget about it, but also for people to appreciate the fact that it is a vital service that should be appreciated and paid for and upkept. But yeah, to echo a lot of what Patrick said too, I mean, I think the top challenge to getting there and especially small systems from what I've seen is the kind of leadership and staffing issues, just having trained people and not only, you know, the water operators, but people that can...
be able to bring in the resources, whatever that might be, in order to solve whatever the challenges are, whether that be that of helping with, you know, collaboration between communities or consolidation or, you know, maybe it's managerial expertise or maybe it's technical expertise and, you know, particular water treatment system or as communities are facing, you know, climate change and maybe changes in their watershed and need some new treatment options. So, yeah, I think it's thinking about what is the workforce around water and the workforce being broad. I know a lot of this. You spoke about earlier, right? A lot of people running water systems in small communities are playing a whole bunch of different roles in the communities. Some of them are volunteers. They're thinking kind of more broadly about who constitutes a water workforce and what sort of support can we provide to them. Great response.
All right, Dave, your turn. Okay, well, I guess it's hard to argue with the importance of human resources. I kind of support what they've said. And, you know, I really would love to see, and we talked about this with WINS, the development of something like a Teach for America or AmeriCorps or Vista program that brings people into the water field. Some of the best and brightest young minds in the U.S. and gets them engaged in working on water, rural water problems. It gives them a chance to realize how important this is and how exciting this field can be and sell the field.
And I think we could do so much more there. And that's the kind of thing I think we need to do. We also need, of course, to provide for resources and compensation for people who are working in the rural water and small water systems too. And that's a challenge. And maybe that's something that needs to come from statewide resources in the same ways we support education on smaller communities too.
So there probably needs to be no more models, better models for that. And that's way outside my area of expertise. And so I'm thinking that there should be a way around this. There should be a way of doing this. And we probably need people who work with government institutions to figure this out. Well, I know the original capacity development program had the operator expense reimbursement program, but that was sunset a number of years back. But I think something like that at the federal level is needed again.
And the AWA program, I couldn't think of as Community Engineering Corps. That's right. Yeah, because it's, you know, in certain areas, it's really helped as well. But it's really kind of what some of the things you've done with your class are along the same line, except they're actually designing plans and stuff. But it's certainly opened the eyes of, I think, you know, when you have the people that can volunteer for a program like that are usually the ones that are higher up in a company that have the time. And they're learning a lot about small systems they may not have known. So, yeah, those are all useful issues. But yeah, anyway. Well, hey, thank you all. It's been great to talk to you.
And we appreciate your time today. And yeah, I look forward to talking some more when we figure out a time maybe for next season we can do one of these just for the PFAS work. It'll be further along. That'll be interesting. Yeah, it was really interesting. We'd certainly like to hear more about it and give it the time it deserves. Because yeah, we probably tried to pack too much into today, but that's okay, right? So a lot of good things going on at UMass. It's great to hear. It was really nice to talk to you all and talk water from a nun.
Yeah, exactly. Just to talk about something we're all passionate about. Which I'm about to do. And we'll include links to all the resources mentioned in the show notes this episode, as well as how to contact each of you, whether directly or via social media. So again, thanks for your time and joining us for Tap Talk. Yeah, well, thanks. Thanks so much, Jennifer and Steve. This was great. Tap Talk is a collaboration between the Rural Community Assistance Partnership and the University of Illinois with funding from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The show is hosted by Steve and Jennifer Wilson of the Illinois State Water Survey. You can visit drinkingwaterpodcast.org to find the full show notes for this episode.